She cares about the one who saw beauty in her. But she has such a low opinion of who she truly is that she just can’t accept that she was really worthy of love and care. So she tries to make Whipped Cream Cookie forget about who she was by lying about who she is. Because how could anything so ugly be truly cared for?
Knowing this could be the work of the Black Sugar Duck, it seems that duck had plans to renovate Dessert Paradise as Black Sugar Cookie but I have only two questions. 1. How did Black Sugar Duck became Black Sugar Swan and 2. What is reason to changing the paradise into a suitable image? The purple gem or eternal sweetness could be part of my answer but only time will tell when we see the Real Sugar Swan Cookie making a return to this paradise. Maybe even see more of Wind Archer Cookie in action as the Zephyr of Life!
I think 1. She made the transformation like in the ugly duck story 2. Shes obcessed with being beautiful and now shes the sugar swan she wants to create what she thinks is a paradise for her, her own paradise
@@LeoAlexa_13 and I believe she really don't know her actions just make the paradise almost died，even she is too obsessed and selfish，she just like “ah，black is good”
@@yeatweichin9825 she knows that what shes doing has bad consequences in the paradise, but she continuous bc shes selfish and dont cares abt the other creatures and cookie (except whipped cream)
I'm sorry but whole vibe in the Dessert Paradise right now is giving: "Nobody will love you if you're unattractive." (a Lyric from Ms.Potato Head) Due to Black Sugar Swan's Tyranny. 😅
But seriously how did they not notice about black sugar swan in the first glance ??? I'm surprised that this place and the residents of it are survive this long from anything that happened in this timeline they've like 0 survival instinct and red panacotta at the end.... curiosity kill the birb I guess
They possible recognized by Sugar Swan‘s scent but not the appearance，that why they keep mentioned ”but she actually like Sugar Swan“ Even she make some actions who definitely never been Sugar Swan，they just like "this look a little off than the Sugar Swan before"
I think it's too early to conclude whether or not Black Sugar Swan and Whipped Cream's relationship is toxic. This is only half of the whole story, I'm sure the Devsisters will reveal more about it in the next half.
Not really, but this more like a Swan Lake story, which not only Black Swan steal the identity of White Swan, the prince still look the Black Swan as White Swan so he love her without knowing she is actually Black Swan So in this case，Whipped Cream care about the duck but seeing as Black Sugar Swan like the duck
Okay, I'm just gonna talk about Black Sugar Swan x Whipped Cream Cookie - because i have nothing better to do, and i feel the need to air some stuff out. (also he/they will be used for whip even though i know they use only he/him in source i have just always connected with whip as a nonbinary character just leave me be about this aspect please). Black Sugar Swan Cookie is aesthetically attracted to Whipped Cream Cookie. She likes the way they dance and the way they look, and that's essentially it. She wants to have them like a person would want to have a piece of jewellery to wear or a statue in their garden or a music box in their room - as something to be admired. Black Sugar Swan doesn't see Whipped Cream Cookie as a person in his own right, but an object, another pretty thing that she can own, and add to her growing collection of pretty things. Its such an intresting dynamic to observe, but not healthy in any way, shape or form, at all. As a person on tumblr said about this ship: "I fw these two in the 'toxic yuri/silly' way where it in fact is 'toxic/srs' and I acknowledge and don't romanticise those parts of the relationship, but I still like both of the characters in the ship and their vibes together, but they are also retroactively bad for each other. But I still ship them anyway. You get me?" (that was me i was the person on tumblr) Anyway, if you made it this far, thank you for considering my opinion, and feel free to rebuke if you wish, because my opinion on the ship has already changed heavily, hence why I'm commenting this.
2:27 OK，based on this quote and last story‘s final line，we all think the duck might be the Black Sugar Swan Cookie，and it might be true，but how? and DAMN, the BGM! （why don't make Black Swan Cookie，this name will make someone confused if Sugar Swan Cookie been tainted by evil power，you know just like in kingdom，or did they？） 18:06 Maybe the jewel there is the Eternal Sweetness based on what Wind Archer just mentioned, and that why she able to corrupt Whipped Cream Cookie, but seriously if she able to done this, she can make others the same right? However, I checked Sugar Swan Cookie herself also had a same jewel in her cookie form, so maybe it not true and I believe people will make a new ship based on the quotes and the scene
1:31 THE COOKIESMALS THERE BACK THERE FUCKING BACK THE BEST COOKIES IN THE GAME IS BACK I LITERALLY WROTE THIS COMMENT THE MOMENT I SEE THEM I LOVE THEM SOO FUCKING MUCH PLS PLAY A IMPORTANT ROLE AND NOT BE SIDELINED PLS DEVSIS GIVE YOUR GODLY CREATIONS LOVE
Something about Black Sugar Cookie with Whipped Cream is just creepy. If it's Black Sugar Duck whose Black Sugar Cookie it's a friend abusing the fact they now have power over him and not telling the truth. If it's not Black Sugar Duck it's some random cookie whose decided "Oh this guy is pretty I'm just going to take advantage of him thinking I'm the real Sugar Swan cookie."
