Seagate 24TB Ironwolf Pro HDD for NAS - Review & Synology NAS Testing

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
  • Seagate 24TB Ironwolf Pro NAS Hard Drive Review nascompares.com/review/seagat...
    You can find the Seagate Ironwolf Pro 24TB Hard Drive on Amazon here - amzn.to/4aQi3kF
    Seagate Ironwolf Pro 20TB ST20000NT001 Hard Drive Massive Video Review - • Seagate Ironwolf Pro 2...
    Written Blog Review of the ‪@seagate‬ Ironwolf Pro 20TB New Version + Noise testing + Benchmarks + Compatibility - nascompares.com/2023/02/13/se...
    You can find the Seagate Ironwolf Pro 24TB Hard Drive on Amazon here - amzn.to/4aQi3kF
    Synology HAT5300 vs WD Ultrastar vs Seagate EXOS Video - • Synology HAT5300 vs WD...
    nascompares.com/review/seagat...
    Should You Use Fewer Larger HDDs or More Smaller HDDs? nascompares.com/guide/big-har...
    Seagate Ironwolf Pro vs WD Red Pro vs Synology HAT5300 HDDs blog post - nascompares.com/guide/seagate...
    Seagate Ironwolf Pro vs WD Red Pro vs Synology HAT5300 HDDs video guide - • Seagate Ironwolf Pro v...
    How to Choose the BEST Value Hard Drive and Best Price per TB - Get it Right, FIRST TIME! - nascompares.com/2022/12/28/ho...
    More Hard Drives or BIGGER Hard Drives, Which is Better? - • More Hard Drives or BI...
    NAS Buyers Guide - Get It RIGHT First Time - nascompares.com/guide/nas-buy...
    NAS Media Server vs Streaming Netflix, Disney+, Prime, Hulu, HBO - Which Should You Choose? - • Synology DS1522+ 4K ON...
    Are NAS Drives Still Safe in 2022/2023? - • Are NAS Drives Still S...
    8 WAYS TO SAVE ELECTRICITY AND MONEY ON YOUR NAS - • 8 WAYS TO SAVE ELECTRI...
    Video Chapters
    00:00 - WHO NEEDS THIS???
    00:30 - The Start
    00:45 - Seagate 24TB Hardware Specifications
    01:29 - NOT SMR!!!
    02:19 - Stable Platters!
    02:53 - Start of Benchmarks
    02:58 - CrystalDisk
    03:15 - AJA Speed Tests
    03:35 - ATTO Disk Benchmark
    03:55 - Windows Transfer Test
    04:18 - Synology NAS Testing and Compatibility
    04:47 - Synology NAS Setup
    05:49 - Synology NAS RAID 5 / SHR Test
    06:29 - Synology NAS RAID 0 Test
    07:12 - What I LIKE About the Seagate 24TB Ironwolf Pro NAS HDD
    08:34 - What I DO NOT LIKE About the Seagate 24TB Ironwolf Pro NAS HDD
    Looking for deals and offers on all things NAS, DAS, SSD, HDD and more? On NASCompares we have a featured DEALS Page that is regularly updated by me, Eddie and many of our visitors. Take a look at what devices are on on special offer right now, worldwide, by visiting here - nascompares.com/daily-deals/
    Thinking of buying a product mentioned in today's video from Amazon? If this video has helped you make that decision, you can head to Amazon using this link and we will get a small % profit of whatever you buy, which goes directly back to NASCompares and allows me and Eddie to keep doing what we do here on UA-cam and the Blog - amzn.to/3TjM0kj
    Find NAS Solutions from SCAN.CO.UK here (and support us at NASCompares at no extra cost!) - tidd.ly/3eSqzaT
    Visit the Community Support forum 'ASK NASCompares' here if you need more help - ask.nascompares.com/
    Finally, if you need data storage/networking help NOW and the free advice/forum on NASCompares is not going to be quick enough for you, you can use the Ko-fi commissions page here - ko-fi.com/nascompares/commissions
    Thanks for watching. Do you still need help? Use the NASCompares Free Advice section above. It is my free, unbias community support system that allows you to ask me questions about your ideal setup. It is NOT a sales platform, NOT a way to push hardware you don’t need and, although it is just manned by me and might take a day or two for me to reply, I will help you any way I can. Below are some more popular guides.
    NASCompares Free Advice Area - nascompares.com/contact-us/
    Vulnerabilities And Exploits On Synology & QNAP NAS - Stay Updated! - nascompares.com/2021/05/26/vu...
    Synology NAS DSM 7.1 NAS Software Review - • Synology DSM 7.1 Softw...
    Synology DSM 7 Review - ALL PARTS - nascompares.com/synology-dsm-...
    QNAP QuTS 5.1 ZFS NAS Software Review - Best of Both Worlds - • QNAP QuTS 5.0.1 ZFS NA...
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 370

  • @ASUSTOR_YT
    @ASUSTOR_YT Місяць тому +113

    It's never enough! MOAR storage please! I'm addicted to storage!

