Comic Book Lies - The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 112

  • @WhelmedButReady
    @WhelmedButReady 6 років тому +171

    Don't worry Ben, I got the Big Fat Liar joke. That deafening silence was painful

    • @howardroark3208
      @howardroark3208 6 років тому +6

      Yeah I got it too but still nothing about that movie is funny

    • @howardroark3208
      @howardroark3208 6 років тому +4

      Zyle Rayner not judging Ben just the movie, Bens generally kinda corny but 90% of the time I’d say it works for him, this is just the other 10 %

    • @F_lippy
      @F_lippy 6 років тому +3

      @@greatmajingo GET THE CLOWN!!!!

  • @TheOTA101
    @TheOTA101 6 років тому +84

    Ben I truly appreciate that Big Fat Liar reference, was obsessed with that movie when I was younger

  • @ridge825
    @ridge825 6 років тому +38

    1:23 Tiffany was like "Kill me already"

  • @timshady237
    @timshady237 6 років тому +17

    Ben, props to your story-telling this episode. Idk if you were just tired (lol) but your composure & delivery was spot on for the Avengers issue. Someday you should do a back issue of your own! (There’s gotta be MLPony comics haha)

  • @ryanpollard1166
    @ryanpollard1166 6 років тому +23

    "It's a beautiful lie". I see what you did there Ben

  • @ctl6985
    @ctl6985 6 років тому +12

    I loved Ben's face after going over Batman #50. He's just like wtf

  • @tophfan
    @tophfan 6 років тому +11

    ah yes the batman wedding where the big fat lie was that he is a skrull and she is a doom bot

  • @ArKaYseR
    @ArKaYseR 6 років тому +10

    God.. Ben had me laughing from the start of the video hahaha

  • @MrMike11233
    @MrMike11233 6 років тому +42

    I own all three of these comics. Pretty much agree with the conclusion as well. Bendis intended Wanda to be in that Avengers book, so I think he and the comic itself can be excused. Unlike Batman 50. The fantastic artwork (to me) does *not* excuse all the tie ins I bought, just to be told at the end, "BWAHAHA!!! SUCKER!!!"

    • @derma_tek
      @derma_tek 6 років тому +3

      MrMike11233 agreed especially since bendis didn't write children's crusade which is were she was changed to a doombot.

  • @Darkgreenfangirl
    @Darkgreenfangirl 6 років тому +5

    The biggest lie to me is Batman, mainly cause I hate the very idea that you can't be a hero without being miserable and you have to give up the idea of love. Like no, why can't superheroes be happy and married!? Great episode as always

  • @bj2reckless168
    @bj2reckless168 6 років тому +34

    Batman became ted moseby

  • @CosmicNovember19
    @CosmicNovember19 6 років тому +10

    At least I got see the Wedding of Batman and Catwoman at my local comic book store. It was a good Saturday morning, Elvis Deadpool married them.

  • @Stumbo99
    @Stumbo99 6 років тому +18

    I love Tiffany's hair
    Also good episode

  • @falserizufferezek9394
    @falserizufferezek9394 6 років тому +14

    Big fat liar reference, nice job Ben

  • @flywheelshyster
    @flywheelshyster 5 років тому +1

    This was one of the best GBU, I know because a back issues dropped thirty minutes ago and (when not busy here at work) I keep unpausing this to finish it rather than just jumping into back issues. I xant remember your reactio. To the wedding so i gotta finish the episode 😆

  • @comicsmisexplained
    @comicsmisexplained 6 років тому +8

    This is a great episode! I love that New Avengers book. I ended up reading the whole entire series. It helped me rediscover my love for comics.

  • @Grievousish
    @Grievousish 6 років тому +1

    All i've got stuck in my head now is that one bit from Family Guy. "Hey, this guy's a phony. A big, fat phony!"

  • @matterstoyou2970
    @matterstoyou2970 6 років тому +11

    Would absolutely love VISION on back issues dude make it happen 😃

  • @teemunknee
    @teemunknee 6 років тому +3

    It's okay, Ben. I got your BFL reference right away. You keep doing you, boo.

  • @batnick7230
    @batnick7230 5 років тому +4

    New Avengers = 0:45
    Civil War: The Return = 10:36
    Batman = 18:12
    The Results = 31:06

  • @GreatGarloo
    @GreatGarloo 6 років тому +4

    Best book in this is New Avengers #26. The rest whatever but, can we take a moment to recognize how on point Tiff's hair and makeup are in this video? Gorgeous!
    Also I thought she was going to jump across the table when Ben almost called Wong "Wang". :D

  • @ethanrichmond3992
    @ethanrichmond3992 6 років тому +1

    Best episode yet. You need to do another one of these with the same theme.

