Sahir Ludhianvi-Good Evening India dt 27 10 2016- Shiv Chaturvedi

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @SudhaParekh-c2o
    @SudhaParekh-c2o Рік тому +2

    Very good presentation. There is only one Sahir in the world. Sudha Parekh from New Uork

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  6 місяців тому

      Thanks friend for liking🌹

  • @RajiTripathi
    @RajiTripathi 3 роки тому +6

    Sahir had a unique talent to beautifully express the depths of human emotions... love, passion, betrayal, unrequited love and pathos. His pen equally passionately revolted with the inequality, inequity and injustice in the society... and exoplition and suffering of common men and women. There was no greater writer who became populr, after having attained enormous success in the world of literature, abd whose songs written for the Silver Screen, with their simplicity, reality and genuineness touched the hearts of millions.
    Sahir indoubtedly will forever remain the uncontested "People's Poet." 🙏

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  6 місяців тому

      You are very much right!! Thanks for the comments 🙏🌹

  • @amaldomohan5052
    @amaldomohan5052 2 роки тому +4

    जब गीत और संगीत बात आती है, तो केवल एक ही जोड़ी है - "साहिर रोशन" - जिसने हर गाने को आठ चाँद लगा दिया।
    जब जब भी भजनों की बात करते हैं, तो आम आदमी उन्हें भगवान से जोड़ते हैं , जैसे राम-सीता, राधा-कृष्ण आदि, लेकिन हम में से कुछ ऐसे हैं जो फिल्म बहू बेगम के गीत को भी भजन मानते हैं: अर्ज़-ए-शौख आंखें में है, अर्ज़- ए वफ़ा आँखों में है, तेरे आगे बात कहने का मज़ा आँखों में है, और वक़िफ़ हूं ख़ूब इश्क के तर्ज़-ए-बया से मैं , कह दूंगा दिल की बात नज़र की जुबान से मैं । यह साहिर रोशन द्वारा रचित एक भक्ति गीत के रूप में एक मस्जिद में गाया गया था । मां सरस्वती के इकलौते धन्य जुड़वा हैं साहिर रोशन।

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  6 місяців тому

      शुक्रिया जी आपके कमेंट्स के लिए जो कि एकदम सटीक हैं🙏

  • @skepsib4490
    @skepsib4490 6 місяців тому +1

    This is the loveliest tribute to Sahir Ive heard - SC and his guests have truly understood the depth and width of Sahir’s social, emotional commitment to some of the best human qualities.🙏🙏🙏

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  6 місяців тому

      Thanks for liking and appreciating 🙏🌹

  • @rajkalsi8611
    @rajkalsi8611 4 роки тому +5

    As you were trying to conclude this episode,you were talking about other prominent Shayers of that era,they were good and very good.The depth of expression in words of Sahir sahib on each and every subjects is beyond comprehension. More you listen and think more you start appreciating. his grasp of his knowledge of this world .Sahir,the Jadugar helps to understand many situations and guide through his wisdom.One and only Sahir sahib !
    Raj

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      You are very much right Raj Kalsi ji.Thanks

  • @nitaarya3863
    @nitaarya3863 4 роки тому +5

    Chehre pe khushi chha jaati hai...Is from movie Waqt not Humraaz as indicated

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      U r very much right Nita Arya ji. Anchor has wrongly mentioned it "Hamraz" before song but during detailed discussion of song it was correctly mentioned. However the error is regretted

  • @ashutoshbhondele5568
    @ashutoshbhondele5568 4 роки тому +4

    Guest are very knowledgeable and informative 🖤🖤🖤

  • @surinderkumar-sf2pu
    @surinderkumar-sf2pu 6 років тому +8

    He was a thinker. Great poet and range of vocabulary.A revolutionary.

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  5 років тому

      You are very much right Surinder Kumar ji!!

  • @nayyarkamal6133
    @nayyarkamal6133 4 роки тому +3

    A poet of all seasons, SAHIR the inimitable.

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      Sahi kaha apne Nayyar Kamal ji!!!

  • @rajeshrajsarkar
    @rajeshrajsarkar 3 роки тому +2

    Great

  • @amritgill4345
    @amritgill4345 5 років тому +3

    Sahir was a great poet,such poets are born once in a century.look to days so called poets!,,

  • @nirmalayadav5672
    @nirmalayadav5672 3 роки тому

    Very presentation and no words for Sahirji he above all

  • @azeezanwer594
    @azeezanwer594 5 років тому +11

    SAHIR LUDHIANVI a poet beyond our imagination, our vision is too short to see the Mount Everest of poetry,a God gifted poet ever,a poet of innumerable worthy colourful thoughts, a galaxy of poetry,a continent of great feelings, a little romance, a lot of values makes SAHIR a Great eternal poet,a Genius, a Philosopher, a universal intellectual poet,a people's poet forever.

