@@michaelhamm6805 There is no place for disrespect to a man who was one of Canada's finest entertainers. None of us are perfect. We all make mistakes whether we want to admit it or not. Gordon is not here to tell us why he did this nor is he here to defend his actions but you just told the world that we better all damn well hate his guts for having done such a thing.
@@michaelhamm6805 I'm curious. Aside from a Wikipedia page and other vague comments in Billboard, is there proof of this occurrence? Were charges laid and was Mr. Lightfoot found guilty? Did Mr. Lightfoot admit to this accusation? Ms Cathy Smith - in her own word admits "I killed John Belushi. I didn't mean to, but I am responsible." Would like some clarification.
As impressive as "Edmund Fitzgerald" is I have always felt that this was Gordon's best work. You can feel the train crossing the country then slowing down once it hits the Rockies then building to a climax in coastal British Columbia as the tempo goes within this song. We are so lucky in Canada to have such a songwriter who could translate this into words! We lost a great man and Canadian when Gordon died, I listen to his music every day because he is one man who could translate to all of us what it meant to be "Canadian"!
I know Michigan adopted Gordo as their own! This Canadian has seen nothing but love from that State in places I know they wouldn't have be so kind to their own! Proud to have them as siblings! People in the D kinder to me than Torontards have ever been!
Canada and Canadians are all about the land. Gordon was commissioned to write a song to commemorate our 100th birthday in 1967. He wrote the song overnight and it instantly become a hit "Across This Mighty Land". Miss ya Gordie!
I belong to an adult choir and we sang this song at our concert when we celebrated Canada's 150th birthday. This one of my favourite songs. Gordon Lightfoot was an amazing artist and musician! RIP....
@@karenschneberger2655 I have never heard this song sung by a choir but I imagine it would sound phenomenal. It is one of my favourite songs as well - but I love all of Gordon Lightfoot's music. It's been a year this month since he passed so it is lovely to remember him this way. RIP
Barrie, Ont. here - 1\2 from his hometown. I was so very lucky to see him six times in concert, once in the front row, at Massey Hall in Toronto, which has internationally known “best acoustics”. This song should almost be a national anthem.
Ditto from the Cariboo Gold Rush Trail in BC... and I'm 72! My first ever concert was Gordon at the then state-of-the-art Place des Arts in Montreal in 1969. He sang his controversial Black Day in July, among many other hits.
Grew up listening to Gordon Lightfoot. Not every song was a hit song but he wrote no bad songs. He had a way of making the mundane poetic. I consider him one of the greatest songwriters of the past 100 years.
I totally agree!!! I was lucky enough to see him in concert back in the early years of his career... first time in the Sixties at the River Queen on David Street (IIRC) in Vancouver. He was standing no more than 6 feet from me!!! Blew my mind!!! Still so clear in my mind. Took my Dad to see him twice. RIP Gordie Lightfoot.
@@susieq9801ditto. My grandpa, Scottish immigrant early 1900s, was “cookee’ in N Ontario, I think. My Son, in 1970s rail crew across the west. Brother in 1980s RR across and through the Rockies. The bunkhouses, the food, the backbreaking work. The mosquitoes and the black flies. Oh yeah, this song is central to our Canadian mythology. We are connected to this vast and prosperous land in our collective unconscious. We are defined by the RR. Thanks to the foresight of our forefathers. This is my narrative. Nice analysis,from presenter Mert Can.
A couple of years ago, the CBC (which ironically originally commissioned this song, but perhaps to their credit?) produced this short documentary which re-examined the song with a more contemporary eye: ua-cam.com/video/hh7xNDcA6f4/v-deo.htmlsi=fD8BURxV9Yrihuuh
In 1967 an unexpected assembly was called. Out onto the stage stepped Gordon Lightfoot. He performed to us bunch of teenagers for an hour. He could have chosen to sing at Fredericton High or Oromocto Senior High School but he chose to travel 25 miles from Fredericton to perform at Sunbury West Senior High School. I will never forget his performance. At nearly 71, it is still one of the highlights in my life. Gordon, I know you are up there in heaven still performing for all of us.
@@8moody1 Since you were at Sunbury West at the same time, we should have at least known of each other if we didn't know each other directly. My maiden name was Pattullo.
@@8moody1 So tell me your first name, please. I have been out here in Edmonton, I've forgotten so many people. Seems to me there was a Gwendolyn Beck but I could be mistaken. How are Jocelyn and Ronnie doing? I know Doris was really giving them a hard time about being together, understanding Catholic that she is. I did visit them when I was home for the 40th high school reunion in 2012 for OHS. I stayed with Shara Golden and we went down to visit them. Hadn't seen either of them in at least 20 years.
Credit to the Chinese immigrants to have come from an impoverished land for the opportunity to earn some money. Many died along the way of this dangerous job and might be the only ones who came to be buried here. I hope their people who now live here have come to appreciate them, even as we must. Canada's first Prime Minister was Scottish! Tough, but a fierce trailblazer himself. Thanks Mert.
I've been to the Cumberland Chinese graveyard on Vancouver Island. It's a provincial heritage site, with descriptive plaques informing on the sacrifice of the Chinese workers and the danger pay incentives to place explosives. They sent the bulk of their wages back home. For their families. I hope most made it back home. Too many didn't.
A couple of years ago, the CBC (which ironically originally commissioned this song, but perhaps to their credit?) produced this short documentary which re-examined the song with a more contemporary eye: ua-cam.com/video/hh7xNDcA6f4/v-deo.htmlsi=fD8BURxV9Yrihuuh
One of the things I love is that you can hear the "beat" of rail travel in the music, something you can't miss if you've travelled often by rail. I have always loved Canadian trains.
Agreed. You hear the beat of rail travel the same way you hear the waves rolling in The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald. Gordon Lightfoot was a multidimensional musical genius.
In his last concert in Montreal a few years ago, he had difficulty finishing this song. So we in the crowd helped him. In a predominantly French province, we all sang in English. May he rest in peace.
I saw him live in Winnipeg at the concert hall. He stood and sang for about 2 hours with a break. He had to arrange his songs to accommodate his older vocal chords, but the magic was still there. It was a great feeling to have him make tangible money for the joy he'd brought us through the decades. Mom bought his "Summertime Dream" album, I think that was the name. Such a genius.
I was aged ten when invited to a girl's 16th birthday two cottages away. = Two high school kids were singing there. = My first time talking and meeting Gordie. = Me, now age 79. with 60 years living in Orillia. = Many memories, meet and greets and passing with a great imperfect loved libretto writer.
