That is SOOO sad...I wish I had not watched it....she has sung this so beautifully all her life, but her heart simply wasn't in that rendition. She was then eighty something? Montserrat was THE voice of the last century.. Her floated pianissimo notes were legendary.. God! How I loved her voice!
Franklin P. Uroda For most of us listening involves not only our ears but our hearts, minds and souls. From its composition to performance and aural reception, and mental processing, music is the universal language. Did ever an artist perform without becoming the music? It’s MAGIC, isn’t it? Aren’t we blessed to share this immeasurable gift of Cabble. So much beauty.
Did you ever listen to Mila V and Giovanna P sing this beauty? What word to describe ? Climactic celestial? Unfortunately comments have been turned off this year ua-cam.com/video/yBl3pKAOhaQ/v-deo.html
Genau Es wardie Freude an ihrem Beruf. Da sieht man hinweg. Das was Sie bereits geleistet. Ihre Präsenz allein hat Ihre Wirkung. Es hätte was gefehlt. Ich sehe gelassen❤
Ganz ehrlich Ich sehe dem nach. Ich glaube so geht es mir, mir hätte Ihre Präsenz gefehlt. Anderen auch. Ohne Sie die Oper? Wenn Sie nur gesprochen hätte, das schon allein wäre eine Wirkung gewesen🙏
I love this song by this duet. Two obviously professional singers of such different ages. I have listened to it at least a dozen times. I always watch their interaction as they come onto the stage, and then their stance as the introduction builds up, and then their plunge into the song. They are two beautiful singers and two beautiful women.
Montserrat, a woman to be rememberd forever. A great soprano, and numberless her charity intitutions in favor of children, poor and destitute. Grazie Montserrat. Muchas gracias for existing.
Claro que Montserrat ya no es la que era, tiene 80 años. Puede que ya no sea la mejor soprano del mundo pero demuestra día a día ser una enorme diva y una joven alegre y simpática. Por mucho que los puritanos digan que debe retirarse por mi como si sigue 20 años más, si cantar es lo que le hace feliz y lo sigue haciendo seguirá siendo un ejemplo para todos. Bravo Monste.
No tiene ningún sentido lo que dices por la simple razón que el análisis de tu oido es equivocado. En el mismo recital con otra canción más exigente se notaba que Caballé cantaba con más fuerza que su querida pupila, lo que dice mucho de lo que daba todavía. Miren y escuche: ua-cam.com/video/r04p9B7aDUk/v-deo.html
I love Monserrat forever! I keep listening to this song and the most I see it , I’m thanking God to for la Caballe, May she rest in heaven singing with the Angels 👼
Si ya no lo era para ese entonces, pero fue la mejor por eso este video se debería encabezar por la mejor y por la última soprano absoluto en este caso Montserrat Caballé
Most importantly its her. And she sang the mezzopart here to be able to sing at her age so people could have the chance to hear and see her sing and just be there and meet with this legendary human being ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
The one video of a young and older Diva is gone now. It was the best version of Belle Nuit I ever did hear. One black piano was the only Instrument aside from the two females' voices. A subscriber called gentlemani had uploaded it seven or so years ago. I left a comment to say that i.had seen or heard nothing finer in the whoke world. Wish i remembered their names. Young one had straight black hair to shoulder. Could have been a young Anna Netrebko. And older one was a Dame/Madame? Her hair loftily piled on top of head. Older one may have been the Monserrat but not certain. Two very professiinal singers with the young one having a deep strong voice and older one high and lush sound and i was so in heaven the hundredth time i listened to it, i did not think to record names. Thought it would be a video that everybody knew of. The current gentemani i doubt if he is any relation to the former whose profile has been gone/hidden for at least rwo years maybe three years. I would love to see that video again before i die.
Ce n'est certainement pas faire honneur à la mémoire de cette grande cantatrice que de laisser sur le net un enregistrement d'une prestation aussi lamentable ! Ce n'et pas un secret que Caballe n'a pas su s'arrêter de chanter à temps, mais, de grâce, laissez-nous un autre souvenir d'elle que cet enregistrement !
