I have a personal satisfaction every March 5th, a day to celebrate. And Christmas Day 1991 was an even greater event....the last lowering of the slavish 🔨 and sickle.
This is wonderful. I'm just wondering though... Why are virtually all of the first hand accounts/witnesses reading from a piece of paper? The awkward manner in which many of them are reading it hints that the words were not written by them themselves aswell which only serves to compound my confusion on the matter.
@@marshmallowbudgie Beria was no match for Stalin, not even close. Not in innate brutality or paranoia. He was, at best, Stalin's puppet and handy-man carrying a big club (shades of Yagoda and Yezhov before him).
Ati postat un film despre Revolutia din 89 din România unde s-au facut afirmatii nedovedite si neconforme cu realitatea Adevarul este ca România fost atacata de agenturi straine de securitate în colaborate cu unii securisti ai tarii . Dupa 1989 a scazut masiv nivelul de viata s s-a declansat un genocid national . Asta a fost si scopul acestei lovituri de stat . Eu am luat parte la ultimul meeting si am observat cum printre participanti erau rânduri de securisti iar când a explodat o petarda , ce a fost nu am vazut , dar asa am auzit - asemanator cu o explozie de petarda , In acel moment am fost împinsi spre exterior cu o forta enorma si noi, demonstrantii am plecat acasa , Nici unora dintre noi nu ne trecea prin cap sa rasturnam guvernul , Pe bulevard am întâlnit o coloana se oameni tineri care veneau din sens contar ,care se distingeau prin îmbracaminte , înfatisare si comportament . Noi plecam si ei veneau . La Bucuresti s-a iesit în strada când teroristii au început sa faca primele crime în strada împuscând cetateni la întâmplare . Impuscaturile se spunea ca erau facute cu gloante ce nu se gaseau în dotare la noi si mai ales erau foarte precise ,erau arme cu luneta multi au fost împuscati în frunte . La Timisoara sub pretextul evacuarii unui pastor reformist au fost asezate pe trotuar cadavre în pielea goala si s-a dat zvon ca statul împusca oamenii pe strada . Oamenii au fost indignati si au iesit în strada strigand ,,jos Ceausscu , jos comunismul . Printre demonstranti erau huligani care faceau haos , spargând vitrinele magazinelor si incendiind masini . Militia nu mai putea face fataacestor huligani si a fost chemata armata sa faca ordine . Dar când huligani fac dezastru si în jutul lor demonstreaza o masa de oameni manipulati dar nevinovati iese cuma iesit ,cu victime . Arfi bine sa-i gasim pe acei manipulatori sisa fie acuzati de genocid si condamnati pe viata ; nu omorâti ci condamnati La noi se povesteau bancuri politice când stateam la cozile acelea pe vtremea comunismului , nu am auzit sa fie din cauza sta cineva arestat sau ridicat . Când l-am vazut în acest film pe Silviu Brucan cum rânjeste mi-am dat seama ca-i avea pe români la inima ca sarea în ochi . În 1990 avusese loc un meeting de-al lui Iliescu , veniseram multi oameni , Dupa terminarea lui mergeam pe strada împreuna cu niste colege si la un moment am vazut un mic grup de tiganci Erau foarte curat îmbracate , purtau rochii lungi ce pareau peticite , si aveau prinsi în parul lung împletit , multi bani . M-am oprit si am zis cu voce tare de uimire , ,, ,,uite , pâna si tignii vin la demonstratie ´ !´ Deodata din acel grup se întoarse una spre mine si m-a privit si zis cu o ura ce nu o pricep nici astazi ,, cândva asta va fi tara nostra ´ . Atunci mi s-a parut o vorba -hodoronc - tronc , si foarte ciudata reactia ei . M-am oprit în drum uitându-ma la pleiada de oameni ce se deplasau pe Am vazut o pereche de indieni . Femeia , avea o rochie lunga înfasurata dintr-un material subtire în care domina culoarea maro si era foarte gratioasa .Dupa foarte scurt timp a început genocidul în România , genocid datorat saraciei care afectat tara noastra , Noi fusesem o tara bogata si munciseram mult si reusiseram sa ne platim integral datoriile . Ca România avea dusmani înnafara nu banuisem ,
@@explorerofunknownworlddept6232 Nu doar . I-a gasit spontan in 89 dorinta de adevar ? Ce spui fratiorule , da cata lume as suferit pana atunci si de atunci in colo ? Si inca cum ?! De-asta au preferat sa insceneze o actiune de terorism in România si probat sa faca razboi civil la Bucuresti si Târgu Mures ? A venit apoi razboiul in Europa , Irakul , Siria ; Afganistan , diastruse , generatia de români din tara -distrusa , generatia parintilor si bunicilor nostrii , distrusa, chiar daca s-au gandit la modernizare , rea metoda si-au ales , suntem tara in care altii isi spala banii la fiecare 50 de ani , si nu este mafia , nu este mafia , sunt venerabilii , si nu-i unul ,
Imagine what one sniper bullet could accomplish, and how many great things that good men and women could've accomplished, if not for starvation, purge, and paranoid behavior.
