Professor Avi Shlaim answers question about whether Zionism is a racist ideology

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
  • “Most certainly Zionism is a racist ideology and it is largely responsible for the Nakba."
    During the UK premiere event of the film Tantura, hosted by the International Centre of Justice for Palestinians (ICJP) in May, British-Israeli historian Avi Shlaim answered a question by Dr Azzam Tamimi about whether he considers Zionism to be a racist ideology and responsible for the Nakba.
    Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
    Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
    Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
    Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
    Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
    Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @fjordhellas4077
    @fjordhellas4077 Рік тому +1640

    Professor Shlaim, as a Jew myself who comes from Norway, I feel proud that a prominent Israeli like yourself speaks in the name of Humanity! You denounce the Apartheid regime embedded in the Zionist racist and criminal ideology, of Israel which is the antithesis of Judaism. I dissociate myself from that country and its criminal history against the Palestinian people.

    • @hrvatskinoahid1048
      @hrvatskinoahid1048 Рік тому

      For any Gentiles who do not accept and observe the Noahide Code, the Jews are commanded to expel them from the Land of Israel, and they are forbidden by Torah Law to dwell there (whether they are expelled or not).

    • @raidaradham4625
      @raidaradham4625 Рік тому +120

      You're a man of integrity and high moral conciseness and you deserve all the respect for your views of the tragic injustice forced upon the indigenous people of Palestine.

    • @palestinabaddie
      @palestinabaddie Рік тому +41

      👏🏻💗🇵🇸

    • @Rudolf_Bottler
      @Rudolf_Bottler Рік тому +29

      Veldig bra sagt👏🏽

    • @tutorialchief
      @tutorialchief Рік тому

      modern jews are not israelis, you are descendants of forcefully converted edomites, your own encyclopedia tells you that a modern jew has nothing to do with some monoethnic tribe called hebrews

  • @MohammedShafi-ou8bl
    @MohammedShafi-ou8bl Рік тому +584

    A decent human being who isn't afraid to tell the truth.

    • @netanelzion
      @netanelzion Рік тому +1

      which truth?the the racial features by which israel discriminates...avi shleim claimed he had "proofs" israel instigated bombings to make iraqi jews flee...maybe he has a proof that the 1941 baghdad riot,in which at least 180 jews were killed by huge islamists and pan arab mobs,was orchestrated by mossad(or maybe he is going to try and justify and it and say "they were suspected of being complicit in the British invasion of Iraq in 1941 and in the Nakba."(unarmed religious jews who lived in iraq for centuries).he relies on the so reliable records of the iraqi police(not racist at all...no simmele...)who put on trial 3 jews for those bombings(and now he says the bombing that killed 4 jews was done by arabs...isnt he in contradiction with his "sources"?)
      in israel you can say we discriminate on religious basis,sure.no racial criteria there.only country in the world to do so?say it to all muslim theocracies in the middle east,we would love to see which country has the most religious freedom in the us.
      maronites and syriacs,druze,orthodox jews,circassian muslims,samaritans and atheists born to all the above communities fight to make sure there isnt another 1929 hebron and safed massacre...

    • @MohammedShafi-ou8bl
      @MohammedShafi-ou8bl Рік тому +8

      The truth that "thou shall not kill". "Thou shall not steal "
      I thought that the 10 commandments were the basics of your belief system.
      Only the righteous shall inherit the kingdom of heaven.
      Paint it however you want, a wrong is a wrong! Whoever commits it!
      May God guide all of humanity! Aameen.

    • @SCBotanicals
      @SCBotanicals Рік тому

      @@netanelzion lol 😂 🥲truth hurts as we can see and the massacre your talking about 1929was done bc it was rumored that the zionist we’re gonna try to take over the mosque . And you left out the 1950-51 synagogue , in iraq .bombing by the zionists funded by mssod . Killing j ews inside

    • @tutorialchief
      @tutorialchief Рік тому

      why should he, they own our governments and are the only ones able to tell it and not get punished by the government, which they installed as fake jews, tell the same and you are a antisemite, which in reality you are not because they are converted edomites and not judeans or israelis

    • @fatimazenasni1880
      @fatimazenasni1880 Рік тому +1

      There is no higher value than our integrity.

  • @leoniegureghian7156
    @leoniegureghian7156 Рік тому +438

    I salute you Mr Shlaim & my deepest respect for being honest & speaking the facts!
    Thank you moreover 🌹

    • @leoniegureghian7156
      @leoniegureghian7156 Рік тому +3

      Is there his complete lecture section?
      That would be most educational & interesting!
      Thank you in advance 😊

    • @joseywales148
      @joseywales148 Рік тому +1

      Imagine if RFK had the ballz and guts to speak the truth about Israel… he lost my vote with the comments he made on Rogan’s show

    • @thegerm1397
      @thegerm1397 Рік тому

      ​@AtillaOguzHanOne of founders of Zionism was Theodore herzel.

    • @CaptainThach
      @CaptainThach Рік тому +3

      This VIDEO needs to be SENT to Joe Biden at his STAFF & also to the ADL “Anti Defamation League”

    • @thuggeegaming659
      @thuggeegaming659 Рік тому +3

      @AtillaOguzHan Ancient Israelites weren't even Jewish in the first place. They weren't even monotheistic, they were polytheistic. The name of their religion has been retroactively named as Yahwism. And it has more in common with Ancient Egyptian religion, than it does with Judaism.

