Frank can hardly even sing this, he's out of tune, shouting, but it just makes it all the honest and real. So emotional. Breaks my heart every time I watch it.
He’s literally singing Scott back into existence and screaming I’m Not Dead. Fucking hell man, that’s one powerful performance. Love them both so much 🖤
@@alexandersudheim1699 biffy are also well attached to FR. SN talks so highly of FR so not sure i get where you are coming from with the hate. I do agree FT should have been on the record
@@christopherallen4827 ikr, the "self-absorbed histrionics" is how you described 1975, not biffy ffs. clearly you have no idea how huge their impact has on rock scene. punk genre, mathrock, pop, industrial, metal. basically... you can find each of these genres in almost all of their songs. the fact that you went with self-absorb histrionics ironic cuz ... y r u making this unnecessary yelling and overdone gesture for? @Alexander Sudheim
@@alexandersudheim1699 the "self-absorbed histrionics" is how you described 1975, not biffy ffs. clearly you have no idea how huge their impact has on rock scene. punk genre, mathrock, pop, industrial, metal. basically... you can find each of these genres in almost all of their songs. the fact that you went with self-absorb histrionics ironic cuz ... y r u making this unnecessary yelling and overdone gesture for?
I've had a rough 2020, and I'm sure many people have. I found Frank Turner back in April, and was instantly hooked. I found Frightened Rabbit in July, and was instantly saddened by the history. This video quickly became my favorite live performance by anyone. It is so emotional, so raw, so real. It's a man singing his friend's song while still in shock that his friend cannot sing it with him ever again. I have no idea how FT made it to the end of this song.
It would have been Scott's 40th birthday today. It's been 3 and half years since the one time i watched this video, left a comment and balled my eyes out, revisisted for the first time today.... saw so many likes and just thought wow, there will never be another like him. Utter genius. Still unsure how Frank got through this that night
@@boarderjm when people ask me about my favourite records, I always mention the midnight organ fight, the amount of comfort that record has brought me over the past few years (especially the past few months) in indescribable. I have make tiny changes tattooed on thigh, that’s all we can expect to make
I am ill but I’m not dead, and I don’t know which of those I’d prefer. Imagine singing that line the day you found out your friend is dead from suicide. Absolutely amazing of FT to perform such an emotional tribute so soon after Scott’s passing.
wow i wish i was there to feel the love for scott, live. but i can feel frank and comments like these make it close enough. my heart will always ache for scott and his family, friends, and fans.
oh christ, its watching a heart breaking on stage. Frank is so raw and upfront with is emotions and yet able to not break down completely. Seeing him sing it, broke me and I only discovered Scott today
Chris Pepper im glad u discovered him. frank was so right in that we need to just continue to let everyone know how great he was by carrying on his music.
8 months in and it’s still no easier. I don’t think a single singer/actor/writer etc has ever affected me in the way Scott did with his passing. I think of him almost every week; I think of how I’ll never see him live again, how I’ll never hear his heart poured out over the strings of his ratty old acoustic. I think about his family, and his friends, and Frank.. it’s enough to bring a man to tears.
damn. I found this video 3 weeks ago. I didn‘t know anything about Scott. 3 weeks of frightened rabbit later and I am impressed that Frank could sing one note of this Song. I couldn‘t. R.I.P. Scott FCK Depression
We were on holiday in London and went to this gig. I didn't know about Scott's passing until Frank played this song and it broke my heart. One of my favourite writers ever, I hope he found peace.
„I am ill but i‘m nur dead“ is one of the grearest lyriks of all time. Please please Talkt to someone. Please. Talk to 911 or if you don‘t want to spake, just Tell anybody.
I started listening to FR when Scott had already left us. And just watched this video for the first time. Jesus. I've cried many tears for Scott, and these were the quickest to start. Amazing moment, thankful it was captured, to share the depth of the loss that many have felt, just knowing Scott is gone. But. What Frank said is really everything. Keep playing the music and letting everyone know how fucking amazing Scott was. ❤ It was a good cry, thanks Frank.
I saw the headline accidentally while I was out a few days ago when I glanced down at the articles on the new tab page of my chrome app, which I never do. I was already feeling really low and I couldn't even process how sad this made me. His music meant more than a great deal to me. I've been too scared to even listen to his music since, even though I love it, even though I badly needed to. When I saw this video, I knew I just had to take that plunge. Frank's words were exactly what I needed to hear right now. Watching this really helped me heal a little bit, or at least helped give me that small push to start moving forward again.
