AspenPaw Arts my guess is that they didn’t watch the whole video then when they did they went “Oh.. she DID include him.. oh, well, it’s funny anyways.”
Before FireStar died, sandstorm said “I love you.” I lost it then. For me she knew he wasn't gonna live any longer. And when FireStar died, I burst into tears. However his personality kinda disappeared after the prophecies begin. (Sorry for my rant XD)
For some reason I didn't cry xD I guess I didn't like him as much, as he was pretty annoying, because everyone thought he was this "high person/cat, that is better than everyone"
@@mo0onsh0t It's ironic in a way because that was exactly firestar's struggle at first, trying to prove himself to be as good as all the clanborn cats who thought they were the "high and mighty" ones. In a way he had to become like that to at all change the clan's prejudice. In short: he just about took on the role of the cats he was trying to prove himself to (although he did make a difference)
I had a dream of Akira being a middle schooler . . . how weird. Then I woke up and that was the day Akira's icon changed. I had an OMEN from STARCLAN, you can call me your medicine cat now.
@@arianamarie8442 Wow, thanks! I have a few OC's that I try to make mirror my personality, but I haven't made an actual medicine cat one . . . honestly, yeah, that'd probably be my name.
Past this point is a roleplay section if you want to join read the how to join below ___________________________________ Allegiance; Leader; scarstar Deputy; Juniperbush Warriors; GooseFeather Waspstripe Feathersong *app Frecklepaw* Moonstripe *app Tumblepaw* Honeyshine Apprentices; Tumblepaw Frecklepaw branchpaw Kits; wolfkit, Snowkit Medicine cat; skyleaf (App); *Flamefur* Queens; Shrewclaw Elders _________________________ Outsiders/kittypets/rouges Scarwhisker (rogue) (Look at skylar lees comment for more detail mine is just real people that are one cat, not npc multiples)
Cats I would've added: Thushpelt. He is such an underrated little baby! He could've reacted like Ashfur, but he didn't. Stonefur. No one talks about Stonefur! I fell in love with even though he was only in a couple chapters. Redtail: I admit, I haven't read whatever his novella is, I just really, really like him. Oakheart: In the words of Bliximi, I truly adore this cat. Scourge:..... I also admit I don't know why I love him so much. Darktail: A L S O don't know why I love him so much. I mean, just look at my profile picture.
Redtail's novella wasn't that interesting, but I would still recommend it. it just his POV of Tigerclaw before he killed him, and how Tigerclaw manipulated him.
Me: I hope Firestar’s here! Though people think he’s overrated and a Mary Sue so I shouldn’t get my hopes u- Akira: *adds Firestar Me: *happy Firestar noises*
@@insertname.5985 no hate but I think that most of the warriors characters need alot of work I mean okay all of them do because it just seems like the book is a kid who's playing with their action figures I mean theres nothing wrong with that. But the plot really has no point to it other then okay theres a battle coming up In The near future we should prepare for it or theres a bad guy on the loose we should deal with it and then they deal with it but then they waste time just doing some else away from the main part of the story and the characters idc how much you say its emotional to me I feel nothing no not because idk have heart it's just that simply throwing something that would be realisticly emotional without any depth wouldn't make it emotional like for example moonflowers death and bluestar and snowfur crying they didnt say anything that could potentially trigger emotion I would have said that bluepaws heart was shattered into pieces there was nothing she could do her mother was dead she felt cold and numb just like her dead mothers body but as she grieved with her sister beside her a light shined and then they watched as their mother curled around them in an embrace and whispered to them dont cry because I'm gone be happy because I was there and I will always be there for you even though I'm far away I always be here in your heart as moonflower finished and faded away or something like that and if there were some more family moments as well because I think that would make the scene that seems emotional would make it more emotional because I didnt find firestars death that emotional because telling sandstorm he loved her without any evidence I was just sitting there emotionless the whole time so that's what I mean when warriors is stiff and all the characters pretty much need work
willowfur the fox no offence taken, I see your point and agree that warrior cats characters do need more working on. Some characters have lots of potential and need to have character development and the books need some more emotion. Dawn of the Clans has some amazing books because of the good characters. Gray Wing, Clear Sky, Thunder and even the background characters are good. I enjoy reading Dawn of the Clans, and the other books should certainly be more like it. Have a good day
Akira: *going through the list* Me, like a greedy badger: *wheres Jayfeather? Where? Where is he?!* Akira: *gets to number one* Me: *inhales* Akira: Jayf- Me: *spontaneously bursts into dancing*
For people here who are confused about the new sprites and icon: Akira came out as trans, and now she is using she/her pronouns. Please respect these pronouns!
