can imagine being at that concert...hear the into...think..."nah they wont, they never play it".....then it kicks in with the real playing....and "OHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCCCCCCCCK!!"
@@novaseer If Cliff was still alive everything would probably still go as planned, but as Out Of Arkham said To Live is to Die wouldn't exist and Lars wouldn't be in the band.
@@fedora997 Blackened and other songs with Jason as a songwriting credit also wouldn't exist, and they probably wouldn't feel the need to write more angry songs such as Dyers Eve or Harvester of Sorrow.
He really is insanely precise. Fleming Rasmussen has said that during the recording of Master of Puppets, James would lay down an 8 track in one go and Fleming never had to edit any of it. That's to say James played an entire song 8 times in one go and did it flawlessly each time.
Jasons stage presence and backup vocals were beyond epic and perfect for Metallica, but Rob is a far superior player, the speed and tone from his fingers is just next level stuff way beyond Jasons ability.
@@tomm7733 yeah, jason energy was amazing, but i dont think he was a great bassist, not because he uses pick but because he played some songs whatever he wanted to and sometimes even ruining them, and lets be honest, his tone wasnt that great, he was a pretty standard bassist wich is not bad but robert is far more better bassist in almost every sense.
Yep in my opinion Robs vocals and finger picking fit Metallica a lot better than Jason’s picking and vocals. Like Jason’s vocals were definitely a lot better than robs but they just feel a bit intense for Metallica and only really work in creeping death and master of puppets.
I think this particular case it doesnt have a lot to do with the song being 20 years old, Lars wasnt able to play this song live back in the day, and not even in studio, thats why And Justice is full of edits and studio tricks to transform a mediocre drummer like Lars into a almost a prog drummer (and all Lars fanboys can try to explain how the hell he didnt came with such amazing ideas in Master of Puppets, which is an album thats only a little bit less complicated than AJFA). And about aging and being a drummer, i think it all has to do with the way you´ve been playing, someone who has been using correct techniques since he started to play, like Dave Lombardo, probably will be able to play for much longer time than someone who doesnt. There are other factors clearly, lets not forget that even Neil Peart ended his carreer with tentinithis, but if you play correctly from the beginning, your chances are better.
@@franciscor.1325 Lars was a beginner in drumming at the start of the Metallica, and he progressed a lot during his years, and no, his drumming wasn't modified in the studio, and he could've played it live back in the day. Do you need proof? Go check demo version of the song and you'll hear his double pedal with small mistakes, and those mistakes are the proof the demo version wasn't modified. And one more thing, during Master of puppets days he still had a tutor in drumming so it is completely normal to progress a lot in 2 years, and trust me I know what I'm talking about. I'm a drummer myself, and my brother is a professional jazz drummer and we grew up idolizing Lars back in the day. He just stopped practicing from 2002 and he aged, and those are the reason why he cant play like he used to.... and all those great fills he has in songs like Harvester of sorrow and stuff like that, he played them live back in the day. Not in Seattle which is the most viewed live version, but he played it in 1988, you have videos on youtube, google it before you accuse someone with so hard presumptions.... EDIT: Go check a tape from auditions with Jason and listen to his extremely fast bass pedal on fight fire with fire! His weakest link was tempo. not the ability to play the songs.... Back in the day he was practicing like an idiot, constantly, but when Cliff died, he took the burden of management and all that other stuff for the band, and one night Jason asked him, dude, why dont you practice more with us? His reply was: you don't know what kind of burden I'm carrying. You have to remember that Lars isn't just a drummer in Metallica. He is 90% of the Metallica! And his best techniques wasn't in AJFA, it was in Black album which you will probably dissagree bcs id doesnt have those fast fills, but it's not all in that! Lars and James are responsible for almost all songs from Metallica. And Cliff while he was still alive
@@terriblesamurai8850 went through both demo versions with Lars on drums that are available in the AJFA expanded edition. In the first one, from 1987, the double bass sucks, and in the one from 1988 they are playing it at least 20 bpms slower than the final version, and thats a big gap when you are playkng fast.
@Lana Drah He could’ve learned how to do double stroke kicks. Understandable if he’s not able to do the single stroke kicks at 194 bpm. But Lars has had plenty of time to learn kick doubles.
The mixing engineer deserves a raise. This performance sounds phenomenal, the band looks so good, and Rob's bass can be heard really good too. Just don't tell Lars.
Something amazing: When this song was first writen, Jason was Metallica's bassist. He played this song with a pick and had a little hard time. Rob plays it, live speed, with the fastest fingers I've ever seen.
Rob has said that when he got into Metallica, there were 2 songs that he wanted to play, and that hes been working on for a long time (at that time), those 2 being Dyers Eve and Frayed Ends of Sanity
@@JM00237 I agree it isn't as heavy, but the pitch and breath control were much better. He really learned how to sing and in my opinion it made for a much more listenable show
I've never been that much of a fan of Rob, always felt like he was kind of just "there," but I gotta say: he is the STAR of the show when it comes to playing Dyers Eve. Not only is he having to play this song with his fingers, a song that was written with a pick, but he doesnt get to rest his hands during the verses like James and Kirk do. He's pretty much playing his hardest non stop through 95% of the song. Hats off completely. Edit: not to mention they're playing this faster than the studio version which makes it even harder.
