if you’re wondering how i decided the rankings, i gave every song a rating from 1-5 and averaged the scores for each musical. ex.) i love a lot of tto's songs but like caulk your wagon is terrible also the clips i chose to put aren’t necessarily the best songs. i chose songs that show each musical’s vibe.
Trail to Oregon being one of my favorites, I was upset it was so low. But honestly that makes some sense, I really don’t care for caulk your wagon, and usually skip it if I’m listening to the soundtrack.
My neck snapped from both recoiling in shock seeing it placed so low and jumping out a window. I can’t think of a song from Twisted I dislike, and my favorite songs r from twisted but I respect the list nonetheless
I was with you until Twisted. I’d put Twisted at 2 or 3 probably, and I’d put Ani lower, at 6 or 7 probably. but your opinions are valid and I respect them even if I don’t agree with them
*Me who’s favorite soundtracks are Firebringer, Twisted and TTO* Me: Wow I can’t wait to see where they end up!! Me at the end: Oh...well I’m happy for AVPSY and Ani!!
can you do a compilation of characters in starkid sayin ‘whawazzat??’ (what was that) I’m pretty sure it happens a lot (or at least in hmb and ani, from memory)
me: huh what an interesting ranking system they're all so good and i respect everyone's opinion so let's check this o- *sees holy musical b@tman and AVPS on the lower end* i...respect............every.....person''s........opin..ion................
twisted is my favorite soundtrack of them all. the music is just so good. ballads that actually break your heart and also songs that make you cry laughing. iconic
I have to disagree w like all ur ratings here. So I'm just watching to sing along to every amazing song from each musical, bc every musical is amazing in my eyes anyways. Some have stronger songs, stronger plots, or stronger characters. But honestly these videos make me realise how amazing starkid is, and how no musical is bad.
TRAIL TO OREGON IS SECOND LAST? HOW DARE YOU. Also I have done nothing but watch Twisted over and over for the past 4 days and that soundtrack is nothing less than perfection...HOW DID YOU NOT HEAR WHEN EDITING THIS 😭
The Ani soundtrack is underrated and I think why everyone gives it a hard time is because the Starkid faves are not on it. Clark and Meredith are the only known starkids on there but it’s still really really good.
i have no idea how anyone can rank them so GOOD ON YOU honestly for me it just depends on which one i watched most recently bc i love all of them so freaking much im so glad avpsy is getting love tho bc its HONESTLY AMAZING AND I LOVE THE SOUNDTRACK
This just made me realise how good all of the soundtracks really are! I would've put MAMD a lot higher, it really has amazing music in my opinion, the sound quality is just horrible. I just love the jazzy vibe that all the songs have ^^ Here's my order: 1. Twisted 2. AVPSY 3. AVPM 4. Starship 5. MAMD 6. ANI 7. TGWDLM 8. Firebringer 9. AVPS 10. Holy Musical B@man 11. Trail to Oregon Edit: I calculated scored in the same way that Bread Roll did, here's my scores: 1. AVPM (4.5) 2. Twisted (4.4) 3. ANI (4) and AVPS (4) 5. Firebringer (3.9) and AVPSY (3.9) and Starship (3.9) 8. TGWDLM (3.6) and MAMD (3.6) and HMB (3.6) 11. TTO (3.5)
It's refreshing to see someone who's favorite isn't twisted tbh, even though i love the show I probably would've rated hmb higher and mamd higher as well because those both are full o' bops, but I agree with pretty much every other one
I respect ur opinion, but... AVPSY is good but not better than twisted TTO should be higher and Starship should be a little lower. Imo they have equal numbers of great songs, just different percentages. ANI should be much lower. Maybe it's just me, but those songs sound all similar and aren't memorable
I really agree with TGWDLM as number one, in ever show I can think of at least one song that I don't like, or that goes on for too long. In this, though, every song is amazing.