In a Q&A stream with Moonkitti, she mentions she hates Tigerheart but loves Tigerstar. She mentions that Tigerheart manipulates Dovewing and doesn't do much in compensation, which makes it seem as if he was just using her instead of actually caring for her (ShadowClan has a problem with stealing ThunderClan apprentices to get herbs). _Tigerstar_ on the other hand is a good, dedicated parent and mate who tries his best in tough situations. I don't like him, but he's definitely a good character and a huge improvement from Tigerheart. After watching the "Jayfeather Scene Everyone Missed", and doing that survey on the Warriors website (which took over an hour long, I typed too much in the Other section), I remember a question regarding which Super Editions and manga would you like to see. Personally, I'm fine with anything (aside from Onestar . . . Leopardstar and Blackstar would be interesting, but Onestar is pretty much a brat non-The Prophecies Begin.), but I did write Squirrelflight, which breaks up the formula but there could be a manga, plus having her important roles in the Ashfur love triangle and The Broken Code, and Alderheart, because of his therapist role in that bonus scene. It would be interesting to see him [therapist as a verb, which I'm pretty sure doesn't exist] cats until he dies . . . loved . . .
Top toms in Warriors: (in no particular order) Firestar, Jayfeather, Gray Wing, Clear Sky, Crowfeather, Alderheart, Tree, Hawkwing, Shadowsight, Rootspring. I'm so thankful Bramblestar isn't on this list. I either like these cats for character development, personality, or overall role in their highest point.
I think that Power of 3 is what kind of killed Firestar for a lot of people. Rereading the entire series I had forgotten how much character and personality he actually had, albeit he was still his best in Prophecies Begin. Saying that, he wasn't bad in New Prophecy, especially at the start. I really enjoyed seeing him interact with his daughters as apprentices. From what I can tell, I really believe that it was Power of 3 and Omen of the Stars that soured him for a lot of people. This was the point where he stopped having meaningful connnections with the cats around him, and basically became an all powerful emotionless robot. Not even mentioning the "Find the Fourth Cat" prophecy; which I consider the be the single most pointless prophecy in the entire series. It's not like Firestar would have done anything different without it. Finally, becasue of this, it made his death one of the least emotional in the entire series. The problem is that everybody when into The Last Hope knowing that he wound die. (kind of simular to Bluestar) If you are going to make in incredibly predictable death have any sort of impact, you need to go over the top. I've always said that His final battle with Tigerstar should have been from his perspective; that is a hill I'm going to die on. It would have been a nice way to wrap up the story, and a nice call back. If I were writing The Last Hope, I would have Firestar take over right as Sandstorm was being attacked by Mapleshade. This way you could see his feeling of him seeing the two cats he loved being attacked in front of him. We could know what he was thinking as he says his final goodbye to Spottedleaf. He could even have a moment of "Wait what is Sandstorm thinking" after Firestar confeses his love for Spottedleaf as she is fading. He could have a moment of panic thinking that Sandstom is going to reject him becasue of it. But have her say that she understands and they can have a final moment together. Ok, the whole thing with Spottedleaf didn't have to be from his prespective, although it would have been better. However, his final confrontation with Tigerstar needed to be. This has been built up for 24 books at this point, they needed to go all in with this scene. I would have loved to have seen Firestar feeling literally all of the emotions at once. All of the fear, courage, anger, resentment, pride, and maybe even some respect for Tigerstar should have boiled over at this point. One thing that I would have changed was the whole Tigerstar missed his death blow lol. This is probably the single most cliche thing they could have done. A few people I know say that, that should have just been cut out entirely. However, I think what should have happened is; have Tigerstar actually land the hit, but then have Firestar be all like "I'm taking you out with me." Have Tigerstar let his guard down thinking that he has won, and have Firestar be all like nope. For a long time Firestar's signature thing was making his opponent think that they had won and then punishing them for it. That would have been a really good throwback to earlier books. Ah yes, another wall of text, this is just something I am fairly passionate about. One thing that I will add it Squirrelflight's hope is one of his best appearences in terms of emotional build.
No one asked but mine are: 5. Longtail - I STAN for him he best 4. Micah - Another great character that I stan! 3. Tree - Best dad and best bush ALSO STAN BUSH 2. Lightning Tail - MY BOI MY PRECIOUS BOI I STAN 1. Jayfeather - He just deserves it I stan also All Kings in my opinion
Me: I really love Jayfeather, but certain people don’t like him, I’m not sure if Akira like him, so I won’t get my hopes to high up for seeing him on the list ^Jayfeather is number 1 on the list^ Me: SCREECH OF HAPPINESS!!!!
Yassss! My boi Jayfetaher deserves that number one lol.. That doesn't mean that I think the other cats are bad it just means they are good and jayfeather is great... anyway.... thank you so much for this awesome video can't wait for the next one!
I feel like this has really gotten "old" to the point where not as many ppl watch anymore 😭😭 Akira I dont watch all ur videos but Im subbed and still enjoy the videos I do watch!
@@pikathemimikyu6655 Im just saying I feel like not as many ppl watch Akira as often anymore bc either they're growing out of the "warriors phase" or they just think his content has gotten old- he may not be as enthusiastic as he used to be but he's still the same Akira we know and love❤ Good job Akira, you've come so far👍👍
Akira: And I do like the Rootspring/Bristlefrost pairing, just in the sense that the scenes they're together feel so emotionally charged-- *intense spinning*
I’m that one person who loves bramblestar. I just love the development in his character in the new prophecy and he is my favorite cat by far. I would put him at 10 though because I cannot ignore him being a jerk to squirrelflight in squirrelflight hope.
