It is a twist that Galbaldon and/or the script writers have come up with for the finale episode. It is a neat trick, but it defies believability. 1. Why would Raymond take the infant? 2. How could the head nun or Claire be mistaken in the child's death? 3. How would the infant have remembered a song that Claire sang to her? It defies all logic and is pretty unbelievable after a couple of moments of thought. I think Season 8 is going to get very weird.
@@nweinflash Well, you have to suspend disbelief with any time travel story, but aspects of a story have to follow rules of the world that the author created. I think this twist violates the rules of world Gabaldon created, making it nearly impossible to suspend disbelief.
No. If you build a fantasy, it still will have rules. If you violate the rules, you lose the reader/ viewer. For the most part the books and series have followed the rules of the world the author built. This little trick is a bit of a stretch. I don't know if it will work out or not. It is going to take skillful writing to make it work.
It was certainly quite the twist. Can't wait for season 8 now.
Mother hildergard could have taken the baby to save Claire because Jamie is gone
0:58 Sentence makes no sense. I gather the first bit refers to dualing, and the second bit to the post delivery complications.
Faith died in France before Culloden. What are you people talking about?
It is a twist that Galbaldon and/or the script writers have come up with for the finale episode. It is a neat trick, but it defies believability. 1. Why would Raymond take the infant? 2. How could the head nun or Claire be mistaken in the child's death? 3. How would the infant have remembered a song that Claire sang to her? It defies all logic and is pretty unbelievable after a couple of moments of thought. I think Season 8 is going to get very weird.
The entire story is beyond believably 😂
@@nweinflash Well, you have to suspend disbelief with any time travel story, but aspects of a story have to follow rules of the world that the author created. I think this twist violates the rules of world Gabaldon created, making it nearly impossible to suspend disbelief.
So whatever they do is ok 😁
No. If you build a fantasy, it still will have rules. If you violate the rules, you lose the reader/ viewer. For the most part the books and series have followed the rules of the world the author built. This little trick is a bit of a stretch. I don't know if it will work out or not. It is going to take skillful writing to make it work.