@@Scoubidou-if1of but it literally is, that’s why i said it was there’s no reason it can’t be all three things, even if very few people can manage that
Well, it isn't, some of Liszt's hardest pieces are practically unreachable to play in tempo (like 12 grand etudes or Beethoven symphonies transcriptions)
Unless you've seen the whole concert on medicitv or on stage-plus, , try not to make a hasty comment about this artist. The boomerang eventually comes back to yourself.
You should take down the video. The poor audio quality of this snippet only gives a wrong idea of the pianist’s whole performance. Read this comment section to see what I mean.
@@QuocBinh-us7lb u must be smoking Crack when u said it's a boring climax finale. It's one of the reasons why I fell in love with this Exhibition. Didn't care for others since I found it quite a boring piece. But I realized there's a whole drama with this work! And Yunchan was the one who opened my eyes and ears to the masterpiece. What a grande majestic Gate!
He’s amazing AND there are a lot of wrong notes in the octaves. Maybe slow it down to gain more control. Even Horowitz hit plenty of wrong notes. It’s not a bad thing. I’d say it’s noticeable here.
he rearranged the piece himself. Some parts were from Horowitz's score, some parts from the original, and some parts he added himself (like the glissandi in this video).
Of course it isn’t! He followed in the tradition of the great Horowitz, for which we should be thankful. There are other pianists who can play the original score. Yunchan brings his own fire and genius to it!
@@douglaskurz8578 Personally I'm not a fan of this approach. If you want additions, listen to the Ravel orchestration. The piano version should stay as Mussorgski wrote it.
@@karstensandleben3666it's not a piano competition... since the beginning pianists were used to improvise over any piece (read some Liszt facts, during the peak of this, not counting the ancient times)... It's all about personality!
@@georgealderson4424 It’s his way of making his own music. You might prefer others interpretations but don’t call his performance anything other than music. You’d be wrong
I don't disagree. I think the Baba Yaga was too much. I'm sure there are other movements in the larger work that he makes special, but this particular movement is not my cup of tea in his hands (at least in this video). Part of it could be the quality of the recording, but I don't think that's it. There are different levers to pull to make music exciting other than speed and volume. It's a careful balance.
@@user-mr3cz5vt6n nobody is forcing u to listen to this. If u don't like it, go listen to ur type of Exhibition. There are many ppl who were knocked out by this masterpiece performance. I'm one of them. Can't wait to listen to him Live playing this in few months!
Please wisely use your divine talent to create great scenes of musical pictures that audiences can easily enjoy and resonate with your music. Get your musical ideas from GIANT like Gilels and Richter to reach a higher level of artistry. Looking forward to your future success.
I’m sure I’ll get hate for this. But I don’t like the sound he is producing, i guess it’s hard to tell due to the quality of the recording but he is pounding the piano. Technically astonishing but he doesn’t need to whack the piano so brutally.
@@UUpianoman everyone else judging it favorably seems to be viewed as judging it just fine based on this recording. It's only the criticism that is being discounted. It's an interesting double-standard.
He believes to be better than Mr. Mussorgsky in writing piano music maybe, so he decided to add a glissando... A good F1 top qualifying lap, but art is another thing
If you want to hear a perfect presentation of the piece, you’re better off training an AI. It will sound leagues better than anything any musician has ever played. But if you want to hear a musician’s music, you’re better off understanding that this is completely acceptable and has been for the last 300-400 years.
That's what interpretations are called. You certainly don't want to listen to cookie cutter works of the composition, bec it'd be quite boring to play by the textbook. Yunchan is quite known to add his personal touches in not just that piece, but mostly all the works he plays. For example, he added his personal interpretations in Rach 3 live concerts with the ossia. Horowitz added extra notes to the works, and I understand why Yunchan loves Horowitz so much.
@@dionysus4778 interpretation is quite different than add personal non requested notes, sorry. And if even... You need to be able to. That's not the case
@@alexmandelli3994 Music is a form of art, not science where 1 + 1 will always equal to 2. He's an artist, just like Horowitz. You just have to get used to these interpretations, bec that's what Yunchan is quite known for. If it's not your cup of tea, then don't listen to him. Nobody is forcing you. Simple as that.