I'm glad for her! I'm just straight as a line but I support BIG TIME. SUPER PROUD FOR HER and anyone else who's trans. I'm a proud ally, if anyone needs support, here is your crown and support: 👑🤗
FEELS SO- *rootspring and bristlefrost start spinning madly for 3 seconds* -EMOTIONALLY CHARGED me: head starts singing electric feel edit: peeks at last while ignoring crow me: IIIIIITTTTTSSS JJJJAAAYYYYFFFEEEAATTTHHHEEERRR
Interesting Idea! Although I don't like the whole time travel thing. And Half Moon. SO if you cut out Jayfeather/Jay's Wing thing and Half Moon then I'd be totally down for that. I hope they make the Ancients more unique/different though.
Random Potato i really want either what happened after they arrive at the Tribe territory, or before that and some origin for how they formed. That’d be so cool :D
@@LmaoMeowz Yeah! Like how do these groups come together? What make these cats be like 'oh lets be together', right? cuz like, even in dotc they started out from a group called tribes into a new group called clans. the ancients were already a group beforehand, so what make these cats think 'oh we'd survive better together' kinda deal, ya know? Since in Firestar's Quest it was Firestar who made SkyClan, so I want a reason that has nothing to do with outside group telling them what to do.
If I had done this Tigerclaw Star would have been there because reading through the first six books it’s so easy to say “I hate you Tigerstar” whenever he gets away with something
Same. Like AlderPAW was a solid character, and the Erins just forgot to solve his whole character arc or smth. actually they just solved it in like the next book or smth. And like Shadowpaw was interesting, but then I'm afraid it's going to happen again like Alderheart.
My top Tom cats 10.Tallstar 9.Crookedstar 8.Hawkfrost 7.Tigerstar the first 6.Firestar 5.Ashfur 4.Gray wing 3.Stormfur 2.Graystripe 1.JAYFEATHER!!!!!!!!!!
Darktail: "OI, WHY DON'T I GET A SPOT?" Tigerstar: "Uh because everyone thinks we dumb." 26 Dislikes Be Like: *Tigerstar and Darktail switch from different yt accounts, dislking on each* I mean, obviously.
I love Jayfeather also, because it’s really great to see in the perspective of a disabled character and the fact that he was a lot different than other cats. I’d say that he’s my #2 favorite character in the entire series, not just out of the male characters. ❤️
Ooooo Tigerstat I mean I'll go with it. Shadowsight is a good cat. Alderheart is understandable. OMG I love trees design is so cute. It makes him look cool. Darktial design is 9 out of ten. Gray wing OMG . I love gray wing and turtletial . There designs are so beautiful. Missy Dakota draws so well. As far as the design goes I agree 💯. This was cool to watch. I really loved the order they were in.
Yes, I adore Hawkwing so much!! I love him as a dad and seeing him struggle with his grief over his brother and dad and mate. Gah, I could rant about how much I adore Hawkwing.
Akira: *doesn’t include Crowfeather*
Tenelle: *so you have chosen death*
Akira: *ends up including him (sort of)*
Tennelle: Now *thats* better..
yeah
She said he was 7
AspenPaw Arts my guess is that they didn’t watch the whole video then when they did they went “Oh.. she DID include him.. oh, well, it’s funny anyways.”
Omg I love Crowfeather! I was sad not to see to him here
“Little blind cat”
I completely forgot that Jayfeather is a tiny angry gremlin.
"Jayfeather is small. Like his mum, Squirrelflight! Squirrelflight is the mum."
How?
Im proud of it
He's _my_ tiny angry gremlin.
Jayfeather I-
Before FireStar died, sandstorm said “I love you.” I lost it then. For me she knew he wasn't gonna live any longer. And when FireStar died, I burst into tears. However his personality kinda disappeared after the prophecies begin. (Sorry for my rant XD)
i think we all did that
He didn’t transition well from being the main character to a side/background character
For some reason I didn't cry xD I guess I didn't like him as much, as he was pretty annoying, because everyone thought he was this "high person/cat, that is better than everyone"
ThiccQueen Moon That’s because he’s the start of warrior cats. He’s the main hero
@@mo0onsh0t It's ironic in a way because that was exactly firestar's struggle at first, trying to prove himself to be as good as all the clanborn cats who thought they were the "high and mighty" ones. In a way he had to become like that to at all change the clan's prejudice. In short: he just about took on the role of the cats he was trying to prove himself to (although he did make a difference)
Alderheart: *Is a cinnamon roll*
Me: _OUR SON_
BrO YES
Alderheart does look like a cinnamon roll
Yes!
snowfrostclaws aj oh yes
yes.
I had a dream of Akira being a middle schooler . . . how weird.
Then I woke up and that was the day Akira's icon changed.
I had an OMEN from STARCLAN, you can call me your medicine cat now.
Okay > skyleaf
Based on your profile name, I think Skyleaf would be your name. Let me know what you think!
Aris Marie good idea
@@arianamarie8442 Wow, thanks! I have a few OC's that I try to make mirror my personality, but I haven't made an actual medicine cat one . . . honestly, yeah, that'd probably be my name.
