Why Environmentalists, Climate activists, left-leaning political parties are against Nuclear Energy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 тра 2024
- In this video, we'll learn Why Environmentalists, Climate activists, and left-leaning political parties are against Nuclear Energy.
Podcast available on:-
Spotify:- open.spotify.com/show/3uMcktM...
Google Podcast:- podcasts.google.com/search/am...
UA-cam:- / amitsenguptaaks
Instagram:- / amitsengupta01
Facebook:- / amitsengupta01
Telegram:- t.me/SenguptaAmit
Quora:- www.quora.com/profile/Amit-Se...
Koo:- www.kooapp.com/profile/amitse...
Hindi Channel
/ amitsenguptahindi
-- Geography playlist
• Geography terms and de...
-- Economy playlist
• Economics
• Indian Economy - UPSC ...
-- Current Affairs playlist
• UPSC Current Affairs v...
-- Indian history playlist
• Modern History for UPS...
-- Govt of India schemes playlist
• Government of India Sc...
-- Map based learning
• Map based learning
-- Climatology playlist
• Climatology
-- Previous year solved question paper analysis
• Solved Question Papers...
-- Environment & Ecology playlist
• Environment and Ecolog...
-- International relations playlist
• International Relation...
-- Check the other playlists of NCERT Geography videos
Class 6 - goo.gl/DDFtIF
Class 7 - goo.gl/ppPK05
Class 8 - goo.gl/OD3Gwh
Class 9 - goo.gl/AIEXxQ
Class 10 - goo.gl/inWIAR
Class 11 - goo.gl/Pn5EIE
Class 11 (Part 2) - goo.gl/X4zY9K
Class 12 - goo.gl/Kszpz5
In India, Kudankulam Nuclear Plant faced protests from Church/christian NGOs, funded by USA. Why?? Bcz KNP was with Russian support.
Whenever USA wants anything in India, they fund the NGOs.
Bruh, cite your sources, cause India does have a good system to catch foreign entity funding like this.
@@Abhinav_Nayana_Sailen PM Manmohan Singh cancelled the FCRA license of these NGO, a basic google check will show you
Exactly
💯
Christian NGOs?????????? George Soros’s NGOs along with other liberal NGOs are literally anti-Christian. The liberals literally hate Christianity and undermine it in the west.
Nuclear energy is in a way like traveling by an airplane. It is very safe, but when something happens people freak out.
True i think Air travel is like 18 times safer than driving don't know about trains though
True, which is ironic because air travel is statistically significantly safer than road travel.
Exactly
Everything is safe until there is an accident! When an accident happens with nuclear however, the consequences are extreme beyond anything with any other technology and the byproducts of normal operation are toxic radioactivity, that never goes away, accident or no accident!
@@rodkeh That's also goes for solar and wind.... Rare earth materials extraction causes immensely amount of CO2 emissions and than manufacturing solar panels or related sub system s for both solar and wind create huge co2 emissions which in return create many direct or indirect casualty over the years in a very long term period.
U can not fulfill ur power demand on just relying solar and wind because those depends on environmental factors.
These so called safe power sources takes thousands fold more life than nuclear.
And those leftist woke also create chaos on land aquisation which is the main component of solar and wind.
So where logic doesn't work there these woke comes...
In India, more Fast Breeder Reactors must come, it will built plutonium239 reserves for Security also used in third stage with Th233 for mass adoption of Thorium reactors 🇮🇳🙏
thenk you sarrr🙏
They're against nuclear power because choosing to be a clown isn't just a societal stance, it can also be scientific.
This era needs Engineers and Innovators to mitigate future risk to humanity and not these stup!d clowns who dont know what affects and doesn't affect climate change.
But when this same power plant would set up in Gujarat all south India would start crying
They're scared of something they don't fully understand
You're ignorant of the science and the facts, so you are easily led and easily conned by the swindlers and crooks trying to get their hands in your pockets. You are the ones who don't understand...
Lefties and Librandus are dogs of Chernobyl and Fukushima nuclear disasters
Oh they understand it very well
@@studentwon1168 They haven't a clue!