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  Місяць тому +11

      You'll get yours next week @asustor!

    • @DrMechxico
      @DrMechxico Місяць тому +3

      I just put 4x 20TB EXOS drives into a AS5404T yesterday on Unraid 😅

    • @kenwilliams3279
      @kenwilliams3279 Місяць тому +2

      Yeh never enough. Here, 6 x 18tb and 1x22tb for backups and recovery testing. 84tb NAND in my workstation

    • @kenwilliams3279
      @kenwilliams3279 Місяць тому +3

      So I've got about 200tb storage in my home office. I wonder when it will be 1pb😅

    • @adenwellsmith6908
      @adenwellsmith6908 Місяць тому +2

      More cores. More computers. More memory. Faster storage. Faster internet. Faster networking. It's all needed.

  • @dennisc6716
    @dennisc6716 Місяць тому +75

    "That's too much space" said no Plex user ever.

    • @kendrakirai
      @kendrakirai Місяць тому +5

      I'm sitting at about 20 terabytes in my library right now. None of it 4K. :3

    • @Antimonkat
      @Antimonkat Місяць тому +6

      @@kendrakirai thats why you're ok....I was fine with liek 24tb until I started into 4k, now I'm at 92TB, and full

    • @Fischmett
      @Fischmett Місяць тому

      @@kendrakirai thats why i run all my rips through handbrake, to get as much usable storage space as possible

    • @kendrakirai
      @kendrakirai Місяць тому +1

      @Fischmett I'm not sure what Handbrake is. For me, I simply don't have anything that's capable of displaying 4K, so anything over 1080 is wasted, and I don't have a system that's capable of pushing 4K to begin with. If I ever manage to get a new system I'll probably see about converting everything to AV1, but I only just recently got a card capable of transcoding HEVC for my home server. Was all running through my laptop's 3060 mobile before then. :3

  • @D_Chm
    @D_Chm Місяць тому +31

    As a self certified data hoarder I AM going to get this hard drive into my NAS, great video as always!

    • @dustojnikhummer
      @dustojnikhummer Місяць тому

      I think the problem is when you need to rebuild an array (one out of 4 disk dies) it will take days with a 24TB drive

    • @bitlong4669
      @bitlong4669 Місяць тому

      @@dustojnikhummer lol that’s when you pray the other doesn’t go bad while rebuilding lol

    • @fuzzykitty7549
      @fuzzykitty7549 12 днів тому

      @@dustojnikhummer thats what the secondary back up for xp

  • @manuelchavez4296
    @manuelchavez4296 Місяць тому +48

    Im a datahoarder and I NEED it! Looking forward to their 32 TB HAMR drives. Another fantastic video!

    • @touchai1482
      @touchai1482 Місяць тому

      What is a HAMR drive and when would it arrive to consumers?

    • @logan594
      @logan594 Місяць тому

      Do they have same issues as smr

    • @JaySilva88
      @JaySilva88 Місяць тому

      @@logan594 CMR/SMR does not refer to the same thing as HAMR, I think.

    • @Antimonkat
      @Antimonkat Місяць тому +1

      @@JaySilva88 HAMR uses heat to fit more data on a CMR array, no performance hit like with SMR, but it uses more power, and we don't know how reliability is affected if at all.

    • @stevenvanpelt486
      @stevenvanpelt486 Місяць тому

      I'm guessing this uses HAMR as well since all >18 TB drives use it?

  • @MrMaxeemum
    @MrMaxeemum Місяць тому +7

    4x 24TB storage? That's ideal for my cat picture collection.😮

  • @ProjectSimRacing
    @ProjectSimRacing Місяць тому +1

    Thanks for the review mate!✌

  • @garyrichards6079
    @garyrichards6079 Місяць тому +23

    Some of us have LARGE Blu Ray and UHD collections of FILMS ;) ... lol

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  Місяць тому +14

      Why do I feel like your use of the word *films* is telling half the story!

    • @garyrichards6079
      @garyrichards6079 Місяць тому +7

      @@nascompares
      Ok ...
      There might be some Gentleman's Photography in there ! lol

    • @alexg9727
      @alexg9727 Місяць тому +2

      a 20 minute clip in 4k uncompressed takes up like 20-30 gigabytes.

  • @BS25999
    @BS25999 Місяць тому +9

    I use a 16tb disk as a 'take away' disk. I sync our artwork files onto this disk and then take it home for a week. Then sync again. It's a 'just in case' sort of off site backup. Big disks are good for this.