A FRIBOI COM ESSA PROPAGANDAS CHATAS ENCHEM O SACO NIMGUEM É OBRIGADO A COMPRAR CARNE PELA MARCA NÃO O QUE LEVAMOS EM CONTA SÃO AS ORIGENS, SE SÃO LEGALIZADAS E SE NÃO LIMPAS NÃO ADIANTA COLOCAR UM ATOR CONHECIDO PARA TENTAR VENDER O PRODUTO ISSO É APELAÇÃO.
La peculiarità di questo pezzo viene dall'armonizzazione completa delle due voci, che spesso debbono risuonare come fossero un unico strumento. In questo caso si notano gli sforzi della Caballè (basta guardare quanto deve aprire la bocca per afferrare le note più alte - colei che dava grandi acuti a labbra socchiuse) ed i virtuosismi della Kazlaus, che appaiono assolutamente fuori luogo.
Daniel Piotrowski I think your ears are not in form. Sad to hear such a voice perform this ... Singers should notice the change of their voices. However many cannot stop performing. *too sad*
@@MusikPiratCH Очень многие, если не большинство, артистов грешат этим: не хотят вовремя уйти "на пенсию", - вероятно, не могут отказаться от новых гонораров, букетов, аплодисментов,..
Dal mio punto di vista ci sono due nei: 1- la Caballè, che giustamente, data l'età ed il calo fisiologico della voce, passa la parte del contralto, più agevole per lei in questo momento; non è questo il neo, quanto la mancanza di corpo della sua voce (adesso), che non riesce ad armonizzarsi con i picchi del soprano; 2- Nomeda Kazlaus dà troppa forza alla sua voce; dovrebbe capire l'importanza di chi ha accanto e la necessità di dosare il vigore della voce, che spesso copre la Caballet...
It's obvious who has the better technique. Caballe at 80 even singing the mezzo part still covers over the soprano voice with her unmatched technique. And that girl who sings the soprano part, please look how Caballe sings and fix your technique. Her sound is thick and doesn't have the squillo to carry over a big orchestra. Her big,heavy dark voice is just not enough.
![Sarah Brightman & Andrea Bocelli - Time to Say Goodbye (1997) [720p]](/img/n.gif)
When Montserrat died we lost one of rhe greats ...
That is SOOO sad...I wish I had not watched it....she has sung this so beautifully all her life, but her heart simply wasn't in that rendition. She was then eighty something? Montserrat was THE voice of the last century.. Her floated pianissimo notes were legendary.. God! How I loved her voice!
Very beautiful moment. Thank you for posting.
Why me? Why did this melody enter my life? Countless others have never heard this beauty.
Because you have ears that CAN hear.
Stenka Razin brought me to barcarolle
Franklin P. Uroda For most of us listening involves not only our ears but our hearts, minds and souls. From its composition to performance and aural reception, and mental processing, music is the universal language. Did ever an artist perform without becoming the music? It’s MAGIC, isn’t it? Aren’t we blessed to share this immeasurable gift of Cabble. So much beauty.
@@e.conboy4286 cabble. Laugh out loud
Did you ever listen to Mila V and Giovanna P sing this beauty? What word to describe ? Climactic celestial? Unfortunately comments have been turned off this year
ua-cam.com/video/yBl3pKAOhaQ/v-deo.html
Tudo tem um fim. Como é triste nossa humana e caída condição. Mas há quem, mesmo findando seu brilho, não deixa de brilhar. Viva Montserrat Caballe.
Genau
Es wardie Freude an ihrem Beruf. Da sieht man hinweg. Das was Sie bereits geleistet. Ihre Präsenz allein hat Ihre Wirkung. Es hätte was gefehlt. Ich sehe gelassen❤
Номеда - браво! Певец должен знать, когда надо перестать петь на большую публику... Обожаю Монтсеррат Кабалье, но увы...лучше все таки воспоминания.
