How to Choose a Countertop Surface

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 104

  • @chrisgraham2904
    @chrisgraham2904 9 місяців тому +13

    I was happy to see a respectable evaluation of laminate counter tops. Products, ranging from Corian, through Quartz and Granite are very expensive in Canada, ranging from $250 to $350 per linear foot, based on a standard 24" counter depth, for material only, before labor. I've had laminate throughout the kitchen for 25 years and it made it through raising a family and is still in very good shape with no scratches, burns or delamination. I'd like to replace the counters, only to update the color and pattern. Our kitchen is a separate utilitarian space and not an entertainment center of the home. I hesitate to do laminate, only because it has gained a reputation as been cheap. We've seen home buyers here reject buying a home because it had laminate counter tops.
    As a senior now, I don't want to spend the price of a car to update my kitchen counter tops. lol.

    • @gregpendrey6711
      @gregpendrey6711 6 місяців тому +2

      Any installer worth his salt will put whatever color laminate directly over and in contact with your existing tops. If someone passes over your house because you don't have solid surface they don't deserve it anyway. Ignoramuses 😂.

    • @debbielockhart7762
      @debbielockhart7762 2 місяці тому

      I don't see those prices for countertops here in Canada. Lots of quartz can be had for under $100sf or a bit over.

    • @vinlago
      @vinlago 2 місяці тому

      How about epoxy? It can be any color or combination, with or without speckles, streaks, glitter or none of the above. It might be a project for DIY but maybe ask around for someone who can apply it over existing countertops.

  • @Julia.Mandelbrot
    @Julia.Mandelbrot 9 місяців тому +16

    I'm laughing so hard "Granite has speckles that my brain cannot stand." I've been struggling to figure out why I absolutely detest my granite counters. U nailed it! 😂

    • @gregpendrey6711
      @gregpendrey6711 6 місяців тому

      Too funny. I think of grey speckled granite commonly see in our mountains. If I could only use granite I think the grey with minimal graining would stand the test of time in the PNW.

  • @veritasca24
    @veritasca24 2 місяці тому +2

    I love Corian because of its softness, seamless joints and integrated sink which is easier to clean.

  • @nacmegfeegle2310
    @nacmegfeegle2310 10 місяців тому +6

    Thank you for talking about some choices besides stone countertops. I want corian or laminate. I don't care if it is not trendy.

    • @spremier9626
      @spremier9626 Місяць тому

      I had Corian in my first house. It was a dream!

  • @debbielockhart7762
    @debbielockhart7762 2 місяці тому +2

    I used butcher block for the whole kitchen (and it looks beautiful). I kust coated it with s few coats of poly before insralling and have done zero maintenance (it has been a few years). Still looks great, including around the sink.

  • @purpleslurple5149
    @purpleslurple5149 Рік тому +4

    100% agree with you on the choice of local cabinets over something 4hrs away. If you have a renter with an emergency, you want to be able to get what you need and get it fixed ASAP. Don't doubt yourself 💜

  • @MrKlawUK
    @MrKlawUK Рік тому +5

    the kitchen that was in my house has been there so long before we are getting around to renovating that Quartz came along, became fashionable and apparantly became unfashionable again. Its so complicated! :)

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +1

      There is a ban on quartz coming to Australia in 2024.

  • @lyndy9072
    @lyndy9072 Рік тому +3

    Hi Mark, just recently found your channel and have been enjoying your content. I’m just about to start on a total kitchen Reno and have already made all my design decisions so I’m a little late to put any of your advice into my project but I hope it all works out. No OTR microwave, lol, so I agree with you there. Mostly because I am on the short side and always considered it a hazard taking hot liquids out of an appliance above my head. I’m looking forward to following your B&B project.

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому

      Hey! Thanks so much for watching my content. I hope your project goes awesome for you. I started the reno on the rental, so stay tuned!!