My problem is I have arguments for why every one of them should be higher so only a few of them would even fukinv move I'm still I'm the process of watching all the shows (currently watching starship but I'm only 10 minutes through so I wont include it, just know that I have heard all of kick it up a notch and that song is in my top 5 starkid songs overall) so from the ones I've seen mine would be: Twisted (every song is top fucking notch) Tgwdlm (first starkid show I've seen in a couple years and what actually pulled me into the fandom. Probably the one I listen to the most) Avpm (back to Hogwarts and granger danger are played at least once a day) Tto (wagon on fire goes h a r d and so does pretty much everything else) Avps (its. Not. O. Ver. Yet. I sing it so often and believe me it was hard to put so low. There are so many amazing songs but overall a lot of the songd rank a bit lower on my top songs list in comparison to say twisted which makes up most of my top 20) Fire bringer (I love it but its not one I ever listen to outside of it coming on from shuffling my starkid playlist)
Given your ranking system, I totally understand why Twisted wouldn't be first (I agree about "Golden Rule" and tbh I'm not crazy about any of Aladdin's songs) but (and I'm extremely biased) I'm surprised how low Firebringer is then... I guess it depends on what you count (because the soundtrack technically has a lot of very short "songs" that are more effects and not really a part of the story that, if weighted equally to the important songs, could bring them down), but every full song in that show (besides the Painting song) SLAPSSSSSS
*However, I obviously completely understand that it's YOUR opinion and that's your choice to make and I respect that, I just wanted to share my own haha... Tbh I completely disagree with 1 and 2 haha (with Starship for example, while I love it overall and "Kick it up a Notch" and "The Way I Do" are 2 of my favorite songs overall, none of the rest of songs really hold up to me tbh)
Everyone in the comments is biased against Ani because they don’t love the show but you need to look at the soundtrack separately and realise it fucking goes hard.
Here’s how i would rank them. 11. MAMD 10. Ani 9. Holy musical b@man 8. Trail to Oregon 7. AVPM 6. AVPSY 5. AVPS 4. TGWDLM 3. Firebringer 2. Starship 1. Twisted IMO AVPS has the best soundtrack of the three although i love AVPSY and I wish TTO was higher but i agree it didn’t have the best soundtrack
WHAT?! Trail To Oregon has one of the best soundtracks ever! (I respect your opinion, I just don't understand how you could forget about bops like Wagon on Fire, Speedrun, Lost Without You, and Naked in a lake)
i used your same process except i ranked every song out of ten and then averaged them (didn’t do much but give me a bunch of decimals bc i ranked most of the songs above 6 anyway) but here’s what i got, with the averages (ani isn’t in it, i haven’t watched it yet ): ) 10.MAMD, 6.79 9.AVPSY, 7 8. AVPM, 7.07 (it’s 7.3 if i exclude pigfarts lmao) 7. AVPS, 7.29 6. TTO, 7.3 5. Firebringer, 7.57 4. TGWDLM, 7.71 3. HMB, 7.75 2. Starship, 7.94 1. Twisted, 7.95 but fr this was all so close, starship almost beat twisted until i decided to change a few things, i think avpsy almost beat the other potter musicals, avps almost beat tto until i changed some from there. so like. starkid has amazing musicals and they were really hard to rank and that’s that.
i’m v happy u gave ani & avpsy the rec it deserves i liked the way u liked them so i did it too (i didn’t include mamd cause i don’t rlly remember it) 1. starship 2. hmb 3. avpsy 4. ani 5. tto 6. avps 7. twisted 8. avpm 9. tgwdlm pls don’t hurt me over tgwdlm
as an experiment i did the same thing, but used a scale of 1-10, 10 being the best, decimals allowed, and got the following, lowest to highest MAMD averaged 7.08, mostly bc while it had very high highs it also had some very low lows, with scores ranging from 2-10 TTO averaged 8.04 (mostly bc of caulk the wagon) AVPM averaged 8.29 AVPS averaged 8.54 AVPSY averaged 8.58 Twisted averaged 8.97 Starship averaged 9.05 HMB averaged 9.06 TGWDLM averaged 9.07 Firebringer averaged 9.22 and barely scraping into first place, with an average score of 9.25, is Ani, because it has only 8 songs and it goes hard on all of them and they're all designed to be listened to on their own without the context of the musical so they just sound very very good. I can only imagine that they must have been even closer than .01 (1/100) if you only used a score of 1-5, Jesus Christ.
