2016 Personality Lecture 08: Existentialism: Nietzsche, Dostoevsky and Social Hierarchy

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 вер 2024
  • When Nietzsche announced the death of God, he was announcing the collapse of Western Civilization's belief in itself. This has had dire sociological, political and psychological consequences. It wasn't just that God died. Christ was the symbol of the perfect Western man. What died was that ideal, taking with it direction, purpose and meaning. What emerged was rational nihilism and the predilection towards resentment and authoritarian revenge.
    -- SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL --
    Direct Support: www.jordanbpet...
    Merchandise: teespring.com/...
    -- BOOKS --
    12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos: jordanbpeterso...
    Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief: jordanbpeterso...
    -- LINKS --
    Website: jordanbpeterso...
    12 Rules for Life Tour: jordanbpeterso...
    Blog: jordanbpeterso...
    Podcast: jordanbpeterso...
    Reading List: jordanbpeterso...
    Twitter: / jordanbpeterson
    Instagram: / jordan.b.peterson
    Facebook: / drjordanpeterson
    -- PRODUCTS --
    Personality Course: www.jordanbpet...
    Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring....
    Understand Myself personality test: understandmyse...
    Merchandise: teespring.com/...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 189

  • @KATVballSpiker
    @KATVballSpiker 6 років тому +28

    Nietzsche may be a "hammer" but I found Dostoevsky to be like a surgical knife - so eloquent, succinct and accurate in his distillation of "the mouse". It brought chills as his closely packed points hit home again and again. My list of "must reads" continues to grow.

    • @alexsveles343
      @alexsveles343 Рік тому

      Dostoyewski is a bit deeper than Nietsche.,but 5uey both are incredible

  • @davidwilliamson5406
    @davidwilliamson5406 4 роки тому +43

    It’s so nice to listen to a person who scrutinized their own intuition so carefully. I am a suspicious person and it is hard for me to trust lecturers, but you don’t have to trust Peterson. He will tell you exactly where the shortcomings of his ideas are.

  • @mimisworlda
    @mimisworlda 6 років тому +70

    Wow, lecture like this makes me proud of being human. Knowledge like this gives me hope. Thank you!

  • @DoclightmegamanX
    @DoclightmegamanX 7 років тому +107

    Jordan B Peterson I've been that mouse person described in your lecture. Your lecture about reality and the sacred helped me let go of the spite I felt for others, especially religious people. Obviously I was already transitioning away from that person to start with, or one lecture wouldn't have made the difference. You helped me widen my frame of reference to include the future. I have imbued my life with meaning and am less stressed. I'm thinking seriously about my future as well as contemplating where being complacent will lead. People around me are responding positively as well.
    Thanks from a random american

  • @manusm3097
    @manusm3097 Рік тому +2

    I appreciate how modest Dr. Peterson is , to put this video on on UA-cam he recorded with a self standing camera kept on Side on lecture stand rather than say recoding being handled by some person, which could involved overhead expense or other stuff that could have become hindrance in production of recording but thankfully a simple effort is enough for us to receive fruits of this education.

  • @theninjafuckr4109
    @theninjafuckr4109 7 років тому +12

    You uploaded this just before my finals for Philosophy started last year, and Nietzsche was one of the main authors. My teacher pretty much left all the work up to me, with the exception of the names of his major works. If only I'd found you sooner, Dr. Peterson.

  • @Beofware
    @Beofware 7 років тому +11

    Seriously incredible stuff, Mr. Peterson. You speak so genuinely, and so truthfully that it FORCES me to see my pathological problems. Thank you so much.

  • @Herintruththelies
    @Herintruththelies 7 років тому +18

    Fascinating. It is refreshing to me to see someone marry Philosophy and Biology. I did not go to a university but I still read as much as I can about both Philo (Russell) and Bio (Darwin) and I often find myself thinking in a sort of fusion of the two disciplines. This was very illuminating. Thank you so much for sharing it with us plebs.

    • @nickstanton1090
      @nickstanton1090 3 роки тому

      Four years on I hope you don’t consider yourself a pleb.

    • @Herintruththelies
      @Herintruththelies 2 роки тому +1

      @@chrispywilliams1992 I thought he was insightful, broad, and helpful

    • @Herintruththelies
      @Herintruththelies 2 роки тому +1

      @@chrispywilliams1992 nope

  • @dustinjef
    @dustinjef 7 років тому +11

    I'm working though seeing all your videos and just want you to know the absolute love i have for you.