  • @ZeroPointZap
    @ZeroPointZap Рік тому +423

    “The British stole Palestine from the Palestinians and gave it to the Zionists” - Avi Shlaim, Israeli historian and academic writer

    • @bryanbrookes6366
      @bryanbrookes6366 Рік тому +41

      As a British citizen I would like to apologise for the Balfour declaration which was a slap in the face to the Palestinian people. When the British were trying to drive the Ottoman empire out of Palestine it was the Arab tribes who helped liberate Jerusalem not the Zionists.

    • @y.l7455
      @y.l7455 Рік тому +12

      Interesting, and when was the palestine identity born? In the 1960s.
      From who Britain conquered Israel's land? Ottoman Empire.
      Was there any palestinian state, country or kingdom ever? No.
      Did the British and the UN gave the palestines the option to create their own state? Yes. Did the palestines use this option? No.

    • @y.l7455
      @y.l7455 Рік тому +3

      ​@@bryanbrookes6366
      The Jews and the Arabs helped the British. That was the reason of the Balfour declaration in the first place, so the Jews would have help Britain. And the Jews fought against the Ottomans even before Britain arrived, before the Arabs did a thing against the Ottomans.

    • @bryanbrookes6366
      @bryanbrookes6366 Рік тому +31

      @@y.l7455 I suggest you read the Balfour declaration as the zionists have not honoured the part that said should not prejudice civil and religious rights of any non--Jewish communities in Palestine

    • @y.l7455
      @y.l7455 Рік тому

      @@bryanbrookes6366
      The Zionists did do that part. Read the Declaration of Independence of Israel, Israel offered there peace for the Arabs. When Israel was establish it offered the Arabs peace to live in two states next to each other. The Arabs refused and declared a war. And still - those Arabs that didn't attack the Jews and Israel and didn't run away all got lately Israel's citizenship. Today 20% of Israelis are Muslims&Arabs that have full rights and are equel to the Jews in any possible way. And Israel has the freedom of religion.

  • @retrofedora7061
    @retrofedora7061 10 місяців тому +63

    Prof Shlaim & Prof Finkelstein always speak the truth. They are both jews but not zoinis. They speak against zoinis & injustice & stand with humanity, Stand with Palestine. May god protect them.

  • @pillarsofdoom4891
    @pillarsofdoom4891 11 місяців тому +347

    As a Muslim, I salute and admire courage of any man irrespective of sex, faith or religion. Courage of the truth and humanity and not courage of evil and lies.

    • @drivebyquipper
      @drivebyquipper 10 місяців тому

      Speaking of evil and lies ...

    • @karelbellic8480
      @karelbellic8480 10 місяців тому +6

      @drivebyquipper ah - he is muslim so he can't have an y humanity in him.
      That's... thats what you're pointing at. Right ?
      You didn't finish your post, so we're left to draw conclusions, that you're hurt, that a jew has pointed out that racism of the israeli state.

    • @drivebyquipper
      @drivebyquipper 10 місяців тому

      ​@@karelbellic8480 Lol! Give it a rest. He's just full of bull.

    • @cyrusparsa1724
      @cyrusparsa1724 9 місяців тому +5

      A country that classifies its citizens based on their race, religion or ethnicity won’t last in the long run. I think if Israel wants to keep the land it conquered, like USA taking Texas from Mexico, it needs to give the natives of that land full citizenship with equal rights, just like the native Mexicans who became Americans with full citizenship right after Texas was added to USA. Same with California.

    • @drivebyquipper
      @drivebyquipper 9 місяців тому

      @@cyrusparsa1724 You have it all mixed up. Texas? Lol! Why advertise your ignorance with a false equivalency? Even a fool who remains silent is perceived as a wise man. Could you give it a try?

  • @josephgee143
    @josephgee143 Рік тому +105

    Spoken by a fine example of a respectable gentleman, total respect to you Sir!
    May God bless you and let you be a role model for others.

  • @TruthSeeker12345
    @TruthSeeker12345 Рік тому +81

    Strong words from a truthful wise man...

  • @mrindia3710
    @mrindia3710 11 місяців тому +100

    How simply and honestly he has analysed the reality of Israelies.
    Hats off to his honesty .

  • @okhan1929
    @okhan1929 Рік тому +187

    What a decent,respectful,intelligent and overall truthfull human being,if only every hypocrite that believes Israel is doing no wrong could understand this narrative beautifully explained mad respect for this Gentleman ❤💯💯

    • @rizkhan3368
      @rizkhan3368 11 місяців тому +1

      I am sure the majority jews wish peace like him , but they have no say just like Palestinians, and many are duped by Israel govt with war rhetoric .....if they are shown the truth, they will change too

  • @karaklcmehmetosmanpasa3680
    @karaklcmehmetosmanpasa3680 Рік тому +232

    If the Jews say it themselves, it must be truth... Congratulations, Mr. Professor! 👏

    • @toassistindo
      @toassistindo Рік тому +7

      Ok so if a Jew says the opposite you’ll also accept?

    • @presentcalmmind
      @presentcalmmind Рік тому +1

      @@toassistindo you are a zionist troll , how much do they pay you? In USD or shekels

    • @presentcalmmind
      @presentcalmmind Рік тому

      Hell yeah it’s a fact and he’s not the first their have been Jews opposed to Zionism and the number is continuing to grow and Israel is going to internally dismantle itself.

    • @presentcalmmind
      @presentcalmmind Рік тому +17

      @@toassistindo you mad?

    • @toassistindo
      @toassistindo Рік тому +1

      @@presentcalmmind how do you mean?

