We know his backstory Roger found him raised him He grew up went is own way Tried to fight mihawk lost everytime Gathered his crew Started his journey Lost his arm Started his Yonko journey
Yoooo shanks clone can actually give Mihawk motivation to dominate and actually give us viewers a real scale of what the 1v1 with shanks actually looked like . Or or hear me out Shanks and Mihawk vs clone and Garling .
How one dimensional can you be? You think it's impossible for Shanks to PRETEND to be on the WG side just to eventually stab them in the back while they least expect????? One Piece fans are super paranoid lmao.
It could be a situation where Shanks was a clone of Garling and since he ended up with Roger, they made another for Garling to raise and train to be his successor. For people who've read the Kengan series, it's like the connector making multiple clones.
@@lemonplayz4032 the first "perfect" clone, vegapunk also considered df clones failures due to color defect only and sanji was considered a failure for having emotions, maybe shanks was a failed clone? stabs is actually the perfect clone, both are clones of garling instead... that would be neat, so a "clone", but still the same so in a way still "twinning" lol but a year younger just made maybe with more sociopathic tendencies or to perfectly be trained by garling's wisdom like if you took everything you knew and made a perfect version of yourself, then he goes on to later become elder himself, dawg im cookin wtf lemme stop here before I ruin it
The idea that Shanks might have a twin brother or a clone is certainly a unique theory. However, what if he is neither a twin brother nor a clone? What would be the possibility-no matter how absurd it seems-that he is Shanks' biological father, who teleported to Elbaf to speak with Loki about Shanks? In Chapter 1135, only the bandaged woman addressed the two guard giants, mentioning that they were looking for Loki. For someone who could be Shanks' twin or clone-and who allegedly murdered King Harald six years ago-it’s peculiar that the guard giants are discussing this, yet the person in question remains silent. Instead, the giants talk about whether the group is part of Luffy's crew. The bandaged woman, on the other hand, appears more thoughtful and speechless. If the gods knights were aware that Luffy and his crew were on the island, they might have planned their defenses better and possibly strengthened their position. Instead, their focus on speaking with Loki suggests they believe Loki is still in the castle.
Not possible, unfortunately. Cloning technology only became successful three years after Shanks was born. And Vegapunk was unaffiliated with the World Government until a decade after Shanks was born.
@shrapidbunny4437 or shanks was the failed clone of garling and this look alike shank could be the perfect clone. Just like how vega punk made a perfect clone if himself.
I can see it being a twin, based off 1) Garling mentioning sons 2) This twin was summoned with Saturn's ability/ which is now in the possession of Garling 3) Chapter 907 mirror panel of this hooded figure. The pirate that we thought "Shanks" was talking to the gorosei about is actually Loki.
Just like how Bonny's mom died to bring bonney away from marijoa, I think shanks mom may have done the same to entrust shanks with roger instead of garling
No one’s talking about it but what if Skanks is actually a clone of Saint Garling and Stabs just Garlings legitimate child. Shanks was 1 years old when the gods valley incident occurred. One year before that was when judge, queen, Caesar, and vegapunk joined together and made MAD. What if shanks was the failed attempt of cloning the holy knight sir garling they wanted to make an army of the strongest person they knew and what would’ve been better than a arm of the leader of the holy knights? and they instead of making an exact clone they ended up with a baby and dumped the baby on god valley or the world government found out about clone baby garling and had them execute shanks but vegapunk as it was shown has a soft heart and was tasked to end baby shanks life to show his commitment to the world government and MAD so he hid shanks in a treasure chest that was then taken to god valley as a prize but no one knew that a baby was inside and lead to successful cloning of stussy
I have a strange feeling that the god's knights are devil fruit users and advanced haki users. The more i look at them, the more they must have a mythical zoan users, or we have to wait and see....the cloning part i have a feeling that they clone some of the notorious pirates or marines that will be wild
Honestly though ill be a bit disappointed if it isnt Shanks that was talking to the Goroseis in chapter 907. Because it gave some sort of illusion and aura that Shanks had insane power and was able to casually go into Mariejois and talk to the Gorosei lol
Today I'm with Larry because Shanks killing his brother would be tragic but not sad plus many will feel nothing. It's just another fight, plus the annoying thing is like this is when you pick a character from a 1v1 fight game and your opponent picks the same but in different cloths like get your own character.
