You are ill-informed. Racist, Islamophobic & against women! Labor check every before giving Ticket.Same Western Colonial Criminals who illegally Blamed & Bombed Afghanistan & killed millions of innocent Civilians, CREATED Taliban to Defeat USSR & Now after looting everything Holding Billions of Afghanistan Funds so They can't run Afghanistan & because of that reason. PAYMANA application of surrendering citizenship simply Cant be processed! Well Deport her then You All convinced Criminals came here, Killed Almost All Aboriginals should Also be Deported back to UK, EUROPE, USA or Wherever you all Racist Criminals came from
Its Labors money that helped her campaign and she only got in because of Labors preference as she got in with only 1600 votes. I would like her citizenship investigated.
She came here for a peaceful life, and now causing trouble in the country that welcomed her, why doesn’t she go to Palestine and help the people she talks about,
I am sure that for the majority of Australians..this woman should simply just not be in the Parliament...she should never have been able to be elected...she stands with the Taliban!
She should know that she is getting paid by taxpayers and her responsibilities are for Australia and Australians not for particular race, religion or colour. The government has let this things to happening not only in Australia but around the world.
No, she owes us all every cent she got. Her unlawful inclusion was labour cheating and flaunting the laws and rules. Section 44. Dual citizens are ineligable to sit and they knew this.
Oh dear, how sad... Incidentally, if you are a member of government e.g., a Senator - you should NOT have dual citizenship. When entering office your LOYALTIES SHOULD BE CHRYSTALLISED... you cannot serve 2 loyalties at that level of citizenship... you represented Aussies and that is the point.
@@hariseldon3786 it is though. It’s why we had those issues regarding legality of our elected MPs in the 2017-18 period. They’re now vetted before they’re allowed to stand up. Fatima Payman’s case is one I am unfamiliar with, but from my understanding, the issues around legality were drawn due to her circumstances (she was a refugee).
Other politicians who have crossed the floor and changed parties over the years haven't called out for the abolishion of Jews by using the phrase from the river to the sea Palestinian will be free. No comparison Shorten.
Bill looks like he has had a hard night Payman has dual citizenship and as such should not be in parliament there should be no conditions around it no matter who you are
The biggest culprits of NDIS are by the registered providers who are abusing the system, charging the highest rates for care services. The registered providers must be investigated
no, we need a govt with enough guts to make Bill Of Rights that encompasses not only a citizens right, but what is expected of a person as an Australian citizen... that will sort all of them out, not just middle eastern component... and they all said Pauline was racist. well she could do a far better job than the current fools on both sides.
@@AVportau great ideas, but we have a constitution and QLD has a bill of rights, that are set aside when the government sees fit to do so. This is an invasion of the western world by the Muslim/islamic ideology and that has no place in any level of Australian government. Australia is at the doorway of defeat and we are still debating and being divided over a chalk and cheese situation. If we could only get Pauline, babet and other top class Aussies in to power problems would be solved. We would agree on that, but I think our only other hope is Trump24. He won’t put up with this pro Muslim interference in what should be his no 1 ally.
@@chrisb3248 USA gives huge aid to it's No.1 ally and it isn't us. we are just puppets of convenience. this is just a political farce to get people to accept domination over truth and fairness.... the greens who voted to recognise Palestine weren't muslims, or even if one or 2 may be it's not the issue and politics would rather attack the person than debate or fix the issue. i'm white atheist prior christian so religion means nothing to me. now Palestine should have been a state long ago. this is not an overnight thing, it's 57yrs of oppression and occupation, plus another 19yrs of prior wars and conflict... 2 things are causing all of this recent unrest... the major issue is illegal zionist settlers in the West Bank and IDF occupation... and the inability of the UN to make Jerusalem an international city as first planned before UN being expelled... it's only time until it becomes a focus due to religions clashing but only one having any power, and an army to back them even if they are wrong or doing wrong. should've been a UN occupied city with soldiers from all UN countries protecting all citizens as planned... Jerusalem means a lot to many not just a chosen few.
Fatima was voted as a Labor politician, she should be replaced by another Labor politician. Or have another election for that electorate. Let the people decide who they want representing them. Do the want Fatima as an independent/ possible The Muslim vote or do they want a Labor politician who will serve all Australians.