Ew. As someone who was in an abusive relationship… Get the hell out of here. She lied to him because she’s extremely insecure about her true self and doesn’t want to let him know and risk losing him. Both mutually are into one another. All she did was LIE about HERSELF and you people are calling it ‘abuse’. Absolutely insane. Also, Whipped loves her true self, which she has yet to accept. Not to mention he STILL asks for Black Sugar Duck despite everything. If you don’t like the ship, fine. But don’t make up reasons as to form it as problematic. That is wrong.
@@magicalramune Then apparently 90% of people on social media are abusers and are evil and problematic for using face filters. Get a grip. Whipped Cream loves her true self, and she just doesn’t want to lose him, have yall not ever lied in your lives?? Ohh are we all angels now of a sudden? It’s not problematic, start worrying about actual problematic ships such as age gaps and hurtful power dynamics. DuckWhip is NOT one of them, she has not hurt him. I am someone who was and has been in toxic and abusive relationships… Shut the hell up!
@@magicalramune It is not problematic. Please grow up. Apparently that makes 90% of people on social media problematic and abusers for using face filters. As someone who was in abusive relationships previously, go instead focus on actual problematic ships. You people are grasping at straws and it is embarrassing. She loves him, he loves her, she lied about her appearance but he STILL loves her true self. Stay mad
And so the Black Sugar Duck got so jealous of Sugar Swan it... whatever they took to get that same beauty as her, they did. And then, they lied to everyone they cherish. I can only imagine Sugar Swan just going to tell Black Sugar Duck to tell the truth about who they really are.
I may have a few theories in mind to what happened or either what turned the black sugar swan this way:p 1.This could also be likely caused by black sugar duck, considering all the hints and clues,I theorize that black sugar duck found a way to discover or find the power that brings the immortality,peace and harmony throughout the dessert paradise,black sugar duck may have corrupted its power or either stole the power of the dessert paradise causing it to succumb to corruption and darkness. 2.Black sugar duck may have also found a way to control the swan,combining their personality to the sugar swan creating the so called "black sugar swan" black sugar duck may have corrupted the sugar Swan's power letting them take in control and corrupt the thoughts and minds of the sugar swan. 3.Black sugar duck may or may not have made a deal with another dark and corrupted force ,giving them the power to control the dessert paradise and it's citizens,turning it to a place of darkness and chaos. So ye:] those are my theories ,srry for any grammar or spelling mistakes y'all ^^
The thing is this is actually more simple than you think First，Black sugar duck just accidently found the essence that make the paradise always living and not going winter，which is mentione by Wind Archer. The duck used the power to make herself as Sugar Swan, because the scent and power, make everyone (the Guardians, the birds, the cookiemals) thinks she is the Sugar Swan, the Red Panna Cotta even believe she is the Sugar Swan for one second, but easily doubt that because the change of personality of the Black Sugar Swan, not caring the balance just herself. The power also mentioned why she can easily change the whole paradise by her concept, however, since the power just not giving to the paradise causing the paradise is going to died, so she need to release the power as soon as possible However, the real Sugar Swan still traveling to the world so not knowing what actual happening in the paradise
Ive always thought of sugar swan cookie and whipped cream cookie as mother and son duo just like how scarlet witch and wiccan duo you know... It felt weird shipping them😅
18:11 if you pause here before the dialogue starts, you can see the black sugar duck in the water reflection
You are right 😮
You ain't the only one, I also saw a reddit post on Google
Quote of the Update frfr 2:44 : "I am very demure, very mindful, a beauty unmatched by any other."
omg my teachers say something like this 😭
@@SomebodyJustExisting wait ACTUALLY???!?!?!?! 😭😭
She cares about the one who saw beauty in her. But she has such a low opinion of who she truly is that she just can’t accept that she was really worthy of love and care. So she tries to make Whipped Cream Cookie forget about who she was by lying about who she is.