T.C.W Report Lol, just referring to the fact that he gets a little sloppy these days. P.S I have heard he has arthritis and can't hit those notes fast enough now.
+Vishal Sheth I honestly just think he doesn't care anymore. He's been playing the same riffs/solos for so long he probably wants to just improvise on most of them. Songs they rarely play being an exception to actually play the solo.
who cares if he didn't play the double bass... things don't always have to be like they were in the 80's... I'm pretty sure they didn't play the song in E-flat then either. Roll with it.
@@bigtommy9715 Nitpicking much? Everybody wanks off Seattle way too much, they played other shows you know?. A great performance all around here of a rarely played live song.
Nah, I saw it live in 2004 in Paris. They played this song a couple of times in between 2004 and 2010, and since then they were done, but I'm pretty sure it was a least 20 or more times... It's of ourse one of the most seldom song they've played live, so you were lucky (since they don't play it anymore) if you got to see it at least once!
From what I read, most youtube Metallica fans think Metallica should look like this: James Hetfield: rhythm guitar James Hetfield 1986 - 1989 (through time machines, because those are a thing): vocals Dave Lombardo: drums Not Kirk Hammett: lead guitar Jason Newsted: bass and backup vocals.
Rule number fucking 1 - Do NOT take what 'youtube Metallica fans' say or suggest regarding 'the band'. Your comment is ridiculous and proves rule number 1 to be taken as valid. Btw, the James Hetfield you want in your line up...or 'they' want, just so you know... wouldn't be the James Hetfield you think you know.. without Lars.
The crazy thing is first time hearing AJFA and going through the album. Sounds like harvester shortest straw frayed ends. Then you hit this fucking head smasher on the very last track. HOLY FUCK! It blew my face off first time I heard this gem
Holy crap, I'm blown away how good this sounds. Sure it's tuned down a bit but so are a lot of their songs nowadays. But James' rhythm hand is spot on and seemed like Kirk's was too!
This is one of the rare moments where I can say that Lars is killing it on the drums, even though he skips the double bass part. I love the way he's playing this time!
i'd forgotten how blistering this song is!!! They hammer it man!!!! Power in angst and ruthless precision crunch delivery!!! It just pummels you ... so tight and clean. And James sings it with raw energy. Blows me away ....
Everybody is complaining about Lars , Metallica give 2-3 hours concerts, and the drummer is the most exausthing instrument there, i´ve heard "Dave Lombardo still plays like 20 years ago, same age as Lars.." yes, but the Slayer concerts are 40-60 minutes or so, dont fuck with Lars.
Lars has said so himself in interviews he doesn't practice and has gotten worse over time. Its not age. Its laziness. Many drummers much older than him can play stuff way faster than Lars ever played.
Really? They couldn't play the intro? I understand why they wouldn't play the intros to Battery and Fight Fire With Fire, but why not Dyers Eve? There are no extra instruments, and it's relatively simple.
There is no intro to this song. What you're thinking of is actually the end of the song before it on the album which To Live is to Die. They played the entire song in that respect!
Anthony Kartsev Download an mp3 of "Dyers Eve" or buy an ...AJFA vinyl and skip to "Dyers Eve" and that intro will still be there. Want more proof it's the intro to the song? Why else would they play it over the PA system before the song started?
The way this song erupts at 45 seconds is just amazing! It grabs you by your throat and just punches you in the face. They should play this live more often :)
@C. Doom Schneider yeah. He's playing,g triplets with the kick drum. It's still double bass. Double bass and playing triplets aren't contradictory. In fact, he'd have to use double bass to play triplets because no one can play that fast on a single kick drum.
I just remembered how impressive it is that James plays that riff after the solo AND sing the lyrics. He does is it all the time, but with this riff it seems a little harder.
The Extinct Surgeon Doesn't stop bedroom drummers from playing it. But Lars, a professional drummer for over 30 years with the best equipment that money can buy...thinks he doesn't need to because he is famous. That is the problem. So many drummers could do what Lars does better and so much more, because they work so hard. Lars thinks "I'm famous" and lets his abilities slide.
Ronan Slevin Yup!..'Cos it's a pretty challenging song to play..not guitarwise,but for Lars the drummer.Back then,Lars was quite a competent Metal drummer..but well,he has slackened alot over the years after the "..And justice for all" album.so I think Lars is now trying to get back in shape(his drumming).lol!\m/I'm NOT saying Lars is an awful drummer..NO..it's just that he's aging and has fairly slackened in his drumming for the harder,heavier and faster Metallica songs,that's all.I fucking love ALL the old Metallica albums,particularly "..And justice for all."\m/\m/\m/
And let’s all thank Rob Trujillo it’s been said that he’s pushed for many of the classics that weren’t played much to be played more since he’s been in the band 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Heard this song at their show at parc des princes on the st anger tour, amazed at how they could still pull this off and yeah kirk is great with the solo
People are talking shit about Lars, talking good about James vocals and Kirk’s solo... is anyone going to talk about Robert’s performance??? He played this with fingers!