Anisia Villamejor I feel ya. Frabbit came into my life when I was in some dark teenage days and I was a heavy listener for years, faded away from listening to music all together after becoming depressed again. The news of Scott brought me back to listening to the entirety of the band. I even bought a book he illustrated for. His voice and lyrics bring new meaning. I am in a good place right now but I couldn’t tell him thank you enough for what he did. And continues to do through his music. I hope where ever he is now he FINALLY know how loved he was and missed he is. 🤘🏼🐇
Oh wow, I looked into the book you mentioned and it's beautiful. And truly, Scott's work will never stop being important to me. His words got me through so much and I still fall back on them when things get hard.
Having met Scott several times (Including talking about life and stuff and sharing a drink or more at Electric Fields festival) this is a great tribute to an unbelievable person who is sadly missed. Scott lives on through his music and all those who perform it.
It's so hard for me to watch, but this is one of the most loving, touching tributes I've seen. After watching the video with the two of them together, seeing this one just with Frank Turner... it hurts so much. Especially when he reaches the line "I am ill, but I'm not dead" and he nearly breaks. But so much love is here, I can't help but love this so, so much.
thank you for recording this and making it available for us all as we grieve. watching Frank give this insanely powerful and emotional tribute is so hard and so lovely.
i think >10 years of struggling is long enough... can't have asked for much more than that. i will always miss him as if he was a best friend but my heart only hurts because of the fact that he went on hurting for so long...
9 months late to this but I remember the day it was reported Scott went missing and I remember so clearly the day I read he had been found, heart broke that day. Hearing this I can hear the pain and cracks in his voice during this performance that we all felt that same day.
I know this is years after you commented, but I think at this point (before meeting his wife) Frank was almost entirely driven by the idea that playing live shows could cheer people up for a few hours, I think letting down his paying audience would've been unimaginable for him. A similar thing is Weird Al Yankovic, who played a gig hours after finding out both his parents had died at the same time. Top performer's brains are not wired the same as you or I.
![Ham Sandwich - Good Arms Vs Bad Arms [Frightened Rabbit Cover]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QbXXSdXrqvI/mqdefault.jpg)
![Ham Sandwich - Good Arms Vs Bad Arms [Frightened Rabbit Cover]](/img/tr.png)
Frank can hardly even sing this, he's out of tune, shouting, but it just makes it all the honest and real. So emotional. Breaks my heart every time I watch it.
“Scott decided to go away from us” Still heartbroken. 😢😢😢😢
I keep returning to this every so often, one of the most powerful performances ever
Me too pal
Seeing Frank struggle to sing “I am ill, but I’m not dead” breaks my fucking heart. This is such a hard song to listen to now.
That moment right there, that's the whole performance in a breath. I hope anyone that misses it goes back and pays attention.
He’s literally singing Scott back into existence and screaming I’m Not Dead. Fucking hell man, that’s one powerful performance. Love them both so much 🖤
The fact Frank didn't end up on Tiny Changes is a straight-up crime
An excellent point. This beats Biffy Clyro's self-absorbed histrionics hands down.
It is my understanding that Tiny Changes was created before Scott's passing.
@@alexandersudheim1699 biffy are also well attached to FR. SN talks so highly of FR so not sure i get where you are coming from with the hate. I do agree FT should have been on the record
@@christopherallen4827 ikr, the "self-absorbed histrionics" is how you described 1975, not biffy ffs. clearly you have no idea how huge their impact has on rock scene. punk genre, mathrock, pop, industrial, metal. basically... you can find each of these genres in almost all of their songs. the fact that you went with self-absorb histrionics ironic cuz ... y r u making this unnecessary yelling and overdone gesture for? @Alexander Sudheim
@@alexandersudheim1699 the "self-absorbed histrionics" is how you described 1975, not biffy ffs. clearly you have no idea how huge their impact has on rock scene. punk genre, mathrock, pop, industrial, metal. basically... you can find each of these genres in almost all of their songs. the fact that you went with self-absorb histrionics ironic cuz ... y r u making this unnecessary yelling and overdone gesture for?
I've had a rough 2020, and I'm sure many people have. I found Frank Turner back in April, and was instantly hooked. I found Frightened Rabbit in July, and was instantly saddened by the history. This video quickly became my favorite live performance by anyone. It is so emotional, so raw, so real. It's a man singing his friend's song while still in shock that his friend cannot sing it with him ever again.
I have no idea how FT made it to the end of this song.
You’ve made great decisions when you started listening to Frank Turner and Frightened Rabbit. I hope you’re doing well now buddy :)
Hope you’re well, bud. Welcome to the family.
im still here... probably the 80th time ive heard this but god damnit
God damnit
Must have taken a lot to have been able to play this so soon after his passing. Parts of that broke me
It would have been Scott's 40th birthday today. It's been 3 and half years since the one time i watched this video, left a comment and balled my eyes out, revisisted for the first time today.... saw so many likes and just thought wow, there will never be another like him. Utter genius. Still unsure how Frank got through this that night
It's our duty to keep Scott's voice alive - hard as it can be.
