Inside China's 'thought transformation' camps - BBC News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 чер 2019
- The BBC has been given rare access to the vast system of highly secure facilities thought to be holding more than a million Muslims in China’s western region of Xinjiang.
Authorities there insist they are just training schools. But the BBC’s visit uncovers important evidence about the nature of the system and the conditions for the people inside it.
The BBC's China Correspondent John Sudworth sent this report.
Please subscribe HERE bit.ly/1rbfUog
"Is it your choice to be here?"
"Yes, a policeman told me to sign up."
@Juke Chinese, you have to do whatever you want in your own land China, Eastern Turkistan aka Xinjiang is Uighur land invaded by Chinese in 1949.
Tibet invaded too.
Chinese must go home to China.
We are tired of endless Chinese immigration, just like Eu tired of arabs, go home Chinese.
That was A Lie, I am very sure the Policeman did only recommended to join.
Didi Smith the translation is not very correct here, in China, ”a policeman in my village” is more like a social worker in western country.
@@didismith5805 Guess you didn't watch the video.... they said they put people in the camp that haven't committed crimes.
@@thenutbrothers8726 before 1949, Xinjiang is controlled by China's former goverment --the Nationalist Party Government. and before the Nationalist party government is China's Qing government . So you should get used to the Chinese. Xinjiang is China, the Chinese must go to Xinjiang
“before they even commit a crime” but they didn’t commit a crime yet, how did they know that they will commit a crime. this is just sickening
Chinese gov replied, before they donthe crime, let us do crime on them first
These people are clearly in no danger. This is just the west picking at China again because the whole Hong Kong thing didn't go exactly as planned. If you people care about human rights go help these kids in cages at your border these kids need food clean clothes and medicine. Stop buying into propaganda. What China is running is more like a rehabilitation centre than a prison.
@@marshalljulie3676 they are in danger since they are held against their will.
can you accept being held in a muslim countrey against your will and dicteted how to live and what to do ?
@GDOI Soldat ᚦᚬᚩᛅᛄᚢᚠᚻᛈᛉᛋᛏᛒᛖᛗᛠᛢᛣᛥᚸ no one should be obliged to learn anything if he don't want to. its called freedom. have you ever heard of freedom?
@GDOI Soldat ᚦᚬᚩᛅᛄᚢᚠᚻᛈᛉᛋᛏᛒᛖᛗᛠᛢᛣᛥᚸ hhhhhhhhhh i dont want to learn.
You can see the pain behind those eyes. Truly unfortunate.
😔😔...
then why does the west support Israle. I can see the pain behind Palestinian people
@@jixuanwu4009 Two things can be wrong at once yk stop trying to cover up this by saying "sO wHat tHe uS doEs iT aS wEll"
@@skeltainz yeah so stop complaining LAMO
@@jixuanwu4009 don't ask me. ask the American Government. They know the answer. 😊
As an ethically Chinese person living in Singapore, I am extremely disheartened to see these people being treated like animals. I want all people, regardless of ethnicity to live in harmony.
Why disheartening? This is beautiful & smart. These people were not compatible with Chinese society. They’re just being integrated correctly. Europe should be taking notes!
@@jeremias-serus after all, they are still humans and must be treated as such.
@@deathx_x Im from singapore as well! I also wish for harmony amongst every ethnicity/race/religion
Like animals? Most people treat their pets and some even their cattle, much better than this.
Most Chinese Singaporean boomers seem to support the CCP and deny that these camps exist, dismissing such videos as "Western propaganda". I'm also a Chinese Singaporean and I support the Western agenda. Those boomers always get so triggered when they see me doing so.
"We can tell that they will commit a crime before they do it, so we arrest them to avoid the crime" Literally sounds like something out of George Orwell's 1984
Big brother is watching you
How ironic huh?
ua-cam.com/video/U3YBomwuB10/v-deo.html
MINORITY REPORT
@@ruihuahuang8872 Don't try and sell your orwellian fascist tyranny here
''they are affected by extremist thoughts''
*ironic*
Ikr, they keep saying that as if they live in their minds and so sure bt that
Same thing happened in Algeria in the 1990s, my father was imprisoned because the neighbor made a false police call saying we were hiding terrorists from the GIA, the FIS' (Front Islamic du Salut, an Islamic party which won the first turn of the 1991 election, then were cancelled) armed branch. He had to pray in a cell with urine all over the floor. Many other people were tortured, sodomized, my grandfather owned a shop and the police would intimidate and steal food in this period. It was an all out civil war. They would pick people and imprison and interrogate them at random, and beat them, it was crazy if you study it. Protesters were getting shot at in the streets, tanks in the streets, mosques being surveilled at the Friday prayer and some closed, it was insane, then later they were bombing each other shooting each other.
Non-Provit 100% lol
@Thirsty Cup bababoey
@Thirsty Cup nah im just making shit up /s
Imagine having to dance and smile like that before a western camera, while dying inside.
And watching this believing we're not next.
@@labogne1928 omg 😢
😢🫣😡 Uyghur Lives Matter 🆘
They look happy as they have been reformed from their evil thoughts !
@@MM.-qo7pkyou deserve to be treated worst than they're treated if you're this stupid!!
i feel so sorry for these people, they are being forced to do all this, you can read it in their faces.
Lol, what you can read their faces,
Go to China and look for your self and get the facts right,
Don’t trust any shit this channel publishes, just false news and propaganda.
yea sort of like the islamic brainwashing that had been forced on them previously turning them into jihadis.
Journalist: “Would you not class this as a prison?”
Mahemuti: “We let them paint”
Journalist: “But are they allowed to leave?”
Mahemuti: “WE LET. THEM PAINT.”
I agree Meg. The US should intervene now and send some democracy to China like they did in Iraq and Afghanistan. After all US has been very kind to Muslims throughout history.
@@hitchhiker8798 hitchhiker good sir what on Earth are you talking about
@@megmaynot he is saying that unlike China, uncle Sam brought destruction to muslims
@@SgtNoPants sergeant, my friend, I’m seriously starting to doubt that you even watched the video, or are even aware of the situation in general
@@megmaynot meg, darling, you better start watching videos from both sides to come to a conclusion...
The fact that THIS is what China is willing to show to the public to make these camps seem ok is scary as fuck.
*"b-b-but muh muh muh not real communism! is uh duh perfect utopia that just hasnt been tried yet and im not just saying that cuz im a reddit neckbeard durrrrrrrrrrrrr"*
@@KandiKlover bAsEd
@@KandiKlover it isn’t real communism. China is a very capitalistic country.