@@user-ih5jr8rt5q no way. I honestly don't understand the hype about this song. Sure it's a good song but for me personally not even a TOP 20 Metallica song, based on my taste of music. For me "One" is too lame and boring except of 1 or 2 minutes of the song. Just my personal opinion. I know many other Metallica fans think different.
@@Destruction-1990 wellyeah if you don't actually like dynamic music and are just in it for the fast heavy thrashy , that makes sense I recommend the band Iced Earth
My band cover Metallica song for more than 10 years, and still we hardly could play this live in a smooth proper and powerfull way.. They on their ages deserve a huge credit for this live performance...
Once per week I come here to make my day better watchong this raw priceless masterpiece live. Thanks for doing that back in 2009 guys.. simply nailed it 🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🔥🔥
Not a bad performance but it is an incomplete one. This song requires double kick, one of those iconic double bass songs in their catalog and it is not the same without it.
And every drummer in the world is same as Lombardo. Thank God that he still can play like that, but not everyone can be beast at young AND old age. Someone's amazing while young, but due to age, gets worse. I'm not defending Lars, he isn't practicing like before, and why should he tbh? He's got nothing to prove, you are the vocal minority that is shiting on him, he still sells the shows.
I don't care what everyone says. This sounds fukn AWESOME. I'm glad they played it. And at least Lars is using his bass pedals. Come one people it's not 1989
That’s why they keep putting out thrash cuz none of you dickriding fans care about a good performance you just wanna pay to see Metallica spit on ur face
I love these guys but I don't understand why they're rushing so much in their live performances of the past 10 years. Kirk's fingers get tangled and he screws up because Lars is going too fucking fast even for the album's version! This isn't cool fast, guys, this is too fast fast.
Arturo Fuenmayor You guys are nuts. I listen to their first 5 albums every other week, MoP and Justice are not this fast, there's a clear rushing here.
It's just disappointing to some that he's not blasting on the double bass during the verses like the album version... In some alternate universe there is a Lars Ulrich that always applies himself and is never complacent, and is widely regarded as one of metal's most influential drummers. He would be soo damn good if he was more motivated to practice/get better. Starting with the Black Album but mainly on Load is where Lars started to simplify his drumming. I mean, listen to ...And Justice For All drumming compared to Load, it's like two different people.
One of their most brutal songs. Friggin love it. Didn't notice Lars wasn't doing thr double bass in the chorus until halfway through. A little sad, but still love METALLICA!
Kirk, the fucking god absolutely lovely. I hope you read this kirk, because I want you to know how much I appreciate your playing, even though I'm a rhythm player and idolise James. You're an absolute legend in my eyes and always will be till the day I die.
Sounds amazing. Lars' double bass may not be exactly the same as the album, but to claim this is a poor performance from him is asinine. It's a great performance from everyone.
Before covid Metallica was playing a ton of shows a year alot of wear n tear on lars shoulders arms back and legs. It's amazing that he can still play these songs. Just appreciate it while we can
![Metallica: All Nightmare Long (Live in Mexico City) [Orgullo, Pasión, y Gloria]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ec9Z2jcCYCM/mqdefault.jpg)
![Metallica: All Nightmare Long (Live in Mexico City) [Orgullo, Pasión, y Gloria]](/img/tr.png)
This is the ultimate 'they should have played it back in the day' song.
Señor Romántico jkhbkc
Sad but true
I get chills even imagining this being played in Seattle '89.
@@Scarecrow545 yup, fuck. if u could go back in time and edit the setlist. +dyers +damage inc +full frayed ends etc :(
Jayeahms Godfield take a look at the new “Justice” remastered box set, they had played Damage, Inc. throughout that tour
This with Seattle 1989 energy would be deadly
@Adam he meant the concert you fruitcake
@Adam I'm from Seattle and this is very true
I'm glad I have that Seattle live on CD
so thankful to my nephew who bought it for me when I barely knew metal
you mean with seatle's 89 coke,would be deadly.but still they couldnt
caleb carriker and impossible, he plays 10-20% faster live. Think about it.
This is one of the most raw, chilling metal songs ever written. Mom, dad, love your kids.
Finally a call comment that at least mentioned the lyrical content lmao
Such a true comment 👊🏻
on point man ! love it
nahhh. I say treat them like shit, just make sure they know how to play the guitar first.
@@heisenbooger there's truth to this. Because then you get musical masterpieces like this.
"Cannot cope without UA-cam?" Wow James was way ahead of his time! Sorry, bad dad joke. haha.
Just came from two of your Dyers Eve videos! Possibly my favorite Metallica song too
Stuck with the tabs we all see, Art Of Guitar go and rescue them *wink wink*
love seeing you on every metallica video lol
He cannot cope without U2, it's his favorite band lol ok I'll see myself out
No, that was a GREAT joke.. Hahah. Kudos
No one’s gonna talk about how Kirk practically nailed the solo here?
thats what I was thinking lmao crazy solo
Same this is probably some the most complex solo he had written only second to Shortest Straw
Without the wah...
