To me, The One Edp has the best looking bottle of everything i have seen, simple but so classy. That in combination with the color of the juice and the gradient , it is perfect. So satisfying and the fragrance smell so good!
Whew! I just bought this for my son's 26th birthday coming up, and now I can tell him it comes with ATH's seal of approval (he trusts you).😁I'd gotten him Chanel Allure Homme last Christmas, but it may be a bit mature for him. He is a Tobacco Vanille lover, and I agree that someone who enjoys that scent will also most likely appreciate this One.
@@NiAudaxNeObstes Chanel Allure Homme is a fantastic perfume for any age, especially if he’s 26 years old… I wouldn’t say it’s too mature for him, I hope he enjoyed it, my dad used to have it when I was a kid and I absolutely loved that perfume… it’s amazing :)
Thank god for the only honest and forthcoming fragrance reviewer on UA-cam. In a sea of phone's and sellouts, you are the standard of honesty. Thank you for your wonderful reviews. Bless you Aaron!!
@@MrMelonMan96 100% agree. I never quite understood what everyone else was complaining about. My personal experinece with its performance has always been solid to good. I have also smelled other people wearing it and, while it is subtle, it is definitely noticeable. I'd say its performance perfectly matches the style of fragrance that it is.
Thanks Aaron! Y'know, I've always thought that ATH can sell little discovery sets of whatever raw materials that you have in mind when you suggest that we get our noses on them. I think it's a great idea and I really do want to learn more about this stuff, but I've looked into it, and I simply can't figure out how to jump into that whole thing. Either way, thanks for all you do.
I was JUST thinking this when he said he hopes we're smelling the raw materials and components he always mentions. I don't think I'd have the talent to try perfumery myself, but I'd love to know what all these ingredients smell like on their own. :)
@@Rolly_951 2 frags i will always have. Any others are replaceable. The One, and Versace pour homme. I'm not saying they are better than all others, just that others can be substituted for.
I have the TF Tobacco Vanille Eau de Perfume which has almost gone and now I have a bottle of this which arrived today. You are absolutely correct, very similar, very familiar yet very different in a good way. A very enjoyable fragrance to wear as an alternative to the TF. And for the cost difference it makes perfect sense. Your great insight as usual.
I'd consider this my first fragrance, glad you're reviewing it! One of my favorite too, though, I rarely wear it now. Decided to wear it tonight after this seeing this video lol Thanks, Aaron; always enjoy your videos!
I know we shouldn’t put to to much stock in other peoples opinions of things but I’m soooo glad Aaron loves this one. It’s my favorite and I’m always trying to find new fragrances that are similar but not redundant.
@@drentar4423 Well yeah, he wanted something similar, so I gave him a fragrance that I use under the same circumstances as The One EDP but nothing close enough scent wise as to be redundant.
5:37-5:41 Thank you! Finally someone says exactly my thoughts with this fragrance. I own a 150ml of the edp (and i used all 50ml of the edt). But, it bores me to have it on. The tobacco here is so safe and the scent is so linear that find myself struggling to enjoy this beautiful scent. I do have people tell me that I smell good, so the fragrance does its job, but for me it's just too boring. It's still lovely, so I recommend it for safe buys.
Yes, this is one of my very favourite frags, I've even got the intense version of it, but this one is by far the superior one, just doesn't last as long as I'd like.
@@InspireApon I currently have The One Intense EDP but I’ve read that is a different scent rather than the same as the original EDP but with better/longer projection.
I have The One Intense. I'm not sure what's Intense about it but it does smell amazing. Just wish the longevity on my skin last a bit longer. But I travel with it and refresh around the 4 hour mark
Man after using xerjoffs for a while , I'd be scared to try this again. Had a bottle went through it quickly one of the weakest scents out there for me
It's a great scent but doesn't last at all. Little to no projection from the beginning. It turns into a skin scent almost immediately. I enjoy your reviews. 👌
Agreed. Not sure why there’s not been a dupe with way more staying power. I don’t think it needs to be a projection monster because the scent profile suits being a little more intimate but it’s hard to justify buying a bottle when it lasts about 5 minutes!
