Did Manmohan Singh Crash India's Economy? | Dirty Truth of Modi's ‘White Paper’ | Akash Banerjee
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лют 2024
- Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman presented a 'White Paper' on the UPA's Economic Policy in the Lok Sabha - it outlined UPA’s 10 years of mismanagement & policy paralysis.... More importantly it aimed to show how - the NDA extracted the nation from a massive 'crisis'.
What are the allegations against the Manmohan Singh Govt in this unprecedented 'White Paper' - How did the Congress's 'BLACK PAPER' counter the BJP and who's the biggest loser in this While Paper vs Black Paper War?? ....any WHY is the BJP doing this????
Modi Govt's 'White Paper'
dea.gov.in/sites/default/file...
Congress Hits Back with 'Black Paper'
www.inc.in/media/press-releas...
** When Modi Mocked UPA's MGNREGA in Parliament -
• Government won't stop ... **
Truth about our Economy in Numbners
• Is India's Economic Bo...
FAKE NEWS??? _ FDI down to a 16 year low???
• FDI Into India Falls 1...
theprint.in/economy/why-fdi-i...
⛔️ BECOME A DESHBHAKT MEMBER - www.patreon.com/thedeshbhakt ⛔️
Unlock MEMBER ONLY: 1) Chats 2) Discord Server 3) Special Episodes
OR
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @thedeshbhakt
👕 DESHBHAKT MERCH - India's First Line of Socially & Politically aware tees 👕 kadakmerch.com/thedeshbhakt
📧 BUSINESS ENQUIRIES - contact@thedeshbhakt.in 📧
Credits :
Script : Akash
Thumbnail : Khursheed
Graphics : Ritam
Editor : Ritam, Mehul & Khursheed
Associate Producer : Aman
Producer : Sahil
#indianeconomy #whitepaper #blackpaper
A lot of frothing is happening because we mentioned that FDI is down to a 16 year low - because Godi Media and Whatsapp University has been telling us that its breaking records??!!!
SOME MAINSTREAM REPORTS ON THIS 'FAKE NEWS'
_ FDI down to a 16 year low???
ua-cam.com/video/ht87dkjku2M/v-deo.html
theprint.in/economy/why-fdi-in-india-is-lowest-in-16-yrs-no-real-ease-of-doing-business-ill-considered-treaty-moves/1927937/
READ - Modi Govt's 'White Paper'
dea.gov.in/sites/default/files/White%20Paper%20on%20the%20Indian%20Economy%20-%20February%202024.pdf
READ - Congress Hits Back with 'Black Paper'
www.inc.in/media/press-releases/shri-mallikarjun-kharge-congress-president-and-lo-p-rajya-sabha-addressed-the-media-in-new-delhi
Watch - When Modi Mocked UPA's MGNREGA in Parliament -
ua-cam.com/video/UGmrOaxUw7Y/v-deo.html **
Watch - Truth about our Economy in Numbers
ua-cam.com/video/nVgo5DFza4A/v-deo.html
(ofcourse subscribers to Deshbhakt know all this :)))
@@Alonecrest Abe tu kon hota h Deshbhakt ki sachhai aage laane k liye
Andhbhakt Teri jgh idhar nhi h Tu #Godi Media dekh,Godi Media ki trh tu v dimaag taakhe pe rakh k aaya h kya idhar Gyan Dene 🤣🤣
Until people look the picture as a neutral responsible citizens, its no use... Just check the comment section, how the people are divided. BJP & Congress are just using them.
Isn't the Modi gvt build on big excuses !?
16 percent low is from FY 2022 not from last 10 years😂🤷🏻♂️😂
Deshbhakt sir want to understand one thing . At 17:47 when You said fdi is 16 year low , what do you mean by it? . I just checked the values in number, its not less than 2008. In terms of percentage% of gdp we can say its lower to 1.42% previous year. So please specify when you make such statements because although percentage is less but gdp is more so in terms of value its not that less than 16 year low
There is an old saying, "if you cant convince them, confuse them". The fact that this is political than actual performace is very clear.
Yes it's doing before and after bjp
Avi 5L college fee bhot mushkil se jugaad krke avi 90,000 tax bharne ke lie ghis rha hun..