  • @takeshi171
    @takeshi171 Рік тому +204

    SUPPORTING PALESTINE🇯🇵❤🇵🇸✊ FROM JAPAN
    ISRAEL APARTHEID STATE !!!!!
    BDS INTERNATIONAL ❤

  • @salahuddeenayyubi9515
    @salahuddeenayyubi9515 Рік тому +67

    Allah be with this Jewish gentleman

  • @amareto5772
    @amareto5772 Рік тому +172

    “Netanyahu is like the man who is negotiating with the division of the pizza while he is keep eating it”.
    Avi Shlaim

    • @salahuddeenayyubi9515
      @salahuddeenayyubi9515 Рік тому +3

      🤯👌

    • @jonlenihan4798
      @jonlenihan4798 Рік тому

      With whom is Netanyahu meant to negotiate? The Jew-haters and murderers of Islamic Jihad, Hamas or Fatah?

    • @muhammadahmadkhan9881
      @muhammadahmadkhan9881 11 місяців тому

      ​@@salahuddeenayyubi9515 Genocide barking dog speaking

    • @donnaw3765
      @donnaw3765 11 місяців тому +2

      @AtillaOguzHan Believe every book you read or simply the ones who push a false narrative?

    • @Kim_Jong_Un_.
      @Kim_Jong_Un_. 10 місяців тому +1

      ​@@donnaw3765it's true 🤣 Ashkenazi are from Japeth. Semites are from Shem

  • @deniseallemandou793
    @deniseallemandou793 Рік тому +39

    Absolutely brilliant, God bless you professor Shlaim.

  • @gazsm1
    @gazsm1 11 місяців тому +18

    I liken Israel to the book Frankenstein. As in the book, Dr Frankenstein created the monster that eventually killed him, but the real victim was the monster, not the doctor. Israel created Hamas by subjugating the Palestinians, and although Hamas are not the victims per se, the Palestinians are. As with the book, most people today don't actually read it, instead the rely on film adaptations where the true message of the book is lost... making Dr. Frankenstein out as the victim. Just like people don't really examine what goes on in Israel and Palestine, instead they listen to adaptations by the media. A media that makes them believe Palestinians are the monsters!

    • @AlexM-zp2ti
      @AlexM-zp2ti 9 місяців тому

      You mean the Golem story?

  • @GuenterLukasVideo
    @GuenterLukasVideo 11 місяців тому +26

    Why the hell can our western politician not say these obvious truth? Why do they help a racist state?

    • @jesuswept1334
      @jesuswept1334 10 місяців тому +5

      Why was everyone in the media silent about this? Were they forbidden to discuss it?

    • @stephaniecarrow4898
      @stephaniecarrow4898 10 місяців тому +6

      Financial, geopolitical and military benefits is all they care about.

    • @ashwaganda
      @ashwaganda 10 місяців тому +2

      @@stephaniecarrow4898 100%

    • @karelbellic8480
      @karelbellic8480 10 місяців тому +2

      In a word - money.

    • @NaturalMystic71
      @NaturalMystic71 10 місяців тому

      Because they are all racist imperialists.

  • @sammyogla7829
    @sammyogla7829 Рік тому +25

    as a Jordanian i truly have much much respect for avi

  • @5673mmmmm
    @5673mmmmm 11 місяців тому +22

    Before zionism all nations (jews, christians, muslims, buddhist) lives together with peace and helped for each others.
    But nowadays...????

  • @georgesrobreau647
    @georgesrobreau647 9 місяців тому +8

    After the Deir Yassine massacre, "On December 2, 1948, 29 American Jewish personalities including Hannah Arendt and Albert Einstein co-signed a letter[29] denouncing “the appearance of a political party closely related in its organization, its methods, its political philosophy and its social appeal to the Nazi parties and fascists." The political party Was the Menahem Begin party, the ancester of Netanyahu governement.

  • @hereitcomes3912
    @hereitcomes3912 Рік тому +39

    God bless this man

  • @matthummel8306
    @matthummel8306 Рік тому +18

    Israel literally has a law called jewish state nation which recognises israel as a jewish state. They also have the law of return for jewish people only. It is racist

    • @user-bo8nb2mi
      @user-bo8nb2mi Рік тому +1

      1.5 million Arab Israelis in Israel with equal rights and Arab on Supreme court. How many more than0 to 9 Jews in Arab countries? So who's really racist?

    • @matthummel8306
      @matthummel8306 Рік тому

      @@user-bo8nb2mi jews have been living under muslim for centuries lol. Look up when the ottoman saved jews from spain. Many jews from arab countries moved to israel when israel was created

    • @muhammadahmadkhan9881
      @muhammadahmadkhan9881 11 місяців тому

      ​@@user-bo8nb2miArabs Muslims treat other religion people equally and always think them as human beings.

    • @muhammadahmadkhan9881
      @muhammadahmadkhan9881 11 місяців тому

      ​@@user-bo8nb2miIsreal and Palestine were the lands of both Jews, Muslims and Christians. Main Problem is the Zionist that who came from different western countries to settle in the Isreal and the Palestines. And Zionist slowly starting to invade Isreal and Palestines territory. Half of the Jews run away from the Isreal and Palestines due to they were disturb from Zionist and half of Jews were become Zionist just like them. Only remains were the Muslims and Christians in Isreal and Palestines. These Zionist first started to genocide Muslims and Christians so that they will rule in Isreal. And Now they are doing genocide in Muslims and Christians in Palestine for ruling.

  • @stephaniecarrow4898
    @stephaniecarrow4898 10 місяців тому +12

    How softly, gently and clearly he speaks the truth. The truth does not have to be yelled; when it is spoken, people listen and recognize it. Only lies have to yell to try to drown it out.

