Sykes-Picot: Lines in the Sand (Ep 1) | Al Jazeera World

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 145

  • @masaharumorimoto4761
    @masaharumorimoto4761 8 років тому +73

    Documentaries like this are why I love Al Jazeera! Fantastic work!!!

  • @tankoahmed9296
    @tankoahmed9296 3 роки тому +5

    Historical technicalities of this sort make for better future historians and strategists - Bravo Al Jazeera

  • @donaldpharand7123
    @donaldpharand7123 5 років тому +12

    Great doc. Love the historic perspective on such important matters that are still on the front pages 100 years later. It is unfortunate this information is not front and center when the Palestine/Israel or any Mid-East matter hits the news.

    • @samluca1244
      @samluca1244 3 роки тому

      They're STILL trying to keep the lid back even after the secret of Sykes-Picot agreement was already revealed in 1917. The remaining actors involved still want the sykes -picot remains a mystery. After all, the agreement was conceived in secrecy.
      Bad for the perpetrators because in 1917 the bolshevik revolution took place and edged out the tsarist government who were part of the secret initiative to divide the middle east. The communist spilled the bean to the costernation of UK and France. UK was embarrased by the revelation. Its image drastically tarnished it forced one of its prime movers (Mcmahon) to resign.

    • @donaldpharand7123
      @donaldpharand7123 3 роки тому

      @@samluca1244 Where can I read more about the '17 revolution and Sykes-Picot connection? I did not know that.
      Thank you.

  • @DursunX
    @DursunX 8 років тому +53

    this is the reason why there will NEVER be peace in the Middle East.
    so sad

    • @soulscanner66
      @soulscanner66 8 років тому +7

      Iraq was secular and technologically advanced before the U.S. conquered it, so you're wrong. Foreign meddling and colonialism set it back.

    • @DursunX
      @DursunX 8 років тому +10

      +MANTLE religion and technology??
      Islamic scholars contributed inventions that changed the world./
      includ. hospitals, algebra, guitar, glasses/optics, coffee, cryptology, chemistry, immunization and other info readily available online and easily confirmed.

    • @soulscanner66
      @soulscanner66 8 років тому +6

      Dursun Sahin It actually extends to science too. Islam has no problem with evolution the way American Christianity does.

    • @emreus1
      @emreus1 8 років тому +4

      All regions had their dark ages.
      Byzantine was to your east and it was much more advanced in everything when Europe was a gloomy cloud. Get of your high horse please. People in the Middle East were closer to it then you ever would be. They inherited it much better than the Venetian envy and the Crusaders, which pillaged and ransacked the city to a tee, before the Ottomans ever breached the walls.
      We even have Celtic heritage sprinkled in this region dating back 300 BC. To presume that Europe was the only beacon of civilization is just a selfish allusion of grandeur.
      The current tacitness for this intrigue and double cross(Sykes-Picot) is making everything worse in the perception of any person regardless of their heritage. Unless they suffer from cognitive dissonance.
      It is easy to disregard millions of people as backward thinking and insignificant after you exploited them and all their generations that came after.
      This dramatization (video) ain't bad. Production is above average. But beyond the presentation all the talking points are facts. These and more.
      Accountability is the golden trait here, not excusing everything on the basis of ''Middle East was dark all along..''

    • @emreus1
      @emreus1 8 років тому +3

      Well the media we are talking under is based on the infamous intrigues which actually is nothing more than imperial ambitions. Yes the Middle East today is the fruit of western aspirations.
      Lacking acknowledgment about this crucial matter is saddening.
      The Middle East and Ottomans in general never left Trafalgar. They never ventured into the open seas. That was all there is to it.
      You can sugarcoat it however you like but in the end it boils down to that.

  • @TheSkcube
    @TheSkcube 8 років тому +30

    The British Empire - Shafting nations since 1915.

    • @jonathanmartin4125
      @jonathanmartin4125 7 років тому +6

      Selva KK a long time before that

    • @mitchkeller5055
      @mitchkeller5055 5 років тому +1

      A very long time before that. Try 1776. One could say the 30 or 100 years wars.

