This is will be the most heartfelt chinese song ever, the crowd are fantastic helping shirley to carry on with the song .Brilliant song, brilliant singer and one of the greatest chinese songs ever!!! well done Shirley!
I was read about this song & about her love. It was strange but also touch!! Her life & love was like a coming from story book This is one of best song ever by her!! She must remind about her love, her youngful, her moments when she was youngful & sing this song fitst time it make her famous & this song was so popular, it was a part of her life & her love though that make she cant stop holding her tears. I can understand it SHE MAKE ME CRYING TOO 😭 😭 😭 What a beautiful song, so meaningful & so touching!! She have beautiful & she’s beautiful women with beautiful voice 💖 💖 💖
Hôm qua tôi được xem 1 đoạn ngắn của video này và thực sự thấy xúc động. Sau đó tôi đã tìm hiểu về Quan Thục Di và lời bài hát. Thật là một câu chuyện buồn và đáng tiếc. Cảm ơn bạn đã đăng tải video đầy đủ này.
Btw, love when the whole crowd singing along with her to help her & cheering for her 😍 😍 😍 ONE OF BEST CHINESE SONG EVER 👍🏻 👍🏻 👍🏻 (Im not Chinese though)
and i would like to add this is probably the most romantic song ever to come from one of HKs most famous and beautiful singers of all time ....... Doesn't matter what life throws you , You are who you are and don't let anyone tell you different. You are my favourite and best singer of all time ...... Hopefully you will make a comeback sometime .... We all admire you Shirley!
yes, that's what's available in youtube right now, in HD...maybe the copyright holder prefer that version. i personally really like this one, very touching. (couple of years ago, there was an HD version of this one as well, it'd removed now :(
Ivan Gan I was reading about this song & about her love. It was strange but also touch. Her life & love was like a coming from story book This is one of best song ever by her!! She must remind about her love, her youngful, her moments when she was youngful & sing this song fitst time it make her famous & this song was so popular, it was a part of her life & her love though SHE MAKE ME CRYING TOO 😭 😭 😭 What a beautiful song, so meaningful & so touching!! She have beautiful & she’s beautiful women with beautiful voice 💖 💖 💖
😒 Lol, on Syed Syed comment! It's a very touching song and she must have had a lot of heart breaking memories of the past. People say she was very upset when her mother died and still can't get over it, but who knows!
![关淑怡 - 《难得有情人》 (国) [歌词] 『最难得有情人 曾经出现在我身边 爱过你 不枉今生』~ 梁静茹 - 《爱久见人心》 [歌词] ll Chinese - Lyrics](/img/n.gif)
这首歌只有关淑怡能唱出甜蜜爱情的感觉，听着听着不自觉的流出了眼泪。好像又回到了学生时代，和初恋在一起的时候。感谢关淑怡，她是一位优秀的好歌手！
这首歌80年代尾横空出世的时候，第一次听就非常喜欢了，30多年过去，照样很喜欢，她唱出了恋爱甜甜的感觉，值得永远听下去
听着听着留下眼泪~致敬逝去的青春😭😭😭
