AC/DC - Who Made Who - Live with Phil Rudd (Rare)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 101

  • @AshArcher
    @AshArcher 6 років тому +32

    Phil Rudd is quite possibly the greatest drummer to hit the stage... and before all the metalheads go out there saying how boring he is... less is always more! A natural timekeeper and every sound is so precise... master class.

  • @BooMan24
    @BooMan24 13 років тому +52

    finally this song sounds like AC/DC Thanks Phil!

  • @rodrigomussak
    @rodrigomussak 10 років тому +45

    You can feel Phil's groove... he is the best drummer in the world! It sounds like a big metal scoop being hit against a leather couch.... that is the true ACDC beat!

  • @UNF2021
    @UNF2021 Рік тому +5

    Dang! What a difference with his groove! Phil could practically hypnotize someone with that skilled drumming if he wanted to lol, what a great masterpuece now perfomed by Rudd 🤘😎

  • @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd
    @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd 13 років тому +30

    PHIL IS THE BEST AC/DC DRUMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @smokesletsgo2374
    @smokesletsgo2374 7 років тому +96

    All respect to Chris and Simon intended, but Phil is the only true AC/DC drummer. Without him, they're a very good band. With him, they're the greatest rock band of all time.

    • @jeremysimpson2476
      @jeremysimpson2476 6 років тому +8

      smokeslet'sgo I agree. Technically Chris and Simon are superior to Phil but Phil has that swing that just sounds right.

    • @malcolmseb
      @malcolmseb 6 років тому +6

      Phil and Malcolm were the sound of the real AC/DC Rhythm. Phil don't have a very impressive technic but he got the groove and swing that made AC/DC, never see a drummer sound like him. Unfortunately we don't have other recording with phil on who made who, his playing is so powerful, excellent

    • @bunglegamingmusic1784
      @bunglegamingmusic1784 3 роки тому +1

      @@malcolmseb and Cliff

    • @tonydenada93
      @tonydenada93 3 роки тому +1

      i could agree with you but we have to admit that Chris and Simon are more creative and on some tracks like Who made Who or Thunderstruck, if Rudd had composed the drums part, those tracks would have been less impactfull. Rudd would never had used bass toms.

    • @guideouro3755
      @guideouro3755 3 роки тому

      Queen is better

  • @rickardnyberg4899
    @rickardnyberg4899 6 років тому +12

    I have almost tears in my eyes. Listen to The Mal, The Rudd and The Cliff working together ! That Ladies and Gentlemen was the true sound of AC/DC !!

  • @michaelm5285
    @michaelm5285 6 днів тому

    What a monster phils the man no one gets close

  • @lateramae
    @lateramae 4 роки тому +7

    As soon as you hear that hi-hat, you know thatʻs Phil Rudd! I love how the drums can really make a difference in a song, especially how "Who Made Who" sounded with Simon!

  • @bluegrassboy2448
    @bluegrassboy2448 14 років тому +21

    Wish they played more jewels like this..Phil's drumming would make it sound alot better.

  • @Bluesr0cker
    @Bluesr0cker 9 років тому +32

    I have to say this song is made for rudd no matter how you may like/dislike him

  • @Eisbaermusik
    @Eisbaermusik Рік тому +2

    I Love that Song!!! That was the first i ever heard of AC/DC when the Stephen King Movie Maximum Overdrive came out back in the day. I was a kid and blown away. I got the same feeling by listening to that song. I got old. But that song not. AC/DC was the reason why i learned playin`guitar. Great!!!! Best Band ever!!!

  • @MrSG61
    @MrSG61 12 років тому +6

    its so sad that songs like this arent played live now, these are jewels

  • @maxti6
    @maxti6 11 років тому +26

    Phil had a way with the drumming that spoke a language that unless you knew that 'voice' the song never sounded right. It was almost like he was singing through his sticks

    • @meanstreak-1017
      @meanstreak-1017 7 років тому +5

      maxti6 Yes , Phil is the best drummer for AC/DC...forget Simon Wright and Chris Slade. Phil drumming style is the AC/DC style

  • @polsterj
    @polsterj 11 років тому +11

    Gosh, that grooves!
    Phil is the man!

  • @runed8635
    @runed8635 6 років тому +10

    Phil is a machine

  • @MrTurbododge
    @MrTurbododge 13 років тому +2

    Phil Rudd is the machine. Period.

  • @GGBundy
    @GGBundy 12 років тому +6

    Simple and powerful!! The coolest of the cool!

  • @them3ssageman748
    @them3ssageman748 6 років тому +8

    Damn I wish there was some footage to go with this, sounds amazing!

  • @andreiwayneandrewbrucewayn3421
    @andreiwayneandrewbrucewayn3421 6 років тому +2

    I love this live version,Phill is my favorite AC/DC drummer! But all the respects for Simon and Chris!

  • @stratman1967
    @stratman1967 13 років тому +3

    Phil Rudd is a human metronome!