Ganz ehrlich
Ich sehe dem nach. Ich glaube so geht es mir, mir hätte Ihre Präsenz gefehlt. Anderen auch. Ohne Sie die Oper? Wenn Sie nur gesprochen hätte, das schon allein wäre eine Wirkung gewesen🙏
MONTSERRAT CABALLÉ FOREVER! I LOVE CABALLÉ!
Quanti ricordi in queste canzoni il cuore pare che vada lontano......quante lacrime...
I love this song by this duet. Two obviously professional singers of such different ages. I have listened to it at least a dozen times. I always watch their interaction as they come onto the stage, and then their stance as the introduction builds up, and then their plunge into the song. They are two beautiful singers and two beautiful women.
Grande Montserrat Caballé, eres y serás la MEJOR entre todas, Dios te cuide mucho.
So impressing. At that age, people have trouble speaking.
One of the great voices of the 20th century.......sad to hear the loss, but glad she's still singing.
Love her forever in my heart, always x
Sempre sorrindo, uma simpatia e um grande talento.
Montserrat in tired but she tried! We still love her!!
She has my heart whatever she does.
Bell Canto. La música, lenguaje universal que une a todos los pueblos de la Tierra.
Molto bello Grazie
Preciso che io adoro Montserrat Caballè e la ritengo tra i più grandi soprani della storia, ed indubbiamente il più grande soprano vivente!
Beautiful performance of this classic Song and Aria. Best greetings to You from Maciek Matt Malas from Katowice Upper Silesia Poland Europe ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Wonderful thank you R.I.P
Absolutely enchanting! What a pleasure to see! Heavenly beautiful!
Una artista impareggiabile come montserrat caballé non la vedremo mai più
Kazlaus ottima idea x il duetto con montserrat caballé Bravissima artista
Montserrat, a woman to be rememberd forever. A great soprano, and numberless her charity intitutions in favor of children, poor and destitute. Grazie Montserrat. Muchas gracias for existing.
Even at that age the Queen still got it. RIP
un bien joli duo bravo c'est magnifique , c'est Offenbach , merci
Whatever she does - yes, we love her.
Au nom du Ciel chère, chère si chère Montserrat, ne gâchez plus ainsi nos mémoires!!
Claro que Montserrat ya no es la que era, tiene 80 años. Puede que ya no sea la mejor soprano del mundo pero demuestra día a día ser una enorme diva y una joven alegre y simpática. Por mucho que los puritanos digan que debe retirarse por mi como si sigue 20 años más, si cantar es lo que le hace feliz y lo sigue haciendo seguirá siendo un ejemplo para todos. Bravo Monste.
+Chrisonum toda la razón, tanto que me voy a verla a Alemania en unas semanas y tan feliz, siempre e sun placer ;)
yo la amo aun aqui! soy contemporano con ella es lo que mas importa. pena que no pude verla nunca:(
Para mim sempre irá ser uma das melhores sopranos do século XX, nunca me canso de ouvi-la...!!!
Es verdad lo que dices. Su voz está débil y es plenamente perceptible.
No tiene ningún sentido lo que dices por la simple razón que el análisis de tu oido es equivocado. En el mismo recital con otra canción más exigente se notaba que Caballé cantaba con más fuerza que su querida pupila, lo que dice mucho de lo que daba todavía. Miren y escuche: ua-cam.com/video/r04p9B7aDUk/v-deo.html
Exzellent!!!
Dzięki za taką pieśń i wspaniale wykonanie thank YOU danke merci spasiba djakuju grazie bedankt Ryszard Kulesza
Kazlaus hat eine gewaltige stimme
I love Monserrat forever!
I keep listening to this song and the most I see it , I’m thanking God to for la Caballe,
May she rest in heaven singing with the Angels 👼
Diva! Eterna!