I would’ve put Oregon last on my list because as much as I love that show I can only listen to a few songs without being annoyed or bored Meanwhile every song in mamd fucking slaps Also firebringer would be much higher for me because the music is so freakin good
respectfully disagree with you. TTO and Twisted should be way higher, Ani should be lower, and while starship was good, I don’t think it was good enough to be second. Finally, TGWLM deserves to be second. As much as i like working boys, it doesn’t beat Twisted. But props to you for taking the time to rank and make a video about starkid soundtracks.
I agree with majority of the list, or at least can see where you're coming from when you're putting some soundtracks lower. They are all so good so it really comes down to nitpicking. Glad starship was #2, though I personally would've put ani lower and twisted a little higher
Can respect your ranking of tto, love the musical more than life itself but some of the songs are roooough. But twisted and hmb are CRIMINALLY low anyways that’s all I have to say thank you and goodnight
Lol these are so hard to rank but for some reason I love the HMB and Firebringer soundtracks more than the actual musicals so I would put them higher And don’t kill me but... Twisted is SLIGHTLY overrated by the majority of starkid fans so I actually agree with its rating (but Dylan is one of the best singers ever)
I think Twisted would have really benefited from a song or two between Twisted and The Power In Me. Every time I listen to the soundtrack, I just feel like something is missing from the second act really
Do you mean music and lyrics or soundtracks? Because like some of the starkid shows have actual cast recordings that they released, so then it would be a ranking of the produced soundtracks. Then there's the music and lyrics, which would just be a ranking of the songs in the shows and not necessarily the recordings. just wondering which you mean, since you showed show clips throughout and not soundtrack recordings.
if you’re wondering how i decided the rankings, i gave every song a rating from 1-5 and averaged the scores for each musical. ex.) i love a lot of tto's songs but like caulk your wagon is terrible
also the clips i chose to put aren’t necessarily the best songs. i chose songs that show each musical’s vibe.
That's a good method. I know people are getting triggered in the comments, but in your defence, Caulk your wagon *is* terrible
Trail to Oregon being one of my favorites, I was upset it was so low. But honestly that makes some sense, I really don’t care for caulk your wagon, and usually skip it if I’m listening to the soundtrack.
I actually quite like caulk the wagon just because of its absolute insanity
I normally skip Naked In A Lake XD and maybe only listen to You Gotta Go twice because 5 is too much at some times XD
I was mad about tto then I realized caulk the wagon is horrible and the only song I genuinely love is Wagon on Fire
I disagree with lots of these, but I respect your opinion. But, FINALLY someone recognises how good the AVPSY soundtrack is.
Tabitha Benton-Evans IKR
Its disliked too much
Yes!
I think it’s only disliked because the performance wasn’t the best (there was limited rehearsal time, so it makes sense)
Angel L it’s not a bad show at all but the performance was honestly not the best they were just under rehearsed
I disagree so much yet at the same time I agree how is this possible?
11 You
10 Can't
9 Rank
8 Them
7 All
6 Starkid
5 Shows
4 Are
3 Equally
2 Amazing
1 Little White Lie
Clearly
THANK YOU
For some reason when I read little white lie my mind played “caught in a lie”
That was a curve ball. Agrees tho
DUDER'S A SPYYYYY
Firebringer has one of the best soundtracks and you can't convince me otherwise
this is twistedphobic but i respect your opinion
twisted is my fav starkid musical actually!
@@breadroll_sk same 💯💯💯
twisted at #5 gave me whiplash
protect your neck!
Haven't watched it all yet but if Twisted isn't first I'm going to jump out my window
UPDATE: I broke both my legs
Hope Cartwright I broke my fucking back
oops
Thanks for the spoiler. I expected it to be first too
My neck snapped from both recoiling in shock seeing it placed so low and jumping out a window. I can’t think of a song from Twisted I dislike, and my favorite songs r from twisted but I respect the list nonetheless
@@mehspacedorito i don't dislike any twisted songs. just a few are a little meh. like unpopular opinion, not a huge fan of the golden rule
How dare you disrespect trail to Oregon like that
Aly in the Bathroom at a party ya!