Yes, the building of the railway unified Canada as a nation, physically and collectively as Canadians. It was the way Gord used the acceleration and deceleration of the music to imitate the rhythm of the building of railway, as well as its use in transporting people and goods. His reverence, respect and gratitude to those who worked so hard, sacrificed much, especially those whose lives were lost. An incredible song! ❤🇨🇦
Gordon was arguably the greatest song writer/story teller of all time. Over 400 songs. But, what is often overlooked is how perfect his guitar playing was. You know immediately when it is a Gord tune. His strumming on the 12 and 6 string is super clean and spot on picking with his Martin. A total musician too. Miss him a ton.
I have heard Gordon Lightfoot over 40 times on stage live in my life. Back to the late 1960s. As a singer songwriter myself , he was my absolute hero. The Canadian Railroad Trilogy and “If you can read my mind “ which you have also featured are two of the most powerful songs I’ve ever heard. Love your content Cheers from Canada Bob
1974, I was 22 and leaving Vancouver Island for Toronto, Ontario. What a trip! I had just read "The Last Spike" by Pierre Berton and every mile we drove resounded in my head with the Canadian Railroad Trilogy. I found this to be particularly true through the Fraser Canyon. When you come to Canada, please allow yourself lots of time to visit and relive our heritage. And think of this Trilogy. I loved your reaction!
This song was commissioned for the 100th birthday of Canada (1967), and hence is very patriotic. On the one hand, the building of the railroad brought British Columbia into confederation, or else it may have become part of the U.S. It was quite a feat to build, especially through the rocky mountains. On the other hand, the Indigenous and Métis people of the plains saw their lands being taken away to make way for the railroad and there definitely was an exploitation of the Chinese railroad workers. There is a good documentary of the "dark" side of the railway being built and of Gordon's song: ua-cam.com/video/hh7xNDcA6f4/v-deo.html
The original performance was televised on national TV (CBC) on January 1st, 1967 and is available to view also on UA-cam. This version was done live on a set with actors playing the part of the railroad workers and Gord walking around playing his guitar and singing. Worth checking out if you like his music.
CANADIAN RAILROAD TRILOGY! Almost everyone puts this as their No 1 of his songs, even over The Wreck........which is itself an amazing song. The Cdn RR Trilogy makes me weep (not just cry, actually weep), as it does many Canadians. It tells a story, an important part of Canada's history and the sacrifice of so many men to build a railroad to cross this huge and amazing country, as only Gord Lightfoot could tell it. I'm in my 70s now, I grew up listening to Gord's records during my adolescence and beyond. I saw him live in Ottawa in a tiny coffee shop venue when I was only 14, so close to the little stage because the place was so small. Unforgettable! RIP Gord, we miss you! What a blessing you were to us all.
I am proud to be a Canadian and equally honored to have known him. I am truly blessed. We are diminished by his passing but he left an unsurpassed legacy.
Greetings from the Canadian Rockies! I'm glad you are enjoying Gordon Lightfoot, he was salt of the earth. Building the railroads cost many men their lives, I know the Spiral Tunnel in BC claimed many lives alone. It is also important to remember that we imported workers from China to aid construction, which is why every small railroad town seems to have a Chinese restaurant. Another musical suggestion: Stompin' Tom Connors.
Gordon Lightfoot was one of the few musicians I'd spend my itsty-bitsy allowance on. (It mostly went to books) I grew up in the sixties and seventies, and matured in the eighties, probably his most productive period. I got to hear him live and in real time and was never disappointed. What an amazing talent. CRT is one of my all time favorites. It's musically divided in three, (hence the title). It celebrates an amazing number of sets of three: owners, workers, workers' families. Dream to construction to completion. East coast to prairies to west coast. Past to present to future. The cycle of work, food/drink, sleep. There are almost certainly more, but that's part of each person's personal communion with Lightfoot.
Some songs age like fine wine or whisky. This is one of them and it is almost 60 years old. My goodness how time flies. I'm 66 and don't even remember the first time I ever heard this one, but I keep coming back to it and it remains my favourite by Gordon Lightfoot. 👌👀🎸💖🤠
The CBC commissioned a song from Gprdie to celebrate Canada's 100 th anniversary . This was what he wrote. Has "Black Day in July" been done? Another of my favourites .
This song was Gord's Canadian Centennial project. The country, having been founded in 1867, was 100 years old and everybody was involved in efforts to commemorate that. The US had just finished its civil war (1865) and was turning its attention to possibly taking over its neighbor to the north, so Canada knew it had to get unified and that a railway would do the trick. I was fortunate enough to meet our greatest troubador/minstel/singer and I thank him for his gift of reflecting Canadians back to themselves.
You might be ready for Stompin' Tom Connors. Stompin' Tom was Canadian music for a Saturday night at the bar. Fun songs about miners, fishermen, truck drivers, and bugs. All with a Down East voice and a bootheel stomping a hole in a piece of plywood. Simpler stuff than Gord, but essential to the Canadian experience.
I have so many thoughts on this song, which is by all means a masterpiece and one of my favourite songs not just of Gord's but of all time. As someone with a background in history, I will say that it's important to remember that this song was very much a product of its time in terms of Canadian historiography: it paints an extremely romanticised picture of the transcontinental railway's construction and of the westward expansion of Canadian settlers, and completely ignores the unspeakable horrors and violence the government used to acquire the land for the railway to run on. These uncomfortable aspects would most certainly be taught in a modern history of Canadian railways, but not in the 1960s when the romantic notion of the frontier myth was alive and well. That being said though, the song is by all means a classic, and I love that Gord never fails to sing about the lives of average everyday working people even when covering monumental historical events like this. It keeps the story grounded and gets the listener really invested in listening and learning more. Add on top of the phenomenal writing his flawless musical talent and you get a truly amazing piece of art.
Queen Elizabeth 2 stated how much she loved this song which was actually commissioned for Canada's 100th birthday... one of my favourites as CV a Canadian.
Since I was born, raised, and continue to live in Gordon Lightfoot's home town, I grew up in the '60s and '70s hearing his songs almost every day on the local AM radio station. My best friend's father had all the Gordon Lightfoot albums that were released, so I often heard his songs when playing inside the house on rainy days. I never got sick of listening to his music.
As a French Canadian I have heard these songs all my youth. But I never understood the language and did not know what they were about. Now that I see the words written and understand their poetry, I regret immensely that my youth was not lifted by that singer in the manner that it could have been. Learning a second language opens doors to a world of discoveries.