Thanks to bjp 🙏
Manmohan singh is great finance minister of india 🇮🇳 🙂 and also great minister of Congress party 🙂
Jai siya ram 🔱🕉❤🇮🇳
Jai hind 🇮🇳
@@user-zt1xu3dv8g you should not have joined college, not taken job. You deserve a bowl on the streets.
ua-cam.com/video/iUF-Wh1Iu7w/v-deo.html
This guy is talking numbers and not gibberish like this fellow
Manmohan Sing is a great man in the world with heart in developing our nation
Guess what, from 2014 to 2024 , they saved economy just by selling government companies 😢😢😢😢😢
Very ture brother
And as a psu employee, I am not receiving salary for last 20 months
Just look in private sector its much better and more career growth @@maithantrip6821
Please comment the name of the PSU you work in.....
once there was a time when all the companies was under the government AKA before liberalization . how was that can you explain to me ? i you've learned anything instead of just believing pappu that is. don't waste your time go make potato to gold making machine first 😑😑
pm from Nehru to manmohan Singh debt of India was 55 lakh crore and modi government debt alone in 9 year 155 lakh crore , 3 times of 70 years government
Debt to gdp
Irony Modi was the one who fulfill the supply of toilets to every household in rural area .
Usa ka debt dekh lo pata chal jayega
@@vishaldwivedi3839Uski GDP bhi jyada hai. Dent to GDP dekho. America ka 60-68 percent hai. Modi ka 89 percent hai. Search google
@@prajwaltrivedi7052construction of toilets reduced 😂
History will be more kinder to me than the contemporary india
~manmohan singh
as finance minister he was fine ... he lost everything as prime minister
@@akshay288 Bjp is lier party and is fooling everyone either educated or illiterate.
History will curse him even more for all the ways he has destroyed the spine of this country
@@shivendrapratapsinghrajput4058 There is only one epic trash that is modi. Modi is selected so he can be trashed and blamed for all loot in India.
@@shivendrapratapsinghrajput4058 hasna tha kya!!!
Respect Dr. Singh the Greatest Economist God bless him ❤❤❤
But also spin less 😢
The Man who saved us from the Flintstone era in 1992, today appears as a meagre figure in a political partys white Paper. What an irony and tryst of fate. The Backbone of Indian economy was made by Manmohan Singh, the economic legend of India.
Vo Sab to Thik hai.... India Kangaal kiske Raaj me huaa __ BJP ka to Raaj nhai tha us time ???
Desh ko Khud Barbad kiye to Aabaad bhi to karna padega __ 1947-1996 tak 50 Saal Congress thi Naa ki BJP or 1990 me Desh ko Kangaal karne wali bhi Congress hi thi Mandmohan Ki hi Party thi ..
The man who saved us but who put this situations
This is something andhbhakts won't understand.
@@anitajurelimizor7372 tum kya ho ....andhvirodhi
@@anitajurelimizor7372 if you had properly researched about that than you wouldn't have said that. well you shortsighted people won't understand that anyway. kisi random bande ne bol diya aur tumne vishvas kar liya😄😂😂😂
This guy is a true Deshbhakt, I see no partiality during this whole video ❤❤
She is the same woman who said about not eating onions. After failing its always blame game. Atleast she realised that the economy is at the bottom.
Please explain how is economy failing
GDP increasing
Rupee comparatively strong
Inflation is less than bank interest
Forex reserves r increasing
So I think economy is good
@@pranav.m.k.high inequality
High unemployment.
Closure of msmes and smes
@@bloodwargaming3662
examples of inequality
msmes internationally are in difficulty because of recession still government has announced loan without securities for msmes and only mechanical msmes are suffering, tech msmes are thriving.
@@bloodwargaming3662 US China are one of the most unequal countries.
So what u meant by that!
Should be revisit the path of crony socialisms 😢
“If u have stabilised, then For next 5 years, can we just talk about economy” this actually hit hard bro…great & very logical question
Yeah hope Modi government can actually focus on manufacturing in India rather than other stupid bullsh!t
@@pipipupu5104 bhai tum 1rs ki cheez 100 ki kardo aur phir kaho ki logo ki spending 100% badh gayi gdp consumption based hai agr inflation hta do to real growth actually kya hai
@pipipupu5104 and it is doing that ,you guys will not talk about the fiscal deficit reduction and reducing imports, last year imports increased and he cried like a b$tch ,this year our imports reduced compared to exports which increased alightly ,and he is not talking about it ,government has started working on second PLI scheme to atrract electronic manufacturing ,but you will call make in india andh bhakt and companies andh bhakt ,hell even apple which is making worlds largest factory of it in india is andh bhakt ,deny truth and progress chamche you will never reach truth then
Without economy how we make our public rich?? 🙄
@@tutariousvoredore7790 bhakt is religious word har cheez mein religion ko ghusana jaruri hai kya?? 🙄 tum log yaha par achai ki baat karne aate ho kya phir dharm ke naam par nafrat felane?? Economy or jo topic hai uski baat karo yaha par religion ke naam par hate mat felao yaha par 🙄
Knowladge का भंडार है आपके पास,,,, hat's off,,,,, कुछ बाते तो ऊपर से जाती हैं,,,,अब रोज सुनूंगा तो पल्ले पड़ेगा,,,,
First time in the history of India a PM blamed the past for everything that went wrong. Let us get another team that does not blame the past. People blame others to hide their shortcomings and limitations.