Si ya no lo era para ese entonces, pero fue la mejor por eso este video se debería encabezar por la mejor y por la última soprano absoluto en este caso Montserrat Caballé
Beautiful
Piękne wykonanie śliczne głosy dzięki za taką pieśń i WSPANIALE wykonanie thank YOU danke merci Ryszard Kulesza
MAGNIFICAS
Brawo ciekawe wykonanie🌹⚘
Magnifique
A diva is gone ...what a voive what a fantastic .....woman
Two grande voices..... so amazing!!!!!!💫💫💫💫💫💫👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏⚘⚘❤❤
Gran diva com sus 80 anos y situe cantando muy lindo
Mi querida, La Superba! In my heart forever!
Bravo....hermoso....
Q lindas voces....
Y a que la belle musique qui adouci nos coeur surtout tout se qui arrive a notre epoque
Qué bella es la barcarola
Voces uncas y maravillosas
Suuuuper spectacular, fans are invited to organize a tribute concert and sing along some more
maravilhosas!
Montserrat divina
Bravo....amo montserrat
Human voice: perfect (almost) musical instrument... as a good wine, gets "great" in years... but "warranty" is not forever...
Caballe can still do it and does it better than ever!
Przykro patrzeć i przykro słuchać
Diva eterna
Clear difference in quality.. the old diva still can do it!
Sonoramente fantastica la Caballé è volata in cielo. Lasciando il mondo con tanta voglia di sentire la sua voce
It's eternal
Sehr gut.
Кабалье...Прекрасна Монтсі вже їде з ярмарку..
There are hints of the legendary Caballe voice. But there is a time to retire when everyone remembers your great years.
sure she'd seen better days BUT what if she just enjoys performing ...
@@alexandrasandu3947 And you paying...
Most importantly its her. And she sang the mezzopart here to be able to sing at her age so people could have the chance to hear and see her sing and just be there and meet with this legendary human being ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bravoooooooooo
....minha grande diva, sua presença é espiritual!!!!
Sigue siendo mi soprano favorita. Grande Montserrat.!!!
Fico a admirar estás belíssimas vozes.
Interpletaçao unica. MONSERRAT CABERE roubou a cena como sempre
Oh dear Montse....my beloved Montse....please
Ouch!!!!
Nomeda Kazlaus has a monochrome vibrato which sometimes makes her sound off-pitch.
Desmond P T You are more than right. Well observed.
bravo Caballe e Nomeda ,que ano foi gravado o vídeo? obrigado por postar...
Mariana GRACIAS por Existir
Ma come ai fatto,
Ma come TI AMO.
bravo
com certeza as musicas dela são fantasticas o chato do you tube ultimamente são essas propagandas chatas da marca FRIBOI
De soprano a mezzo soprano...que show montserrat
Too much power from Kazlaus
Perfect synergy is in "Caballé, Horne - Barcarolle" (search on youtube)
Yes. I love Caballe and Horne singing together, holding hands and embracing. :)
duc ho No, even Netrebko/Garanca are better than Caballé/Horne! I like Norman/Ciesinski best! (However my dream combination would be Norman/Garanca!)
I like the combination of old & young voices. Agree that Kazlaus stole the show being the vocal powerhouse here. Still enjoyed it.
The one video of a young and older Diva is gone now. It was the best version of Belle Nuit I ever did hear. One black piano was the only Instrument aside from the two females' voices. A subscriber called gentlemani had uploaded it seven or so years ago. I left a comment to say that i.had seen or heard nothing finer in the whoke world. Wish i remembered their names. Young one had straight black hair to shoulder. Could have been a young Anna Netrebko. And older one was a Dame/Madame? Her hair loftily piled on top of head. Older one may have been the Monserrat but not certain. Two very professiinal singers with the young one having a deep strong voice and older one high and lush sound and i was so in heaven the hundredth time i listened to it, i did not think to record names. Thought it would be a video that everybody knew of. The current gentemani i doubt if he is any relation to the former whose profile has been gone/hidden for at least rwo years maybe three years. I would love to see that video again before i die.
I agree. Far too much
Jamas la olvidare Montserrat Canalle y su esposo los conocí en persona eran maavillosas, bravo.