@@KandiKlover thinking china is communist would be the same as thinking that North Korea is democratic or that the Nazi’s were socialists. Just because it’s in the title, it doesn’t mean it’s true.
cry about it
This is EXACTLY what happened back in the 1940s. People were shown a place of happiness and joy, when it was anything but. For example, at 1:43, while this could be wrong, the guy appears to have a bruise on his eye. I think we know what that means. Just before, during the dance, the people’s smiles seemed pained and forced. A clear indication that something worse is going on here. It’s just that nobody is saying it.
"no no that was birth mark see no bruise no bruise reah no no bw uises" - some CCP pr agent 😂 WTF gallow humor cuz id been trying to yell about this one for years like a decade now and ppl are just like so what it's the normal you really can't tell them they must be shown n only then do they believe it and since it's so far away they feel like why should we care. Yet they'll turn around and reee over Ukraine and Israel all day but ya call this out and then they want nothing to do with it and don't even care to give the time a day and when you try to tell them something about these CCP apps like tiktok and even temu that they use these ppl slave labor it's sad man
1:20 You can see what is happening in his eyes. They trained them really hard to smile like they're enjoying it. Training - torture. But the eyes don't lie
The lips don't move. The teeth don't disappear. They hold the exact position that they were trained to hold. Because there are horrible consequences to be had if even one frame of footage doesn't have smiles.
7:52 the guy to the left accidentally drops the thing too early then quickly fixes his mistake
Imagine what happens when they're alone and the cameras are gone
They will be forced , tortured and brainwashed
@@culture5679 Thank you but i don't understand chinese
@@asliceofbred4882 It speaks in English, only the title and one min in this vedio is Chinese. if you have time and interest, you could watch it ^.^
The same things communists always do to people they disagree with. Inb4 the "b-b-but muh muh muh not real communism! is uh duh perfect utopia that just hasnt been tried yet and im not just saying that cuz im a reddit neckbeard durrrrrrrrrrrrr"
Apperently alot of rape goes on there
An extremist would never call himself an extremist.
I'm not an extremist
A stupid person wouldn't call himself stupid
@@palestinabaddie I would call myself stupid if I was being stupid
@@Trilliman707 still waiting
A non-extremist would never call himself an extremist.
i am a youth from Hong Kong, and i have travelled many different provinces in China. What's I could say for this video is that's video may have a great misleading to audiences. Before you watch this video, some facts you should know first,
1. China is a developing country, even thought it is the greatest economic country in the world, but its GDP / Person is still very low. Don't expect always having very good facilities, especially in those very small town.
2. China have great infrastructures in different city, but still have a lot of old building still not be renew. ( i think most of the village government still did had that budget for that as one of latest KPIs on village government is building public toilets )
So when the reporter described that it looks like a prison, then the man will feel angry as it is just as good as the living level compared with the average of local living environment to him. (There is another topic about economic development, i will not extend here, but you could try to treat it as a normal phenomena in village that still not well developed. i believe you wouldn't expect a place have high living level where's average salary level is lower then 300 USD per month)
3. There are a still lot of people who born 60 - 70s don't received education, but most of the job offered to those with at least primary education and that basic threshold made those people cannot easily fit in the society. in 10 yrs ago, when i travelled in China with my family, we are always need to keep our eyes on our properties as it was a lot of theft especial in tourist attraction. And sometime you could hear some news about brutally killing / kidnapping by ethnic minorities (Xinjiang minority is most of the case). You could search about Xinjiang cut cake may know more. A lot of bad news about some Xinjiang people selling cut cake, but not telling you the price. After they cut the cake, if you didn't pay for it, they will show the knife and i meat once in Yunnan in 2018 (Xinjiang minority as well) , an unbelievable experience hahaha, then i told my friends i almost die.
4. Those social issue that i mentioned is getting much progress now, it is much more safety and indeed i appreciate for what the government did. They provide a basic education opportunity for those adult by reeducation training. That could increase the credit / at least good in CV for them when they look for a job. As old generation Xinjiang minority did have good impression to public, it may have difficulty for those 40-60 seeking a decent job.
I know I couldn't change your mindset for China, but if you just look on the surface on one event , i believe you probably be misled to the wrong direction / led to a preset perception that the reporter want you to see.
As a person who understand a bit more about the situation , I couldn't do nothing but to tell you something more.
Yes, China have a lot of social problems but they all happen around the world. like poverty, public health issue, security issue, social inequity. US, Euro, Asia have the same problems as well or even worst. What we need to see is how the government take responsibility for handling those crisis under their capability ( financial / technical / operational / else ) . I don't think that Xinjiang is a human right issue, but a measurement that government trying to eliminate the inequity for those minority in a disadvantage in the society. We all got free education, why others couldn't even a basic version.
I couldn't say local government in China always did perfectly, there was always could have improvements but we know that it spare no effort in handling / responding the social problems. And all of my friends from Xinjiang give positive appraisal for the government performance.
I am not criticizing BBC just showing one face of the problem, but I really hope that people who watching this video could had an opportunity to use different angle to understand China, but not just the face that the report what to show.
I could understand most of the comments are come from nice persons with sympathy. you know, it is always have scandal if you want. But what we could do if we really want to understand a country / person is to travel there and have a talk with the local people with a humble attitude ( a basic respect that is very important ) , then you will know more about them but not just receive the message from a media. I believe you will see the different world if you really take this step forward.
Looking at this video I can tell they look like they were forced to this, but yeah china could do better in these reeducation camps instead of copying US corruption standards in abusing men and women like they do in guatalenmo prison. China needs to stop copying literally everything and stop being so corrupt and acting like fascist within both government and police.
Wth are you trying to say, ain’t no one is going to take their time reading all that
Looks like a psychological horror movie
"Is it your choice to be here?"
*looks outside with security cameras, barbed wires and guard towers and armed guards*
"Ehmm... yes, sure."
And is that a bruise on his eye?
zainab rahimi that’s what I was thinking lmao
zainab rahimi I didn’t notice until you mentioned it as I thought it was a drag kinda make up but looking closer it could possibly be a skin pigmentation issue
I think he was looking at the translator, could be wrong though. 1:42
@@TheMainLuke it looks like a bruise
That bruised eye must have been from all that joy going through his heart one day with a few guards.
@@MM-wy4np i think u misunderstood the comment, he was being sarcastic
I think it was a birthmark,
Ikr that's so lovely
That is make-up.
@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth oh shut up
This breaks my heart
Just imagine the absolute horrors inside that camp. imagine how terrified those people in this video were.