    • @aaammm1888
      @aaammm1888 5 років тому +2

      @@mitchkeller5055 from history i seen every empire has a end

    • @paololuckyluke2854
      @paololuckyluke2854 4 роки тому +1

      Everyone was shafting everyone, and some were better at it than others. There were differences in shafting styles, too, with some kinds being relatively civilized and others downright brutal.

  • @abrarhameem1000
    @abrarhameem1000 Місяць тому

    Amaizing documentary as always!
    Aljazeera documentaries keep impressing me more than expectation every time I tune in!

  • @irfand4
    @irfand4 8 років тому +26

    "He (M Sykes) gave himself the appearance of an expert, when in fact he was more of a gifted amateur".

  • @mohdataemohsineinsaniyatka7208
    @mohdataemohsineinsaniyatka7208 5 років тому +2

    Platinum period of Syria (1435I-2436A) N,. Masha Allah Tabaraka Allah!

  • @paololuckyluke2854
    @paololuckyluke2854 4 роки тому +5

    10:59 Since when is the most logical way of defeating an enemy to take on yet another? Selective truth from Al-Jazeera as is often the case. Germany and the Ottoman Empire were drawn to each other, yes, because of Russia’s threat to Turkey, but also because of the great value to Germany of transforming the Ottoman presence in the Middle East into a serious threat for Britain’s trade route with India. All this and more is clear from the first page of Cambon’s letter at 12:54, to which no attention is given!

  • @baskan123
    @baskan123 5 років тому +6

    Only 64000 have seen it? What a great documentary serie that Al jazeera makes.

  • @ibrahiemelfazarey7890
    @ibrahiemelfazarey7890 3 роки тому +3

    our nation will be return one again .. from egypt

    • @koksalceylan3934
      @koksalceylan3934 3 роки тому +1

      You nation was never one in the first place! The only time it was united was under the Ummayads, never again until the Ottoman times united for 400 years.

    • @Rami.2025
      @Rami.2025 3 роки тому

      It will return again! ان شاء الله but with Sisi about I don't think it will be from Egypt هههه

  • @Sammy-wu8gm
    @Sammy-wu8gm Рік тому +2

    “The British stole Palestine from the Palestinians and gave it to the Zionists” - Avi Shlaim, Israeli historian and academic writer

  • @Celevie
    @Celevie 8 років тому +40

    West was afraid of ottoman and thats the case to stop practicing muslim to come. together and establish khilafa again

    • @Celevie
      @Celevie 8 років тому +1

      +TheBrabon1 Well yes. No one defeated ottoman. It was crumbling due to their allegiance to shirk and innovations in Islam.

    • @TheYoucompaq
      @TheYoucompaq 8 років тому +9

      +Inherent Emperor Inshallah...the Caliphate will come back...

    • @Celevie
      @Celevie 8 років тому

      +TheYoucompaq Ameen. bro. The army of imam mehdi will come from Khorasan

    • @TheYoucompaq
      @TheYoucompaq 8 років тому

      Inherent Emperor inshallah...if u r in khotasan then u know dat ur progeny will b part of d army...

    • @Angrycomments
      @Angrycomments 4 роки тому

      I'd love to message you..???

  • @mohamedalhawary7949
    @mohamedalhawary7949 3 роки тому +5

    عشاق الألش خانة

  • @ducthangnguyen9519
    @ducthangnguyen9519 2 роки тому

    worthy the title lines in the sand.

  • @steveN111333
    @steveN111333 3 роки тому +5

    They way the guy portraying Picot goes in and out of English and French accents is hilarious ! :)

  • @cayetanosoler3432
    @cayetanosoler3432 3 роки тому +4

    Sykes-picot followed swiftly by Balfour ........What was WW1 about really ?

    • @JAJ1986
      @JAJ1986 3 роки тому

      Over Africa. 1885 Berlin Conference was a meeting between 14 european nations who would declare war on Africa and decide which nations would get what land, mainly for mineral resources hence countries like Ivory Coast (Cote d'ivoire), Nigeria, DRC etc. As the Germans got the short end of the stick, they declared war on Europe for the resources of Africa and subsequently went into France, Poland and the Rhineland as example for Coal, Timber and Farmland Respectively. Very insidious but was the main reason was for mineral resources and land control of Africa. Study the Berlin Conference more and you'll understand.