  • @shelleythistleton4935
    @shelleythistleton4935 Рік тому +2

    Thank you for all your knowledge you are sharing. Can you please address options for rental properties and the pros and cons. I am starting a Reno of my ground floor to put in a two bedroom granny flat very soon. Thanks! ❤

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +1

      This is a great video idea. Thank you.

  • @kd-CarvingAway
    @kd-CarvingAway 10 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for the education. Much appreciated.

  • @hopehart2922
    @hopehart2922 Рік тому +9

    I have laminate and I like it. It is so durable. I’m probably the only one on the planet who likes it. I’ve had mine for 20 years!!!

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +4

      I have laminate too.

    • @krjohnson29
      @krjohnson29 11 місяців тому +3

      I would get laminate if my wife would let me... Cost and utility can hardly be better, and price is also great.
      But it just doesn't have that romantic appeal of stone or wood I guess 🤷
      We have wood countertops and I have mixed feelings. Looking to change to something a little more water/heat proof and low maintenance.

    • @juliebrooke6099
      @juliebrooke6099 11 місяців тому +4

      My last kitchen had laminate tops which still looked good after 25 years. My new kitchen has got it again so I’m hoping it will last as well as before.

    • @barbaraeaton9266
      @barbaraeaton9266 9 місяців тому +1

      @@krjohnson29 What is it that you don't like? Do you have it sealed? I have so many questions.

    • @krjohnson29
      @krjohnson29 9 місяців тому +1

      @@barbaraeaton9266 I don't think our wood countertops were done in the greatest way. I think a house flipper did it himself. So it probably isn't the greatest example. It is sealed somehow, but I'm not exactly sure with what.
      But yeah, what I am not liking is all around the sink area it's gotten black stains. And a couple of places where a too hot item has been mistakenly placed it has burned rings. We tried just sanding the marred sections them off and re-sealing but it doesn't look the same. I probably need to do the whole thing but that seems like an enormous amount of work.
      I think it would definitely be better if they were not around the sink. And I've seen examples of ones that look a lot more natural (ours looks like it was sealed with polyurethane or something like you'd seal a deck). Those strike me as possibly easier to maintain.
      We're looking currently at quartz or granite on the island with the sink and wood the rest of the kitchen. Deliberations are ongoing though.

  • @shirleybeneteau629
    @shirleybeneteau629 4 місяці тому

    enjoy your knowledge and content I have decided on granite because I am tired of the white and grey vein in Quartz and the white cabinets I have checked all your previous videos and love them I am confused about sealant maintenance through the years with granite after the original sealant when purchased How often should a person use a sealant on the granite.

  • @carinamcquilkin926
    @carinamcquilkin926 Рік тому +1

    Thank you for the content and enjoy your vacation. 😊

  • @kristinnelson-patel442
    @kristinnelson-patel442 Рік тому +1

    I just found your videos and really like your channel. Already learning a lot in prep for a big kitchen renovation sometime in the next several years. FWIW it seems really stupid to me to surround a sink with solid wood.

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +1

      Hey! Thanks for watching! And yes, sinks and wood are going to get moldy.

    • @runningfromabear8354
      @runningfromabear8354 Рік тому +1

      ​@@MTKDofficial we had wood counters in our old house. My grandparents had them on their farm. It's not for perfectionists but I've never seen issues with mold. If you leave water on your countertops long enough to cause mold, you're not keeping a hygienic kitchen.
      The benefit was my countertops were my chopping boards (except meats, that's best chopped on a stone chopping board) with the expectation of replacing the counters every ten years. We oiled every 6 months. If you want absolutely no staining or cut marks or burn marks, it's not for you. You do wood wanting those marks.

  • @markbeiser
    @markbeiser Рік тому +2

    44:20 Some custom wood slab counter tops can run into several hundred dollars a square foot.
    The raw slabs of some trees can cost as much or more than high end marble, and require a very high amount of labor and materials to turn into a functional countertop.

    • @debbielockhart7762
      @debbielockhart7762 2 місяці тому +1

      Well that isn't what I'm using. You can get great wood countertops for $70-$80sf.