When you don't perform the best escape route is BLAME GAME
❤❤
Me Mumbai se hu English nahi aati par economy asan he dekho
Azadi se ab tak bangal me congress CPI TMC ki sarkar 2 Nobel economyst amarth sen abhijit benarjee Or bangali gand marvane Gujrat or Mumbai me aate he ye benarjee ki Maa bahan biwi bhi Mumbai me chudvake peisa kamati he
😂😂😂😂😂 I think you need to get your eye checked up. Didn't perform ? that's why there will be a third term for BJP.
You guys are making BJP critics into BJP supporters with your delusions. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@manojkothwal3586 टकला of UP will try to break if BJP doesn't gets majority 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂, feku's entire career is at stake andhbhakt 😃😆😅😂
Manmohan singh is great finance minister 🙂 and also great politician of congress 🙂
Jai siya ram 🕉🔱❤🇮🇳
Jai hind 🇮🇳
Imagine, people who said demonetization was a masterstroke are criticizing one of the greatest economist of our country !😂
Imagine, a country that missed the bus to Industrialisation and manufacturing because of corrupt socialist government congress and later on put India into a debt crisis with extreme corruption by Manmohan government is some how “ GrEaTesT eCoNomIsT” 😂😂😂
what?, if you let a monkey control a super computer, you cannot expect the computer to function even at 1%, use little brain dude, what is wrong with you guys, ofc Modi govt failed miserably on social aspect, but the congress period ruined and bought the nation to its knees, if it was not for PV Narsimha Rao, MMS(1st term) and Vajpayee huge prior success, we would've been worse than Pakistan by 2014
@@abhinavcharan6893 yes gomuthra nagpur half knickers you are right
@@abhinavcharan6893The debt on India has raised significantly since 2014. In 2014, our debt was 55 lakh crores. Today, it is 155 lakh crores.
@@boipob look at whom you are asking they are just a uneducated animals.
We are indians , we love our nation , we will always be there if anything happens to our nation .
I will Always Say "SELECT YOUR LEADER WISELY"
Button to Dr. Singh, the greatest Economist among Indians ❤❤
Manmohan Sir was well read, an RBI Governor, and a minister of Finance 1991-1996, how can UPA do something when as compared to 1990-2023 inflation is 243% where as inflation between 1990-2014 was only 98.62%(Net)
But he was the puppet of Italian aunty
@@umeshralekar5543 bro i never understood if you consider Rishi Indian and sonia Italian but Rishi made UK great why not give a little regards to her dedication in india
@@arnavraj8948 Bhai, ise hi rajneeti kehte hai.
2013 inflation was near 9 to 10 and now below then 5 😂😂
Biggest economist Manmohan singh era 2013 india was in top 5 most fragile country and now we are 5th largest economy open your eye and see the truth .
After 10 years they are blaming UPA
They are blaming nehru and gandhi. Glorify Godse. Mujhe lagta hai these people want someone to assassinate modi.. He is chosen to be trashed. Uske aage peeche koi nahi.. So BJP can have marter like UPA have gandhi. Tab tak loot machao party fund bharo. They are not going to stop. never keep rigging elections. selling indian psus/ taking loans in name of Indians. THey are true deshdrohis antinational. I donot understand what motivates them.
After 10 years BJP made India the fastest growing economy.
Facts hurts
If i damage my car and sell it to you ,who will you blame?
@@tutariousvoredore7790 firstly country isn't car and second i did not blame u after 10 years
@@zyrexx0012 jb fastest growing economy banaya to phir past govt ki glti kiu gina rahi h bjp aur aage badhao desh ko sabka acha hoga govt logo ko serve kare koi galat nhi h apass m lade to problem logo ko h
Due to demonization of currency our rural economy collapsed, now they never include in rural economy with gdp , rural economy is negative , upa times rural economy was included in GDP
ua-cam.com/video/iUF-Wh1Iu7w/v-deo.html
This guy is talking numbers and not gibberish like this fellow
India became a superpower because of Manmohan singh 1991 economic reforms
"we got freedom after 2014" was hard 😂
Bhai maja aa gaya 😂😂😂
Andhbkto ko .....jinki tarksakti sunya ho gai hai
Yes after 2014 sanatani are got freedom.