I now want some stew, and whiskey! I've known this epic song for years, through my Dad's records since the 1970's. When we saw Lightfoot 'live' in 2017, concert in Ohio, this was one song that he did not play -yet, it is a complex tune. We, as a family used to travel a lot by train in the USA and CA. Have traveled by railroad between Vancouver and Toronto, from Winnipeg up to Churchill on Hudson's Bay. from Alaska into the Yukon -fewer trains in the Maritimes.
Canadian icon❤ I saw Gordon many times live here in Canada 🇨🇦. Some with a band and some just Gordon and his guitar. Brilliant songwriter singer storyteller. ❤
I agree, the greatest Canadian song ever written. I had the great pleasure to see Gord play numerous times and he always closed the show with the Trilogy, and brought the house down every time. I don’t know how many Lightfoot songs I can sing along with and not miss a word. I also play guitar and love to play and sing his songs. Gordon Lightfoot was and is a Canadian national treasure . And missed by his huge legion of fans. A once in a generation talent.
Gordon Lightfoot was definitely the greatest Canadian writer , his music is fantastic. He told the stories of the common folk and most of the struggle of life
Lightfoot was asked to write a song for the Centennial in 1967, and he produced this, blowing everyone away. The song was premiered on the CBC, if I remember correctly. It became an instant classic, and is taught in various music classes. My sister sang it with her school choir. It makes me cry when I hear it.
Thanks so much Mert, the people asked and you delivered. Canadian Railroad Trilogy is a monumental song detailing a very important part of our Canadian history. Lightfoot has a huge, extensive catalogue to delve into and I know you've reacted to some of his songs already but this one here stands at the very top of Canadian lore. For me it's an essential song if you want to know Gord's music and what he meant to us Canadians. Cheers from southern Ontario!
Gordon Lightfoot's lyrics are able to stand alone as magnificent poetry and prose. His music and voice (a true musical instrument) bring the listener into the lyrics to feel the story being told. I believe he is not only the greatest Canadian songwriter (maybe the world), but he is a classic troubadour who continues the ancient tradition of keeping history alive through song. My heart aches to know that he is gone.
As a young 9 year old kid riding the train from Halifax to Vancouver there in the lounge car was a young man with his guitar come to find out it was a young Gordon Lightfoot just riding the train to his next gig the next 2 hours just blew by what a great memory for a 9 year old kid I still love his music today
One of his hardest song to do a cover.....Trying to match his cadence throughout, along with the words is very hard. Love his music, been singing and playing it in Pubs and Buskers fairs for years now...
A real poet our Gordon Lightfoot. For more canadiana, listen to Did She Mention My Name or A Winter’s Song and of course his masterpiece, If You Could Read My Mind.
Great reaction but this audio is from the overproduced Gord's Gold album. Try the cleaner original recording without the "literal" video. Another great Canadian folk artist is the late Stan Rogers - The Mary Ellen Carter, One Warm Line (for more Canadian history) and many other great songs.
This and The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald are two of the best songs to show his story-telling ability. Another is Black Day in July about the events of the July 23-28, 1967 Detroit Riots. The song wasn't released until 6 months later in January of 1968 and some believe it didn't do as well as the later "Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" because of the delay with people moving on and the events weren't as relevant anymore. The Tragically Hip do a great version of "Black Day in July" on a 2003 tribute album, Gord Downie's voice was perfect for the song. He performed this at the 100th Grey Cup (CFL Championship) halftime show on November 25, 2012. The halftime show started with Justin Bieber, who performed to a chorus of boos from the audience, Carly Rae Jepsen followed with a better response, but when Gordon came on there were loud cheers, people joined in. As a note, the typical Grey Cup crowd are Country music or Classic Rock fans (Stones, Guess Who, BTO, etc) so it was odd to see Bieber and Jepsen on stage.
Dear Mert. I had the pleasure of hearing and seeing Gordon Lightfoot sing this song in person, in concert back in 1967 (the very year of it's release). POW!! That happened at the Yates Center in Lethbridge, Alberta. He was very handsome and charismatic in those days. All I can say is that was an absolutely beautiful experience. I followed Gordon's music for the next 40 years and was never disappointed by any of it. What an incredible storyteller he was. From the bottom of my heart I thank you for your interest in Canadian history, my own history (as a descendant of Ireland) 🙏
The first steam engine to make the historic cross country journey to Vancouver was eventually placed in the middle of a beach parking lot for us ‘70’s kids to climb on, even conquering the tall smoke stack if we were brave enough. A great time to be a Canadian kid listening to Gordon Lightfoot on the radio.
Agreed. Towards the end, it really sound like a train slowly trudging up a mountain then picks up speed as it's coming down the other side - to the coast and success. I love that about this song.
Lightfoot is legend. For a wee bit more old timey Canadiana try some Stompin’ Tom Connors. Choose any of them that look interesting. Bud the Spud is a good place to start. Have fun.
Gordon Lightfoot was commissioned to write a patriotic song for our 1967 Centennial here in Canada; and he outdid himself on this one. I weep lovingly every time I hear this, thinking of my ancestry and all they they have done and others of course as well. Thanks for paying homage to this Mert Can. Much appreciated and may God bless. Amen.
I have loved Gordon Lightfoot since the late sixties. His songs continue to move me at the ripe age of 73, and I have several of Lightfoot’s vinyl albums from back in the day. However, I really want to put in the hugest possible plug for the voice and songs of the utterly unparalled Stan Rogers. His song ‘Northwest Passage’ even by itself, puts him in the small category of Canadian musical giants. Stan was an astounding talent, who like Gordon, told our stories with deep poetic honesty. His rich, warm baritone and stories of ordinary working Canadians can summon pride, despair, hope, and tears. Stan is famous here in Canada, and especially in Atlantic Canada, but not as famous as Gordon Lightfoot, and that is an enormous loss to young people in Canada and to the world. ❤🎶🇨🇦
Pierre Berton, a noted journalist/writer in his day , wrote the history of the Canadian Pacific Railway in a thousand page book called The Last Spike. At a party he is reputed to have remarked to Lightfoot, “Gordon in your song you have told the story better that I did in 1,000 pages!” High praise but so very true. RIP Gordon and Peter, you were both great Canadians!
He was the BEST of the best! A friend of mine years ago lived in the same building as he did. One day she ran into him as they both did laundry together. His comment to her was........... you can imagine all his fans around the world believing his clothes cleaned themselves? 'LOL' THAT's a Canadian!