I KNOW RIGHT
caulk your wagon exists
bread roll caulk your wagon is the best starkid song ever
bread roll fair point...
I was with you until Twisted. I’d put Twisted at 2 or 3 probably, and I’d put Ani lower, at 6 or 7 probably. but your opinions are valid and I respect them even if I don’t agree with them
Sarah Shine as a whole show, Ani isn’t amazing, but the soundtrack is banging.
I’d put ani lower too
Nah Ani slaps.
We get Clark Baxstresser singing in Ani, what else is there to want?
Ohhh this is... debatable
Too. TRUE.
twisted definitely deserves at least top 3 imo
I respect your choices but I think tto is has one of the best soundtracks
Anna N. I completely agree
same, they have a lot of silly songs in it but the good ones are SOOO good
@@nessiev2373 even some of the silly ones dysentery world? A bop
**inhales**
*YOUR WAGON IS ON FIIIIIIIIRE*
Anna N. I’m so glad someone else genuinely loves dysentery world lol
Finally AVPSY being appreciated for its soundtrack
*Me who’s favorite soundtracks are Firebringer, Twisted and TTO*
Me: Wow I can’t wait to see where they end up!!
Me at the end: Oh...well I’m happy for AVPSY and Ani!!
I think APSY being in the top 3 is awesome
I’m glad to see AVPSY and Ani getting the love they deserve
Definitely forgot tgwdlm was a thing during this video
Same
can you do a compilation of characters in starkid sayin ‘whawazzat??’ (what was that) I’m pretty sure it happens a lot (or at least in hmb and ani, from memory)
me: huh what an interesting ranking system they're all so good and i respect everyone's opinion so let's check this o-
*sees holy musical b@tman and AVPS on the lower end*
i...respect............every.....person''s........opin..ion................
MAMD was done real dirty
Idk why but their soundtrack is one of my favorites. Like some songs are hella weird but they’re all bops
I think MaMD is just ignored by most or avoided cuz of the title and video quality.
flight of the pussies will never not make me laugh
I haven’t listened to the soundtrack in years but Ready to Go is still stuck in my head all the time.
Sleep? Nahh, bread roll is more important
The duck is pleased
At first I was mad about the ones you rated low but then they just kept gettin better. As is the struggle of comparing fabulous Starkid plays.
twisted is lower than expected rip
twisted is my favorite soundtrack of them all. the music is just so good. ballads that actually break your heart and also songs that make you cry laughing. iconic
in my opinion twisted is number 1 but I respect your opinions
i disagree w most of these but i appreciate having all these clips in one place (twisted ftw honestly)
Twisted has so many fans
TTO, AVPS and Twisted deserved better!
Inês S big agree!!!
At least twisted was in the top 5 rip
Yes!
Those are my top 3, and as much as I love the trilogy, avps is the best of them, also hmb deserved better too
Ack Twisted should’ve been in the top 3 lol
I have to disagree w like all ur ratings here. So I'm just watching to sing along to every amazing song from each musical, bc every musical is amazing in my eyes anyways.
Some have stronger songs, stronger plots, or stronger characters. But honestly these videos make me realise how amazing starkid is, and how no musical is bad.
TRAIL TO OREGON IS SECOND LAST? HOW DARE YOU.
Also I have done nothing but watch Twisted over and over for the past 4 days and that soundtrack is nothing less than perfection...HOW DID YOU NOT HEAR WHEN EDITING THIS 😭
5 seconds in and I’m already bitter lmao
This is a hard one
i will accept holy musical b@tman being so low only because starship is #2
I understand why someone would love it, but there are reasons it's not a favorite for everyone. On that not... 🎵I wanna be your friend forever!🎵
AVPS and TTO are probs my favorite but it’s so cool to see other rankings and tbh they’re all so good
A Jeff show right at the top, a Jeff show by the bottom. He’s got the range.
I think this is the highest AVPSY has ever been and I'm so happy for it.