  • @Nacnueed
    @Nacnueed 13 років тому +24

    How does he get that balanced, deep drum sound?? Even with this dodgy recording you can here the whole kit poundin through! He's just brilliant lol

    • @averycamden4730
      @averycamden4730 3 роки тому +1

      He beats the hell out of it. You hear it shaken because it is.

  • @deanm1681
    @deanm1681 3 роки тому +1

    Phil can play anything, e is a machine. Dean AUstralia

  • @Daveyboy10053
    @Daveyboy10053 4 роки тому +1

    this is one of their best songs!

  • @NC4MP
    @NC4MP 10 років тому +1

    I was at that show as well Charlotte, North Carolina! It was my first AC/DC show ever! Ill never forget it! Ive seen them twice since then. Better and better every time!

  • @thekid9152
    @thekid9152 11 років тому +6

    I would have given anything to see Phil play the 1986 version on a filmed concert

  • @tfs4499
    @tfs4499 5 років тому

    Phil has always been solid, spot on, and the back bone of AC⚡️DC; the structure that the whole thing is built around.

  • @ACDCdude200
    @ACDCdude200 12 років тому +15

    You can tell all 3 main drummers apart because they all have different styles. You can tell:
    Phil because of the regular use of symbols and hi hats.
    Simon because of his regular use of the bass drum
    Chris because of the almost frenzied style of playing! (Also the hair do :D)

    • @theseagullthatcould5698
      @theseagullthatcould5698 Рік тому +2

      not rly
      the main difference is the hi-hat.
      Simon and chris, dont groove, every hi-hat hit sounds the same,
      The difference between chris and simon is that Simon bounces more with it if that makes sense
      Phil accents all 4 notes differently to give it more groove and it rlly just gives it that ACDC sound
      Simon & Chris - Dadadada
      Phil - DuduDada
      (Hihat sounds lol

  • @daleroberson6605
    @daleroberson6605 Рік тому +1

    You could tell it's phil playing drums on this

  • @jackmomma7481
    @jackmomma7481 4 роки тому

    Pretty remarkable to hear how much this song improved just having Phil Rudd on the kit... HUGE difference. One that makes this spng sound like it's from the 1980 - 1981 AC⚡DC era

  • @SuperStrik9
    @SuperStrik9 7 років тому +1

    Saw AC/DC on this tour.

  • @micaeltrainguyhayes7338
    @micaeltrainguyhayes7338 8 років тому +5

    should acdc sing songs like flick of the switch and ballbreaker later this year

  • @drumbugproductions
    @drumbugproductions 13 років тому +2

    oh ye.. thats a groove.. listen to that snare growl...

  • @nitroangus23
    @nitroangus23 14 років тому

    Cool.

  • @MarkanVaran7
    @MarkanVaran7 2 роки тому

    26 years ago today

  • @marksman444
    @marksman444 14 років тому +1

    i noticed in the first verse angus plays reversed riffs he does the deeper riff then the medium then the high one then back down usualy its the other way around.

  • @addman34555
    @addman34555  12 років тому

    @thunderhayes dude that would be so sick, i wish they could rerecord that album and the razors edge with rudd on the drums

  • @marksman444
    @marksman444 14 років тому +2

    this is at 0:47 he plays the low riff first then the high one. just something different i noticed.

  • @addman34555
    @addman34555  14 років тому

    @nitroangus23 i read it on wikipedia and some other site a wile back

  • @Turk_2023
    @Turk_2023 6 років тому +2

    Brian sang it good, wonder why they nixed it from the tour?

    • @talenmcgraw6102
      @talenmcgraw6102 4 роки тому +1

      Supposedly Brian could not get enough breathing in through out the song

  • @nickslade3978
    @nickslade3978 2 місяці тому

    I dearly wish they’d played this just one more time for the No Bull show 🏟️🚫🐂

  • @mysticmac2025
    @mysticmac2025 6 років тому

    Can take any song from Simon wright or Chris slade era an Rudd kills it! No better drummer!!

  • @addman34555
    @addman34555  14 років тому

    @Big85Jack yeah it does

  • @freepressright
    @freepressright 10 років тому +2

    Wow, is that use of the ride cymbal I hear? Rudd hasn't used a ride cymbal since the few tracks on Dirty Deeds that included it.

    • @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd
      @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd 10 років тому +2

      no :P phil doesn't even have a ride cymbal on his kit :)

    • @freepressright
      @freepressright 10 років тому

      Then he's riding on a crash cymbal, because clearly in the chorus of this song, a cymbal is being ridden.

    • @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd
      @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd 10 років тому +1

      freepressright trust me, it's just hi-hat ;)

    • @ImperialRadioYT
      @ImperialRadioYT 9 років тому

      Andy Diaz Isn't it? It's just a hi-hat right, never anything else?

