Lee and Meade Plan for Battle, July 2 - Real-Time Anniversary Program with Ranger Angie Atkinson

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 43

  • @fireman19841
    @fireman19841 6 років тому +8

    Really digging the videos! Her husband Matt is one of the best guides there.

    • @aarontataryn3623
      @aarontataryn3623 6 років тому +3

      I was wondering if she was related to ranger Matt. I never tire of watching his lectures. The guy is custom made for his job.

    • @mhollman8650
      @mhollman8650 6 років тому +1

      Angie is married to that Rebel Matt...I love that guy..we share the same name so I'm a little biased. Been watching him since the 1st series of vids on Gburg NPS UA-cam

    • @fireman19841
      @fireman19841 6 років тому +1

      I was there in 2016 with my family. Wife went antique shopping and I spent the whole day on the fields doing all the lectures I could. Got to meet Mattand John during the lectures and pick their minds.

    • @mhollman8650
      @mhollman8650 6 років тому +1

      fireman19841 1st visit was after the filming of the movie in late 90s, was lucky enough to actually have Scott Harmann (sp?) as a tour guide. Hooked ever since. 30 years later, I give lectures, teach children & anybody interested abt the Civil War. Everytime I've been to Gburg, it's a new experience as the battlefield has grown, changed, evolved..ect to what it is today. Sadly I am unable to go anymore due to poor health & distance.. (I live in Ut)
      The next best thing to being there r these videos. I am ETERNALLY grateful for all the hard work it takes to produce them. They allow the next generation to do things not taught in school anymore...learn abt our history as a nation

    • @fireman19841
      @fireman19841 6 років тому +1

      of course, the time taken for these videos is great! While I do enjoy the major action videos (Little Round Top, Picketts Charge) I even more so enjoy the smaller lesser known units they cover.

  • @marymoriarity2555
    @marymoriarity2555 5 років тому +2

    I wish I got notified if new lectures and battlefield tours. Despite subscribing and touching the bell it’s like finding buried treasure. I appreciate all posted videos. All the park rangers are excellent.

    • @marymoriarity2555
      @marymoriarity2555 5 років тому

      I see scribe also but never receive notifications of anything. I just look every day when I have time

    • @james6495
      @james6495 4 роки тому

      You have to click the little bell next to the subscribe button to receive notifications.

  • @jaywinters2483
    @jaywinters2483 5 років тому +3

    Matt, this must be your better half... no wonder you’re a happy blessed man. Happy for you 👍. “Whoso findeth a wide findeth a good thing”. Proverbs.

  • @Senor0Droolcup
    @Senor0Droolcup 6 років тому +1

    Thank you for these great videos!

  • @233monte
    @233monte 6 років тому +4

    These videos rock! The park service UA-cam channel hasn’t posted any of these in a while. Thank you for posting these. Do you live close to Gettysburg?

  • @zettle2345
    @zettle2345 6 років тому +1

    At the 14:00 so far, forgive me for raining on your parade... They had field glasses in 1863. If General Lee wanted to know where the Union troops were? Seminary Ridge is the perfect place to look from, in order to find out. General Lee didn't know... is a sad excuse. Especially considering where General Lee's headquarters were. And please, please don't say that General Sickles change of position came as a complete suprise to the Confederate Army. A.P. Hill's troops had a perfect line of sight to what the Union troops were doing. And being a Yank, I'm pretty sure "the guy in charge" of the Union Army, was General Meade, not just Meade. Please show the same respect for both Generals when making these videos, Mrs Atkinson. Thank You NPSGettysburg, for all that you have done.

    • @springfield03sniper
      @springfield03sniper 6 років тому +2

      zettle 234 really splitting hairs there, aren't you? I assume you know about the flank attack at Chancellorsville. There are many instances like this where large numbers of troops were missed all together, whether it was due to faulty intelligence or just mistakes.

    • @darinweeks9330
      @darinweeks9330 6 років тому +6

      zettle 234 If you have been to Gettysburg and walked the ground, you’d know that the land have swales and ridges that mask much of the landscape. If you stand on Seminary Ridge, you can’t see Devil’s Den. Lee had no idea because the land rose and masked much of the Union battle line.

    • @mhollman8650
      @mhollman8650 6 років тому +2

      Fact of the matter is Lee DIDNT have correct info re Union positions around south end of the battlefield. Field glasses or not. Hence the Longstreet change of ave. of attack July 2...Have you actually studied the battlefield physically? Your opinion/impression of Lee's attack plans confuse myself as well as others..Im curious as to where you base your assumptions on..

    • @MrWestmarket39
      @MrWestmarket39 5 років тому

      Patrick Ancona he whipped Bobby lee

    • @pierredupuy4242
      @pierredupuy4242 5 років тому +2

      I served 24 years in the US Army as a non-commissioned officer and as a commissioned officer. Retired in 2012 as a Lieutenant Colonel. I very much appreciate your concern for respecting the individual commanders of the Armies in contact at Gettysburg. I do not know if you have served in any branch of the military, but want you to be aware there is nothing disrespectful about referring to a General Officer -or personnel of any rank- by last name once you have established their rank with the audience. We do this for the sake of brevity, and it is accepted practice - have done so myself in many briefings. We can use a more casual reference such as "guy in charge" on occasion to vary the tenor/tone of the briefing. Being too formal and too 'stilted' all the time turns an audience off so we do use a lighter tone when appropriate to avoid this. We teach these techniques and more in the Instructor Training Course (ITC) to Army personnel who will be "on the platform" teaching Soldiers. Just a perspective from one who has served and has taught Military History to Soldiers and to ROTC Cadets - including the Battle of Gettysburg.

  • @genenoud9048
    @genenoud9048 2 роки тому

    Meade just got the keys to the army , not even a week

  • @chrisdfx1
    @chrisdfx1 3 роки тому

    I love this woman/man/he/she/they/etc.

  • @Bob.W.
    @Bob.W. 2 роки тому

    Pretty basic stuff. Masterson's new book, Meade at Gettysburg, really lays out Meade's decisions and orders before, during and after the battle. Not sure about which is the best reading on Lee's command.

  • @NYCYankInTexas
    @NYCYankInTexas 5 років тому +3

    Lee wrote that the attack on the smaller hill (Later known as Little Round Top) by Oates was embarrassing and took away from the attack by Law. Law ordered Oates back into line and to IGNORE the small hill- that hill- Little Round Top meant nothing- NOTHING to Lee or the ANV sans Warren and his usual drama queen theatrics. Had the Confederates captured the hill it still would have been useless- the topography would have prevented them from aiming anything at Meade's line.
    Biggest myth of the battle was Little Round Top.

  • @james6495
    @james6495 4 роки тому +2

    Did Matt and Angie divorce?

    • @marymoriarity2555
      @marymoriarity2555 4 роки тому

      No idea. He talks about getting his children. He seems to speak more about childcare at times plus mentioning some other lady at times. Must admit I wondered myself.

    • @kimberlyhenshaw8368
      @kimberlyhenshaw8368 4 роки тому

      Mary Moriarity To my knowledge, from what Matt himself has said, it seems that they are at least separated at this time.

    • @M_Lopez_3D_Artist
      @M_Lopez_3D_Artist 3 роки тому

      @@kimberlyhenshaw8368 really there seperated you sure? dang thats crazy if that his wife i was thinking she look totally different interesting

  • @PunchtheLion
    @PunchtheLion 4 роки тому +2

    Do not looketh upon another man's wife..forgive me lord. You prefer us to confess our faults with each other so...

  • @markholbrook3949
    @markholbrook3949 5 років тому +1

    Nepotism at its finest... I'll leave it at that...