@@tigerking2742 Sharm kar lavde, tere liye hazaro log shahid huye the. Only 1947
Telling we got freedom after 2014 is a disrespect to all our freedom fighters . What BJP know about freedom struggle
Today's India is not for middle class or poor 😢
Poor ke liye phir bhi schemes hai but it's not for middle class poor ko 5 kg ration deti hai sarkar middle class ko toh woh bhi nhi deti
It has been never.
@@ranj58 han han sab kuch manipulating hota sarkar jo road aur naye train tracks bichati hai woh sab bhi manipulation ho hota hai na tab toh.
@@ranj58 Jo gau gau me dikh raha hai woh kahi chupa nahi hai. Tap water, electricity, roads, bank accounts, etc. If this could have been done in 90s. But anyway, Modi/BJP is going to come for another 10 years for sure. Keep complaining and be happy 😁
The promise of Article 370 and Ram mandir was mocked by this Bonerjee. Remember - "Mandir wahi banega" I actually want this bonerjee to keep complaining 😁😂
@@ranj58 han bhai hum figures manipulate kar rhe hai aur imf agree kiye jaara hai because imf is godi media. Koi proof hai ni bakwaas karni hai bass
Poverty ,unemployment, inflation etc must be continue for the ruling ???!!!!.....
Amazing stuff. Well put forth. Very balanced and good intent. Agreed that unless you acknowledge the achievements of the past you cannot build on the future.
But then there is a reason why politics happens. That's because politics is not just for doing people's work. Its not a job only, its a business for these people. Everyone wants to be in power , so being balanced is simply not possible for them. Definitely they all must be knowing it in their hearts , but who will accept it ?
Even at record oil prices upa kept fuel prices in control, kept inflation in control and still achieved 8+ growth rate. Today even at record low crude oil ,prices are uncontrollablly high, says a lot about current gov
Upa lent oil bond of over 2 lakh crore please search about oil bond scam of upa even government is still not able to repay the debts. Today the gdp growth rate is expected to be 6.3 percent from 7 percent in 2023 what about that.
@@pipipupu5104 what a joke
@@rajaguru3785 what joke dude it's on record oil bond scam.
@@rajaguru3785 it's true
@@Thewolverinejean exactly inko kuch bhi report do yeh usko fake bata denge mereko andhbhakt bata denge matlab jo sab upa mein hua woh acha hua jo sab bjp mein hua woh bura hua.
सर हिंदू मुसलमान का मुद्दा ग्राउंड लेवल पर इस कदर फैला दिया गया है की सभी दल मिलकर कितना भी जोर लगाए बीजेपी को नहीं मात दे सकता।
True ....
even school k baccho me nafrat hai
हिंदू को क्या benefits अधिक मिलेगा? Education free, medical free, accomodation free, punishment free, employment free, free fare, free food etc? कुछ तो benefit होगा।
Raghuram suggested 10k notes in 2013 let that sink in banerjee
After 10 years , again blaming UPA and Nehru. What a genious is our FM.
Yeah, exactly! It is built on the back of each other's work. Rather than blaming others, just and just focus on your future goal and connect people to develop the economy.
Correct.
Atal ji hote to pareshan ho gaye hote, as ek dusre ke kaam pe improve kar ke aage badhne ke bajaye, pehle apna competition khatam karte hai. Election campaign ki kya zarurat hai BJP ko, if you've done a good job. Just show your previous work. Woh iff achha hoga to log apne aap vote denge, but no they eliminate opposition first
Manmohan singh is great finance minister of india 🇮🇳 🙂 and also great minister of congress party 🙂
Jai siya ram 🔱🕉❤🇮🇳
Jai hind 🇮🇳
80 crores people getting 5kg cereals and they were telling about 5 trillion GDP. Shame on baseless and Illiterate communal party'. Dr Manmohan Singh was great great Economist who did a great job for nation economy.
5 kg Anaj batkar ye BJP wale white paper la rhe hai. 2014 me 40 crores poor log the ..now 80 crores people getting 5kg anaj bcz of poverty. Shame on these BJP people
What about our foreign reserves. Please do research before commenting
@@AnilKumar-lz8iiare you stupid or something. Who told you that there are 80 cr people live in poverty. Please do some research
@@gamingwithbipul0073 r u getting a pie from foreign reserves it's not for u it's for stability of Indian currency is it stable you tell me what is the current price and what was the price on 2014 don't give random facts understand what he telling
In 2010 P Chidambaram finance minister said we will be 3rd biggest economy in 2044 that time India rank was 11th in GDP
Chamcha wow 😲🤩
In 2023 Narendra Modi we will be 3rd biggest economy in 2029 with 5 trillion GDP
Chamcha fake, agar congress rehti toh bhi hota 🤡 Irony 😂
Announcing schemes is not amounting to development.