  • @garywintle8023
    @garywintle8023 6 років тому +2

    This is far funnier:
    Avengers Disassembled:
    Doctor Strange: "There's no such thing as Chaos Magic"
    New Avengers #26:
    Doctor Strange refers to Wanda's Chaos Magic
    Strange's reputation has never really recovered from this.
    Bendis can't even keep to his own continuity (and he doesn't know who Shuma Gorath and Chthon are), and the creepy undertone of misogyny in Bendis' robotic writing of Wanda is the reason Alan Heinberg ret-conned the Doombot. The point Heinberg is making is that Bendis writes Wanda like a brainless robot.
    Likewise, Dan Slott had Chthon brutally mock everything Doctor Strange said in Disassembled , in another pointed dig at Bendis. Chthon's words are clearly directed at Strange AND Bendis. Bendis tried to remove Chthon, David Sexton (Marvel Tarot), Dan Slott (Mighty Avengers) and Jeff Parker (Mystic Arcana) put him right back in.

  • @BlueScarabGuy
    @BlueScarabGuy 6 років тому +4

    I understand what Tiffany is saying, trying to separate the hype of the wedding from the actual issue itself, but...I don't think that's possible. Batman proposed to Catwoman like a year and a half ago, they built this up like this was the surest thing ever, and then YOINK. And then Tom King has the audacity to go on some interview and apparently say "I mean, really, the wedding storyline is all the way up to issue 100". Nah. Batman is the worst one here by a WIDE margin, because it wasn't ever meant honestly and then retconned into a lie later, this was something they spent like 30 issues actively lying to the audience about on purpose, and clearly not to make some grand statement, but to make money off the hype.
    Oh, and for the record, Tom King, Batman is more interesting when he isn't totally defined by edgy bullshit like I MUST BE MISERABLE OR ELSE I CAN'T HELP PEOPLE.

    • @jonahi1304
      @jonahi1304 3 роки тому +2

      that's what Frank Miller kept trying to tell King when they were on a batman writers' panel: that Batman isn't really that miserable and enjoys what he does in a way

  • @YouCalledForTheDoc
    @YouCalledForTheDoc 6 років тому +1

    We need a Good, Bad and the Ugly with 3 Green Lantern issues. The Tom King Darkseid War one-shot, one of the Guy Gardner Warrior issues(maybe the christmas special?) and that Alan Moore issue with Mogo.
    Also, you can do a Omega Men Back Issues if you want to wait on Vision to see if that new one not by King will be good or not

  • @lettersndnumbers
    @lettersndnumbers 6 років тому

    HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAH the best opening Ben 😂

  • @TommyBaysMusic
    @TommyBaysMusic 3 роки тому +1

    Love the Klimt references.
    Klimt is one of my favorite artists of the early 20th century.

  • @Yungtacosss
    @Yungtacosss 6 років тому +20

    Tom King's Batman is incredibly terrible I feel your pain Ben lol

  • @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache
    @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache 5 років тому +5

    Tiffany's "OH COME ON". I felt that. In my soul.

  • @benjaminkellog7311
    @benjaminkellog7311 6 років тому

    "No, you were thinking of that new CBS reality show that's a mix of Survivor, Bachelor in Paradise, and Big Brother." "...That's 'Love Island,' Dave."

  • @flywheelshyster
    @flywheelshyster 6 років тому +1

    my mouth dropped when you said it wasn't wanda and it's a doom bot. recon bullocks. i love the art and similar to hawkeye series i really liked. probably same artist

  • @nycSnowman
    @nycSnowman 6 років тому +3

    Good, Bad, Ugly Weddings in 2018. X-men Gold #30, Injustice 2 #69, Batman #50

  • @donlowe6585
    @donlowe6585 6 років тому +2

    I would LOVE to see Miracleman on BackIssues.

  • @K_Mcwa
    @K_Mcwa 6 років тому +6

    30:04. Ben is very disappointed in you.

  • @benhramiak8781
    @benhramiak8781 6 років тому +6

    Batman number 50? This is gonna be funny.

  • @Marcus-xk9im
    @Marcus-xk9im 6 років тому +2

    0:19 don’t worry Ben, I got the reference

  • @adamquenano8563
    @adamquenano8563 6 років тому +4

    Good Avengers, Bad Civil War, Ugly the Wedding . All of them are overhyped

  • @Cubelarooso
    @Cubelarooso 6 років тому

    Don't remember Big Fat Liar? Tiffany's expression during that exchange was wonderful.