  • @ra20sha
    @ra20sha Рік тому +30

    Truth speaker. A good man.

    • @user-bo8nb2mi
      @user-bo8nb2mi Рік тому

      So long as one parrots to your tune he is good. Otherwise evil?

  • @Ahmed-pf3lg
    @Ahmed-pf3lg Рік тому +13

    Some Jews have self-integrity at the end of the day. Respect, from an Arab.

  • @dabay200
    @dabay200 11 місяців тому +16

    Prof. Shlaim is absolutely correct

  • @andrescalvobarrantes2896
    @andrescalvobarrantes2896 3 місяці тому +3

    The calm yet demolishing logic of Mr Shlaim is commendable. He has lived so much...

  • @tara34952
    @tara34952 11 місяців тому +16

    Well said. Now if only our short-sighted and ignorant politicians could be so honest...

    • @ashwaganda
      @ashwaganda 10 місяців тому +1

      They are too greedy for that...

    • @karelbellic8480
      @karelbellic8480 10 місяців тому +1

      What,,and cut off the lucrative money train ???

  • @hell5457
    @hell5457 11 місяців тому +15

    Protect this man at all cost.

  • @remurems5637
    @remurems5637 11 місяців тому +11

    Thank You Prof. Shlaim for speaking the TRUTH, God bless you Sir!

  • @adriennemarierozario6591
    @adriennemarierozario6591 11 місяців тому +11

    Thank you for speaking the truth about Zionism! 👏👍

  • @berniesalem
    @berniesalem 10 місяців тому +9

    An honest man speaking truth.

  • @EugVR6
    @EugVR6 11 місяців тому +10

    100% Correct, Smart man👌🏼

  • @theshapeshifter1532
    @theshapeshifter1532 Рік тому +13

    My respect to this man : ↗️↗️↗️↗️↗️↗️

  • @abmzaman7863
    @abmzaman7863 Рік тому +16

    Thanks for the truth....

  • @Aurilaqq
    @Aurilaqq Рік тому +40

    So intelligent and well-spoken

  • @bossman674
    @bossman674 11 місяців тому +10

    Thank God for people like this man ❤

  • @scott1357
    @scott1357 Рік тому +59

    A Jew telling the truth. Amazing

    • @HenryTownsmyth
      @HenryTownsmyth Рік тому +2

      Also Norman Finkelstein

    • @netanelzion
      @netanelzion Рік тому +1

      an "muslim"(islamist)news channel listening instead of suicide bombing. but if you say the things they want and dont dare to criticise them,they are actually not so violent.

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому

      @AtillaOguzHan
      "There is no such country! 'Palestine' is a term the Zionists invented! There is no Palestine in the Bible. 'Palestine' is alien to us; it is the Zionists who introduced it." -- Awni Bey Abdul-Hadi, Secretary of the Arab Higher Committee, before the Peel Commission in 1937.
      The argus-eyed reader will be quick to note that Arab representation during the mandate period was the "Arab Higher Committe" and not the Palestinian Higher Committee.

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому

      @@HenryTownsmyth
      Lebanese American Princeton professor, Philip Hitti (1886-1978), who testified before the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry in Jerusalem in 1946 stated that, "There is no such thing as Palestine in history, absolutely not." Of course, what Hitti meant was that there was no Palestine in Arab history, in which he is correct. Hitti was opposed to even using the word Palestine in maps because it was "associated in the mind of the average American, and perhaps the Englishman too, with the Jews."

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому

      @AtillaOguzHan
      Professor Azmi Bishara (b. 1956), Israeli Arab, currently living in Qatar:
      "There is no "Palestinian nation" When were there any Palestinians?
      Until the end of the 19th century, Palestine was the south of 'Greater Syria' another recent invention. There is only an Arab nation!
      The word 'Palestine' itself is a colonial invention used by the Romans in order to erase the Jewish identity of Judea and Israel.
      Even the 'Palestinian National Charter' recognizes all the Jews living in the region prior to the 1948 war as "Palestinians"*
      Its an intellectual fad, divorced from the concerns of uneducated people."
      *The Palestine Liberation Organization original 1964 Covenant:
      Article 7. "Jews of Palestinian origin are considered Palestinians if they are willing to live peacefully and loyally in Palestine."

  • @wajidhayatali
    @wajidhayatali 11 місяців тому +6

    He spoke the truth although it maybe bitter and displeasing to people, including his own people. An honourable man

  • @albertroundtree8546
    @albertroundtree8546 Рік тому +22

    The Yankee Empire is crumbling so Israel will have to find a new host.

    • @Δογλογ
      @Δογλογ Рік тому

      never mind

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому +1

      There was an Israel before there was a Yankee Empire. Israel will be fine

    • @matthummel8306
      @matthummel8306 Рік тому +1

      ​@@cosimodirondo972lol, fine like getting kicked out and prosecuted everywhere they lived?

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому +1

      @@matthummel8306
      We must make peace with the suffering servant, the Jewish People.

    • @md.muzahidulislamsamrat8037
      @md.muzahidulislamsamrat8037 Рік тому

      @@cosimodirondo972
      “America is a thing you can move very easily.”
      Benjamin Netanyahu, 2001
      Source:
      ISRAELI INSIDER
      7/19/2010
      Having hollowed out US sovereignty and taken control of all major US media, Israel is a far greater threat to US independence than any other nation. Russia? China? They are nothing compared to the death grip Israel has on US democracy.