I feel like some were done dirty but I'm also happy because Starship is my all time favourite musical
I'VE SEEN IT WITH MY OWN EYES IS AWESOME AND SO IS THE WHOLE ANI SOUNTRACK ILY
CLARK'S VOCALS IN HAUNTED BY THE KISS ARE TOP FUCKIN NOTCH
I love Starship! I think it’s super under appreciated sometimes, but it’s such a bop! I’m really glad it was up there!!
so happy for the ani love though. that musical is so underrated.
ALL OF THE SONGS ARE FUCKIN BANGERS
Firebringer and Twisted deserved better lol - appreciate you for making this though!
What?!! AVPS AT 9?!!! that's definitely in the top 3 for me! But I respect your opinion even though I don't agree! Great video!
The Ani soundtrack is underrated and I think why everyone gives it a hard time is because the Starkid faves are not on it. Clark and Meredith are the only known starkids on there but it’s still really really good.
CLARK AND PIERCE SOUND AMAZING ON IT
The respect the Ani soundtrack deserves!
So glad you used The Night Belongs to Snarl for Firebringer! That song is so under appreciated!
It’s nice to see Starship getting the appreciation it deserves
Twisted at #5 had me shaken but Dylan has legal ownership of my soul so I’m biased
finally AVPSY getting recognition! the soundtrack is amazing
i have no idea how anyone can rank them so GOOD ON YOU
honestly for me it just depends on which one i watched most recently bc i love all of them so freaking much
im so glad avpsy is getting love tho bc its HONESTLY AMAZING AND I LOVE THE SOUNDTRACK
i totally agree with avpsy and starship being in the top 3!! thank you for acknowledging how amazing their music is
Show stopping number on it’s own could be number one, it doesn’t need the rest of the musical 😂😂
FINALLY some Ani appreciation!
You have brought justice to Ani and Starship, also Clark Baxstresser is a god on the Ani soundtrack
This just made me realise how good all of the soundtracks really are! I would've put MAMD a lot higher, it really has amazing music in my opinion, the sound quality is just horrible. I just love the jazzy vibe that all the songs have ^^
Here's my order:
1. Twisted
2. AVPSY
3. AVPM
4. Starship
5. MAMD
6. ANI
7. TGWDLM
8. Firebringer
9. AVPS
10. Holy Musical B@man
11. Trail to Oregon
Edit: I calculated scored in the same way that Bread Roll did, here's my scores:
1. AVPM (4.5)
2. Twisted (4.4)
3. ANI (4) and AVPS (4)
5. Firebringer (3.9) and AVPSY (3.9) and Starship (3.9)
8. TGWDLM (3.6) and MAMD (3.6) and HMB (3.6)
11. TTO (3.5)
I mean i love AVPSY and Ani but i just LOVE THE TWISTED TO BITS but i respect your choices
It's refreshing to see someone who's favorite isn't twisted tbh, even though i love the show
I probably would've rated hmb higher and mamd higher as well because those both are full o' bops, but I agree with pretty much every other one
In my opinion Avps has a better soundtrack than avpm and avpsy, and Twisted should be nº1, but it's ok everybody has their own opinions
Let AVPSY Have this moment
I somewhat agree with most of these but I would for sure put Firebringer and Trail to Oregon higher but Ani and AVPSY lower
I respect ur opinion, but...
AVPSY is good but not better than twisted
TTO should be higher and Starship should be a little lower. Imo they have equal numbers of great songs, just different percentages.
ANI should be much lower. Maybe it's just me, but those songs sound all similar and aren't memorable
ANI songs are all pretty good tho. I do think starships songs arent all that great.
Lmaooo literally my four favorite Starkid musicals are at the bottom (but I respect your opinions, nice video!)
My top 3 for the nones of people who asked
3: TGWDLM
2:Twisted
1:Starship (i cried several times during some songs)
Valid af. My opinions change too much whenever I rewatch anyone of them tho
Finally someone putting starship first I liked it mores than twisted
TTO is really good, but the live version is so much better
I really agree with TGWDLM as number one, in ever show I can think of at least one song that I don't like, or that goes on for too long. In this, though, every song is amazing.
