AYYY I made the cut! Also, the Poppy Playtime tape!! AJ had told patrons about that shot in the VC right after the musical came out. I had been wondering if/when we'd ever get to see it! It's also interesting to see the effects makeup better, since it's hard to see that Riley has bruising or blood on her face in the musical. Either way, this video had me laughing... Way too much. See you all next week!
This is par for the course daily life with them. I've visited them, can confirm. I'm only mildly surprised that they decided to keep the entire 2+ minute tangent in the video!
You definitely deserve it! You've left some real gems over the years. I appreciate coming across them, even when they *don't* make it into a comments video.
So… how many times did Gwen die in this video? 😂 I feel for you, Gwen! There were so many times my reaction was the same as yours… 😆 Love the comments video! 💚
Even if that scrapped ending had been set in place, Poppy Playtime is one of the few games that have been given a confirmed "no." Also, Markiplier is super busy and probably wouldn't have been able to be cast as Huggy. Either way, it's a super fun secret ending, but it most likely wouldn't have teased anything if it had been canon.
I loved this, its nice to see you guys so relaxed and having fun, super excited for Dark Remains but take your time with it. Your sanity is more important to us then anything else and I know that no matter what you're going to amaze us. Take care guys your work is truley incredible. Also the urinal poop discussion has to be one of my favorite things ever, I can't believe I got so engaged in such a subject😂
i honestly support you guys and i just hope that you guys are doing well and everything and i am realy excited for the Fnaf dark remains or whatever it was
Honestly, y'all are AMAZING!!! You all made up my childhood with Baldi's Basics the musical! You all made me inspired to be a music artist and my sister has started filmmaking! I hope you all keep doing what you're doing! This song has been stuck in my head for the past 2 weeks, and I listen to it while I'm going to sleep! :D
I even didn't notised how I became this musical's fan. And Im watching every video about amanda the adventurer musical. I love it. You guys are great!❤
I believe that it is considered a musical and I’m a musical theater kid because like you guys said it is people playing characters and telling a story (and there is also singing)
If you pause at 3:49, (I think its from Sally face) and look at the symbols in the demon circle, you see zodiacs, except for the second to the left which is the RE symbol. Just a fun thing I saw.
I thought she died at the end because the monster dodged the brick. By that point, the monster was already there and attacking her. The TV had nothing to do with it.
6:53 as a person who does musical theater, I can confirm that this is true, because people ALWAYS GET PLAYS AND MUSICALS MIXED UP AND IT’S SO STUPID I HATE IT AH AH AH AH AH AH AH AH AH
I had a thought/question. I know y’all aren’t doing livestreams of the comments anymore, but would we be able to still select from a poll what video y’all pull comments from?
Unfortunately for you, that was just a teaser that had no plans of actually going anywhere. They have confirmed that Poppy Playtime is one of the few games that they will *never* made a musical for, for undisclosed legal reasons. Other content creators (namely, The Stupendium) have made songs for it that you're welcome to enjoy, though!
Some fans have done stage adaptations of it! (With RE's permission.) RE does their best work with a camera, where they can do as many re-takes as necessary... That doesn't exactly translate to "live theater" very well ;)
I saw this UA-cam video and I was in a car come back from my trip with two little girls so I couldn’t watch it and as soon as I got home, I went to my bed and watched it
Some fans have done stage adaptations of it! (With RE's permission.) RE does their best work with a camera, where they can do as many re-takes as necessary... That doesn't exactly translate to "live theater" very well ;)
sadly poppy playtime is a confirmed no wich is probably one of the reasons that ending was scrapped so they diddnt get people hyped for something that wouldnt happen
@mands1397 is just joking around, or he/she WANTS the Musicle with DragonSnow's "Changed"? Furryfans, who wants to see the first music video with original "Changed" song!?
AYYY I made the cut! Also, the Poppy Playtime tape!! AJ had told patrons about that shot in the VC right after the musical came out. I had been wondering if/when we'd ever get to see it! It's also interesting to see the effects makeup better, since it's hard to see that Riley has bruising or blood on her face in the musical. Either way, this video had me laughing... Way too much. See you all next week!
Ofc you did your like the most recognizable re fan
I'm glad we finally got to show that scene, too! Thanks for your comment, too!
@@REExtradoes that mean ur gonna make a poppy playtime musical?!??!?!
amzing RE xtra
@@Ramikar599 Unfortunately, no. Poppy Playtime is a confirmed "no" for undisclosed legal reasons.
I’m so sorry you have to put up with these two Gewn😂😂
This is par for the course daily life with them. I've visited them, can confirm. I'm only mildly surprised that they decided to keep the entire 2+ minute tangent in the video!
@@Nefenjo Nate cut it down... it went on for a while...
@@GwenPink That's... even less surprising!