  • @noorzam72
    @noorzam72 11 місяців тому +8

    Mr. Shlaim said rightly, agree with you sir

  • @md.muzahidulislamsamrat8037
    @md.muzahidulislamsamrat8037 Рік тому +35

    Remember, every pro-Israel argument can be classified as either false or irrelevant. Many are both. Example: “Arabs left their villages voluntarily in 1948.” Even if a Palestinian left for a drunk weekend in Vegas, he still has the right to return. Period.

    • @user-bo8nb2mi
      @user-bo8nb2mi Рік тому

      So where were did hundreds of thousands of Jews kicked out of Arab countries disappear to?

  • @ॐIo
    @ॐIo Рік тому +21

    If only kind voices of people such as yourself were in power

  • @laurasantoscapilla9701
    @laurasantoscapilla9701 Рік тому +30

    Este señor tiene todo mis respetos por su gran honestidad intelectual, ha escrito varios libros al respecto que merece la pena conocer. Su labor de divulgación es muy importante porque al ser un judío israelí su postura adquiere un gran peso.
    Muy buen vídeo éste trayendo al Sr. Schlaim,gracias

  • @johnmccarthy1770
    @johnmccarthy1770 Рік тому +11

    What a great man

  • @HelenaEdelsztein
    @HelenaEdelsztein 11 місяців тому +5

    Salute your Brave statement. Thanks só much

  • @ThomasRutgers-rc7pc
    @ThomasRutgers-rc7pc Рік тому +10

    Please spread awareness of the plight of muslim minorities under hindu right government of Modi .lot worse than any other place

  • @iiTzHaroon
    @iiTzHaroon Рік тому +42

    Free Palestine

  • @markofsaltburn
    @markofsaltburn 10 місяців тому +4

    Came for the hair, stayed for the facts.

  • @0RiCeBuBbLeZ0
    @0RiCeBuBbLeZ0 11 місяців тому +4

    Why can't Palestine be that country for all? Why the need for an Israeli state?

  • @misstunes1765
    @misstunes1765 9 місяців тому +3

    While I respect and agree with. Mr. Shlaim, I must also add how impressed I am with his 'fro. 🙂

  • @cogthusiast1150
    @cogthusiast1150 11 місяців тому +8

    Much respect

  • @Woosaidthat
    @Woosaidthat 9 місяців тому +2

    Love this guy! His face shines of wisdom and knowledge

  • @deezznutts6036
    @deezznutts6036 11 місяців тому +7

    This guy is intelligent!

  • @ilirllukaci5345
    @ilirllukaci5345 11 місяців тому +4

    Sometimes it takes a very intelligent person to recognize the obvious.

  • @charlesdolphinboy
    @charlesdolphinboy Рік тому +6

    there you have it * amazingly clear * impunity must cease * 🇵🇸 give peace a chance 🎉

  • @makombeignatious
    @makombeignatious 11 місяців тому +4

    Raw objective facts. God bless you professor

  • @NotHuda
    @NotHuda 11 місяців тому +5

    thanks for saying the truth

  • @seletarroots3258
    @seletarroots3258 11 місяців тому +3

    Perhaps we can agree on calling it a racial ideology, one based in ethnicity and race and heredity, rather than some more amorphous idea of the "nation" that is more inclusive. And that when applied in reality, it inevitably leads to racist actions, although it is not the stated purpose or intention of the ideology as such. Which when contrasted with, say, White Power movements like the KKK who clearly are a racist ideology, will not yield an explicit racist motif or purpose for the ideology.

  • @JuanMateoUno
    @JuanMateoUno 11 місяців тому +2

    WOW, THANK YOU SIR. We need NOT add anything to that ..that sums it up in the perfect sense.

  • @jimfromwakanda7991
    @jimfromwakanda7991 Рік тому +7

    Great explanation

  • @ranasalem4075
    @ranasalem4075 7 місяців тому +1

    Wow.. This guy is so honest and knowledgeable.

  • @arfankhan1783
    @arfankhan1783 Рік тому +8

    Good man 👍🏻

  • @balanbaalis123
    @balanbaalis123 9 місяців тому +2

    Huge respect 🙏 👏 #freepalestine #freegaza ❤️

  • @ImGladImNaC
    @ImGladImNaC 11 місяців тому +3

    I like the Albino Afro reminds me of mine

  • @mzple
    @mzple 2 місяці тому +1

    As an American Jew I agree. I digest Ethno religious nationalism, whether it’s in Iran, or in Israel, no religious or ethic group should ever by favored by the state, one person one vote period, end of question.

  • @timblackwood1531
    @timblackwood1531 Рік тому +9

    “The tragedy of the people of Palestine is that their country was “given” by a foreign power to another people for the creation of a new state. The result was that many hundreds of thousands of innocent people were made permanently homeless. With every new conflict their numbers increased. How much longer is the world willing to endure this spectacle of wanton cruelty

    • @kayejones1482
      @kayejones1482 11 місяців тому +1

      You’ve summed up the situation perfectly.

    • @andym9571
      @andym9571 2 місяці тому

      It wasn't " given" by Britain. It was suggested by UN Resolution 181 ( 1947 )

  • @robinholland2990
    @robinholland2990 10 місяців тому +1

    I am a South African and yes the gentleman is totally correct here..now the huge gazillion dollar question is...drumroll drumroll......the UN imposed heavy sanctions including the USA and Britian etc on the then Apartheid regime yes regime and I'm so called white and a semite too and well here is my question...why is nothing being done regarding the current Israeli apartheid state???.....the UN is about fairness etc or is it???...frankly enough deeply learned Jewish minds have said what Avi has said now is it education and knowlwdge that the world should be listening to or the waffle we are being exposed to by the media networks and the IDF who are the puppets of the regime like we were as soldiers in the then SADF???....
    The elder speaks truth and wisdom fit and superb for any young mind wanting true knowledge..thank you elder...at 58 I still learn everyday from men and women your age to hopefully have a broad horizon and understanding..