@@dionysus4778 you don't need to teach me what art is for sure. There's a huge difference between interpretation and bad interpretation. Same between running on a keyboard and playing. That's it.
하르트만의 그림은 아래에 닭발이 달린 시계 모양을 한 바바야가의 오두막을 묘사하고 있다.’ 바바야가는 러시아 민담에 자주 등장하는 마녀이다. 변덕스럽고 광포하면서도 익살스런 악상이 빗자루를 타고 이리저리 날아다니는 마녀의 모습을 묘사한다. 이 악장에서 단절없이 바로 ‘10곡 키이우의 대문'으로 이행된다. Wiki dictionary
@@paulvandenberg9588 of course I can, but criticism is supposed to be with arguments, not just sterile sentences based just on our taste like as if they were the absolute truth. Not interesting for u? Well just don't write anything and save time for u and us to read such sterile comments...
@@mattiadamiani9812 I gave you my argument but you didn't get it. And yes, music is based on taste and very little else. If you think that there are absolute truths in music, make them known.
This is absolutely horrible. He can play much better than this. This is pure spectacle and clownery. These are not the paintings of Mussorgsky’s dear friend who died so young of an aneurism, this is sheer bombast at its worst.
@@theclassicalarchive what does it matter? It's an art, not science where facts are facts, not like in art where freedom of expressions is what make it to be an art. Again, if u didn't like it, go listen to the ones u like. Nobody's twisting ur arm to listen to him.
이번 임윤찬의 연주를 뭐라고 표현해야 하나.. 순전히 주관적인 의견이지만 전람회의 그림을 알고 듣는 청중의 입장에서 임윤찬의 해석이 원곡의 느낌을 파괴한다는 느낌이 들 정도로 과도하다는 생각이 들고 무소르그스키 전람회의 그림을 너무 테크닉적으로 연주한다는 느낌이 들어서 전람회의 그림을 연주하는 게 아니라 리스트의 초절기교 에튀드를 연주하는 느낌이 드네ㅠㅠ 새로운 것, 신선한 것 또는 연주자 본인이 생각했을 때 재미있을 만한 것들을 너무 많이 시도한 것이 오히려 이질감을 들게 해서 이번 연주는 좀 거북한 느낌이 든다..ㅠㅠ
저두 이번 실황 갔었는데 비슷한 생각을 했었어요! 추후에 윤찬군 인터뷰 보니까 본인이 "해야 하는 연주"랑 "하고 싶은 연주"를 나누어 둔다고 하더라구요. 무소륵스키는 하고 싶은 연주라고 언급하기도 했고요. 그래서인지 이번에 1부 사계나 무언가는 오히려 너무 얌전한 느낌(해야만 하는 연주) 이었고, 반대로 2부 무소륵스키는 너무 브레이크를 풀어버린거 같긴했어요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 키예프의 대문 포함해서 전체적으로 연주가 굉장히 묵직해서 푹 퍼져버린거 같은 느낌도 받았고.. 저도 전람회의 그림 너무 좋아하는 곡인데, 감동보다는 감탄? 신기해서 웃음이 나더라고요. 재밌기도 하고.. 정석적인 연주였으면 오히려 눈물이 났을텐데 말이죠ㅎㅎ..
그쵸. 청자의 주관적 해석이 있겠죠. 그런 의미에서 저도 주관적 해석을 하자면 차콥의 사계는 단순하더라도 원작의 시적 느낌을 살려야하는게 어려운거고, 전람회의그림은 죽은 친구의 그림 전시에서 느낀 상상력을 토대로 만든 곡이기때문에 후세의 피아니스트들이 연주하면서 창작의 창작이 얼마든지 가미될수 있는 종류의 음악이란 생각이 들어서 저는 놀랍던데요~
these japanese fellows are certainly amusing.What they lack in technique they certainly make up for in enthusiasm! Alas he needs to apply himself to practice more and work on his sound.Any damn fool can play loud with terrible tone.