This song always brings tears to my eye. I worked for the CPR and you feel this song in every mile. You need to cross the country to appreciate what went they went through. I still get excited every spring to hear the track laying or the haunting sound of a diesel fully loaded and hard on the horn
Attended many of his concerts over the years. Always felt incredible after them. I cried when he passed. It was like a part of my Canadian sole died too. This is an iconic Canadian piece. You can’t go wrong with anything by this troubadour. Try Christian Island, another place in Canada. Also, Song for a Winter’s Night and Black Day in July, about race riots in Detroit in July 1967. A Painter Passing Through, though is voice was not the same as it once was, it’s his story.
As an elderly Canadian, I appreciate your ode to this song. I have heard many of Lightfoot's songs but never felt such joy from his work as I have listening to it along with your reaction. Thank you for your work to bring this to us.
Wonderful tribute song with a touch of history. Good reminder that most work constructing railways in the 1800s was daily manual back breaking labor. Gordon Lightfoot is one of Canada's richest treasures. Wonderful reaction video.
Gordon's Centennial project. As 1967 approached, many people took it upon themselves to do something special for that anniversary. This was Gordon's contribution.
Canadian Pacific Railway built it's transcontinental rail, plus a string of Grand railway Hotels, hired Swiss Mountaineers to introduce alpine climbing and skiing to Canadians to promote Banff National Park, and built two steamship lines on the Atlantic & Pacific, to make it easier to travel from the UK to Hong Kong & Malaysia, before the Panama Canal made it easy to avoid a trip around Cape Horn. It was probably the largest transportation system in the world, but German uBoats and modern air travel ended much of that.
There was a famous Canadian historian who wrote a lot about 19th century Canada and in particular the importance of the railroad to Canada. When he heard this song commented that Gord was able to tell in one song what it took him to tell in a 1000 page book. We still miss Gord.
As Canadians, we were lucky to have Lightfoot. An incredible talent. Love this song … it takes you on a journey of how Canada was built and how important the railway was to the country’s growth.
Absolutely his best song...my favorite... Our 4th grade teacher made us learn Gordon Lightfoot songs when she didn't feel like teaching us actual lessons. 😅 Been a fan since the mid 90s
My favourite Gordon Lightfoot song, written for Canada's 100th birthday. Thank you so much for covering it. Canada would not be a country if it weren't for the railroad (the western provinces joined because of the promise of a transcontinental railway.) As you observed, the pace changes and at one point sounds like the movement of a train across the tracks.
Correction, British Columbia joined Confederation under the promise of the railway. The Western provinces, meaning Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta were not asked anything by Ottawa because they were not even in existence except as part of the North-West Territories, with "postage stamp" sized Manitoba being the sole exception. And Ottawa wanted to keep it that way so they could just expropriate whatever land they desired and give it to the Canadian Pacific Railway. That is why none of the prairie provinces were even created until 1905, and even then without control of their own lands and resources. This was completely contrary to the Canadian constitution which clearly stated no additional territory could be added to Canada except as full fledged provinces with all the rights and privileges of all the other provinces. So Macdonald had the constitution quietly changed to cheat the prairies of this right in 1869, again in order to build the CPR with free land. There is a history lesson in very short form for you. It is not easy to ferret out the real story of confederation and this is one of the reasons the West hates Ottawa to this day.
Great song. It was so important for Sir John A Macdonald to build the railway, to bind the country together. You have no idea how big this country is. I've taken the train from Vancouver to Toronto which is a little over half way across the country and it take 4 days. Amazing man, amazing song, amazing country ❤ 😂🇨🇦
No, all Macdonald ever saw the West of Canada as being was a colony of Ontario and Quebec. He even wrote that himself. You are swallowed up in the overly romantic version of Canada. It never was this glowing dream of unity. It was exploitation from the word go. But I still love my country. Too bad it isn't worthy of such heart felt amazement.
There is a reason Gordon Lighfoot is a Canadian Legend. He wasn't just a musician, he was a troubador, a story teller, and a fine man.
Well,,,he did break his mistresses cheekbone after punching her in the face...so I wouldn't go so9 far as calling him a "Fine" man....
Pushy willows cat tails might even be better😂
@@michaelhamm6805 There is no place for disrespect to a man who was one of Canada's finest entertainers. None of us are perfect. We all make mistakes whether we want to admit it or not. Gordon is not here to tell us why he did this nor is he here to defend his actions but you just told the world that we better all damn well hate his guts for having done such a thing.
He admitted to being an alcoholic for decades and a poor husband. A far better singer than a good man.
@@michaelhamm6805 I'm curious. Aside from a Wikipedia page and other vague comments in Billboard, is there proof of this occurrence? Were charges laid and was Mr. Lightfoot found guilty? Did Mr. Lightfoot admit to this accusation? Ms Cathy Smith - in her own word admits "I killed John Belushi. I didn't mean to, but I am responsible." Would like some clarification.
As impressive as "Edmund Fitzgerald" is I have always felt that this was Gordon's best work. You can feel the train crossing the country then slowing down once it hits the Rockies then building to a climax in coastal British Columbia as the tempo goes within this song. We are so lucky in Canada to have such a songwriter who could translate this into words! We lost a great man and Canadian when Gordon died, I listen to his music every day because he is one man who could translate to all of us what it meant to be "Canadian"!
You have to listen to Black day in July with the video and photos of the Detroit riots - drums like cannon roar.
He also mentions how many lives were unnecessarily lost
Agree completely.
I know Michigan adopted Gordo as their own! This Canadian has seen nothing but love from that State in places I know they wouldn't have be so kind to their own! Proud to have them as siblings! People in the D kinder to me than Torontards have ever been!
This song was commissioned by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation for the Centennial of Canadian Confederation in 1967
Canada and Canadians are all about the land. Gordon was commissioned to write a song to commemorate our 100th birthday in 1967. He wrote the song overnight and it instantly become a hit "Across This Mighty Land".
Miss ya Gordie!
It actually took Gordon Lightfoot three days to write the song, which is still phenomenal considering the intricacies of this masterpiece.
I belong to an adult choir and we sang this song at our concert when we celebrated Canada's 150th birthday. This one of my favourite songs. Gordon Lightfoot was an amazing artist and musician! RIP....
@@karenschneberger2655 I have never heard this song sung by a choir but I imagine it would sound phenomenal. It is one of my favourite songs as well - but I love all of Gordon Lightfoot's music. It's been a year this month since he passed so it is lovely to remember him this way. RIP
on
I feel lucky growing up listening to Gordon lightfoot
I think this is the greatest Canadian song ever. PERIOD
💯
Still makes me weep with pride, every time I hear it - and I’m 66!
Peace - from British Columbia’s Okanagan Valley.
Kamloops, here. We are pretty lucky to have Canada and Gordon.
@@MaryHemmings Kamloops too! Howdy neighbour!