    • @sbhflavorsromania6994
      @sbhflavorsromania6994 5 років тому +2

      Words fully putup in magician way

    • @sumitshinde6291
      @sumitshinde6291 4 роки тому

      He suffer alot in his early days .his poetry shows ho great sahir sab

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  3 роки тому

      You are very much right Azeez Anwer ji!!!

  • @zafarullahkhan4887
    @zafarullahkhan4887 4 роки тому +3

    Bahot khub.

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      Thanks Zafarullah Khan ji

  • @navketan1965
    @navketan1965 7 років тому +8

    Sahir Ludhianvi was FIRST A philosopher who wrote poetry to convey his GOD GIVEN WISDOM & life experiences of his own to public.in his poetry. Every word was carefully crafted & inserted in the right context to convey true message from that great thinker for A given situation (issue facing common man).Wisdom of Aristotle--brilliance of Einstein.

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  7 років тому +4

      Ur very much right friend!!!. Every word of his poetry and song has intense meaning!!!

    • @sbhflavorsromania6994
      @sbhflavorsromania6994 5 років тому +1

      Your language is very POWERFUL

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      md Sabir Ali ji Thanks

  • @mohammadali2293
    @mohammadali2293 4 роки тому +4

    Sahir ludhianvi sahab ke likhe huye ek ek gaane hindi cinema ki dharohar hai

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      Mohammad Ali ji bilkul sahi farmaya aapne

  • @devenderkumarbahl1723
    @devenderkumarbahl1723 4 роки тому +4

    I’m listening before the portrait of Sahir in my study

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      Devender Kumar Bahl ji thanks for liking the program

  • @devenderkumarbahl1723
    @devenderkumarbahl1723 4 роки тому +4

    Besides Sahir ,presentations is also graceful ideally matching to his poetry

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      Thanks Devender Kumar Behl ji for liking!!!

  • @avneetshergill5381
    @avneetshergill5381 4 роки тому +3

    Program was good and authentic but short to describe Sahir

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      You are very much right Avneet Shergill ji!!!

  • @abidsidhu3451
    @abidsidhu3451 6 років тому +3

    Raat ye bahar ki phir kbhi naaayegiiiiiiii..great Sahir sb

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  5 років тому

      wakai Jaffar.Aziz ji!!

  • @SudhaParekh-c2o
    @SudhaParekh-c2o 10 місяців тому +1

    Great presentation. Research based

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  8 місяців тому

      Thanks!!

  • @premnath-lj7qs
    @premnath-lj7qs 3 роки тому

    Sahir Ludhianvi’s Poetry & Philosophy in Literature & Bollywood history-- “Generations to come will scarce believe that such a one as this ever in flesh and blood walked upon this earth. (said Einstein of Mahatma Gandhi)” Sahir’s poetry & wisdom would shine on this earth long after we have perished. ­ ­ ­ SAHIR= Wisdom of Aristotle+Brilliance of Einstein. ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ Sahir Ludhianvi was FIRST A PHILOSOPHER who wrote poetry to convey his GOD GIVEN WISDOM & life experiences of his own to common man for his/her welfare in his poetry. Every word was carefully crafted & inserted in the right context to convey true message from that great thinker for A given situation (issue facing common man under similar circumstances).Not even one other published poet in any language has addressed so many diverse issues facing the mortals in his/her work as Sahir has done in impeccable manner & forceful combination of words.
    Long after we (mortals) have perished, immortal poetry by SAHIR would shine on this earth with light radiated by NEXT SUN after demise of the present Sun.

  • @navketan1965
    @navketan1965 2 роки тому

    Einstein’s Quote about Mahatma Gandhi fits perfectly well about stature of Sahir Ludhianvi’s Poetry & Philosophy in Literature & Bollywood history-- “Generations to come will scarce believe that such a one as this ever in flesh and blood walked upon this earth. (said Einstein of Mahatma Gandhi)” Sahir’s poetry & wisdom would shine on this earth long after we have perished. ­ ­ SAHIR= Wisdom of Aristotle+Brilliance of Einstein. ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ Sahir Ludhianvi was FIRST A PHILOSOPHER who wrote poetry to convey his GOD GIVEN WISDOM & life experiences of his own to common man for his/her welfare in his poetry. Every word was carefully crafted & inserted in the right context to convey true message from that great thinker for A given situation (issue facing common man under similar circumstances).Not even one other published poet in any language on this earth has addressed so many diverse issues facing the mortals in his/her work as Sahir has done in impeccable manner & forceful combination of words.
    Long after we (mortals) have perished immortal poetry by SAHIR would shine on this earth with light radiated by NEXT SUN after demise of the present Sun (and that is perhaps few hundred million years from now-- and also if "MEN" do not kill each other in between all those long years & life has to start with single cell organisms once again as full circle on this earth second time around).My 2 cents from New York.