Asked an Israeli reservist who was on duty October 07 what he thinks of Palestinians now… three words I don’t care What the western worker fail to understand is…. This is a war between Palestinians and Israel It’s a Middle East conflict which has no place here in Australia My money is on the biggest gorilla in the room😮
@@raclark2730 they help & support all those countries with our security not to mention all the contributions to technology , medicine etc etc.... What has so called Palistine ever given to the world apart from refugees & terr0r organisations?
you people don't even know the history of unrest in the creation of israel. best to read up on your so called allies and what they have done to the brits and yanks... google jewish insurgency in mandatory palestine... i dont want any ally like that... meanwhile do you back the creation of illegal israeli settlements in West Bank?.. well that's what most of this conflict is about and the reason Gaza went to war.
The only reason people like Fatima want to get into Parliament is to further their own causes and beliefs,,,it has happened in other countries if you are in the Australian parliament you represent the Australian people and our values,,,,,end of story 🇦🇺
If these people are so concerned about what is happening in Gaza they should pack up their banners and go and demonstrate over there. See how they go. Politicians are elected to represent people in Australia not people in other countries, it's an abuse of taxpayers money. Payman does not represent Australian citizens and should not be parliament.
Yes, I noticed that. "When the bell tolls it tolls for all of us.." but the bells tolled for Israel... those that were killed on the day and those who are still in captivity... but hello, our pm and his wong give money and support Unwra who in turn support hamas. So when did the bells toll for Israel. only in lip service but in reality, if elbow didn't throw out and sack payman , he supported her. you cannot have both views.
I wouldn’t have a go at anyone if I were you bill, you have much to answer for a the ndis. You failed miserably as opposition leader what’s changed ? Not much
He didnt overreact and he didnt underreact, in other words, he did sweet f.a. cmon bill, that statement means nothing. He should have sacked payman. Shes toxic and divisive. Pure dei pick.
Albo treated Payman with privilage. A protected Maoist figure to be used as a socialist pawn, and in doing so, invited an extreme terrorist trojan horse onto the shores of Australia.
Bill puting emphasis on the consumer instead of regulating NDIS providers. You need a whelchair for the cost of $10000 but providers will charge the skim 20000. Please stamp out providers not consumers!! If what you are saying only 1 or2 have an issue, it was for the cost of millions?
She is a duel citizen . She never should have been put up as a candidate, Now labor will just be known as the party of the duel citizen Muslims and not the party for the rest of us
This business of changing teams mid-stream without a consequence is so wrong! Parliament, pass legislation that ends this practice. Make it impossible to remain in Parliament and make it mandatory to hold a bye-election.
What happened to the recent few tens of boats with 100s of Afghans and Pakistanis who landed in Western Australia? Who was behind in bringing the boats? NO news of them or what's going on? Was it a political trojan horse to bring down democracy with an imported vote bank for election and power?? Was it to build religious political power for one community and suppress\hate all others? Who is running the show of immigration and migration and
I suppose the important thing that everyone misses here is what do the people who voted her in think. Its not up to the labour party to tell her to quit.
There was actually a lot that Albanese could have done. Firstly, recognise Palestine as a State as 145 other countries in the UN have. Until Australia does this, a two state solution is unachievable.
Shorten sounds like he is returning to be reasonable after years as leader reading crass scripts wiith teams if nodders. Good to see but WTF is going on?
It was a terrible betrayal and backstabbing to Albo and labor she knew what she was doing probably planned it right from the beginning, very lucrative for her money wise. .
Immigration is one thing but culture change is quite another. Imagine yourself in a busy public place when someone shouts "hallelujah", how would you react? Now imagine the same place when someone shouts "all-u-ahkbar", would you react differently?
perfect example of biasm in media. when scomo was bouncing around like a loon at hillsong the ABC jumped on it and now with this individual sky is going for it. This host also fails to mention that the radicalisation of religion is directly correlated with generational oppression, poverty, wars etc. How do you think devout Christians who live in a texan trailerparks would go if they were faced with similar living conditions for generations incl war, misery and poverty as we see in for example Palastine atm. I can guarentee they would hijack their belief system in a similar fashion and cause the same pain and misery.