Barrie, Ont. here - 1\2 from his hometown. I was so very lucky to see him six times in concert, once in the front row, at Massey Hall in Toronto, which has internationally known “best acoustics”. This song should almost be a national anthem.
Ditto from the Cariboo Gold Rush Trail in BC... and I'm 72! My first ever concert was Gordon at the then state-of-the-art Place des Arts in Montreal in 1969. He sang his controversial Black Day in July, among many other hits.
@@patakel my brother is in Angus! All the best from Langley, BC ❤️🇨🇦
Grew up listening to Gordon Lightfoot. Not every song was a hit song but he wrote no bad songs. He had a way of making the mundane poetic. I consider him one of the greatest songwriters of the past 100 years.
I totally agree!!!
I was lucky enough to see him in concert back in the early years of his career... first time in the Sixties at the River Queen on David Street (IIRC) in Vancouver. He was standing no more than 6 feet from me!!! Blew my mind!!! Still so clear in my mind. Took my Dad to see him twice. RIP Gordie Lightfoot.
@@gilknutson1938 I finally had the great privilege of seeing him in his later years in the early 2000s, and i am very glad I did.
Have a listen to James Keelaghan.especially "Hillcrest Mine"
@@SteveBibby-p4h That was an excellent recommendation! Thank you very much!
A lot of men died during the building of that railroad. They had some pretty tough terrain to go through! Great Canadian history!
My grandfather worked on building tunnels for the RR in the Rockies in the early 1900's. Before you ask, yes I'm old and he died before I was born.
@@susieq9801ditto. My grandpa, Scottish immigrant early 1900s, was “cookee’ in N Ontario, I think. My Son, in 1970s rail crew across the west. Brother in 1980s RR across and through the Rockies. The bunkhouses, the food, the backbreaking work. The mosquitoes and the black flies. Oh yeah, this song is central to our Canadian mythology. We are connected to this vast and prosperous land in our collective unconscious. We are defined by the RR. Thanks to the foresight of our forefathers. This is my narrative. Nice analysis,from presenter Mert Can.
A couple of years ago, the CBC (which ironically originally commissioned this song, but perhaps to their credit?) produced this short documentary which re-examined the song with a more contemporary eye:
ua-cam.com/video/hh7xNDcA6f4/v-deo.htmlsi=fD8BURxV9Yrihuuh
In 1967 an unexpected assembly was called. Out onto the stage stepped Gordon Lightfoot. He performed to us bunch of teenagers for an hour. He could have chosen to sing at Fredericton High or Oromocto Senior High School but he chose to travel 25 miles from Fredericton to perform at Sunbury West Senior High School. I will never forget his performance. At nearly 71, it is still one of the highlights in my life. Gordon, I know you are up there in heaven still performing for all of us.
@@8moody1 Since you were at Sunbury West at the same time, we should have at least known of each other if we didn't know each other directly. My maiden name was Pattullo.
@@8moody1 I remember Harvey and Jocelyn Beck. Are you Jocelyn?
@@8moody1 So tell me your first name, please. I have been out here in Edmonton, I've forgotten so many people. Seems to me there was a Gwendolyn Beck but I could be mistaken. How are Jocelyn and Ronnie doing? I know Doris was really giving them a hard time about being together, understanding Catholic that she is. I did visit them when I was home for the 40th high school reunion in 2012 for OHS. I stayed with Shara Golden and we went down to visit them. Hadn't seen either of them in at least 20 years.
I met him once in downtown Toronto near Caggage Town, a great guy and very easy to talk to
😂
Credit to the Chinese immigrants to have come from an impoverished land for the opportunity to earn some money.
Many died along the way of this dangerous job and might be the only ones who came to be buried here. I hope their people who now live here have come to appreciate them, even as we must. Canada's first Prime Minister was Scottish! Tough, but a fierce trailblazer himself.
Thanks Mert.
I've been to the Cumberland Chinese graveyard on Vancouver Island. It's a provincial heritage site, with descriptive plaques informing on the sacrifice of the Chinese workers and the danger pay incentives to place explosives. They sent the bulk of their wages back home. For their families. I hope most made it back home. Too many didn't.
A couple of years ago, the CBC (which ironically originally commissioned this song, but perhaps to their credit?) produced this short documentary which re-examined the song with a more contemporary eye:
ua-cam.com/video/hh7xNDcA6f4/v-deo.htmlsi=fD8BURxV9Yrihuuh
One of the things I love is that you can hear the "beat" of rail travel in the music, something you can't miss if you've travelled often by rail. I have always loved Canadian trains.
Agreed. You hear the beat of rail travel the same way you hear the waves rolling in The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald. Gordon Lightfoot was a multidimensional musical genius.
he was a legend , hurt my heart to see his dog keeping vigil at his coffin , RIP Gordon ❤
Broke my heart
I heard somewhere that when Gordon Lightfoot met Queen Elizabeth, she told him that she "just loved" this song.
In his last concert in Montreal a few years ago, he had difficulty finishing this song. So we in the crowd helped him. In a predominantly French province, we all sang in English. May he rest in peace.
I first saw him Montreal, Place des Arts… with my BFF…. 70’s….. I dodged Good Friday.
I saw him live in Winnipeg at the concert hall. He stood and sang for about 2 hours with a break. He had to arrange his songs to accommodate his older vocal chords, but the magic was still there. It was a great feeling to have him make tangible money for the joy he'd brought us through the decades. Mom bought his "Summertime Dream" album, I think that was the name. Such a genius.
@@redelfshotthefood82139
😊😊
I have memorized the trilogy song. Time for a new Canadian anthem.
@@redelfshotthefood8213 My favourite album. I sing every song on it.
I was aged ten when invited to a girl's 16th birthday two cottages away. = Two high school kids were singing there. = My first time talking and meeting Gordie. = Me, now age 79. with 60 years living in Orillia. = Many memories, meet and greets and passing with a great imperfect loved libretto writer.
Gordon was asked to write a song about Canada by the Expo '67 organizers to celebrate Canada's 100th birthday. This was the result.
I didn't know that! Thanks for sharing!
And a fitting song, to ride along with the Centennial Train!
We saw it in Victoria BC! 1967💕🇨🇦💕
@@57Jimmy Chilliwack for me. I always credit that train for igniting my interest in Canadian history.