    • @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd
      @ACDCKISSCCRSkynyrd 9 років тому +5

      it's phil, it's half-open hi-hat, nothing else :)

  • @keefriff99
    @keefriff99 6 років тому +10

    That inimitable Rudd groove...its ALL in the hi hat. Chris Slade, while he has great chops, played way too stiff for AC/DC...his hi hat was always too choked off, while Phil has that great up-down washy hi hat feel.

    • @danielpetrucci8952
      @danielpetrucci8952 2 роки тому

      Phill has a accent ghost note with the tip of his drumstick on the high hat witch give its that nice tamber

    • @theseagullthatcould5698
      @theseagullthatcould5698 Рік тому

      du du da da
      on the hihat thats phil's signature shit there

  • @NoBullBand
    @NoBullBand 7 років тому +1

    You can tell its Phil straight away because the hi hat is more open instead of Simon and Chris would of played it closed

  • @Gbhbbgvsbnjhhdchhb
    @Gbhbbgvsbnjhhdchhb 2 роки тому

    The spice is back in the AC/DC pizza…

  • @jakub03021980
    @jakub03021980 7 років тому +7

    Simon did a better drum roll at the end of the song.

  • @maxti6
    @maxti6 14 років тому +4

    This song was actually written and rehearsed before Rudd left in '83 but never used. When it was used in 1986 they redid it entirely with Simon Wright.
    I read this somewhere but can't remember where, just that it was around but never finished.

  • @blackandwhitecat69
    @blackandwhitecat69 6 років тому +15

    No Phil Rudd no AC/DC!!!

    • @drm2566
      @drm2566 6 років тому

      Dejan V. Totally agree, Phil locks them into a perfect grove

    • @blackandwhitecat69
      @blackandwhitecat69 6 років тому

      True story :)

  • @rainbow8522
    @rainbow8522 3 роки тому

    No se pero cuando phil toca la bateria con ac/dc es otra cosa y se le llama "P E R F E C T S I O N"

  • @bryanriffrock1100
    @bryanriffrock1100 3 роки тому

    BALOURD. it's Simon

  • @nitroangus23
    @nitroangus23 14 років тому

    Hmmm,never heard that one before.
    It's entirely possible,I'd like to know where you read it.

  • @ACDCLIVE11
    @ACDCLIVE11 12 років тому +1

    it only might be rare in its a one off

  • @addman34555
    @addman34555  12 років тому

    @MrSG61 it is

  • @FranLevitzky
    @FranLevitzky 13 років тому

    @Big85Jack it relly does! he's the GROOVE

  • @ACDCdude200
    @ACDCdude200 12 років тому

    Yeah, these guys should defo re record those albums it would sound awesome lol!
    But would they manage to get into the charts, what with all the crap that's in them all ready?

  • @nachito3213
    @nachito3213 3 роки тому +1

    I prefer the versión whit Chris Slade that's si epic

  • @rohnakp2396
    @rohnakp2396 2 роки тому

    Phil is excellent! But the ride cymbal in the chorus is missed🥲

  • @kenianpark2216
    @kenianpark2216 7 років тому +3

    Why do people criticise Chris Slade? He was an excellent musician and drummer for AC/DC, miles better than Simon Wright.

  • @sjcsiba
    @sjcsiba 12 років тому

    You mean the live versions right? Because the album was recorded with Simon.

  • @lancasterquo3741
    @lancasterquo3741 8 років тому +2

    my fav drummer phil rudd ,,but i will say this chris slade is damm good as well ,,,,i think slade its the drums harder,,but i like phil

  • @gonzosud3732
    @gonzosud3732 6 років тому

    phil eats peanut butter in the bathroom

  • @arielhpaiz
    @arielhpaiz 7 років тому +2

    Malisimo, le gana la fatiga a Phill...Hay partes que hay que tocar la campanita y al final van unos redobles de tambores y Phil no hizo nada de eso, demasiado monotono, por no decir amarrete o basico 😪

  • @layman1194
    @layman1194 8 років тому +11

    CHRIS SLADE does the best live version of this...

    • @airbournefreak9722
      @airbournefreak9722 8 років тому +7

      anthony lay Phil Is The Drummer!

    • @layman1194
      @layman1194 8 років тому

      this is not the version i'm talking about....phil sucks

    • @airbournefreak9722
      @airbournefreak9722 8 років тому +4

      anthony lay You Are Stupid

    • @robinm1211
      @robinm1211 7 років тому +9

      if you dislike Phil, you dislike classic ACDC. I personally like all drummers ACDC has had over the years. Phis is definetly my favorite though.

    • @layman1194
      @layman1194 7 років тому

      I'M FOR SLADE

  • @ACDCLIVE11
    @ACDCLIVE11 12 років тому

    this ain't rare its been so circulated so much

  • @ACDCLIVE11
    @ACDCLIVE11 12 років тому

    give me chris slade anyday

  • @Elvis-55
    @Elvis-55 5 років тому

    simon Wright is better sorry phil