  • @lettersndnumbers
    @lettersndnumbers 6 років тому +1

    Strange kind of looked like Robert Deniro in one panel

  • @ethanrichmond3992
    @ethanrichmond3992 6 років тому +14

    I’m glad Mar-vell never came back. His death is one of the few in comics that matters, and was incredibly heartbreaking to read, especially because it stuck.
    Plus, you can’t just come back from cancer after you’ve DIED from it.

    • @tophfan
      @tophfan 6 років тому

      i mean technically it was time travel and he was going to die anyway so...

    • @ethanrichmond3992
      @ethanrichmond3992 6 років тому

      What do you mean?

    • @ethanrichmond3992
      @ethanrichmond3992 6 років тому +1

      Well, still, it just sort of lessens the effect of him dying so quickly, because now he has a lot of time left to say goodbye.

  • @gorrie3113
    @gorrie3113 6 років тому

    Haha!...OMG Paul Giamatti I remember that movie, very quippy Ben !

  • @nyloc5795
    @nyloc5795 Рік тому

    Ah this was back in a time when you couldn’t be a Tom King fan you had to be a Tom King apologist

  • @doogless
    @doogless 6 років тому

    I really prefer this shorter episode length for this series. And I can't wait for Vision on Back Issues!

  • @kaasw.m6880
    @kaasw.m6880 6 років тому +4

    Yes vision back issues pleaassee!

  • @flywheelshyster
    @flywheelshyster 6 років тому

    ben's reaction to tom king's batman is my reaction to tom king's batman

  • @flywheelshyster
    @flywheelshyster 5 років тому

    I truly loved and laughed how sal jyst moved past the big fat liar reference

  • @flywheelshyster
    @flywheelshyster 6 років тому

    death of captain marvel back issues brought me back!

  • @Aliaskitfisto
    @Aliaskitfisto 6 років тому

    0:24 Never change, Ben. Never change.

  • @sam.e.a6422
    @sam.e.a6422 6 років тому +1

    You guys should do another video on Mr miracle. I think everyone needs to remember a time when tom king didn't clickbait us

  • @CrazyWildChris
    @CrazyWildChris 6 років тому

    yooooooon how the crap did Sal not know about big fat lair lol

  • @LPJZ456
    @LPJZ456 6 років тому +1

    LOL i feel like im the only one who got the big fat liar reference

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  6 років тому +2

      You should read the comments.

    • @LPJZ456
      @LPJZ456 6 років тому +1

      ComicPOP omg I was thinking the same thing after hitting enter and scrolling down 😂
      And holy crap you guys replied! Hi from a fellow new Jerseyan in India at the moment 🤗

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  6 років тому

      Hi!

  • @SophiaSanders61
    @SophiaSanders61 6 років тому

    Isn't the marketing team to blame for making the Batman wedding into this giant thing when Tom King wanted it to be the middle point of his story?

    • @jabezcreed
      @jabezcreed 6 років тому +1

      No. Tom King was all in on the push as well. And the marketing doesn't excuse the poor lead up to this issue. He doesn't get to say that the first 50 issues will be good after reading the second 50 issues. Issue 50's story fell flat after promising to be so much more. It deserves the panning it got. I love the art, and I loved 95% of the run up to the issue (I Am Bane being the exception), and then Tom King threw a bunch of cop out story beats in issue 50. And to make things worse, he just drops a final page reveal that makes absolutely no sense. No one bought a $4.99 Batman wedding issue to see Bane make a cameo.

  • @ivansplvd6518
    @ivansplvd6518 6 років тому +1

    Awesome episode! Agree totally

  • @Exman33x9001
    @Exman33x9001 6 років тому

    I got here early and thought this didn't pop up in my subbox

  • @stickflip4308
    @stickflip4308 6 років тому

    starting off the episode on a strong note i see

  • @SophiaSanders61
    @SophiaSanders61 6 років тому +5

    Why are there so few views on this exciting new "issue" of the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly? Blasphemy!

  • @fredbushee9161
    @fredbushee9161 6 років тому

    Skellig Island was the porg ones....I was just there like 2 weeks ago

    • @TheRealZubes
      @TheRealZubes 6 років тому +1

      Fred Bushee no way! I have heard it's beautiful in person!

    • @fredbushee9161
      @fredbushee9161 6 років тому

      i mean....i was on the "mainland" i could see it in the distance but i didn't get to go out to it at all lmfao but the tour guide was like "that's the star wars island over there"

  • @instantbadass
    @instantbadass 6 років тому +3

    Surprised Death of Superman isnt on here

    • @Martin_TheCollector
      @Martin_TheCollector 6 років тому

      instantbadass maybe because he did die.

