MUSLIM "SCHOLAR" CONFUSED ABOUT THE CRUCIFIXION OF JESUS
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лис 2023
- Imran Hosein claimed that Jesus (as) was put on the cross, and believing that it was another person who was crucified was unjust.
➡️ Support Us Through PayPal: paypal.me/syfetalk
📱: SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / syfetalk
Facebook: / syfetalk
Twitter: / syfetalk
-------------------------------
📧:BUSINESS:
syfetalkBiz@gmail.com
-------------------------------
Video uploaded by:
SYFEtalk
#imranhosein #islam #jesus #christianity #muslim #christian #quran #bible - Розваги
Hey guys, if you enjoyed this video, please consider supporting me and my channel by liking and subscribing.
If you want to contribute to help me continue to make more videos and improve the quality of my content,
You can send a donation via:
➡paypal.me/syfetalk
IF THE HADITH WAS APPROVED BY THE PROPHET MOHAMMAD, WHICH WAS NOT, AND DONT BE SURPRISED IF THE PROPHET’S FORESEEING OF THE HADITH ENDING UP IN THE QURAN IS RIGHT, THERE ARE MANY HADITH THAT IS IN THE QURAN BECAUSE THE PROPHET SAID IT WILL END UP IN THE QURAN IF YOU DONT STOP WRITING HADITH ON ME
AGENT 63 LEFT THIS COMMENT
@@AGENTARCHIVESAAlmao wth
No, he brought up a solid point man, God allegedly punishing an innocent man, and making him look like Jesus is wrong. Lying and getting an innocent person killed would be a sin if a person did it.
God is suppose to be better than us. We are no questioning God, but the way in which the qur'an is being interpreted to make Allah look lie a liar and a murderer of an innocent man who didn't claim he was God.
What type of made up story that someone volunteered to die in Jesus place? So Jesus let him do it? What type of man is Jesus to let another innocent man take his place to get crucified, it makes him look like a coward and a liar.
So this man who ever he is, is more brave than Jesus. Who ever this man is, he should have been the Messiah then, if Jesus is such a chicken as you guys falsely claim.
Allah was just a prophet...
@@adim00lah
@@taasmr4203 I agree, this young guy has no respect. There are other interpretations of the qur'an as well that I have heard.
One explaination is that Jesus did die on the cross and that it was the plan of Allah. The qur'an itself is saying essentially that when the Jews claimed they killed Jesus, it was wrong, because in truth it was Allah's plan for him to die. It only appeared that the Jews killed him, but they did not kill him, Allah did.
Allah may be saying, that the Jews taking credit for killing him is false, it was Allah's plan, so only he can get the credit. "They" did not kill him, because Allah did.
The qur'an also mentioned in another verse, those that die God's way, are not truly actually dead.
“Think not of those who are slain in God’s way as dead. Nay, they live,
finding their sustenance in the presence of their Lord.”
- Holy Qur’an 3:169
If someone define themselves as 'Islamic Scholar' and 'Philosopher', that's a big red flag.
lol yeah
He's tryin to sell his "Islamic Eschatology" stories everywhere at every chance.
A "Nostradamus Wannabe".
He's just a conspiracy theorist.
@@Saber23safavi-rafidi-sabai-majosi son of zina son of nargis the bitch of bishr alnakhas and hamida the prostitute of the slave marchent
Once i heard him talking about ottoman -constantinople and his bad mouthing Dr Zakir Naik about constantinople matter, i knew theres something wrong with this guy called a muslim scholar-philosopher.
And at another day when he loudly speaking his conspiracy theory about my country history (Indonesia in 1965), i get confirmed about what kind of guy he is : an ignorant charlatan, who speak loud without any proper knowledge or wisdom about the matter he spoke.
.
I used to listen to him over a decade ago. I can't believe people still listen to him.
I thought it was a bit much when he talked about England being the Island of the Dajjal. When he went to Belgrade and told Serbian TV that Srebrenica wasn't a genocide he really lost me.
He was right about one thing tho. "What a brainwashed ummah we are today" :D
@@PenX79this is a small part the real issue is some traditions that go against islam is more of a problem
@@ericferguson9989 Well Britain colonized most of the world, gave birth to Wahabi Saudi Arabia and established Israeli state. I think he's into something there.
same hier
I don’t know what’s worse him or his fanboys who defend him
Fanboys
You habibi😂
I once called him donkey in the comment section. His fanboys went crazy. He himself didn't answer. Crazy fanboys 🤪
@@htxhallitronix1569 hahaha🤪so funny, not! Btw stop masturbation it’s haram
@@iAkhaass fanboy allert 🚨
The fact that Islam gives you a clear picture of the end of times and the events of Judgement Day already proves itself as the true religion
Alhamdulillah for Islam 😊
Alhamdolillah ☝🏾
That does not make it a true religion. Clarity on a topic does not make it clear.
@@Tomf-tz4pd How about reading the book before commenting on the religion
Alhamdulilallah for ISLAM ❤
@Tomf-tz4pd I would love to help God when he's taking you're punk @ss to hell.
Never change the content of your channel! I've learned so much and pray Allah rewards you for your hard work!
Insha'Allah, I wouldn't. May Allah SWT bless you and reward you immensely for your support since the beginning.
Verses on the crucifixion of Jesus.
Prophesied about 700 years before Christ.
Isaiah 53:4-6
Surely he has borne our griefs
and carried our sorrows;
yet we esteemed him stricken,
smitten by God, and afflicted.
But he was pierced for our transgressions;
he was crushed for our iniquities;
upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace,
and with his wounds we are healed.
All we like sheep have gone astray;
we have turned-every one-to his own way;
and the LORD has laid on him
the iniquity of us all.
1 Peter 2:24-25
He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree, that we might die to sin and live to righteousness. By his wounds you have been healed.
For you were straying like sheep, but have now returned to the Shepherd and Overseer of your souls.
John 19:28-30
The Death of Jesus
After this, Jesus, knowing that all was now finished, said (to fulfill the Scripture), “I thirst.”
A jar full of sour wine stood there, so they put a sponge full of the sour wine on a hyssop branch and held it to his mouth.
When Jesus had received the sour wine, he said, “It is finished,” and he bowed his head and gave up his spirit.
Philippians 2:5-11
Have this mind among yourselves, which is yours in Christ Jesus,
who, though he was in the form of God, did not count equality with God a thing to be grasped,
but emptied himself, by taking the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men.
And being found in human form, he humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross.
Therefore God has highly exalted him and bestowed on him the name that is above every name,
so that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth,
and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father.
Hebrews 12:1-2
Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us also lay aside every weight, and sin which clings so closely, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us,
looking to Jesus, the founder and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is seated at the right hand of the throne of God.
@ssugar 100% agree, great content, keep up the good work brother ❤️🌹 JazakAllah
AllahuAkbar, because of this channel I confessed my shahada.
@thedrbat9572 Alhamdu'Allah welcome back home again, ahki. Subhan'Allah.
Some years back listened to him. I stopped listening to him because he never provides any proof. May Allah swt guide us all and keep us safe on the straight path.
Ameen 🤲🏾
Yupp. Same here.
Once i heard him talking about ottoman -constantinople and his bad mouthing Dr Zakir Naik about constantinople matter, i knew theres something wrong with this guy called a muslim scholar-philosopher.
And at another day when he loudly speaking his conspiracy theory about my country history (Indonesia in 1965), i get confirmed about what kind of guy he is : an ignorant charlatan, who speak loud without any proper knowledge or wisdom about the matter he spoke.
.
@@syariefdirgantara7670 - what I concluded was that he says what is popular mixed with bizarre theories. The main thing in Islam is to have proofs. He never presents that. May Allah swt guide us all.
Sheikh Imran Hosein is good
@@SalmaiChicken : Define good. Why do you think that? Does he substantiate his claims? Are his claims in line with the main body of scholars?
This is the same sheikh who said we''re already within the 40 days of the Dajjal's reign in the 3rd day
lol You sure? If true he seems to make thinks up on his whims and desires. May Allah guide him.
@@CountChocula-on9ixoh well he is a Sufi. I used to listen and watch his videos but when I found out he is a Sufi I stopped.