@@boarderjm when people ask me about my favourite records, I always mention the midnight organ fight, the amount of comfort that record has brought me over the past few years (especially the past few months) in indescribable. I have make tiny changes tattooed on thigh, that’s all we can expect to make
I am ill but I’m not dead, and I don’t know which of those I’d prefer.
Imagine singing that line the day you found out your friend is dead from suicide. Absolutely amazing of FT to perform such an emotional tribute so soon after Scott’s passing.
It's taken until now to go back to watch this. I was in the crowd crying my eyes out with friends.
Same. So fn powerful live... and now all over again.
wow i wish i was there to feel the love for scott, live. but i can feel frank and comments like these make it close enough. my heart will always ache for scott and his family, friends, and fans.
Cheers Frank I'm crying again
oh christ, its watching a heart breaking on stage. Frank is so raw and upfront with is emotions and yet able to not break down completely. Seeing him sing it, broke me and I only discovered Scott today
Chris Pepper im glad u discovered him. frank was so right in that we need to just continue to let everyone know how great he was by carrying on his music.
It made me so sad to see how close he was to tears and how many times he almost choked up. We all love you Scott! The world is worse without you.
you can tell he's hurt while he's singing. the pain is real and it's raw. RIP Scott
8 months in and it’s still no easier. I don’t think a single singer/actor/writer etc has ever affected me in the way Scott did with his passing. I think of him almost every week; I think of how I’ll never see him live again, how I’ll never hear his heart poured out over the strings of his ratty old acoustic. I think about his family, and his friends, and Frank.. it’s enough to bring a man to tears.
damn. I found this video 3 weeks ago. I didn‘t know anything about Scott. 3 weeks of frightened rabbit later and I am impressed that Frank could sing one note of this Song. I couldn‘t.
R.I.P. Scott
FCK Depression
I've watched this so many times, can't imagine what Frank was feeling as he was singing this. This is so powerful.
What a perfect tribute to Scott. Remember him always. Sing his songs. Introduce others to his songs. And, be there for anyone in crisis. Just listen.
Coming back to this after hearing A Wave Across A Bay for the first time. We miss you, Scott
Breaks my heart. Can't believe this was the evening after it happened. Beautiful tribute.
Keep Scott's voice alive always
Don't know how he kept it together. That's a beautiful tribute.
I was standing right in the front, sobbing my heart out. This was so hard,... So beautiful but so hard.
Scott, you're missed....
We were on holiday in London and went to this gig. I didn't know about Scott's passing until Frank played this song and it broke my heart. One of my favourite writers ever, I hope he found peace.
It seems like he was shouting harder to prevent himself from crying. This was a powerful tribute.
The emotion in his voice breaks me every time
Big respect to you Frank
Love this version...so much emotion. thank you Frank Turner and thank you Scott Hutchison
Thank you so much for this, Frank.
All love to Frank- So sorry for his loss. We are here with him. Let's keep Scott's fucking songs going.
„I am ill but i‘m nur dead“ is one of the grearest lyriks of all time. Please please Talkt to someone. Please. Talk to 911 or if you don‘t want to spake, just Tell anybody.
MAD RESPECT FRANK that looked like it was really hard for him
My heart hurts. A fitting tribute and good on ya Frank. This shows the character you possess.
I started listening to FR when Scott had already left us. And just watched this video for the first time. Jesus. I've cried many tears for Scott, and these were the quickest to start. Amazing moment, thankful it was captured, to share the depth of the loss that many have felt, just knowing Scott is gone. But. What Frank said is really everything. Keep playing the music and letting everyone know how fucking amazing Scott was. ❤ It was a good cry, thanks Frank.
In tears, listened to this many times now. Thank you.
Frank played this for us in Glasgow and it was glorious but Head Rolls Off in Dumfries was just magnificent. This is how we remember
I saw the headline accidentally while I was out a few days ago when I glanced down at the articles on the new tab page of my chrome app, which I never do. I was already feeling really low and I couldn't even process how sad this made me. His music meant more than a great deal to me. I've been too scared to even listen to his music since, even though I love it, even though I badly needed to. When I saw this video, I knew I just had to take that plunge. Frank's words were exactly what I needed to hear right now. Watching this really helped me heal a little bit, or at least helped give me that small push to start moving forward again.
Anisia Villamejor I feel ya. Frabbit came into my life when I was in some dark teenage days and I was a heavy listener for years, faded away from listening to music all together after becoming depressed again. The news of Scott brought me back to listening to the entirety of the band. I even bought a book he illustrated for. His voice and lyrics bring new meaning. I am in a good place right now but I couldn’t tell him thank you enough for what he did. And continues to do through his music. I hope where ever he is now he FINALLY know how loved he was and missed he is. 🤘🏼🐇
Oh wow, I looked into the book you mentioned and it's beautiful. And truly, Scott's work will never stop being important to me. His words got me through so much and I still fall back on them when things get hard.
i was there that night and frank completely broke me.
