Kady, you nailed this song. Can't figure out why the judges didn't get it. I'm a big Heart fan I don't usually care for covers, but you totally owned this one.
I'm only 15, but I'm a huge Heart fan and Kady did really great considering that she's no Ann Wilson... I'm not saying she did bad... one of the best performances of that day She should have stayed longer!
Ann Wilson is a very unique vocalist, she has a powerful vocal suitable for those 80s rock. No one else can sing a Heart song any better than Ann herself. Not even Celine Dion, as great of a vocalist Celine was, she did no favor for the song Alone when she covered it That said, anyone who is brave enough to cover a Heart song deserve credits. The band was great too, especially the guitarist For the record, I think Kady did well. She just didnt have the vocals as deep as Ann did.
@pnroyal correction Kady cannot or did not sing this song but she can sing listen to her do Sara Mclaughlins tune "angel" then say she can't sing" & I know you are wrong.. but i understand where you are coming from
She was just a little "tense" on stage, which is understandable. Maybe perfomance wise she is a "Drunken Master" like my sister in law who is stiff doing the Hula Sober but on her Wedding day she was graceful and swooping and I was like "Wow, she got better at Hula" and someone nudged me "Look closely, she's Plastered" and surely enough her skin was flushed and she was "out of it"....lol (Best Hula she ever did though)
I think the judges had a point. She's got the amazing look, the great voice, a good personality, not too snippy or bitchy. ONLY problems are that the song was weird and not catchy and she wasn't REALLY feeling or showing the emotion of the song. It's a weird thing but it's subtle and people usually can feel the difference. Nonetheless she's like, one or two tweaks away from a superstar.
that was rough, why does she kill this tune? she is so talented she can sing.. i love this girl and i am frustrated too because w/ the right tunes she would probably win this competition..
Kady herself said she didn't get to sing the songs she originally wanted to sing, so you're the one that is off base here. You have to be in denial if you truly believe American Idol is untampered. Oh well, it's just a TV show.
JuMm... idk... this was a good performance, but I still think she should have picked other song for her voice range... Im a HUGE fan of heart myself and hearing this track in a different level its kind of odd to me... it was good though!
@myoon87 YES. She was insanely pitchy throughout and completely lacked soul. But even if it were sung perfectly, it still would have been a very poor song choice.
This wasn't a very good song for her. The singer from Heart definitely did a better job, but that's just how it works out sometimes. This girl should be more into pop songs.
She can definitely sing... but the verses were really horrible.; very pitchy and rough. Hehehe "Winter nights we sang in t-U-û-û-ne" was indeed, not in tune! hehe. Anyway, this song was just too big for her... A real shame because I liked her but based on this performance and her previous one, she really deserved to go instead of Alaina or Alexandrea...
There was a version of this on youtube that tweaked/auto-tuned her vocals....she sounded AMAZING in that version! XD
Kady, you nailed this song. Can't figure out why the judges didn't get it. I'm a big Heart fan I don't usually care for covers, but you totally owned this one.
LOVE that dress
the ending rocks
agreed 100 percent
what are they talkin about this was great!!!
i've heard the original song, once, a few months after i heard kady's version. she did great.
I'm only 15, but I'm a huge Heart fan and Kady did really great considering that she's no Ann Wilson...
I'm not saying she did bad... one of the best performances of that day
She should have stayed longer!
Ann Wilson is a very unique vocalist, she has a powerful vocal suitable for those 80s rock.
No one else can sing a Heart song any better than Ann herself. Not even Celine Dion, as great of a vocalist Celine was, she did no favor for the song Alone when she covered it
That said, anyone who is brave enough to cover a Heart song deserve credits. The band was great too, especially the guitarist
For the record, I think Kady did well. She just didnt have the vocals as deep as Ann did.
i think the problem with her was that she was not enough mature vocally and artistically when she was on AI... because she has indeed potential
Kady you should've sung the White Stripes songs like we usually do TT_TT and all the other songs from our British Invasion concert...
@pnroyal correction Kady cannot or did not sing this song but she can sing listen to her do Sara Mclaughlins tune "angel" then say she can't sing" & I know you are wrong.. but i understand where you are coming from
She's great. Its the judges who messed up.
she was amazing when she performed Groovy kind of love... I agree this song choice is weird ...
She was just a little "tense" on stage, which is understandable.
Maybe perfomance wise she is a "Drunken Master" like my sister in law who is stiff doing the Hula Sober but on her Wedding day she was graceful and swooping and I was like "Wow, she got better at Hula" and someone nudged me "Look closely, she's Plastered" and surely enough her skin was flushed and she was "out of it"....lol (Best Hula she ever did though)
I think the judges had a point. She's got the amazing look, the great voice, a good personality, not too snippy or bitchy.
ONLY problems are that the song was weird and not catchy and she wasn't REALLY feeling or showing the emotion of the song. It's a weird thing but it's subtle and people usually can feel the difference. Nonetheless she's like, one or two tweaks away from a superstar.
How is it some one in the music b. never heard that song?
that was rough, why does she kill this tune? she is so talented she can sing.. i love this girl and i am frustrated too because w/ the right tunes she would probably win this competition..
Kady herself said she didn't get to sing the songs she originally wanted to sing, so you're the one that is off base here. You have to be in denial if you truly believe American Idol is untampered. Oh well, it's just a TV show.
Yeah, she had that problem a lot throughout the competition, not just throughout this song.
I agree with the judges on this one. She didn't really nail this song as I've seen others do at karaoke no less.
who sing that song
Heart. And they are in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. :)
@Danklin24 exactly the songs were just wrong
JuMm... idk... this was a good performance, but I still think she should have picked other song for her voice range...
Im a HUGE fan of heart myself and hearing this track in a different level its kind of odd to me... it was good though!
magic man isn't opera, just a gal with a pair of lungs that rocks!!!!!!!!!!! Heart isn't opera!!
LOL.
She sounded great when she powered??? It was a decent Christina Aguilera impression, I suppose.
ok this was not better than alaina's Hopelessly Devoted
He's never heard of Magic Man? Really?
@myoon87 YES. She was insanely pitchy throughout and completely lacked soul. But even if it were sung perfectly, it still would have been a very poor song choice.
honestly, this is a singing competition and this was probably the worst song she could have chosen for herself. her only problem was song choice.
Noooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!
I bet Carly Smithson, who loves Heart, was cringing while Kady was butchering the song.
This wasn't a very good song for her. The singer from Heart definitely did a better job, but that's just how it works out sometimes. This girl should be more into pop songs.
Wrong song
the song had no melody or rythm
She had heaps of potential :/ Bad song choices.
She can definitely sing... but the verses were really horrible.; very pitchy and rough. Hehehe "Winter nights we sang in t-U-û-û-ne" was indeed, not in tune! hehe. Anyway, this song was just too big for her... A real shame because I liked her but based on this performance and her previous one, she really deserved to go instead of Alaina or Alexandrea...
Good singer. Wrong song for her. Stick with pop ballads
robbed
the band is no heart they sucked, sounded like a bar band..
The band stinks ( good guitar solo only) .
this sucked, lol