Didn't the other satellites work in a way specifically to cut York off from the network? Like as far as York is aware she's the only surviving Vegapunk left. To the point that Lilith is confident she can just start over on Elbaf and the others are confident they can just float around in the clouds for a few decades without worry. It's like she got booted from the discord chat LOL.
What if Shanks was a clone and planted on Rogers ship to be a spy and get information on laughtale and poneglyphs. The fishman island poneglyph was only taken by the man marked by flames after Rogers journey.
They found shanks on god valley, then after leaving the island opened the chest when they were at a safe distance and realised shanks was in there. There’s no way oda showed us those 6 identical chests on god valley for no reason
Luffy is gonna get taken out by stabs like knocked out or severely hurt and removed from the story for a bit... Or if kid is there somehow he might crash out on stabs due to confusion... There's some plot pieces that can be placed...
The Kuma flashback literally affirmed he has a brother... If the brother was a good guy, we'd have known about him already. So we know he's down with the elders... Why are they ignoring the actual plot points in this convo. Is this pod for super casuals?
Failed clone maybe? The red hair? He did make his crew the red haired pirates. That’s like a stamp on the red hair. Vegapunk considered Momo’s fruit a failure only because the dragon was pink, maybe this is the same case. Gingers have also been discriminated against in history so I wouldn’t be surprised the celestial look down on that hair color
Because it doesn’t make sense. Clones were invented by MADS, which is technically a criminal organization, whose first successful clone wouldn’t be made until 3 years after Shanks’ birth. And Vegapunk and MADS would not have anything to do with the World Government, in fact working in the Underworld, against them, for over a decade after Shanks’ birth before they were absorbed by the Marines.
Can’t be shanks, where does his crew go when he makes these moves? Is his crew evil ? We hardly know anything about the crew.. usopp n his dad might impact this arc, so maybe we will learn more about the red haired pirates .. looking like holy knights vs revolutionary army , straw hat pirates and loki vs evil/good shanks and the red haired pirates..
@@jaydenhaidle7339 That’s not what I mean. The issue isn’t control. The issue im presenting is if we presume both clones. That means artificial life would have a higher ceiling for a human based power system than actual humans. We haven’t seen anyone showcase anything remotely that strong yet. And if they are clones we may never see a natural human do it because they may be showcasing a level of power beyond human Haki.
@@WriteWhatISee We also haven't seen how strong Garling actually is right now tho it is possible with in the confides of the story and little context clues that he is that strong. Its possible that he was the one who wounded white beard, He was also one of the four major players in the god valley incident this doesnt mean hes on Garp , Rodger and Xebecs level but he is the forth player in the picture. Also as far as we know he's the only new Gorosei member ever which lends credit to hes strength
Why is nobody talking about Shanks being the failed clone? Failed clone is possible. The red hair? He did make his crew the red haired pirates. That’s like a stamp on the red hair. Vegapunk considered Momo’s fruit a failure only because the dragon was pink, maybe this is the same case. Gingers have also been discriminated against in history so I wouldn’t be surprised the celestial look down on that hair color
I swear ppl are so brainless… why are the only 2 options a twin or a clone? He could easily just be a brother who’s slightly younger or older. Garling had women changing him probably for his entire youth.
it's only cause of the fact they "have the same facial hair and hair so far" which I mean I get, don't think it means it is shanks or a twin, always said the same as you and could just simply be figarland blood is very distinct is all with its features just as some others like lunarians etc and they're just idk fkn similar looking but to explain why people jump to those conclusions immediately I guess would be that
I will be damned after nearly 30 years, We get a twin brother for shanks before we even get his back story
Shanks backstory is obviously going to be tied to his family
We know his backstory
Roger found him raised him
He grew up went is own way
Tried to fight mihawk lost everytime
Gathered his crew
Started his journey
Lost his arm
Started his Yonko journey
@@ItachiUchiha_1724 it was never said that mihawk beat shanks lol
I’m ngl this comment is kinda disingenuous
@@ItachiUchiha_1724 we need to know where that treasure chest he is find in from that’s the question
I think its possible Shanks himself was a clone of Stabs. It's possible that's why he was in the treasure chest because he was put up as an award
I think they are both clones of garling
This’ll be a good idea
@@trapshadowltf you cooked with this
Yoooo shanks clone can actually give Mihawk motivation to dominate and actually give us viewers a real scale of what the 1v1 with shanks actually looked like . Or or hear me out Shanks and Mihawk vs clone and Garling .