Nice to have you back :-) Edit: I personally got bored by it pretty quickly - let's say the first sniff. Somewhere I smelled very similar smells, and I didn't like it...
Easily one of my favourites and i rarely have favourites in fragrances. It lasts quite a while, maybe a bit too long for its intended use. (No its not a projection panty dropper beast, its not supposed to be).its a quality scent.
Awesome Video! I love this fragrance as well Aaron! If you can get your hands on the D&G the one gold for men! I would be very interested on your thoughts on it! I love it as well! Keep these great videos coming my friend! 👍🏼
Aaron I bought this fragrance online at a discount website - catch of the day I think it was called - and when I got it and sprayed it, I couldn’t smell anything. It was just like ethanol. So I presumed I had been done over. Then a month later, I happened to be on the Gold Coast and I walked into David Jones and it was on display so I thought I’ll buy one from a big box retailer and do a test on the assumption the big box retailer is not selling fakes So I paid through the nose at David Jones got another bottle and I still couldn’t smell anything All I get is Ethanol And the other week I went to the dentist. I put heaps of it on and I jokingly said to the assistant. What do you think of of my aftershave and she sniffed me and said I can’t smell anything.…….!!!
I blind bought this based on reviews and loved the smell, but I don't know what it was about it, that made me feel sick and gave me an awful headache. I really wanted to wear this but I just couldn't stand it. At least I could confirm that it is VERY long lasting because I could smell it all day long.
I love and look forward to your reviews, Aaron, so please take this as constructive criticism. 🙏 - Whenever you say, "cacophony", I think you mean "symphony". Cacophony is a harsh discordant mixture of sounds, aromas, etc.. "Symphony" is the opposite. 🤔
I like The One EDP, but I find it is very soft. For one or other reason, I tend to wear the EDT more often - I also wear it to the office at times. I would rate the Middle Eastern exclusives higher, though. I find them more interesting - I got myself the Royal Night and the Luminous Night. Apart from those, I also enjoy The One for Men Intense, mostly in colder weather.
I really appreciate the scent but on my skin don’t long lasting that’s for me is 8/10 cause was just 3 or 4 hours. And I’m really care about my skin been hydrated, I feel that is more in the way of imagination, LV. Anyways is a great scent thank u AARON for one the best reviews here 🤙
Yeah, this one is really amazing, my wife loves smelling it on me, she bought it to me to use it every evening just chilling around here. It's really great, but it def is just a skin scent, projection is really non existing. Now, compared to that, another one that my wife bought me and I absolutely love is Tom Ford - Noir Extreme, if you like The One, Noir Extreme is gonna be up your alley for sure, and it def has better longevity and projection. I wore it (Noir Extreme) to a black / death metal concert, and I could notice ladies turning heads around to figure out source of smell (I guess in a good way?). Made my wife a bit nervous there at that moment a bit, but hey, if you're a guy and wanna smell mysterious - this is or Noir Extreme is the way to go. Question: I'm wondering (and this is gonna be an experiment to make), if layering Escentric Molecules 01 on top of D&G - The One, would make it last and project a bit longer? Dunno if someone tried that and has experience with it? I guess it would maybe elevate it a bit and project. Great review as always!
Thanks for reply. I think I might’ve been getting myself mixed up with the different flankers. Isn’t Dior Homme with iris ? Either way I’ve added this to my sample list 👍
If this cologne was long lasting with a good projection it would be hands down the greatest men's fragrance ever. Seriously, the first time I smelled it was when I was 18 in an airport and I bought it on the spot. 10 years later and its still my favourite.
Hi Aaron, this is one of my all time favs. But I’m surprised about what you said, as this fragrance notoriously has bad performance. 2 hours tops and it’s gone. Unfortunately
It smells good, but it is a skin scent immediately upon applying. Zero projection. I felt like i got ripped off. ATH's fragrances are light years ahead
If any of you guys love this fragrance, you'll most likely like jazz club, which is just a touch more bright and tobacco(y). I often layer these two fragrances to help give this fragrance a little lift. Everyone who complains about the performance of this fragrance, just wear more sprays, it's affordable enough to go a little heavier. Love this stuff.