关淑怡的唱功已经达到了一流的水准，很接近超好的水准，她唱歌咬字的技巧做的很圆满，她咬字很清楚，很准确，很正确，很圆融，她咬字是用口型的技巧来唱出每一粒字出来，这个口型的技巧，很少歌手会用，就算会用，也不会去用它，以为这个技巧不重要的，已经过时了，其实这个是大错特错，它是咬字清不清楚，正不正确的关键所在，她唱歌是 100% 投入的，她的歌唱技巧是一流的，她的感情发挥做到了 100 %圆满，而且很自然，她是真感情，是从内心抒发出来的，不是用歌唱技巧装出来的，她的她的韵味也是 100% 圆满的，她每一首歌都可以唱出它的感情，韵味，味道，意境出来，她的收放自如这技巧也做到很圆满，她最擅长的技巧是抒发歌曲，其实歌曲不是拿来唱的，它是拿来抒发的，抒发歌曲是唱歌给人感觉要唱不唱的样子，轻轻把歌曲的感情和韵味从心里抒发出来，所以唱歌不是大大声，用尽力去唱，那是错误的，只有歌手达到很高的境界才会抒发歌曲的，而这个技巧，关淑怡做到了很圆满的水准， 她最擅长的地方就是抒发歌曲这个技巧，她这个技巧比很多女歌手好，你注意她唱歌，好像要唱不唱的样子，轻轻的歌曲抒发出来，这个是达到了很高的境界，她也 100% 会用正确的发声位置来呈现歌曲，其实，一个人的声音美和丑不一定是天生的，天生的声音只占 20% 而已，另外 80% 是那个人会不会用正确的发声位置来唱歌或讲话，所以会不会用正确的发声位置，其实是一种学问，而这个技巧常常会被人忽略掉，甚至歌唱评判员也很少去讨论这个技巧，歌唱评判员最多会讲唱歌一定要有感情，咬字要清楚，等等，很少去讨论这个发声位置的技巧，以为这个是不重要的，其实这个技巧是很重要的，这个是唱歌和声音好不好听的关键所在，如果一个歌手唱歌很投入，咬字很清楚，很懂得歌唱技巧，很有感情，样样都好，他就是不会用正确的发声位置或用错的发声位置，哪他唱歌不会好听到那里去，总觉得这个人唱歌怪怪的，又找不到他唱歌到底那里不好，不会用正确的发声位置或用错的发声位置是好比一辆火车根本都不在它的轨迹上，我打个比喻，如果一个人，他的声音天生很美，但是他不会用正确的发声位置或用错的发声位置，他的声音也不美，不好听的，因为天生的声音只有 20% 而已，反过来如果一个人天生的的声音是不美的，但是他会用正确的发声位置，他的声音也会变得很美，很好听，因为发声位置是占 80%，正确的发声位置是眉间发声位置(以上)，眉间是指两条眉毛的中间，正好印堂那个位置，这个发声位置是最美的，意思说只要你会用这个位置来唱歌或讲话，不管你是不是歌手，你的声音也会很美，很好听的，眉间发声位置(以上)，那个(以上)是指头音或脑音，它是拿来飙高音的，在这个方面，关淑怡做到100%，她唱歌是很有内涵，现在要讨论她的嗓子，声音，关淑怡的声音很特别，很吸引，很成熟，很有女人味，很好听，很耐听，很温柔，很动听，很有气质，很独特，很有质素，很甜蜜，很性感，很有内涵，很浪漫，很有性格，很有磁性，很干净，很清雅，很圆滑，声音干净，清雅，圆滑是讲他天生的音质，而关淑怡的音质是圆满的，意思说她的声音是 100% 干净，一粒尘埃也找不到，100% 圆滑，圆是将他的声音和他的咬字很圆，很饱满，滑溜是讲他的声音好像铺上一层油这样的，滑滑的，一点沙哑的声音也没有，100% 清雅，他的声音一点都不会浑浊，好像一杯清清的白开水这样的，真的很难很难找到这样的一个歌手，不管是男或女歌手，是老一代的歌手或现代的歌手，是音质 100% 圆满的，加上发声位置也达到 100%，真的少之又少，就算是全世界的歌手，也没有几个可以达到这样的条件 所以关淑怡其实不是一个普通的歌手，而是一个很有质素和拥有很高天分的奇才歌后，她的声音最大的特点就是她的声音真的很性感
她的歌，让我感觉到，我们是活生生的人，有血有肉有情感的高级生物！也许在舞台上落泪显得不专业，但是，关小姐除外！难得有情人，她是在用心歌唱！超级喜欢她，自从听了她的歌，爱的不行！永远支持你！
关小姐的声音，美貌，舞台气质，具惊为天人！
沒有人比Shirley可以將這首歌演繹得更好。這首歌永遠屬於Shirley。非常喜歡這首經典中的經典歌❤️。
不要感到孤獨，妳還有好多，好多我們這班歌迷的，加油！
情路不順，真讓人不捨
沒有人比她能讓入人心❤！
I'am vietnamese but i love her singing voice. Great!
关淑怡是一个非常好👍🏻的一个歌手我幸亲我是和她同一个年代的👍🏻👍🏻🥰🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️❤️
至少她的歌聲裡感受到真心。我喜歡
至少她的歌聲裡感受到真心。我喜歡
This is will be the most heartfelt chinese song ever, the crowd are fantastic helping shirley to carry on with the song .Brilliant song, brilliant singer and one of the greatest chinese songs ever!!! well done Shirley!
I was read about this song & about her love. It was strange but also touch!!
Her life & love was like a coming from story book
This is one of best song ever by her!! She must remind about her love, her youngful, her moments when she was youngful & sing this song fitst time it make her famous & this song was so popular, it was a part of her life & her love though that make she cant stop holding her tears. I can understand it
SHE MAKE ME CRYING TOO 😭 😭 😭
What a beautiful song, so meaningful & so touching!! She have beautiful & she’s beautiful women with beautiful voice 💖 💖 💖
Bài này mình nghe lâu rồi, nhờ tik tok mà mình mới nhớ, thấy thương c này quá
香港的歌坛影坛从此没落，怀念
好多外國欣賞者留言、
只能証明好的歌聲是能傳遞千里的!
真與假
其實也不用刻意去証明和爭辯
在我心中
香港只有一個歌姬
Shirley kwan
Hôm qua tôi được xem 1 đoạn ngắn của video này và thực sự thấy xúc động. Sau đó tôi đã tìm hiểu về Quan Thục Di và lời bài hát. Thật là một câu chuyện buồn và đáng tiếc.
Cảm ơn bạn đã đăng tải video đầy đủ này.
Bài hát nầy nghè hòaì o cháng tồi rất thít
Tôi yêu cô ấy. Tôi ko quan tâm đời tư cô ấy, có lẽ đây là bài hát lãng mạn nhất mà tôi đã từng nghe
Người phụ nữ bất kể đúng sai phải trái thế nào thì cũng là số phận nhận lấy đau khổ bất hạnh. Thương cảm xúc động gửi về QTD !!!