Manrega/Adhaar/Food secutmrity are great intentions. UPA never had the intention of implementation.
Keeping people under poverty, appeasing a section of people with the sole intention of vote bank, shouting Garib hatao (without doing anything really ) were the path chosen by congress
What's wrong with BJP's economic model
We are just now following American capitalist economy model
Our FM (Nirmala Sita Raman) said in parliament, Modi govt stretched more then 3CR houses for people, next days our PM Modi said we are stretched more than 4CR houses for people. now tell me how is right FM or PM.
PM Modi Govt have only agenda to divert people from main problems nothing else.
Not PM Nor FM bcz neither 3 nor 4 crore house it's totally fake by both if possible actual enquiries to be done by central and as well as state government investigation team where and which state how much house will be given or taken by poor people .
Pm awas yojna scheme is a although not going on full speed but it is still building in North Eastern and central States it's 3 crore initially and now it has been increased to 4 crore.
This was the biggest jhumla of Modi check non BJP channels ground reporting of the houses allotment to poors
@@rohitg4569wo bhi toh chamche hai wo kaun sa sach bolenge😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@pipipupu5104yeah 1 day
Calling Nirmala Sitharam qualified is like calling a pigeon a great swimmer
Ohh like rahul gandhi is qualified for pm 😂
Bhai thoda padh le opinion banane se pehle - PHD he economics me
Thats a good one !
@@ironwill7446 a PhD and still not qualified enough is... Sad
han bhai tune hi toh economics ka paper check kia tha nirmala ka. kis basis pe tu bol rha hai she isnt qualified? left media narrative ya koi proof bhi hai?
Old wines in the new bottle policy seen in the labour surplus democracies nation of the world???!!!!..
Very good work by Deshbhakt. You are doing the work of 4th pillar of democracy. Indian media is not at all talking about such relevant issues except Gandhi-Nehru accusation and benefits to Ambani-Adani. Thank you for speaking the truth. Please save the democracy if not now then when. Every Indian should come out and caste their votes to the right party. 🌞🙏🏻🙏🏻
Most unbiased and neutral journalist 😂😅
He is make video only one side on coin
Kangana Ranaut's 2014 ke baad azaadi was epic Akaash Vy 😂😂❤❤❤❤
😂😂😂
Nice analysis. As a centrist, I have seen both sides over the time and I'd say Dudh ka dhula koi ni hota. Every party also prioritizes its own political interests be it with misinformation. I just hope people realize this and stop disrupting religious and social harmony. We cannot develop unless we're united when it comes to national interests.
😂as a centrist
Well done Akash for explaining so clearly your research is so well read !! Kudos to your team 😊❤
Thank you 🙌
There should be a open debate between current FM and opposition member who was FM in a live TV show
It will be interesting to watch
Pm aajtak kabhi samne nhi aya press k🤣
Unscripted. And well moderated. Where 30 seconds means 30.
Game on!
Both of them are absolutely useless be it nirmala Sitharaman or p chidambaram or pranab mukherjee
@@pipipupu5104beta COVID ke baad bhi inflation kitna tha😂
WhatsApp ka gyaan Dena band karo
@@pipipupu5104among them nirmal aunty kinda okayish.
India is growing and you will also grow if you are skilled and hard working , no one goverment comes and make you rich and that's fact
But government can definitely make you poor
Even a mentally challenged person grows.
Economic Policy is also thing regulated by the Central Govt.
Then if you are hardworking you can excel and become rich in Pakistan as well. 😂 Because hardwork matters and govt does not.
Tejaswi Bhai 😂.
Infact why go to Pakistan we have Bihar people there are hardworking and intelligent phir bhi state ki kya haalath hain.
Soch vichaar karte ho kee nahi woh bhi chod Diya kisi aur pe.
What a beautiful analysis by Deshbhakt !!! My only and only real source of knowledge in Indian Politics ❤❤ more powder to you Akash and your team
Can we link the population growth or number of youth with eligible age for a job to the rate of unemployment of India ?
I agree to your point that no survey was done regarding census, to get an actual idea of the unemployment rates.
I wish this topic could've been broadly discussed in parliament.
Whatsapp university on his hoodie got me😂....anyways sir you elaborate everying nicely..keep it up
Trolling those people who forward news on WhatsApp
He say fdi was on lowest of last 16 year but the fact was its double from 2013 😂😂😂😂
This Video is Important For
1. Student
2. Political People
3. Industrialists
4. People Who Enjoy With Knowledge
5. Any Person in The World.
Thanku You 🙏🙏
I'm the 5th 😊
Thank you for the honest analysis. We vs them white paper would have greater effect if brought in 2014-2015 and informed us what the new govt will do and analysed the same in 2024.