I usually go at least 15 sprays of The One and even this way it doesn’t peform at all! I have some weak fragrances in my collection like YSL La nuit that I love a lot, but even these perfumes has at least something you can call “performance” which is nonexistent in The One.
I have the original and it is indeed a boring scent after a few minutes. Once the top notes are burnt out. You are left syick smelling tobacco, and vanilla. I don't know if it is because I switched to Middle Eastern fragrances, I can't barely and hardly smell it after 3 minutes.
I came here to understand the fragrance but Aaron throwing all these Aroma Chemicals at me lol I'm more confused than ever. Aaron kind request , please go off the notes and not the actual aroma chemicals because general people are more familiar with what info is available online about the fragrance, and not what goes behind the scenes that only perfumers will understand. ❤
To me, The One Edp has the best looking bottle of everything i have seen, simple but so classy. That in combination with the color of the juice and the gradient , it is perfect. So satisfying and the fragrance smell so good!
Whew! I just bought this for my son's 26th birthday coming up, and now I can tell him it comes with ATH's seal of approval (he trusts you).😁I'd gotten him Chanel Allure Homme last Christmas, but it may be a bit mature for him. He is a Tobacco Vanille lover, and I agree that someone who enjoys that scent will also most likely appreciate this One.
@@NiAudaxNeObstes Chanel Allure Homme is a fantastic perfume for any age, especially if he’s 26 years old… I wouldn’t say it’s too mature for him, I hope he enjoyed it, my dad used to have it when I was a kid and I absolutely loved that perfume… it’s amazing :)
Thank god for the only honest and forthcoming fragrance reviewer on UA-cam. In a sea of phone's and sellouts, you are the standard of honesty. Thank you for your wonderful reviews. Bless you Aaron!!
I’ve never heard this fragrance described as long lasting with good projection before.
Because people just parrot what other people say. In my experience this has pretty solid performance
@@MrMelonMan96 100% agree. I never quite understood what everyone else was complaining about. My personal experinece with its performance has always been solid to good. I have also smelled other people wearing it and, while it is subtle, it is definitely noticeable. I'd say its performance perfectly matches the style of fragrance that it is.
From experience with my 2023 batch, I get 8 hours at least
@@muntster yeah exactly. Same as La Nuit De L’Homme. Not every fragrance is supposed to be “beast mode”
It's the complete definition of a skin scent. Absolutely ZERO projection.
Love the way AAron gives us so much knowledge throughout his breakdowns. Another one for the books. One love
I love it when you give a Designer fragrance a 9 or a 10 ! I don't speak Niche so I'm glad you're not snobbish ! :)))
Thanks Aaron! Y'know, I've always thought that ATH can sell little discovery sets of whatever raw materials that you have in mind when you suggest that we get our noses on them. I think it's a great idea and I really do want to learn more about this stuff, but I've looked into it, and I simply can't figure out how to jump into that whole thing. Either way, thanks for all you do.
I was JUST thinking this when he said he hopes we're smelling the raw materials and components he always mentions. I don't think I'd have the talent to try perfumery myself, but I'd love to know what all these ingredients smell like on their own. :)
Awesome review Aaron, whow a 10!!
Is very good scent, in category of La nuit de l'homme, attractive and very compliment scent as well
This is in my top 5 fragrances of all time.
Same I wish they would create an elixir to this . Would be a day one purchase
This is one of my favorite fragrances, and never gets boring. I'm still amazed every time i wear it. Will always be in my collection
@@Rolly_951 2 frags i will always have. Any others are replaceable. The One, and Versace pour homme. I'm not saying they are better than all others, just that others can be substituted for.
Awesome review Aaron! Thank you for sharing your love of perfumery!
I have the TF Tobacco Vanille Eau de Perfume which has almost gone and now I have a bottle of this which arrived today. You are absolutely correct, very similar, very familiar yet very different in a good way. A very enjoyable fragrance to wear as an alternative to the TF. And for the cost difference it makes perfect sense. Your great insight as usual.
I'd consider this my first fragrance, glad you're reviewing it! One of my favorite too, though, I rarely wear it now. Decided to wear it tonight after this seeing this video lol
Thanks, Aaron; always enjoy your videos!