Thank you, brother for telling to True❤
Jazakallah Khair ❤️
Dude it’s a liar yall claim the Bible is corrupted but yet keep citibg verse from this other call Christians from the past and believe him more than the actual bible. Yall claim yall believe in the prophets but don’t believe in their prophecies. The father of lies yall belong
The uploader is incorrect
@@syfetalk
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮
“And for their saying, "Surely we killed the Masih, Isa son of Maryam, (The Messiah, Jesus son of Mary) the Messenger of Allah." And in no way did they kill him, and in no way did they crucify him, but a resemblance of him was presented to them (i.e. the matter was made obscure for them through mutual resemblance). And surely the ones who differed about him are indeed in doubt about him. (Or: it, "that") In no way do they have any knowledge about him except the close following of surmise, and in no way did they kill him of a certainty.” (Quran 4:157)
*So Allah is saying that We killed Jesus Alehey Salam, but they (Romans) did not, but then Allah is also saying that Allah changed someone's face just like Jesus and then that guy whose face was changed into the face of Jesus was crucified. So, my question is that is Jesus dead or still alive and if he is dead then where in Quran it says that Jesus will return before Qayamat? Also, if Romans crucified someone who looked like Jesus then until Qayamat all modern day Christians will believe that Jesus was actually crucified by Romans so will Christians be responsible for having such belief about the crucifixion of Jesus by the Romans?*
@@taasmr4203you can't trust the story mentioned by Christians, for all you know early true followers of Issa a.s didn't believe he was crucified, or perhaps they didn't know what happened to him, either way the religion of Christianity progressed over time, their theology was not set in stone from the very beginning, all their writings at best date back to 2nd century.
@@taasmr4203as for if he is alive or not, it doesn't really matter, Allah s.w took him up and that's all that matters, and he will return based on the Qur'an where it says علم للساعة "he is a sign of the hour" and as mentioned in authentic narrations.
@@taasmr4203as for if he is alive or not, it doesn't really matter, Allah s.w took him up and that's all that matters, and he will return based on the Qur'an where it says علم للساعة "he is a sign of the hour" and as mentioned in authentic narrations.
@@taasmr4203please read one of my response to this video and also I would love to explain this issue of you want to send me a message .this is a very delicate topic to understand but once you did or any Christian did will be guided. The Imam shouldn't have rejected a common understanding of Muslims not the UA-camr should challenge or criticize him in this manner where he himself lack much substance to this delicate issue
Alhamdullila brother, thank you for bringing the truth 🙏 and removing falsehood. I have seen previous podcast of this shaikh. I also experienced a similar reaction too. May Allah protect the Muslims from shirk..
Thanks for your videos brother, keep on going! May Allah bless you.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
He actually rejects the Qur'an with his theory since Allah s.w says "they did not kill nor *CRUCIFY* him"
3:144 Muhammad is only a Messenger. The Messengers before him have passed on. So, if he died or were slain, would you turn about on your heels? But anyone who turns about his heels, would no harm God in the least. And God will soon reward those who remain appreciative (for the guidance). [The System the Prophet has established is to become a beacon of light for all humanity. The believers will reap the fruit of the Benevolent System here and, then, get rewarded in the Hereafter. 3:101, 3:185, 35:10]
All Messengers before Muhammad are dead, this includes Jesus. Every 'scholar' that has not read or understood the Qur'an but presents an idea that goes against the Qur'an must be and should be condemned as a heretic, Ibn Kathir amongst them. It is no good claiming it has been narrated by someone that the Messenger said this or that, if it goes against the Qur'an it was not from the Messenger and is insulting to him.
@@truehikma even if he died , it still isn't relevant, the relevant fact is Allah took him up and *he was never killed nor crucified* , his return or 2nd coming is not that difficult for Allah to facilitate and make happen even if he died.
@@farhat5325 You do not seem to understand what death means. Allah says in the Qur'an that Jesus will be resurrected on Judgement day, like all of us and never does He say that Jesus will return to earth, fight with swords with fairy tale figures, and the die and go to heaven once more.
The 'scholars' bewildering you with this nonsense have give us the substitution fiction so they have no credibility according to the Qur'an.
@@truehikma and what makes you right and them wrong ?
Your emotional disagreement and belittling of the text is irrelevant, either you have solid scholarly argument against the idea of jesus being raised to heaven and returning or you don't, the fact you refer to it as fiction only proves you are seriously in need of some humble education.
@@farhat5325 I do not need a scholar to tell me what the Qur'an says or follow texts of men that contradict it. What part of all Messengers before Muhammad are dead, which means Jesus as well, do you not understand?
3:144 Muhammad is only a Messenger. The Messengers before him have passed on. So, if he died or were slain, would you turn about on your heels? But anyone who turns about his heels, would no harm God in the least. And God will soon reward those who remain appreciative (for the guidance). [The System the Prophet has established is to become a beacon of light for all humanity. The believers will reap the fruit of the Benevolent System here and, then, get rewarded in the Hereafter. 3:101, 3:185, 35:10]
His interpretation of Yajuj and majuj, and Dajjal are as ridiculous as well. I don't know where he got his information from. I stumbled upon his channel sometime ago and right away realized he is misguiding people, big time
He gets a lot of his nonsense from the Bible, the Talmud, and Israelite stories and myths
What is his interpretation of yajuj and majuj and dajjal
@@syfetalkHe is influenced by dr.Israr ahmed
@@harharharharharharharharha240He thinks Yajooj and Majooj is allegorical and refers to the European expansion if I am not mistaken
@@harharharharharharharharha240I may be highly mistaken because I heard him talking about this years ago so my memory might be failing me
Didn’t he also say that what happened in Bosnia was not a g € n ○ c ¡ d € ?
Yes, he did. and when confronted, he started playing the semantic game
@@syfetalkhe also said Ugurs deserve to be oppressed by China and that they're Gog Mgog 😂
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
@@IvanChrisantus The disputes have been on going among the scholars of Christianity, since 600 years ago, even before Islam was established in Arabia. It will continue until the return of Isa Ibn Maryam (May Allah be please with both of them.) Qur'an takes you to the path of the middle ground. To be on the safe side, don't go to the extreme, believing Isa is a divine being and you, worship him. Worships only the One true God. Among the followers of Jesus Christ today, some have concluded he is not the God. Save your soul. Come to Success.
I love the way you speak english and ur accent! Keep these videos goin! I have many questions and you always give me answers. I keep an open mind so I question my own faith until it is fully proven so thank you for that:)
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
It is clearly stated in the verse in surah an-nisa verse 157 that jesus was not crucified nor was he killed. This man claiming to be a scholar when he is either talking out of ignoranance or deliberatly rejecting a verse from the holy quran. (Rejecting a verse from the quran is rejecting allahs message).
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
@IvanChrisantus anyone could interpret the verse from Surah Nisa 157 to how they see fit. However, it explicitly states that Jesus was neither killed nor crucified, implying that he was never killed. The notion of a body dying while the soul remains alive is a concept without basis, for in order to release the soul from the body, the body must be killed, no one soul really dies cause we will all be judged by god (our souls). One of the biggest problems about christains is that they alway take verses from the Bible and interpret them to fit their beliefs, such as the concept of the Trinity, which some argue contradicts the idea of God as an independent and omnipotent entity, as he has to rely only three individuals to be a whole. Similarly, the assertion that Jesus claimed to be God is often based on vague statements like "before Abraham was, I am," which some Christians interpret as an affirmation of his divinity, though it lacks explicit clarity. Why can't any of the Bibles state an ambiguous statement claiming that "jesus is god" rather than over complicating his divinity.
@@IvanChrisantus take this for example. ua-cam.com/users/shortspwYzV7GYIC0 . A christains is trying to believe that man came up with the mathematical soultion that 2+2 = 4. See your guy's logic. You try to warp everything to fit your logic when its is completly absurd. So when we say 1 + 1 + 1 = 3, a christain comes with the logic to say we could interpret it in any way, shape or form.