Past this point is a roleplay section if you want to join read the how to join below
___________________________________
Allegiance;
Leader; scarstar
Deputy; Juniperbush
Warriors;
GooseFeather
Waspstripe
Feathersong *app Frecklepaw*
Moonstripe *app Tumblepaw*
Honeyshine
Apprentices; Tumblepaw Frecklepaw branchpaw
Kits; wolfkit, Snowkit
Medicine cat; skyleaf
(App); *Flamefur*
Queens; Shrewclaw
Elders
_________________________
Outsiders/kittypets/rouges
Scarwhisker (rogue)
(Look at skylar lees comment for more detail mine is just real people that are one cat, not npc multiples)
Akira: To start off the list, we have..
Me: An unpopular opinion
......I love Tigerheart......
Tallstar's Revenge is my all time favorite super edition, my second favorite is Crookedstar's Promise
TallStar’s revenge is the best super edition by far, and kind of the best book besides maybe some of the first series ones
Have you read Tigerhearts shadow...? Lol that’s my fav
Not yet but I want to
WolfstarWoof Animation and Gaming
Yeah. I don’t care much for tigerheart, but his super edition was really good.
@ZOEY ALISON FINKE Wow! What's your top 2 then? Mine is Bluestar's and Tallstar's! Third would be Crookedstar's!
Cats I would've added:
Thushpelt. He is such an underrated little baby! He could've reacted like Ashfur, but he didn't.
Stonefur. No one talks about Stonefur! I fell in love with even though he was only in a couple chapters.
Redtail: I admit, I haven't read whatever his novella is, I just really, really like him.
Oakheart: In the words of Bliximi, I truly adore this cat.
Scourge:..... I also admit I don't know why I love him so much.
Darktail: A L S O don't know why I love him so much. I mean, just look at my profile picture.
I LOVE Thrushpelt, Oakheart and Scourge! Oakheart and Scourge both make my top ten toms list 100% and Thrushpelt is so precious 🥺
@@acerola7955 if it weren't for him, feathertail and stormfur probably wouldve died.
I would added Lightning Tail MY BOI He so good boy he best boy
Redtail's novella wasn't that interesting, but I would still recommend it. it just his POV of Tigerclaw before he killed him, and how Tigerclaw manipulated him.
YES STONEFUR ✊
Me: I hope Firestar’s here! Though people think he’s overrated and a Mary Sue so I shouldn’t get my hopes u-
Akira: *adds Firestar
Me: *happy Firestar noises*
He is my favorite :)
I’m not much of a fan of Firestar because he’s not really original, boring compared to the others. But I sort of see your point
@@insertname.5985 no hate but I think that most of the warriors characters need alot of work I mean okay all of them do because it just seems like the book is a kid who's playing with their action figures I mean theres nothing wrong with that. But the plot really has no point to it other then okay theres a battle coming up In The near future we should prepare for it or theres a bad guy on the loose we should deal with it and then they deal with it but then they waste time just doing some else away from the main part of the story and the characters idc how much you say its emotional to me I feel nothing no not because idk have heart it's just that simply throwing something that would be realisticly emotional without any depth wouldn't make it emotional like for example moonflowers death and bluestar and snowfur crying they didnt say anything that could potentially trigger emotion I would have said that bluepaws heart was shattered into pieces there was nothing she could do her mother was dead she felt cold and numb just like her dead mothers body but as she grieved with her sister beside her a light shined and then they watched as their mother curled around them in an embrace and whispered to them dont cry because I'm gone be happy because I was there and I will always be there for you even though I'm far away I always be here in your heart as moonflower finished and faded away or something like that and if there were some more family moments as well because I think that would make the scene that seems emotional would make it more emotional because I didnt find firestars death that emotional because telling sandstorm he loved her without any evidence I was just sitting there emotionless the whole time so that's what I mean when warriors is stiff and all the characters pretty much need work
willowfur the fox no offence taken, I see your point and agree that warrior cats characters do need more working on. Some characters have lots of potential and need to have character development and the books need some more emotion. Dawn of the Clans has some amazing books because of the good characters. Gray Wing, Clear Sky, Thunder and even the background characters are good. I enjoy reading Dawn of the Clans, and the other books should certainly be more like it. Have a good day
Me starting a war in the comments be like:
._.
Jake needs his own super edition, I need to see his thoughts on everything!
*We also need to see the gayness*
BIG FAT FIRE DAD YES
I mean yes. He *IS* your dad. My dad, too. He's *everyone's* dad.
@@Owibi jake is everyones father, jake is your father.
*jake is our father*
Akira: *going through the list*
Me, like a greedy badger: *wheres Jayfeather? Where? Where is he?!*
Akira: *gets to number one*
Me: *inhales*
Akira: Jayf-
Me: *spontaneously bursts into dancing*
This is me
Me:*cries in being the only person on this earth who doesn’t see why everyone cry’s with joy with any mention of jayfeather*
Me who hates Jayfeather:
**Slowly shakes head**
꧁CřispýFriĕdTøeş꧂ that username is actually amazing
The Warrior Cat Hashtag lmao yes
Akira: I'm gonna go by she/her pronouns for the time being.