  • @gulamhussainhassam-jn6pv
    @gulamhussainhassam-jn6pv 8 місяців тому +3

    'In 1937, Winston Churchill said of the Palestinians - I quote - 'I do not agree that the dog in a manger, has the final right to the manger, even though he may have lain there for a very long time. I do not admit that right.
    I do not admit for instance, that a great wrong has been done to the red Indians of America, or the black people of Australia. I do not admit that a wrong has been done to these people by the fact that a stronger race, a higher grade race, a more worldly - wise race, to put it that way, has come in and taken their place. '
    That set the trend for the Israeli states attitude towards Palestinians. In 1969, Israeli prime minister Golda Meir said - 'Palestinians do not exist
    Her successor, prime minister Levy Eshkol said
    - 'What are Palestinians? When I came here to Palestine there were 250 thousand non - jews, namely Arabs and bedouins. It was a desert, more than underdeveloped. Nothing.' Prime minister Menachem Begin calls Palestinians - 'two legged beasts.' Prime minister Yitzhak Shamir called them called them -
    'Grass hoppers who could be crushed!'
    This is the language of head of states, not the words of ordinary people.'

  • @phony75
    @phony75 21 день тому

    Said it perfectly. Thank you, Dr, Shlaim for your courage.

  • @tk3831
    @tk3831 Рік тому +7

    Finally, someone who understands the true nature of what is happening.

  • @1960Reem
    @1960Reem 10 місяців тому +2

    100% right .. proud of our British Iraqi Professor

  • @KNIGHT-TEMPLARS-888
    @KNIGHT-TEMPLARS-888 Рік тому +6

    My respect 🫡 for you Sir👍🍺

  • @abokareem7586
    @abokareem7586 Рік тому +6

    It is settler colonization, ethnic cleansing and apartheid regime.

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому

      Stop with the propaganda. It is not helping to bring peace to the region.

  • @connormcleod9595
    @connormcleod9595 10 місяців тому +2

    Well said sir.

  • @salvatori307
    @salvatori307 Рік тому +19

    One word Apartheid

    • @netanelzion
      @netanelzion Рік тому

      apartheid against what race?avi shlaim claims there is no such thing as jewish nation and that mizrahi jews(half the jews in israel)are arabs...avi shleim claimed he had "proofs" israel instigated bombings to make iraqi jews flee...maybe he has a proof that the 1941 baghdad riot,in which at least 180 jews were killed by huge islamists and pan arab mobs,was orchestrated by mossad(or maybe he is going to try and justify and it and say "they were suspected of being complicit in the British invasion of Iraq in 1941 and in the Nakba."(unarmed religious jews who lived in iraq for centuries).he relies on the so reliable records of the iraqi police(not racist at all...no simmele...)who put on trial 3 jews for those bombings(and now he says the bombing that killed 4 jews was done by arabs...isnt he in contradiction with his "sources"?)
      in israel you can say we discriminate on religious basis,sure.no racial criteria there.only country in the world to do so?say it to all muslim theocracies in the middle east,we would love to see which country has the most religious freedom in the us.
      maronites and syriacs,druze,orthodox jews,circassian muslims,samaritans and atheists born to all the above communities fight to make sure there isnt another 1929 hebron and safed massacre...

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому +2

      NO APARTHEID
      There are 15 Arab members in the Israeli parliament. Arab, Samer Haj Yehia, is chairman of Israel's largest bank, Leumi. Arab, Dr Masad Barhoum, is Director-General of Israel's Galilee Medical Center. Arab, George Karra, served as a judge on the Supreme Court of Israel until his retirement in 2022. No apartheid.
      The Arab party, Ra'am, was part of the Israeli government under PM Bennett from 2021-2022.
      It would interest you to know that three Arabs served in the first Israeli Knesset in 1949. They are, Tawfik Toubi; Seif-El-Din El-Zubi; Amin-Salim Jarjora.
      Arabs and Jews go to the same beaches; are patients at the same hospitals where they're attended to by both Arab and Jewish doctors.

    • @King_of_Antisemites
      @King_of_Antisemites Рік тому +3

      ​@@cosimodirondo972we aren't even talking about Jews here. We're talking about Zionists.

    • @charlescaudell9493
      @charlescaudell9493 Рік тому +1

      Yes apartied. Didn't you listen to a word he said? No. Of course you didn't.
      If Jews from around the world are allowed to settle in Palestine and displaced Palestinians are denied the right to return 5o their villages and very homes then this is apartied. Apartied by a racist settler colonial state of occupation.

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому +1

      @@King_of_Antisemites
      "Zionism is the return of the Jews to Judaism even before their return to the Jewish land." -- Theodor Herzl

  • @sdjslkdjlsskldjslkdjsl8262
    @sdjslkdjlsskldjslkdjsl8262 3 місяці тому +1

    Imagine if any other race on earth claimed to be "chosen by god." That's not just racist, it's megalomaniacally racist.

  • @kapunda6741
    @kapunda6741 10 місяців тому +3

    Apartheid was never this brutal. This is more like European Colonialism. Most of the Apartheid laws were already in place while the English were in power. Apartheid was just the scapegoat that is used by the West to this day. Apartheid did not kill 109 000 Hereros in Namibia, it did not kill 8 million Congolese, it did not kill 29 000 white women and children as well as 33000 blacks in concentration camps in South Africa, it did not kill millions of Indians, it did not destroy Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan etc with the loss of lives no also more than a million in the spreading of democracy and freedom. More or less 27 000 people died under Apartheid, where most of the killing was due to faction fighting between the ANC and the IFP. The Apartheid argument is lame. Call it what it is. Old European racist colonialism.