  • @michaelkiddle3149
    @michaelkiddle3149 Місяць тому +4

    I remember some early hard drives with a storage capacity only a few megabytes these are just mind-blowing

  • @7rich79
    @7rich79 Місяць тому +16

    I'd like to see the raid rebuild times on a 96TB array 😅

    • @bittripper3530
      @bittripper3530 Місяць тому +3

      I suspect you might want to just mirror them, unless you have a week to wait for a rebuild 🙂

    • @Antimonkat
      @Antimonkat Місяць тому +3

      on my 10 year old atom NAS it's about 5-6 days for the rebuild and another 4-5 for the expansion (moving to larger drives) That's with it full under a hybrid raid config. I think I might prefer an UNRAID type config with a server this size and up, resilvering is a lot faster.

  • @abvmoose87
    @abvmoose87 8 днів тому

    Looking good man, keep up the good job

  • @MarkRose1337
    @MarkRose1337 Місяць тому +5

    Even if the top capacity drives are more expensive per GB, once you include the cost of the drive bay and system supporting the drive bay, it's almost always the best per GB cost to buy the top capacity drives unless you have dozens of drives in a system.

  • @riffdex
    @riffdex Місяць тому +6

    When you’re watching the part where he says you wouldn’t consider putting this drive in a regular PC but you’re actually planning to put this drive is a regular PC 👀

  • @doctorkj5640
    @doctorkj5640 Місяць тому

    Thank you for this video. So you went ahead and put these drives into 923+. The system complaind you went against compatibility list, but the it showed you green healty icon nevertheless. So I’m good to go with these to put them in my 923+???
    Any red or orange icons with other Ironwolf oro drives?
    Thanks in advance.

  • @ThePaulpope
    @ThePaulpope Місяць тому +3

    I don't know about the Iron Wolf Pro's but the 24TB Exos drives I do. I have had 8 of these in the DS1821+ in SHR2 for about 3 weeks with no issues and yes I have 135TB of resultant storage and it is well used already with over 50gb on each volume already used.

  • @praetorxyn
    @praetorxyn Місяць тому +11

    I'm planning to cancel the Ugreen and build an 8 bay DIY as I want ECC. I'm also planning to use 8 of this drive in ZFS 😈

    • @Locationary
      @Locationary Місяць тому

      Benefit of diy is you can choose your own cpu and swap out the CPU if you ever decide to upgrade.

  • @jerrywatson1958
    @jerrywatson1958 Місяць тому

    Hey will this work in older series Synology NAS? Like a js series or their other ARM based consumer units? I have two older js units I use them for my HTPC as backup and media long term online storage. I would use them as 1 big single 48TB dive as I already have 12TB of files. I think buying two of these drives now and using them then later upgrading the NAS will be more managable for me. Thanks for all your hard work.

  • @1xXNimrodXx1
    @1xXNimrodXx1 Місяць тому +3

    I'm wondering, why the Toshiba MG10 gets overlooked so ofthen when it comes to price/capacity/performance ?

  • @skarrambo1
    @skarrambo1 Місяць тому +9

    I've currently got 4 10TB Seagate IronWolf Pros in a DS920+, and I'm approaching maxing out (Plex server), so I'm excited about this. I'll wait a couple of years though for a significant price drop.

    • @MisterPikol
      @MisterPikol Місяць тому +2

      I just got a 16tb exos x16 for 130 bucks

    • @martydee755
      @martydee755 Місяць тому

      @@MisterPikol 130 a pop, where?

    • @mariuszfuchs2010
      @mariuszfuchs2010 Місяць тому

      Same here but 6 hdd seagate and it's nearly full just music and video. The storage soon or later will run out.

    • @chupa2000
      @chupa2000 Місяць тому

      Where do you get the vids?

    • @stevenvanpelt486
      @stevenvanpelt486 Місяць тому

      I've got 10x 20 TB WD Ultrastar DC HC560 disks in HW RAID 6 and they weren't that expensive t.b.h. Only when you opt for the top tier capacity (currently 24 TB) you'll pay a premium.

  • @420jahlion
    @420jahlion Місяць тому +3

    im a data hoarder. i spend a lot of time traveling or on remote farms. i save as much media and games as i can so i have it while very remote. as long as its not shingled i will be happy. i have about 6 external 4+ tb drives full.

