The Submarine Graveyard that Became a Nightmare (Devonport Royal Dockyard)

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 141

  • @warpigeonofdoom
    @warpigeonofdoom Рік тому +119

    Using a mushroom cloud when describing possible dangers of decommissioning a submarine’s reactor is a little hyperbolic,

    • @Spookieham
      @Spookieham Рік тому +31

      Not to mention completely impossible

    • @oldman975
      @oldman975 Рік тому +3

      But it does get the point across.

    • @r.t.1077
      @r.t.1077 Рік тому +2

      Caught me off guard with that image lmao

    • @r.t.1077
      @r.t.1077 Рік тому +8

      @@oldman975 Not really it’ll be a environmental hazard it’s not going to incinerate a entire coastal area

    • @IDNHANTU2day
      @IDNHANTU2day Рік тому

      Didn't look like a mushroom to me.

  • @robertbangkok
    @robertbangkok Рік тому +27

    "Nuk-U-lehr" LOL Sheesh!

    • @ut000bs
      @ut000bs Рік тому +1

      It depends on where you're from. If you don't pronounce everything correctly then what does that make you?

    • @EllieMaes-Grandad
      @EllieMaes-Grandad 3 місяці тому

      @@ut000bs A Yank ?

  • @rj5529
    @rj5529 Рік тому +68

    Established Titles is a scam BTW, you may as well make your own lordship certificate in microsoft word and print that out instead, it would be just as legitimate as Established Titles and you don't have to give your money to scam artists :P

    • @baobo67
      @baobo67 Рік тому +8

      Exactly R J. Generally one can call oneself what they like if the intent is legal. Will call myself "Lord Bo" and see if I get a discount at McDonald's.

    • @tarajoe07
      @tarajoe07 Рік тому +5

      It's not intended to be serious. Lol. It's a fun way to fund planting trees

    • @ShadowWizard123
      @ShadowWizard123 Рік тому +2

      It's mostly intended as a lark.

    • @rj5529
      @rj5529 Рік тому +4

      @@tarajoe07 they aren't doing that either :P

    • @rj5529
      @rj5529 Рік тому +5

      @@ShadowWizard123 you can have a lark without paying scam artists though, you could make a certificate title yourself, then declare a piece of your garden as your holdings, and even have a little display there lol

  • @konstantin.v
    @konstantin.v Рік тому +40

    Reactors stop requiring constant external cooling shortly after they are shut down. You should learn (at least) the basics instead of spreading irrational fears 🙄

    • @IDNHANTU2day
      @IDNHANTU2day Рік тому +2

      I had always thought that once you retrieve the rods, coolant is not necessary.

    • @konstantin.v
      @konstantin.v Рік тому +2

      @@IDNHANTU2day , not instantly (check out the Fukushima incident), but it's a matter of hours, not even days, until the reactor is cool enough not to melt its insides 😎

    • @wiretamer5710
      @wiretamer5710 Рік тому

      Appart from the risk of terrorist activity, the dangers of a dirty steam explosion would spell the end of the Uk.

    • @dc-4ever201
      @dc-4ever201 Рік тому +2

      Most of these subs have been laid up for decades, I should think their reactors are cold enough hence why scrapping is beginning.

    • @ut000bs
      @ut000bs Рік тому

      @@IDNHANTU2day "insert"

  • @grahamleiper1538
    @grahamleiper1538 Рік тому +9

    Most of the retired Polaris boats are actually berthed in Rosyth near Edinburgh. There's only fleet subs in Devonport.

  • @jetsons101
    @jetsons101 Рік тому +4

    Great watch, now I want to watch "Hunt for Red October" Thanks for posting.....

  • @thelemming54
    @thelemming54 Рік тому +17

    A 27' drought?

  • @martindoyle831
    @martindoyle831 Рік тому +3

    Yes. Build a 3 teir enclosed drydock u can tow these subs into that is 3 full levels of containment for any and all radiation problems the inner dry dock itself should be automated with all robotics and triple back ups for the equipmemt. then drag them in and take them appart.

  • @richardstoker4963
    @richardstoker4963 Рік тому +3

    When I was based there in 2006 , I was told that the T boats would be left for 10 years for the reactors to cool down.