Me:
*Support 100*
Saniya Quinones
Correction: support 100000000000000
Nhat Minh she posted it on Twitter
twitter.com/Bright_Guardian/status/1276908338786127873?s=20
@Nhat Minh Yep! She's trans!
Transgender pride yEssss
Also, I think Akira isn't sure so it might change in the future. Right now they're a girl ^^
Bright Guardian Akira: posts video
Me: rushes to comments
same
You: rushes to comment before even watching and appreciating the video
Ugh I hate these comments they suck and are so repetitive
Akira : *Doesn’t include Ravenpaw*
Me: *Death it is then.*
Dawn Animates lol I love raven paw he a sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo cute
YES
RAVENPAW 4EVER
I can already tell that JayFeather will be on this list
Edit: yep, called it
@Katherine Schneider I get the reference XD
But forgive my for saying...
JayPURRger
:3
I think everyone called it ^^; I mean he deserves the spot tho haha
@Random Potato agreed XD
@Katherine Schneider What the fu.....?? LOL
well he did save McDonald's so.....
Jayfeather: **doesnt appear the whole vid**
Everyone: **sad**
Akira: number one: Ja-
Everyone: **SCREECHING**
For people here who are confused about the new sprites and icon:
Akira came out as trans, and now she is using she/her pronouns. Please respect these pronouns!
Kitti Colors really where?
Emicorn Twitter- kinda anoyying she didn’t say anything about it on UA-cam where more people know her but eh
@@orchid7493
Twitter! Here's the link: twitter.com/Bright_Guardian/status/1276908338786127873?s=20
Some random girl ty
thanks for the info! i wasn’t exactly expecting it, but it’s cool and all
In a Q&A stream with Moonkitti, she mentions she hates Tigerheart but loves Tigerstar. She mentions that Tigerheart manipulates Dovewing and doesn't do much in compensation, which makes it seem as if he was just using her instead of actually caring for her (ShadowClan has a problem with stealing ThunderClan apprentices to get herbs). _Tigerstar_ on the other hand is a good, dedicated parent and mate who tries his best in tough situations. I don't like him, but he's definitely a good character and a huge improvement from Tigerheart.
After watching the "Jayfeather Scene Everyone Missed", and doing that survey on the Warriors website (which took over an hour long, I typed too much in the Other section), I remember a question regarding which Super Editions and manga would you like to see. Personally, I'm fine with anything (aside from Onestar . . . Leopardstar and Blackstar would be interesting, but Onestar is pretty much a brat non-The Prophecies Begin.), but I did write Squirrelflight, which breaks up the formula but there could be a manga, plus having her important roles in the Ashfur love triangle and The Broken Code, and Alderheart, because of his therapist role in that bonus scene. It would be interesting to see him [therapist as a verb, which I'm pretty sure doesn't exist] cats until he dies . . . loved . . .
i was also in that stream, and i agree. my friend hates tigerheart for taking the herbs, but she hasn’t read avos yet.
I see that yeah, I guess Akira saw those issues as character growth (which I don’t blame him)
Instead of SquirrelFlight sense there’s already books from her perspective, maybe AshFur? It would be interesting too see his side of things
AspenPaw Arts maybe there will be an ashfur novella after the broken code arc is over
@@topmalk Either that or a Squirrelflight manga, an illustrated or Ashfur-POV of the fire would be really awesome.
Me hoping that alderheart is in the vid
Akira: *puts alderheart in vid*
Me: *victory yowl*
Hi Leafstar, you're the only sensible leader around the lake currently, good job :)
I love hearing Akira's opinions on these books.
I may not agree with all of them, but Akira makes some valid points in every video.
Akira: doesn't mention Ravenpaw
Me: All around me are familiar traces worn out face...
HoneyBee Productions 🐱
RAVENPAW IS BEST
Top toms in Warriors: (in no particular order)
Firestar, Jayfeather, Gray Wing, Clear Sky, Crowfeather, Alderheart, Tree, Hawkwing, Shadowsight, Rootspring.
I'm so thankful Bramblestar isn't on this list. I either like these cats for character development, personality, or overall role in their highest point.
Yes finally! Someone else who thinks Gray Wing deserves attention! 😄
Edit: Clear Sky is amazing too. I love Dawn Of The Clans
*I’M* obviously number 1
Hahahahaha cant argue with that honestly
Scourge McEdgeLord hahaa.... who is gonna tell him?
@@quackitsnackits6735 don't
no.
you should be in the ''worst'' list
*yes*
Jayfeather is my favorite tomcat, no my favorite character, Ima go order a Jayburger I'm hungry
Can you get me one ?