I’d be so down for this mainly because I love team-ups/fights like that
I dont want shanks to be evil lol
Same, it would kinda be disappointing to have him be this great person and end up needing to fight luffy after the great image he has for him.
How one dimensional can you be? You think it's impossible for Shanks to PRETEND to be on the WG side just to eventually stab them in the back while they least expect????? One Piece fans are super paranoid lmao.
@@thegreatimuthat's kinda cliche
I think that's why oda brought in the shanks twin/clone so that we can have an "evil shanks" without making shanks evil
It could be a situation where Shanks was a clone of Garling and since he ended up with Roger, they made another for Garling to raise and train to be his successor. For people who've read the Kengan series, it's like the connector making multiple clones.
my money is on you my guy
It can’t tho, based on the timeline of cloning technology, starting after Shanks was born.
@@lemonplayz4032 the first "perfect" clone, vegapunk also considered df clones failures due to color defect only and sanji was considered a failure for having emotions, maybe shanks was a failed clone? stabs is actually the perfect clone, both are clones of garling instead... that would be neat, so a "clone", but still the same so in a way still "twinning" lol but a year younger just made maybe with more sociopathic tendencies or to perfectly be trained by garling's wisdom
like if you took everything you knew and made a perfect version of yourself, then he goes on to later become elder himself, dawg im cookin wtf lemme stop here before I ruin it
@lemonplayz4032 stussy clone was the first perfect clone that was created absvthat was 1 year after God valley so the timeline does make sense
“Who does Shanks fight in the endgame???”
Himself
I think it's a devil fruit darling has that makes him look young and he uses it to get around
The idea that Shanks might have a twin brother or a clone is certainly a unique theory. However, what if he is neither a twin brother nor a clone? What would be the possibility-no matter how absurd it seems-that he is Shanks' biological father, who teleported to Elbaf to speak with Loki about Shanks? In Chapter 1135, only the bandaged woman addressed the two guard giants, mentioning that they were looking for Loki. For someone who could be Shanks' twin or clone-and who allegedly murdered King Harald six years ago-it’s peculiar that the guard giants are discussing this, yet the person in question remains silent. Instead, the giants talk about whether the group is part of Luffy's crew. The bandaged woman, on the other hand, appears more thoughtful and speechless.
If the gods knights were aware that Luffy and his crew were on the island, they might have planned their defenses better and possibly strengthened their position. Instead, their focus on speaking with Loki suggests they believe Loki is still in the castle.
Maybe its shanks older brother and shanks was a given up as a prize on god valley bc he wasnt first born. And maybe kids is there youngest brother 😂
OR Shanks is the clone and this other one without scars is the real one
@@shrapidbunny4437 thought the same thing
Bro that’d be insane lowkey im down
Sure, vegapunk shared his knowledge and technology to every single person. So everybody could be a clone 😒
Not possible, unfortunately. Cloning technology only became successful three years after Shanks was born. And Vegapunk was unaffiliated with the World Government until a decade after Shanks was born.
@shrapidbunny4437 or shanks was the failed clone of garling and this look alike shank could be the perfect clone. Just like how vega punk made a perfect clone if himself.
He forgot he hit him with a controller yeah he’s a menace 😭🤣
I can see it being a twin, based off 1) Garling mentioning sons 2) This twin was summoned with Saturn's ability/ which is now in the possession of Garling 3) Chapter 907 mirror panel of this hooded figure. The pirate that we thought "Shanks" was talking to the gorosei about is actually Loki.