Watching the massacre by the Chinese government
seeing is believing
ua-cam.com/video/WU3cpoodpIg/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/67pU0Ybovnc/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/5gbD-vfO_OU/v-deo.html
Persecution of Uyghurs?
ua-cam.com/video/u4cYE6E27_g/v-deo.html
people's channel
ua-cam.com/video/OewWrCt3sgA/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/9H088qCNCVE/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/K5sFALR3OMg/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/TJrGKlJ_Sio/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/l8qew8w4AFk/v-deo.html
Please come and experience it yourself
The close up of the man's face while he was dancing was deeply disturbing. His gaze was different.
Yea straight up from a dystopian novel
Read his eyes, he's saying, 'Get me out of here !' :-O
Yeah, they used wide angle close up for that. More of a cinematography technique than emotion.
He was like Tiny Rick....HELP ME
Drama queen
The scary part is that someone in China thought that this would be a good look for them... like this is the positive show. Just imagine what is really happening then...
I see happy people receiving free education, nothing wrong with that.
@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth So then people in Work Camps are getting employment lmao
@@just_dmitri3192 After the education, they have the option to travel aboard to get a job where the area needs. China CPC spoke with many business leaders to look for talents trained in these camps. Those businesses do get some sort of tax relief.
@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth Yeah they are all happy so why not join them ?
@@ChinaGreatestNationOnEarth lol did the chinese goverment threathen you to say this?
I'm not a Muslim myself but I have been researching and following the information on what is going on in China for a while and I'm in deep shock. There is a genocide happening right in front of our eyes. I pray for justice for Uyghur people and Muslims and I hope your traditions and culture will survive.
Thank you for your concern. A few things, though:
First, you gotta know that calling this genocide is an insult to the actual genocide victims. Second, using google and reading news is not considered a "research" (you gotta know where those reports come from). Third, this video is a propaganda and full of mistranslations (you can checkout medium article titled "breaking down BBC visit on Xinjiang").
Also, let's not forget how all of this started. The Uyghurs are influenced by wahabbis, became extremists, and did what extremists do, striking terror on the Han Chinese. The CPC (or CCP) then responded by reeducating the suspected Uyghurs who became extremists to clean their Wahhabi influence. The west saw opportunity to bash China even more by accusing China of genocide towards Uyghurs.
If you think that what the CPC do is immoral, then you should consider how the west would react if they get the same event in their countries. The west will not do such hassle building reeducation camps to eliminate the extremism, instead they would choose the hard way: by bombing them to the stone age.
The alternative is so bad that the reeducation camp sounds really good for me. You got free food, free shelter, free education, and free time on weekends.
It’s all fake news don’t believe British!
i am a youth from Hong Kong, and i have travelled many different provinces in China. What's I could say for this video is that's video may have a great misleading to audiences. Before you watch this video, some facts you should know first,
1. China is a developing country, even thought it is the greatest economic country in the world, but its GDP / Person is still very low. Don't expect always having very good facilities, especially in those very small town.
2. China have great infrastructures in different city, but still have a lot of old building still not be renew. ( i think most of the village government still did had that budget for that as one of latest KPIs on village government is building public toilets )
So when the reporter described that it looks like a prison, then the man will feel angry as it is just as good as the living level compared with the average of local living environment to him. (There is another topic about economic development, i will not extend here, but you could try to treat it as a normal phenomena in village that still not well developed. i believe you wouldn't expect a place have high living level where's average salary level is lower then 300 USD per month)
3. There are a still lot of people who born 60 - 70s don't received education, but most of the job offered to those with at least primary education and that basic threshold made those people cannot easily fit in the society. in 10 yrs ago, when i travelled in China with my family, we are always need to keep our eyes on our properties as it was a lot of theft especial in tourist attraction. And sometime you could hear some news about brutally killing / kidnapping by ethnic minorities (Xinjiang minority is most of the case). You could search about Xinjiang cut cake may know more. A lot of bad news about some Xinjiang people selling cut cake, but not telling you the price. After they cut the cake, if you didn't pay for it, they will show the knife and i meat once in Yunnan in 2018 (Xinjiang minority as well) , an unbelievable experience hahaha, then i told my friends i almost die.
4. Those social issue that i mentioned is getting much progress now, it is much more safety and indeed i appreciate for what the government did. They provide a basic education opportunity for those adult by reeducation training. That could increase the credit / at least good in CV for them when they look for a job. As old generation Xinjiang minority did have good impression to public, it may have difficulty for those 40-60 seeking a decent job.
I know I couldn't change your mindset for China, but if you just look on the surface on one event , i believe you probably be misled to the wrong direction / led to a preset perception that the reporter want you to see.
As a person who understand a bit more about the situation , I couldn't do nothing but to tell you something more.
Yes, China have a lot of social problems but they all happen around the world. like poverty, public health issue, security issue, social inequity. US, Euro, Asia have the same problems as well or even worst. What we need to see is how the government take responsibility for handling those crisis under their capability ( financial / technical / operational / else ) . I don't think that Xinjiang is a human right issue, but a measurement that government trying to eliminate the inequity for those minority in a disadvantage in the society. We all got free education, why others couldn't even a basic version.
I couldn't say local government in China always did perfectly, there was always could have improvements but we know that it spare no effort in handling / responding the social problems. And all of my friends from Xinjiang give positive appraisal for the government performance.
I am not criticizing BBC just showing one face of the problem, but I really hope that people who watching this video could had an opportunity to use different angle to understand China, but not just the face that the report what to show.
I could understand most of the comments are come from nice persons with sympathy. you know, it is always have scandal if you want. But what we could do if we really want to understand a country / person is to travel there and have a talk with the local people with a humble attitude ( a basic respect that is very important ) , then you will know more about them but not just receive the message from a media. I believe you will see the different world if you really take this step forward.
This is purely information distortion, if you really ask a person who can speak mandrain. The translation and information is so distorted. PLUS china has one child policy for HAN people (most chinese), but Uyghur has priority that they can give birth to how many they want. So that the Uyghur population is increasing significantly faster in China without restriction like anyone else. And you call it 'genocide'? Give priority in policy, and it is now called genocide? Great distortion.
These so called camp education is a way for dealing with terrorist activity. Do you know the background of the camp? If you know nothing about the terrorist activity before the camp education, CONGRATULATION! You know how much that you don't know about the REAL story. The whole story is so much distorted, without background, without proper translation, with selected information to present.
I have so many Muslim friends and I wish you can see more of the background to see the real picture.