Interesting... Now it's not the congress govt but rather Manmohan Singh's govt ? Nice choice of statement !
In 2004, Electricity in my Home comes for Taking Chai Nasta only, When I want to go any other places Roads were not available, Debt may be high now but you can see development different between those government. Clearly. No government is fully proof, we should select much better between them.
What was the position in 2013
It's not difficult to understand from the White paper that the self proclaimed best economist like Nirmala Aunty is not able to manage the economy.
Anybody remember Silencer and his adult comics distribution from 3 Idiots 😁. If you don't have the capacity to excel then distract others from the core issues 😉
Me soch ta hu ye chije achi kyu ki khami ya dekh ne se hi pata chal ti hai, baat rahi Nirmala ji ki hame respect dena chahiye unko ofcourse constructive criticism is a part of democracy or hame baat kar ni chahiye us ke bare me but ye bol Dena ki kuch sahi kiya hi nahi hai ata ni nahi hai I think that's very wrong, jo bhi changes hue hain hamare infrastructure mein hamari lifestyle mein , hamari economy mein hamari growth mein mujh lagta hai credit Dena Banta hai .
@@nitinmaurya4088 Can you please throw some light?
@@nitinmaurya4088That's the whole point. Do you really think that nothing good has actually happened during the UPA Era? What is the purpose of this White Paper? Nothing just defame others and mislead commoners that Nehru, Sonia, Rahul and Manmohan Singh Ji are responsible for economic slowdown.
Nirmala Aunty, just can’t handle, so She’s taking a Blame Game to Cover Up Economic Collapse to happen
Good job Akash bravo, ye dil mange more.
Thank You for being honest. Journalism needs truth seekers as well as truth speakers.
Very harsh reality that the youngster are going to suffer in the future because of this old peoples politics .. because nobody is talking about education & youth development
first do reforms in your religion where girls are not allowed to study ..where education is haram..why muslims in india have lowest literacy rate..
Absolutely true...💯
Even I suffered from our Education system...😢
I was taught carpentery even though chose to be an IT engg...
No one talks about education how our country will grow...
I feel very bad for the future students...😢
Instead of carpentry they would have taught AI ML...😂 But that was never taught in 4 years..
Congress literally talked about unemployment in its black paper
1st sensible comment . They have lived their life and they have enough money in their accounts who will be used by their kids to enjoy life . And we were same and will be same
@@SachinKumar-ew2gr definitely they're just fighting & doing politics to feed their own ego ...while nobody talks about the young generation & future of india
You didn't mention one word about ballooning external debt? 55 lakh crores from 1947 to 2014. And, 185 lakh crores in last 9 years. What about that?
debt is necessary for all infrastructure. Most of our revenue goes into paying interests , most of the projects use the money they get through loans.
@@oddneighbour Ah, you must be a Saffron University graduate. Everything looks rosy to you.
@@user-dp48ry5 tbh you are showing your bias , the person above said right. Debt is necessary otherwise, how is a country going to develop? Saying someone is nda/congress bhakt doesn't make you look literate, just counter the argument with fact rather than saffron/green thing.
@@prashantgoswami2 I have counter argument but it's pointless to argue with the other party which has jaundiced view of everything. To your kind, no matter what Modi does, it is right. I never blindly say Congress was always right. It had its own share of follies, failures and mistakes. But your kind will not accept that modi govt made any mistakes on any front in last 10 years. So, I am out of here. Keep believing in all the hogwash that is dished out on a regular basis.
@@user-dp48ry5agreed, some of them said they'll vote for Modi even if they go bankrupt
Stagflation is a great economic problems in the labour surplus democracies nation of the world!!!???
Absolutely Dr. Singh❤
Every government tries it's best. Show the good you have accomplished instead of running down your opponents. That's unfair and non constructive for the nation. That's the sign of self love and nothing to do with love for nation and it's welfare.
Very good comment I appreciate you I think so
19:34
Shameless and spineless people are highlighting our country's biggest economic reformer Dr. Manmohan Singh !
People are highlighting other economist like p chidambaram.
Manmohan singh did nothing.
Lpg was carried out in an unplanned manner though Vajpayee is horribly responsible too we can't necessarily adapt to everything we need holistic development raghuram rajan etc suck too what about factories ?
@@lakshyavarshney9942 raghuram rajan literally chocked the msmes by high intrest rates although later on Modi government also did nothing to combat that. But rajan was unable to settle NPAs too.