![Mussorgsky - Pictures at an Exhibition [Yunchan Lim]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ne9c16YSIMw/mqdefault.jpg)
His fortissimo a sound that I think no other pianist has ever produced. Very unique sound!
Can only mean you have heard VERY few pianists😢
Metallic sound, he has the capacity to strike violently the piano, personally, I don’t like it
What about Matsuev?
That is sheer Yunchan.
Bingo. NOT Moussorgsky, that's for sure.
@@Scoubidou-if1of No irony intended. “Not Moussorgsky”, but It is a great Mussorgsky.
watched this live and everyone was on the edge of their seats 😮😮
was this the one at esplanade? I really wanted to go :((
@@acetonewong4608yup
Bet they were not Russians.
보고도 믿기지않는다.
Wasn’t expecting the glissando to hit me like a truck 😮
So ask yourself "what's a truck doing at the Great Gate of Kiev?". Peddling souvenirs???
Янчан, ты играешь не пальцами , а душой!❤
Great that Im Yoon Chan can actually do that when he needs to.
I'm just grateful
I was just thinking the same thing
My God! Insane, love the glissando he added!
Is it possible??? Just phenomenal
Yea, just a phenomenon.
😮🎉Fantástico, Yunchan!!! ❤Mejor no puede ser!!!! 🌹❤️💙❤️
영상은 불법이지만... 다시봐도 심박수 겁나 오르네..
ㅇㅈ
i’ll never understand how his interpretation is so controlled when he’s playing so loud and fast
If it is SO loud and SO fast, then it is NOT controlled.
@@Scoubidou-if1of but it literally is, that’s why i said it was
there’s no reason it can’t be all three things, even if very few people can manage that
If you listen to pletnev 2003 you will be even more amazed.
g o o s e b u m p s AHHHHH IT SOUNDS SO GRAND
일반인 입장에서 저렇게 뚱땅뚱땅 힘 실어서 내려치는데 다 정확하게 친다는게 신기함 내가하면 미스터치 장난아닌데..
화난 바바야가가 쿵쾅거리며 쫓아 오는데 가까스로 위기를 모면하는 듯한 장면이 눈에 보이는 듯... 이렇게나 찰지고 박진감 넘치는 소리에 심장이 강타 당할 수 밖에요
I lowered the volume on my phone so his hands can rest
I did so my ears can
저부분!!!! 저도 롯콘에서 보면서 소름이 돋아서 기절할것 같았어요!!!
I want his pictures at an exhibition recording asap!!! If he doesnt have a time for studio then just release it as a live album please i beg you
Now i remembered guys medici will stream his recitals couple of days later :D i was desperate but suddenly filled with joy
Unbelievable!
Imagine what it would sound like if he started using his left hand too
I was seated at the same balcony as you! His baba-Yaga was nothing short of crazy.
Waiting for the audio stream from Verbier…
Will it be only audio? And no video?
@@ct3293 We’ll find out!
Stage+and Medici. tv… with video on 20th July (Verbier Festival)
@@ct3293 I’ll get back to you on that.
@@ct3293Medici is the stream provider, meaning it’s def a video stream
i was just listening to pictures at an exhibition yesterday lol
Hmm maybe i shouldnt have sold my tickets
OMG! Truly a once in a generation talent.
와....... 말이 안나오네요 😮😮
he didnt forget hes just god 💀
That gliss at 0:24!
와.. 사람이 아닌듯!!!! 진짜 멋져요
우주가 들썩이네요
This looks as hard as the hardest Liszt pieces
Well, it isn't, some of Liszt's hardest pieces are practically unreachable to play in tempo (like 12 grand etudes or Beethoven symphonies transcriptions)
@@teodorb.p.composer It's just a hyperbolic simile, lol. I do realize that.
@@jiyoukang660 Oh, I get it
Unless you've seen the whole concert on medicitv or on stage-plus, , try not to make a hasty comment about this artist. The boomerang eventually comes back to yourself.
why? is the rest shit?
That poor piano needed a vacay after that! (or surgery...lol)
C’est l’œuvre de Moussorgski qui veut ça !!! Il faut connaître le morceau !
@@Marie-ChristineCoupillaudaaaahhh yo pensé que era la donna inmóbili.