Yes, the building of the railway unified Canada as a nation, physically and collectively as Canadians. It was the way Gord used the acceleration and deceleration of the music to imitate the rhythm of the building of railway, as well as its use in transporting people and goods. His reverence, respect and gratitude to those who worked so hard, sacrificed much, especially those whose lives were lost. An incredible song! ❤🇨🇦
Gordon was arguably the greatest song writer/story teller of all time. Over 400 songs. But, what is often overlooked is how perfect his guitar playing was. You know immediately when it is a Gord tune. His strumming on the 12 and 6 string is super clean and spot on picking with his Martin. A total musician too. Miss him a ton.
I have heard Gordon Lightfoot over 40 times on stage live in my life. Back to the late 1960s. As a singer songwriter myself , he was my absolute hero. The Canadian Railroad Trilogy and “If you can read my mind “ which you have also featured are two of the most powerful songs I’ve ever heard.
Love your content
Cheers from Canada
Bob
If you could read my mind….. got me right there!
1974, I was 22 and leaving Vancouver Island for Toronto, Ontario. What a trip! I had just read "The Last Spike" by Pierre Berton and every mile we drove resounded in my head with the Canadian Railroad Trilogy. I found this to be particularly true through the Fraser Canyon. When you come to Canada, please allow yourself lots of time to visit and relive our heritage. And think of this Trilogy. I loved your reaction!
Yes. Passed through Craigalache to let my dog have a pee. I was blown away by where I live to think how unified Canada became.
A great song by a great Canadian. Another you might enjoy is Northwest Passage by Stan Rogers. I am sure you would like it too.
This song was commissioned for the 100th birthday of Canada (1967), and hence is very patriotic. On the one hand, the building of the railroad brought British Columbia into confederation, or else it may have become part of the U.S. It was quite a feat to build, especially through the rocky mountains. On the other hand, the Indigenous and Métis people of the plains saw their lands being taken away to make way for the railroad and there definitely was an exploitation of the Chinese railroad workers. There is a good documentary of the "dark" side of the railway being built and of Gordon's song: ua-cam.com/video/hh7xNDcA6f4/v-deo.html
The original performance was televised on national TV (CBC) on January 1st, 1967 and is available to view also on UA-cam. This version was done live on a set with actors playing the part of the railroad workers and Gord walking around playing his guitar and singing. Worth checking out if you like his music.
CANADIAN RAILROAD TRILOGY! Almost everyone puts this as their No 1 of his songs, even over The Wreck........which is itself an amazing song. The Cdn RR Trilogy makes me weep (not just cry, actually weep), as it does many Canadians. It tells a story, an important part of Canada's history and the sacrifice of so many men to build a railroad to cross this huge and amazing country, as only Gord Lightfoot could tell it. I'm in my 70s now, I grew up listening to Gord's records during my adolescence and beyond. I saw him live in Ottawa in a tiny coffee shop venue when I was only 14, so close to the little stage because the place was so small. Unforgettable! RIP Gord, we miss you! What a blessing you were to us all.
I am proud to be a Canadian and equally honored to have known him. I am truly blessed. We are diminished by his passing but he left an unsurpassed legacy.
"we have opened up the soil, with our tear drops and our toil"...truth. 🇨🇦
Greetings from the Canadian Rockies! I'm glad you are enjoying Gordon Lightfoot, he was salt of the earth. Building the railroads cost many men their lives, I know the Spiral Tunnel in BC claimed many lives alone. It is also important to remember that we imported workers from China to aid construction, which is why every small railroad town seems to have a Chinese restaurant. Another musical suggestion: Stompin' Tom Connors.
This Canadian has chills running up my spine and tears filling my eyes. RIP Gord.
Gordon Lightfoot was one of the few musicians I'd spend my itsty-bitsy allowance on. (It mostly went to books) I grew up in the sixties and seventies, and matured in the eighties, probably his most productive period. I got to hear him live and in real time and was never disappointed. What an amazing talent. CRT is one of my all time favorites. It's musically divided in three, (hence the title). It celebrates an amazing number of sets of three: owners, workers, workers' families. Dream to construction to completion. East coast to prairies to west coast. Past to present to future. The cycle of work, food/drink, sleep. There are almost certainly more, but that's part of each person's personal communion with Lightfoot.
Some songs age like fine wine or whisky. This is one of them and it is almost 60 years old. My goodness how time flies. I'm 66 and don't even remember the first time I ever heard this one, but I keep coming back to it and it remains my favourite by Gordon Lightfoot. 👌👀🎸💖🤠
The CBC commissioned a song from Gprdie to celebrate Canada's 100 th anniversary . This was what he wrote. Has "Black Day in July" been done? Another of my favourites .
Fantastic suggestion! Definitely essential Lightfoot listening.
This song was Gord's Canadian Centennial project. The country, having been founded in 1867, was 100 years old and everybody was involved in efforts to commemorate that. The US had just finished its civil war (1865) and was turning its attention to possibly taking over its neighbor to the north, so Canada knew it had to get unified and that a railway would do the trick. I was fortunate enough to meet our greatest troubador/minstel/singer and I thank him for his gift of reflecting Canadians back to themselves.
This is the quintessential Canadian song and one of Lightfoot's finest!!!
A great guy
I knew him well
May he RIP
Gordon Lightfoot is an icon in Canada! He was an amazing singer-songwriter and his music defines Canada! Thanks for showcasing this amazing man!
In concert, he was amazing. Audiences were so spellbound,you could hear a pin drop.
You might be ready for Stompin' Tom Connors. Stompin' Tom was Canadian music for a Saturday night at the bar. Fun songs about miners, fishermen, truck drivers, and bugs. All with a Down East voice and a bootheel stomping a hole in a piece of plywood. Simpler stuff than Gord, but essential to the Canadian experience.
"Black Day In July" was written about the 67 riots in Detroit. It has a darker tone, similar to "The Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald."
Black day in July - so immensely powerful based on truth!
It was banned in the states
I am a proud Canadian and so lucky to have Gordon as a fellow proud Canadian
I have so many thoughts on this song, which is by all means a masterpiece and one of my favourite songs not just of Gord's but of all time. As someone with a background in history, I will say that it's important to remember that this song was very much a product of its time in terms of Canadian historiography: it paints an extremely romanticised picture of the transcontinental railway's construction and of the westward expansion of Canadian settlers, and completely ignores the unspeakable horrors and violence the government used to acquire the land for the railway to run on. These uncomfortable aspects would most certainly be taught in a modern history of Canadian railways, but not in the 1960s when the romantic notion of the frontier myth was alive and well. That being said though, the song is by all means a classic, and I love that Gord never fails to sing about the lives of average everyday working people even when covering monumental historical events like this. It keeps the story grounded and gets the listener really invested in listening and learning more. Add on top of the phenomenal writing his flawless musical talent and you get a truly amazing piece of art.