@@Alex-xm7hw my friend it's impossible to understand the crucifixion of Jesus if you don't understand the people who were responsible , the Sadducees who were leaders at that time , you have to know them and what they believed concerning death and resurrection!!! and you can't understand the Quran verse above
Candidates for the substitution theory:
- Disciple John son of Zebedee
- Disciple Thomas the twin brother of Jesus pbuh
- Jesus BarAbbas
- Judas Iscariot
- Simon of Cyrene
وَقَوْلِهِمْ إِنَّا قَتَلْنَا الْمَسِيحَ عِيسَى ابْنَ مَرْيَمَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ وَمَا صَلَبُوهُ وَلَٰكِن شُبِّهَ لَهُمْ ۚ وَإِنَّ الَّذِينَ اخْتَلَفُوا فِيهِ لَفِي شَكٍّ مِّنْهُ ۚ مَا لَهُم بِهِ مِنْ عِلْمٍ إِلَّا اتِّبَاعَ الظَّنِّ ۚ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ يَقِينًا (157)
Salmz watching from Trinidad and Tobago 🇹🇹 I agree with you sayfe... just saying Imran Hosein is my father cousin lolz
He a loser
Sheikh Imran Hosein is the best scholar
@@SalmaiChicken you watched the entire video???
@@triniguy3423 Yes I did
@@triniguy3423 If you study Quran 3:55 it says inee mutawafeek nabi esa(as) soul is being taken?
They did not kill Jesus(pbuh)....that is all we need to know. There are things we should not argue and go out of our way to make it conform to our limited minds and understanding. Just like Allah warned us of disputing about the sleepers of the cave.
i agree. Jazakallah Khair
@letmetalk- my comments are now being deleted happens quite often now. So here is my reply to you below👇🏻
***Tom According to the Christian Bible, Jesus can change his appearance.
Proof this first.
****Even his own disciples could not recognize him.
Proof this again.
In Luke 13.33 Jesus admitted that he will not die outside Jerusalem.
For goodness sake why don’t you and your fellow religious community like to read things in context ? Read the next verse ? The reference to Jerusalem is it a kid geography or the inhabitants- Israelites. Jesus in verse 34 has just made the case that non-Israelities do not kill prophets of God .. it has always been the prophets own people the Israelites that kill them. Even in verse 31 of the same chapter you are quoting the Israelite spiritual leaders are basically taunting Jesus with death.
***The crucified victim was killed outside Jerusalem. Hebrew 5:7 states that Jesus prayed for his safety and his prayer was answered.
Are you seriously like reading this as really solidified my thinking that Muslims are living proof that “God sends them strong delusions that they believe a lie”
All the answers to your objections are in the very chapters that you are quoting. I truly dislike Muhammad for what he has created in Muslims. The author of the Hebrews is literally quoting from Prophet Moses. From Prophet Moses will understand the role his brother, Aaron received high priest.
Jesus is both the sacrifice and High Priest. The author of Hebrews literally is telling you in verse 3 that even the high priest must offer a perfect offering for himself.
Jesus Christ the High priest offered to God a perfect life and sacrifice therefore, the same way that Aaron and his sons who officiated as High Priest were saved from death so Jesus is also saved from death. The first thing Jesus did when He rose from the dead was go to heaven to see if his sacrifice was accepted by the Father then He comes back to earth and stays with his followers for 40 days.
“Touch Me not; for I am not yet ascended to My Father: but go to My brethren, and say unto them, I ascend unto My Father, and your Father; and to My God, and your God.” John 20:17.
****Quran does not state explicitly of the substitution theory. Why bother getting involve in the debate of who was crucified instead?
The Bible is clear, God taught the Hebrews for 4000 years that He will come and give His Life.
***That is for the Christians to provide concrete proof if they claim Jesus was crucified. So far, they fail to produce any. The claim of Jesus crucifixion is made by the Christians. Without it, they can never be saved.
You are a Muslim your very spiritual existence is to opposed Christianity. As someone who follows the anti-Christ I need not answer to you friend.
@@Tomf-tz4pd
According to the Christian Bible, Jesus can change his appearance. Even his own disciples could not recognize him.
In Luke 13.33 Jesus admitted that he will not die outside Jerusalem.
The crucified victim was killed outside Jerusalem.
Hebrew 5:7 states that Jesus prayed for his safety and his prayer was answered.
Quran does not state explicitly of the substitution theory.
Why bother getting involve in the debate of who was crucified instead?
That is for the Christians to provide concrete proof if they claim Jesus was crucified.
So far, they fail to produce any.
The claim of Jesus crucifixion is made by the Christians.
Without it, they can never be saved.
That's exactly how should we behave! It certainly is the matter of Emaan to believe that he was not killed nor crucified and that it was made appeared to them but how this happened is a matter of debate and open for argument and not a matter of Emaan as it is not mentioned in Quran and Hadiths. If someone didn't attribute something to prophet AS. then it doesn't have the level of Hadith no matter who said it and how saheeh this is. Thus everything else is n this sense would be a conjecture and assumptions as Allah said in Quran 4:157
Argument/assumption #1:
Someone did die on the Cross thus crucified but wasn't Essa A.S. but his look alike.
Argument/assumption #2: No one Died on the Cross thus not crucified ! But Allah saved Essa A.S. on the cross from death thus didn't let him crucified ! This arguments has more plausible and circumstantial biblical evidences which could be correlated with some of Quranic passages regarding this matter. Id be more than happy to explain it if one want to. It is a lengthy topic and requires very thoughtful understanding
Just to point out few facts:
-"Background of this incident."
-Jews didn't believe if Essa AS. Was the true Messiah(the chosen one) they were in doubt as Essa A.S. criticize their Rabbis of wrongdoings and corruption(according to Bible Old and New testament and Quran) So, as according to their tradition True messiah could not be killed(they still believe this and waiting for him) So they wanted a challenge a sign from him to believe though he had shown all the miracles yet they called it majic (Quran 5:110) gospels prove this too.
-Hence there was a challenge in Bible between Jews and Essa A.S. called Sign of Jonah to prove if Essa A.S. was the true Messiah or not. If Essa A.S. fulfills his challenge then he is the Messiah and if not then he isn't!.(please read the sign of Jonah in Gospel)
-yahood set a trap to get Essa A.S. killed by the Roman by falsely accusing him of claiming King thus challenging Roman authorities which he didn't and was cleared of this accusation at the court.Yet they insisted to have him killed to prove that he isn't the True Messiah. so it was proceeded while Romans declared him innocent.!(Gospel)
-In Gospel, Essa A.S. prays to Allah (In SaJood like a Muslim) to be saved from this (crucifixions) and surrenders his Will to Allah's Will (again like a Muslim) this is before his arrest.(Gospel)
-In Quran Allah promises Essa A.S. to save him from the wicked people snares surah 3:55 .
-As the Story goes in Gospel one finds various evidences that how he was not killed on the cross(thus not crucified)but was actually saved and was brought down while alive but it did look as he died!!! The very Quranic view!!
If this argument is explained to Muslim , Christians and Jews and if they come to the common ground it would be that Essa A.S. was saved and didnt die, he was the True Messiah ! Will make Christian and Jews agree with the Quranic Stand about Jesus A.S.... is this why on his second coming he will break the Cross??!!
Like I said it's very complex and detailed and one need a lot more depth to understand this, so Allah didn't explain it in the Quran for Quran is for everyone to read ..further more one of the mission of Messenger of Allah Pbuh. Was to clear Essay of the slanders fabricated by News and his misguided believes and confirm that he didn't fulfill his challenge the sign of Jonah when Allah saved him! And this is In Bible that a comforter will come and tell the world abt ain of not believing in Essa AS. And also in Quran.61:6.
Don't hesitate to ask me it's very important for Muslims to know
And Allah Knows the best
Salam
Well, It certainly is the matter of Emaan to believe that Essay AS. was not killed nor crucified and that it was made appeared to them but how this happened is a matter of debate and open for argument and not a matter of Emaan as it is not mentioned in Quran and Hadiths. If someone didn't attribute something to prophet AS. then it doesn't have the level of Hadith no matter who said it and how saheeh this is. Thus everything else is n this sense would be a conjecture and assumptions as Allah said in Quran 4:157
Argument/assumption #1:
Someone did die on the Cross thus crucified but wasn't Essa A.S. but his look alike.
Argument/assumption #2: No one Died on the Cross thus not crucified ! But Allah saved Essa A.S. on the cross from death thus didn't let him crucified ! This arguments has more plausible and circumstantial biblical evidences which could be correlated with some of Quranic passages regarding this matter. Id be more than happy to explain it if one want to. It is a lengthy topic and requires very thoughtful understanding
Just to point out few facts:
-"Background of this incident."