7:20 "so you think Lionel's a recycle" 😭😭😭😭
At this point I think all the old yonkos and Roger probably have clones
23:56 My brother and I got same dad different moms, and we look exactly alike lol
Just like how Bonny's mom died to bring bonney away from marijoa, I think shanks mom may have done the same to entrust shanks with roger instead of garling
No one’s talking about it but what if Skanks is actually a clone of Saint Garling and Stabs just Garlings legitimate child. Shanks was 1 years old when the gods valley incident occurred. One year before that was when judge, queen, Caesar, and vegapunk joined together and made MAD. What if shanks was the failed attempt of cloning the holy knight sir garling they wanted to make an army of the strongest person they knew and what would’ve been better than a arm of the leader of the holy knights? and they instead of making an exact clone they ended up with a baby and dumped the baby on god valley or the world government found out about clone baby garling and had them execute shanks but vegapunk as it was shown has a soft heart and was tasked to end baby shanks life to show his commitment to the world government and MAD so he hid shanks in a treasure chest that was then taken to god valley as a prize but no one knew that a baby was inside and lead to successful cloning of stussy
Dang, Mihawk had to 1v2 Shanks and Stabs
Shnaks, the Evil Twin
I have a strange feeling that the god's knights are devil fruit users and advanced haki users. The more i look at them, the more they must have a mythical zoan users, or we have to wait and see....the cloning part i have a feeling that they clone some of the notorious pirates or marines that will be wild
I like this theory since almost every new villain is advanced in haki and the last few have been zoans
Can we argue about the whitebeard scar again with this new information? I had thoughts lmao
Honestly though ill be a bit disappointed if it isnt Shanks that was talking to the Goroseis in chapter 907. Because it gave some sort of illusion and aura that Shanks had insane power and was able to casually go into Mariejois and talk to the Gorosei lol
Today I'm with Larry because Shanks killing his brother would be tragic but not sad plus many will feel nothing. It's just another fight, plus the annoying thing is like this is when you pick a character from a 1v1 fight game and your opponent picks the same but in different cloths like get your own character.
Didn't the other satellites work in a way specifically to cut York off from the network? Like as far as York is aware she's the only surviving Vegapunk left. To the point that Lilith is confident she can just start over on Elbaf and the others are confident they can just float around in the clouds for a few decades without worry. It's like she got booted from the discord chat LOL.
What if Shanks was a clone and planted on Rogers ship to be a spy and get information on laughtale and poneglyphs. The fishman island poneglyph was only taken by the man marked by flames after Rogers journey.
W video boys !
They found shanks on god valley, then after leaving the island opened the chest when they were at a safe distance and realised shanks was in there. There’s no way oda showed us those 6 identical chests on god valley for no reason
Will the real slim shady please stand up?
Check if the voice actor for 'Shanks' changed for that episode.
16:20 bro clearly didn't read thru egghead well enough for this convo
I think it’s a clone also… vegapunk talked about perfect clones in the beginning of the chapter
Luffy is gonna get taken out by stabs like knocked out or severely hurt and removed from the story for a bit... Or if kid is there somehow he might crash out on stabs due to confusion... There's some plot pieces that can be placed...
If shanks has a twin brother ,bro it’d be so wack
Zoro is gonna fight shanks. Luffy is gonna fight shanks’ brother
What happened with the Whitebeard that man smoke?
The shanks and his crew are the gods knights. Always were
The twin with the reading glasses. Don't be talking about anything just talking on circles.
What difference does it make if the guy is a twin, older/younger brother, or cousin? Seems really nitpicky to complain about their relation
Shnak’s
It might be Garling but IMU gave him immortality and now he looks like shanks because they’re related 😅
No just no lmao
It’s Shanks seraphim.
You and the community referring to as Stabs? This guy watching KOL. Shout out to KOL man!
why tf can it not just be a brother?? like whats wrong with that
These people just want to talk about something that not as simple as being a Brother is mid for them. So everybody has to be a clone, it’s tiresome.
The Kuma flashback literally affirmed he has a brother... If the brother was a good guy, we'd have known about him already. So we know he's down with the elders... Why are they ignoring the actual plot points in this convo. Is this pod for super casuals?
Why has nobody talked about Shanks being the clone instead?
Failed clone maybe? The red hair? He did make his crew the red haired pirates. That’s like a stamp on the red hair. Vegapunk considered Momo’s fruit a failure only because the dragon was pink, maybe this is the same case. Gingers have also been discriminated against in history so I wouldn’t be surprised the celestial look down on that hair color
Yo you spittin
Because it doesn’t make sense. Clones were invented by MADS, which is technically a criminal organization, whose first successful clone wouldn’t be made until 3 years after Shanks’ birth. And Vegapunk and MADS would not have anything to do with the World Government, in fact working in the Underworld, against them, for over a decade after Shanks’ birth before they were absorbed by the Marines.