I know we shouldn’t put to to much stock in other peoples opinions of things but I’m soooo glad Aaron loves this one. It’s my favorite and I’m always trying to find new fragrances that are similar but not redundant.
Prada Amber Pour Homme Intense ? Maybe.
@@ianmorrow9300 I just picked up Prada Lina rossa ocean parfum and I’m really liking it as well!
@@ianmorrow9300 Not even remotely alike, but it is still an incredible fragrance 👌
@@drentar4423 Well yeah, he wanted something similar, so I gave him a fragrance that I use under the same circumstances as The One EDP but nothing close enough scent wise as to be redundant.
Try the royal night.
It’s an amazing cuddle fragrance. On the flip side it doesn’t project well for me without being obnoxious with the number of sprays
Same!
I can’t smell anything makes no sense.
5:37-5:41 Thank you! Finally someone says exactly my thoughts with this fragrance. I own a 150ml of the edp (and i used all 50ml of the edt). But, it bores me to have it on. The tobacco here is so safe and the scent is so linear that find myself struggling to enjoy this beautiful scent. I do have people tell me that I smell good, so the fragrance does its job, but for me it's just too boring. It's still lovely, so I recommend it for safe buys.
Yes, this is one of my very favourite frags, I've even got the intense version of it, but this one is by far the superior one, just doesn't last as long as I'd like.
Masterpiece designer fragrance
I disagree. The performances is awful.
This fragrance blows… performance is awful. Absolutely awful
Scent is 11/10.
It’s a certified Mona Lisa.
@@warrendchildnot the EDP it lasts. EDT is like water though.
I don’t agree
I love this fragrance , I bought one and after 2 months I sold it, sadly p/s are very very weak. Its so unfortune, really loved it
It's very weak! I remember testing this with my girlfriend. I just had sprayed like 5 times and she couldn't smell within an arms length 😅
I can’t smell anything either!
This is hands down my favorite fragrance I’ve ever smelled
Fantastic video and insights. The story analogy really spells out the mathematics of the design, balance and construction. Well done.
I shall be purchasing this fragrance very soon.
Thank you Aaron for your review.
just keep in mind its very weak and no one can really smell you unless they are 1 ft away
@@InspireApon I currently have The One Intense EDP but I’ve read that is a different scent rather than the same as the original EDP but with better/longer projection.
I love this scent as a scent but doesn’t project or last unfortunately
@@DemonAbumi - Has it been reformulated do you know since it’s original release?
@@cheekster777multiple times find an old batch if you can.
Would love to see you review Versace Dylan Blue…. One of my favs
I tried both Edp and Edt and it seemed the EDt was actually better with more projection and the smell was maybe a bit more aromatic
It's one of two first frags I've had. I want to get tired of it as I pile up my collection, but man... it still hits. Such a timeless scent
10, let's gooo.
You need to have a clip listing all your 10 ratings
There are so many flankers in the line but I'd like to see it compared to the EDT version
I have The One Intense. I'm not sure what's Intense about it but it does smell amazing. Just wish the longevity on my skin last a bit longer. But I travel with it and refresh around the 4 hour mark
Man after using xerjoffs for a while , I'd be scared to try this again. Had a bottle went through it quickly one of the weakest scents out there for me
Great review and great insight, this is a favourite of mine, it's Autum in a bottle for me 😁
You have a very soothing voice.
The new ones 'made in Italy' have acceptable longevity and projection (comparing them to ones 'made in France'), this scent is amazing
When did they start making them in Italy ?
It's a great scent but doesn't last at all. Little to no projection from the beginning. It turns into a skin scent almost immediately. I enjoy your reviews. 👌
Yea, I have it and it's weak juice. You need to spray 8-10 times to get something decent out of it.
I absolutely agree. Sadly it does not last long
Agreed. Not sure why there’s not been a dupe with way more staying power. I don’t think it needs to be a projection monster because the scent profile suits being a little more intimate but it’s hard to justify buying a bottle when it lasts about 5 minutes!
Nice to have you back :-)
Edit: I personally got bored by it pretty quickly - let's say the first sniff. Somewhere I smelled very similar smells, and I didn't like it...