-Jews didn't believe if Essa AS. Was the true Messiah(the chosen one) they were in doubt as Essa A.S. criticize their Rabbis of wrongdoings and corruption(according to Bible Old and New testament and Quran) So, as according to their tradition True messiah could not be killed(they still believe this and waiting for him) So they wanted a challenge a sign from him to believe though he had shown all the miracles yet they called it majic (Quran 5:110) gospels prove this too.
-Hence there was a challenge in Bible between Jews and Essa A.S. called Sign of Jonah to prove if Essa A.S. was the true Messiah or not. If Essa A.S. fulfills his challenge then he is the Messiah and if not then he isn't!.(please read the sign of Jonah in Gospel)
-yahood set a trap to get Essa A.S. killed by the Roman by falsely accusing him of claiming King thus challenging Roman authorities which he didn't and was cleared of this accusation at the court.Yet they insisted to have him killed to prove that he isn't the True Messiah. so it was proceeded while Romans declared him innocent.!(Gospel)
-In Gospel, Essa A.S. prays to Allah (In SaJood like a Muslim) to be saved from this (crucifixions) and surrenders his Will to Allah's Will (again like a Muslim) this is before his arrest.(Gospel)
-In Quran Allah promises Essa A.S. to save him from the wicked people snares surah 3:55 .
-As the Story goes in Gospel one finds various evidences that how he was not killed on the cross(thus not crucified)but was actually saved and was brought down while alive but it did look as he died!!! The very Quranic view!!
If this argument is explained to Muslim , Christians and Jews and if they come to the common ground it would be that Essa A.S. was saved and didnt die, he was the True Messiah ! Will make Christian and Jews agree with the Quranic Stand about Jesus A.S.... is this why on his second coming he will break the Cross??!!
Like I said it's very complex and detailed and one need a lot more depth to understand this, so Allah didn't explain it in the Quran for Quran is for everyone to read ..further more one of the mission of Messenger of Allah Pbuh. Was to clear Essay of the slanders fabricated by News and his misguided believes and confirm that he didn't fulfill his challenge the sign of Jonah when Allah saved him! And this is In Bible that a comforter will come and tell the world abt ain of not believing in Essa AS. And also in Quran.61:6.
Don't hesitate to ask me it's very important for Muslims to know
And Allah Knows the best
Salam
Thank you, brother. May Allah's favor be always upon you brother.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
Thanks for this clarification, I know he was wrong but your explanation helped to know why. Also, I didn't know about the hadith as well.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
We Muslims argue over a thing that is not that important.
Read the Quran and forget the opinion of the Tafsir and Hadith for the moment. I am not saying to reject them.
Imagine we were Ibn Kathir or Imam Bukhari who live 400 years after the Prophet SAW.
Now where can we get the source to write the Tafsir or to decide whether the Hadith is authentic or not. Remember non of the Hadith were ever authenticated or written by the prophet himself otherwise there would not be 4 Madhab.
First lets read the Quran translation word by word. Does it say anything about another man was changed to look like Isa AS and was crucified instead of the Prophet?
The only word mentioned is "shubbiha lahum" meaning it was made to appear (so) to them.
So the most accurate translation word by word without adding our own words are :" And not they killed him and not they crucified him but it was made to appear (so) to them".
So that is it!!
Imagine now you were born 100 years after the death of Prophet Muhammad pbuh. Far before Imam Bukhari or Ibn Kathir were even born. How would you look into this? Remember there were 600,000 hadith where mostly were considered as fabrication. Just imagine you have excess to all the hadiths. What would you say about the verse?
There are four theories:
1/ Isa AS could be replaced by Judas the guy who was a traitor
2/ Isa AS was replaced by innocent person
3/ Isa AS was not dead as he was in coma after being crucified.
4/ An angel took the form of Isa AS and pretended to be killed.
Which would make less sense among these theories?
2/ Isa AS was replaced by an innocent person.
So as a Scholar who knew that Hadith were not authenticated by the prophet nor he himself wrote them, what would you wrote in your Tafsir?
So which of these remaining theories would you use in you Tafsir?
If it was me, I would say ...None!
Because only Allah knew what actually happened as it was not mentioned in Quran and the Hadith was not written or authenticated by the Prophet pbuh himself.
You would say I am a kafir for not believing in the Prophet's sahabah or Imam Bukhari or Ibn Kathir!
Well I only believe in the Prophet himself 100% but as for the Sahabah and other scholars .....may be 70-90%. Why?
First there are 4 madhab with different understanding of some of the verses in the Quran and hadith.
Secondly, who fought in the Battle of Siffin and Battle of Jamal? Was it the Jews against Muslims or Christians against Muslims?
And how was the battle fought? WHo were killed and who killed them? Or maybe, we could fabricate a fake hadith saying that no one died as they only fought in the battle by playing Chess?
So stop being a "Jerk" accusing other Muslims being a Kafir just because his opinion differ from your teacher or your madhab.
If you refuse to use your logic and only believe blindly with your Sheikh teaching, you are no different from the Christians who believe in their Priests or Pastors' bullshit..
I got to share this on my fb rightaway
I m imam mehdi and call all the peaple in World come to islam in peace
jzkAllah khair for exposing this fraud.
Firstly ,let`s not confuse right and wrong. Saying that Allah SWT made someone else to appear as Eesa A.S. would indeed be injustice to that person because
1.He whoever is ,is not Eesa A.S ,not the Messiah ,not The Word of Allah SWT , but to say that Allah SWT raised Eesa A.S. is not wrong ,because the verse does not mention "someone else" .The verse 157 says that it was made to appear so ,not made someone else to appear as Eesa A.S.
2.Allah SWT is The Most Powerful ,The Most Just ,so if He SWT wanted to save His Prophet ,He would not need to place someone else in his A.S. stead ,He can do whatever He Wills ,and if He wanted to punish someone ,He wouldn`t need to make that person as someone else ,much less as His Prophet ,so saying that made someone else appear as His Prophet to save His Prophet is also a nonsense.
3rd.157.and for boasting, “We killed the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the messenger of Allah.” But they neither killed nor crucified him-it was only made to appear so.1 Even those who argue for this ˹crucifixion˺ are in doubt. They have no knowledge whatsoever-only making assumptions. They certainly did not kill him.
Verse clearly states :it was made to appear so , not "We made another to appear so" or something similar.
4.It states that those that argue about crucifixion are in doubt ,not only to state that it was not Eesa A.S. that wasn`t in cross but also to state that those that argue about it are not sure themselves ,no knowledge whatsoever ,only making assumptions.
5.Even if Ibn Abbas R.A. said it ,it does not say that he R.A. said that Rasul Allah SAW said it ,so it can be wrong.
and finally ,don`t compare the story of Ismail A.S. to the story of Eesa A.S. cause you`d be making massive mistake : Ismail A.S. was put to be sacrificed as a test for him and Ibraheem A.S. ,and they both passed it ,as for Eesa A.S. was not going to be sacrificed as a test ,he A.S. was going to be murdered if Allah SWT had not raised him unto Himself.
Also, Imran Hossein is a scholar ,wait until you have his qualifications and debate him ,that would be fair ,cause what you are doing is same as backstabbing ,saying that he doesn`t know is same as calling him ignorant ,and that is serious accusation you`re doing ,so beware ,Allah accounts you for everything .
And Allah knows everything best.
Also ,Eesa A.S. did not die ,and you are claiming he quotes bible but you are also quoting bible , and most funny thing is that none of you truly understand the verse 157. Why in the end says "they certainly did not kill him" not "they certainly did not crucify him" . It is because of the after math ,that they claim he A.S. came back to life ,Quran affirms that he A.S. did not die to begin with.
Instead of explaining you accuse the other one ,truly low, our Prophet SAW taught us to correct our brother`s mistakes not to accuse each other of disbelief in first mistake.
The dude is a good example of 'schoolboy' Sheikh's talking about.
The best comment I have seen here, barakallahu fik
this man does not qualify to be islamic school teacher nor to be called a scholar the same man said aircraft are dajal
It's clearly stated by Allah in His Qur'an, anyone who contradicts Allah is a disbeliever. Astagfirullah
as always this is very beneficial knowledge content :)
☝️May Allah bless you brother for telling the truth, a correction was needed because the Quran is decisive and clear on this matter, they neither killed nor crucified Jesus/ Isa pbuh, imagine the Christians applauding this brother for this statement!