Everyone is too busy shitting on Lars to bring that up
Luchiini I was gonna say it but I scrolled down the comments first. Fuck yeah he nailed it !!! Legend
can imagine being at that concert...hear the into...think..."nah they wont, they never play it".....then it kicks in with the real playing....and "OHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCCCCCCCCK!!"
Can confirm
Then comes the first verse and you leave.
....
They wouldn’t have done this song if not for Robert! How many people can play that on bass WITH FINGERS!
@Jacob Burnett If Cliff was alive the song would not exist.
@@novaseer it would. But "To Live Is To Die" wouldn't.
@@novaseer If Cliff was still alive everything would probably still go as planned, but as Out Of Arkham said To Live is to Die wouldn't exist and Lars wouldn't be in the band.
@@fedora997 Blackened and other songs with Jason as a songwriting credit also wouldn't exist, and they probably wouldn't feel the need to write more angry songs such as Dyers Eve or Harvester of Sorrow.
@@novaseer Yeah
James is a picking riff machine. His precision is astonishing.
He really is insanely precise. Fleming Rasmussen has said that during the recording of Master of Puppets, James would lay down an 8 track in one go and Fleming never had to edit any of it.
That's to say James played an entire song 8 times in one go and did it flawlessly each time.
And everyone else...
@aqualung1466 Speedallica
Kirk is just as fast and plays all the solos, not sure why this overwhelming adulation for James exists.
check out Iced Earth and Jon Schaffer!
I'm a huge Jason Newsted fan, but seeing Rob doing this song on the bass live. Man, what a monster player.
Jasons stage presence and backup vocals were beyond epic and perfect for Metallica, but Rob is a far superior player, the speed and tone from his fingers is just next level stuff way beyond Jasons ability.
@@tomm7733 yeah, jason energy was amazing, but i dont think he was a great bassist, not because he uses pick but because he played some songs whatever he wanted to and sometimes even ruining them, and lets be honest, his tone wasnt that great, he was a pretty standard bassist wich is not bad but robert is far more better bassist in almost every sense.
I never could hear Jason’s tone…🤔….almost like it was lost in the mix somehow
Ever heard him play flamenco?? he's insane good!!! will blow your mind!!!
Yep in my opinion Robs vocals and finger picking fit Metallica a lot better than Jason’s picking and vocals. Like Jason’s vocals were definitely a lot better than robs but they just feel a bit intense for Metallica and only really work in creeping death and master of puppets.
1988:Dyers eve(367 Kick)
2009:Dyers eve(100 kick)
but i still love lars
yeah. its too hard now. Song for yong metallists
@C. Doom Schneider people age differently, u know?
I think this particular case it doesnt have a lot to do with the song being 20 years old, Lars wasnt able to play this song live back in the day, and not even in studio, thats why And Justice is full of edits and studio tricks to transform a mediocre drummer like Lars into a almost a prog drummer (and all Lars fanboys can try to explain how the hell he didnt came with such amazing ideas in Master of Puppets, which is an album thats only a little bit less complicated than AJFA). And about aging and being a drummer, i think it all has to do with the way you´ve been playing, someone who has been using correct techniques since he started to play, like Dave Lombardo, probably will be able to play for much longer time than someone who doesnt. There are other factors clearly, lets not forget that even Neil Peart ended his carreer with tentinithis, but if you play correctly from the beginning, your chances are better.
@@franciscor.1325 Lars was a beginner in drumming at the start of the Metallica, and he progressed a lot during his years, and no, his drumming wasn't modified in the studio, and he could've played it live back in the day. Do you need proof? Go check demo version of the song and you'll hear his double pedal with small mistakes, and those mistakes are the proof the demo version wasn't modified. And one more thing, during Master of puppets days he still had a tutor in drumming so it is completely normal to progress a lot in 2 years, and trust me I know what I'm talking about. I'm a drummer myself, and my brother is a professional jazz drummer and we grew up idolizing Lars back in the day. He just stopped practicing from 2002 and he aged, and those are the reason why he cant play like he used to.... and all those great fills he has in songs like Harvester of sorrow and stuff like that, he played them live back in the day. Not in Seattle which is the most viewed live version, but he played it in 1988, you have videos on youtube, google it before you accuse someone with so hard presumptions....
EDIT:
Go check a tape from auditions with Jason and listen to his extremely fast bass pedal on fight fire with fire! His weakest link was tempo. not the ability to play the songs....
Back in the day he was practicing like an idiot, constantly, but when Cliff died, he took the burden of management and all that other stuff for the band, and one night Jason asked him, dude, why dont you practice more with us? His reply was: you don't know what kind of burden I'm carrying. You have to remember that Lars isn't just a drummer in Metallica. He is 90% of the Metallica! And his best techniques wasn't in AJFA, it was in Black album which you will probably dissagree bcs id doesnt have those fast fills, but it's not all in that! Lars and James are responsible for almost all songs from Metallica. And Cliff while he was still alive
@@terriblesamurai8850 went through both demo versions with Lars on drums that are available in the AJFA expanded edition. In the first one, from 1987, the double bass sucks, and in the one from 1988 they are playing it at least 20 bpms slower than the final version, and thats a big gap when you are playkng fast.
well... at least you can hear the bass...