@@warriorcathub4244 okie dokie
@@RowletRampage Thx
He my fav in all
I haven't read the broken code yet ;-;
And then I'm early yEeS
Jayfeather really has a distinct personality that makes him such a great character
My library only got the broken code 2 weeks ago
@@cutekittins406lleshull6 Lucky- ;-;
Cutekittins406 Oof my library only has books 1, 3 and 5 of the prophecies begin so I had to download literally EVERY single other book on my kindle
I think that Power of 3 is what kind of killed Firestar for a lot of people. Rereading the entire series I had forgotten how much character and personality he actually had, albeit he was still his best in Prophecies Begin. Saying that, he wasn't bad in New Prophecy, especially at the start. I really enjoyed seeing him interact with his daughters as apprentices.
From what I can tell, I really believe that it was Power of 3 and Omen of the Stars that soured him for a lot of people. This was the point where he stopped having meaningful connnections with the cats around him, and basically became an all powerful emotionless robot. Not even mentioning the "Find the Fourth Cat" prophecy; which I consider the be the single most pointless prophecy in the entire series. It's not like Firestar would have done anything different without it.
Finally, becasue of this, it made his death one of the least emotional in the entire series. The problem is that everybody when into The Last Hope knowing that he wound die. (kind of simular to Bluestar) If you are going to make in incredibly predictable death have any sort of impact, you need to go over the top. I've always said that His final battle with Tigerstar should have been from his perspective; that is a hill I'm going to die on. It would have been a nice way to wrap up the story, and a nice call back.
If I were writing The Last Hope, I would have Firestar take over right as Sandstorm was being attacked by Mapleshade. This way you could see his feeling of him seeing the two cats he loved being attacked in front of him. We could know what he was thinking as he says his final goodbye to Spottedleaf. He could even have a moment of "Wait what is Sandstorm thinking" after Firestar confeses his love for Spottedleaf as she is fading. He could have a moment of panic thinking that Sandstom is going to reject him becasue of it. But have her say that she understands and they can have a final moment together.
Ok, the whole thing with Spottedleaf didn't have to be from his prespective, although it would have been better. However, his final confrontation with Tigerstar needed to be. This has been built up for 24 books at this point, they needed to go all in with this scene. I would have loved to have seen Firestar feeling literally all of the emotions at once. All of the fear, courage, anger, resentment, pride, and maybe even some respect for Tigerstar should have boiled over at this point. One thing that I would have changed was the whole Tigerstar missed his death blow lol. This is probably the single most cliche thing they could have done. A few people I know say that, that should have just been cut out entirely. However, I think what should have happened is; have Tigerstar actually land the hit, but then have Firestar be all like "I'm taking you out with me." Have Tigerstar let his guard down thinking that he has won, and have Firestar be all like nope. For a long time Firestar's signature thing was making his opponent think that they had won and then punishing them for it. That would have been a really good throwback to earlier books.
Ah yes, another wall of text, this is just something I am fairly passionate about. One thing that I will add it Squirrelflight's hope is one of his best appearences in terms of emotional build.
A+ for the essay
Top Sauce
Very beautiful essay, you nailed it.
Top 5 Tomcats (in my opinion):
5. TigerheartStar
4. Tallstar
3. Crowfeather
2. Gray Wing
1. Jayfeather!
We do! I love Stonefur.
Good
Hikari- -Chan how do you feel about eating red berries with no explanation
No one asked but mine are:
5. Longtail - I STAN for him he best
4. Micah - Another great character that I stan!
3. Tree - Best dad and best bush ALSO STAN BUSH
2. Lightning Tail - MY BOI MY PRECIOUS BOI I STAN
1. Jayfeather - He just deserves it I stan also
All Kings in my opinion
@Snowleopard101 I Knoooowwwww he is so precious
Congratulations for coming out Akira! You are amazing and just know, I will always support you girl!
I was expecting Greywing being number one but Jayfeathers cool
Cindrr same
It better be
@Lila Wagner Well it's her opinion and this whole thing is subjective.
Me too but I can't argue with Jayfeather being number one.
Gray Wing is so underrated.
*When your favorite tom is Thrushpelt-*
I know- where’s my bb 😔🤚
He's not in my top ten but I still LOVE him he's such a good boy 🥺
Def in my top 10
I’m so glad I’m not the only one UvU
Thrushpelt is my favorite by far
Thrushpelt WHO-?
Nah seriously though he's okay in my opinion
but its cool and i respect that ppl like him and he deserves that.
Me: I really love Jayfeather, but certain people don’t like him, I’m not sure if Akira like him, so I won’t get my hopes to high up for seeing him on the list
^Jayfeather is number 1 on the list^
Me: SCREECH OF HAPPINESS!!!!
Yassss! My boi Jayfetaher deserves that number one lol.. That doesn't mean that I think the other cats are bad it just means they are good and jayfeather is great... anyway.... thank you so much for this awesome video can't wait for the next one!
Jayfetaher
Kinda sad Ravenpaw wasn’t included and Crowfeather was forgotten, but Jayfeather being first made up for it
All your choices were absolutely spot on
Akira: *talking about Rootspring’s relationship with Bristlefrost*
Bristlefrost and Rootspring: *intense spinning*
Shadowsight: ...?
Spiresight: *we will watch your career with great interest*
lmao
I feel like this has really gotten "old" to the point where not as many ppl watch anymore 😭😭 Akira I dont watch all ur videos but Im subbed and still enjoy the videos I do watch!