Christians were happy with his statement. It's like he confirmed the crucifixion and resurrection for them. Subhanallah
He doesn't say Jesus died due to crucifixion instead what he says is that the Jews demanded Hazrat Isa A.S be crucified as this was a cursed way according to them to die. The Romans supported them in doing everything but the Jews had to put Hazrat Isa A.S on the cross which they could only do for 10 hours as they had to bring Hazrat Isa A.S down at Magreb time because it was start of the Saturday where Jews not allowed to do anything. At that time Hazrat Isa A.S was alive and taken to Heaven. Although not a mainstreaming theory it doesn't contradict the Quran. 1. Because the Quran gives examples of where Kufar powers have tried to execute Prophets and Allah has allowed them to try most famous example is Hazrat Ibrahim A.S being thrown in the fire. 2 It matches the accounts in the bible and the traditions of the Jews which would explain why they were in a hurry to bring Hazrat Isa A.S down so quickly because crucifixion is a very evil way to die usually a person dies very slowly suffocating under their own body weight as well as severe exposure to the elements over several days to weeks 10 hours on the cross would be extremely painful but would not kill you.
@@zaynpharm
According to the Christian Bible, Jesus can change his appearance. Even his own disciples could not recognize him.
In Luke 13.33 Jesus admitted that he will not die outside Jerusalem.
The crucified victim was killed outside Jerusalem.
Hebrew 5:7 states that Jesus prayed for his safety and his prayer was answered.
Quran does not state explicitly of the substitution theory.
Why bother getting involve in the debate of who was crucified instead?
That is for the Christians to provide concrete proof if they claim Jesus was crucified.
So far, they fail to produce any.
The claim of Jesus crucifixion is made by the Christians.
Without it, they can never be saved.
@letmetalk2240 Agree but whilst I don't agree with everything Imran Hosein says I don't think he's Kafir and definitely does give you a new perspective to reflect on so shouldn't be blindly dismissed as this video does.
@@zaynpharm Let Allah SWT decide whether he's kafir or not.
Well said you now have spoken the truth about the Quraan and open the eyes of the people God has given you great guidance Allah hu Akbar God is great
I used to follow him for years. Alhamdulilleh I left him years ago.... truly misguided.
Perhaps he confuses the bible with the quran. Even a child can understand that jesus (peace upon him) was not killed or not crucified in the quran.
He is confused. He claimed that the body of Jesus (as) was put in a cave when Allah swt told us in the Quran that Allah swt raised him to himself way before the so-called crucifixion
@@syfetalk Hope he's really confused. He's old and seems tired. Could be that.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
That so called scholar is digging a pit for himself on front of Allah.He keeps talking from his whims and own opinions almost completely.
Great post brother.Followed Imran Hossain before but cant take his attitude to other scholars mocking them and just got a hunch that he is misleading many Muslims
Why are you a muslim
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮..
I used to listen to him in 2012 when i found his lectures unique and dramatic. But by 2014 I realized either this guy was either a state sponsored shiekh like Yasir Qadhi or lacked complete understanding of quran and hadith
Either of these scenarios make Allah and Jesus look bad though. They claim someone volunteered to take Jesus place, and Jesus was okay with it? It makes Jesus look like a coward, and it makes Allah look like a liar.
If Allah wanted to save Jesus, there is no need for any trickery. When he saved the Jews from the Egyptians he split the red sea and didn't try to hide it. God is not a liar, Jesus is not a chicken.
@@adim00lah or you fucking idiot. Allah saved jesus because it was already ordained for him to be saved for a bigger mission and it appeared to them that they did kill him. Now that can be translated different by different people. It could mean anything, it could mean that Allah saved him like he saved Abraham from the fire. But it appeared to the people that he was burned when he wasnt. But either way Allah does what he pleases and has no need for trickery. This world is nothing but a test and to a muslim its just a crossway to eternity. As a prophet of God their main objective is to deliver the message and the greatest death is martyrdom for the sake of Allah so it’s safe to assume that Jesus would’ve probably died like his cousin John the baptist if it were up to him.
Thank you for calling out this despicable man.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
We’ll said Brother, this was very important! People need to be aware of this Sheikh, I use to listen to him years ago and I like him but he’s talking rubbish! Don’t know what happened to him! Hope he realises his mistake!!
Once i heard him talking about ottoman -constantinople and his bad mouthing Dr Zakir Naik about constantinople matter, i knew theres something wrong with this guy called a muslim scholar-philosopher.
And at another day when he loudly speaking his conspiracy theory about my country history (Indonesia in 1965), i get confirmed about what kind of guy he is : an ignorant charlatan, who speak loud without any proper knowledge or wisdom about the matter he spoke.
.
Sheikh Imran Hosein is correct
@@SalmaiChicken No he is not, not according to Islam, not according to the Quran, so you wrong, so is he
@@maqboolusman2914 Read Quran 3:55 the word mutawafeek is used meaning jesus's soul was taken
@@SalmaiChicken I’m not saying that everything he says and has ever said is all wrong at all, like I said I’ve always liked him, still do, people can misunderstand sometimes, not saying I would never listen to him again either
Allah says in the Quran.. when you listen to speech take what is good leave the rest.
The only speech we cannot question or choose to like or dislike is the Quran and Hadith
The rest we can agree or disagree, by deciding if it matches the Quran/Hadith.
Peace
In Islam, they have the substitution theory.
In Christianity, they have the Trinity theory.
Human interpretation is rarely, if ever perfect.
Using the inventors of the Trinity as your proof of substitution is drinking from the same poisoned well.
Brother , I like your shows and arguments with the non Muslims but here on this one I say you are too young to be criticizing him in this way. Secondly All muslims agree that Essa A.S. was not killed but raised to Allah. And how this happened none is really sure as it's not in Quran nor in Hadith. What you referred as Ibn Abbas it is a narration not even Hadith. This open to a debate Now when Quran says he was not Killed but it appeared to them like that doesn't mean someone else had to be crucified. This is a very long subject to talk about and with very fine understanding. I really advice you to not criticize or debate upon this topic like that. Mostly the theory of substitution comes from Gospel of Barnabas. But if we want to explain the Quranic stand" but it appeared like" to them. It doesn't negate the understanding of Essa A.S.being saved by Allah where he was supposed to be dead and this all could be proved by all four accepted Bibles. If we correctly believe and take Quranic stand as the guide that he sure was not kiled nor crucified and then read the details in Existing gospels the Quranic stand on this topic will be proven that he was not killed nor crucified. Just to point out "Sign of Jonas" described in gospels" as a key to solve this issue aligned with Quranic stand. Also crucification doesn't mean you put someone on Cross but a person must die on it and that constitutes to a crucification . For example if one is sentenced to death by hanging and are hanged but they don't die after taking down from the noose then it will not be considered as that person was "Hanged" so here term "Hanged "and "Crucify" are technical terms not mere actions. In both scenarios a person must be placed on Noose or Cross and death must occur; this will be described as Hanged or Crucified so both segments must occur in order to be considered it Hanging or crucification. Again it is a very long topic and Neither that Imam should have addressed this issue without going into it's fine details , back grounds and references; nor you should react in this way without doing a thorough research on the topic. You are young and do not have the. Intellect level or are very experienced and well versed scholar of Islam and Bible. Mere UA-cam videos and internet research will not qualify you to argue about anything especially with Islamic scholars. If you or anyone want to know the complete understanding of this issue ; I will be more than happy to explain it . Send me a message and keep things respectful or blocked.
Salam
Thank you for addressing this because this is exactly how I felt when I watched this video. This brother who is not a scholar or a shiekh is criticizing someone who’s dedicated is whole life in studying the eschatology of Islam.