My problem is I have arguments for why every one of them should be higher so only a few of them would even fukinv move
I'm still I'm the process of watching all the shows (currently watching starship but I'm only 10 minutes through so I wont include it, just know that I have heard all of kick it up a notch and that song is in my top 5 starkid songs overall) so from the ones I've seen mine would be:
Twisted (every song is top fucking notch)
Tgwdlm (first starkid show I've seen in a couple years and what actually pulled me into the fandom. Probably the one I listen to the most)
Avpm (back to Hogwarts and granger danger are played at least once a day)
Tto (wagon on fire goes h a r d and so does pretty much everything else)
Avps (its. Not. O. Ver. Yet. I sing it so often and believe me it was hard to put so low. There are so many amazing songs but overall a lot of the songd rank a bit lower on my top songs list in comparison to say twisted which makes up most of my top 20)
Fire bringer (I love it but its not one I ever listen to outside of it coming on from shuffling my starkid playlist)
FINALLY someone respects Ani in this house
how dare you disrespect my child, AVPS, like this? never contact my family again.
Given your ranking system, I totally understand why Twisted wouldn't be first (I agree about "Golden Rule" and tbh I'm not crazy about any of Aladdin's songs) but (and I'm extremely biased) I'm surprised how low Firebringer is then... I guess it depends on what you count (because the soundtrack technically has a lot of very short "songs" that are more effects and not really a part of the story that, if weighted equally to the important songs, could bring them down), but every full song in that show (besides the Painting song) SLAPSSSSSS
*However, I obviously completely understand that it's YOUR opinion and that's your choice to make and I respect that, I just wanted to share my own haha... Tbh I completely disagree with 1 and 2 haha (with Starship for example, while I love it overall and "Kick it up a Notch" and "The Way I Do" are 2 of my favorite songs overall, none of the rest of songs really hold up to me tbh)
Everyone here on about twisted and tto while I'm here like what about mamd it is SO GOOD and too low, in my opinion of course
Everyone in the comments is biased against Ani because they don’t love the show but you need to look at the soundtrack separately and realise it fucking goes hard.
Tbh Trail to Oregon, Twisted and Starship are my top 3 but otherwise I agree
Here’s how i would rank them.
11. MAMD
10. Ani
9. Holy musical b@man
8. Trail to Oregon
7. AVPM
6. AVPSY
5. AVPS
4. TGWDLM
3. Firebringer
2. Starship
1. Twisted
IMO AVPS has the best soundtrack of the three although i love AVPSY and I wish TTO was higher but i agree it didn’t have the best soundtrack
This is an order I can get behind.
wow I actually really like your list! (except for Ani being so low ;-; but all the soundtracks are good so i get it.)
Libby Stabile It hurt me so bad to put Ani so low because it’s already so underrated and i love it so much 😭
@@reneenoelj hha it's ok! I haven't seen every StarKid show so I don't even know how hard it must've been to rank them all!
WHAT?! Trail To Oregon has one of the best soundtracks ever! (I respect your opinion, I just don't understand how you could forget about bops like Wagon on Fire, Speedrun, Lost Without You, and Naked in a lake)
i must counter with caulk your wagon and when you gotta go
@@breadroll_sk True... But every soundtrack has some songs that aren't very good. (For example Tied Up My Heart and What Do You Want in TGWDLM)
Love that Ani is recognized for its straight bops, but sad MAMD is so low :(
i used your same process except i ranked every song out of ten and then averaged them (didn’t do much but give me a bunch of decimals bc i ranked most of the songs above 6 anyway)
but here’s what i got, with the averages (ani isn’t in it, i haven’t watched it yet ): )
10.MAMD, 6.79
9.AVPSY, 7
8. AVPM, 7.07 (it’s 7.3 if i exclude pigfarts lmao)
7. AVPS, 7.29
6. TTO, 7.3
5. Firebringer, 7.57
4. TGWDLM, 7.71
3. HMB, 7.75
2. Starship, 7.94
1. Twisted, 7.95
but fr this was all so close, starship almost beat twisted until i decided to change a few things, i think avpsy almost beat the other potter musicals, avps almost beat tto until i changed some from there. so like. starkid has amazing musicals and they were really hard to rank and that’s that.