    • @markbeiser
      @markbeiser 2 місяці тому

      @@debbielockhart7762 Even if I could afford it, there is no way in hell i'd spend as much for a slab of wood as some of the really expensive stuff goes for!

  • @geaengbers896
    @geaengbers896 4 місяці тому +1

    A little late after your video, but would never have granite again! It chipped so badly around the edges around the sink and over to the dishwasher, and was costly to have a professional fix it. And that was an ongoing cost. Made the switch to quartz!

  • @TheSimArchitect
    @TheSimArchitect 9 місяців тому +1

    Nice video! Missed your opinion on stainless steel countertops and back drop. I had a very old stainless steel countertop and it was looking quite fine, at my rental. Felt safer using it than the new "fake Formica" they installed. Had different marble and granite countertops and sinks before and I feel stainless was the best material from a usability perspective (and with a reasonable cost). Is there any development on new designs that make them less dated (and cheap looking)?

  • @MrKlawUK
    @MrKlawUK Рік тому +2

    was in a showroom a few days ago and the laminate mostly felt like what I’m familiar with - slightly rough to the touch feel which is one of the reasons I’m considering something else. But I found a countertop that felt smooth and a little cooler to the touch but the assistant said it was ‘luxury’ laminate. I have no idea what that means but it felt great and looked great so I’ll be exploring that a little more if it means more cost effective but doesn’t feel like laminate. I’d be having an overmount sink so no biggie there

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +4

      Im always suspicious of words like "luxury", however, I've personally ordered high gloss laminates that look every bit like a stone top. They are easy to clean but also easy to scratch. There are newer laminate products on the market now that are more durable and manufactured with out the particle board substrate. This is probably what they were showing you. Very nice indeed. Luxury even. lol

  • @edkaempf906
    @edkaempf906 10 місяців тому +5

    "Direct heat" was the only one you mentioned about quartz. Then, after a long pause, you threw in staining. Use trivets. The heat problem is solved.

    • @debbielockhart7762
      @debbielockhart7762 2 місяці тому

      Who the hell puts really hot things directly onto their countertops anyways? Just like who doesn't use a cutting board and cuts right on their counters?

  • @creativitybycarilyn6634
    @creativitybycarilyn6634 8 місяців тому +3

    I really want soapstone for my new kitchen with white cabinets. I want something that can handle heat that is timeless. I think its beautiful.

  • @Carol_Pearson
    @Carol_Pearson 7 місяців тому +1

    I had a laminate that was very cheaply made and falling apart. With my current renovation (still going on) I am getting a solid surface (Corian type, but different brand) because I happen to like the look of those, and I am the only human in my house. (My dog doesn't care. She's just happy she now gets her own cabinet for food and treats.)

  • @bridmanifold2668
    @bridmanifold2668 Рік тому +9

    What about poured concrete - you can do some very interesting things with dye pigment -adding crushed glass etc

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +6

      Yeah. I should dedicate a video to that. Thanks for the idea.

  • @sherristockfleth746
    @sherristockfleth746 Рік тому +10

    I hated granite when it came out, I hate it still. Granite has speckles that my brain cannot stand. We are building a house right now and this is timely because I am currently nailing down my counter choice. If I had the unlimited budget of my dreams I would put soapstone on every counter. Because I actually have a budget I am deciding between porcelain, quartz and quartzite.

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +1

      Well, those are all great choices. I'm thinking quartz will be the least and porcelain the most.

    • @frannieb715
      @frannieb715 Рік тому +3

      Hi Sherri - I'm with you on the speckled granite, it boggles my brain! Silestone and Caesarstone both have quartz countertop options that look like soapstone. I haven't decided which one I'm putting in my kitchen remodel yet, but the honed finish on the Silestone version is REALLY hard to tell that it's not real soapstone. Check them out, and good luck with the kitchen design on your new home build!

    • @KrysC-TX
      @KrysC-TX Рік тому +2

      Honed Nero mist granite looks just like soapstone.