    • @davepowell7168
      @davepowell7168 Рік тому

      So you have confidence a cooler reactor will cost more to decommission one day.
      Babecocks might tug it to an Asian beach?

    • @richardstoker4963
      @richardstoker4963 Рік тому +1

      @@davepowell7168 you'd be better off asking a submariner.
      I was on the skimmers mate.

    • @ut000bs
      @ut000bs Рік тому +1

      @@davepowell7168 You have to wait for the reactor to cool before you can cut it out.
      The reactor compartments might end up in the US. I have no idea.

  • @mikmik9034
    @mikmik9034 Рік тому +9

    @4:54, "Draught"? You meant "DRAFT" it is and English thing.

  • @RichieWellock
    @RichieWellock Рік тому +19

    So the pwr used here require sea water to cool them in use but as they are shutdown SCRAM they would not over heat even if depressurised. The want to remove them is understandable and the RN would like this as to there security but would have to be equally as safe were ever they are placed. One good use for them would be to place them in to use as electric generation to push up rods in fission state. they would then effectively create power for Portsmouth. As all rafted together these subs could continue to deplete there core making there eventual dismantling safer. it would mean they would have to have forced sea water through them as if they were moving. Its something that Russia has done for decades to power the towns near bases.

    • @RichieWellock
      @RichieWellock Рік тому +1

      ps @IT'S HISTORY great vid

    • @thisisnev
      @thisisnev Рік тому +4

      Welcome to Plymouth. P-L-Y-M-O-U-T-H. We're 137 miles from Portsmouth.

    • @konstantin.v
      @konstantin.v Рік тому +6

      @@RichieWellock , for me it was quite annoying to hear this nukilar fear-mongering from someone who obviously doesn't know the first thing about how nukilar reactors work 🤪

    • @RichieWellock
      @RichieWellock Рік тому +3

      @@thisisnev LOL to be honest I worked at at both as well Clyde. A momentary brain fart when I put Portsmouth.

    • @verdebusterAP
      @verdebusterAP 6 місяців тому

      The reactors are shut down and the rods are removed

  • @ginog5037
    @ginog5037 Рік тому +34

    Really Ryan, a mushroom cloud isn't that a little dramatic. I enjoy your channel but you lost points on this one. Also pushing Lordship is a scam as buying land on the moon. What's next pet rocks...lol

    • @GeneralJackRipper
      @GeneralJackRipper Рік тому +2

      Hey man, that acre of land I bought on the moon is gonna be a great investment some day!

    • @criticality2056
      @criticality2056 Рік тому +1

      At least you'd have a rock

  • @spartankc
    @spartankc Рік тому +3

    What about Rosyth naval base?

  • @lachbullen8014
    @lachbullen8014 Рік тому +9

    It would be nice to see the HMS Valiant and Conqueror to be turned into museum ship..

    • @chriscrook4481
      @chriscrook4481 2 місяці тому +1

      There’s very little left of Valiant these days. Courageous already is a museum boat at Devonport.

  • @Dog.soldier1950
    @Dog.soldier1950 Рік тому +9

    A few miles from where I live the USN regularly disassemble nuke boats and ship the reactor up the Columbia for long term burial at the Hanford Works. It just takes will and money.

    • @GeneralJackRipper
      @GeneralJackRipper Рік тому +7

      Everything worth doing requires only will and money.
      But money is controlled by people who don't have any will.

    • @dc-4ever201
      @dc-4ever201 Рік тому

      Trouble is the people who control all this are subjected to campaigns by eco groups opposed to us well living, so getting anything done in the UK is proving to be a bloody nightmare. This "just Stop Oil" group are a prime example of eco nutters who will do anything and everything to disrupt plans.

    • @ut000bs
      @ut000bs Рік тому +2

      @@GeneralJackRipper It isn't their money, it's ours. They don't care.

  • @jimmywilliams9824
    @jimmywilliams9824 Рік тому +2

    I guess it would be a no go to use as shore power some how!

  • @Arfshesaid457
    @Arfshesaid457 Рік тому +79

    I couldn’t listen any further than “nukular.”

    • @msw7021
      @msw7021 Рік тому +5

      Why?