Finally someone who doesn't put Twisted at number 1!!
i’m v happy u gave ani & avpsy the rec it deserves
i liked the way u liked them so i did it too (i didn’t include mamd cause i don’t rlly remember it)
1. starship
2. hmb
3. avpsy
4. ani
5. tto
6. avps
7. twisted
8. avpm
9. tgwdlm
pls don’t hurt me over tgwdlm
yes!!!!! i love ani sm
How can you say something so controversial yet so brave
tbh I love the Ani Soundtrack
Trail to Oregon got ROBBED. It should be #1
as an experiment i did the same thing, but used a scale of 1-10, 10 being the best, decimals allowed, and got the following, lowest to highest
MAMD averaged 7.08, mostly bc while it had very high highs it also had some very low lows, with scores ranging from 2-10
TTO averaged 8.04 (mostly bc of caulk the wagon)
AVPM averaged 8.29
AVPS averaged 8.54
AVPSY averaged 8.58
Twisted averaged 8.97
Starship averaged 9.05
HMB averaged 9.06
TGWDLM averaged 9.07
Firebringer averaged 9.22
and barely scraping into first place, with an average score of 9.25, is Ani, because it has only 8 songs and it goes hard on all of them and they're all designed to be listened to on their own without the context of the musical so they just sound very very good.
I can only imagine that they must have been even closer than .01 (1/100) if you only used a score of 1-5, Jesus Christ.
Excuse you, putting Twisted at 5
honestly you should rank the Starkid librettos too.
oh you did HMB sooooooo dirty
I would’ve put Oregon last on my list because as much as I love that show I can only listen to a few songs without being annoyed or bored
Meanwhile every song in mamd fucking slaps
Also firebringer would be much higher for me because the music is so freakin good
yEs
respectfully disagree with you. TTO and Twisted should be way higher, Ani should be lower, and while starship was good, I don’t think it was good enough to be second. Finally, TGWLM deserves to be second. As much as i like working boys, it doesn’t beat Twisted. But props to you for taking the time to rank and make a video about starkid soundtracks.
I accidentally clicked ahead to the end and got spoiled for #1 :(
*aggressive agreement*
i was pissed about tto but then it hit me
*_caulk the wagon_*
Pays to be an animal as well
THIS IS IT. THIS IS THE COMMENT
@@BritishLuverimo Pays to be an Animal is a bop, but I respect your opinion
caulk the wagon slaps hard
I agree with majority of the list, or at least can see where you're coming from when you're putting some soundtracks lower. They are all so good so it really comes down to nitpicking. Glad starship was #2, though I personally would've put ani lower and twisted a little higher
finally ani and starship gets the respect they deserve, but holy musical batman was ROBBED
Can respect your ranking of tto, love the musical more than life itself but some of the songs are roooough. But twisted and hmb are CRIMINALLY low anyways that’s all I have to say thank you and goodnight
How was your vacation?
so good! thanks for asking!!
I agree with your #1 but MAMD is just too low for me to agree with anything else- but it's your opinion and i don't care what you like more :p
Lol these are so hard to rank but for some reason I love the HMB and Firebringer soundtracks more than the actual musicals so I would put them higher
And don’t kill me but...
Twisted is SLIGHTLY overrated by the majority of starkid fans so I actually agree with its rating (but Dylan is one of the best singers ever)
Mary totally agree
My favourites are Starship, HMB and AVPS
Why did you place Twisted at 5 if I may ask? Because in my opinion it has the best soundtrack
I think Twisted would have really benefited from a song or two between Twisted and The Power In Me. Every time I listen to the soundtrack, I just feel like something is missing from the second act really
Do you mean music and lyrics or soundtracks? Because like some of the starkid shows have actual cast recordings that they released, so then it would be a ranking of the produced soundtracks. Then there's the music and lyrics, which would just be a ranking of the songs in the shows and not necessarily the recordings. just wondering which you mean, since you showed show clips throughout and not soundtrack recordings.
music and lyrics! i said soundtrack in the title bc i couldn't think of a shorter/better title oops
Okay but where can you get the AVPSY soundtrack?!