I can't say I've ever been a big fan of Bill Shorten, but in this interview he comes across as well grounded and informed. Makes Joe Biden look like a stage-managed puppet.
It's not a sustainable proposition? what about using human bodies as s. toys and promoting commodified grape? that's ok? That was a disappointing answer from labor.
Poor Bill Shorten..He really needs a script writer to help him with everything and that script writer will need to be very creative with sanctimonious babbling, in an attempt, to making Bil look like he's a patriarch of caring and understanding.. Billy back stabber..
The radicals can never be reasoned with. Stop trying to bend over backwards for these muslims . Fatima showed her true colours
Exactly!! Do not touch the cancer, if you want to be healthy ❤
Bill won't criticise Albo or the Labor party or he might be suspended,,, Fatima should be kicked out of Parliament,,,
There are thousands of white christian non-racist Aussies protesting for the genocide in Gaza. Are they bending backwards for Muslims too?
She is the foot that gets them in the door.
deport the lot of them to Palestine
A. Understanding section 44 - "Foreign citizens and dual citizens cannot sit in Parliament'. She must be disqualified.
If that is the LAW, how the fk is she even there in the first place?
You are ill-informed. Racist, Islamophobic & against women! Labor check every before giving Ticket.Same Western Colonial Criminals who illegally Blamed & Bombed Afghanistan & killed millions of innocent Civilians, CREATED Taliban to Defeat USSR & Now after looting everything Holding Billions of Afghanistan Funds so They can't run Afghanistan & because of that reason. PAYMANA application of surrendering citizenship simply Cant be processed! Well Deport her then You All convinced Criminals came here, Killed Almost All Aboriginals should Also be Deported back to UK, EUROPE, USA or Wherever you all Racist Criminals came from
Democracy is under threat in Australia, no Islam in Australian politics period!
Totally agree they can keep their hate and religion to themselves in their own countries not here,,🇦🇺
Wherever Islam goes, bad times are sure to follow. 💯
and she wants to make Hijabs normal fashion item_BS
Its Labors money that helped her campaign and she only got in because of Labors preference as she got in with only 1600 votes. I would like her citizenship investigated.
SEND HER TO HELL!!!!
Sounds like you're talking about Lambie.
No he didn't. She broke the rules she knew about when she joined the party and he should have sacked her immediately.
She came here for a peaceful life, and now causing trouble in the country that welcomed her, why doesn’t she go to Palestine and help the people she talks about,
I am sure that for the majority of Australians..this woman should simply just not be in the Parliament...she should never have been able to be elected...she stands with the Taliban!
Her family fled from the Taliban when she was a baby, ignoramus!!!
She should know that she is getting paid by taxpayers and her responsibilities are for Australia and Australians not for particular race, religion or colour.
The government has let this things to happening not only in Australia but around the world.
100% nailed it!
@@Gusto0172 Their loyalty will always and ultimately be for and with Islam. This will always be their bottom line. People please... THINK!!!
No, she owes us all every cent she got. Her unlawful inclusion was labour cheating and flaunting the laws and rules. Section 44. Dual citizens are ineligable to sit and they knew this.
@@lucasroe2878 Well said! 👍🏻💯
Oh dear, how sad... Incidentally, if you are a member of government e.g., a Senator - you should NOT have dual citizenship. When entering office your LOYALTIES SHOULD BE CHRYSTALLISED... you cannot serve 2 loyalties at that level of citizenship... you represented Aussies and that is the point.
Hence why we have it in our constitution mate.
she will not be loyal but to Islam and the Shariah just learn ,
@@Whoisthis1111 Thanks... mate... then lets make it reality before they can even stand for such an Office... mate
@@hariseldon3786 it is though. It’s why we had those issues regarding legality of our elected MPs in the 2017-18 period. They’re now vetted before they’re allowed to stand up. Fatima Payman’s case is one I am unfamiliar with, but from my understanding, the issues around legality were drawn due to her circumstances (she was a refugee).