  • @funkyboodah
    @funkyboodah 8 років тому +23

    [21:51] Jung and Nietzche [51:23] The Death Of God [1:04:38] Death of God II

  • @timrichardson4018
    @timrichardson4018 5 років тому +5

    At 26:51. I have long admired Nietzsche's intellect and his diagnosis of the death of God, once I understood that it was more of a lament and a recognition that society was in serious moral trouble because of it. Hearing this statement of his, I'm struck by how Socratic it is (I'm more learned in Greek philosophy that 19th century). Socrates believed that all learning was remembering, that there is something eternal and shared about human cognition, foreshadows of Jung's idea of the collective unconscious.

  • @martinburrows6844
    @martinburrows6844 4 роки тому +7

    I've never listened so intently to anyone . Ever.
    Jordan Peterson.
    Outstanding brilliance with every utterance .

  • @awilda4807
    @awilda4807 8 років тому +6

    Thank you so much Professor for making these lectures possible to all and the convenience of one's surrounding. I've learned so much. Please continue providing lectures. You are helping so many people.

  • @afinedeadsound
    @afinedeadsound 7 років тому +4

    “Reasoning led [Levin] into doubt and kept him from seeing what he should and should not do. Yet when he did not think, but lived, he constantly felt in his soul the presence of an infallible judge who decided which of two possible actions was better and which was worse; and whenever he did not act as he should, he felt it at once. (791)” Tolstoy, Anna K.

  • @GelidGanef
    @GelidGanef 8 років тому +11

    The prof's inspired me lately to finally pick up "Thus Spake Zarathustra" which has been on my shelf for a while. Fucking genius. It takes me ten minutes to read a page. I wanna pick up a highlighter but I know I would just highlight everything. Can't think of anything I've read but the Gospels that profess such a unique and intelligent moral system.

    • @GelidGanef
      @GelidGanef 8 років тому

      ***** I took a break from Zarathustra to read The Glass Bead Game, which turned out to still be halfway about Nietzche. I feel like Herman Hesse was trying to express a middle way between the excesses of Nietzsche's philosophy and those of the church. Beautiful, and very archetypal story.
      Thanks for the recommendation. I may start on Beyond Good and Evil next before I finish Zarathustra. Zarathustra was lovely but a little long and very dense for a first encounter.

    • @dionhenderson
      @dionhenderson 7 років тому +1

      Natural Law is a fantastic moral system IMO.

  • @PexDoombringer
    @PexDoombringer 2 роки тому +1

    That concept of abstract death is mind-blowingly revealing. I can relate so much with it, that maybe I've suffered it and I didn't even know it.

  • @dessiec6489
    @dessiec6489 7 років тому +15

    I'm in the belly of the whale & can't articulate the spark needed to flame the fire. Thank Christ for men like Dr Peterson.

    • @r0n1n-
      @r0n1n- 6 років тому

      Cry it out, get angry at the situation and use that anger to face what's harming you, really ride the roller coaster and go with it without letting anxiety and judgement holding you back.
      And most importantly, never go null.
      Your comment is a year old now. So how are you now ?

    • @googlewantstoknowyourlocat1115
      @googlewantstoknowyourlocat1115 5 років тому

      @@r0n1n- what does "never go null" mean?

    • @Gallowglass7
      @Gallowglass7 3 роки тому

      4 years on I hope it worked for you and you're improving yourself. I feel ya

  • @rajab2852
    @rajab2852 7 років тому +4

    Illuminating elaboration! I had goosebumps watching this video!

  • @dhrumilbarot1431
    @dhrumilbarot1431 6 років тому +2

    you are incredibly inspiring and inspired me to look into psychology despite me being a computer engineering student ,from other part of world and exorbitantly motivated ..

  • @GAB-vq7re
    @GAB-vq7re 3 роки тому

    Went to continue watching my long list of JBP videos. Then the ads come up and one is an hour plus ad. Jonathan Haidt talking about anti fragility and the rise of psychopathology in the western world. First hour plus ad I've ever watched. Well done algorithm I will be watching more of this gentleman. Highly recommend if this pops up for anyone else watch it or at least go to the page and save it to watch later.