How are people here actually defending the imprisonment of 40 million Muslims for NO reason other than they believe in Allah. Shame on you all, may Allah guide your blackened hearts.
The place from where you're not allowed to leave is the prison, nothing else is needed to confirm that. So it's the prison, what are the conditions in the prison is another talk.
The guy with the Bruise on the face:
"A Policeman at my village told me to get enrolled in school..."
The Reporter:
"HOW"
Because of this behavior and the entire behavior of the transformation camp we see that they attempt to counteract extremism of the prisoner with extremism of the country.
That they don't feel ridiculous to themselves with this contradicting behavior is really crazy. Ready for psychiatry.
it's not a bruise, why tf would they show someone with a bruise on their face? it's a birthmark, very clearly
@@reje Yes, thats can be true. I had not thought of that.
@@reje a policeman told him to get enrolled in a school.. becoz of his TERRORISM AND EXTREMIST activities..
Spoon fed words..
What kind of school is it?
@@coremanishmehta all i said was it's not a bruise, i think you can critique china without making stuff up, that's all
"Are you here by choice?"
Bruh there are literally bruises on the poor man's eyes.
He prob got into a fight inside by himself
@@Vict0rHy wtf
@@ishaaq.a079 can you adamantly say that someone did it to him? Where is the evidence of foul play? What if he was playing soccer and got headed in the face. All you idiots out there that listen to western media have been brainwashed from birth.
@@Vict0rHy I support Muslims ?
@@Vict0rHy he probs got beaten by guards or something they are scared to say the truth
The world is quiet while they are suffering and going through so much. Thanks to the journalist for bringing truth to the world but sad that no authority is taking action to set these people free. May Allah give guidance to the oppressor, or destroy them. Ameen
Allahumme Amin........
I had to watch this special for a journalism, and I remember being seriously creeped out. Just creeped out. It honestly felt like a horror movie. Three years later, I wasn't surprised but still shocked when the truth came out. China is still in denial, no surprise. People know the truth now.
look at the eyes of the dancers. vacant stares, heart breaking.
Their smilies are creepy as hell, so forced but that's the only thing they can do now. Fake their position in society and hope they don't ever slip up, their only freedom exists through their thoughts now, which even then might be compromised. Since there's another video of chinese students forced to wear devices that measures brain activity to tell teachers if their focusing hard enough. Wouldn't surprise me if China developed them enough to tell if people support the government or not
@@AndresPerez-jc6nv the guy had what seems like bruise on his right eye
Any danse school in China all let the students force a smile when they dance. I used to do that when I was a kid. That’s just how they dance.
look at the eyes of muslims... angry..
@@calhackit9806
You'd be angry too if you were held against your will and had your children put into an orphanage. It's not about religion. It's about humanity. But you have been trained to see their faith before their humanity. You can still unshackle your mind...
These are not smiles, they’re crying souls, crying for last bit of humanity & empathy. The eye NEVER lie
Humanity or extrimist.
@Grey Wild Wolf really? you tell me which scene shows abusing? just tell me ？ it just a skill training school ,BBC got nothing，at the last BBC did make a second unannounced “surprise” visit late at night, what they got ?only to see Uyghurs leaving the center, as usually as the other weekend，BBC got nothing evidence ，them they edited this movie with dark colors, weird background music,and Induced narration。is it a documentary should be？ why not look at this ,the same re-education skill training school visiting by japanese,ua-cam.com/video/SnUNpnVll_A/v-deo.html
BBC
@Grey Wild Wolf Don't you see that this footage is edited by a kind of campus suspense movie technique?
@Grey Wild Wolf There are always people who have never been to China and feel that they know China better than people who have been to China or Chinese people,even actualy they know nothing bout China.Let me ask you some questions repeatly ,and you can ask youself too:,have you ever been to China？ Have you ever been to Xingjiang ? have you ever seen any footage showing massacre on Tiananmen Square? Have you ever talked with any native chinese ? Over so many years, have you ever seen what is the “concentration camps”look like? have any medias and the CIA got any pictures,video,recordings of the so called “concentration camps” just like the U.S. army abusing prisoners at Guantanamo prison? Why you believe the things you have never seen ? why you believe all what the the media tells you?Even some of them said the mask is useless for virus.why not go to China to see who is telling the truth and who is lying? Why not look at this youtuber ,this guy is living in Qindao in China.he often make live streams ,you can see the real China without any Intermediate media,all you need to do is open your eyes .ua-cam.com/users/ThisisChinaLifevideos
@Sir Sinjin Smythe What did they do?
as a school kid researching about this topic, you can tell they are also being trained how to act before this visit to that pacific camp and the fact there all smiling is contradicting from what's probably happening
Whatever school you go to, W school. No schools here even TALK about this. It’s disgusting how people ignore this
Bro my service in the Russian navy is a walk in a park in comparison with this scary shit
it's painful to watch the forced smiles behind their sad faces.
TRULY AGREE! very heartbreaking..
@GDOI Soldat ᚦᚬᚩᛅᛄᚢᚠᚻᛈᛉᛋᛏᛒᛖᛗᛠᛢᛣᛥᚸ lol you are easily fooled..
This is soo heartbreaking
How hard that can be 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
GDOI Soldat ᚦᚬᚩᛅᛄᚢᚠᚻᛈᛉᛋᛏᛒᛖᛗᛠᛢᛣᛥᚸ
They can’t even pray !! How could that be a real smile it’s not a joke they are forcing them to change their religion!
Even their fake for show camp is depressing . its like a nightmare fever dream. But it doesnt end.
much better than the USA directly BOM them.
@@alanssshh Id rather be bombed.
@@alanssshh there it goes again, the blame and misdirection, ad hominem at its most stupid
@@loveear5370 i looked at it.
1) she worked as a translator for uighur inmates. thats common thing in prison. its meant to allow legal representation.
the apparent violation of human right was only done on few prisoners in guantomanto to extract relevent information . it was not by any means a measure to convert them away from their religion or other.
also who china is torturing is main question, it is known for batlant censorship laws including banning criticism of party , making people disappear, and other.
2) US had a nasty sterilization program in 1910s iirc . but you can say the same .. it doesn't mean everyone will be victim of it.
@@fironfiron8843 1. This is not a justification for Guantanamo, either, and exposes her false face as a "human rights defender. Think about what you would say if Guantanamo happened in China.
In China, if you attack the Communist Party on the internet, the most you will get is someone deleting your comments (my comments are always deleted from youtube, and many anti-American accounts on Twitter are restricted). In reality, there are many people who express their discontent, no one will make you disappear. Chinese star Yao Chen, who has tens of millions of Weibo followers, posted something like "China is the land of evil" and is still active in the entertainment industry, and many similar things.