@@Zeeeee19 exactly , sadly, this is a common attitude among our ummah to be impulsive and deny or accept a issue without getting the full picture of the issue. Incomplete knowledge is worst than having no knowledge! It is very simple to criticize other , let's say Christian and Christianity because their basis is undoubtedly very weak and crumbling and it is according to their own fair scholars who now the history.so it is very easy of any Muslim with a little good faith and knowledge to debate and win with them but this shouldn't make them think that now they are they are the Scholars.of Islam and can criticize and discredit Muslim Scholars who are not been declared Kafir or non-muslim by the Majority of the Scholars and ummah.and even that is only on the clear cut rules of Islam, such as denying the seal.of prophethood by the Qadiyani cult. It is clearly defined in Quran and is part of the faith. Now something that has not been clearly defined in Quran nor in Hadith and is not part of core faith is not an argument to declare some one Kafir. The core issue here is the Emaan that Allah saved the Essa A.S. as he promised him in surah 3 Vers 55. And anyone believes in this is not going against the Quran or the Hadiths hence is a believer and a sound Muslim. When it comes to how he saved it Allah only said it appeared to them that they killed him but never mentioned how He saved him and that's where it opens up the whole deby and arguments and none will claim to be more right except with more convincing proves. even after that it won't be an issue to dwclare.or decide whether someone is Kafir or going against the Allah ot Quran. Iman and this young cat both have right to bring about there way of understanding this issue but with proves and let it be understood by whomever wants to. But certainly everything would be a conjectures.and assumptions as s Allah says in surah 4 aya 157. And it is be abuse Neither Allah nor he Messenger A.S. told us how did this happen
Wallah Alim
Feel free to ask me if you really want to understand more convincing view of this crucification with rather more convincing proves. I'd love to explain and it is very important for Muslims to understand this incident as correctly understanding this incident demolishes the whole slander by so called believers of Essa A..S
This was another mission of Messenger of Allah to clear Essa A.S. of the Slanders fabricated by his opponents and so called believers. As a Muslim and followed of the Messenger A.S. we must do this as well. Work to clear slanders against Essa AS. One that He comes to be God or son of God and other that he died or was killed ! In Gospels it is referred to Essay A.S. saying that. Comforter will come. And will tell the world of sin of not believing in me. To which Allah also mentions in surah 61 aya 6. Ahmad mean the one who praise and here Messenger of Allah A.S. praised Essay A.S. to be righteous and Messiah hence praising him by clearing him of slanders that were fabricated by his opponents and misguided believers. Example 5:110 and 5:116-117 .
Don't hesitate to ask me for this is very important topic.
Salam
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
6:42 I keep returning to this video 😂😂 just to hear this part. Oh Brother Syfe, please do more reactions and response to this man's video, Expose him brother. May allah reward you.. ameen.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
The scholar is right though. Where's the issue? He is trying to save islam from an obvious stupidity.
Love your videos from Somalia 🇸🇴
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
Barakallu feekum. May allah azzawajal increase your knowledge With striving the ummah for allah's sake
Jazak Allah kairan dear brother mashaAllah tabark Allah keep doing what you doing spreading the truth ur my favorite youtuber after Daniel
May Allah bless you and protect you. ❤ and may Allah guide the Uma to the truth and unite us all all hu ma amin.🤲🏼
Finally a wise man telling the truth, pls you better listen to him. Jesus is Lord. 1 cor 15:1-5, john 3:16
وفقكم الله لما يحبه ويرضاه
This man, when asked by me, was Constantinople, now Instambul, conquered by Muhammad al Fatih, he said no, and he said that city, constantinople must still be conquered. This man is confused as he is a self taught man.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮...
It means Jesus didn't die via crucifixion per say but his spirit was raised while upon the cross. Substitution theory makes no sense.
I did not know about ibn abbas(ra) narration.
Alhamdulillah, learned something.
They have an alternative interpretation of Surah 4:157 which was written in direct response to unbelieving Jews who were mocking early Muslims for believing that Jesus was the messiah. For they said, “We already killed your so called messiah, Jesus, the son of Mary.” (For the Jews had already by then in circulation a succinctly written antimissionary account of Jesus’ life akin to _Ma'aseh Yeshu_ or _Toledot Yeshu_ etc.) But they (the Jews) did not kill him, nor did they (the Jews) crucify him. But it was made to appear (i.e. to seem) to them (that they were the ones who crucified and killed Jesus, as in the revisionism found in 'Acts of the Apostles'). And indeed, those who differ (i.e. whose opinions differ among dispersed religious Jews) concerning it are in doubt about it. They have no direct knowledge of it (i.e. about the death by crucifixion of Jesus) except to follow suspicion (i.e. their handbook in circulation), for they did not kill him. (It was the Romans who had flogged and crucified Jesus for being a messianic claimant, as they had summarily done to several others)
Thank you for explanatio
Yes but it's a theory and we have to ask for evidence of where Ibn Abbass ( ra) got this report from . Me myself I don't ascribe to the substitution theory because it's a theory . We know Jesus was not crucified as fact but Allah says , it appeared to them so " and that is all we need to know . We can make many assumptions but there is no clear cut answer . I see no wrong with what the Sheik said . I think my brother Syfe misunderstood his statement . But we should not act like we are sure about what happened just to be careful not to ascribe falsehood to Allah and his messenger .
This. I agree with you. It's needlessly divisive to argue about specific details about broader knowledge that we all agree on. We know that Jesus (AS) did not die as we understand death to be. How that happen should not concern us.
Imran Hossein's claims are in the category of Theory based off on the Bible. No where does it states in the Quran or Hadith states that Nabi Isa( Alayi Salaam) was put on the Cross as claimed by Imran Hossein. Imran Hossein himself should not use the Bible to Interpret the Quran. He himself need to prove from Quran and Hadith only That Jesus was put on the Cross and in addition he must also provide evidence that Nabi Isa( Alayhi Salaam) was buried in a Cave which is as well not mentioned in the Quran or Hadith. Imran Hossein himself uses invalid sources for his Theories. The Bible is an invalid source which Imran Hossein uses to base his claim making his claim invalid. Also the tiny Remnants of the Gospel existing during the Time Of Nabi Muhammad Sallallahu Alayhi wa Sallam is a more reliable source of Truth then the Four Synoptic Gospels which are the basis of Imran Hossein's baseless theories based off on the four Synoptic Gospels. Claims not found in the Quran or Hadith.
@@Darthnemesis3581 I think you misunderstand my point . 1. Can we really say without a doubt that someone was crucified in his place ? Allah says " it appeared to them so " .2. Did ibn Abbas get his report from Nabi Muhammad ? ( sws) Where did his report come from
As Muslims it is irrelevant what or how the events took place, what difference does it make ? Nothing at all, all that matters is Issa a.s was not crucified, but the silly minded people bring such claims against muslims, so we stick to the exact words in the Qur'an "it only appeared so to them"
@@farhat5325 Yes ahki that is the point . Sheik Hossein theory is his theory like anybody else's theory . All he is saying is we should not assume the replacement theory and gives reasons why . That is more sensible to me . They killed him not they crucified him not . That is all that matters .
They declared, "We have put to death the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the Messenger of God." They did not kill him, nor did they crucify him, but it only seemed to them [as if it had been so]. And those who differ in this matter are in doubt concerning it. They have no definite knowledge about it, but only follow mere conjecture. But they certainly did not kill him. (Nisâ 4:157)
People who rely on hadith differs from Quran in this matter because the iblis has helped them lost the meaning of crucifixion so that they would become confused today and start looking for hadith sources to explain the quran. When Rasulallah gave the qutbah, it was clear and did not did hadith for clarity. Crucifixion does not mean nailed or hunger to the cross, it means death by hanging or nailing to the cross or stake. And death means mout, never to return until resurrection. So quran is clear.
Voluntary suicide is not islamic nor would Essa ask people to die for him this wont make him the massih.
Beautiful video ❤.
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮.
That was clear information. Mashaalahh..
I used to listen to (no sheikh) Imraan Hoosain years ago, but stopped completely when he said Gog n Magog are out and about now at this time😂😂😂, Qadiani? Quranist? U decide😮
*I once followed him very closely, even buys his books... but not anymore....*
mansha ALLAH
may ALLAH bless you you’re talking the truth ❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️🇸🇴❤️
Iska waran
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮..
INTERPRETATION OF QURAN BY SOMEONE IS NOT A LAW THAT WE SHOULD FOLLOW IT......ANYONE CAN INTERPRET THE QURAN BUT SHOULD SAY THAT ALLAH KNOWS BEST.......QURAN IS THE MOTHER LAW IT JUDGES HADITH AND OTHER SCRIPTURES
Nisa 4;157 . " For their saying , We killed the MESSIAH Isa the son of Maryam , the MESSENGER of ELOIM! They did not kill him ( because they couldn't kill his soul only his body) , nor did they crucify him ( because they couldn't crucify his soul only his body) but it appeared to them ( for three days and three nights) as if they had . Those who dispute are in doubt of Him they have no knowledge except to follow conjecture.They did not kill him for a certainty ( because they couldn't kill his soul) " , in injil Isa says don't fear those who can kill the body but can't the soul rather you should fear ElOIM the only one who can kill the body and the soul, after resurrection of Isa Sadducees (Jews leaders) who did not believe in resurrection who also believed that the soul dies with the body after three days Isa rose from the dead so the Sadducees were disproven, it was clear prove that there's resurrection , and the soul does not die with the body for his soul was returned to his body after three days , only a single Muslim sheikh imram could grasp that , it's shame !!!😮..