Because how could anything so ugly be truly cared for?
2:44 She definitely very DEMURE, very MINDFUL😍😍
Knowing this could be the work of the Black Sugar Duck, it seems that duck had plans to renovate Dessert Paradise as Black Sugar Cookie but I have only two questions. 1. How did Black Sugar Duck became Black Sugar Swan and 2. What is reason to changing the paradise into a suitable image? The purple gem or eternal sweetness could be part of my answer but only time will tell when we see the Real Sugar Swan Cookie making a return to this paradise. Maybe even see more of Wind Archer Cookie in action as the Zephyr of Life!
I think
1. She made the transformation like in the ugly duck story
2. Shes obcessed with being beautiful and now shes the sugar swan she wants to create what she thinks is a paradise for her, her own paradise
@@LeoAlexa_13 and I believe she really don't know her actions just make the paradise almost died，even she is too obsessed and selfish，she just like “ah，black is good”
@@yeatweichin9825 she knows that what shes doing has bad consequences in the paradise, but she continuous bc shes selfish and dont cares abt the other creatures and cookie (except whipped cream)
I'm sorry but whole vibe in the Dessert Paradise right now is giving: "Nobody will love you if you're unattractive." (a Lyric from Ms.Potato Head) Due to Black Sugar Swan's Tyranny. 😅
@@LeoAlexa_13 Good observation. This might as well be the case for this story.
2:48 THEY ACTUALLY PUT IT BYE💀
they done got the devs 😭🙏
I CANT 😭😭😭
HAHAH BYEE LMAOO
THEYRE KEEPING UP W THE TRENDS NAW
@@Lychee-by4nmIKRRRRR
But seriously how did they not notice about black sugar swan in the first glance ??? I'm surprised that this place and the residents of it are survive this long from anything that happened in this timeline they've like 0 survival instinct and red panacotta at the end.... curiosity kill the birb I guess
They possible recognized by Sugar Swan‘s scent but not the appearance，that why they keep mentioned ”but she actually like Sugar Swan“
Even she make some actions who definitely never been Sugar Swan，they just like "this look a little off than the Sugar Swan before"
2:46 DEVSHITS ACTUALLY PUTTED THAT TRULY,TRULY BEAUTIFUL AND VERY DEMURE WORD😍😍💅💞💞💞
Guys...I think she's very demure, very mindful.
I think it's too early to conclude whether or not Black Sugar Swan and Whipped Cream's relationship is toxic. This is only half of the whole story, I'm sure the Devsisters will reveal more about it in the next half.
Not really, but this more like a Swan Lake story, which not only Black Swan steal the identity of White Swan, the prince still look the Black Swan as White Swan so he love her without knowing she is actually Black Swan
So in this case，Whipped Cream care about the duck but seeing as Black Sugar Swan like the duck
lol i was kinda surprised that black sugar swan liked whipped cream that much XD wonder how this will go
Black Sugar Swan liked Whipped Cream Cookie just as much as Black Sugar Swan likes Whipped Cream Cookie. A coincidence maybe…
Shipers are coming
Very demure, very mindful☺️
2:43
“This is fanum tax. First, I gyatt Whipped Cream Cookie and now I rizz you. Skibidi, my friend!”
Black sugar swan when she sees whipped cream:
🖤///👁👄👁///🖤
Also thats a underrated comment
@@LeoAlexa_13 bro I see u everywhere😭
@@EternalSug4r im everywhere 🌚
And i see you everywhere too bro
she did say that i can tell you, i was there
Okay, I'm just gonna talk about Black Sugar Swan x Whipped Cream Cookie - because i have nothing better to do, and i feel the need to air some stuff out.
(also he/they will be used for whip even though i know they use only he/him in source i have just always connected with whip as a nonbinary character just leave me be about this aspect please).
Black Sugar Swan Cookie is aesthetically attracted to Whipped Cream Cookie. She likes the way they dance and the way they look, and that's essentially it. She wants to have them like a person would want to have a piece of jewellery to wear or a statue in their garden or a music box in their room - as something to be admired. Black Sugar Swan doesn't see Whipped Cream Cookie as a person in his own right, but an object, another pretty thing that she can own, and add to her growing collection of pretty things.