Yes but that could be said for anything, good or bad. What is more telling is that he created such an atmosphere of fear around him that few even in a position to take such a shot would have. He was also a constantly moving target, by design.
It is to bad most of people don't know thatStalin was a mass killer . He killedd more people than Hitler. Yes, he had camps and more. Read a little history, read about Mao, Stalin and Hitler. This is the order of the mass killers.
He was a mass killer, but no, he did not kill more people than Hitler. Acording to the Soviet Archives, that were declassified after the fall of the SU, he were responsible for the deaths of between 680 000 - 1 million people. These people died either trough executions or in the gulags. Still, Stalin was a monster. Mao is worse than Stalin simply for being more incompetent as well. The man who should have gained power instead of Stalin was Bukharin, leader of the Right wing opposition in the party. He wanted to democratize the party and the country, stop Stalin's brutal collectivization and stop Hitler in the 20s.
@@marcusappelberg369 You are grossly underestimating this figure by quoting a compromised (incomplete and unreliable) source. But here's news for you. If you think Stalin is difficult to pinpoint accurately, Hitler is even more difficult. There even fewer records exist when it comes to his supposed actions.
Poor Molotov? Not sure what that means considering he was Stalin's most devoted long-term henchman and diehard believer. This didn't stop even when Stalin was looking to do away with him at the end.
The fake history is over. Archives have been recently looked in Russia and it is concluded Stalin was a great leader. All the Myth about millions killed by Stalin is no longer in use. Stalin was a greatest leader ever in the history. Stalin received USSR in poor conditions but left country with best economy, social benefits and science in the world.
Stalin was worst evil psychopath leader of the human history. A ruthless mess murderer of millions of Russians, Ukrainians, Polish, latvian, almost all East European people. He didn't spare even women & children. ROT in HELL.
Lenin did not like him after his stroke when he was in semi retirement. Stalin was his most loyal comrade. He personally sneaked into austria-hungry to give him news and personally reported to him and took care of his security. In the early stages Stalin risked his life many times going to jail or exile in siberia 6 or 7 times escaping about half those times. Stalin was the most loyal out of the Lenins comrades thats why you see so much footage them sitting together, Stalin would always personally go and report to lenin and Stalin had much influence with the non russian soviet republics. Also about the deaths that is said to be 3-60 million people. It was a war between the Kulaks (serf owners/land owners) and the state. It was against the law to burn grain they were supposed to hand it over and if the deaths are accurate why did the population increase drastically during the time of the famine? But go down during ww2? if he killed so many people the population would also decrease during that time.
Stalin himself was in exile in the arctic circle he risked his life many times for the revolution and was in sent to exile at least 6 times. His own son was conscripted to the war effort and captured. The Germans thought they would get a lot for trading his life but Stalin he did not trade him in for high officials he treated him as he would treat any other captured soldier. He himself did not have any special luxuries. He seemed to be a very principled man who put the country ahead of himself.
Well, when you hold up a psycopath like Stalin who's up there with Hitler in terms of being a barbarian, it does leave the door open. Not that I have anything against the average Russian any more than I would anyone else. Also, pointing to the archives as vindication for Stalin in certifiably insane. Equal opportunity dictator I guess, he was having the people around him killed as much as everyone else. Except for Yezhov and Beria, he needed them. No, wait, Yezhov was killed too. And so was Beria as soon as Stalin died. And Stalin died in part to the fact that the people around him were so scared to death of him that they were afraid to go in his room to check on him because they thought they'd maybe get sent to the gulag or killed for it. I guess when you're about to have a stroke isn't the best time to decide that all the doctors are plotting against you and need to have yet another purge. But at least he was great in The Great Patriotic War. No wait, Hitler played him like a fiddle and Stalin wouldn't allow the military to strike back when the Germans invaded because he refused to believe it was happening. The country was saved by its size and weather. And then he had the heroes of the Siege of Leningrad arrested and often killed after war. What a guy, huh? At least we can say that Lenin died wanting Stalin to lead the country. No, wait, he wanted the opposite. Fuck I'm having trouble here. Got it! At least he figured out how to have people removed from photos long before Photoshop existed.