Wow!
That' s sheer harsh hitting with hammers....
저렇게 피아노를 두드리는데 손목이나 팔이 괜찮을까요? 우리 윤찬림 오래오래 피아노 쳐야되는데~ 연주는 너무나 닭살 돋을 만큼 멋진데 말이예요.
به به تکنیک عالی . عاشق این مهارت هستم
The instrument immediately had a nervous breakdown!😅
very yunchan limmy
Super
Really hope he doesn't injure himself again!
그냥 맘대로 냅다 치는듯한 ㅜ
경이롭다
I felt like I was listening to Martha
Do you have the video of the ending of this piece ? 🙏
제발 영상내리지 말아주새요ㅜㅜㅜ
again...where is he....
earth
Wow
You should take down the video. The poor audio quality of this snippet only gives a wrong idea of the pianist’s whole performance. Read this comment section to see what I mean.
How is this piano not collapsing?
This is a pirate cellphone recording with the expected horrible audio. It’s not possible to judge a performance or the artist’s sound quality. 😎🎹
He is in such a frenzy and makes such a goddam noise the Finale turns into a boring Anticlimax😢
@@QuocBinh-us7lb u must be smoking Crack when u said it's a boring climax finale. It's one of the reasons why I fell in love with this Exhibition. Didn't care for others since I found it quite a boring piece. But I realized there's a whole drama with this work! And Yunchan was the one who opened my eyes and ears to the masterpiece. What a grande majestic Gate!
😍😍😍😍😍
This guy had a drop too much Vodka 😂 Better stick to your cup of tea.
그냥가지고 노네
Oh
a new competitor i say? XD
사람은 사람다워야~~
오우 전람회
Судя по видео Юнчан думает что Баба Яга это Джон Уик
참나 그시간에 이걸 찍다니 개념이 없으시네.
Why did he retreat from the first chord of the Kiev gate part…
He is very good , no doubt. It is just that sometimes music is in a second level. And then you can get closer to a circus.
😮😮😮
Martinez Mark Williams Barbara Taylor Helen
He’s amazing AND there are a lot of wrong notes in the octaves. Maybe slow it down to gain more control. Even Horowitz hit plenty of wrong notes. It’s not a bad thing. I’d say it’s noticeable here.
피아노 살려~
These are not yunchan‘s hairs.
This isn’t the original version
he rearranged the piece himself. Some parts were from Horowitz's score, some parts from the original, and some parts he added himself (like the glissandi in this video).
Of course it isn’t! He followed in the tradition of the great Horowitz, for which we should be thankful. There are other pianists who can play the original score. Yunchan brings his own fire and genius to it!
@@douglaskurz8578 Personally I'm not a fan of this approach. If you want additions, listen to the Ravel orchestration. The piano version should stay as Mussorgski wrote it.
@@karstensandleben3666it's not a piano competition... since the beginning pianists were used to improvise over any piece (read some Liszt facts, during the peak of this, not counting the ancient times)... It's all about personality!
@@mattiadamiani9812 I don't care about personality. Want to show it? Write your own piece. But the pieces of others you play as written.
Hmmm.... Let's hope celebrity doesn't turn Yunchan into a circus animal.
Sheesh
yummy
Where is this performance?
Singapore
There comes a time with this sort of performance that requires sifting through to separate cacophony from music in my opinion!
Not sure what you mean by that. Do you think what he’s playing is not music?
Let me rephrase… do you DARE say that?
@@bennyksmusicalworld Some of it was music and some of it was instrument abuse!
얘 또 이러고 있네 윤찬림 영상마다 댓글 싸지르고 있음
@@georgealderson4424 It’s his way of making his own music. You might prefer others interpretations but don’t call his performance anything other than music. You’d be wrong
I don't disagree. I think the Baba Yaga was too much. I'm sure there are other movements in the larger work that he makes special, but this particular movement is not my cup of tea in his hands (at least in this video). Part of it could be the quality of the recording, but I don't think that's it. There are different levers to pull to make music exciting other than speed and volume. It's a careful balance.
К сожалению добрался и до русской музыки....