@@studentwon1168 don't have any clue, They still believe atom as plum pudding model, let alone nuclear energy 😂
Nuclear power is the cleanest source of energy, so long as safety measures are in place and are not compromised for the sake of profit. It is a matter of regret that there is such a strong uninformed public opinion against it.
Please make a video about Thorium as a source of nuclear energy. Most people know very little about it.
these same groups have stalled the Jaitapur nuclear project in Maharashtra, once completed it would be the largest in the entire country and yet people say we live in a dictatorship
Time to empty the mind from all concepts, ideologies and Knowledge. I think it boosts movement of thoughts and make mind exhausted. Thankyou
Elaborate
Amit sengupta what's a personality man thanku so much sir ❤
Perfect brainstorming to woke's. Thanks Amit ji.
Anyone saying pro roof-top solar and building international alliances have no idea of indian power grid. Indian distribution systems are not equipped with two way transmissions. This requires a complete overhauling of distribution systems and will become pain in the a** for any government. So nuclear is one of the safest option in dealing with emissions.
Agreed. There is threat from everything that we do to harness energy but that doesn't mean we stop progressing. There was incredible threat to our lives when ancestors used to live in caves having no special feature like nails, tooths or speed that other creatures had. That didn't stop us from progressing. Threat is in everything we do but one needs to adapt to it and move forward than running away from it.
You should have as many nuclear plants as possible close to you... We'll stick to coal and feed the environment while we make cheep abundant and dependable and safe energy, for ourselves...
you should live near a coal mine@@rodkeh
You should live near a Uranium mine...@@adolft_official
@@rodkeh only privilaged people can say that. More people are dying of bad climate policies then there are because of actual climate change in America. You should try to find solutions for cheaper low pollution alternatives for energy generation and stop crying about everything. Change the victim mindset. Develop problem solver mindset.
@@s-qc9ns You're just a shill for big business. Do you get a cut if the people get swindled? Coal is not low pollution, with modern coal burners, coal is NO pollution! And coal is the most inexpensive to install and maintain and is best for the environment. Coal has no down side...
In long run, We have to fix the issue of Tamil Nadu, Kerala, WB state govt issue.... because they feel insecure when it comes to development, betterment of nation....they are imposing serious nation security issue by talking like they're separate nation from India..... They always act like indifferent 😐 when we talk constructive development...Jai hind from overseas....🇮🇳🧘♂️🙏🌍
Bro I am from Kerala and I am telling u if this govt dont change my state is going for a financial collapse. All the ministers here do with money provided by centre is pay govt workers, officers and the rest is licked up by ministers in the name of development project(not many have completed and the completed ones are plagued with corruption). Once in forefront of innovation is now shithole. Young Keralites are leaving the country in high numbers.. We f*cked up big time.
Stop your nonsense. Why are ppl flocking to these states for jobs if they are not contributing to the betterment of the nation. If you are that much concerned why don't you have the plants right next door to your home?
See firstly politics dominates this developmental discourse. These stars and centre have different pol parties so coop federalism scope is less here.
You are right to some extent though these are a lot of examples where we can clearly see the tussle between these states and centre which might be also due to regional and national developmental agenda mismatch.
@@kumar.193 TN maybe have jobs but it's totally a different scenario in WB...
And why don't u have the plant to your next door its an stupid statement
@abhimanyunath2001 All the people who are commenting here will run away if the plant comes up in their own locality. Simple fact. This gets politized further be it left/right. Who was protesting against Rawatbhata plant?
Thank you, Amit
Sir ji always gives a different perceptive, helps us think beyond the present scenario...
Commendable 🙏
Nuclear Power plant is quite good in generating energy but a disaster management system should be developed before invest activities in this field
Plz make regular video......this channel has immense potential.....the way things are explained.....with spiritual touch ......no one could explain in such a way......plz make videos whenever necessary.
I know creator Amit sir prefers quality over quantity.
Very well explained.
Thank you sir
Thankyou for making it sir❤
Leftist ki what lga di sir ne
Activist always against authority and national interest
Not all activist are stupid, but climate activist in the west are. They dont want to find solutions ,they just protest for the sake of doing it.