No double bass instead.
Trade off
@Lana Drah He could’ve learned how to do double stroke kicks. Understandable if he’s not able to do the single stroke kicks at 194 bpm. But Lars has had plenty of time to learn kick doubles.
Oh shit hahahaha savage
You could hear Jason, too
The mixing engineer deserves a raise. This performance sounds phenomenal, the band looks so good, and Rob's bass can be heard really good too. Just don't tell Lars.
I could barely hear Kirk
Something amazing:
When this song was first writen, Jason was Metallica's bassist. He played this song with a pick and had a little hard time.
Rob plays it, live speed, with the fastest fingers I've ever seen.
If we could just get robs fingers with Jason's vocals eh
are yall gonna stop shitting on jason for no reason?
Rob has said that when he got into Metallica, there were 2 songs that he wanted to play, and that hes been working on for a long time (at that time), those 2 being Dyers Eve and Frayed Ends of Sanity
Where is anyone shitting on him exactly ?
@@theamateurlancia omfg dude….🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
So fucking cool to hear Dyers Eve live, holy shit
2009 was definetely one of the high points of Kirk's guitar playing. That solo was flawless.
Im pretty sure that 09 was Metallica's best overall. I've watched Mexico and Quebec shows and boy does it match the 89
@@gansior4744 yeah too bad james voice isn't the same here as 89 still great
@@JM00237 I agree it isn't as heavy, but the pitch and breath control were much better. He really learned how to sing and in my opinion it made for a much more listenable show
Wow! Was actually really impressed with Kirks solo! Go Kirk!!
He nailed it!💪💪💪✌
This is undoubtedly the heaviest music of Metallica and one of the best...
For whom is quiet heavy
It's a very angry song from a very angry album. It's my favorite song of theirs. Arguably their fastest and most complex song to date.
Magic mirror damage inc!
Thing that should be is heaviest by far. It is D standard while almost everyother is E.
its angry and fast
Double Kick R.I.P † 1988
He stopped playing it somewhere around 2000.
Yet still in death magnetic
Still uses it in night mare and lords of summer
there was no double kick drum at all :( that is why they don't play this(great) song ussualy.
I think Burton makes this striking doubles on LP :)
giullianohammett double kick AND ride cymbal.
He changed them for a china.
I've never been that much of a fan of Rob, always felt like he was kind of just "there," but I gotta say: he is the STAR of the show when it comes to playing Dyers Eve. Not only is he having to play this song with his fingers, a song that was written with a pick, but he doesnt get to rest his hands during the verses like James and Kirk do. He's pretty much playing his hardest non stop through 95% of the song. Hats off completely.
Edit: not to mention they're playing this faster than the studio version which makes it even harder.
Rob is a beast
His speed and stamina are unmatched, and with this tone he absolutely steal the show. Not even gonna mention that power stance
Hé is the star. But he full color brother.
#beast
This whole concert is played at light speed
Kirk was fucking amazing!
Was? He's still alive.
T.C.W Report Lol, just referring to the fact that he gets a little sloppy these days.
P.S I have heard he has arthritis and can't hit those notes fast enough now.
+Vishal Sheth I honestly just think he doesn't care anymore. He's been playing the same riffs/solos for so long he probably wants to just improvise on most of them. Songs they rarely play being an exception to actually play the solo.
Gorge Deharo That's a bit harsh, the guys practice for hours everyday and care a lot about their music. Guess we'll find out in the new album.
Gotta give them credit, this was a really good performance all around.
Except for Lars, but it's a difficult song to play to begin with.
I've always defended Lars, but it's kinda weird why he didn't touch his second bass pedal In this song
When they recorded this song, the double bass were edited from studio. Lars didn´t play with double bass.
who cares if he didn't play the double bass... things don't always have to be like they were in the 80's... I'm pretty sure they didn't play the song in E-flat then either. Roll with it.
How do you know?
My jaw dropped when I heard Kirk’s solo
Perfectly played !!! 😃👍
James's vocals are pretty good on here.
@Shallex hey shallex found you again
Idk that “fucking lullaby” was weak as fuck
This songs vocals are so metal on the album it’s hard to compete
This shoulda been played at Seattle
@@bigtommy9715 Nitpicking much? Everybody wanks off Seattle way too much, they played other shows you know?. A great performance all around here of a rarely played live song.
Still sounds like volbeats singer
😃👍👍
Think how Lucky the audience is.
Metallica just played 2 time this song in live
35 times now
sounds like they've never played it live.
Nah, I saw it live in 2004 in Paris. They played this song a couple of times in between 2004 and 2010, and since then they were done, but I'm pretty sure it was a least 20 or more times... It's of ourse one of the most seldom song they've played live, so you were lucky (since they don't play it anymore) if you got to see it at least once!