Queen Elizabeth 2 stated how much she loved this song which was actually commissioned for Canada's 100th birthday... one of my favourites as CV a Canadian.
A man of the people... living & struggling within the real walls of society, feeling and tasting life's pain!
Since I was born, raised, and continue to live in Gordon Lightfoot's home town, I grew up in the '60s and '70s hearing his songs almost every day on the local AM radio station. My best friend's father had all the Gordon Lightfoot albums that were released, so I often heard his songs when playing inside the house on rainy days. I never got sick of listening to his music.
As a French Canadian I have heard these songs all my youth. But I never understood the language and did not know what they were about. Now that I see the words written and understand their poetry, I regret immensely that my youth was not lifted by that singer in the manner that it could have been. Learning a second language opens doors to a world of discoveries.
He was definitely one of our greatest songwriters.
I now want some stew, and whiskey!
I've known this epic song for years, through my Dad's records since the 1970's. When we saw Lightfoot 'live' in 2017, concert in Ohio, this was one song that he did not play -yet, it is a complex tune.
We, as a family used to travel a lot by train in the USA and CA. Have traveled by railroad between Vancouver and Toronto, from Winnipeg up to Churchill on Hudson's Bay. from Alaska into the Yukon -fewer trains in the Maritimes.
Canadian icon❤ I saw Gordon many times live here in Canada 🇨🇦. Some with a band and some just Gordon and his guitar. Brilliant songwriter singer storyteller. ❤
I agree, the greatest Canadian song ever written. I had the great pleasure to see Gord play numerous times and he always closed the show with the Trilogy, and brought the house down every time. I don’t know how many Lightfoot songs I can sing along with and not miss a word. I also play guitar and love to play and sing his songs. Gordon Lightfoot was and is a Canadian national treasure . And missed by his huge legion of fans. A once in a generation talent.
Gordon Lightfoot was definitely the greatest Canadian writer , his music is fantastic. He told the stories of the common folk and most of the struggle of life
Lightfoot was asked to write a song for the Centennial in 1967, and he produced this, blowing everyone away. The song was premiered on the CBC, if I remember correctly. It became an instant classic, and is taught in various music classes. My sister sang it with her school choir. It makes me cry when I hear it.
I’m from Canada and the vary first time I heard this tune. I love his music
Thanks so much Mert, the people asked and you delivered. Canadian Railroad Trilogy is a monumental song detailing a very important part of our Canadian history. Lightfoot has a huge, extensive catalogue to delve into and I know you've reacted to some of his songs already but this one here stands at the very top of Canadian lore. For me it's an essential song if you want to know Gord's music and what he meant to us Canadians. Cheers from southern Ontario!
Well said! And I couldn't agree more
Gordon Lightfoot's lyrics are able to stand alone as magnificent poetry and prose. His music and voice (a true musical instrument) bring the listener into the lyrics to feel the story being told. I believe he is not only the greatest Canadian songwriter (maybe the world), but he is a classic troubadour who continues the ancient tradition of keeping history alive through song. My heart aches to know that he is gone.
WOW! Super good song telling the real story
As a young 9 year old kid riding the train from Halifax to Vancouver there in the lounge car was a young man with his guitar come to find out it was a young Gordon Lightfoot just riding the train to his next gig the next 2 hours just blew by what a great memory for a 9 year old kid I still love his music today
One of his hardest song to do a cover.....Trying to match his cadence throughout, along with the words is very hard. Love his music, been singing and playing it in Pubs and Buskers fairs for years now...
The first time I heard this, I thought it should be our national anthem. Reminds us all that this beautiful country came at a cost
A real poet our Gordon Lightfoot. For more canadiana, listen to Did She Mention My Name or A Winter’s Song and of course his masterpiece, If You Could Read My Mind.
I had a chance to see him sing this live. So lucky. He is Canada’s pride and joy.
Great reaction but this audio is from the overproduced Gord's Gold album. Try the cleaner original recording without the "literal" video. Another great Canadian folk artist is the late Stan Rogers - The Mary Ellen Carter, One Warm Line (for more Canadian history) and many other great songs.
I have been fortunate to see him many times over the years.
This and The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald are two of the best songs to show his story-telling ability. Another is Black Day in July about the events of the July 23-28, 1967 Detroit Riots. The song wasn't released until 6 months later in January of 1968 and some believe it didn't do as well as the later "Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" because of the delay with people moving on and the events weren't as relevant anymore. The Tragically Hip do a great version of "Black Day in July" on a 2003 tribute album, Gord Downie's voice was perfect for the song.
He performed this at the 100th Grey Cup (CFL Championship) halftime show on November 25, 2012. The halftime show started with Justin Bieber, who performed to a chorus of boos from the audience, Carly Rae Jepsen followed with a better response, but when Gordon came on there were loud cheers, people joined in. As a note, the typical Grey Cup crowd are Country music or Classic Rock fans (Stones, Guess Who, BTO, etc) so it was odd to see Bieber and Jepsen on stage.
Dear Mert. I had the pleasure of hearing and seeing Gordon Lightfoot sing this song in person, in concert back in 1967 (the very year of it's release). POW!!
That happened at the Yates Center in Lethbridge, Alberta. He was very handsome and charismatic in those days. All I can say is that was an absolutely beautiful experience. I followed Gordon's music for the next 40 years and was never disappointed by any of it. What an incredible storyteller he was. From the bottom of my heart I thank you for your interest in Canadian history, my own history (as a descendant of Ireland) 🙏
Gordon what a talent that moves me everytime, no matter what song he sings. I LOVE HIM
One of my top three solo artist in North America.
The first steam engine to make the historic cross country journey to Vancouver was eventually placed in the middle of a beach parking lot for us ‘70’s kids to climb on, even conquering the tall smoke stack if we were brave enough. A great time to be a Canadian kid listening to Gordon Lightfoot on the radio.
I've always felt the pace of the song, especially parts of it has the cadence of a train. I think that was genius. Love this song.
Agreed. Towards the end, it really sound like a train slowly trudging up a mountain then picks up speed as it's coming down the other side - to the coast and success. I love that about this song.
Lightfoot is legend. For a wee bit more old timey Canadiana try some Stompin’ Tom Connors. Choose any of them that look interesting. Bud the Spud is a good place to start. Have fun.
Gordon Lightfoot was commissioned to write a patriotic song for our 1967 Centennial here in Canada; and he outdid himself on this one. I weep lovingly every time I hear this, thinking of my ancestry and all they they have done and others of course as well. Thanks for paying homage to this Mert Can. Much appreciated and may God bless. Amen.