    • @nashmifarie9832
      @nashmifarie9832 2 роки тому +1

      @@JAJ1986 And they talk about human rights 🤡

    • @JAJ1986
      @JAJ1986 2 роки тому

      @@nashmifarie9832 And they have people thinking that the Arabs were innocent bystanders and they were BETRAYED, when in fact they've always been subordinate to europeans especially britain and france and they knew they were getting played plus they had ZERO entitlement to any land. Then again ARABS are europeans/whites anyway 🤐.

  • @jebrilabdulazeez
    @jebrilabdulazeez 8 років тому +19

    the french diplomat said. ;there is no saladiin to save the Arabs; it's true.

    • @koksalceylan3934
      @koksalceylan3934 3 роки тому +3

      Salahattin was not an Arab but a Kurd under Turkish command at the time.

    • @koksalceylan3934
      @koksalceylan3934 3 роки тому

      Israel will save the Arabs from tbere Petrol and lands.

    • @mariyabiswas3391
      @mariyabiswas3391 3 роки тому +3

      Saladin was a Muslim first then a kurd.He was not a nationalist.

    • @nashmifarie9832
      @nashmifarie9832 2 роки тому

      There are many Arabs such as Salah al-Din

    • @okyes5671
      @okyes5671 2 роки тому

      @Jay between 2008-2021 around 5600 Palestinians where killed. The total Palestinian population is around 4.8million if there was a “Holocaust” how come only around 0.001% of Palestinians have been killed 🤔

  • @user-nr5vm9ky6d
    @user-nr5vm9ky6d 4 роки тому +6

    Sykes and Picot destroyed the medel east

  • @mdalmomen5390
    @mdalmomen5390 Рік тому

    nice documentary

  • @TheBanmb
    @TheBanmb 8 років тому +14

    Ok i wanna play Europa Universalis after watching this

  • @ahmadosama460
    @ahmadosama460 3 роки тому +3

    هل فى نسخه مترجمه للوثائقى دا ياخونا

    • @ibrahim_habib
      @ibrahim_habib 3 роки тому

      ممكن تشغل الـCC وتختار auto translate للعربي ، مش أحسن ترجمة لكن بتبقى معقولة إلى حد ما.

    • @ahmadosama460
      @ahmadosama460 3 роки тому

      @@ibrahim_habib العربي مش متاح

  • @__Man__
    @__Man__ 4 роки тому +1

    You can divide but watch the ethnic and religious border. If you can't, better united them in one country.

  • @nick-jo3hy
    @nick-jo3hy 7 років тому +1

    Hi everyone
    I got distracted at 26:51 What is that big long building? Anyone know ?
    Otherwise thanks for the vid. It contains information that everyone ought to know but which many english people are not aware.

  • @Celevie
    @Celevie 8 років тому +3

    Hijaz was also under control of ottoman empire.. Which is not shown in thr mapm

    • @nashmifarie9832
      @nashmifarie9832 2 роки тому +1

      It is true that I am a resident of Hijaz, in the end, the Arabs cut off the heads of the Ottomans, and their cemeteries are now located in Saudi Arabia

    • @aaammm1888
      @aaammm1888 7 місяців тому

      @@nashmifarie9832 where can i learn more about this

  • @TrggrWarning
    @TrggrWarning Рік тому

    Please link series UA-cam takes us to your video page.

  • @peterbustin2683
    @peterbustin2683 Рік тому

    13:50 Leave the subtitles on as they are hilarious !

  •  5 років тому

    Not sure why, but this documentary is incorrectly stating that the Ottoman Empire joined WW1 after Bulgaria did. It's the other way around.

  • @Celevie
    @Celevie 8 років тому +2

    Istanbul was previously called as islambul..

    • @Max-ii3pj
      @Max-ii3pj 8 років тому +4

      Constantinople.