    • @Zxzero36
      @Zxzero36 4 роки тому

      I think with death of superman that was a retcon. I think the writers fully intended him to die but they had to give a reason to why he came back

  • @TevyaSmolka
    @TevyaSmolka 6 років тому +3

    i think the batman wedding was the biggest lie

  • @familiacastroconejofederic2016
    @familiacastroconejofederic2016 6 років тому

    Guys, google Chonpiras to look for the live action clone of the plush toy Punisher you have in the background

  • @foley247
    @foley247 6 років тому +1

    🤣🤣🤣🤣 Ben for the cringe.

  • @katiedaly3040
    @katiedaly3040 6 років тому

    Good joke Ben ! 😊lol (cow)

  • @ThePandaSupreme
    @ThePandaSupreme 6 років тому

    I dig the half hour good bad and ugly 😊

  • @loganshirley9058
    @loganshirley9058 6 років тому

    This is my favorite episode of this show

  • @DMorfin11
    @DMorfin11 5 років тому

    I think Tiff should have done the avengers book, she seemed like she enjoyed the story.

  • @johnzaragoza6572
    @johnzaragoza6572 4 роки тому

    ben just gets me

  • @jok86er
    @jok86er 6 років тому

    The people in Gotham know that Selina is Catwoman?

  • @ToonGal12
    @ToonGal12 6 років тому +1

    27:44 I'm sure this is weird to point out, but I've started to notice that both Tiffany and Sal pronounce "Mario" as 'Mere-e-o" and not 'Mar-e-o'. Is that a New Jersey thing?

  • @tremblingcolors
    @tremblingcolors 6 років тому

    Alex Maleev art can either be really good or just look like edgy Tom Goes to the Mayor to me. His style really started to annoy me in his run on Daredevil.

  • @brandonwheeler6612
    @brandonwheeler6612 6 років тому

    Batman 50 turned me off to batman so much that it's the first time I dropped the title in 15 years. I just don't like kings batman at all... The bendis book i thought was really good at the time. It doesn't hold up because of retcons but still was a good book.

  • @ervingarcia874
    @ervingarcia874 6 років тому

    That fucking sucks! so Mar-Vell is going to stay dead forever ? Fuck Marvel! I can't believe they will never bring back Mar-Vell! it's not fair!

  • @NachiketNaik
    @NachiketNaik 6 років тому +1

    Batman 50 was a cash grab bankrupt book. The emotional moments were predictable.

  • @GiottoEman
    @GiottoEman 6 років тому

    Please do Vision! I sent it to you guys!

  • @benhramiak8781
    @benhramiak8781 6 років тому

    Am I the only one that thinks clint looks like the master from doctor who. The john simm one.

  • @michaelravencharnes9543
    @michaelravencharnes9543 6 років тому

    I knew it was a Captain Marvel LOL do know he was a scroll though

  • @zielskie
    @zielskie 6 років тому

    Anyway. The truth is that Tiffany looks gorgeous.

  • @sladetuner8661
    @sladetuner8661 6 років тому

    Batman vol 3 #50 was a predictably lit down and a joke

  • @andrewmatseshe7343
    @andrewmatseshe7343 6 років тому

    God damn it Tom King.

  • @jok86er
    @jok86er 6 років тому +2

    Scarlett Witch is THICC

  • @ryanmiller6103
    @ryanmiller6103 4 роки тому

    Probably in the minority here but kings batman run is pretty great

  • @Benm701
    @Benm701 6 років тому

    Bat....
    Cat.....

  • @jamaalellison941
    @jamaalellison941 6 років тому

    One of these IS a fat lie.

  • @gorrie3113
    @gorrie3113 6 років тому

    Nice jokes

  • @ridge825
    @ridge825 6 років тому

    Sal have you ever torn a comic apart because of how mad it made you?

    • @Axeroix
      @Axeroix 6 років тому

      its too bad cos Ivan Reis' art is spectacular

    • @ridge825
      @ridge825 6 років тому

      JustStat Bendis is cancer to Superman

    • @comicpop
      @comicpop  6 років тому +2

      Nope.

  • @benhramiak8781
    @benhramiak8781 6 років тому

    The batman one is just disappointing.

  • @fun2building
    @fun2building 6 років тому

    It's especially shitty because like if the wedding had actually happened I would have considered this Kings second "classic" story after War of Jokes & Riddles
    It's ESPECIALLY shitty because this arc immediately following the wedding arc is awesome so far
    Still though like every Snyder Batman story is a classic and King has two at most assuming this arc pans out it's buckwild

  • @BurnedChiliMan
    @BurnedChiliMan 6 років тому

    Woooooooooooooooooo

  • @goshdamnbatman8578
    @goshdamnbatman8578 6 років тому

    Lol

  • @robobrando
    @robobrando 6 років тому

    Was Ben high?