If you go in for spectacular stuff, then write your own. Please don't go mess up other people's work.
@@user-mr3cz5vt6n nobody is forcing u to listen to this. If u don't like it, go listen to ur type of Exhibition. There are many ppl who were knocked out by this masterpiece performance. I'm one of them. Can't wait to listen to him Live playing this in few months!
Please wisely use your divine talent to create great scenes of musical pictures that audiences can easily enjoy and resonate with your music. Get your musical ideas from GIANT like Gilels and Richter to reach a higher level of artistry. Looking forward to your future success.
What's the name of this work?
Pictures at an exhibition
I’m sure I’ll get hate for this. But I don’t like the sound he is producing, i guess it’s hard to tell due to the quality of the recording but he is pounding the piano. Technically astonishing but he doesn’t need to whack the piano so brutally.
라이브를 들어야해요. 소리가 너무 다르니까
He is a proven artist. It’s the sound he wants, and he seems to be getting it.
Why? I love it. I love it when artists don’t only worry about the sound, but the physicality and emotions involved in actually pressing the keys.
you cannot judge live sound from a set of headphones, no matter how fine the speakers or headphones are.
@@UUpianoman everyone else judging it favorably seems to be viewed as judging it just fine based on this recording. It's only the criticism that is being discounted. It's an interesting double-standard.
Is this a sport competition ?
He believes to be better than Mr. Mussorgsky in writing piano music maybe, so he decided to add a glissando... A good F1 top qualifying lap, but art is another thing
If you want to hear a perfect presentation of the piece, you’re better off training an AI. It will sound leagues better than anything any musician has ever played. But if you want to hear a musician’s music, you’re better off understanding that this is completely acceptable and has been for the last 300-400 years.
That's what interpretations are called. You certainly don't want to listen to cookie cutter works of the composition, bec it'd be quite boring to play by the textbook.
Yunchan is quite known to add his personal touches in not just that piece, but mostly all the works he plays. For example, he added his personal interpretations in Rach 3 live concerts with the ossia. Horowitz added extra notes to the works, and I understand why Yunchan loves Horowitz so much.
@@dionysus4778 interpretation is quite different than add personal non requested notes, sorry. And if even... You need to be able to. That's not the case
@@alexmandelli3994 Music is a form of art, not science where 1 + 1 will always equal to 2. He's an artist, just like Horowitz. You just have to get used to these interpretations, bec that's what Yunchan is quite known for. If it's not your cup of tea, then don't listen to him. Nobody is forcing you. Simple as that.
@@dionysus4778 you don't need to teach me what art is for sure. There's a huge difference between interpretation and bad interpretation. Same between running on a keyboard and playing. That's it.
I hear someone playing fast and loud. I don't understand why this is suppose to be interesting.
하르트만의 그림은 아래에 닭발이 달린 시계 모양을 한 바바야가의 오두막을 묘사하고 있다.’ 바바야가는 러시아 민담에 자주 등장하는 마녀이다. 변덕스럽고 광포하면서도 익살스런 악상이 빗자루를 타고 이리저리 날아다니는 마녀의 모습을 묘사한다. 이 악장에서 단절없이 바로 ‘10곡 키이우의 대문'으로 이행된다. Wiki dictionary
Fast ≠ midi/robot, if u're envy because u can't reproduce it the same way, just be quiet
@@mattiadamiani9812you can't handle criticism? This clip is not at all interesting. Maybe he has learned the notes and nothing more.
@@paulvandenberg9588 of course I can, but criticism is supposed to be with arguments, not just sterile sentences based just on our taste like as if they were the absolute truth. Not interesting for u? Well just don't write anything and save time for u and us to read such sterile comments...
@@mattiadamiani9812 I gave you my argument but you didn't get it. And yes, music is based on taste and very little else. If you think that there are absolute truths in music, make them known.
This is absolutely horrible. He can play much better than this. This is pure spectacle and clownery. These are not the paintings of Mussorgsky’s dear friend who died so young of an aneurism, this is sheer bombast at its worst.
Do you even know what he's playing? If so, you'd understand the whole drama of this piece.