Gwen's face during the discussion following the final comment was just... fantastic. :D
Ohh no🥺
Poor Gwen, hiding her face like that!😂😂
Also, can't stop, won't stop! I say let's have more musicals!
7:35 I finally made the comments list, after so many years. Thank you guys, this actually means a lot to me. And AJ your welcome 😊🙏🏻💚
You definitely deserve it! You've left some real gems over the years. I appreciate coming across them, even when they *don't* make it into a comments video.
So… how many times did Gwen die in this video? 😂 I feel for you, Gwen! There were so many times my reaction was the same as yours… 😆 Love the comments video! 💚
8:44 if you guys kept this ending in, we could’ve gotten a poppy playtime musical, and also Markiplier as huggy Wuggy
Even if that scrapped ending had been set in place, Poppy Playtime is one of the few games that have been given a confirmed "no." Also, Markiplier is super busy and probably wouldn't have been able to be cast as Huggy. Either way, it's a super fun secret ending, but it most likely wouldn't have teased anything if it had been canon.
@@CBLOfficialI am not aware of what they have said about making a Poppy's Playtime musical, why is it a confirmed no?
@@actualnoob85 Undisclosed legal reasons
Yeaaaaaaah probably not. 😅
@@CBLOfficial I said the Markiplier thing as a joke
I would absolutely watch a stage version!
I loved this, its nice to see you guys so relaxed and having fun, super excited for Dark Remains but take your time with it. Your sanity is more important to us then anything else and I know that no matter what you're going to amaze us. Take care guys your work is truley incredible.
Also the urinal poop discussion has to be one of my favorite things ever, I can't believe I got so engaged in such a subject😂
Gwen's blue tounge made me giggle 😂
Me too😂
01:25 I'm a different breed of human🙂👍🏻
i honestly support you guys and i just hope that you guys are doing well and everything and i am realy excited for the Fnaf dark remains or whatever it was
Im scared- I think Gwen is too. I bet if Gwen could she'd probably run away
The only thing I can look at is Gwen tounge being blue
Same. Its weird
Not just Nate and Aj talking about we’re to poop while Qwen just sat hiding behind her clipboard. Honestly that bit made laugh 😂
2:24 Gwen had enough of AJ🤣💙
Honestly, y'all are AMAZING!!! You all made up my childhood with Baldi's Basics the musical! You all made me inspired to be a music artist and my sister has started filmmaking! I hope you all keep doing what you're doing! This song has been stuck in my head for the past 2 weeks, and I listen to it while I'm going to sleep! :D
Gwen has a blue touge.
I even didn't notised how I became this musical's fan. And Im watching every video about amanda the adventurer musical. I love it. You guys are great!❤
I believe that it is considered a musical and I’m a musical theater kid because like you guys said it is people playing characters and telling a story (and there is also singing)
I'm actually crying when's face 9:44 and this 12:12
1:59 That was me, finally someone agrees with me😅
I have listened to the song so many times, and I can officially says that you guys said "Everything Rots" 12 times in the musical.
The comment where someone says that beard wasn’t in the musical he was actually in the musical when wooly said: maybe we should just buy some muffins
"I can't stop and I won't stop."
Hell yes.
Screw the haters, do what you enjoy. (ᵔᴥᵔ)
Great comments
Video on this game called gun's Gore and cannoli I think you could really make a fun musical out of that just suggestion
I love your guys music its so amazing❤and also you guys are so funny I actually daily listen to your music!I would love love to meet you guys.
10:24 “I WAS CHAINED TO A TABLE! 😡”
WHY YOU Nervous on RExtra🥺💛
7:44 I remember watching that video when I first started watching you guys! Granted it was 2020 or something like that, but still a long time ago!
Im so sorry you have to but up with these two Gwen😂😂
If you pause at 3:49, (I think its from Sally face) and look at the symbols in the demon circle, you see zodiacs, except for the second to the left which is the RE symbol. Just a fun thing I saw.
12:00 I'm dying! OMG! When you said "weird stuff in the next comment video" I didn't know you meant "*WEIRD* stuff in the next comment video!"
I'm crying laughing at how derailed the second to last comment went
I thought she died at the end because the monster dodged the brick. By that point, the monster was already there and attacking her. The TV had nothing to do with it.
6:53 as a person who does musical theater, I can confirm that this is true, because people ALWAYS GET PLAYS AND MUSICALS MIXED UP AND IT’S SO STUPID I HATE IT AH AH AH AH AH AH AH AH AH
14:06 BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! they're music videos are great!
9:34 I feel like I'm watching pirates decide how they're going to kill me. 0_0
love Gwen's blue tongue!!
I'm brave enough to watch it at 2am in a silent and dark room, gonna do it!
Anyone else getting distracted by Gwen's blue tongue? And wondering which blue candy/beverage she consumed?
7:28 you should do that. you need more multi-song musicals.
I had a thought/question. I know y’all aren’t doing livestreams of the comments anymore, but would we be able to still select from a poll what video y’all pull comments from?