  • @adacPROKYON
    @adacPROKYON Місяць тому +2

    Ive got the 16 tb version of those and would love to know how noisy the 24tb version is

  • @PatrickDKing
    @PatrickDKing Місяць тому +3

    18 TB drives still the sweet spot on price per TB. One to two times a year here in the States, the WD gold 18tb will go on sale for $299. That's when i grab one or two until next year. Other brands go $250-$270 on 18 TB on sale as well. I hope they keep pumping out larger size drives because that will probably push down the price of the lower capacities. Win for me. Then in 20 years when the drives fail I can start putting 50 TB drives in where the 18 TB drives used to be 😛

  • @martydee755
    @martydee755 Місяць тому +1

    hello, questions about workload. are these drives get longer lifespan if you use them at say half the workload rating or it doesnt matter. and does it affect the lifespan of it if you have say (4) 24tb into a nas but only have 30-40tb total data. does it prolong their life or not? ps: im a noob at this, cheers!

  • @retomusterle2419
    @retomusterle2419 Місяць тому

    Just wondering how long it takes to fill the 4bay NAS fully with 96TB and secondly how long it takes for a rebuild of the raid cluster after a disc exchange...

  • @---us7qf
    @---us7qf Місяць тому

    Yes, YES and YEEESSS!
    I want a few

  • @Antimonkat
    @Antimonkat Місяць тому +1

    I'm running mostly 20's now, 22's or 24's is what I want to build my new NAS out with, but I usually go EXOS since they typically it the market at lower prices.

  • @021om6
    @021om6 2 дні тому

    So, if it is not compatible with synology, how did you get it to work? Can I get this for my synology nas?

  • @youritguy1
    @youritguy1 Місяць тому +6

    I can always use more storage capacity :)

  • @fuzzykitty7549
    @fuzzykitty7549 12 днів тому

    My various hdds of linix isos are over 24 tb. so ya it be nice to have that drive to condense everything

  • @webmail4
    @webmail4 Місяць тому

    Excellent video and great content. Thank you for putting this out there and keep up the great work.

  • @f.iuliavr
    @f.iuliavr 9 днів тому

    Hello, can this be used as a simple external HDD, for storage? And why some websites states 256MB cache and other 512MB cache? Thanks

  • @novatrajana7875
    @novatrajana7875 Місяць тому +1

    Hello,
    Thanks for your great effort,good job.
    would you make a video on the HDD datasheet details in depth,like TB per year work load, what it really means.
    also MTBF,TLER...etc
    regards,

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  Місяць тому +1

      I had a video vaguely similar to this, on the subject of "SSD Terminology" a couple of years back, but this sounds like a better idea! Added it to my to do list. Thanks for the suggestion bud

  • @richlittell5406
    @richlittell5406 Місяць тому

    Yes. Synology ds1821+ Plex Server. It’s time to replace a couple of the smaller drives.
    BTW, I’d like to see a short on replacing drives in a Synology NAS. Just a little confidence builder. I’ve added drives but never had to replace one.

  • @philippemiller4740
    @philippemiller4740 Місяць тому +1

    I wish you'd test the rebuild time of the pool at these speeds and capacity. And drive speed varies. You seem to only mention the top speed from the inside of the platters. The more the drive is full the slower it is. Have you notice how slow it is at its slowest and how long it takes to fully write it? My guess is 36 hours which would be ridiculous

  • @keyboard_g
    @keyboard_g Місяць тому

    Looking forward to the Axos x2 drives with dual actuators.

  • @xConundrumx
    @xConundrumx Місяць тому

    Buddy ... I have 24 of those in my NAS, and looking for a couple extension cabinets ...

  • @user-kg6uj6ji5p
    @user-kg6uj6ji5p Місяць тому

    i'm exicted to have one, when i hold 12tb wd red plus for first time i'm really shock the weight compare to 1tb/2tb 3.5" drive

  • @simon_s
    @simon_s Місяць тому

    0:15 what if I have a Plex system with a lot of 1080p series and movies ? We do need for some cases big nas hard drive…

  • @BoraHorzaGobuchul
    @BoraHorzaGobuchul Місяць тому

    Wonder what rebuild time on this thing will be

  • @konsul2006
    @konsul2006 Місяць тому

    96 TB? In a nas would you even be able to write to all those bytes before the EOL of the drives?

  • @dragonballjiujitsu
    @dragonballjiujitsu Місяць тому +2

    Having too much storage is like being too rich or too good looking. It just doesn't happen. You can never have too much storage. I "need" at least 5 of these right now. I am currently using over 40TB and running out of space.

  • @matjazwalland903
    @matjazwalland903 Місяць тому +1

    You mentioned a capacity of 24TB, I'm wondering how many movies you could store on this disc if the movie is 1080p 5.1 audio. And how would it respond when searching for a specific movie from a full disc. Let's see if the integrated memory has enough capacity for the spreadsheet?!

    • @LiLBitsDK
      @LiLBitsDK Місяць тому

      full or not doesn't change the searching for a specific movie...

  • @sinrob1
    @sinrob1 Місяць тому

    The concept of having too many eggs in one basket comes to mind.