Love the review Aaron, incredible fragrance and such amazing value. 😊
Easily one of my favourites and i rarely have favourites in fragrances. It lasts quite a while, maybe a bit too long for its intended use. (No its not a projection panty dropper beast, its not supposed to be).its a quality scent.
Love the reviews. Can you do more reviews from the Ysl "le vestiaire des parfums" line. Blouse, Caban, Lavalliere.
Yes, I have it in my collection and agree it's a gorgeous fragrance and very good value as well. My only gripe is that its performance is mediocre.
Awesome Video! I love this fragrance as well Aaron! If you can get your hands on the D&G the one gold for men! I would be very interested on your thoughts on it! I love it as well! Keep these great videos coming my friend! 👍🏼
Thanks for another great video Aaron
Great review! Thanks.
I love your body language, especially your eye gestures
Aaron
I bought this fragrance online at a discount website - catch of the day I think it was called - and when I got it and sprayed it, I couldn’t smell anything. It was just like ethanol. So I presumed I had been done over.
Then a month later, I happened to be on the Gold Coast and I walked into David Jones and it was on display
so I thought I’ll buy one from a big box retailer and do a test on the assumption the big box retailer is not selling fakes
So I paid through the nose at David Jones got another bottle and I still couldn’t smell anything
All I get is Ethanol
And the other week I went to the dentist. I put heaps of it on and I jokingly said to the assistant. What do you think of of my aftershave
and she sniffed me and said I can’t smell anything.…….!!!
I love your videos Aaron and i HAVE to know... what microphone are you using?
Oh man gotta love Aaron, he’s my go to guy before I even consider purchasing any fragrance ❤️
I can’t stop smelling this ❤️🔥
Great review as always - Solid
People are on here crying already. I have never had problems with the edp longevity. It is a masterpiece, but it's just not my style
Great review as always! How can i improve longevity of "The one" Edt\edp? Will vaseline on skin before aplying frag help ? Any tips?
I blind bought this based on reviews and loved the smell, but I don't know what it was about it, that made me feel sick and gave me an awful headache. I really wanted to wear this but I just couldn't stand it. At least I could confirm that it is VERY long lasting because I could smell it all day long.
I love and look forward to your reviews, Aaron, so please take this as constructive criticism. 🙏 - Whenever you say, "cacophony", I think you mean "symphony". Cacophony is a harsh discordant mixture of sounds, aromas, etc.. "Symphony" is the opposite. 🤔
One of my favourite all-time frags!
The fact Aaron likes it tells me im justified 👌
Review the Royal Night version next.
I like The One EDP, but I find it is very soft. For one or other reason, I tend to wear the EDT more often - I also wear it to the office at times. I would rate the Middle Eastern exclusives higher, though. I find them more interesting - I got myself the Royal Night and the Luminous Night. Apart from those, I also enjoy The One for Men Intense, mostly in colder weather.
I really appreciate the scent but on my skin don’t long lasting that’s for me is 8/10 cause was just 3 or 4 hours. And I’m really care about my skin been hydrated, I feel that is more in the way of imagination, LV.
Anyways is a great scent thank u AARON for one the best reviews here 🤙
Le Male Elixir next!
Always interested in why fragrances like these don’t last. It’s beautiful but what in its composition could be changed to increase its longevity?
The moment Aaron's hand starts to move, I'm enchanted
I agree, it’s a pretty perfect blend. I do use Ambroxan with it for better performance.
Yeah, this one is really amazing, my wife loves smelling it on me, she bought it to me to use it every evening just chilling around here. It's really great, but it def is just a skin scent, projection is really non existing. Now, compared to that, another one that my wife bought me and I absolutely love is Tom Ford - Noir Extreme, if you like The One, Noir Extreme is gonna be up your alley for sure, and it def has better longevity and projection. I wore it (Noir Extreme) to a black / death metal concert, and I could notice ladies turning heads around to figure out source of smell (I guess in a good way?). Made my wife a bit nervous there at that moment a bit, but hey, if you're a guy and wanna smell mysterious - this is or Noir Extreme is the way to go.
Question: I'm wondering (and this is gonna be an experiment to make), if layering Escentric Molecules 01 on top of D&G - The One, would make it last and project a bit longer? Dunno if someone tried that and has experience with it? I guess it would maybe elevate it a bit and project.