@@ibtisamhtewek3407 yep. Unfortunately that’s where it looks like she’s going.
They are so weak 😮
Other politicians who have crossed the floor and changed parties over the years haven't called out for the abolishion of Jews by using the phrase from the river to the sea Palestinian will be free. No comparison Shorten.
As their numbers grow, so too will the problem.
I agree.
That has been the case across the world , Muslims equate to Trouble
Shorten, has taken 2 years to attempt to bring the NDIS under control,
You get it 👍
Start of a hostile takeover
Fatima made Albo look incompetent and that's the last thing Albo government needed.
It made Albo look weak, ineffectual and beholden to the Muslim vote.
Bill looks like he has had a hard night
Payman has dual citizenship and as such should not be in parliament there should be no conditions around it no matter who you are
Yes, something looks off with him, or maybe he doesn’t want to be there.
Caused trouble in Afganistan and now create chaos in Australia
... wherever they go, bad times soon follow.
Slippery Shorten is a Great Example Of Labor, accepting Anybody into the Party for a Possible Vote !
The biggest culprits of NDIS are by the registered providers who are abusing the system, charging the highest rates for care services. The registered providers must be investigated
Young disabled girl on the NDIS has the NDIS paying for her mums lawn mowing, gardening and they also have a home paid by NDIS.
So much wasted money.
We need a better government! Yes we do, one that will reverse middle eastern immigration policy.
Reverse Muslims.. not middle easteners..
no, we need a govt with enough guts to make Bill Of Rights that encompasses not only a citizens right, but what is expected of a person as an Australian citizen... that will sort all of them out, not just middle eastern component... and they all said Pauline was racist. well she could do a far better job than the current fools on both sides.
@@AVportau great ideas, but we have a constitution and QLD has a bill of rights, that are set aside when the government sees fit to do so. This is an invasion of the western world by the Muslim/islamic ideology and that has no place in any level of Australian government. Australia is at the doorway of defeat and we are still debating and being divided over a chalk and cheese situation. If we could only get Pauline, babet and other top class Aussies in to power problems would be solved. We would agree on that, but I think our only other hope is Trump24. He won’t put up with this pro Muslim interference in what should be his no 1 ally.
@@chrisb3248 USA gives huge aid to it's No.1 ally and it isn't us. we are just puppets of convenience. this is just a political farce to get people to accept domination over truth and fairness.... the greens who voted to recognise Palestine weren't muslims, or even if one or 2 may be it's not the issue and politics would rather attack the person than debate or fix the issue. i'm white atheist prior christian so religion means nothing to me.
now Palestine should have been a state long ago. this is not an overnight thing, it's 57yrs of oppression and occupation, plus another 19yrs of prior wars and conflict... 2 things are causing all of this recent unrest... the major issue is illegal zionist settlers in the West Bank and IDF occupation... and the inability of the UN to make Jerusalem an international city as first planned before UN being expelled... it's only time until it becomes a focus due to religions clashing but only one having any power, and an army to back them even if they are wrong or doing wrong. should've been a UN occupied city with soldiers from all UN countries protecting all citizens as planned... Jerusalem means a lot to many not just a chosen few.
Poor old Bill! Non committal on everything! 😂😂😂
This woman should not be on parliament in this country!
Gaza has a few job opportunities for her
Fatima was voted as a Labor politician, she should be replaced by another Labor politician. Or have another election for that electorate. Let the people decide who they want representing them. Do the want Fatima as an independent/ possible The Muslim vote or do they want a Labor politician who will serve all Australians.
"PETER DUTTON for PM "
hell no... all of them are imbeciles... maybe it's time for Pauline. can't be worse than the sniveling bunch of back patters in the major parties.
Hahah delusional Australian politician thinking they know what’s best for Israel.
Asked an Israeli reservist who was on duty October 07 what he thinks of Palestinians now… three words
I don’t care
What the western worker fail to understand is….
This is a war between Palestinians and Israel
It’s a Middle East conflict which has no place here in Australia
My money is on the biggest gorilla in the room😮
Why aren't we working with our Ally in the middle east, Israel?
When has Israel ever sent troops to support Australian, US or UK forces. I can't recall, seems like rather a one sided alliance.