  • @SamuHell782
    @SamuHell782 Місяць тому +1

    Serious Question: Can I have a RAID 5 with 3 x 4TB drives + 1 x 8TB drive in a backup role? And if so, in a DIY or latch NAS?

    • @LiLBitsDK
      @LiLBitsDK Місяць тому

      yes you can raid 3 drives in raid5.... yes you can run a standalone disc for backups

  • @stairjoke
    @stairjoke Місяць тому

    I edit videos. A lot of them. And I have no use for this much storage… what are people doing? Are they keeping their proxy/render files after they’re done editing?

  • @SidebandSamurai
    @SidebandSamurai Місяць тому

    I have an unriad system with 15 bays. I am going to start upgrading all my drives to 24 Tb

  • @recklessthor4
    @recklessthor4 Місяць тому

    I am getting into 8k video editing and have used 4 Tb already in a couple months

  • @andychow5509
    @andychow5509 29 днів тому

    With BTRFS and soon BcacheFS, it just makes sense to always buy the biggest drive available to add to your array or to replace a failing drive. ZFS doesn't have that capability, but that's a huge defect. Say you have 6x8TB drives from 6 years ago. One drive fails. Replace it with a 24 TB drive, and your whole array increase to about where it should be by your normal addition of data.

  • @hadesangelos
    @hadesangelos Місяць тому

    how long does it take to rebuild 24tb

  • @nadtz
    @nadtz Місяць тому +1

    I'm about to rebuild my NAS as I've filled up (well, gotten close to 80%) of ~70tb. If I wasn't such a data hoarder I could probably delete about half the stuff I'm storing but that's no fun. Going to go with 8x18tb and I can't wait for the prices on 30's to start to drop so 20-24's start dropping too. Hopefully in 3 or so years when I do my next rebuild they will cost what 18's are going to cost me now.

  • @curtisbme
    @curtisbme Місяць тому +3

    UHD blu-ray collection can eat that up like it ain't nothin'.

  • @warlordattack
    @warlordattack Місяць тому +2

    Need this because every 5 years you can replace your nas with a single drive for cheap:)

  • @interproservice
    @interproservice Місяць тому

    If my NAS is turned on once a month for 2-3hrs. Will it last me 100 years?

  • @CreachterZ
    @CreachterZ Місяць тому

    When I ran a Commodore 64 BBS, I spent all summer saving up to buy a Lt. Kernal 10MB hard drive for my download section. I was a god.

    • @NNokia-jz6jb
      @NNokia-jz6jb Місяць тому

      Now i have almost all software for the C64? It would fit on a 64GB micro-SD.

  • @smstnitc
    @smstnitc Місяць тому +1

    Yes, I have a problem, my wife would agree. I actually recently down sized because I am using bigger drives now. I am no longer using my 12 bay Synology. I'm kicking less heat into my home office by using a DS1522+ with 22tb drives.

    • @MarvellousVisuals
      @MarvellousVisuals 3 дні тому

      Question bro, I'm looking to get the DS1522+ too... would you say it's easy enough to set up as I saw it wasn't on the compatibility list

    • @smstnitc
      @smstnitc 3 дні тому +1

      @@MarvellousVisuals I don't have any drives on the compatibility list. There's no extra work involved in using them. You just get a warning when you first set up the array that I just click through and all is good from there.

    • @MarvellousVisuals
      @MarvellousVisuals 3 дні тому +1

      @@smstnitc Perfect, I appreciate the insight. Thanks man, I'll proceed to order then 👌🏾

  • @richcreedy4118
    @richcreedy4118 Місяць тому

    I NEEEED it

  • @linearburn8838
    @linearburn8838 Місяць тому

    I wish i had one just for a backup drive to back up my nas so I could reload it

  • @Geoffr524
    @Geoffr524 Місяць тому

    It is crazy that the One TB hard drives have been out since they were introduced in 2007, and computers are still being built with them, and even smaller sizes. Computers are being made cheaper and not last as long.

  • @kenwilliams3279
    @kenwilliams3279 Місяць тому +1

    4 x 18tb in a ds420+ here. Never enough space!

  • @josephstacklin3853
    @josephstacklin3853 Місяць тому

    As someone with over 120TB of data I will love when these hit the used or refurbished market

  • @LoftechUK
    @LoftechUK 29 днів тому

    What about my Swann security box.

  • @wildzeke
    @wildzeke Місяць тому

    My concern would be if one of the drives were to go bad, would you have enough time to rebuild the RAID before a second drive goes bad.

    • @tim3172
      @tim3172 Місяць тому

      If only backups existed...

  • @harrynorway
    @harrynorway Місяць тому +4

    What about noise level in this 4 bay NAS drive? Will the noise level be a linear increase from 8tb drives to 24TB drives? ore is the noise level similar between 12-24tb drives?