@@rahulboro6284Everything he did was great 👍🏻,Tu godi media subscribe kar tere se na ho paega
Sirf English jhaadne se nahi hoti
Dimaag bech k idhar gyaan Dene mt aaya kar 😂😂😂😂
Farm laws would have doubled the income, if the farm laws were implemented, they only rolled it back
Hindi songs " Aasu na baha, fariyad na kar, rotehee rahe, rotahee rahe. "Seen in the labour surplus democracies nation of the world..!!!!!??????
Imagine the people learning economics from this guy
Is it a good or bad thing?
It is good
@@mukundpatwardhan264 that is the problem of liberals.
If you always like something just because it is better than shit. It simply means your whole comparison is based on the shit.
Bhai whatsapp se ku padhna. Tujhe aur koi option nahi pata??
@@mukundpatwardhan264 bro whatsApp university yahi guy hai 😂 because ishe pahle yeh word existence mein nhi tha 😂
@@AkashSingh-nt4rc liberals not bro fake liberals real Islamists
real100%
Indian debt is ₹155 lakhs crore ÷ 140 crore population = ₹1, 10,714 debt person as on the 31/3/2023
Actually We don't have any alternative
Singh is King
He deserves Bharat Ratna than LK Advani
He will get... in case he wish to join BJP 😂😂
Neither LK Advani nor PV Narishma Rao deserves Bharat Ratna
Bjp ratna he
@@mohitxxv you have lost your mind completely if you say both Narsimha Rao and Lal Krishn Advani doesn't deserve.
@@SKumar-bs7zz Nar Simba Rao was a Congress Leader
As a person who grew up in the 90s i saw a lot of change during the 2000s including peoples lifestyles, the discourse about future, technology etc. Now it looks like that has become stagnant and people like to discuss about which religion or god is the best 😐. Its not always about economy and its related numbers.
Because 2000 was liberalization era. We were literally transforming from a socialist to capitaliat state. Now it's not stagnant I could see highways,roads, increased Electricity,digitalization you have to be updated through news I guess.
@@pipipupu5104 you mean godi media, sorry i dont follow that. You did not get my point. Do yo mean roads, electrification etc happened only after 2014? I did not say it stopped after 2014 either, a lot of that things happened after 2014 too, but i said about the current situation.
@@rideintrance5625 what point so all highways, increased number of electricity grid in uttar pradesh all of that is false to you please come to amroha. The birth place of John ellias and see the development here. How else do you think yogi is able to secure votes.
@@rideintrance5625 what is stegnant in 2024..? I can see warm welcome to our pm modi across the globe unlike that in 2004-2014 where manmohan singh stood like a puppet behind sonia.... 😃
Its confusing who was the pm at that time,, if you watch some of the videos you will get to know...
If you feel there is a lot of development in your state, you should definitely support them. Nobody is stopping you. But you cant say this is the kind of development everyone in the country wants
Did NDA ever in this ten years had crude going to 140 dollars or even 100 dollars...they are about UPA failing to control inflation....
Well said and articulated!! 👏👏👍🏻
"Government wasn't able to work because it was correcting the wrongdoing of past 10 years." This is all I need to know about the credibility and agenda of these papers.
It has been quite clearly stated that what paramters their govt has done well, compared to UPA. Don't be blind. You can only understand their performance if you compare the numbers with UPA era.
Yup my friend wants to become a billionare but his father did not leave a billion dollar empire . Now all he does is blaming his father for not being billionare😢
'correcting' and it is taking more than 10 years for them to correct it ?
Currently both parties are just blaming each other, none of them are doing any better
I got 45% marks because my parents didn't study well 😔😔 Lol!
@@dharteetops5759 sad for ur marks go study why r u watching UA-cam and economics doesn't work like marks it is to be built on a foundation set by previous government which was actually weak
Really sad today.Why the white paper was not for the Nehru regime ? Now I am also getting doubt about this Government 's Credibility. 🙆🏻♂️
What Nehru regime.
@@pipipupu5104it's sarcasm.
You should have long back. Anyway better late than never and please do not roll back
So true.. 😂😂
@@ZamKhan-wd7vz 😂
Petrol price on 2014 is 60 now 105 and Ruppees to Dollar 2015 50 now 83
This vedeo is a guideline for opposition towards 24 election.
Mr Manmohan Singh is globally respected economist. V r in stupid,non sense nd sad state of democracy ( if its still alive). Ur team really work hard nd do proper research bring out a balanced view.
How is it sad state of democracy if we elect the central government.
If only Manmohan Singh is a respected economist but not chidambaram or pranab mukharjee. Congress is a corrupt party atleast BJP central leadership is better in international relations
Democracy was killed by MK GANDHI when he did nehru prime minister instead of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel
But how did india get to the situation of going bankrupt?
@@pranav.m.k. let's not go back to past. Actually Both parties are equally responsible, ii personally admire Dr Singh. Nd like. I said I like AAKASH'S balanced VIEW.