No way Akira is great!
Emotional Wolf ye
@@pikathemimikyu6655 Im just saying I feel like not as many ppl watch Akira as often anymore bc either they're growing out of the "warriors phase" or they just think his content has gotten old- he may not be as enthusiastic as he used to be but he's still the same Akira we know and love❤ Good job Akira, you've come so far👍👍
Akita is a she now!
Yes I realised that Akira is a she/her moments after I posted that comment mb
I knew it would be our king, Jayfeather
me too
We all did
And I no longer have to flip a town as I promised I would do if Jaybae wasn’t first
👑
Akira: And I do like the Rootspring/Bristlefrost pairing, just in the sense that the scenes they're together feel so emotionally charged-- *intense spinning*
When you are early but you don’t know what to say.
Last time I was early, Oakheart was alive
"3. Gray Wing"
Me (who's favorite character is Gray Wing): yesss, Gray Wing!
Akira: And Jayfeather-
Me: YES THE GRUMPY BLIND GREMLIN-
Sol be rocking forward and backward having a mental break down
*_as usual, probably/j_*
first time i have ever been this early?!
Same here
Same
*sad Thrushpelt noises*
I really liked some of your picks! Very interesting ones I wasn't expecting were on here and I love it!
"There are a lot of cats that are just plain old jerks"
Pulls up a picture of Bramblestar. HINT HINT
Squirrelfart started the fights!
@@FabulousFeathertail She doesnt? Bramblestar punishes her for even daring to have an opinion
I’m that one person who loves bramblestar. I just love the development in his character in the new prophecy and he is my favorite cat by far. I would put him at 10 though because I cannot ignore him being a jerk to squirrelflight in squirrelflight hope.
Liking a cat doesnt mean you condone their actions, so brambleclaw could be 1 if you want :)
Akira's new Cat sprite is my *life!* Props to Dako! And, also, *trans rights!* -proud pansexual noises-
Wait, Akira’s trans?! THAT’S AMAZING!!!!!! **proud ace and lesbian noises**
*proud omnisexual noises*
@@lynxz-studios Yeah, she goes by she/her pronouns now
It's on her twitter
I'm glad for her! I'm just straight as a line but I support BIG TIME. SUPER PROUD FOR HER and anyone else who's trans.
I'm a proud ally, if anyone needs support, here is your crown and support: 👑🤗
Random Potato
Same, I’m straight, but I support her a lot! I’m really happy for her!
I really like how you go and describe what you really think instead of going oh firestar is awesome, he led the clans in battle la di da.
FEELS SO-
*rootspring and bristlefrost start spinning madly for 3 seconds*
-EMOTIONALLY CHARGED
me: head starts singing electric feel
edit: peeks at last while ignoring crow
me: IIIIIITTTTTSSS JJJJAAAYYYYFFFEEEAATTTHHHEEERRR
Warriors should have another series like Dawn of the Clans but with the Ancients!!
Yesssss i second that!♡
Interesting Idea! Although I don't like the whole time travel thing. And Half Moon. SO if you cut out Jayfeather/Jay's Wing thing and Half Moon then I'd be totally down for that. I hope they make the Ancients more unique/different though.
Random Potato i really want either what happened after they arrive at the Tribe territory, or before that and some origin for how they formed. That’d be so cool :D
@@LmaoMeowz Yeah! Like how do these groups come together? What make these cats be like 'oh lets be together', right? cuz like, even in dotc they started out from a group called tribes into a new group called clans. the ancients were already a group beforehand, so what make these cats think 'oh we'd survive better together' kinda deal, ya know? Since in Firestar's Quest it was Firestar who made SkyClan, so I want a reason that has nothing to do with outside group telling them what to do.
I got so happy that Gray Wing is on this list. He’s my number 1 favorite cat and that probably won’t change.
Me too. DOTC really needs more attention!
Tree has my heart the moment she said “you have to think bush” too 😂
7:47 briarlight x jayfeather is confirmed
Blutle 1
I always shipped them along with Fallen Leaves and Hollyleaf.
Blutle 1 hecc yeah
Yaaaass my fav ship!
Eiji Kobayashi EW!
Rockstar Ivypool
What?
This is so coool
gg man u first
Yay mah fav gurl posting some of her warrior content.Keep it up Akira and take as much time as you need if anything ever happens I can wait :3
2:15 I’m still proud of getting that quote in the out of context quotes video.
AKIRA I AM SO HAPPY FOR YOU!!
(She is trans so respect her pronouns!)
yup! support her all the way.
Me: I just know that Jayfeather is the number one pick
Akira: Number one, Jayfeather
Me: Of course
Jayfeather is the Toph Beifong of warrior cats
If I had done this Tigerclaw Star would have been there because reading through the first six books it’s so easy to say “I hate you Tigerstar” whenever he gets away with something
jayfeather god
Could you do top ten kits/apps cause some cats completely loose there personality after the kit/app stage and it's annoying 😂
Not always. Jayfeather was always salty lol
@@crucify_then_learn3370 jayfeathers just a salty bae 😂
Same. Like AlderPAW was a solid character, and the Erins just forgot to solve his whole character arc or smth. actually they just solved it in like the next book or smth.