Your channel deserve million subscribers !!
He gets things wrong too. Like he said Buddhism was named after a man, and Hinduism is named after a location which is false. Sanatan dharma is the true name of Hinduism, which certainly isn't named after any land. Buddha dharma is the name for Buddhism, and isn't named after a man.
Buddha means awake, it is a state of being, it's not the name of a person. Just like Islam is not the name of a person, it means submission, which is a state of being.
Dharma means like order or right way.
As a formwe avid listener of the shiekh i can attest to what i remember him being like
He used to be alot more sensible speaking about the end tone scenarios like yajooj and majooj, isa, the dajjaal etc. He was the only one it seemed back then who was speaking about these issues although alot of his conclusion were out of the box per say especially when it came to attempting to use rational outcomes to these issues like the beast of the earth(daabatul ardh) being israel instead of an actual beast that will mark mark the faces of ppl as the ahadeeth state. Another example and more notibly was the advent of yajooj and majooj, he stated that they were resleased during the time of prophet Muhammad pbuh when he had the dream that a hole was made in their damn. And that the proof of this is the sea of galilee is drying up to record lows and that when the last of yajooj and majooj are upon the earth they will pass by it and say there was a sea here. So alot of what he used to say made alot of metaphorical sense, but wasnt rooted in any truth it was just his attempt to interpret these ahadeeth.
Now i believe he has totally leaned into this making metaphoric reasoning out of the concrete established truths from the quran and sunnah to the point where it has become essentially kufr.
May Allah bring shikeh Imran Hussien to the way of ahlul sunnah wal jamaa. He really can be an asset to the ummah and a beacon of hope and truth if he only opened his eyes to the massive mistakes hes making. Allah is the one who guides
i am not accept syeikh interpretation, you can have differ in this area, and this is not the main creed of our deen so don't make of fuzz about this. He is scholar not prophet, he can false but we cant attack his person so harsh too, we must exchsnge opinion in a position of love our fellow brother muslim.
if you like to correct his mistake, then just say it the correct one, dont put him like He insult Allah, it is something i fear, because Muslim kill each other from this simple quarrel from History. And the enemy of islam will laugh at us. Keep your tone on good tone in remembering our fellow brother in public. please.
Even the Bible says he was not crucified
Jesus prayed not to be crucified and his prayer was answered in Psalm 91.
Matthew 26:39
Going a little farther, he fell with his face to the ground and prayed, "My Father, if it is possible, may this cup be taken from me. Yet not as I will, but as you will."
@@telorceploksambelkecap
ua-cam.com/video/8aeOX8tLQKo/v-deo.htmlsi=nNxdsov89hiNRSep
And there is no God else beside Me; a just God and a Savior; there is none beside Me. Look to Me, and be saved, all the ends of the earth; for I am God, and there is none else.’ (Isaiah 45:21-22, Jonah 3:5-10)
@telorceploksambelkecap
Psalm 91
A messianic psalm-The Lord will deliver the Messiah from terror, pestilence, and war-The Lord will give His angels charge over the Messiah and deliver Him and honor Him. He that dwelleth in the secret place of the most High shall abide under the shadow of the Almighty.
There's no eyewitness accounts of the crucifixion of Jesus. even the authors of the gospels are anonymous, gospel of John being the least historically accurate. It also doesn't make sense that a pagan society (Romans) would order his death for claiming he's God or the son of god, they believed in multiple gods and gods having children, not an issue for them. Even then when he supposedly arose from the dead, why did he eat? Only HUMANS need food to survive, God doesn't need anything to sustain. Jesus dying doesn't fulfill anything. Because he himself says "until the heavens and earth pass away" that means judgement day! His purpose has not been fulfilled because he still has to comeback to fight the antichrist.
If you do research, only pagans believe in multiple gods, gods having children, gods being weak, gods being regretful, gods being tempted, gods having trinities etc. This concept was in Roman, Greek, Hindu, Ancient Egyptian societies. They couldn't fathom a pure monotheistic view of God, a God that is all-powerful, absolutely One, that created everything , that doesn't sleep, get tired, need anything or anyone, not even children.
God can forgive us without an innocent person being murdered. An innocent being murdered for others' crimes is not justice. What makes Jesus so special, that he has no father? Adam was created without a mother and a father, so going by this logic Adam would be a better choice since he has no parents. It doesn't make sense because they're both humans, not gods or pieces of God. God having persons or pieces of Himself renders Him weak, what a blasphemous thing to say.
I invite others to read the Quran and see what pure monotheism looks like. God that is All Powerful , The Most Compassionate, The Most Merciful, the Most Loving, The Forgiver, The Creator, The Sustainer, The One and Only.
God doesn't need children. We are His creations and we've been put on this earth to worship Him alone without any partners. See why Islam is the fastest growing religion, why so many are becoming Muslim from all backgrounds, why millions memorized the Quran cover to cover, and every Muslim at least has a small portion of the Quran memorized even if they don't speak Arabic.
It's the Book that is like a close friend, there's no long boring chapters that have nothing to do with anything. The Quran has no beginning, middle or end, you can open it anywhere and learn something beneficial. The theme of it is simple , believe in God without associating partners with Him, believe in all the prophets and messengers that were sent, enjoin good and forbid evil, if you sin then repent to God because He is The Forgiver. The miracles mentioned in the Quran weren't common knowledge at the time, especially in 7th century Arabia.
It's the Book you never get tired of reading and as you read it more, you find more depth in it, it's truly an amazing book. Even my Christian family members say it's easier to understand than the Bible. It's meant for everyone, every time and place.
@@telorceploksambelkecap Read Psalm 91:10 to 16 KJV
I still watch him sometimes but always felt something was off with him.
He should have known this.
Not many Muslims talk about the narration that Ibn Kathir references, why is that? If it's authentic and goes back to Ibn Abbas (RA), then why don't we reference it much?
The Prophet SAAWS said "Oh Allah, teach Ibn Abbas the Qur'an AND IT'S INTERPRETATION!"
So surely that's what really happened?
I have watched a lot of videos of him. He makes hundreds of mistakes. Brother you should watch it and expose his ignorance. Because he has large following. So it is important to expose his ignorance about Islam. Jazakallah
Yupp.
Once i heard him talking about ottoman -constantinople and his bad mouthing Dr Zakir Naik about constantinople matter, i knew theres something wrong with this guy called a muslim scholar-philosopher.
And at another day when he loudly speaking his conspiracy theory about my country history (Indonesia in 1965), i get confirmed about what kind of guy he is : an ignorant charlatan, who speak loud without any proper knowledge or wisdom about the matter he spoke.
.
When Rasulallah responded to jews, christians, disbelievers, and kings, i do not recall any hadiths by bokare or horaira, or muslima or other strange sources quoted anywhere by Rasulallah or Sahabahs.
Read quran it is clear. Suicide or voluntary human sacrifices are pagan nonsense and not quranic. I don't think voluntary crucifixion took place or was commanded by A or His Messenger Essa.
No lo crucificaron ni lo mataron = sigue vivo, fallaron
What i don't understand in Islam is they say issah is the messiah but i can't see the relevance of that title in Islam what did he do to be the messiah
A3udoubillah ! He must have a hard time with Surah el Kahf although he talks about it a lot ! Imagine - Just thinking about, not even doing it - giving your feedback, your opinion about Khidr 🤦♂.Its a very similar scenario if you think about it. Imagine being like "...It was still an innocent kid maybe he would ve grown to become righteous you never know🤷♂... " Astaghfiroullah. May Allah guide us and the entire Ummah 🤲
salam my brother! Correct me if im wrong but I think a major difference from the bible to the quran is that Abraham wasn't commanded in the quran but saw it in a dream that he should sacrifice his son because it doesn't befit the most high to command someone to sacrifice his son.
@syfe
Did you not hear at the beginning of the video that we don't question what is just by Allah?