Canalle? Huuu caballe
woof
Ho dato un voto positivo solo per caballé ma le troppe arie che si da la Kazakistan non lo meritano!8
Las notas de piano y las de soprano y medio son idénticas...no mienten.atte.juan isepo.
Бедная Монсеррат уже не вытягивает, а дребезжит. Увы, время никого не жалеет. Но будем наслаждаться ее более ранними записями!
¿2019?
Para la edad que tiene ella no lo hace tan mal , es posible que haga presentaciones en público en ciertas ocasiones . Bien por ella .
🥺🥺🥺🥺
EXQUISITAS
Ce n'est certainement pas faire honneur à la mémoire de cette grande cantatrice que de laisser sur le net un enregistrement d'une prestation aussi lamentable ! Ce n'et pas un secret que Caballe n'a pas su s'arrêter de chanter à temps, mais, de grâce, laissez-nous un autre souvenir d'elle que cet enregistrement !
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A FRIBOI COM ESSA PROPAGANDAS CHATAS ENCHEM O SACO NIMGUEM É OBRIGADO A COMPRAR CARNE PELA MARCA NÃO O QUE LEVAMOS EM CONTA SÃO AS ORIGENS, SE SÃO LEGALIZADAS E SE NÃO LIMPAS NÃO ADIANTA COLOCAR UM ATOR CONHECIDO PARA TENTAR VENDER O PRODUTO ISSO É APELAÇÃO.
La peculiarità di questo pezzo viene dall'armonizzazione completa delle due voci, che spesso debbono risuonare come fossero un unico strumento. In questo caso si notano gli sforzi della Caballè (basta guardare quanto deve aprire la bocca per afferrare le note più alte - colei che dava grandi acuti a labbra socchiuse) ed i virtuosismi della Kazlaus, che appaiono assolutamente fuori luogo.
Mrs. Caballe is still in a form worthy performance!
Daniel Piotrowski I think your ears are not in form. Sad to hear such a voice perform this ... Singers should notice the change of their voices. However many cannot stop performing. *too sad*
@@MusikPiratCH Очень многие, если не большинство, артистов грешат этим: не хотят вовремя уйти "на пенсию", - вероятно, не могут отказаться от новых гонораров, букетов, аплодисментов,..
@@user-gc3ug2tl3d Please write in English or don't reply to my comment.
I watched this only because of school
Elle n’arrive plus à lire sa partition ...😱
Кабалье потеряла голос! Не надо ей
было выступать. Жаль. В прошлом -
прекрасная певица.
So sad!
mala decisión de la Caballé, hubiera permitido que la recordáramos como lo que fue: una de las voces más maravillosas de todos los tiempos.
El hecho de que siguiera cantando no quita el crédito a eso. Es lo que la hacía feliz, fue su decisión.
I'm guessing Caballe was in a lot of pain here, because of her hip.
Dal mio punto di vista ci sono due nei:
1- la Caballè, che giustamente, data l'età ed il calo fisiologico della voce, passa la parte del contralto, più agevole per lei in questo momento; non è questo il neo, quanto la mancanza di corpo della sua voce (adesso), che non riesce ad armonizzarsi con i picchi del soprano;
2- Nomeda Kazlaus dà troppa forza alla sua voce; dovrebbe capire l'importanza di chi ha accanto e la necessità di dosare il vigore della voce, che spesso copre la Caballet...
Poiché la giovane artista cosciente di chi ha avuto accanto ha vocalizzato più di quanto se
Proprio cosciente di chi gliera accanto ha forzato la sua voce x vocalizzare quella della sua maestra
Ahahahahaha
Why all this vibrato. It spoils the sound.
Que o CRIADOR a tenha
Lamentable à tous points de vue, hélas...
OperaFree Gracious performance with the younger generation. The exchanged smiles got to my heart.
It's obvious who has the better technique. Caballe at 80 even singing the mezzo part still covers over the soprano voice with her unmatched technique. And that girl who sings the soprano part, please look how Caballe sings and fix your technique. Her sound is thick and doesn't have the squillo to carry over a big orchestra. Her big,heavy dark voice is just not enough.