Robert Trujillo feels every song he plays!
He is amazing!!
He "suffers" a lot on this one
(The riff si so fucking fast 😁👍)
In my opinion,this is more badass than frayed ends of sanity
Agreed
From what I read, most youtube Metallica fans think Metallica should look like this:
James Hetfield: rhythm guitar
James Hetfield 1986 - 1989 (through time machines, because those are a thing): vocals
Dave Lombardo: drums
Not Kirk Hammett: lead guitar
Jason Newsted: bass and backup vocals.
Rule number fucking 1 - Do NOT take what 'youtube Metallica fans' say or suggest regarding 'the band'.
Your comment is ridiculous and proves rule number 1 to be taken as valid.
Btw, the James Hetfield you want in your line up...or 'they' want, just so you know... wouldn't be the James Hetfield you think you know.. without Lars.
@@RobErt-zu4zs it was a joke
Rob M It was a fucking joke.
Dave Mustaine on Lead
@@RobErt-zu4zs it was a joke you fucking dumbass
The first metal song I became obsessed with.
Found my dad's old metallic Cassettes when I was 10 and this sing was nonstop!
The crazy thing is first time hearing AJFA and going through the album. Sounds like harvester shortest straw frayed ends. Then you hit this fucking head smasher on the very last track. HOLY FUCK! It blew my face off first time I heard this gem
Is it just me or is James' voice getting higher? It doesn't usually go that way.
Yes. It's called getting old. Happens to all of us.
LOL!Yeah!\m/
+T.C.W Report not to cliff
Ouch
How's your band ?
Holy crap, I'm blown away how good this sounds. Sure it's tuned down a bit but so are a lot of their songs nowadays. But James' rhythm hand is spot on and seemed like Kirk's was too!
DVD Proshot - Displayed at 360p
+Troy Durrance 27 Nov 2009
I don't even think you could send HD videos by UA-cam back then
DVD isn't HD. Bluray is.
+
@@WafunSk8 umm 1985 day on the green was 480p?
@@ivenalanko2462 what?
Kirk nailed it. A Difficult fast solo, Kirk, you are great.
one of their hardest songs, you can tell they're really concentrating haha but damn glad to see they're not retiring the hard stuff as they get older
2:15 holy shit that's concentration haha
Well, they haven't played it live since 2010 so I guess they've became too old now to play this one...
This is one of the rare moments where I can say that Lars is killing it on the drums, even though he skips the double bass part. I love the way he's playing this time!
i'd forgotten how blistering this song is!!! They hammer it man!!!! Power in angst and ruthless precision crunch delivery!!! It just pummels you ... so tight and clean. And James sings it with raw energy. Blows me away ....
Lmao they didn't even bother pitching down the intro tape to match the key, sounds hilarious as fuck when they kick in
LMAOism will win
indeed. At least in the 2004 tour they make the Intro and not a tape
Alyosha why do they even need an intro tape for this song? they can play it just fine
Josh White yeah lars can't
boy u peoplejust complain about everything haha, fucking overanalizying freaks xDD its a great performance
Hetfield may not be able to sing as well as he used to but fuck man, that right hand is like a hammer - as good as it ever was. Tight as hell...
Everybody is complaining about Lars , Metallica give 2-3 hours concerts, and the drummer is the most exausthing instrument there, i´ve heard "Dave Lombardo still plays like 20 years ago, same age as Lars.." yes, but the Slayer concerts are 40-60 minutes or so, dont fuck with Lars.
Shut up u dumb
Slayer sets are 90 minutes minimum.
@@christiandown seen them twice, that's false.
Lol, how long ago? Their 2019 tour was 90 minutes.ua-cam.com/video/PC-bKq8YJAU/v-deo.html
Well tbh Dave is by far a better drummer....
one of best Metallica's songs ever
With James' current raspy vocals right now, this would sound really good live.
Lars has said so himself in interviews he doesn't practice and has gotten worse over time. Its not age. Its laziness. Many drummers much older than him can play stuff way faster than Lars ever played.
а Ты не думал что Ларсу и не нужна практика ?! знаешь есть поговорка "что быстро делается то слепым родится" ))
Roses are red
Violets are blue
This comment is in English
The replies should be too
Kameron Ulibarri yessssss
Even still he uses double kick sparingly cos it apparently fucks with his back and legs
Yeah it does fuck with your back and leg if your technique is poor. Something you can prohibit by practicing. xD
When a song gets better the louder you play it, you know it's good.
Really? They couldn't play the intro? I understand why they wouldn't play the intros to Battery and Fight Fire With Fire, but why not Dyers Eve? There are no extra instruments, and it's relatively simple.
ČYLDЯØN ΔЯ SĪN BΛT ΔЯ NΔT HŒЯD
There is no intro to this song. What you're thinking of is actually the end of the song before it on the album which To Live is to Die. They played the entire song in that respect!