  • @lindaprimm667
    @lindaprimm667 Рік тому +2

    Having a hard time finding high definition laminate, which I've bought multiple times and found it to be extremely scratch and heat resistant. Pots directly out of the oven no problem. Cutting directly on the counter top no problems. I want to say the sales pitch was that it was up to 550 degree ok but I can't find that information any more. Never had problems with it. I don't like cold stone.

  • @patthomas9041
    @patthomas9041 9 місяців тому +3

    Can I get my Matt laminate changed to gloss?

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  9 місяців тому +3

      You can order gloss laminate. This is usually a special order and will cost a little extra, but it is available. In my last house I ordered mine with a gloss finish. It came from Arbotire. But many of the laminate makers have them.

  • @Julia.Mandelbrot
    @Julia.Mandelbrot 9 місяців тому +1

    I'm loving your background paint color, a smoky navy? What is the name? Also that the overhead beams are painted same color, it looks high end. Ceiling too, or is that a little darker navy? Love your content, big fan, saving up for a kitchen consult with u. So glad you're offering the service. 🛟❤️🙃

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  9 місяців тому

      Hey thanks so much! The paint is called Midnight something...lol. The name escapes me.

  • @catwhall581
    @catwhall581 Рік тому +5

    Why no real discussion of soapstone. Have loved it since college science labs

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +2

      Great idea. I do plan to talk a little more about some of the less popular countertop options.

  • @Valk021
    @Valk021 7 місяців тому

    13:47 haha, i got something like this but more red and black streaks. Looks awful and now any change feels like a downgrade. Im not sure what to do as i want light, neutral colours than 90s red brown darks. Not sure what to do. Laminex until it is in trend again?

  • @barbaraeaton9266
    @barbaraeaton9266 Рік тому +1

    Will there be the standard replay still be available?video

  • @KaosHappens
    @KaosHappens Рік тому +1

    What about polish stainless steel countertop to a mirror finish?

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому

      Is that possible?

    • @KaosHappens
      @KaosHappens Рік тому

      @@MTKDofficial yea just go through all the grits of sandpaper and polish it. Aluminum and copper are more reflective but i'm not sure about durability

  • @SnowySpiritRuby
    @SnowySpiritRuby 2 місяці тому +1

    For homes that are mobile, wood is also a lot lighter weight than stone.

  • @AndreaMcNair-j9e
    @AndreaMcNair-j9e 12 днів тому

    Granit is mined in Texas.

  • @barbaraeaton9266
    @barbaraeaton9266 Рік тому +2

    Can quartz have a drain board?

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому

      I'm thinking it can. But I can't recall if I've ever seen it.

  • @agnescleary2312
    @agnescleary2312 10 місяців тому +1

    What about stainless steel countertops?

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  10 місяців тому

      Excellent choice. Very durable. Just not very popular.

  • @ladyj02
    @ladyj02 10 місяців тому +1

    No mention of nanoglass?

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  10 місяців тому

      Seems pretty niche?

    • @ladyj02
      @ladyj02 10 місяців тому

      @@MTKDofficial We bought it for its high durability, and it was marketed to us by our local countertop vendor as superior granite, quartz, quartzite, marble (basically it's like marble but with superior durability and low maintenance), for less than marble's cost. It is also forged, which we thought was pretty cool.
      We installed it in our workshop sink, but now are trying to decide whether to stick with it again for our main kitchen.
      What I heard is that it's supposedly one of the newer options, not yet as popular.

  • @Julia.Mandelbrot
    @Julia.Mandelbrot 9 місяців тому +2

    If you are even a little bit klutzy, reconsider marble. It's incredibly slick, so you go to pick up your beautiful coffee cup, or a vase, whatever, it can shoot away from u and land violently elsewhere. Or u can do what I did and knocked over my glass pitcher and cracked the handle. Actually I did that with my hideous speckled granite, also very slick. And I stayed in a hotel with a marble floor in the bathroom, I fell so suddenly and unexpectedly and hit my head pretty hard. These very hard polished surfaces are horrid.