  • @Toxodos
    @Toxodos 7 років тому +66

    Here's my impression of Dr. Peterson
    >:( "It's like, good luck with that! Pathological bloody Neo-Marxists!"
    Seriously: Great channel, thanks for doing this, I'm learning a lot. Also thanks for being a voice of reason in that whole SJW-debate.

  • @HP-ow2up
    @HP-ow2up 3 роки тому +2

    Much food for thought here. Even better on second time of watching

  • @stancexpunks
    @stancexpunks 4 дні тому

    Would have loved to have had a professor like Dr Peterson when I went to university.

  • @TheMikeyp60
    @TheMikeyp60 4 роки тому +3

    Seems like the laughter has left the classroom after that first test

  • @3rdcoastnyucka
    @3rdcoastnyucka 7 років тому +2

    Not only is the lecture fascinating, but you watched the Robert Crumb documentary too? Awesome.

  • @UnluckyFatGuy
    @UnluckyFatGuy 7 років тому +1

    Few people know that Nietzsche is the glorious mustache not the man. Most of the works Dr. Peterson alludes to here can be attributed to it.

  • @jman2697
    @jman2697 8 років тому +91

    how could you boil a lobster to death knowing it belongs to a lobster society :^(

    • @pendejo6466
      @pendejo6466 8 років тому

      Homer Simpson did it, and he's the man.

    • @buffgarfield5250
      @buffgarfield5250 8 років тому +5

      I wish pinchy were here to enjoy this...

    • @jman2697
      @jman2697 8 років тому +1

      i wish that corporate greed is stricken down! lobsters have souls! lobsters have souls!
      but to be honest i dont think killing animals is nice, especially boiling them i think its very wrong.

    • @pendejo6466
      @pendejo6466 8 років тому

      J Man Everything you do is bad for someone.

    • @jman2697
      @jman2697 8 років тому +1

      well saving a lobster isnt bad for someone.

  • @JacksonTaylorandTheSinners
    @JacksonTaylorandTheSinners 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you so much for these videos. 🙏🙏🙏

  • @intraterrestrial5035
    @intraterrestrial5035 6 років тому +2

    1:07:40 the biological urge to crack the knuckles overrides the logical urge to resist

  • @hakimhakim389
    @hakimhakim389 2 роки тому

    No words can channel my gratefulness to you

  • @dcoburn88
    @dcoburn88 7 років тому +1

    I love your interest in finding connections and compliments between ancient and modern sources, as well as in integrating insights from science, psychology, psychotherapy, religion, mythology, etc. What is your take on Ken Wilbur's work?

  • @rileylaforge7640
    @rileylaforge7640 7 років тому +3

    I wish I could sit at a cafe and talk to you for an entire weekend. Ever come to Edmonton? haha

  • @zayed4675
    @zayed4675 Рік тому

    I don't think I quite understand what he said at the end. He read out Kierkegaard and Nietzsche, and they seem to say (in a massively oversimplified way) stop being lazy and do hard things. But how is that a solution to the death of God? There is no belief structure to guide action since the one predicated on God has collapsed. So how do you decide what to do? What hard things are worth doing?

  • @theguy9067
    @theguy9067 7 років тому +1

    i wonder if Jordan gives the students some of these statements of the philosophers to go think about BEFORE these lectures?

  • @alexsveles343
    @alexsveles343 Рік тому

    Philosophers and book writers are capable of 9bserving trend and moments inside a culture that vary few can.And dostoyewski and nietsche do just that,
    And givent that nobody else predicted the unfolding events but them its vary much accurate in considering them as prophets

  • @Sophia.
    @Sophia. 6 років тому +5

    A whose perspective? Piége?
    At around two minutes... I keep hearing this name but I have no clue, how it's spelled, so I cannot ask our god Google for more information and I haven't yet heard Dr. Peterson name a book of this man the title of which could lead me to the man's name...
    Anyone?

    • @sheiken9754
      @sheiken9754 2 роки тому +1

      Piaget

    • @Sophia.
      @Sophia. 2 роки тому

      @@sheiken9754 thanks :) came across him in other ways by now, but thanks nonetheless!

  • @symbolicmeta1942
    @symbolicmeta1942 7 років тому +1

    I saw you confirmed the 2015 version has much material that did not overlap with the 2016 version. So I wanted to know whether the 2014 was obsolete or not? Or is watching all 3 years worth while?