Its such an intresting dynamic to observe, but not healthy in any way, shape or form, at all. As a person on tumblr said about this ship:
"I fw these two in the 'toxic yuri/silly' way where it in fact is 'toxic/srs' and I acknowledge and don't romanticise those parts of the relationship, but I still like both of the characters in the ship and their vibes together, but they are also retroactively bad for each other. But I still ship them anyway. You get me?"
(that was me i was the person on tumblr)
Anyway, if you made it this far, thank you for considering my opinion, and feel free to rebuke if you wish, because my opinion on the ship has already changed heavily, hence why I'm commenting this.
Is it just me or red panna cotta kinda look fine-
He kinda looks like longan dragon cookie if he was red
@StarArtGamer yeah I mean by outfits
2:27 OK，based on this quote and last story‘s final line，we all think the duck might be the Black Sugar Swan Cookie，and it might be true，but how?
and DAMN, the BGM!
（why don't make Black Swan Cookie，this name will make someone confused if Sugar Swan Cookie been tainted by evil power，you know just like in kingdom，or did they？）
18:06 Maybe the jewel there is the Eternal Sweetness based on what Wind Archer just mentioned, and that why she able to corrupt Whipped Cream Cookie, but seriously if she able to done this, she can make others the same right?
However, I checked Sugar Swan Cookie herself also had a same jewel in her cookie form, so maybe it not true
and I believe people will make a new ship based on the quotes and the scene
Fr shipers gonna be crazy after this 18:08
I know this is off topic, but look at the water in 18:08 That's definitely Black Sugar Duck.
@@SeaBioStuff I think you're the first one to find out about this detail 😅
@@SeaBioStuff how tf nobody noticed before you
@@LeoAlexa_13 Welp, time to spread this knowledge/Hj
a part of me can't help but think of Mytho and Kraehe from Princess Tutu in the scene of them dancing together
1:31 THE COOKIESMALS THERE BACK THERE FUCKING BACK THE BEST COOKIES IN THE GAME IS BACK I LITERALLY WROTE THIS COMMENT THE MOMENT I SEE THEM I LOVE THEM SOO FUCKING MUCH PLS PLAY A IMPORTANT ROLE AND NOT BE SIDELINED PLS DEVSIS GIVE YOUR GODLY CREATIONS LOVE
Something about Black Sugar Cookie with Whipped Cream is just creepy.
If it's Black Sugar Duck whose Black Sugar Cookie it's a friend abusing the fact they now have power over him and not telling the truth.
If it's not Black Sugar Duck it's some random cookie whose decided "Oh this guy is pretty I'm just going to take advantage of him thinking I'm the real Sugar Swan cookie."
Even looks like shes somehow a lil obcessed with him... Creepy indees
Ew. As someone who was in an abusive relationship… Get the hell out of here.
She lied to him because she’s extremely insecure about her true self and doesn’t want to let him know and risk losing him. Both mutually are into one another. All she did was LIE about HERSELF and you people are calling it ‘abuse’. Absolutely insane. Also, Whipped loves her true self, which she has yet to accept. Not to mention he STILL asks for Black Sugar Duck despite everything.
If you don’t like the ship, fine. But don’t make up reasons as to form it as problematic. That is wrong.
@@owo4876she is still deceiving him how is that not problematic. the reasoning doesn't matter
@@magicalramune Then apparently 90% of people on social media are abusers and are evil and problematic for using face filters. Get a grip. Whipped Cream loves her true self, and she just doesn’t want to lose him, have yall not ever lied in your lives?? Ohh are we all angels now of a sudden? It’s not problematic, start worrying about actual problematic ships such as age gaps and hurtful power dynamics. DuckWhip is NOT one of them, she has not hurt him.
I am someone who was and has been in toxic and abusive relationships… Shut the hell up!
@@magicalramune It is not problematic. Please grow up. Apparently that makes 90% of people on social media problematic and abusers for using face filters. As someone who was in abusive relationships previously, go instead focus on actual problematic ships. You people are grasping at straws and it is embarrassing. She loves him, he loves her, she lied about her appearance but he STILL loves her true self. Stay mad
You will never believe what happens at 2:43
18:11 WHIPPED CREAM COOKIE THEME REMIX
Devsis need to release that theme asap because it's so beautiful like the other one but I prefer these one because it's have that mellow feels
Red panna cotta cookie: GOLD HONEY CAKE COOKIE!!!!!!!!!
