To be in hall with a lonely piano on stage and have someone as gifted as Sissi Yhang calmly step up and sit down at the keyboard to play a Bach Prelude and Fugue as well she does from memory is a rare and memorable privilege. I would have loved it. Her performance here is breathtaking and blows away any pernickety comment. Thank you Sissi
Gotta love YT critics. “Too romantic” from one and “metronomic” from another for the same performance. 😅People who could not in 5 lifetimes accomplish what the artist has in this performance. She departs from the score as Berenboim, Richter, Levit and Gould have done. Beautiful interpretation, brava.
Oh please, I have high school students who can play the piece just like this, and probably with a more beautiful tone quality and sense of line. This young woman can certainly play the piece, but she looks great in a dress and with long hair, which sells thousands of copies. Let's not pretend, shall we.
@@lagunagreg4019It's true, you are a piano teacher. Listen to the music and leave the clothing issue to the dressmakers. As always, and as Socrates already showed in the 5th century BC, the problem is that people believe they know what they do not know. Judge the world for valuing clothing more than the sound of music, but leave this girl alone, as our colleague Fray Juan Bermudo (musical theorist who published the Declaration of Musical Instruments in 1555) already said: "God will give science to those who have it as long as they share it." By the way, I also belong to the musicians' guild, and I am ashamed to see how, with my still young 21 years, snobbery and arrogance reign in our beautiful art. Bach is not understandable without the idea of God or, at least, of the Whole; So you should know by now that in any interpretation of Bach, only that which is celestial is a worthy judge. I deeply regret that your excess of science has clouded your true judgment by academic conventions, and I hope that after extensive thoughts, you will accept the world as it happens, and not how you would like it to happen. And on the other hand, I apologize if it seems that I spoke abruptly; I only believe I have said the right words, no more and no less than necessary. Have a cordial greeting and guard your soul from vainglory (Ptahhotep already said: "may your heart not be vain because of what it knows")
Ich denke alle Menschen jeglichen Kulturkreises und jeglichen Standes dürfen sich mit dem grossen Bach auseinandersetzen. Es kann spannend sein, was dabei herauskommt. Und der Bach nimmt keinen Schaden. Er surft über alle Vorstellungen seiner Interpreten hinweg.
I thought it was a very thoughtful interpretation. I love how she brings out elements of the different voices - it really makes the work come alive.
To be in hall with a lonely piano on stage and have someone as gifted as Sissi Yhang calmly step up and sit down at the keyboard to play a Bach Prelude and Fugue as well she does from memory is a rare and memorable privilege. I would have loved it. Her performance here is breathtaking and blows away any pernickety comment. Thank you Sissi
I loved it. Immediately I noted the loud/soft responses in the prelude.
This performance teaches me to trust your own call and be sincere no matter where you are at in experiencing music. This is great ❤
Magnífica interpretação. Vozes muito claras que nos levam a cantar.
Beautiful interpretation.
Love this crystalline rendering of the fugue. Such an intriguing and heartbreaking theme
great performance but also thumbs up on the technicians. The lighting is very good!
Gotta love YT critics. “Too romantic” from one and “metronomic” from another for the same performance. 😅People who could not in 5 lifetimes accomplish what the artist has in this performance. She departs from the score as Berenboim, Richter, Levit and Gould have done. Beautiful interpretation, brava.
Oh, they're everywhere
They don't own the piece but act as such
Oh please, I have high school students who can play the piece just like this, and probably with a more beautiful tone quality and sense of line.
This young woman can certainly play the piece, but she looks great in a dress and with long hair, which sells thousands of copies.
Let's not pretend, shall we.
@@lagunagreg4019It's true, you are a piano teacher. Listen to the music and leave the clothing issue to the dressmakers.
As always, and as Socrates already showed in the 5th century BC, the problem is that people believe they know what they do not know. Judge the world for valuing clothing more than the sound of music, but leave this girl alone, as our colleague Fray Juan Bermudo (musical theorist who published the Declaration of Musical Instruments in 1555) already said: "God will give science to those who have it as long as they share it."
By the way, I also belong to the musicians' guild, and I am ashamed to see how, with my still young 21 years, snobbery and arrogance reign in our beautiful art.
Bach is not understandable without the idea of God or, at least, of the Whole; So you should know by now that in any interpretation of Bach, only that which is celestial is a worthy judge.
I deeply regret that your excess of science has clouded your true judgment by academic conventions, and I hope that after extensive thoughts, you will accept the world as it happens, and not how you would like it to happen.
And on the other hand, I apologize if it seems that I spoke abruptly; I only believe I have said the right words, no more and no less than necessary.
Have a cordial greeting and guard your soul from vainglory (Ptahhotep already said: "may your heart not be vain because of what it knows")
beatiful and emotional.
いかなる演奏においても時空を超えてBachは普く顕現する。ここには能楽を思わせる、序破急があります。深く感動いたしました。ありがとうございます。
The piano is an extension of her soul.
She feels the tension of the pieces movement in time and plays aware of the pieces “great phrase”
Spell binding beauty.
You mean the dress, the hair, and the good lighting? I quite agree.
The performance, much less so.
深みのある素晴らしい演奏です！
そして、同時に気になるのはこのピアノは何年製のスタインウェイでしょうか？
見た目あまり外観はあまりメンテされていなそうに見えますが、素晴らしい音に驚きました。
目をつぶって聴いていると、リヒテルの音色のようです。
Extremely nice ❤❤❤
Very good.
This is way too romantic! But I like it. Thank you!
A perfect example of Bach played like it was Schumann.
Bach singing😊
Could nt be better played!
You got it!
Olives
Another very cute Asian woman at the piano. 😍. Great music too.
手つきはやわらかそうなんだけど、なんか音が固いような気がして落ち着かない
too much wrist with these hyper-trained orientals
Mechanical and metronomic
That's the way Bach wrote it. If you want Rachmaninov, you're in the wrong video.
Lacks sensitive dynamics, I can not like this. This expression is not European culture.
Wow then show your own professional demonstration?
Ich denke alle Menschen jeglichen Kulturkreises und jeglichen Standes dürfen sich mit dem grossen Bach auseinandersetzen.
Es kann spannend sein, was dabei herauskommt.
Und der Bach nimmt keinen Schaden. Er surft über alle Vorstellungen seiner Interpreten hinweg.
Bach no pertenece unicamente a la cultura occidental si no a todos nosotros, al mundo entero