Great review as always!
I love the smell but doesnt last at all on me
I love this fragrance so much
Thanks for reply. I think I might’ve been getting myself mixed up with the different flankers. Isn’t Dior Homme with iris ?
Either way I’ve added this to my sample list 👍
Dior home intense and parfum are iris, the normal yellow bottle dior is not.
this fragrance was my first love. it will always be in my collection.
If this cologne was long lasting with a good projection it would be hands down the greatest men's fragrance ever. Seriously, the first time I smelled it was when I was 18 in an airport and I bought it on the spot. 10 years later and its still my favourite.
What would you say is the niche version of this ?
poor longevity on this one, but dear oh dear this smells good.
Wonderful review Aaron!
So wild I just saw this after picking this up for a crazy steal at a rack store haven’t opened it yet… was thinking of giving it as a gift
Is this one even available or did they discontinued it
Yes it is available here in the U.S. I cant speak for anywhere else.
The only 'The One' discontinued to my knowledge is Gentleman.
Excellent video and fragrance.
absolutely love this scent
I need a video with all of your 10-rated fragrances
Hi Aaron, this is one of my all time favs. But I’m surprised about what you said, as this fragrance notoriously has bad performance. 2 hours tops and it’s gone. Unfortunately
EDP is great, but the EDT smells better for me.
@@ottopaasikivi2830
100%
A 10!?! Ok im buying this, thx Aaron
Does this perform better than La Nuit? 🤔
No, even the newer batches of the reformulated La nuit perform better than The One.
Is there a fragrance that smells similar to this one but has better Performance?
One of my favorites
The One elixir would do crazy numbers
It smells good, but it is a skin scent immediately upon applying. Zero projection. I felt like i got ripped off.
ATH's fragrances are light years ahead
I was looking for this comment. I can attest that this is a skin scent after few minutes of application. Very disappointing. I also feel ripped off 😢
Thank you, Aaron. You've just pointed my next purchase
It doesn't last long at all! Maybe a 3-4 hours! A few extra sprays, 10 or 14 and it performs like it should.
I have this one, projection is about 2-3 ft, longevity i get easily 6 hours with no problem.
I have this fragrance its wonderful
Great fragrance been wearing it for years now
hey aaron! please review YMC 105 By bon parfumeur!!
Thoughts on clive christian X for men, or kilians smoking hot?
Would your carbon, blend go well with this?
He's right about everything other than it being long lasting
For everyone complaining about performance, D&G listened and fixed it recently.
Love this fragrance, but unfortunately i only get about 4-5 hours of longevity
If any of you guys love this fragrance, you'll most likely like jazz club, which is just a touch more bright and tobacco(y). I often layer these two fragrances to help give this fragrance a little lift. Everyone who complains about the performance of this fragrance, just wear more sprays, it's affordable enough to go a little heavier. Love this stuff.
I usually go at least 15 sprays of The One and even this way it doesn’t peform at all! I have some weak fragrances in my collection like YSL La nuit that I love a lot, but even these perfumes has at least something you can call “performance” which is nonexistent in The One.
... classic date night scent that brings a lot of memories!
Love this as instant hit with ladies on date nights
Please do a review on 1 Million Golden Oud!
At 2:00 you say cacophony, which means: 'a harsh discordant mixture'. Is it really the case or did you just misspoke?
I have the original and it is indeed a boring scent after a few minutes.
Once the top notes are burnt out. You are left syick smelling tobacco, and vanilla.
I don't know if it is because I switched to Middle Eastern fragrances, I can't barely and hardly smell it after 3 minutes.
Projection is trash but up close holy cow! Instant crowd pleaser
Wow a 10! I honestly didn’t think you were going to give it a high score lol. I don’t know why but I didn’t think you would lol
Probably the best designer date fragrance. Poor performance but the scent is unbeatable
I came here to understand the fragrance but Aaron throwing all these Aroma Chemicals at me lol I'm more confused than ever. Aaron kind request , please go off the notes and not the actual aroma chemicals because general people are more familiar with what info is available online about the fragrance, and not what goes behind the scenes that only perfumers will understand. ❤