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  Місяць тому +6

      It sounds pretty much identical to the sound in my 20TB testing. I go into more detail next week in a follow up vid on this

    • @indiekiduk
      @indiekiduk Місяць тому +1

      Helium are much noisier than air filled so depends what’s in your 8tb

  • @robertleem5643
    @robertleem5643 Місяць тому +2

    I bought 6 Seagate Ironwolf 14tb drives and all but 2 were dead upon arrival. Never used them again and have since purchased 6 14tb Toshiba NAS drives and 2 16tb Toshiba Drives and touchwood not a problem yet. 4 x 14tb are in my NAS and the others are used as a backup medium. You can never have enough space

    • @the_bogeyman.
      @the_bogeyman. Місяць тому +1

      I’ve been unlucky with Seagate HDDs too in the past, but never with Western Digital.
      That’s one of the reasons I went with 16TB Ultrastars instead of EXOS for my NAS.
      I have friends that use Seagate because they had problems with WD in the past too, I guess it’s mostly ”luck”.

  • @ArnoldTohtFan
    @ArnoldTohtFan Місяць тому

    Could you make a video about MEMS technology? It's the biggest development in sound reproduction in a century.

  • @NoMusiciansInMusicAnymore
    @NoMusiciansInMusicAnymore Місяць тому

    You're right, I don't need 96TB, I need YB's

  • @indiekiduk
    @indiekiduk Місяць тому

    Is it better to avoid TLER drives in a synology? Maybe their behaviour isn’t suitable for a software raid,

  • @Lorondos
    @Lorondos Місяць тому +1

    Makes 2-bays more sensible at least :D, I use a single large drive for back-up of my 4-bay NAS so knowing I can go up to a 24GB RAID, all is good!

    • @JSAVGA
      @JSAVGA Місяць тому

      Have a DS224+ with two 12TB Ironwolfs and this was my first thought also. I could double my capacity if i could get it to work.

  • @leoyoung7547
    @leoyoung7547 Місяць тому

    Lol. I am an on set data manager. I can fill one of those hard drives in a few days. The speed sounds good.

  • @AMDPCBuoldersCommunity
    @AMDPCBuoldersCommunity Місяць тому

    yeah I have a problem all right I Have 160TB usable space on my nas with the ability to add 32 of these if needed down the road

  • @DaystromDataConcepts
    @DaystromDataConcepts Місяць тому

    Would like to know what the spin up time on the big 10 platter drives are as well as noise levels.

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  Місяць тому +1

      This should be covered in Next week's vid. Cheers for watching man

  • @thezfunk
    @thezfunk Місяць тому +1

    Did Synology have an issue with Seagate drives in general or is that fixed now?

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  Місяць тому +1

      Not an issue as such, just not adding them on their compatibility lists above 16-18TB

  • @whya2ndaccount
    @whya2ndaccount Місяць тому

    I’ll wait until the price drops before going near my 1821+. With SHR-2 running I’d probably need to replace 4 to 6 of the current 12TB ones before I actually saw any additional available capacity,

  • @PitboyHarmony1
    @PitboyHarmony1 Місяць тому +1

    Heres the thing. At my Canadian Newegg site, Seagate is running 16Tb NAS Pro drives for $429.
    And this 24Tb part is $654. The math there is not good, that 8Tb is going to cost me $225.
    I get that its new and drool worthy so they will ask for and get a premium ... but that price is going to come down some.

  • @pdp11processor42
    @pdp11processor42 Місяць тому

    Just so many tests needed. So you buy your standard Synology DS923+ with 4 TB RAM and decide to expand with the 24 TByte Seagate drives with the 10Ge expansion. RAID 10 is sold as the best of both worlds of RAID 0 and RAID 1. What is the performance in RAID 10?
    Any significant performance change when you then play it 'Safe' and enable the Synology Antivirus by McAfee package?
    When reading the DSM 7.2 manual you see that 2x SSD modules enables you to create a Read/Write SSD Cache for improved performance. You read some more of the DSM 7.2 manual then discover you can configure the system to pin all Btrfs metadata to this SSD cache for even higher performance. Now what size M2 SSDs are required in the base of the DS923+ to support your set of four 24 TByte drives in this metadata cache mode?
    Now if you can't find a calculation by Synology for the size of the required SSDs, what is your best guess and what happens when you try using whatever SSDs you actually have available? What is the change in system performance with a Read/Write SSD cache?
    Actually I do have one DS923+ with a 10Ge interface that is now populated with 12 TByte Seagate Ironwolf drives in RAID 10. Wasn't what was planned but it is where it has landed.

    • @LiLBitsDK
      @LiLBitsDK Місяць тому

      4TB Ram? that's a LOT in a NAS....