Jai guru great master antarik pranam salute your courage you the great 🙏🏽🎉👍🏽👌🏽
Thanks a lot for your respect and jai guru and good night sweet dreams have a dinner time god bless you always boss 👍🏽👌🏽🎉🙏🏽
@@shakuntalasonar1683😂😂
@@morgandroid2030 thanks a lot for your respect and jai guru ji and good evening have a tea time 🙏🏽👍🏽👌🏽🎉
@@shakuntalasonar1683 okayy Sonar ji....you too have a great time with yourself...Day and night enjoy the shining light...may your future be bright like a Dj night. Good night Sleep tight don't let mosquitoes bite on your pokkr side ❌🦟❌
@@morgandroid2030 thanks a lot for your respect and jai guru and same to you boss you the great boss God bless you always 🙏🏽👍🏽👌🏽🎉
Amit is love 🎉😂
Thank you Sir 🥰
Really good explanation ❤
Valuable Info 🙏
Thank you
🎉
PPP Model seems to be the most balanced and moderately efficient way for execution of projects
But not in the case of nuclear installation.......every energy source can be privatize but not nuclear....private entity are not answerable in the world forum...its the government and country....private entities are not white washed infact they have more nexus, corruption and quid quo pro.......think what if the CIA bribe the magement to reduce the flow deutorium and hard water in the reactor....they will do and another Chernobyl will happen.....(miscarriage of union Carbide)
Really seeing these agitation one feels these people are really Andolan Jeevi .😊
Sir, please do a video on every political group manifesto so that we could able to determine which group have matching thought and whichever to be good at centre like pose and cons of every political parties
Ohh finally the videoo...
It'll be worth than winning an Oscar
.❤❤❤
can you make a video on kerala financial crisis on why it is happening
NPCIL is psu but govt of India has 100 percentage ownership of NPCIL.
NTPC se itna dhuaa niklta h fir logo ko chinta nhi h or NPCIL se bilkul bhi dhua nhi niklata h sath me hi we are working on 3 stage nuclear energy plan fir to waste bhi 0 ho jayega almost
Good video bro
When you argue that there should be public private partnership in nuclear power then let me tell you Indian civilian nuclear power sector is run by PSUs and they’re well aware about the risks and their safety practices are top notch. To the extent you can call them “paranoid” about safety. The private sector is driven by profits and their propensity to cut corners and susceptibility against global powers to stand up firmly seem to be the challenges in this politically sensitive sector.
Sir , We would like you to take doubt clearing sessions for boards especially grade 12 Geography. The statistics are confusing . Many answers in each guide/study link differ. For eg State with highest urban population according to 2011 census...student is left in doubt ..
Sir please make video regularly
Nuclear energy is the only clean baseload energy source. Not deploying it the biggest disservice to the environment. India needs at least 100GW .
Sir do some polity and economy current and static thing.
Pllzz start any new series.
Please do daily one video
Trust the engineers they can make the nuclear power more safer. Diversification in energy with Nuclear being a part is the way to go.
Please upload more videos, we miss your content and perspective!
Correct
They protest for the sake of protesting.
A slight point of correction. The Australian liberal party is actually the party on the right (I know, it can be confusing). But they are going by the old perspective of a liberal, which was free market, free people, free society. These days people can say that they are more centrist these days, but that's a story for another day.
That is easy. They all have brains governed by emotions rather than facts.
Make video on Ladakh issue.🙏
Handling nuclear power is very risky and hard. If we can tackle that there's nothing better than it.
Yes, we should invest and research on that, so that the risk should be minimised and it should be away from human settlements.
We must go for Thorium based ones
Electoral bond? 😢
Plzzz do. Geography and environment current 2023 for prelims 2024
Christan NGO, comminist,
Free Bharat
Nuclear Power is extremely important if we want to control worldwide emissions. It is a clean and super efficient, long-term energy solution which has a bright future for India, and is definitely closely linked to our economic progress.
With new innovations like the small sized factory-made reactors, its future is ever brighter.
Jai Hind! 💪🏼🇮🇳
Like for Amit sir ❤
Sir please can you make video on going Ladakh Anshan😊🙏 your videos cover all required perspective...so wanted your view on Ladalh issue❤😊
Good morning sir,itne dino se kahan the
We need more power plants.