12:11 gwen is so done with this 🤣
8:43 ohhh? Poppy Playtime the musical???? Maybeeeee?🤔
Unfortunately for you, that was just a teaser that had no plans of actually going anywhere. They have confirmed that Poppy Playtime is one of the few games that they will *never* made a musical for, for undisclosed legal reasons. Other content creators (namely, The Stupendium) have made songs for it that you're welcome to enjoy, though!
@@Nefenjo oh, I had no idea, thanks for letting me know! It was still a cool reference lol
What did Gwen eat to make her tongue blue?
Mt. Dew Summer Freeze, I think...
@@GwenPinkohh Gwen amzing
at 11:55 The comment is referencing the "Amanda the adventure but I ruined series" by PuffyMillie
Hey, that makes way more sense. That video was amazing!
now u shuld do a musical about colab don't starve together and cult of the lamb
there is a musical for both of those games
@@OtherRealMintyLemonTrue, but why not a song combining the two?
how on earth would that work@@peachymiku6432
@@peachymiku6432 that's what i mean
8:45 congrats you've scared me.
*A LOT*
I wonder if they are planning to do a Mr. hopp's 3 musical?
The Mr.Hopp series is sadly over and concluded with His Perfect Playhouse
@@OtherRealMintyLemon you sure?
i am@@Cereza626
You should do Fnaf the musical live at an actual theatre
Agreed, but they cast may be too busy for that.
*the
Some fans have done stage adaptations of it! (With RE's permission.) RE does their best work with a camera, where they can do as many re-takes as necessary... That doesn't exactly translate to "live theater" very well ;)
For everyone who needs a laugh today 11:56
9:02
⚠️ITS MAY MAKE YOU LAUGH TOO MUCH⚠️
Yippee new video 🎉
Question, was the “out there somewhere” section of the song inspired from CG5’s ATA song?
8:44 hmm... a poppy playtime tape. what could that mean?
is Gwen's Tongue Blue?????? I swear it is-
4:34 guys it's not to be rude or anything but the one in cult of the lamb was just a bit.. Christmasy for casual listening
4:53 DARN YOU NATE
I saw this UA-cam video and I was in a car come back from my trip with two little girls so I couldn’t watch it and as soon as I got home, I went to my bed and watched it
I think it would be cool if you did Fnaf the musical on a stage it would be epic :D
Some fans have done stage adaptations of it! (With RE's permission.) RE does their best work with a camera, where they can do as many re-takes as necessary... That doesn't exactly translate to "live theater" very well ;)
@@Nefenjo Ah ok! This was ment to be a reply to a comment but thanks for the info! :D
I feel bad for Gwen she is always ether the scary character or the person being attacked
Why aren’t you making any songs
As AJ said in the video, they've been working on the script (and some filming) for the FNAF project, Dark Remains.
How is aj able to do screaming and voices.
I wish Alssya Bass will come back.
Nice video
@RE Xtra
At 11:59 that comment is talking about the but I ruined it version by puffymille
8:43
That tape!!!!!
Will there be a sequel to Amanda the adventure the musical get like a sequel because I would love that?
18 times of everything rots
12:20 simple...poop in the sink
amanda is meky dora amanda🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
YO ENCOUNTING REFERENCE!
you should make an omori musical even though it’s really depressing 😭
its always a maybe
Hello REXTRA how are you to day
you said everything rots in the song a total of 8 times
8:42
is there gonna be a poppy playtime musical (im just saying that because of the tape)
sadly poppy playtime is a confirmed no wich is probably one of the reasons that ending was scrapped so they diddnt get people hyped for something that wouldnt happen
12:15 I just realized phamaphpia is playing
what is phamaphpia
@@OtherRealMintyLemon it’s another musical
no the phasmaphobia instrumental is playing not the phamaphpia instrumental @@nuklarguy679
Why was your tongue blue?
You had to use bill in every in your musicle
Hi
I did look like a Mikey mouse hat 😅
I was thinking yall can do poppy playtime
Changed? That would be too hard to make, beside, how the fuck is that game gonna even get approved for a video?
yeaaah but hey its always a maybe so you never know
AJS MOM
Hi AJ Hi Gwen hi nate hi nefenjo
Kirby musical please I beg u u have to give us a Kirby musical
its always a maybe
14:10. I'm interested but really hope they don't make a Changed musical cu'z the content of the game is nsfw
@mands1397 is just joking around, or he/she WANTS the Musicle with DragonSnow's "Changed"?
Furryfans, who wants to see the first music video with original "Changed" song!?
Aj can you do fnaf the musical
they............... did a fnaf musical------- there is like...... 6 of them.... 1 being in devlopment
15:05
I don’t get it why don’t make the entaty a puppet instead of a man in a costume 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡🫔
12:20
Atyauin
@BKR12198 i think the commet was a reference to puffymillie