  • @waynetaylor2784
    @waynetaylor2784 Місяць тому +1

    I have 3 x Dell MD3460s, each with 60 x Seagate exos 8tb sas drives. I.e 180 x 8tb hdds or 1.44 petabytes

  • @TazzSmk
    @TazzSmk Місяць тому

    it's almost scary when I think about it more,
    what I would really like to know @NASCompares :
    1) how long does it take to rebuild the RAID5 or SHR1 pool with one 24TB disk swapped (let's say 80% of 72TB volume filled with data)?
    2) what's the likehood of 2 drives failing (second drive during replacement of one drive), in other words would you recommend RAID6 (or SHR2)?
    3) why would anyone buy such huge drives, if obviously saturating 10Gbe needs more than 4 drives, yet Synology doesn't allow more than 108TB volume so even something like 8 drives in RAID6/SHR2 could not be fully allocated?
    4) what's the technical limitation of such drive not reaching 6Gb SATA throughput (550MB/s read/write) with so many platters? I mean, why would anyone buy 4x 24TB HDDs for RAID5/SHR1 when they could have literally 2x faster 8x 12TB HDDs in RAID6/SHR2?

  • @adenwellsmith6908
    @adenwellsmith6908 Місяць тому

    1. Graphs of price per TB - where's the sweet spot
    2. Price against speed
    3. History of cost over time. What's the prediction for SSD to overtake mechanical?
    4. Mixed set ups SSD + HD
    5. Memory again what's the sweet spot for RAM with drives
    6. Processors - sweet spot again. What if you encrypt? What if you compress? What if you de-duplicate? What's the requirements

  • @NeseComedy
    @NeseComedy Місяць тому

    Me see big number, me happy :)

  • @DeltaSol3
    @DeltaSol3 Місяць тому

    With all the 4k films and TV series I have on my 2 bay NAS, realistically in my case I think 16TB (8x2) would be sufficient. This may change later but I have been using a NAS for about 6 years now

  • @QNAPUK
    @QNAPUK Місяць тому +1

    Never too much! Using these drives with QNAP's 24 bay NAS & Expansion you can have 1 Petabyte of storage EASILY!

  • @chrisvig123
    @chrisvig123 27 днів тому +1

    Video can easily chew that space up if your into production

  • @furzcouchoffiziell
    @furzcouchoffiziell Місяць тому +6

    I could see myself running them as raid 6 in a 5bay synology.

    • @blahorgaslisk7763
      @blahorgaslisk7763 Місяць тому +2

      It would be interesting to see the rebuild time for that array. I'd like to know the time needed if it is left alone and at medium and heavy access.

  • @brionlund2467
    @brionlund2467 Місяць тому

    Bud, in the last 4 months I’ve filled 8 tb. At this rate, I’ll do 24 by the end of the year. I like my movies KRISP.

  • @nyiceone2075
    @nyiceone2075 Місяць тому

    If ur running ds418 play then u do need it. Mkv files are large

  • @kchaney56
    @kchaney56 Місяць тому

    I will fill my QNAP 12 bay system with these.

  • @sunnycloudy1337
    @sunnycloudy1337 Місяць тому +2

    imagine the plex library on 4-5-6 of these 😂

  • @BrianDickens4
    @BrianDickens4 Місяць тому

    Well, I've got 5x 16TB in my DS1522+ and I'd like more -- but that's just wanting, not needing. Currently filled about 10TB of it all. But steadily working on increasing storage use. :+

    • @stevenrussell6581
      @stevenrussell6581 Місяць тому

      Are these Seagate Ironwolf Pro’s? I’ve bought a new DS1522+ and can’t install DSM, for some formatting issue. Synology support say these are not on the compatibility list so not supported.

  • @frostmedia
    @frostmedia Місяць тому

    Yes density and less drives less power is king, but the resync time must be very long that i stick with 12TB drives. Refill one 24 drive with at best 260 MB/s don't want to imagine that.

  • @renascence239
    @renascence239 28 днів тому

    HDDs still undisputed kings of capacity

  • @sutty101
    @sutty101 Місяць тому +1

    Great, more stuff I want that I can't afford 😂😢

  • @Belaziraf
    @Belaziraf 27 днів тому

    You forget there was a time when 4-8 MB was in insane storage size. The bigger the storages capacity goes, the bigger the files will get . Like games and softwares files got bigger and more power hungry as the storages got bigger and hardwares more powerful.

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  27 днів тому

      I remember my first proper grown up PC (the ones before were .umm.. underpowered to say the least) was 1GB, and it blew my mind how I was never going to fill it....ahh the folly of youth!