Steven Kotkin’s Stalin series is probably the most in-depth knowledge about the Stalin ever written. I highly recommend. Most Americans could never fathom that a lot of the purges in the 30s were justified. Especially Zinoviev, Kamenev, Bhukharin, Radek, Rykov, Yehzov, and Yagoda.. Trotskyist traitors plotting behind Stalin’s back. Also, Stalin gave Bukharin a pass to go to Paris before he was exposed.
I've watched this a least a dozen times. It only gets better.
Pure gold
Always struggle for power, everywhere in different ways!
I have a personal satisfaction every March 5th, a day to celebrate. And Christmas Day 1991 was an even greater event....the last lowering of the slavish 🔨 and sickle.
the KGB chekists remain in charge of all the Russian serfs, just as they have for over a hundred years
Glml
This is wonderful. I'm just wondering though... Why are virtually all of the first hand accounts/witnesses reading from a piece of paper? The awkward manner in which many of them are reading it hints that the words were not written by them themselves aswell which only serves to compound my confusion on the matter.
Couldn't have happened to a nastier guy.
❤❤😂
his successor was literally Beria
@@marshmallowbudgie Beria was no match for Stalin, not even close. Not in innate brutality or paranoia. He was, at best, Stalin's puppet and handy-man carrying a big club (shades of Yagoda and Yezhov before him).
30:05 I agree with the short statement of this lady!
Ati postat un film despre Revolutia din 89 din România unde s-au facut afirmatii nedovedite si neconforme cu realitatea Adevarul este ca România fost atacata de agenturi straine de securitate în colaborate cu unii securisti ai tarii . Dupa 1989 a scazut masiv nivelul de viata s s-a declansat un genocid national . Asta a fost si scopul acestei lovituri de stat . Eu am luat parte la ultimul meeting si am observat cum printre participanti erau rânduri de securisti iar când a explodat o petarda , ce a fost nu am vazut , dar asa am auzit - asemanator cu o explozie de petarda , In acel moment am fost împinsi spre exterior cu o forta enorma si noi, demonstrantii am plecat acasa , Nici unora dintre noi nu ne trecea prin cap sa rasturnam guvernul , Pe bulevard am întâlnit o coloana se oameni tineri care veneau din sens contar ,care se distingeau prin îmbracaminte , înfatisare si comportament . Noi plecam si ei veneau . La Bucuresti s-a iesit în strada când teroristii au început sa faca primele crime în strada împuscând cetateni la întâmplare . Impuscaturile se spunea ca erau facute cu gloante ce nu se gaseau în dotare la noi si mai ales erau foarte precise ,erau arme cu luneta multi au fost împuscati în frunte . La Timisoara sub pretextul evacuarii unui pastor reformist au fost asezate pe trotuar cadavre în pielea goala si s-a dat zvon ca statul împusca oamenii pe strada . Oamenii au fost indignati si au iesit în strada strigand ,,jos Ceausscu , jos comunismul . Printre demonstranti erau huligani care faceau haos , spargând vitrinele magazinelor si incendiind masini . Militia nu mai putea face fataacestor huligani si a fost chemata armata sa faca ordine . Dar când huligani fac dezastru si în jutul lor demonstreaza o masa de oameni manipulati dar nevinovati iese cuma iesit ,cu victime . Arfi bine sa-i gasim pe acei manipulatori sisa fie acuzati de genocid si condamnati pe viata ; nu omorâti ci condamnati La noi se povesteau bancuri politice când stateam la cozile acelea pe vtremea comunismului , nu am auzit sa fie din cauza sta cineva arestat sau ridicat . Când l-am vazut în acest film pe Silviu Brucan cum rânjeste mi-am dat seama ca-i avea pe români la inima ca sarea în ochi . În 1990 avusese loc un meeting de-al lui Iliescu , veniseram multi oameni , Dupa terminarea lui mergeam pe strada împreuna cu niste colege si la un moment am vazut un mic grup de tiganci Erau foarte curat îmbracate , purtau rochii lungi ce pareau peticite , si aveau prinsi în parul lung împletit , multi bani . M-am oprit si am zis cu voce tare de uimire , ,, ,,uite , pâna si tignii vin la demonstratie ´ !´ Deodata din acel grup se întoarse una spre mine si m-a privit si zis cu o ura ce nu o pricep nici astazi ,, cândva asta va fi tara nostra ´ . Atunci mi s-a parut o vorba -hodoronc - tronc , si foarte ciudata reactia ei . M-am oprit în drum uitându-ma la pleiada de oameni ce se deplasau pe Am vazut o pereche de indieni . Femeia , avea o rochie lunga înfasurata dintr-un material subtire în care domina culoarea maro si era foarte gratioasa .Dupa foarte scurt timp a început genocidul în România , genocid datorat saraciei care afectat tara noastra , Noi fusesem o tara bogata si munciseram mult si reusiseram sa ne platim integral datoriile . Ca România avea dusmani înnafara nu banuisem ,
What kind of language is this - Italian?