  • @fbidawi
    @fbidawi 7 років тому +4

    Very smart guy

  • @feelingluckyduck373
    @feelingluckyduck373 7 років тому

    If you haven't seen persistence hunting you should check it out. It expanded my understanding of the biological human as far as uprightness and the absence of fur for energy conservation and modulation. I used to think it was a funny thing that we had so much less fur than other apes.

  • @TUBULAR1213
    @TUBULAR1213 3 роки тому

    Your lectures bring together seemingly separate fields of human knowledge into a compelling narrative. I wish there was more of this approach in our liberal arts colleges and universities. I enjoyed and learned a lot. Thank you JP.

  • @Totemiaczek
    @Totemiaczek 7 років тому +2

    The internet is strange place i make full circle, Some time ago I start know Your persona from identity politics videos/stance, and last week i play game NieR: Automata what make me to look after some philosophy. The game was about "human condition" end "existentialism" in me opinion one of best game of the year [2017] and make me cry in scenes looking like asteroids. and after round of some wikipedia links.. some youtube videos I get to some of Your lectures on this topic.its nice for me how game spark interest to search for philosophy and i end leasing this in background at work.

  • @jeanneneumann461
    @jeanneneumann461 7 років тому +6

    I love his righteous heart

  • @nancymohass4891
    @nancymohass4891 5 років тому +4

    Dostoyevsky tried ( in his book the karamazov.....) to explain how people who love to listen to a big brother / church , etc. Are like children who do not like to be responsible ! They like to taken cared of, instate of having Freedom to choose , so did Nietzche who repeat after him : God is dead!
    They were not against God but against immaturity and irresponsibility of human beings !

  • @invin7215
    @invin7215 7 років тому +2

    Amazing.

  • @lunadog71
    @lunadog71 7 років тому +1

    I'd like to have references to the excerpts Dr. Peterson read.

  • @user-we2qv1cx6x
    @user-we2qv1cx6x 5 місяців тому

    This was great. I read all of these authors but heard some cool preservatives.

  • @tricorntom2254
    @tricorntom2254 6 років тому +1

    The camera angle is Alfred Hitchcock. Kind of matches the content.

  • @charlesfarrant6819
    @charlesfarrant6819 3 роки тому

    This is it. But i think every next is worth the gamble, i hope im not mistaken in thinking it can be on the whole for every self. maybe there's always a conflict, the baby and bath water are equally succession and suffering degradation, cheering hope and perfect corruption. Can we appreciate beauty in imagining the structure of our ignorance in extrapolating the known, rack the bars from the inside a little. will something always wrestle back in desire of death. death of what doesn't directly succeed in the end, and uplifting that which it painfully anchored. some reason we ache. Maybe that battle is what it's about, id rather not call any game quits yet though even if it'd be worth waiting for the next only by chance. I think the struggle on is it, and maybe we can agree to play nicely and it'll struggle on along side us, however there will be some godly collisions
    Loved this lecture

  • @AmalAmal-cx1ev
    @AmalAmal-cx1ev 6 років тому +1

    Thank you😮

  • @TheJojoaruba52
    @TheJojoaruba52 2 роки тому

    If you listen to this man, you will become truly educated in psychology.

  • @BigRed4231
    @BigRed4231 8 років тому +4

    What do you think is happening now in Europe with the radicalization on both left and right? The massive number of immigrants that is threatening the stability of the union, and the member countries. The polarization of the politics and peoples politic beliefs, all while the economic problems are growing bigger. I wonder ... will democracy survive the multicultural project?

  • @alexsveles343
    @alexsveles343 2 роки тому

    Notes from the underground or the first existentialist novel ever

  • @elitesenslaveus415
    @elitesenslaveus415 3 роки тому

    God I love Jordan Peterson

  • @billfriendtoanimals2953
    @billfriendtoanimals2953 2 роки тому

    I'd have to disagree with the human sensation of chills being comparable to an animal making itself seems larger, Awe vs.Threat. If that were true wouldn't before a fist fight we'd feel chills? What we do feel before a physical altercation is adrenaline, which shows itself in shaking, facial twitches, and maybe a red face due to blood pressure rising. I'd be curious to know what others experience with chills is like and what they think the cause is. Personally, when I come to a realization that I am not searching for enters my thoughts I experience chills. It is usually something that no outside source pushed it's way into my thinking, something like an original thought... Maybe I just need to really pay attention myself the next it happens? Comments are welcome :]