The only time you try to use your influence to incite people to overthrow the regime, that's when the government might do something. But I don't think it's much different from the US. Think Snowden, Assange, and Epstein who died for unknown reasons.
2. you are missing the point, the number of her children is enough to shock the Han Chinese, I have never seen a Han Chinese with so many children in the last 20 years. China has a one child policy, but that restriction is very lenient among ethnic minorities, including the Uighurs. If she were Han, she could not have had so many children. The incident proves that not only is there no sterilization of Uyghurs in China, but that births are encouraged. And of course the population growth figures prove this, much higher than the Han Chinese.
Wherever someone gets hurt, my heart hurts too. If your heart doesn't hurt anyway, ıs this a person's heart?
By far the most disturbing video without a single graphic image.
keep in mind, this is the camp they want to show you. God knows the other ones...
Edit: Oh, please tell me more about your lord and saviour, nihilism. Never heard of it.
ua-cam.com/video/2Shla50pRxA/v-deo.html
wander knight it’s just a phrase dickhead. I’m atheist and use the term all the time
Brian Is Me yeah it’s an expression, implying one who is
Omnibenevolent, omniscient, or omnipotent would know of the secrecy of evil. This Is what I am implying, since China and the CCP are a secretive government. For example, “the great fire wall of China”.
Wander knight is likely a troll.
@@wanderknight69 hmm are you using vpn?
@@wanderknight69 And Talibans are what, tribal people from Afghanistan. What did the Uygurs do to anyone.
Pretty sure 1984 was supposed to be more of a warning than an instructional guide
It was a primer. It never mentioned the using of death row prisoners for organ harvesting and sale.
Criminals don't need kidneys and livers, eyes and hearts that can go to lawful wealthy citizens.
Have you met religious extremists?
@@zitronentee even religious extremists aren't as monstrous as atheists and communists
1984 was supose to be in Chinese obviously
USA, country of 320mln people: prison population larger than all other world countries combined, prisoners treated like dirt and forced to work weeks just to pay for 1 phone call to family. Also asylum seeker kids dying at the border with no flu medicine.
China: Opens reeducation camps after uighur riots to eliminate religious brainwash and antisocial behaviour while at the same time building trade network through the region to eliminate economic stressors that lead to violence.
World: omg china is the new nazis, this is 1984
The Kamloops residential school was a "school not a prison " too.
The Chinese people living outside of China looking at this horrific abuse, count how privileged and lucky you are.
That’s not priveleged, that’s normal. What’s happening in China is perverse and evil. Humans shouldn’t feel grateful when they’re not treated like sheep.
Is there any difference with North Korea at this point?
There's High speed internet in China, Businesses, Lots of fast food, TV shows, Holywood Cinema, Cars, Motorcycle, electric car/busses/motorcycle... In North Korea you only have your bike and your morning get up and go to work Morning Announcement.
China could have build Guantanamo style camp but they chose these.
@@kakabitan Is that the price of freedom....
@@tonyatgoogle6076 Another shill arent you... you need to work at it.
@@1Live2Love3Thrive China has more freedom than United states. In the US you can't share your opinion if you're not a liberal democrat, can't drink milk because milk is racist, soon you cannot study math because math is sexist and racist, your companies are against right to fix law, changing tires of a tesla must be in service centers, your mac and iphone are unfixable, you can't do the ok sign because it's racist. In China they do not care if you copy this or that, you can drive without license as long as your car is electric, you can eat dogs and cats, no Liberal SJW and feminazi on the street. You can basically do anything just not against the president or the Government and practice religion of terrorism.
"Our purpose is to get rid of their extremist thoughts"
The thought police
you can say that to anyone that wants to control your speech.
"no swearing in public"
The thought police
@lionpro +12 social credit points to your account, comrade.
@@koka1571 you dont get sent to prison for swearing in no swear zones
@@koka1571 you have a point but this isn't just mild censorship this is full up cultural genocide
@lionpro i know, all these evil bots saying that genocide is bad, and that people should have freedom to practice whatever religion they want
And all those evil bots talking about how this is exactly like nazi Germany
How come I don't see this un our news. This need to be shutdown asap.!
Dystopian as hell
Is it your choice to be here?
Yes.. "with a dark eye"
Only god knows who beat him
I thought it was a black eye too
It's not a black eye, it's an angioma
😂😂😂
🤣🤣😭😭😭😭💔💔
Everyone report the Chinese bot that keeps replying on every comment
This is just evil
yes indeed. fake news is very very evil.
@@zexiali6483 the Chinese spy who defected to Australia has a lot of documents to prove its true.
search“July 5th riots”then you will know who is truly evil
@@jackzhang3939 that's actually fascinating.
none of this was shown on western news.
@@jackzhang3939 Chinese officials and a spy who defected to Australia government leaked many documents containing orders about Uighurs, Tibet, Hong Kong and many more. You can't just lie to yourself and say it's all western propaganda because those proves comes from Chinese citizens who don't want to be part of those horrors and brutalities anymore.
This video is almost unwatchable with headphones: music and video audio on the right and the narrator voice on the left.
how does this not make you angry deep inside? how can we sit and watch this and perhaps think "i feel sorry for them" when we can take action and notify everyone about these horrific acts. 99% of the people who have watched this video will forget about it the next day.
EXACTLY! Watching this makes me wanna punch the wall
"When money talks, humanity is gone."
That's how Chinese government play the game
Who is paying China to do this? Who has enough money to pay China to do this? To every person, when enough money is given, they topple. Not only China. If I gave you 1 billion dollars to kill me, I think you would, not to be offensive. Technically you aren't committing a crime, I told you to do so. Believe or not, the Chinese government get no gain from making camps and changing people, so in the end, they don't do it. This isn't in China, it doesn't make sense that if this is happening in China, China would allow them to film and interview.
YNWA AIY and the America?
@@stefano9633 America allows you to use UA-cam & post comments here like a normal human being without putting your real name. Name a concentration camp in America which host more than a million innocent people and disallow media going in without being tailgated? Karma will 100% haunt China
BBC FAKE NEWS
ua-cam.com/video/BjgSOYRZqIo/v-deo.html
see this,you will know more
Allah-uAkbar，jihad
Is this what you want?
Great quote
imagine you're in hell and you have to act and behave as if you're really enjoying there. this is really sad
Yes, like modern schools
@gemma fiona more than that
They brought it upon themselves by doing terrorist attacks in China
Goood
Кенжетайұлы where’s your proof
"And the sound of THOUGHTS BEING TRANSFORMED , echoes into the night."