Did you not read in Quran Allah telling the angels that they don't know what he knows, when he told them that he was going to send kaliphas on earth.
Take from Syeikh Imran the diamonds he offers and throw away the rocks he has given.
I fully agree with Imran Hosein. He is inadvertently pointing out the utter stupidity of the quran.
As someone who was born, rise and still lives in trinidad 🇹🇹 I am disappointed by our scholar here and I hope allah guide him to change his beliefs instead of quotes the Bible which is a book full with contradictions, he will instead quote the Quran that is perfect.
Sheikh Imran Hosein is the best scholar
In case we forget, I show here the excerpt of Verse 2:85 - "... Is it then, you (are among the) ones who believe in (and are obedient only) a portion of the Book whilst you (are guilty of) infidelity/disbelief by (sidelining the other) portions of it? ...". Also be careful not to countermand any of the 😮Qur'anic injunctions when using materials from ANY human sources, if you know what imean.
Thats no muslim scholar, I've heard him once in recorded session screaming at his Audience for the longest time I could recall saying, theyre out to get me, they want to kill me, the poor guy was so afraid to the point that he kept on repeating himself over and over without stopping for some time, the poor guy is out of it, clearly mad. I petty those who listen to him.
I don't believe this so called "scholar" is Muslim at all.
For someone to deny the Quran and endorse the Bible, and call Allah's judgement as 'nonesense' it takes a tremendous corruption of the heart and hypocrisy of highest level.
Alhamdulillah!
When l first watched the so call scholar saying that Essa was crucified and what l said about him, you just prove to me that l was not wrong about him.
Alhamdulillah, may Allah reward ya akhi syfe, Ameen.
He's talking about substitution theory. Not Jesus. Understand what he's saying first.
Fun fact, Yeshua was also a popular name amongst the freedom fighters of the Jews at the time & many Yeshuas were crucified for opposing the Roman empire. But no confirmation that Yeshua of Nazareth was of those crucified due to lack of witnesses
Fun fact your an idi0t
Lack of witnesses?
The crucifixion happen outside the city gates, with Roman soldiers present, the High Priest and other members of the Sanhedrin, Simon of Cyrene that took the cross to Golgotha, the mother of Jesus, John the Apostle, Mary Magdalene and other women friends and followers of Jesus.
You can just see from his attitude that he's not a full box of chocolates
IMRAN HUSSEIN IS A SUFI PAKISTANI SCHOLAR NAQSHABANDI, HE MAKES MANY MISTAKES TIME AFTER TIME❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Great video like always brother. But I have to remind you that basylidians aren’t Christians. They were gnostics who weren’t considered Christians. Same way Muslims don’t see ahmadyya as Muslims
Isnt there literally a verse in the quran that says 'someone else put on the cross and was made to look like Isa AS' it doesn't clarify who it was, but if the quran says it, its authoritive.
Thank you
Jazakallahu kahiran brother
Quran Surah An-Nisa- 157. And [for] their saying, "Indeed, we have killed the Messiah, Jesus the son of Mary, the messenger of Allāh." And they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him; but [another] was made to resemble him to them. And indeed, those who differ over it are in doubt about it. They have no knowledge of it except the following of assumption. And they did not kill him, for certain.1
I used to listen him (imran hosein) but after this, im not gonna listen him again.
Si tú resucitas es que no estás muerto, los judíos intentaron matarte pero fallaron y luego Jesús ascendió.
There is not contradiction between Corán and the Bible
Hudheifa Ib Al-Yaman asked the Prophet:
"O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! We were living in ignorance and in an (extremely) worst atmosphere, then Allah brought to us this good (i.e., Islam);
"Will there be any evil after that good?"
He replied, "Yes, (there will be) some people calling at the gates of the (Hell) Fire, and whoever will respond to their call, will be thrown by them into the (Hell) Fire." I said, "O Allah s Apostle! Will you describe them to us?" He said, "They will be from our own people and will speak our language."
It is not a matter of fact... The quran says that they are all speculating. What is true is that he did not die.
Where is it in the Quran Allah mentions He lifted Iesa (pbuh) was lifted up from a window in the house to heaven. And what was the reason Allah gave that he (Iesa) needed to be taken that way. Barrak Allahu Feek.
Quran Ibn Kathir Tafsir 4:155 tafsir 169 (4/337)
narrated from Ibn ‘Abbas saying: “When Allah wanted to lift him up to heaven, Jesus came to his companions in the house. There were twelve people, with some from among his disciples. He had just taken a bath, and his head was still dribbling with water, He said to them: ‘There are those among you who will disbelieve in me twelve times after he had believed in me.’ Then he said: ‘Who from among you will take my likeness and be killed in my place, so he will reach my rank?’ A youth came forward. But Jesus said to him: ‘Sit down.’ Then he repeated the same question, and the same youth stood up and came forward, and said: ‘I.’ Jesus said: ‘You are the one,’ and then the likeness of Jesus was put on him, and Jesus was lifted up to the heaven from the window (in the roof) of the house.”
On, 21st night of Ramadan before 8 days of 'Good Friday '
The Jews came looking for him. They took the youth and killed him and then crucified him
He’s a great storyteller 🥱
lol
You sure right 😂
a dangerous story teller
He's tryin hard to sell his "islamic eschatology" stories everywhere at every chance.
A "Nostradamus wannabe" 😂
Once i heard him talking about ottoman -constantinople and his bad mouthing Dr Zakir Naik about constantinople matter, i knew theres something wrong with this guy called a muslim scholar-philosopher.
And at another day when he loudly speaking his conspiracy theory about my country history (Indonesia in 1965), i get confirmed about what kind of guy he is : an ignorant charlatan, who speak loud without any proper knowledge or wisdom about the matter he spoke.
.
Why are you accusing him of lying? That is not correct of you brother.
There is indeed a different and acceptable understanding for this ayat with no rejection of the ayat at all.
Mohamed Assad for example also goes with the understanding that the Christians and jews say that he was crucified but the truth is that he was not crucified but their confusion let then speak in ignorance and declare that he was crucified.
It's nonsense if it's not in the Quran. That is what he means.
I have enjoyed some of your responses to those deplorables who try to mock or falsify Islam but I think you have misunderstood Sheikh Hussein.
Indeed, it would be unjust of Allah to use someone else, especially an innocent person, in place of the prophet Issa for crucifixion.
If you don't understand that, then you have not understood Allah almighty yet. You should know that even when Allah has absolute power over all things, he is still bound by his other attributes such as THE JUST. Crucifying another in the place of his prophet would be gross injustice.
Submission to Allah does not mean you lose all your rights and it also certainly does not mean Allah can indulge in any acts of his choosing, especially not in acts of injustice. He would not deserve the attribute of justice otherwise.
Yes, this also means that Ibn Abbas was mistaken in his views. He didn't quite appreciate the grandeur of Allah almighty even when he was a sahaba. It would be much more to the grandeur of Allah almighty to just suspend the life of prophet Issa for a while and return it later like he does to all of us in our sleep than to indulge in acts of injustice.
Rejecting the falsehoods in the hadith does not only make one a good Muslim, but to do so is a divine responsibility. There are many falsehoods in the hadiths. The Qur'an is the yardstick by which the hadith is measured and not the other way around.
The issue of whether prophet Issa was placed in a cave after his supposed 'crucifixion' is actually irrelevant here. What is relevant is whether Allah almighty would commit acts of injustice even when he's the absolute. This is why the commandment to Prophet Ibrahim would not have and did not take place. If Allah had allowed that commandment to be executed merely because he wanted to manifest his absolute power, then that would have been an act of grave injustice unworthy of the beautiful attributes of Allah almighty. Allah is almighty but he is not a dictator.
And please do not use the Bible to justify your views against issues of disagreement in Islam, it can be used against you.
You should be careful about what you understand about invention and misguidance, otherwise even new knowledge about which the Prophet highly encouraged, you will classify as new invention and misguidance. Some food for thought for you: Why do you think that the Prophet did not give us a tafsir of the Qur'an? Don't you think to do so would have closed the door to all seeking of knowledge, which the Prophet said should be sought from the cradle to the grave?
I will recommend that you refrain from taking up issues that even in Islam, Allah has chosen to be ambiguous about. If you do, all you will be achieving is division of the Muslim ummah.
What a liar sura 4 verse 157-158. Did he ever read the quran i doubt