  • @helenbostock2350
    @helenbostock2350 2 роки тому

    Hi one of my personal treat are not good. I get anocey. When I see people doing stupid things. Silly is different idea. I give you an explain. Why do people sit in car lane try to turn right when they no right turn. Or shops turn up thier music to load I can think over loud music but it's put me personally of shopping. It not the first time it's the 24 time I see it or hear it. I thought chances was good. I changed a bit but other no not really. Then if I say anything peoples say why get angry. I don't feel child sometimes.

  • @williamotoole8668
    @williamotoole8668 4 роки тому +1

    Imagine if it came out, he was alone in the classroom talking aloud to himself lol

    • @jessemontano762
      @jessemontano762 3 роки тому

      Dude. That would be great. I'll be like, who is he looking at???

  • @FG-fc1yz
    @FG-fc1yz 3 роки тому +1

    4:09- 8:43 11:50 24:40 29:06,, 33:04 35:48 37:22 40:24,, 41:33,,-- 48:30 50:30,- (siehe 41:33-47:00) 51:25,,-- ("Gott ist tot") 52:25,, 55:25 59:43 Z 1:04:30,, EXPL 1:10:00

  • @Heyuhp
    @Heyuhp 3 роки тому

    "So brilliant, its a joy to encounter their thinking." That's who you are to us Peterson:)

  • @TheRevAndIsWorld
    @TheRevAndIsWorld 6 місяців тому

    hear life within existence first

  • @wilskr8
    @wilskr8 6 років тому +1

    38:21 kitkat!

  • @dustinbehnka4589
    @dustinbehnka4589 7 років тому +1

    With over 30,000 hits, he better be getting money from Coca Cola to drink that Coke 0 with the label facing the camera at 26:58.

  • @riblets1968
    @riblets1968 4 роки тому

    I gather then that Rodion Raskolnikov was such a mouse as Dostoevsky described in that passage.

  • @strangersound
    @strangersound 7 років тому +2

    The cup of coffee biological subsystem is extremely powerful in it's ability to distract. ;)

  • @gnuPirate
    @gnuPirate 6 років тому +3

    I think I understand most of what he says with reference to dominance hierarchies (so much interesting stuff) -- and I guess he allows room for the many actual exceptions to such beliefs as "people at the top of the hierarchy being more likely to breed" ---
    I think due to the way things are structured this is clearly no longer the case for humans -- with reference to such things as the movie "idiocracy" : Every unfortunate unfit "dumbass" (just as a loose description, for lack of me bothering to think of a better word) who feels like it can breed, and breed a LOT, and they DO (probably a lot more than people who may be far more "fit" to breed, say, from a deep, un-opinionated biological standpoint).... although maybe such dumbasses are at the top of a subset-hierarchy of dumbasses, and do not pass reference to larger structures, and the larger structures do not refer downwards :
    So : the way many things in society are currently structured is a bit of an upside-down pyramid, and will remain such, until the job-lot comes tumbling down.
    It's easy to see a lot of upside-down pyramids developing in society. For example, the cancer of management. There are many organisations with many more management and administration staff than the skilled people who actually do the work the organisation is purportedly supposed to do -- and I note that many times in such organisations, competence is actually not the selector for climbing upward into such managerial and executive structures (see "Dilbert", and everything in reality which that cartoon reflects).
    Competence is a selector to a distinct point .... and then no longer.

    • @EerieExpeditionEnigmas
      @EerieExpeditionEnigmas 5 років тому

      I completely agree with the upside-down hierarchy idea. Jordan Peterson often says that competence and industriousness ensure one's way up the dominance hierarchy, unless the society one lives in is extremely corrupt. Maybe I am biased because my country actually is extremely corrupt, but I wonder how much of his theory actually applies. Where I am from, some specific groups of people that are uneducated, unemployed and make a living illegally have around 5 or more children starting at a very young age. At the same time, the more educated people are less likely to have families and children. The natality rate is decreasing day by day, but not among those groups. Exactly as in Idiocracy. And I can also notice the overwhelming number of managers of all sorts, some of which are not even backed up by skilled people who actually produce something. As if competence was replaced by the capacity of being ostentatious and loud.
      Despite of all I said, I think Jordan Peterson's statements are meant to encourage, guide and support young people who are depressed or anxious, not to state universally applicable facts. I am ok with that, he does a really good job. Listening to him has helped me a lot.