That’s like a normal high school in China except it’s boarding school. 10 beds in a room is not the worst.
I can see those bruises on their face. Stop lying
They can’t or else they will get beaten 😭😭😭
Just imagine the bruises on the prisoners not allowed before the cameras
SuperSMT that’s sad 😔
bro, that's birthmark just like Gorbachev
They are supposed to be free to leave if it's their will joining
"If they don't want to come then what happens?"
"We have not encountered that."
Yun Xie Oh yes, it is absolutely reasonable to imprison an entire ethnicity and impose a police state for the actions of select extremists /s
@@Mo-lf1qv Man, he is probably chinese IT cell. :D
Yun Xie Additionally, China should also imprison all men for the rape of women and harvest the organs of all college students for participating in demonstrations.
@@Mo-lf1qv Entire? Lol why not buying a ticket, flying to Xinjiang and find it yourself? Your favorite news channel told you there's no Uyghur walking on the streets?
@@Mo-lf1qv Asking 100 ppl on the street in Xinjiang, asking if they're Han or Uyghur yourself. I'm really tired of arguing with you guys. Most of you consider news and videos on UA-cam as evidence/truth instead of looking for the truth yourself.
Y'all got some real brass balls going over there and doing these interviews. Goddamn.
看旅游视频给我跳到这来了，这不就是个住宿职校吗，让人工作前有点基础的汉语，教的东西还分类别，前端Java美容美发酒店管理。采访人的话也只截取了说的后半句，求真的可以去搜全程，右边推送还有拿着监狱图片当封面指控的视频，奇怪的推送。
I'm from Hong Kong. Yes, I'm extremely terrified of this.
I fear for your safety
Stay strong! We are with you as much as we can. I really wish I could help more (from US)
say good stuff about china and they will will overlook you thinking you are brainwash
@@ilikepigeons6101 Thank you for your kind regards, the Hongkongers are all planning to immigrate
@@jtomyhope575 thank you so much for your empathy, I will stay as strong as I can. I won't bow down to China. I will stay in Hong Kong until the day it becomes unfamiliar
"We would call the brainwashing"
"no its just we are removing their thoughts"
SPEECH 100
China is best country for double speak or talking in circles. Their government has become quite proficient at it.
[CHECK FAILED]
Yet you believe the BBC? Ok....
it would onky be Orwellian if they were replacing free thought, they are replacing bad ideology with their own, not the best but they will no longer be commiting jihad
Excerpt from the book Operation Gladio: The Unholy Alliance between the Vatican, the CIA, and the Mafia by Paul L. Williams : "Throughout the 1990s, hundreds of Uyghurs were transported to Afghanistan by the CIA for training in guerrilla warfare by the mujahideen. When they returned to Xinjiang, they formed the East Turkistan Islamic Movement and came under Çatlı's expert direction. Graham Fuller, CIA superspy, offered this explanation for radicalizing the Chinese Muslims: The policy of guiding the evolution of Islam and of helping them [Muslims] against our adversaries worked marvelously well in Afghanistan against the Red Army. The same doctrines can still be used to destabilize what remains of Russian power, and especially to counter the Chinese influence in Central Asia. This policy of destabilization was devised by Bernard Lewis, an Oxford University specialist on Islamic studies, who called for the creation of an “Arc of Crisis” around the southern borders of the Soviet Union by empowering Muslim radicals to rebel against their Communist overlords."
At one time, everyone is condemning china official when they said they can predetermined if a person will commit a crime... At another time, everyone is saying how signs of school shooting can be prevented if we pay more attention to the shooter's behavior before he snaps... Which side are you on?
Seems like it's high school musical set in a prision tone
They look brain washed like they don’t act like regular humans this is sad...
Agreed..
you can choose brain washed by isis or china??
They are probably scared because of the cameras and officials watching.
ua-cam.com/video/EovpQE6dZeE/v-deo.html
@rxp56 you could say that about any religion though. Should all governments round up their religious and ethnic minorities, to brainwash them and keep them locked up till they are indoctrinated?
*I didn't remember being given a black eye when I was in school. They talk about protecting the students (prisoners) in camps, take the dude to the medical room. If he carries on dancing and falls it’s game over. But oh yeah it’s a re-education camp so I guess education (brainwashing) comes before health and safety smh even if it means he has to be 6 foot deep under roses before his time* 💔
👏👏👏👏👏🔥
Don't call people 'stupid muslims'. Have some respect, you're disgusting.
Kiki Kannibal free speech
And this stupid channel is deleting all the Chinese comments wow , freedom of speech hahaha wow
I had to censor words coz this channel has banned some words so my comments gets automatically deleted
Looks like the movie
"Get Out".
Creepy as hell !!!
NIce picture. They sign and dance instead of planting bombs.
Wdym “instead of planting bombs”
„Is there a Prison, where u can paint“
like tf is that even a argument?????
Freggel Meggel even more ironic because there’s definitely prisons where you can paint lol
@@sandratran8335 ikr,, in some prisons, programmes are pitched to let the prisoners sew/knit or paint etc.
yeah as if painting is an escape
Camp is fake news, wake up
Lol tf in Germany you have to have your own room bc it’s a basic human right to have enough space to live. You even can go outside over the day. When I say outside I mean like idk go to the supermarket etc.
"It's their choice"
It's not a choice, it's a command.
And it is their choice to obey it... or face the consequences.
@Wanming Hu Sure, why not? We can train them, give them weapons and pay for the return trip. Lets see how CCP deals with people who can fight back.
@Wanming Hu Yes, burning your own people probably comes naturally to you. However, you will find it much harder considering how many sympathisers you would generate after such brutal actions against your own populous. Especially since you are trying to erase their culture and identity.
@Wanming Hu Rarely do we ever need to fight. We certainly don't need to fight you. Oppressive regimes always topple, all they need is a little push. Besides, hiding in the crowd would be useless because we all know you would shoot anyway.
@Wanming Hu Wow, you sound a lot like the Japanese from the 1940s. I wouldn't talk about "backwards cultures" if I were you.
why is the audio messed up
1:16 as creepy and disgusting this is (what they are forced to do), this song is a banger. If anyone knows the name please tell.
The art guy, He got defensive. He's obviously hiding something.
What is there to hide? They are just being forced to take these lessons, that's the issue that the BBC is trying to expose. The moral argument from the West is that forcing people to sing, dance and paint while depriving them of their freedom is wrong. China's position is that by helping poor undereducated people learn valuable skills they can prevent the despair that leads to religious extremism and terrorism.