Anthony Kartsev
Download an mp3 of "Dyers Eve" or buy an ...AJFA vinyl and skip to "Dyers Eve" and that intro will still be there. Want more proof it's the intro to the song? Why else would they play it over the PA system before the song started?
just stop listening to metallica if you keep on complaining man. they really dont care.
Wrong. So very wrong.
these people are so lucky to get to see this song live. they havent played it that much in respect to the other ...and justice for all songs.
Where's the double pedal Lars?
Or need technical
***** just remember that they play like 2h each gig
***** They don't play over 2 hours and they're 2 different people.
***** Not so much for the money when he has enough to live 10 times.
waw jonne Actually its more like 3 and a half hours
Jesus christ. They pulled this one LIKE A BOSS in here. Amazing. Nailing any song of this record is btilliant homework.
No porque me canso :''v
-Lars
The way this song erupts at 45 seconds is just amazing! It grabs you by your throat and just punches you in the face. They should play this live more often :)
Ayee at 4:21 i see you Lars with those triplet bass kicks ;)
@C. Doom Schneider yeah. He's playing,g triplets with the kick drum. It's still double bass. Double bass and playing triplets aren't contradictory. In fact, he'd have to use double bass to play triplets because no one can play that fast on a single kick drum.
C. Doom Schneider When you try to prove somebody wrong but just make yourself look like a dumbass
@@brandonivey9973 I mean he's not wrong.
When James slicks his hair back like that, his voice is fucking amazing.
😄👍
amazing lyrics! James you are the best!
Definitely in my Top 3 of Metallica favorite songs!
20 years after they made the song and Lars is still banging those drums mercilessly....
I just remembered how impressive it is that James plays that riff after the solo AND sing the lyrics. He does is it all the time, but with this riff it seems a little harder.
this is one of the best metallica songs
I wish they perform this live more. Hell of a song!
I think James' singing is pretty good on this one
The fact that bass is so audible here is fantastic and I proves how fucking good rob is as a bass player.
that riff after the solo, why so badass??
Just they did not play it like studio version :(, still good though.
straightfoward thrash with a rhythm that hammers it home
Can we please have a video of just Rob playing the bass? Holy christ, he's so good here. Finger picking the WHOLE fucking song like a complete boss.
These guys look really old today but they still rock very hard! Metallica Rules! The Gods of Thrash-Heavy Metal
They don't play Dyers Eve live often
Ronan Slevin toughest metallica solo and toughest metallica drum beat (stamina wise its fucking hell), and well hetfield can play anything
The Extinct Surgeon Doesn't stop bedroom drummers from playing it. But Lars, a professional drummer for over 30 years with the best equipment that money can buy...thinks he doesn't need to because he is famous. That is the problem. So many drummers could do what Lars does better and so much more, because they work so hard. Lars thinks "I'm famous" and lets his abilities slide.
Goabnb94 ok
Ronan Slevin Yup!..'Cos it's a pretty challenging song to play..not guitarwise,but for Lars the drummer.Back then,Lars was quite a competent Metal drummer..but well,he has slackened alot over the years after the "..And justice for all" album.so I think Lars is now trying to get back in shape(his drumming).lol!\m/I'm NOT saying Lars is an awful drummer..NO..it's just that he's aging and has fairly slackened in his drumming for the harder,heavier and faster Metallica songs,that's all.I fucking love ALL the old Metallica albums,particularly "..And justice for all."\m/\m/\m/
That's because they could never play it with Jason. It sounded like shit with Jason.
And let’s all thank Rob Trujillo it’s been said that he’s pushed for many of the classics that weren’t played much to be played more since he’s been in the band 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Heard this song at their show at parc des princes on the st anger tour, amazed at how they could still pull this off and yeah kirk is great with the solo
People are talking shit about Lars, talking good about James vocals and Kirk’s solo...
is anyone going to talk about Robert’s performance??? He played this with fingers!
One of the best metal tracks ever from the best album ever played by the best band ever!!! Awesome \m/. No argument..
Otlichni svetlinni efekti, a myzikata i teksta i izpalnenie-poveche ot klasa! ❤❤😮😊🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤
Blackened and Dyers Eve the best songs of the album!!!
My 2 favorite on the whole album, great taste bro
you mean, after One ?
I agree, after One
@@user-ih5jr8rt5q no way. I honestly don't understand the hype about this song. Sure it's a good song but for me personally not even a TOP 20 Metallica song, based on my taste of music. For me "One" is too lame and boring except of 1 or 2 minutes of the song. Just my personal opinion. I know many other Metallica fans think different.
@@Destruction-1990 wellyeah if you don't actually like dynamic music and are just in it for the fast heavy thrashy , that makes sense
I recommend the band Iced Earth
@@user-ih5jr8rt5q for example, I love "Fade To Black", much better than "One"
Everyone: following the tempo mentallly
Lars: MY HEADPHONES TELL ME GO
My band cover Metallica song for more than 10 years, and still we hardly could play this live in a smooth proper and powerfull way.. They on their ages deserve a huge credit for this live performance...
Thank you for this upload,saw them at least 15 times through my youth, never seen them play my favorite!