@@dionysus4778Yes, but the sheer pounding in this movement is so unlike of him, even when playing the ferocity of Liszt Etudes 4, 8, 10, and 12
@@theclassicalarchive listen to what you like, bec his playing is unique and incredible that I'm still in awe
Hochvirtuos und gleichwohl extrem unmusikalisch: Mit Mussorgski hat das nicht mehr viel zu tun. Absurd!
disappointing
Horrible....
bro-
i bet u cant even play anything close to this
Very bad he failed so much
Only spectacle 🐒
Not music 😢
Gross
He's not your mirror
@@cyyy2404 nice try
@@OmnivorousOtter101 keep crying
@@cyyy2404 crying laughing at your idol worship 🤣🤣🤣
@@OmnivorousOtter101 I don't even a fan of him I just enjoy music lol pathetic
Real fast, real messy. Go listen to Horowitz.
I love horowitz but recommending him for a clean performance seems a bit ironic
@@user-es9ui3cc3xlisten to Horowitz playing this piece when he was young. The clarity and power is completely unmatched
@@theclassicalarchive just listened, but I've to disagree
@@dionysus4778 Did you listen to him playing this movement when he was young? He took a slower tempo to articulate everything cleanly
@@theclassicalarchive what does it matter? It's an art, not science where facts are facts, not like in art where freedom of expressions is what make it to be an art. Again, if u didn't like it, go listen to the ones u like. Nobody's twisting ur arm to listen to him.
이번 임윤찬의 연주를 뭐라고 표현해야 하나.. 순전히 주관적인 의견이지만 전람회의 그림을 알고 듣는 청중의 입장에서 임윤찬의 해석이 원곡의 느낌을 파괴한다는 느낌이 들 정도로 과도하다는 생각이 들고 무소르그스키 전람회의 그림을 너무 테크닉적으로 연주한다는 느낌이 들어서 전람회의 그림을 연주하는 게 아니라 리스트의 초절기교 에튀드를 연주하는 느낌이 드네ㅠㅠ 새로운 것, 신선한 것 또는 연주자 본인이 생각했을 때 재미있을 만한 것들을 너무 많이 시도한 것이 오히려 이질감을 들게 해서 이번 연주는 좀 거북한 느낌이 든다..ㅠㅠ
저두 이번 실황 갔었는데 비슷한 생각을 했었어요! 추후에 윤찬군 인터뷰 보니까 본인이 "해야 하는 연주"랑 "하고 싶은 연주"를 나누어 둔다고 하더라구요. 무소륵스키는 하고 싶은 연주라고 언급하기도 했고요. 그래서인지 이번에 1부 사계나 무언가는 오히려 너무 얌전한 느낌(해야만 하는 연주) 이었고, 반대로 2부 무소륵스키는 너무 브레이크를 풀어버린거 같긴했어요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 키예프의 대문 포함해서 전체적으로 연주가 굉장히 묵직해서 푹 퍼져버린거 같은 느낌도 받았고.. 저도 전람회의 그림 너무 좋아하는 곡인데, 감동보다는 감탄? 신기해서 웃음이 나더라고요. 재밌기도 하고.. 정석적인 연주였으면 오히려 눈물이 났을텐데 말이죠ㅎㅎ..
정확하네요...
초절기교 듣는 듯 한 느낌
그쵸. 청자의 주관적 해석이 있겠죠. 그런 의미에서 저도 주관적 해석을 하자면 차콥의 사계는 단순하더라도 원작의 시적 느낌을 살려야하는게 어려운거고, 전람회의그림은 죽은 친구의 그림 전시에서 느낀 상상력을 토대로 만든 곡이기때문에 후세의 피아니스트들이 연주하면서 창작의 창작이 얼마든지 가미될수 있는 종류의 음악이란 생각이 들어서 저는 놀랍던데요~
Terrible
these japanese fellows are certainly amusing.What they lack in technique they certainly make up for in enthusiasm! Alas he needs to apply himself to practice more and work on his sound.Any damn fool can play loud with terrible tone.
He's not Japanese, he's Korean but I agree that his playing is becoming more and more like Lang Lang lol
중2가 본 전람회의 그림