@@grimcommander4172
No, what they are doing is torturing them in secret. It is just Nazi Germany in China.
Grim Commander if they were just forcing them to do lessons, as you said. Why would they keep them in such highly protected building in the middle of nowhere, and why would there be people protesting against these "lessons"? The survivors claim they got beaten and tortured. Why would they hide certain areas from journalists? the nazis sent photos of people playing and having fun at the camps, and look at what they found out.
@@grimcommander4172 congrats my man you are brainwashed
@@RereAndRerun - No, at first I was being sarcastic, but then I contrasted that with the UK where British women are told to "shut up about grooming gang rapes for the sake of diversity." and I saw that China has a point to their argument. If people are educated with skills they will avoid despair that Islamist terrorist recruiters often use to their advantage against the government. So China puts education on the front burner, a temporary injustice though a long term helping hand. As Jesus said, "Give a man a fish, he eats for a day. TEACH a man to fish and he eats his whole life." China is teaching them to fish so they will have good jobs their whole lives!
Wealthy Muslim countries be like: "imma pretend I didn't see that"
@@stevenl5006 A Hong Konger. So he has EVERY right.
@@stevenl5006 and even if he was Chinese, since when can’t we criticise our own countries?
i'm from Ohio lmfao
@@stevenl5006 lmao your comment XD so someone who’s ethnically Chinese cannot have a say in China’s policies. Interesting, pretty much destroyed human logics in one go.
@@stevenl5006 😂😂😂😂😂 dude you got made a fool of
why do they treat adult people like kindergarten students? just asking
Oh my heart, don't break
No way did he just say they take people “on edge of committing a crime” literally WHAT does that even mean. This is ridiculous and to be honest it hasn’t even sunk in for me how bad this truly is. There is SUCH a disconnect because we can’t see what’s going on, it’s so easy to disregard and I HATE it. I wish I felt more, could DO more. This is so wrong and sickening.
That’s the same thing I thought. You can determine that someone COULD use violence against other people, but you are not able to determine if someone is one edge of committing a crime, that’s (nearly) psychological impossible.
this means exactly what they said. they use AI cameras EVERYWHERE in china. they are identifying "at risk people" by features they exhibit. and arresting them. but only of the islamic culture. china is now the leading worldpower in AI after deepminds alphazero crushed lee sedol and china realized the potential of AI, then after running a huge AI campaign generated BILLIONS of dollars to build these compounds and put cameras everywhere to fight a small opressed culture residing in their territory
All it means is: here's a wonderful excuse to imprison and brainwash people we don't like
Thought crime
CHINA #1 TIME TRAVELLING JUSTICE
The dancing part is More scary than horror movies 🥶🥶
Maybe it’s because BBC chooses a person from thousands of people whose expression is especially easy to interpret the meaning of this movie.
It's normal in China, my aunt dances similarly every day at the square near her apartment. What are U thinking? A dance class must be ballet? They are just making fun
Did you forget your meds?
China just can't no right can they? How happiness can be twisted into horror with the magic of editing. Love how they used the hairdressing thingy for the brainwashing segments. Yeah the chinese are a proud people, deservingly so. Come on everyone knows what islamic extremism does to people. Better this than death, poverty and violence.
So are you just going to insult their culture then? Hahahaha wtf
thanks for this documentary. i wish there would be some thoughts added how we can help those people get their lives back
I have been thinking too. I think history is a good intro to this conversation such as the holocaust. Why genocide starts and what allows for a minority group to be targeted so easily when propaganda and fear keeps good people from acting. I wrote a paper on this in college but I want to do more.
What the hell are those filters, the video isn’t supposed to be yellow like this, all the of the video footage are making everything looking ugly.
Isn't the literal definition of a prison, a place you can't leave?
did u finish the video? they actually leave at last
@@lugangwang1227 I did finish the video. Did you finish the video? Only some of the men get to leave in the middle of the night, and leave in shifts. It's literally a prison.
@@giangstr yeah， u always see some prisoner leave prison at each 8 o'clock.
@@lugangwang1227 When they 'finish' the transformation process, while most of them even don't know when it will be over (~few years). I just repeated the scripts in this video.
@@pomni8696 do u know what exaggerate mean? and that's what media do for living
They literally look and act like the victims in Get Out. It's horrifying.
True it’s disgusting
@Nerdecon Thought that same thing
@Nerdecon the word is *Sinicization* .
Yesss that’s what I was thinking!!!
● What China's area education camp in Xinjiang really about?
ua-cam.com/video/U3YBomwuB10/v-deo.html
● A glimpse into the lives of Uygur youths in Kashgar
m.ua-cam.com/video/hS93tMWzRjQ/v-deo.html
● How mosques are protected for China's Xinjiang Muslims to pray
m.ua-cam.com/video/oS9M5ifFd9M/v-deo.html
● Xinjiang officials hit back at allegations over the region
ua-cam.com/video/ZYI1dJ4O4k0/v-deo.html
● I went to XINJIANG or | Train to Stay city, walk through Uyghur neighborhood
ua-cam.com/video/Opc_FL605PI/v-deo.html
● Stable lives of trainees from Xinjiang vocational centers counter Western liars:
www.globaltimes.cn/content/1201973.shtml
● The Real Reason Western Media Lies about China
ua-cam.com/video/ve4cwf458k4/v-deo.html
this doesn't look like a prison
Its a sad, messed up world that we live in. Maranatha 🙏
Journalist: "If they don't want to come, then what happen?"
Guard: "We've never encountered that before"
Me: "Really??"
I really don't wanna dig deeper into that statement.
Because they force them to or they escape.
Guard: "IT NEVER HAPPENS...but if it did we would encourage them proactively..."
Yeah, I wish the reporter would have pushed him on that one. Why would literally no one have a problem leaving their family, jobs, homes, and communities behind? Wouldn't you? Literally everyone would.
@@MsJeanneMarie I think most people there don't have a job... The school is teaching they living skills too.
Why are grown adults singing and clapping their hands like kindergarteners?
SniperRose ikr they’ve clearly been brainwashed
Shhh they are studying
Because they're being forced to
Its called BRAINWASHING !!!!
When the feeling part of brain that is governed by emotions is made superior over a person's Thinking brain (the logical side), they start to blindly believe in ideologies. The dancing and singing arouse the feeling brain.
Come on bbc fix this damn audio, you’re a news company and can’t even put out decent quality audio on a video that matters?
"Welcome to the Hotel California"... Makes me want to go on an Eagles binge as I am heading down the highway right now.