Absolutely love that song one of the most underrated Metallica songs ever.Kirks solo is unreal
Always was one of my fav non-single if you will, tallica songs that yes..shoulda been preformed in seattle. It's a high energy song
Lars really shines in this song.
NO !!
not really the main verse is double bass and he doesnt do it.
@@Felix82 Chorus*
He sounds like he's changing speeds here and there...audio not clear throughout...same for Kirk's solo.
I wish they would play this in 2024!
Que buen tema suena muy bien metallica no pierde sus raíces. Desde Buenos Aires Argentina un fuerte abrazo
Double bass double bass.
Complain complain.
Just enjoy the song, people.
God, I'm glad being a pleb.
yes, enjoy this guys, they still play live and they still be the top metal band
Yay someone gets it 😂
One of Kirk's most technical solos. Yet. he needed no wah...
That bass tone is glorious
Once per week I come here to make my day better watchong this raw priceless masterpiece live. Thanks for doing that back in 2009 guys.. simply nailed it 🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🔥🔥
Lars, Lars... Poor Lars...
Hahahahaha
rich Lars
fuck you estupid loser, great perfomance
Not a bad performance but it is an incomplete one. This song requires double kick, one of those iconic double bass songs in their catalog and it is not the same without it.
Why the hate far Lars. Did he fart in your face or something?
Age is no excuse, Dave Lombardo is the same age and still playing like 20 years ago
Not everybody ages the same way.
And every drummer in the world is same as Lombardo. Thank God that he still can play like that, but not everyone can be beast at young AND old age. Someone's amazing while young, but due to age, gets worse. I'm not defending Lars, he isn't practicing like before, and why should he tbh? He's got nothing to prove, you are the vocal minority that is shiting on him, he still sells the shows.
Plus it's not like Lombardo is touring a fraction of what Metallica does.
yeah but dave plays 50 shows per tour,lars plays 300
Yeah and he's an exceptional jazz trained drummer... and probably takes crystal meth from time to time.
@3:45- James "Waaaaah"
Kirk- Yes
Kirk you nailed that solo dude!!!
I don't care what everyone says. This sounds fukn AWESOME. I'm glad they played it. And at least Lars is using his bass pedals. Come one people it's not 1989
Victor Sanchez what
That’s why they keep putting out thrash cuz none of you dickriding fans care about a good performance you just wanna pay to see Metallica spit on ur face
@@adrianfong5783 Are you high?
people love to hate on Lars
I love these guys but I don't understand why they're rushing so much in their live performances of the past 10 years.
Kirk's fingers get tangled and he screws up because Lars is going too fucking fast even for the album's version! This isn't cool fast, guys, this is too fast fast.
That's normal speed
its normal speed.
Arturo Fuenmayor You guys are nuts. I listen to their first 5 albums every other week, MoP and Justice are not this fast, there's a clear rushing here.
Pretty much @196bpm. You are wrong
This performance seems to be fairly normal speed, but yes, this is a common problem with them live.
probably my favourite Metallica song....very nicely done!
Was lucky enough to hear them perform this at Knebworth in 09. Highlight of the set
Everyone always blasting on Lars he kills it here!!
It's just disappointing to some that he's not blasting on the double bass during the verses like the album version...
In some alternate universe there is a Lars Ulrich that always applies himself and is never complacent, and is widely regarded as one of metal's most influential drummers. He would be soo damn good if he was more motivated to practice/get better. Starting with the Black Album but mainly on Load is where Lars started to simplify his drumming.
I mean, listen to ...And Justice For All drumming compared to Load, it's like two different people.
Lars is doing the double kick in this. You can see during the second verse and you can hear it. Lars is and will always be the man.
Are you deaf :), he did not play the most important double bass that goes during the verse, he changed a pattern/beat.
He’s not
The little 2 second part he’s doing it is NOT what we were wanting to hear
He’s a very good drummer, no one else could sound better for Metallica
One of their most brutal songs. Friggin love it. Didn't notice Lars wasn't doing thr double bass in the chorus until halfway through. A little sad, but still love METALLICA!
Absolutely awesome!!!
I'd like to say that Lars is a monster here. You discredit him way more than he deserves. He did amazing, give him that.
Wow, Metallica show her real talent, they should play this song more on concerts. Kirk nailed the fuckin solo!
Kirk, the fucking god
absolutely lovely. I hope you read this kirk, because I want you to know how much I appreciate your playing, even though I'm a rhythm player and idolise James.
You're an absolute legend in my eyes and always will be till the day I die.
I felt that, amazing!
Just impressive!
Sounds amazing. Lars' double bass may not be exactly the same as the album, but to claim this is a poor performance from him is asinine. It's a great performance from everyone.
Lars was awesome here
Wow this is the 1st time I’ve heard this one live. Very tight!!
Nice job fellas hope to hear it in Minneapolis in 2024
Before covid Metallica was playing a ton of shows a year alot of wear n tear on lars shoulders arms back and legs. It's amazing that he can still play these songs. Just appreciate it while we can