This for me is the litmus test. Anybody who understands basic physics and understand energy requirements knows that renewables won't cut it. No matter how you look at it going nuclear is our best option. When you see climate activists protesting nuclear energy that's your answer to what they really care about
🎉🎉🎉
Hi
Sir good evening
They are anti development/progress in India or anti India.
I was engrossed in his explanation and suddenly it came to an end. ☹️
The Simpsons. That show set nuclear power back more than 3 mile island, chernobyl, and Fukashima comboned
❤
Its ok sir... you can call them gawar👍
I'm a left leaning guy, environmentalist, climate activist. We buy our electricity from a nuclear power plant. Ands that's a good thing
I really hope we develop Thorium reactors.
The US and China have built them.
💕💕💕💕
aka "Aandola-jivis"
Very well explained
So many projects of national importance are plaguing with the hindrances caused by so called environmentalists
Sir please make video on electoral bond
he doesnt have a spine to do that !
@@laxmib5885 do you have brain issue
Chornobyl happened because of negligence of safety.
The problem with renewable energy is that we make so many assumptions, starting from the "renewable" part.
Secondly, the whole thing is led by people who shouldn't be leading it. And the one who's controlling the narrative has their own agenda as always.
Very apt analysis
That's very easy question. They are against everything, even against themselves!
w8ted so long for dopamine.....
Timw to build N power plants in North and central India
No way to achieve net zero without nuclear power.
Efficiency of solar power panel is only 12 percent.(poor consumption to cost ratio)
If Fusion creates a breakthrough, it would be human milestone on mankind. For fusion it requires fission anyways.
Both hate development and prosperity because it is detrimental for their politics
Yet in Europe they provoke a nuclear war…
Today nuclear power is as safe as car drive.
In bengal left shoot down the project by spreading rumours amongst poor farmers.
True. These pseudos environmentalists need to wake up and smell the coffee.
In Tamil Nadu, we are not against the nuclear power plant, we are against the method that we use in Kalpakkam, which was no where there in the world 🤦
Don't use electricity ,,save all things ,, Stop factory stop all things ,,
that is called as innovation, that is called as leading a race by margin.
Also stop using UPI , it is not used anywhere in the world !
we expect better from highly educated Tamil society, and be you are just a misfit.
But they ARE the establishment.
Nuclear energy is clean and green energy
Why can't Modi built a new Nuclear Power plant in Gujarat??
Guj has
Sick ,,, already there is ,,,
Hazardous radioactive elements belong in the soil, not above ground where all it takes is one earthquake, flood or war to create a huge disaster.
Locations are chosen specifically to accommodate for that.
This isnt a coal plant that you could choose any tom dick and harry location on the ground to place a nuclear plant.
We can and have improved the safety by leaps and bounds. This is quite clean and spillage is quite impossible to think of in today's time. Waste disposal or reuse might be an issue but something which can be solved. Stop living in the 70s and 90s
If they come up with an idea where the amount of energy that they waste in protest and raising slogans could be converted into electricity.....then I will vote for Communist Party of India.
If we can get our hands on some German reactors rather than indigenous ones... That would better.....
We are not the best at quality control you know....
However,it would be worth mentioning that shutting down a reactor core by plunging the graphite rods quickly can shut the whole reactor down in a few milliseconds....(If i understand correctly)
And unlike, Japan, we are not in any major unstable techtonic boundary and computer controlled failsafes have come a long way since Chernobyl....
I mean,we are incorporating AI tech(some call it 4th industrial revolution) into defence and military equipment to create autonomous drones and other weapons.. Our ability to reduce human error and load has improved significantly since Chernobyl....
That doesn't negate the unlikely event of a terrorist attack or an natural calamity that may or may not happen....
With that being said,i think ,the risk is worth taking.... I mean,we really need energy security to ramp up our production and improve our national output and gdp in the process....
Then these activists and leftists should at least support small modular nuclear reactors
I think the problem is with how the plants are being setup, plus in between the activists you also have those who want to push their own agenda
We should move entirely towards solar energy and tidal energy . The way west is moving towards zero carbon emission. Yeah we don't need nuclear energy , neither in defence as there are no enemies to our india and not in power sector we need nuclear power .