And like Shadowpaw was interesting, but then I'm afraid it's going to happen again like Alderheart.
JayFeather is my all-time favourite character! He’s just so grumpy, sarcastic and dry! 🤍
Akira: top 10 popular Tom cats
Me:hmmmmmmm
Mind:Tigerstar? TIGERSTAR 2!?!?
I agree,Jayfeather is the best character in the books,I can't love his personality
Where's maggottail
Snif.
He's the best.
like that dark forest dude?
@@beaniebooking268 yeah.
He's too minor of a character to make a difference in the story tbh
Koda, Just Koda
... wait, who was Maggottail?
@@jayfeatherthesnarkymedicin8160 a tom from the darkforest.
me: *thinking of my favorite toms*
my mom (who has only read the first arc and midnight) I LIKE BRACKENFUR!
me: *Sputtering of laughter*
Hope Bright Guardian Akira gets a 100,000 subscribers!
Me:definatly number 1 is Jayfather
Akira:number 1......Jayfather
Also me: I know it😂
Me: wonders who will be first
Remembers Jayfeather exists: I have no questions
JayFeather really took after his natural father, CrowFeather.
JAYFEATHER IS MY FAVORITE CAT IN THE WHOLE UNIVERSE! i even named a cat i saw after jayfeather
me:i'm guessing the number 1 tomcat is gonna be jayfeather
akira:my number 1 tomcat is jayfeather
me:knew it
the thing about firestar is that he lost his personality after a bit :(
sadly that happens a lot in characters after we're out of their POV.
Poor Lionblaze barely had character
Congrats on coming out girl!
The dislikes are from all the villain cats that heard that clear sky is the best villain and got mad lol
My top Tom cats
10.Tallstar
9.Crookedstar
8.Hawkfrost
7.Tigerstar the first
6.Firestar
5.Ashfur
4.Gray wing
3.Stormfur
2.Graystripe
1.JAYFEATHER!!!!!!!!!!
Yes. Ashfur really needs some more love.
Star wars Fan yeah! My poor Ashboi ;-;
Greystripe and Ashfur deserve more love!
Akira : little blind cat
Jayfeather: *gets offended and mad *
I screamed when he said number one: jayfeather!!
(I Love him too)
When Tree said "think bush"
I felt that.
Yes! I was so excited for this video 😀
Wow, I absolutely adore your art style. I keep imagining my oc in your art style and it looks so good in my head
TwT
Darktail: "OI, WHY DON'T I GET A SPOT?"
Tigerstar: "Uh because everyone thinks we dumb."
26 Dislikes Be Like: *Tigerstar and Darktail switch from different yt accounts, dislking on each*
I mean, obviously.
Obviously.
1:24
Whether intentional or not, the fact Imposter Bramblestar's covering Shadowsight's mouth, covering him, even, it's a nice touch.
I honestly love Jayfeather so much, I could go on and on about my blind angy boi
Akira: number 1: jay feather
Me: *happy noises*
Crowfeather: AM I A JOKE AKIRA???
Aww the new Akira sprite is so adorable :'00
I love Jayfeather also, because it’s really great to see in the perspective of a disabled character and the fact that he was a lot different than other cats. I’d say that he’s my #2 favorite character in the entire series, not just out of the male characters. ❤️
Akira: says all on the list except number 1
Me: aww, my fav cat wasnt on the list!
Akira: Jay-
Me: YESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYES
When number one came along: *HaPPy sCrEEcH*
Ooooo
Tigerstat I mean I'll go with it.
Shadowsight is a good cat.
Alderheart is understandable.
OMG I love trees design is so cute.
It makes him look cool.
Darktial design is 9 out of ten.
Gray wing OMG .
I love gray wing and turtletial .
There designs are so beautiful.
Missy Dakota draws so well.
As far as the design goes I agree 💯.
This was cool to watch.
I really loved the order they were in.
Me: (Zooms through the video)
Me: (Sees Ravenpaw isn't there)
aLsO mE: SO you have chosen . . .
Free McCdonalds!!!!
(Jk I mean death)
Akira talking about spring: Hope and D--
DESPAIR
*Daganronpa*
Akira: Doesn't include Hawkwing
Me: So u have chosen to be murdured, hm? Because Hawkwing is my beautiful boi and the best cat out of all of them!
Yes, I adore Hawkwing so much!! I love him as a dad and seeing him struggle with his grief over his brother and dad and mate. Gah, I could rant about how much I adore Hawkwing.
yes same Hawkwing is best boi forever and ever i think my farthest rant about him is 1 and a half hours lol
Elytra Aj oh wow! That’s awesome. I really wish I could have been there to hear your rant.
@@Emily-kd6uv oof yea i think i broke my sister's ears just for ranting that long xd
Elytra Aj At least you could talk for over an hour. My brother shushes me at the mere moment I even say the word “warriors”.
Akira: *Includes Alderheart*
Me: *Intense happy cinnamon roll induced screeching*
Lol as soon as Tree said ”think bush” I said bye Yellowfang Tree is my child now