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  9 місяців тому

      Great input about Marble. Thanks for sharing and watching!

  • @ryansoo4000
    @ryansoo4000 Рік тому +2

    Hi, Mark. I found another UA-cam video from Canadian House and Home where they show the cabinet drawers and doors all connected by one trim detail that runs from top to bottom (minute 6:35).
    ua-cam.com/video/SKr0p2OwUFo/v-deo.html
    This detail seems to becoming a big trend. Also, at minute 7:05, have a look at the upper cabinets door hardware detail. On a set of double doors they mounted the door handles in a horizontal fashion right next to each other so that they look exactly like the single handle that’s on the base cabinet drawers. Very nice!

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому

      Thanks for sharing that link. That is a really nice detail. We are seeing that more and more. Definitely screams custom!

  • @edwardcasper5231
    @edwardcasper5231 Рік тому +2

    Have a fun vacation.

  • @kevincinnamontoast3669
    @kevincinnamontoast3669 8 місяців тому +1

    Origin of species for granite. Who writes this stuff?

  • @joekruger2563
    @joekruger2563 Рік тому +2

    Should of spent more time on stainless, in the right space it's beautiful.

  • @cinders302
    @cinders302 8 місяців тому +1

    No soapstone?

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  8 місяців тому

      ua-cam.com/video/07ibSPA1oPY/v-deo.html

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  8 місяців тому

      ua-cam.com/video/07ibSPA1oPY/v-deo.html

  • @barbaraeaton9266
    @barbaraeaton9266 Рік тому +1

    What would you put around the sink if you did have a wood countertop? I thought maybe a SS with a drain board. Does Decton only come in dark or black. So Decton is really expensive like quartz or quartzite? I always have questions.😊

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +1

      haha. no worries! Dekton comes in lots of colours and patterns (white to black). If you have wood make sure to seal it underneath and the cut out too. Just to help protect it. But don't seal the top obviously.

    • @Julia.Mandelbrot
      @Julia.Mandelbrot 9 місяців тому +1

      Home Depot! Ikea ... I'm not a fan. House I bought has an IKEA stove, big, ugly, only one burner works, oven just stopped working also. Ikea cupboards which are all glass even the shelves. It's horrible. So hard it's brutal.

  • @louiseking4519
    @louiseking4519 11 місяців тому +1

    What about Soapstone?

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  11 місяців тому

      Check this one ua-cam.com/video/07ibSPA1oPY/v-deo.html

  • @cherlindra4123
    @cherlindra4123 Рік тому +1

    FYI The largest granite quarry in the world is in North Carolina, USA.

  • @exeterline1930
    @exeterline1930 Місяць тому

    Granite is going out of style because of the splotchiness.
    I prefer a near solid pattern. I can tolerate a small peppered pattern, but not the big spots.

  • @saltyroe3179
    @saltyroe3179 8 місяців тому +1

    Have 1929 teakwood

  • @anjalig5856
    @anjalig5856 Рік тому +2

    Pros and con soapstone

    • @MTKDofficial
      @MTKDofficial  Рік тому +2

      I'm getting more and more requests for this. It's on the short list for sure.

  • @dominaevillae28
    @dominaevillae28 10 місяців тому +1

    Building a house, using granite for counters🙂

  • @sophianicholson8965
    @sophianicholson8965 18 днів тому

    Quartz is definitely not low maintenance, it stains and takes a little elbow grease, yes, serious cleaning.

  • @bluedrummajor2876
    @bluedrummajor2876 7 місяців тому +1

    Why are we so hoidy toidy that we reject laminate out of hand? Laminates are so much better looking and much better quality from when they were introduced.

  • @emilychen9171
    @emilychen9171 5 місяців тому

    I think u missed sintered stone

  • @TheLookingOne
    @TheLookingOne 10 місяців тому +2

    What did people ever see in concrete countertops?
    What a fad
    What a disaster

  • @quickheaven712
    @quickheaven712 19 днів тому

    What about stainless steel countertop?