    • @Ecosse57
      @Ecosse57 Рік тому +11

      good luck with your condition.

    • @dannysulyma6273
      @dannysulyma6273 Рік тому +3

      Awww.

    • @richardpark3054
      @richardpark3054 Рік тому +15

      @@msw7021 If you don't know, it's pointless to explain.

    • @kencarp57
      @kencarp57 Рік тому +21

      Likely the most mispronounced word in the English language. I’ll never understand why people pronounce it like that.

  • @donstewart2059
    @donstewart2059 Рік тому +8

    Australia needs them

    • @RichieWellock
      @RichieWellock Рік тому +1

      yeah even though they have fuel, they would not be now powerful enough to power the propulsor's and other systems, RAN
      would be best without them. Unless they were re fuelled up and that then effects there depth as to re fuel them requires cutting the pressure vessel and shell of boat. They then have to do something with the old cores. best keep them as are or use them as elec generators for the nearest town -city they are near.

    • @davepowell7168
      @davepowell7168 Рік тому

      The Ukraine could annoy Russia

  • @markwillett1740
    @markwillett1740 Рік тому +2

    i was a member ofthe uk sea cadets conqueror was the adopt name of the base we used in fleetwood.when she docked in liverpool one year some of was lucky enough to be invited to vist her and go aboard for a few hours one weekend.i was one loved the vist very cramp indeed but very interesting.last i heard she was one of the subs u could vist in davenport they used to rotate them.but that was yrs ago.i also did deliveries up to faslane to and got to see some of the newer subs there to and into barrow where the new ones are build what sight to see

  • @EllieMaes-Grandad
    @EllieMaes-Grandad 3 місяці тому

    This is more about submarines than the Yard itself. The submarine complex is but a small part of a three-mile-long facility which at one time could accomplish absolutely anything for ships.
    It was 'contractorised' in 1987 [when I worked there] and much of it subsequently sold-off and/or demolished. In 1982 18,000 worked there, now it's only a few thousand . . .

  • @eurosonly
    @eurosonly Рік тому +11

    Established titles is literally buying a bridge somewhere else and that's an old scam slogan.

  • @tarajoe07
    @tarajoe07 Рік тому +17

    These aren't that big of a deal. Yes there's risk, but the same as when building them

  • @mechsgtpuma938
    @mechsgtpuma938 3 місяці тому

    As a child in the eary 80s I went inside Devenport as part of navy days and had buided tour's of Frigates destroyers and submarines. And I remember looking through the periscope. We went 2 or 3 years in a row.

  • @Joe3pops
    @Joe3pops 8 місяців тому

    HMS Valiant ran into propulsion issues late 1960s in the Caribbean Sea. Along with a repair team from a close naval allie, she was fully repaired to the point of continuing full workups. This watery drama closely resembled a James Bond movie.

  • @josephwoody8289
    @josephwoody8289 Рік тому +9

    NU - CLE - AR

  • @NickNZ
    @NickNZ Рік тому +4

    So many inaccuracies, and incorrect details, it should perhaps be featured on the Comedy Channel.

  • @keithmoore5306
    @keithmoore5306 Рік тому +3

    simple solution tow them to Bremmerton and get the US navy to scrap them on contract if they're scared to do it!!!

    • @chriscrook4481
      @chriscrook4481 2 місяці тому

      Just after the end of the Cold War an offer by the Russians to dispose of these boats for us was seriously considered as part of tripartite committee comprising the US, UK and Russian Federation.

  • @atlantianphoenix
    @atlantianphoenix Рік тому +3

    Even the horrible auto genrated subtitles of youtube got it right...lol

  • @majikglustik9704
    @majikglustik9704 Рік тому

    BOOM!
    There you have it.

  • @DisinterestedObserver
    @DisinterestedObserver 3 місяці тому

    After a decade or two of sitting, these submarines reactos’ fuel fission product decay heat would be reduced to a level where active cooling requirements would be minimal and dismantling easy handled.

  • @nemesisn4522
    @nemesisn4522 Рік тому +1

    My home town I live in devonport plymouth

  • @tvviewer4500
    @tvviewer4500 Рік тому +5

    Dude it is called a "draft" even though it is spelled draught.. In another of your videos you mispronounced buffet. Weird when you just read all the time and never bother learning pronunciations..