  • @drgregoryhaus
    @drgregoryhaus 10 місяців тому +1

    And yet they keep playing the antisemitic card for simply disagreeing with them 🤦‍♂

  • @anatolyzeldin612
    @anatolyzeldin612 Рік тому +8

    There were a lot of "good" Jews who after being baptized preached in sinagogues against their dark conservative brothers. It reminds me this "righteous" professor

    • @SCBotanicals
      @SCBotanicals Рік тому +1

      When you write baptized do you mean the purification rites in Halakha, Jewish law called tvilah?

    • @anatolyzeldin612
      @anatolyzeldin612 Рік тому

      @@SCBotanicals Conversed

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому

      "Baptized," as in converting to Christianity?

    • @Gabriel-dy6pm
      @Gabriel-dy6pm Рік тому +1

      Except that tmost Jews in most historical times were not Zionists. They converted to Zionism only in very recent times.

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому

      @@Gabriel-dy6pm
      Check out these paleo-Zionists:
      By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat,
      sat and wept, as we thought of Zion.
      There on the poplars, we hung up our
      lyres, for our captors asked us there
      for songs, our tormentors, for amusement,
      "Sing us one of the songs of Zion."
      How can we sing a song of the Lord on
      alien soil?
      If I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my
      right hand wither, let my tongue stick
      to my palate if I cease to think of you,
      if I do not keep Jerusalem in memory
      even at my happiest hour.
      Psalm 137:1-6

  • @pashapasha8785
    @pashapasha8785 11 місяців тому +2

    Free palestine❤stop zionismus,stop apartheid

  • @harriet4564
    @harriet4564 Рік тому +4

    God bless this beautiful truth telling soul ❤️

  • @bewisdom2
    @bewisdom2 Рік тому +5

    #FreePalestine

  • @andys2151
    @andys2151 Рік тому +4

    World peace starts from free strong PALESTINE 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸♥️♥️🇵🇸🇵🇸♥️😒🇵🇸🇵🇸♥️♥️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸♥️♥️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

    • @cosimodirondo972
      @cosimodirondo972 Рік тому

      World peace will start when the invaders from the Arabian Peninsula, and other places, return where they came from.

    • @fernandosuba9163
      @fernandosuba9163 Рік тому

      World peace started when we destroy allah and mohmad

  • @nileshdavda-t9r
    @nileshdavda-t9r 9 місяців тому +1

    Well spoken SIR, ❤

  • @anngray8224
    @anngray8224 Рік тому +5

    His hair alone is a state.

    • @laurenceegan6136
      @laurenceegan6136 Рік тому +1

      Maybe so, but at least it's not racist...

    • @audreymay9378
      @audreymay9378 11 місяців тому

      I ❤ his full hair of white hair

    • @alphonsemoonflee299
      @alphonsemoonflee299 11 місяців тому

      Me too. It's mad professor hair which is adorable, just like him.@@audreymay9378

  • @user-pz9uw1d07
    @user-pz9uw1d07 11 місяців тому +4

    Free Palestine and say NO to zionism. No to Israel occupation 🇨🇵🇵🇸

  • @AgimMehmeti-oo5gb
    @AgimMehmeti-oo5gb 11 місяців тому +3

    What USA,UK which brought this evil in middle east think about this opinion which absolutely correspond with facts,and social onesided medias what do they think....

    • @ajbudda1038
      @ajbudda1038 11 місяців тому

      That's the problem, we have the expectation that they will 🤔. They already have for quite some time, starting with 🎬 📰🗞️ and 📚 following up with 🔥☠️. Now WE have to RE 🤔 utilizing their usage of actual 📰🗞️ and referencing 🅰️Ⓜ️🪺ty INT 📚 as far as 08 and from multi cultural place with HQ in NYC, the place with all the flgs outside. Those two ✉️s + H'R'C 📚 specifically the one from a year ago THIS month and there days prior NEED to be screamed using the loudest 📢 reaching all of the 🌍. But It's an expensive 📢, the only person I can think of that may and financial can is the 👑 of Jordan seeing that more 🇵🇸 live there than the locals. Please forgive my "grammar". It appears to me that in the last couple 🗓️ , 👽 are abducting more than just humans now, not kidding 🤐

    • @andym9571
      @andym9571 2 місяці тому

      UK was not responsible for a Jewish State. Read the whole of the Balfour Declaration. UN Resolution 181 ( 1947 ) was responsible for that

  • @MMusa-gy7qb
    @MMusa-gy7qb 11 місяців тому +2

    Love from occupied Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤

  • @omranaldweikat6159
    @omranaldweikat6159 11 місяців тому +3

    Palestine will be free

    • @Dienekes678
      @Dienekes678 11 місяців тому +1

      Free from the Satanic Hamas cowards, hopefully.

    • @perc30
      @perc30 11 місяців тому

      @@Dienekes678Palestine≠Hamas

  • @manraman2826
    @manraman2826 3 місяці тому +1

    Thats the thruth ,thanks you prof. Free palestine.