Finally, this is one of the videos where agree with this person completely.
Brilliant Analysis...👍💪👍
One thing very rightly you said Akash that it's economy, not a murti jo kharab ho jati hai!! Govts. build on eachother's work to power the economy and keep it going!
Excellent, very well researched discussion. Congratulations.
Research? 😂 Research =
ua-cam.com/video/iUF-Wh1Iu7w/v-deo.htmlsi=PUUa6spkHTJ9i-id
Till godi media is in the game truth will never come out. It is a His Master Voice .
What we need is something that we do not have. Unfortunately.
Proper opposition parties. No democracy can survive without one.
Complaining about critical issues while voting based on caste or religion is contradictory. Make an informed choice for leaders who address the real problems.
It's quite hard to believe that some talk sensibly about our economy. Because our economy looks good from numbers but the actual situation is quite different
Wow truth is so depressing, Now i am getting to understand why Masses are ignoring the pain by focusing on superficial issues. Cause Truth is suffocating and almost strangling.
Go and check the facts given by him. Most of this info has been either picked from The print ,Hindu etc. I checked few of them which are either false or incomplete. Akash is complete biased.
Love ur neutral stand bro, plz don't lose it, u r today one of the few people we get our news from.
Seriously? He is not neutral. He is not willing to talk about the dark age of India under Congree
🤣 Good joke bro. I seriously needed that laugh today.
Dr Manmohan Singh is well known as world famous Economist
So Great News Sir. Thankyou so much
I'm doing all I can. My parents provided me with good education. I got good marks in college. After not getting placed from college placement and voluntarily opting out from a sales job that college placement was providing, everyone said you have skill issue. I learned some skill still not able to land a job. I am also learning a second foreign language. Hoping for the best but the hopes are getting weak as days are passing. I don't want to be a failure and I'm scared to study further because will it be of any help or even after studying further people will tell me that you have a skill issue but learning skill was the whole point of studying or getting a degree. I'm still trying and learning to the best of abilities but I'm empty and I feel hollow just chasing the dream as it get further away, is this what life is...
Same condition here, but we should not lose hope brother, perseverance is the key
best of luck to both of you
I have always liked your content, but this was one of your best episodes! Keep it up!
Please provide a road map that every citizen of this country gets to vote for an honest MP or MLA.
Well done.. will follow you for unbiased political knowledge. Please stay unbiased always.. very good and honest content 👏👏👏👌😊❤
Thanks for sharing it. They can blaming one other but nothing will change. ✌️
It's good to see healthy discussion, which is rarely discussed by deshbhakt.
Good work and keep on
?
Its a bunch of half-truths and white-washing for congis :)
Hello sir please make a video on ASHOK SWAIN and how he is disrespecting our nation with his deregatory statements🙏🙏🙏
Thanks Akash ji bahut achha baat hai is video me Sab kuch hai
I am a small/micro entrepreneur and I can vouch how smooth and easy GST payment is every month. Also how easy was even getting my company registered.
It is easy for you, not for middle class and the lower middle class groups.
Oh, I'm from lower middle class but it is actually quite easy and fast these days not know about upa era.
@@Sidharth_Kant ok
@@sandeepvashishtha Fired employee of Vript?
@@Sidharth_Kant yes
The country can only develop if each of its brick is strong. The focus should be to develop new cities not only in Gujarat but in other states as well. Brain drain is happening at state level as well. North eastern states, eastern states, Punjab the focus should be on them as well by the Center and State govt otherwise everyone will leave their hometown to shift to cities like Bangalore, Delhi, Hyderabad, Mumbai for jobs
Good thought but this cant be achived ultil we stop this vs us. Vampanth and abvp. these division in society. No brick is strong enough to bear its weight.
Blame your state government because most of the new cities programs was established by Narendra Modi when he was CM of Gujarat.
Is PM Modi for the blame for inefficiency of States like Kerala,Bengal, Punjab 😂
@@ChandranPrema123centre me kon hai ? Tera baap . Kerela Bengal Punjab all have more than 1 lakh crore in receivables from Indian centre govt
Fun fact , there is a state called Odisha in India
One of the best Indian UA-camr..fantastic
People were expecting india to be in next galaxy after ten years of modi, instead we are in a trench anf and loosing even the very democracy.
May Congress has a spokesperson Like Akash!
He indirectly work for congress & opposition party only
Proof? Cuz he criticized both parties btw @@jprasad.
@thedeshbhakt there was no scam at all on coal allocation 2g allotments. it was allotted as per the norms, CAG head was master mind in playing the game to favor the current govt
Modi sarkar basically took every scheme from UPA and advertised it