重聽仍然振盪內心美好回憶。
Btw, love when the whole crowd singing along with her to help her & cheering for her 😍 😍 😍
ONE OF BEST CHINESE SONG EVER 👍🏻 👍🏻 👍🏻
(Im not Chinese though)
香江好聲音 受人愛戴 我願意 2023
可爱的香港歌迷
關淑怡妳好棒的，真的。
關淑怡妳好棒的，真的
唱功固然勁、作曲填詞其實也好到不得了👍🏻
and i would like to add this is probably the most romantic song ever to come from one of HKs most famous and beautiful singers of all time ....... Doesn't matter what life throws you , You are who you are and don't let anyone tell you different. You are my favourite and best singer of all time ...... Hopefully you will make a comeback sometime .... We all admire you Shirley!
這首歌很動聽，我還滿喜歡聽關淑怡小姐唱得歌，不管是國語還是奧語我都喜歡：）
Shirley, you are beautiful, stay well and healthy. Thank you for giving us your songs bringing unforgettable memories♡
I miss my ex boyfriend so much when I hear this song
she is awesome. good voice.
这才是真正实力派。
也看哭了我。好真，堅強！
Thương chị ❤️❤️❤️
她哭得我也哭了。 我的生活就像一部悲伤的电影。
關姐，永遠支持你
A very touching song , good singer , good song forever .
Đau tận trong tim, nước mắt tràn ra từ tim, cảm giác đau không diển tả đc
❤️ I can almost touch her and feel those tears.. very deep
佢喊果陣d歌迷幫佢唱落去果下好touch，好正!!!
关妹 这把声好好听
관숙누님 이렇게 좋은 노래가 있었는지 몰랐어요~~~
睇到好心痛！
Super love this song.
Very good song...❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
非常感动。谢谢
超喜愛她
感人
唱功了得，好好聽👍
she is superb singer
+1
好聽……好有感觸…..謝謝分享
touching performance!
Very touching😘😘😘
I like this song very much.
women power💪💪☝️☝️👍and fans support 👍💪☝️
Shirley 無得頂！
Dont cry anymore plsss ❤️
Giọng hát quyến rũ..
另一版本唱副歌讓台下歌迷唱，這歌是他們的歲月，唱的是懷念，卻也帶著感傷，回不去的時光，陪伴一世的歌
yes, that's what's available in youtube right now, in HD...maybe the copyright holder prefer that version. i personally really like this one, very touching. (couple of years ago, there was an HD version of this one as well, it'd removed now :(
very touching
❤❤❤❤❤
動人
Cool... Sweet
good song
20210311 love song love SK
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻2022-424在聽
讚_＋讚＝曾經過的人,,唱出更美妙@
正翻海洋了！
I don't understand, but I like the song
只属于关淑怡的歌！
She remember of something. Make her cry
Ivan Gan
I was reading about this song & about her love. It was strange but also touch. Her life & love was like a coming from story book
This is one of best song ever by her!! She must remind about her love, her youngful, her moments when she was youngful & sing this song fitst time it make her famous & this song was so popular, it was a part of her life & her love though
SHE MAKE ME CRYING TOO 😭 😭 😭
What a beautiful song, so meaningful & so touching!! She have beautiful & she’s beautiful women with beautiful voice 💖 💖 💖
👏👏👏👍👍👍🎉🎉🎉💖💖💖
可惜已惜影，真希望她能出來再唱歌！
❤👍
❤️
TO CHOOI❤❤❤
Quá hay
한국에살고있는이장권입니다.힘내시고화이팅
歌未唱,旋律🎶享出已很動人
可惜了……好迷人的声线！
🎤👏🎉🎊💪👍👩👧
比以前更為精練
touching
我一路上鄀明白你的暗示，你確實難能可貴。我的真心說話。
画上袅丝丝美敢
連講話都好聽 妳一定要好好振作起來
sangat sangat
我都同佢一齊唱一齊喊
My song eva don't say so much
真正的有情人，維有在你最後一口氣仍望著你不会宛惜的人，只有他知道是該走的時候
lursum Chen
lursum Chen
lursum Chen
2006/////
何故泣いているのか誰か教えて下さい 中国語わからないので
We Belong
Lyricist: the snow pregnant Composer: Tony Lu
Song: Shirley
她為什麼哭？
@TT Tse 我還是天天在她的歌
Can anyone tell me why did she cry, please? Thank so much.
Ha Huy Hai because she accidentally shit in her pant
😒 Lol, on Syed Syed comment! It's a very touching song and she must have had a lot of heart breaking memories of the past. People say she was very upset when her mother died and still can't get over it, but who knows!
@@MrHappyNappy just joking my friend this is 1 of my fav hits song in my list the meaning is so touching.. and sad also.
@TT Tse 你說真的嗎？她應該是被歌迷們感動
@TT Tse 愛錯了人，誤一生
Nice songs nice voice but doesnt look like a star
What does a star look like?
She is a Hongkong diva :)
Touching