  • @majl7917
    @majl7917 10 місяців тому +3

    Sir, I am from the future and you are wrong. Israel is a democratic apartheid state engaging in peaceful genocide. So yes, Israel can be everything at once. Also, the world has gone completely mad. ❤

  • @jayrwickerman
    @jayrwickerman 4 місяці тому +1

    Secularism is the way to freedom.❤🌻☮️

  • @halakurshov1380
    @halakurshov1380 Рік тому +2

    #freePalestine 🇵🇸

  • @lidusok
    @lidusok 10 місяців тому +1

    Thank you for the truth

  • @Δογλογ
    @Δογλογ Рік тому +2

    👏🏻👏🏽👏🏼👏🏿👏👏🏽👏🏼👏🏿👏🏻👏👏🏼👏👏🏻👏🏿👏🏽👏🏼👏🏻👏👏🏿👏🏽👏🏼👏🏽
    Namaste ΗΩΜ ΤΗΑΤ ΣΗΑΤ la ilah illa alllah
    AMDG AVE

  • @charlenethechandlerbeairst1423
    @charlenethechandlerbeairst1423 10 місяців тому +1

    Everyone on earth is FREE
    THE WORD OF GOD IS FREE

  • @notvisible755
    @notvisible755 Рік тому +5

    Jordan 🇯🇴 is Palestine 🇸🇩
    Palestine 🇸🇩 is Jordan 🇯🇴

    • @SCBotanicals
      @SCBotanicals Рік тому

      zionism is Nazism! that makes the supporters 🫵the same !

    • @AzadAli-re2fz
      @AzadAli-re2fz Рік тому +7

      Repeating won't help

    • @xfinity8602
      @xfinity8602 Рік тому +8

      I can't take you seriously. Actually, cant take any of you people seriously with your claim. It is the same as Israel is Europe and Europe is Israel.
      In your case, you have the wrong flag. You have the Sudan's flag. Which shows the lack of education that you might have. Again, a similar trait amongst those who share your claim.

    • @notvisible755
      @notvisible755 Рік тому +1

      @@AzadAli-re2fz
      It means that the people who refer to themselves as Palestinian belong in Jordan.

    • @notvisible755
      @notvisible755 Рік тому +1

      @@xfinity8602
      It's a variation of the pan Arab flag. In any case, there is no Palestine and they could just as well fly the colors of Narnia.
      Jordan was artificially created from historical Israel by the British.
      It's 90% Pali.
      My post stands.

  • @johnrandom
    @johnrandom Рік тому +8

    Israel defines itself as a Jewish state, which means that, from their point of view, more non-Jewish citizens of Israel are a bad thing. So to me, that is racist, since it shows a preference for one group over the other, even though other groups have equal rights under the law in Israel, so far as I know. The question for me is, is this wrong? Jews are in the minority everywhere else. Why shouldn't there be one place where Jews are and stay the majority, and are in control over their destiny? Besides, other groups can live and do well there, also. There are many Arab and Muslim countries where Arabs and Muslims are the majority and in control, and want it to stay that way. Why should the Jews be any different? I believe that every religious and ethnic group should have at least one territory where they are the majority and in control. Those who wish to live in multicultural and multiracial societies can do so; those who wish to live in a society where their own group is in the majority and in control should have the right to do so, also. The world is big enough to accommodate both preferences. Also, Israel is the ancestral homeland of the Jews; doesn't this give them a right to live there, now?

    • @SCBotanicals
      @SCBotanicals Рік тому +16

      Zionism isnt j udaism!
      The Land cannot be sold in perpetuity” says the Torah , “for the Land is Mine, and you are residents and sojourners with Me.” The Land belongs to G-d, and we are no more than His tenants upon it.
      Certainly according to the Torah G-d has promised us the land as an eternal inheritance, but the Almighty has not vouchsafed us ownership. We dwell on the land at His pleasure, always on condition.
      when he said that we belong to the land: We are servants of its moral demands. Divine morality is personified as the moral conscience of the land. Living on the land is not a right but a privilege, and it carries with it certain obligations.
      These obligations are many, but the one most oft repeated by the Torah is not to mistreat the sojourner, for you know what it is like to be a sojourner, for you were sojourners in the land of Egypt. We are G-d’s sojourners on the land, and the Palestinians are our sojourners. They are our litmus test. Our treatment towards them will show if we truly understand who we are and what our status on the land is in G-d’s eyes.
      The Book of Deuteronomy warns us of the mindset of “my power and my might have gotten me all this wealth”. Power corrupts. For the first time in 2000 years the Jewish People have real political and military power, and I fear that it has gone to our head. Worse still, it has corrupted our religious ideology. We act as if G-d’s promise of the land is equivalent to absolute ownership and as if absolute ownership allows us to trample the rights and the dignity of the indigenous Palestinians. We behave as if the Land is ours and as if the Palestinians are therefore ours to do with them as we please. It is not and they are not.

    • @Δογλογ
      @Δογλογ Рік тому +1

      nürhnberg vaticanist look alike error .

    • @toassistindo
      @toassistindo Рік тому +3

      Israel is the home of the Jewish people with equal rights to all citizens. Jews are a people / nation with a particular religion. Is it racist that Georgia is for Georgians? Or Armenia for Armenians? Or Italy for Italians?

    • @SCBotanicals
      @SCBotanicals Рік тому +11

      @@toassistindo 🤣you talk as if the Palestinians are free to move around . Stick to your knowledge of India

    • @toassistindo
      @toassistindo Рік тому +2

      @@SCBotanicals they are. The Palestinian citizens of Israel are. Those who are not citizens need to cross a border like any other country

  • @krogenfeldt
    @krogenfeldt 11 місяців тому +2

    And John Kirby and all USA adiminstrations teach other countries about human rights and democracy. 😂😂😂