Having met Scott several times (Including talking about life and stuff and sharing a drink or more at Electric Fields festival) this is a great tribute to an unbelievable person who is sadly missed. Scott lives on through his music and all those who perform it.
This still remains deeply affecting. RIP Scott.
What a tremendous tribute to a wonderful person. I've probably watched this video 20 times already, thanks Frank for helping us all get through.
Just love this. I wish he was on the upcoming Tiny Changes album though!
this made me buy tickets to a frank turner show
chloe any time you have the opportunity to see Frank live- do it. He is an amazing honest performer and incredibly inspiring. Enjoy your show
Incredible. Thank you for recording this.
This hurts just as much today as it did that night
It's so hard for me to watch, but this is one of the most loving, touching tributes I've seen. After watching the video with the two of them together, seeing this one just with Frank Turner... it hurts so much. Especially when he reaches the line "I am ill, but I'm not dead" and he nearly breaks.
But so much love is here, I can't help but love this so, so much.
Respect Frank........that was fuckin emotional........fuckin heartbroken with scott's passing😔
I love this performance so much but utterly heartbreaking at the same time. Just pure raw emotion.
Scott was amazing. His songs have helped me through so much. Thank you Frank.
This took nuts to perform. What an amazing tribute.
Heartbroken
That was tough. Thanks for sharing this. Lots of heartbroken fans today. Hoping to see other people carry on his legacy by doing things like this.
It's all this time later I come back and I still can't hold it together ♥️
Same.
Amazing tribute mate
absolutely devastated man :( This broke me to watch, cant even imagine how hard it woulda been to get up there and play it. 10/10 for a great tribute
I'm crying. Thank you for doing this, Frank.
thank you for recording this and making it available for us all as we grieve. watching Frank give this insanely powerful and emotional tribute is so hard and so lovely.
I'm shaking. This tribute is so meaningful.
Yep balled through most of this
Thank you for putting this video on, we were there, but we were at the back. Thank you for letting us see it up close. Such a special song xxxx
Heart. Breaking.
Scott. Jesus, man. We could have helped you, mate.
Heartbroken.
i think >10 years of struggling is long enough... can't have asked for much more than that. i will always miss him as if he was a best friend but my heart only hurts because of the fact that he went on hurting for so long...
Lena Pauline
He was my friend.
NotTheSun
He was my friend.
NotTheSun
Thanks mate.
I've just discovered one of my favourite songs because of frank.. RIP Scott
Frank. Genuine. Cheers dude.
thank you for this. i was just in front of you.
It was a privilege to experience. I'm not sure I'll ever be quite the same again after that. Thank you xxx
Just across this, you are amazing and strong. Im crying here but this is beautiful and so pure.
:( Gutted. Thank you for posting this.
Thanks for this, it helps
Respect Frank x
I still can't believe it.
9 months late to this but I remember the day it was reported Scott went missing and I remember so clearly the day I read he had been found, heart broke that day. Hearing this I can hear the pain and cracks in his voice during this performance that we all felt that same day.
this broke my heart to watch
Heart Broken. Thank you, Mr Turner.
Lovely tribute.. RIP Scott
"While I'm alive, I'll make tiny changes to earth"
Beautiful and very brave
So much emotion. Well done Frank for an amazing cover.
A really heart felt tribute-
Gutted still. Saw FT last night in Atlanta. The only music before, in between the sets, and after was Frightened Rabbit. It was beautiful.
What a beautiful tribute.
Aw... Woah... Thanx! 😔💚
Powerful, thank you!
Thank you for uploading this. And bless Frank.
He looks broken. Oh Frank :(
The pain we're in.
thanks so much
Thank you for sharing this with us.
If we was that good a mate of his I don’t know how he was able to play a show, if it was one of my friends I wouldn’t have been able.
I know this is years after you commented, but I think at this point (before meeting his wife) Frank was almost entirely driven by the idea that playing live shows could cheer people up for a few hours, I think letting down his paying audience would've been unimaginable for him.
A similar thing is Weird Al Yankovic, who played a gig hours after finding out both his parents had died at the same time. Top performer's brains are not wired the same as you or I.
awesome!
Best tribute you could give Frank. I can't wait to see you in Red Rocks in August. Keep it up!!
Lovely lyrics, so sad, Rest in Peace
Thanks for sharing ❤️💔
Beautiful - thank you
Beautiful
Nice one Frank.
Well I’m crying now.
i thought i could watch this now and not break down. i was wrong
Thank you for posting this x
🧡🧡🧡
RIP Scott :/