Black Day in July was banned in the US for a while...about the Detroit Race Riots in the 60's...Gord's best song ever.
one of the greatest songs ever written by one of THE greatest poet storyteller musicians to ever exist. miss you gordon
I have loved Gordon Lightfoot since the late sixties. His songs continue to move me at the ripe age of 73, and I have several of Lightfoot’s vinyl albums from back in the day. However, I really want to put in the hugest possible plug for the voice and songs of the utterly unparalled Stan Rogers. His song ‘Northwest Passage’ even by itself, puts him in the small category of Canadian musical giants. Stan was an astounding talent, who like Gordon, told our stories with deep poetic honesty. His rich, warm baritone and stories of ordinary working Canadians can summon pride, despair, hope, and tears. Stan is famous here in Canada, and especially in Atlantic Canada, but not as famous as Gordon Lightfoot, and that is an enormous loss to young people in Canada and to the world. ❤🎶🇨🇦
I think this is really Gordon's finest work. It puts you right there and it's so respectful and warm. Aussie here, but this song makes me so proud!
Love Gordon! He's one of our treasures in Canada
So very true!
Pierre Berton, a noted journalist/writer in his day , wrote the history of the Canadian Pacific Railway in a thousand page book called The Last Spike. At a party he is reputed to have remarked to Lightfoot, “Gordon in your song you have told the story better that I did in 1,000 pages!” High praise but so very true. RIP Gordon and Peter, you were both great Canadians!
He was the BEST of the best! A friend of mine years ago lived in the same building as he did. One day she ran into him as they both did laundry together. His comment to her was........... you can imagine all his fans around the world believing his clothes cleaned themselves? 'LOL' THAT's a Canadian!
Commissioned by the CBC for Canada's centennial in 1967. I cry every time I hear this.
This song always brings tears to my eye. I worked for the CPR and you feel this song in every mile. You need to cross the country to appreciate what went they went through. I still get excited every spring to hear the track laying or the haunting sound of a diesel fully loaded and hard on the horn
Attended many of his concerts over the years. Always felt incredible after them. I cried when he passed. It was like a part of my Canadian sole died too. This is an iconic Canadian piece. You can’t go wrong with anything by this troubadour. Try Christian Island, another place in Canada. Also, Song for a Winter’s Night and Black Day in July, about race riots in Detroit in July 1967. A Painter Passing Through, though is voice was not the same as it once was, it’s his story.
As an elderly Canadian, I appreciate your ode to this song. I have heard many of Lightfoot's songs but never felt such joy from his work as I have listening to it along with your reaction. Thank you for your work to bring this to us.
Wonderful tribute song with a touch of history. Good reminder that most work constructing railways in the 1800s was daily manual back breaking labor. Gordon Lightfoot is one of Canada's richest treasures. Wonderful reaction video.
Gordon's Centennial project. As 1967 approached, many people took it upon themselves to do something special for that anniversary. This was Gordon's contribution.
We have lost so much of what this song represents (and it's not coming back), but this is beautiful song.
Canadian Pacific Railway built it's transcontinental rail, plus a string of Grand railway Hotels, hired Swiss Mountaineers to introduce alpine climbing and skiing to Canadians to promote Banff National Park, and built two steamship lines on the Atlantic & Pacific, to make it easier to travel from the UK to Hong Kong & Malaysia, before the Panama Canal made it easy to avoid a trip around Cape Horn.
It was probably the largest transportation system in the world, but German uBoats and modern air travel ended much of that.
There was a famous Canadian historian who wrote a lot about 19th century Canada and in particular the importance of the railroad to Canada. When he heard this song commented that Gord was able to tell in one song what it took him to tell in a 1000 page book. We still miss Gord.
very few were/are at his level of story telling--a great great musician
As Canadians, we were lucky to have Lightfoot. An incredible talent. Love this song … it takes you on a journey of how Canada was built and how important the railway was to the country’s growth.
He was a great Canadian troubadour!!!!
This is my favourite Lightfoot song. He was commissioned by the CBC to write the song for Canada's Centenial in 1967.
Absolutely his best song...my favorite... Our 4th grade teacher made us learn Gordon Lightfoot songs when she didn't feel like teaching us actual lessons. 😅 Been a fan since the mid 90s
As a Canadian, I appreciate him more now verses when I was young. He was/is an Icon.
As a Canadian he is my favourite singer. all of his songs tell a story, this is my favourite song of all time. I never tire of it.
Proud to be Canadian.Gordon Lightfoot, Anne Murray, K.D. Lang, and the list goes on,the calibre of our artists are incredible.
Neil Young, Leonard Cohen, Joni Mitchell, Robbie Robertson
I think Gordon would have liked this reaction video.
I was always a big Gordon Lightfoot fan. I loved his music.
My favourite Gordon Lightfoot song, written for Canada's 100th birthday. Thank you so much for covering it. Canada would not be a country if it weren't for the railroad (the western provinces joined because of the promise of a transcontinental railway.) As you observed, the pace changes and at one point sounds like the movement of a train across the tracks.
Correction, British Columbia joined Confederation under the promise of the railway. The Western provinces, meaning Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta were not asked anything by Ottawa because they were not even in existence except as part of the North-West Territories, with "postage stamp" sized Manitoba being the sole exception. And Ottawa wanted to keep it that way so they could just expropriate whatever land they desired and give it to the Canadian Pacific Railway. That is why none of the prairie provinces were even created until 1905, and even then without control of their own lands and resources. This was completely contrary to the Canadian constitution which clearly stated no additional territory could be added to Canada except as full fledged provinces with all the rights and privileges of all the other provinces. So Macdonald had the constitution quietly changed to cheat the prairies of this right in 1869, again in order to build the CPR with free land. There is a history lesson in very short form for you. It is not easy to ferret out the real story of confederation and this is one of the reasons the West hates Ottawa to this day.
Superb singer, song writer that may never have an equal in Canada
Great song. It was so important for Sir John A Macdonald to build the railway, to bind the country together. You have no idea how big this country is. I've taken the train from Vancouver to Toronto which is a little over half way across the country and it take 4 days. Amazing man, amazing song, amazing country ❤ 😂🇨🇦
No, all Macdonald ever saw the West of Canada as being was a colony of Ontario and Quebec. He even wrote that himself. You are swallowed up in the overly romantic version of Canada. It never was this glowing dream of unity. It was exploitation from the word go. But I still love my country. Too bad it isn't worthy of such heart felt amazement.
Your reaction to the song as you were listening to the lyrics is how i still hear it some 1000 times later
I saw Gordon Lightfoot in concert in the 60's at Acadia University, Wolfville, Nova Scotia.