@@raclark2730 they help & support all those countries with our security not to mention all the contributions to technology , medicine etc etc....
What has so called Palistine ever given to the world apart from refugees & terr0r organisations?
@@DisgustedAussie No boots or blood shed on the ground with the brothers and sisters though. Not once.
you people don't even know the history of unrest in the creation of israel. best to read up on your so called allies and what they have done to the brits and yanks... google jewish insurgency in mandatory palestine... i dont want any ally like that... meanwhile do you back the creation of illegal israeli settlements in West Bank?.. well that's what most of this conflict is about and the reason Gaza went to war.
The only reason people like Fatima want to get into Parliament is to further their own causes and beliefs,,,it has happened in other countries if you are in the Australian parliament you represent the Australian people and our values,,,,,end of story 🇦🇺
People full of hate always end up in parties that are full of hate! So nothing new here.
If these people are so concerned about what is happening in Gaza they should pack up their banners and go and demonstrate over there. See how they go. Politicians are elected to represent people in Australia not people in other countries, it's an abuse of taxpayers money. Payman does not represent Australian citizens and should not be parliament.
Al-pinocchio tried the best way possible to handle Payman all right by doing what he does all the time, nothing 👍✅
Big speech on Ukraine but nothing for Israel?????
Yes, I noticed that. "When the bell tolls it tolls for all of us.." but the bells tolled for Israel... those that were killed on the day and those who are still in captivity... but hello, our pm and his wong give money and support Unwra who in turn support hamas.
So when did the bells toll for Israel. only in lip service but in reality, if elbow didn't throw out and sack payman , he supported her. you cannot have both views.
I wouldn’t have a go at anyone if I were you bill, you have much to answer for a the ndis. You failed miserably as opposition leader what’s changed ? Not much
The NDIS must be shut down.
He didnt overreact and he didnt underreact, in other words, he did sweet f.a. cmon bill, that statement means nothing. He should have sacked payman. Shes toxic and divisive. Pure dei pick.
❤❤ devillll in hijabbb ❤❤
Albo treated Payman with privilage. A protected Maoist figure to be used as a socialist pawn, and in doing so, invited an extreme terrorist trojan horse onto the shores of Australia.
Payman should not be in government as a dual citizenship holder. She has proven to which country she belongs and it's not Australia.
Bill puting emphasis on the consumer instead of regulating NDIS providers. You need a whelchair for the cost of $10000 but providers will charge the skim 20000. Please stamp out providers not consumers!! If what you are saying only 1 or2 have an issue, it was for the cost of millions?
Australia needs to talk to their masters in Beijing before deciding what steps to take
Handling snakes can be difficult, even pythons will bite .
Omg! Is this bloke serious
BS on the job for over 2 years with NDIS, the results. ???????
"When the bell tolls, it tolls for thee!" For F%#$ sake.
Yes , Bill not worth a tray. Always going to agree with Labors deplorable decisions
That she even got in... wtf. What-the-actual...
She is a duel citizen . She never should have been put up as a candidate, Now labor will just be known as the party of the duel citizen Muslims and not the party for the rest of us
Simply cannot be trusted....
Can't waste a billion dollars in this cost-of-living crisis, was that a dig at Albo and The Voice?
Can't they just fire that crazy lady? Not sure how your government works in that respect.
We have to get Pauline in now.
The government so weak..😢
Never mind Fatima, even worse is Mehreen Faruqi, she was a disgrace when Spiersey interviewed her on Insiders. In fact so un Australian.
Can Bill Shorten give any clear answers, it is obvious he is not very forthcoming.
Bill the union boy
That was the most down to earth interview with Bill that I can recall!
Albo could'nt handle a pissup in a brewery.
This business of changing teams mid-stream without a consequence is so wrong!
Parliament, pass legislation that ends this practice.
Make it impossible to remain in Parliament and make it mandatory to hold a bye-election.
Payman graduated from the Australian ISLAMIC COLLAGE in Perth. That says it all .
Review Muslims citizenship in Australia amd Migration application from Muslim countries.
Is Bill Drunk?