  • @maurindenouden8245
    @maurindenouden8245 Місяць тому

    Actually I a have a big truenas scale server with 5 20 TB hdds. Configured in raid5. So i have 80tb of storage. It is for my plex server. Some movies in 4k hdr are 20gbs of more. So yes i need it.

  • @SmalltimR
    @SmalltimR Місяць тому +5

    Holding out for them Petabyte drives!

  • @kingneutron1
    @kingneutron1 Місяць тому

    CMR 100%. Use cases I could see: 6-bay ZFS RAIDZ2, single drive for a 1-off data migration backup, POSSIBLY a mirror, but you'd need to do some long-term testing. Triple mirror would be better - but then you're kind of wasting cash with the price on these drives, bc you only get to USE ~21-2TiB of storage (before compression) but you're paying 3x the price for reliability. At that point you might as well spend the extra to go with raidz2 and still have 4x drives for storage and 2 for parity.

  • @LiLBitsDK
    @LiLBitsDK Місяць тому

    man the price of those is nuts compared to the models 1-2 notches down the TB ladder...

  • @PhatPhil77
    @PhatPhil77 Місяць тому

    Anyone tried these in a WD EX2 ULTRA?

  • @Gaspa79
    @Gaspa79 Місяць тому +23

    What do you mean "Who needs this?"?
    That's the equivalent to Bill Gate's quote of "640K of memory is all that anybody will need in a computer".

    • @nascompares
      @nascompares  Місяць тому +11

      I did say that with slight tongue in cheek, to be fair. But also, (and I did I video with this with Ed a few years back), if development resources and/or time is limited, I would much rather see development double down on performance, endurance and efficiency. Not capacity goals. But again, different strokes etc

    • @jirehla-ab1671
      @jirehla-ab1671 Місяць тому

      Is it possible to boot into a sas drive thats attached to a sas card on a consumer mobo? My mobo doesnt have a sas controler​@@nascompares

    • @kenwilliams3279
      @kenwilliams3279 Місяць тому +2

      Once upon a time I was amazed by 1tb drives. Now I can't wait for 40tb

    • @kendrakirai
      @kendrakirai Місяць тому

      ​@nascompares I'd personally rather capacity, all I need is for it to be fast enough to download to reasonably quickly and read fast enough to feed a half dozen plex reads at once. And hold my 20ish terabytes of media. Hopefully as reliably as possible. If I need performance there's SSDs.

    • @Gaspa79
      @Gaspa79 Місяць тому

      @@nascompares Oh, sorry I didn't catch the playfulness. Btw I love your videos. Thanks for the content!

  • @KellicTiger
    @KellicTiger Місяць тому +1

    To be fair. My plex system is sitting at 8,206 movies, 783 TV shows, 228 music artists, 80 Anime TV shows. So I can always use more space. But, and I have yet to watch more then 30 seconds in, the size is an issue. I want an array that is wide, not deep. 16-18TB is the max I will go before I just get more drives. The rebuild time is a serious issue even with a fast system. Even if I'm doing RAID Z3 when we are talking north of 72 hours for a rebuild, that is an issue. We are increasing storage density but not increasing read / write speeds on spinning rust. That is the crux of the issue. The write number sound fine when you are talking writing to an array....until you factor in we are seeing a size increase year on year where writes aren't getting any bigger for individual drives. Mostly because they have maxed out the SATA interface speed. Now SAS can do 12 Gbps with higher IOPS so that really should be where Seagate is focusing but, that isn't where NAS manufacturers are....and would up the cost of the hardware. I suspect the market for that is limited just as 24TB drives are as well.

    • @kendrakirai
      @kendrakirai Місяць тому

      Considering I, for one, am running my NAS from a 17 year old Q6600 PC I had laying around with only SATA 2, and not enough PCIe for a SAS controller I'm happy they're rolling capacity. Go SSDs for performance, do a hybrid system that caches stuff or something, hard drives are for sheer size.

  • @KimPossibleShockwave
    @KimPossibleShockwave Місяць тому

    Unless, ya know, you work with expansive matte painting or 3D modelling scenes.
    Some matte paintings can go up to 25GB per project; four of those are 1TB in total.
    Doesn't seem to large now, does it?

    • @maalikserebryakov
      @maalikserebryakov Місяць тому

      Bloat.

    • @KimPossibleShockwave
      @KimPossibleShockwave Місяць тому

      @@maalikserebryakov Depends on how many layers.
      3D objects imported from Maya, 3DS, or Blender in Photoshop, for example, takes up a ton of space in a .psd
      Folders with ten, twenty layers for just one object or layer are possible, too.
      Matte paintings are incredibly detailed and incredibly large.

    • @tim3172
      @tim3172 Місяць тому

      25GB... Times 4... is 1000GB?
      25 x 4 = 1000?
      Twenty five four times is one thousand?