It is crazy how systematic camps still exist in the modern world.
@@culture5679 If the BBC showed what really happened, China would never let is be broadcasted in the first place. And if it was the whole truth about these camps, knowing China , let's be real the journalists won't come out alive.
Thanks, I'll check out the link.
Sadly this is not unique to China, whatsoever. All around the world there's concentration camps/"detention centers". The US has them for immigrants. Many other countries do. 😭 Kashmir in India, Palestinians have basically an "open-air" prison in Gaza, where Israel will not allow them to leave & they're being bombed repeatedly. 😭 It's really, really sad this still continues. 😭
@@JaseekaRawr exactly this isn’t a surprising thing.
@Sam They don't have to be called "camps" to be detainment centers or be oppressed on basis of nationality, religion, etc.
Kashmir, like Palestine, can be classified as an "open air prison". Where the majority or ruling state can control their actions & human rights. I'm not sure if Kashmir even has internet access restored. It was cut off a while back, during crackdowns. Palestinians aren't allowed to leave. They cannot travel freely & are segregated as second class citizens - on their *own native homeland.*
Neither are in "camps". They're oppressed in an open air prison situation. 😕
china is clearly not a developed country
Religious extremism according to China: praying
It's probably the over 200 terror attacks carried out by Uyghar extremists that did it.
@@ZincFold 50 cents isn‘t enough to defend this goverment. Stop it
@@umerirfan1188 nope it was the same form of extremism that also sparked Washington's War On Terror post 9/11.
The major difference is the U.S and allies have slaughtered and displaced millions more in the Middle East. China is dealing with it on the home front.
There are Uyghurs detained in Guantanamo Bay for the same reason but you don't hear anyone crying about it. Western MSM has you blindly accepting a double standard here.
@@ZincFold lol i could repeat the same sentence to you ''blindly accepting a double standard here.'' that one thing goes on doesn't make the other one less worse. don't kid yourself.
@@giocommentary no one is saying that here or aren't you paying attention?
The U.S and allies have actually done a lot worse in the Middle East.
Okay this is scary af
man the audio on this video sucks for headphone users
"is there a prison where you can paint?"
yes. in fact, there are many.
All of them... and read whatever you want, learn whatever you want, and have a fixed term for when you leave
ua-cam.com/video/8N3hnCKtrjE/v-deo.html
Try to hear the voice from both sides
@@clairee4939 inhumane is the word. I'm actually surprised they don't just put a bullet in their heads like the KGB. I guess in China, letting them live at all is probably seen as humane.
@@clairee4939 breaks my heart
Colin Wang Tut tut tut, no more trying to fool us with propaganda!
You get bad vibes from the opening scene in the dance studio
Luis Rivera it feels like they’re all dancing at gunpoint...
Strong North Korean propaganda-like vibe there
*Expecially with the dude who had that large purple mark on his face. He said what he was supposed too, but made it very clear, that he had no choice but fake*
@@yushi8373 It's a human rights issue, not a movie..
@@4realGTFOH it's a human rights issue that you felt the dance delivered a bad vibe? Interesting.
awful and disgusting that something like this is being done
I would invite you all to watch Schindlers list to experience the horrors of a labour camp.
Hmmm, nothing wrong here...
a nobleman I'm a trump supporter who isn't a big fan of Iran, but I do feel bad for the Muslims in China
They call the children’s schools where they live, kindergartens. It’s insane what is going on.
@@gibransaliba8801 I also feel bad for Muslims in America
young MEITEI but they are not persecuted like in China
@@gibransaliba8801 that's good then why stop the immigration dude why is trump building a wall let everyone come in
Adults would NOT behave like children if they were not FORCED to do so.
I m Uighur and all Uighurs who live abroad was asked by Chinese government to scan all documents and send to China- documents are : passport, CPR number, work address,home address ,phone number FROM ALL FAMILY MEMBERS,
We have been told, if we are on social media or in any news papers make a remark or complain about Uighur genocide, the Chinese government will kill or cut fingers, RIP teeth or nail of our siblings and nex if kin back home.
造谣是要负责任的，你竟然不在乎家人的死活，你个鳖孙儿
Although I don't fully agree that the education camp is right, it's effective.Because the terrorists caused the massacre at the Chinese railway station before.
@@Shenzhou. Lmao Chinese people continue to convince me their population is full of complete psychopaths.
@@ericcartmann Look at Chinese culture, and we value hard work, being studious in school and industrious at work, so why can't Chinese government impart some of these positive virtues to Uighurs? The Uighurs weren't even Muslims in the first place, and Xinjiang was part of China long before the Islamic invaders conquered the region and converted the natives to Islam. Why can't Chinese government undo the damage that radicalism done to Uighurs?
If you realise this is the best they could make it seem it’s even scarier
PUT MANDARIN SUBTITLES ON THIS VIDEO!!!!!
This is like a real life black mirror episode
Omg my exact thought. Look at their expressions. They all look so robotic and forced
4:08
@Pavor Yea sure. Except in every NATO nation (maybe except for Turkey which is still ten times better than this), you have freedom of thought, to choose your religion, have whatever opinion you want, etc. How is it that there are communist parties allowed in NATO nations and in some cases, they even participate in government, because we have absolute freedom to have whatever opinion you want. In communist countries, there is not any space for political pluralism they do not allow any other opinions than the official one.
BadAt Everything ua-cam.com/video/NubnqlSNF64/v-deo.html
Watch it before they try to take it down again.
It is very very disturbing
They didn’t even try to hide the bruises on the guys face.
Yumydude West against extremists? Anti-terrorism. China against extremists? Oppression. Double standard BS, watch what’s actually going on in Xinjiang. ua-cam.com/video/u4cYE6E27_g/v-deo.html
Marcus Ng You don’t have to be a phsycic do determine that the guards aren’t treating them well. Also relax yourself 😂.
Hikari yeah glory to the people’s republic that’s literally censoring information as much as possible to any negative aspect about their country.
Hikari extremism? Having religious beliefs is now extremism? You’re ignorant, and it stinks.
It’s a birthmark
why is all the music and the dude talking muted
When I looked all the victims' faces. I can only see fake smiles, they are not Happy at all. You can from their faces that they are beaten up especially the guy who was interviewed.
Ikr
Yeah, fvck china
@@khani54 They know Islam is not a religion of peace.
China kills 0 people in Xinjiang, mainstream media calls it "genocide."
America kills millions in the Middle East, mainstream media calls it "spreading freedom."
@@Generalshouchew You are fully right