Eu sunt vecine , ce nu ma mai recunosti ; ?
@@ferdinanddepaoli1599 Romania?
@@explorerofunknownworlddept6232 Nu doar . I-a gasit spontan in 89 dorinta de adevar ? Ce spui fratiorule , da cata lume as suferit pana atunci si de atunci in colo ? Si inca cum ?! De-asta au preferat sa insceneze o actiune de terorism in România si probat sa faca razboi civil la Bucuresti si Târgu Mures ? A venit apoi razboiul in Europa , Irakul , Siria ; Afganistan , diastruse , generatia de români din tara -distrusa , generatia parintilor si bunicilor nostrii , distrusa, chiar daca s-au gandit la modernizare , rea metoda si-au ales , suntem tara in care altii isi spala banii la fiecare 50 de ani , si nu este mafia , nu este mafia , sunt venerabilii , si nu-i unul ,
This language is Romanian. He's referring to certain oddities he witnessed during the Christmas (Romanian) Revolution of 1989.
Stalin : A paranoid , ruthless killer ....
Indeed
33:01 That is Sergo Ordzhonikidze's funeral..in 1937!
Andrei Zhadnov died in 1948...5 years before Stalin!
I don't believe some of the people who are saying they witnessed part of the history it just doesn't ring true what some of them were saying or doing?
Such as? An example or two would help.
Chet Huntley
When did this aire?
1963
@@cultmamacultmama3571 no when did this aire? 1990’s?
🖤🖤🖤
Peace, democracy and Socialism are they crazy? He was a brutal tyrant. Geez
People were afraid to be the first to stop clapping, Joe had them terrified.
Source: US propaganda
@@verymew lol actually Russians who were in attendance ~ including his daughter Svetlana who was not wholly purchased.
This means: after every Stalin- speech the first one who stopped clapping was punished and the last who started clapping, too?
Everyone who didn't go to listen his speeches was punished too- but harder to force people to listen and clapp ?
Some still are clapping?
18:19, a interesting account of Stalin.
Well ok
Didn't he die in 1953?
He did, but the program aired on NBC 10 years after his death.
Problem,at33.03 we see Zhdanov standing next to Kaganovich at Stalins funeral! Zhdanov died in 1948!!!
Agreed, I spotted that too. It just shows you how little official Soviet footage the west had in its possession at that time.
Imagine what one sniper bullet could accomplish, and how many great things that good men and women could've accomplished, if not for starvation, purge, and paranoid behavior.
Yes but that could be said for anything, good or bad. What is more telling is that he created such an atmosphere of fear around him that few even in a position to take such a shot would have. He was also a constantly moving target, by design.
At 7.05 stalin clapps too.
死因推测 频繁的二联律 三联律 一针肾上腺素 不行再来一针 直到奏效 后来奏效了！
Certainly possible. But a simple stroke (brain hemorrhage) was the much more likely cause of death, just as reported.
The death of Stalin was 10 years earlier - in 1953.
Yes, but the documentary aired 1963, i know the title is confusing
We know.
起码知道是斯大林，也许是林达斯，也许是大司令，也许是死里打
你又在说胡话了😂
@@1a2b3c-gf6ct 是贼喊捉贼！意思就是自己是贼，要捉贼，真正的贼就是自己！
아빠
It is to bad most of people don't know thatStalin was a mass killer . He killedd more people than Hitler. Yes, he had camps and more. Read a little history, read about Mao, Stalin and Hitler. This is the order of the mass killers.
He was a mass killer, but no, he did not kill more people than Hitler. Acording to the Soviet Archives, that were declassified after the fall of the SU, he were responsible for the deaths of between 680 000 - 1 million people. These people died either trough executions or in the gulags. Still, Stalin was a monster. Mao is worse than Stalin simply for being more incompetent as well. The man who should have gained power instead of Stalin was Bukharin, leader of the Right wing opposition in the party. He wanted to democratize the party and the country, stop Stalin's brutal collectivization and stop Hitler in the 20s.