    • @stephen22564
      @stephen22564 8 років тому

      The Roman Constantine made it his headquarters hence the name :)

    • @sintasirait835
      @sintasirait835 5 років тому

      Konstantiniye

  • @johnsonsmith3421
    @johnsonsmith3421 Рік тому

    what a smart title name

  • @Chowmeister
    @Chowmeister 7 років тому +3

    that guys french accent though...

  • @KhalidAli-jc7cv
    @KhalidAli-jc7cv 3 роки тому

    Who is the woman speaking in the back

  • @Hadi_Merza
    @Hadi_Merza 8 років тому +10

    One thing is they didn't gave the Kurds their land (country(

    • @Hadi_Merza
      @Hadi_Merza 8 років тому +4

      tuco albert
      I'm Kurdish to brother I agree many hate us for no reason but I hope future will change

    • @mohammedhamad376
      @mohammedhamad376 7 років тому +2

      U kurds are one of the most oppressed people in the Middle East.

    • @shamimshaikh5521
      @shamimshaikh5521 3 роки тому +2

      Kurds are still being used by western governments to keep Turkey and middle east in check by the promise of Kurdistan. So sad

    • @nashmifarie9832
      @nashmifarie9832 2 роки тому

      @@shamimshaikh5521 The West are criminals who hide behind human rights

    • @salamyaya162
      @salamyaya162 2 роки тому +1

      The Kurds weren't independent before Sykes-Picot, they were ruled by the Ottomans.

  • @ctafrance
    @ctafrance 5 років тому +2

    Actually, I would call this a pretty badly produced documentary. It would be nice if it STARTED with showing a map and explaining exactly what Sykes and Picot agreed upon. Instead, it is spending a lot of time doing...what...development? I can find out much faster what the agreement said and see it on a map if I turn this off now and look up a text site. So that is what I will do.

  • @KhaledSelim
    @KhaledSelim 3 роки тому

    add soft Arabic subtitles please

  • @TISINLI2
    @TISINLI2 Рік тому

    27:06 he looks like a man from 1700s

  • @paparoni100
    @paparoni100 7 років тому +2

    sykes picto divided kurdish land in 4 pieces and gave it away to iran,Turkey, Syria, iraq

  • @عبدالرحمن-ذ8ث9و
    @عبدالرحمن-ذ8ث9و 3 роки тому

    أين الترجمة ياعرب

  • @elyasjan9943
    @elyasjan9943 3 роки тому

    Free Assyria

  • @hichamal-maghribi4600
    @hichamal-maghribi4600 2 роки тому +1

    If it wasn't for the islamic state, im sure nobody would've mentioned this

  • @كشوزير-ت5ض
    @كشوزير-ت5ض 3 роки тому

    عربى يا دولة

  • @orwaaboraad3390
    @orwaaboraad3390 3 роки тому

    الترجمة يا جزيرة

  • @micahshako8834
    @micahshako8834 8 років тому

    M

  • @SenerS10
    @SenerS10 6 років тому

    Sykes-Picot divided Turkish land in many pieces and gave it away to Syria, Iraq, Jordan, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Lebanon.

  • @psidhu1979
    @psidhu1979 7 років тому +1

    I hate it when its an English doco and they put waaaaay too much foreign language experts... you lose the concentration trying to read the interpretation

  • @thehonesttruth415
    @thehonesttruth415 4 роки тому +2

    i love sykes and picot for what they did. 😎

    • @Rami.2025
      @Rami.2025 3 роки тому +8

      however, they don't love you for trolling!

    • @thehonesttruth415
      @thehonesttruth415 3 роки тому +1

      @@Rami.2025 youre the one trolling me. i said i love them how is that trolling. stop hating.😂🤣

    • @Rami.2025
      @Rami.2025 3 роки тому +9

      @@thehonesttruth415 cool lol. I suppose we'll just let viewers make up their mind as to who is trolling

    • @thehonesttruth415
      @thehonesttruth415 3 роки тому

      @@Rami.2025 im sure you also love sykes, picot. 😎

  • @sumitw7
    @sumitw7 8 років тому

    Bad Narration..

    • @isbemorph
      @isbemorph 8 років тому

      +sumitw7 , i agreee.. those subtitles make it hard to watch and multitask at the same time, there should have been English narrative.