  • @VeenaSharma-ji5jc
    @VeenaSharma-ji5jc 5 років тому +3

    Beautiful program

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      Veena Sharma ji shukriya

  • @muhammadpervez4009
    @muhammadpervez4009 2 роки тому

    Sahir is matchless. he is superb. GOD BLESS HIS SOUL.

  • @rajivdatta9125
    @rajivdatta9125 3 роки тому

    He was great poet high think er,

  • @amaldomohan5052
    @amaldomohan5052 2 роки тому

    केवल एक संगीत निर्देशक, रोशन जी ने गीतकारों को अधिक महत्व दिया, क्योंकि रोशन जी बाकी लोगों से खरब (1,000000000000) मील आगे थे।

  • @abuarbab956
    @abuarbab956 5 років тому +2

    Wonderful songs

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  5 років тому

      Thanks Abu Arbab ji

  • @devenderkumarbahl1723
    @devenderkumarbahl1723 4 роки тому +2

    Excellent

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  4 роки тому

      Thanks Deveder ji for liking the program

  • @rajivdatta9125
    @rajivdatta9125 3 роки тому

    Pyassa, Sazadaa, all beautiful song,

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  2 роки тому

      Thanks Rajiv Datta ji

  • @intizaarmehdii7572
    @intizaarmehdii7572 7 років тому +2

    kia kehne hai Sahir sahib.

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  5 років тому

      Thanks Itzaar mehdii ji!!!

  • @AlanGoswami-nz9lg
    @AlanGoswami-nz9lg 4 роки тому +1

    The discussion was very nice, except there exists a very big error/ignorance; when you mention the name "SAHIR", it is mandatory to mention the name "ROSHAN", which was not done at all despite playing their best songs and qawaalis. These two divine souls are two hands of "DEVI SARASWATI" - the goddess of learning. She has a book in her right hand, and a veena in her left hand.......book symbolizes 'SAHIR" & veena symbolizes "ROSHAN". When SAHIR completes writing, ROSHAN begins. I worship this divine duo "SAHIR-ROSHAN" !!
    Now, because of this I am going to teach a fundamental requisite to these three, and say, "When you play a song, remember to mention the names of the lyricist & the music director."

    • @TejasMarathe
      @TejasMarathe 4 роки тому

      Sahir- Roshan .... well said sir. You explained it very nicely.

  • @ashokkalia3725
    @ashokkalia3725 4 роки тому +2

    SAHIR means Jadugar

  • @1101smartkooldude
    @1101smartkooldude 4 роки тому +5

    ek acha geet banta hai ek sahi team work se magar SD ki baat ghalat aur ahankaar waali ya phir shayar ko demean karne waali thee yaqeenan. pahle ek story writer ka importance hai phir director ki soch hai ke kahan gaana aana chahiye aur kaise hona chahiye phir aati hai yeh tigdi shayar, sangeetkaar aur gulukaar jab yeh paanchon milkar apna individual kaam aur collective kaam sahi karte hain toh ek acha gaana banta hai. jahan dhun important hoti hai wahin shayari bhi important hoti hai agar bol sahi nahi hain toh achi dhun bhi kisi kaam ki nahi hoti and vice versa jahan achi shayari ho dhun sahi na ho toh wo bhi kisi kaam ke nahi hote aur ispar agar gulukaar ka contribution na ho toh phir banta dhaar hojata hai aur agar yeh sab sahi perfect bhi hon agar director mess up karde ya zyada interfere karde picturization mein toh phir sab ki mehnat bekaar jayegi.

  • @jkrocks2811
    @jkrocks2811 3 роки тому +1

    Sahir Sahab is a great writer , I m great fan of him ... But today I discovered from the mouth of Anish aarohi sahab that Shailendra Sir Don't hv quality ... Sorry for this poor fellow ... Shailendra is the King Of Indian Film Lyrics Writers nd progressive thinking poets ...

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  3 роки тому

      I do agree with your observation and objected for this comment of Mr Anees after this live programme.No comparison of two great poet.Shailendra was a poet of par excellence and second to none.your concentration is appreciable dear

  • @Aryan-fj7ru
    @Aryan-fj7ru 6 років тому

    shailender is one of the best

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  6 років тому

      you are very much right Aryan Nayak ji

  • @Praveen-fi4vr
    @Praveen-fi4vr 6 років тому +2

    Kya bakwaas kr rha h ye shailendraji ke geeto ki quality km bta rha hai. #awarahu

    • @Praveen-fi4vr
      @Praveen-fi4vr 6 років тому

      Watch at 49:54

    • @shivspc
      @shivspc  6 років тому +1

      I too did not agree with this statement and told him about this. Shailendra was second to none. Both have their own supreme place. I fully agree with you Mr.Praveen. Thanks for watching closely and observing the things.

    • @kishansinghnegi1663
      @kishansinghnegi1663 4 роки тому

      @@Praveen-fi4vr KO