I'm betting Gold Honey Cake Cookie will be the next DP update Epic Cookie
WTF ARE U DOING!!??!!?!!!
@@LeoAlexa_13 He just like Madeline Cookie but extra silly，at least Madeline got some self aware and able to notice the problem
@@yeatweichin9825 i was /j i wrote the wtf are u doing like it was red panna cotta screaming at gold honey cake
I did…
guys is it worth to make a comeback
Yes theres a lot of new stuff going and even tho the reskinned events exist , the first few days of the event give the most
Glad to see the Cookiemals back in action! 😊🐼🦁🦊
where 's gingerbrave when you need him?
To be fair，he still dealing with the freaking dragon and probably the whole dragon island？
18:13 Awwww!!! They're so smitten🥰🥰
2:44 they did not.
And so the Black Sugar Duck got so jealous of Sugar Swan it... whatever they took to get that same beauty as her, they did.
And then, they lied to everyone they cherish.
I can only imagine Sugar Swan just going to tell Black Sugar Duck to tell the truth about who they really are.
2:43 are they being serious rn
give me context what is wrong with that sentence?? im so confused
@@ink_splotchtickletock trend
I may have a few theories in mind to what happened or either what turned the black sugar swan this way:p
1.This could also be likely caused by black sugar duck, considering all the hints and clues,I theorize that black sugar duck found a way to discover or find the power that brings the immortality,peace and harmony throughout the dessert paradise,black sugar duck may have corrupted its power or either stole the power of the dessert paradise causing it to succumb to corruption and darkness.
2.Black sugar duck may have also found a way to control the swan,combining their personality to the sugar swan creating the so called "black sugar swan" black sugar duck may have corrupted the sugar Swan's power letting them take in control and corrupt the thoughts and minds of the sugar swan.
3.Black sugar duck may or may not have made a deal with another dark and corrupted force ,giving them the power to control the dessert paradise and it's citizens,turning it to a place of darkness and chaos.
So ye:] those are my theories ,srry for any grammar or spelling mistakes y'all ^^
The thing is this is actually more simple than you think
First，Black sugar duck just accidently found the essence that make the paradise always living and not going winter，which is mentione by Wind Archer. The duck used the power to make herself as Sugar Swan, because the scent and power, make everyone (the Guardians, the birds, the cookiemals) thinks she is the Sugar Swan, the Red Panna Cotta even believe she is the Sugar Swan for one second, but easily doubt that because the change of personality of the Black Sugar Swan, not caring the balance just herself.
The power also mentioned why she can easily change the whole paradise by her concept, however, since the power just not giving to the paradise causing the paradise is going to died, so she need to release the power as soon as possible
However, the real Sugar Swan still traveling to the world so not knowing what actual happening in the paradise
Sugar swan has returned
Gold honey cake cookie looks really cool😭
Especially i like the colour yellow🫠
So, it was swan lake cookie? Cookidette and cookidile
'Eternal Sweetness'? I wonder if it's connected to Eternal Sugar Cookie in some way
Okay hear me out but Black Sugar Duck my beloved
i was about to comment my little game theory here but i realized that basically that people already commented about iut😔
That’s not Black Sugar Swan Cookie… that’s *Night Swan* Cookie!
(Just Dance reference)
black pearl cookie version 2 ☠️☠️
Why does wind archer look different now?
he's just in his legendary costume
@@nebulaquatic i know but why?
@@Reindeer235 plot reasons
@@nebulaquatic thank you
Is this a princess tutu reference?!
THATS WHAT I'M THINKING
Why is whipped cream and black sugar duck sooo yuri
question what about the extra stories? I thought you would upload them 👉👈
The thumbnail is 😳
...quite sus
Please take a shower..!
18:13 OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG! AHHH SO CUTE! CANON SHIP
Is black sugar swan a costume to sugar swan or a new cookie
New cookie
I have that black sugar Swan cookie been brain washed as sugar Swan cookie by dark enchertrens cookie
Ive always thought of sugar swan cookie and whipped cream cookie as mother and son duo just like how scarlet witch and wiccan duo you know... It felt weird shipping them😅
black sugar swan and whipped cream's relationship gives me such yucky vibes 🤢 what have they done to my boy
I mean the last story whipped cream and black duck aka black sugar swan
Plus they danced together it seemed like a cute ship 😊
Hahaha he likes women cry about it
@@mimi9186you can ship whatever you want. i personally thought it was creepy
@@magicalramune that’s okay!
First thought : yuri