  • @rob379lqz
    @rob379lqz Рік тому +5

    Hello. Where are your replant-trees from? Are you able to provide annual updates?

  • @stephenfurches5091
    @stephenfurches5091 Рік тому +2

    Noocular?

  • @Dr.ZoidbergPhD
    @Dr.ZoidbergPhD Рік тому +6

    Can I have one, I promise I'll take care of it!

  • @weldingwolf2088
    @weldingwolf2088 Рік тому +2

    I'm baffled by your lack of research into your sponsor. Seems you just follow the cash and spew nonsense depending on who lines your pockets.

  • @vespelian
    @vespelian Рік тому +1

    The His/Her Majesty's Ship?

  • @lj.7311
    @lj.7311 Рік тому +2

    Sir, the background music distracts from your narration. It’s not needed. Your content can stand alone by itself. Cheers.

  • @EddieWinebauer
    @EddieWinebauer Рік тому +5

    nuke-lee-er

  • @ilikelampshades6
    @ilikelampshades6 Рік тому +1

    I work there. A lotttt of boats

  • @pghpaisan
    @pghpaisan Рік тому +4

    Nu-klee-er

  • @pcs9518
    @pcs9518 Рік тому +1

    Just scuttle them in the Mariana trench it’s deep and cold

  • @njjeff201
    @njjeff201 Рік тому +1

    “Attack Russian submarines…”???

  • @jerryrichards8172
    @jerryrichards8172 Рік тому

    Is this the base the Americans attacked I think in the revolution.

  • @rayg3583
    @rayg3583 Рік тому +4

    If I become a lord, am I required to pay property taxes on the land that I own? And can I build on the land that I own?

    • @jeremykamel9655
      @jeremykamel9655 Рік тому +1

      What would you build? A mouse house? It’s only a few square feet of land.

    • @Malandrin
      @Malandrin Рік тому +4

      its a scam and theya re not scottish but the company is from Honkong

  • @gordonsmith4884
    @gordonsmith4884 Рік тому

    William King of England try again.

  • @nuqleur1252
    @nuqleur1252 Рік тому

    👀

  • @tombeer9
    @tombeer9 Рік тому

    Ask the Americans for help

  • @donaldgminski8621
    @donaldgminski8621 Рік тому

    There's a lot of teen anxt masquerading as ocd in these comments.

  • @ericv8319
    @ericv8319 Рік тому +4

    You said "nookyoolur",.

  • @WreckerS26
    @WreckerS26 27 днів тому

    Be useful if you knew what you were talking about.

  • @rbleslie1971
    @rbleslie1971 2 місяці тому

    I couldn’t listen to this video when he couldn’t pronounce Draft, even if it’s spelt draught, its draft.

  • @SimeonTurney-t2i
    @SimeonTurney-t2i Рік тому

    Give them to ukraine

  • @IIIBig
    @IIIBig Рік тому +2

    First

    • @ITSHISTORY
      @ITSHISTORY  Рік тому +1

      Hello! :)

    • @IIIBig
      @IIIBig Рік тому

      @@ITSHISTORY wow a comment from a channel with half a million subs! Thanks for making your videos!!

    • @Right-Is-Right
      @Right-Is-Right Рік тому +2

      @@IIIBig I believe most of those subs are paid for, did help him in the algorhtim to gain 15K viewers on this vid though. Strangely he hardly engages with anyone, his lordship does not like criticism, and most of his vids have mistakes in them.

  • @steveshoemaker6347
    @steveshoemaker6347 Рік тому

    Thanks Ryan l am Sub'ed...
    Shoe🇺🇸

  • @gloriaarrowheadripper4899
    @gloriaarrowheadripper4899 Рік тому

    Мене це не цікавить. Цікавить зовсім інше. Чому ютюб блокував відео які я мала бачити ще 7 років тому?

  • @mattgeorge1645
    @mattgeorge1645 Рік тому

    Hello, are you using cuebase?

  • @xmtryanx
    @xmtryanx Рік тому

    A) This is wonderful, and thank you! B) Nuke-u-ler. ☠️☠️☠️