Of course we know. At least 20 million.
@@marcusappelberg369 You are grossly underestimating this figure by quoting a compromised (incomplete and unreliable) source. But here's news for you. If you think Stalin is difficult to pinpoint accurately, Hitler is even more difficult. There even fewer records exist when it comes to his supposed actions.
That's not how it happened at all.
Like much of history, there are flashes of truth hidden within. We will gladly accept footnotes.
Please enlighten us with your version.
Poor Molotov.
😂
Poor Molotov? Not sure what that means considering he was Stalin's most
devoted long-term henchman and diehard believer. This didn't stop even when Stalin was looking to do away with him at the end.
An error in the title of the video. Stalin died in 1953
Incorrect. The show aired on NBC in 1963.
they hate Stalin because he saved Russian people
The ukrain missile crises?
The fake history is over. Archives have been recently looked in Russia and it is concluded Stalin was a great leader. All the Myth about millions killed by Stalin is no longer in use. Stalin was a greatest leader ever in the history. Stalin received USSR in poor conditions but left country with best economy, social benefits and science in the world.
Stalin was worst evil psychopath leader of the human history. A ruthless mess murderer of millions of Russians, Ukrainians, Polish, latvian, almost all East European people. He didn't spare even women & children. ROT in HELL.
Lenin did not like him after his stroke when he was in semi retirement. Stalin was his most loyal comrade. He personally sneaked into austria-hungry to give him news and personally reported to him and took care of his security. In the early stages Stalin risked his life many times going to jail or exile in siberia 6 or 7 times escaping about half those times. Stalin was the most loyal out of the Lenins comrades thats why you see so much footage them sitting together, Stalin would always personally go and report to lenin and Stalin had much influence with the non russian soviet republics. Also about the deaths that is said to be 3-60 million people. It was a war between the Kulaks (serf owners/land owners) and the state. It was against the law to burn grain they were supposed to hand it over and if the deaths are accurate why did the population increase drastically during the time of the famine? But go down during ww2? if he killed so many people the population would also decrease during that time.
Stalin himself was in exile in the arctic circle he risked his life many times for the revolution and was in sent to exile at least 6 times. His own son was conscripted to the war effort and captured. The Germans thought they would get a lot for trading his life but Stalin he did not trade him in for high officials he treated him as he would treat any other captured soldier. He himself did not have any special luxuries. He seemed to be a very principled man who put the country ahead of himself.
Well, when you hold up a psycopath like Stalin who's up there with Hitler in terms of being a barbarian, it does leave the door open. Not that I have anything against the average Russian any more than I would anyone else.
Also, pointing to the archives as vindication for Stalin in certifiably insane. Equal opportunity dictator I guess, he was having the people around him killed as much as everyone else. Except for Yezhov and Beria, he needed them. No, wait, Yezhov was killed too. And so was Beria as soon as Stalin died. And Stalin died in part to the fact that the people around him were so scared to death of him that they were afraid to go in his room to check on him because they thought they'd maybe get sent to the gulag or killed for it. I guess when you're about to have a stroke isn't the best time to decide that all the doctors are plotting against you and need to have yet another purge. But at least he was great in The Great Patriotic War. No wait, Hitler played him like a fiddle and Stalin wouldn't allow the military to strike back when the Germans invaded because he refused to believe it was happening. The country was saved by its size and weather. And then he had the heroes of the Siege of Leningrad arrested and often killed after war. What a guy, huh? At least we can say that Lenin died wanting Stalin to lead the country. No, wait, he wanted the opposite. Fuck I'm having trouble here.
Got it! At least he figured out how to have people removed from photos long before Photoshop existed.
Stop listening to state run media. Stalin was a mass murderer. Everybody knows this.
you people do not half swallow every lie about Stalin
"You people" utterance = major symptom of Dunning-Kruger effect. But not always indicated.
Steven Kotkin’s Stalin series is probably the most in-depth knowledge about the Stalin ever written. I highly recommend. Most Americans could never fathom that a lot of the purges in the 30s were justified. Especially Zinoviev, Kamenev, Bhukharin, Radek, Rykov, Yehzov, and Yagoda.. Trotskyist traitors plotting behind Stalin’s back. Also, Stalin gave Bukharin a pass to go to Paris before he was exposed.