Such a grim ruinable future will guarantee exorbitant electricity rates, energy rationing and massive rolling blackouts.
@@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk it's suits to a third class poor uncivilized my country like india . This is how the western Thinker think india should be so our country should be like that .
A quick info. Nuclear power generation in india increased from 17 TWh in 2005 to 35TWhr in 2014 which is now standing around 50TWhr. So saying that one party is against it and the other against is not correct. An "analyst" shouldn't be spreading propaganda. Anyone can be pro democratic and pro nuclear power. So, don't patronize indians citing some western examples.
You're half right opposition parties are opposing it not because they're against nuclear it's bcz they have nothing much to oppose and elections are coming so even if they loose on national stage they wanna secure seats in south (TN) . Ofcourse they also need support of these local ngos . So just dirty politics by opposition
@shivanshna7618 but I have seen no such protests for the past few years so you're saying opposition doesn't want to win TN in 2024? And these protests happened in 2011 to 2012 when the current "opposition" was in power and the current government in opposition. So stop crying on opposition. The current government has failed to give a major leap in nuclear energy despite no protests. May it's time for you to get your facts right.
@@sreedharreddyabbidi5374no protest 😂 are u blind . we have increased 40% and biggest investment also happened in this government tenure we even tried to get into nsg and after failing joined Hands with Russia and I said they want to atleast win in TN not that they don't want to .
We could have made more if not for stupid protest we lost lot of time bcz Andhra plant was shifted to gujrat bcz of pli and protest from local people and government. There is literally a list of protest on nuclear energy page of indian wiki
Hey I have always liked nuclear reactors despite being a leftie environmentalist. I am becoming a bit more sceptic lately because it takes so long to build and cost so much. But as a socialist I like long term investments, as long as I (as in the state/nation) get to own and run them. The market will never build them, its not profitable today. It could be if we take the long term and invest a lot but thats for governments and nations to do, not private companies, they are just there to reap the benefits.
I guess if we give the capitalists the capital and take on the risks by guarantees so that all the capitalists needs to do is reap the profit then they might build them.... yeah good deal for the tax payer that one hehe.
Mumbai and Chennai industries are working due to nuclear power
Nuclear power share is less ,,still 50 % coal power use in India ,, yes nuclear power is clean energy
@@Balamua_banaras_wala You mean to say industries within 50 kms of the nuclear power plant are also supplied electricity from coal plants from far places.
@@_GMP_ coal solar hydro gas thermal wind nuclear sab power mix hota hai ,, Sam mix hota hai ,,koi ek kam na kare to city nahi rukna chahiye ,, grid system mein sab mix hai ..bharat 50% coal se thermal power use karta hai ..
The people opposing Nuclear energy dont know how climate change works. These people should stop their victim mindset. They should develop entrepreneurial/Innovator mindset. Try to find cheaper sustainable means for producing energy rather than super gluing their hands to roads and Vegetable oil tankers😄.
Those who protest against non renewable energy, should not get any energy, Let them make their own energy.
then they would release atom isn't plum pudding😂
But what about the nuclear waste??
You should see the waste created by wind and solar.
@@SkyForgeVideos exactly 🤦♂️
People have found ways to deal with these things. But wind energy on the other hand, you can just see its useful life. Especially the offshore ones, then compare the wastes.
We have at least four ways of dealing with nuclear waste, and no one in world history has ever been harmed by stored nuclear waste.
@@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk the funny part is we havent been able to deal with scrap from renewables.
No forget that, we aren't even dealing eith e waste here properly.
@@SkyForgeVideosAnswer the question, what about nuclear waste?
@mrmeow2297 Just like safety, waste/reuse of fuel can solved but we'll have to wait and see.
Bro... let's say you should listen to scientists over activists, but the funding scientists is going down in modiji s India.
Good Point. Instead of protesting against NPPlant , They should protest about low fundings, That will definitely have good impact on our society.
Bro saw some woke shit here and there and whole left spectrum became a disease for him 😂. Sirji kindly pull your focus back to geopolitics or geography.