Maybe the twin stopped kaido from reaching marineford 🤔
Can’t be shanks, where does his crew go when he makes these moves? Is his crew evil ? We hardly know anything about the crew.. usopp n his dad might impact this arc, so maybe we will learn more about the red haired pirates .. looking like holy knights vs revolutionary army , straw hat pirates and loki vs evil/good shanks and the red haired pirates..
Why don't we assume that they are both clones of garling?
One good and one bad meaning one is a failed clone being shanks cause he’s good and not a mindless soldier of the government.
Would you really want a clone to be able to access Haki of that level?
@@WriteWhatISee i mean the government and imu has shown that it is able to control strong haki users so why not
@@jaydenhaidle7339 That’s not what I mean. The issue isn’t control. The issue im presenting is if we presume both clones. That means artificial life would have a higher ceiling for a human based power system than actual humans. We haven’t seen anyone showcase anything remotely that strong yet. And if they are clones we may never see a natural human do it because they may be showcasing a level of power beyond human Haki.
@@WriteWhatISee We also haven't seen how strong Garling actually is right now tho it is possible with in the confides of the story and little context clues that he is that strong. Its possible that he was the one who wounded white beard, He was also one of the four major players in the god valley incident this doesnt mean hes on Garp , Rodger and Xebecs level but he is the forth player in the picture. Also as far as we know he's the only new Gorosei member ever which lends credit to hes strength
They answered garling like that cause they had just got clapped
Stop calling the man 'stabs' his name is shaw. I'll let you guys figure out the rest lol
Stabs?!?!? It’s Frank
What if he's just the perfect shanks clone/seraphim
It’s a spy with a devil fruit
I give no creditability to anyone who believe this is a clown. I really doubt the celestial dragons would appoint a clone into the holy knights
I’d like to think that shanks is the clone and this person is the original.
Why is nobody talking about Shanks being the failed clone?
Failed clone is possible. The red hair? He did make his crew the red haired pirates. That’s like a stamp on the red hair. Vegapunk considered Momo’s fruit a failure only because the dragon was pink, maybe this is the same case. Gingers have also been discriminated against in history so I wouldn’t be surprised the celestial look down on that hair color
Vegapunk said that Stussy was the first clone, not counting the "failed" red haired shanks. You cooking
@ ^
Having a twin is realistic btw
I would love for Shanks to be evil. That would a hilarious twist
Nah two things ik for a fact is that shanks is a snitch fr and if shanks has a twin gis name better be "Thanks".
Garling clone or shanks brother
I swear ppl are so brainless… why are the only 2 options a twin or a clone? He could easily just be a brother who’s slightly younger or older. Garling had women changing him probably for his entire youth.
I think it's just a brother. I think twin or clone are more controversial options and it will get better clicks.
it's only cause of the fact they "have the same facial hair and hair so far" which I mean I get, don't think it means it is shanks or a twin, always said the same as you and could just simply be figarland blood is very distinct is all with its features just as some others like lunarians etc and they're just idk fkn similar looking
but to explain why people jump to those conclusions immediately I guess would be that
Naw thats thanks
He’s a seraphim made of haki
first.
Tbh i just want shanks to be evil lmao
The Qanon of one piece smh
I think shanks is evil
What if it’s bon clay using his fruit as shanks??
Twin Shanks with NO FORESHADOWING is awful lazy writing....Right along with everyone that dies coming back is making the story feel really cheap
There’s been tons of foreshadowing. From the timeline that shakes was adopted, and the timeline of God valley.
It’s shanks. I guess I’m just holding out hope that Oda doesn’t pull the worst plot line giving main characters look alike twins.
It’s not shanks
It is very clearly not shanks you're on some fexr timing
@blessinganwana9854 Why is it clearly not Shanks? I feel like I missed something.
@@kobeballerThere’s no definite reason but I’m assuming it’s because we don’t see the scarred side of the face/lack of a left arm
@@kobeballer me too
Neither