People of faith should not be in parliament
What happened to the recent few tens of boats with 100s of Afghans and Pakistanis who landed in Western Australia? Who was behind in bringing the boats? NO news of them or what's going on? Was it a political trojan horse to bring down democracy with an imported vote bank for election and power?? Was it to build religious political power for one community and suppress\hate all others? Who is running the show of immigration and migration and
I suppose the important thing that everyone misses here is what do the people who voted her in think.
Its not up to the labour party to tell her to quit.
Yes it is .....
Only 1600 votes shes totally irrelevant
@@Le_coq_sportiff Well I'm sure they crunched the numbers before suspending her, they always do.
@@Shayne-l5l Well it's not the only person the labour party can get rid of is the Prime Minister in fact.
Islam is like Rust it never sleep 😴 💤 so Remove it 😊
God bless her.
Bill really should have been the PM instead of Albo no comparison really.
Give up on this Payman issue SKY, it is over. She is a decent woman who will vote with Labor anyway.
Religion should be kept out of politics so how many of these politicians are jewish?
Happy JULY
Put a Muslim in parliament n it's at ur peril
Australia has sacrificed the most young in past wars. We need them to build our home.
There was actually a lot that Albanese could have done. Firstly, recognise Palestine as a State as 145 other countries in the UN have. Until Australia does this, a two state solution is unachievable.
The muslim community.... No, the Australian community, get Australian already!
She will be the next prime minister!
Legal professional Murphy. That guy.
It's sad all round.
Shorten sounds like he is returning to be reasonable after years as leader reading crass scripts wiith teams if nodders. Good to see but WTF is going on?
It was a terrible betrayal and backstabbing to Albo and labor she knew what she was doing probably planned it right from the beginning, very lucrative for her money wise. .
I'm the general if you leave office.
Fatima payman she is very brave woman .
👏👏 well done.
Immigration is one thing but culture change is quite another. Imagine yourself in a busy public place when someone shouts "hallelujah", how would you react? Now imagine the same place when someone shouts "all-u-ahkbar", would you react differently?
I'm so confused.
Don't take advise for Murphy. His dodgy
Best way albo knows how is nothing like a competent way.
You’re full of shorten, bill!!
I do miss the White Australia Policy😊
perfect example of biasm in media. when scomo was bouncing around like a loon at hillsong the ABC jumped on it and now with this individual sky is going for it. This host also fails to mention that the radicalisation of religion is directly correlated with generational oppression, poverty, wars etc. How do you think devout Christians who live in a texan trailerparks would go if they were faced with similar living conditions for generations incl war, misery and poverty as we see in for example Palastine atm. I can guarentee they would hijack their belief system in a similar fashion and cause the same pain and misery.
Fatima is OK. Albanese is very very very very weak.
I can't say I've ever been a big fan of Bill Shorten, but in this interview he comes across as well grounded and informed. Makes Joe Biden look like a stage-managed puppet.
Fatima Payman is just Labor political misjudgement, definitely 🇺🇸🐖❤️🤗🇦🇺💯🌎👍 2:00
NDIS should be more affordable and accssseble to all Australians, definitely 🇺🇸🐖❤️🤗🇦🇺💯🌎👍 7:06
NDIS has good intention, definitely 🇺🇸🐖❤️🤗🇦🇺💯🌎👍 10:17
Security?
Who?
That is true, but has to be more responsibility and accountability, definitely 🇺🇸🐖❤️🤗🇦🇺💯🌎👍 8:49
It's not a sustainable proposition? what about using human bodies as s. toys and promoting commodified grape? that's ok? That was a disappointing answer from labor.
Poor Bill Shorten..He really needs a script writer to help him with everything and that script writer will need to be very creative with sanctimonious babbling, in an attempt, to making Bil look like he's a patriarch of caring and understanding.. Billy back stabber..
There are tanks in Gaza?
I do disagree, definitely 🇺🇸🐖❤️🤗🇦🇺💯🌎👍 13:01
Now that payman gone are ham sandwich allowed back at ALP party functions and meeting, the salt must flow
Definately not, there are other Muslims and Chinese in our Parliament.
@user-pd7wc3xs4q aww but Chinese have sweet and sour pork with plum sauce