    • @vargas0897
      @vargas0897 4 роки тому

      @@EerieExpeditionEnigmas Well, reading what you wrote, I have the feeling you answered the problem in the begining of your statement. JP says these 'rules' apply in societies that are not extremely corrupt. So if you say you live in an extremely corrupt society, that's where the problem lies. In healthy societies meritocracy and competence do play a big role in the climbing of the social ladder (or the hierarchy)

  • @KingoftheLizardz
    @KingoftheLizardz 3 роки тому

    Update on human evolution: Homo sapiens first appeared as early as 300,000 years ago from dating of Moroccan evidence

  • @chandrasekarsekar634
    @chandrasekarsekar634 4 роки тому +3

    Who is using Jordan Peterson lectures in lockdown .

  • @Rubashow
    @Rubashow 7 років тому +3

    We got to watch out for those Lobsters ...

  • @gnuPirate
    @gnuPirate 6 років тому +1

    26:54 this lecture brought to you by Coke Zero. The aspartame packed migraine-maker .

    • @FreeAmerica4Ever
      @FreeAmerica4Ever 5 років тому +1

      Judge not my friend. Everyone has their vices. Thankfully his doesn't stop him from being the best professor in modern history.

  • @helenbostock2350
    @helenbostock2350 2 роки тому

    Another personalty treat is I know I do know everything. When I talk to a friend tonight about drilling a wall he was interested so we talk. He says you know. Yes I away remind him not evertime.

  • @TijmenRaasveld
    @TijmenRaasveld 7 років тому +1

    what maniac actually took the time to subtitle an hour and 10 minute long lecture.

  • @gspolima
    @gspolima 15 днів тому

    56:35

  • @toddbukauskas8804
    @toddbukauskas8804 2 роки тому

    We know the universe is 14 billion years old?

  • @johnrobb889
    @johnrobb889 7 років тому

    Game of games. Lobster dominance hierarchies...

  • @CasLee
    @CasLee 7 років тому

    1:00:18 for coke zero

  • @TobiBaronski
    @TobiBaronski 7 років тому +1

    TIL when you die a virgin you literally lose The Game

  • @mahatmacharya
    @mahatmacharya 7 років тому

    "God is dead, out of pity for man hath God died"

    • @nadjiguemarful
      @nadjiguemarful 7 років тому

      why would his pity have come before his death

  • @BigRed4231
    @BigRed4231 8 років тому

    Can`t believe God managed to create this much mess in just 6 days. He for sure was not the idealistic-, artistic-type.

    • @TheEternalOuroboros
      @TheEternalOuroboros 5 років тому

      Dr. Phil - God is beyond any humanistic understanding, is he not?

  • @feelingluckyduck373
    @feelingluckyduck373 7 років тому

    Did you grow up going to church? Your mannerisms remind me of a preacher big time, or is it in your biology. I wonder?

    • @FreeAmerica4Ever
      @FreeAmerica4Ever 5 років тому

      I don't believe he did. But he's a well versed speaker and has done a lot of studying in every subject to do with communication, writing and how to make your point lol.

  • @atharvasalpekar204
    @atharvasalpekar204 3 роки тому

    33:04

    • @CourtClipsUSA
      @CourtClipsUSA 2 роки тому

      i'm at 31:37... 1:37 away from whatever you're highlighting 🥂

  • @MrJoycie1
    @MrJoycie1 2 роки тому

    Dont ✍️ mess✍️ with✍️ chimps✍️

  • @monstersisters8167
    @monstersisters8167 6 років тому

    Geez, he lost a lot of weight.

  • @susannec659
    @susannec659 4 роки тому

    Lobster Society playing games 400 million years ago

  • @mahaaalghamdi711
    @mahaaalghamdi711 4 роки тому

    why he keeps talking about evolution as a fact?

  • @edwardramize6690
    @edwardramize6690 3 роки тому

    The quarrelsome person appropriately attach because lion namely sneeze between a ashamed step-grandfather. halting, guiltless squirrel