@@urlittlewindmill Ikkkkk. The Doctor loves/loved Rose it is canon. It irritates me so much when I read comments on how "Rose was so idiotic to believe the Doctor was in love with her"
It's 2020 and I'm still not over rose and the doctor. Rose and the doctor had this connection that no other companion has had with the doctor. They loved each other so much, yet they never said it. It breaks my heart to see her never mentioned anymore. It's like she has disappeared from the doctor who universe. I think she deserves more mentions, maybe even another appearance!
I don't really agree with you. I mean, the doctor and Rose realy had chemistry but saying that he never had the same thing with no other companions is denying completely Sarah Jane's existence. They had almost the exact same kind of relation with the doctor, which is actually shown in "the school reunion" episode, the thing is that Rose loved the doctor back a thing Sarah didn't realy did, she loved him, but in a diferente way. Well both stories make me really sad btw
I just can't get over the current lack of Rose in DW. I know she's off the show and all, but why is she never, ever mentioned anymore? She's a fairly recent character, and as this video and many other show, she had a huge impact on the Doctor and they were obviously in love. Clara is still mentioned. Even River. Doesn't Rose deserve to be remembered too? I just don't think they're accurately portraying how utterly important Rose and her story were to the Doctor.
Sandra Perales Yes and the only other time she came back was the the fourth serues and the 50th anniv episode and she was the moment there not really rose tyler but somehow a part of her
Completely agree, I found a small place in my heart for any and even for Clara but I could never with River. If the doctor was going to get married to anyone, it should have been rose
Moffat hates that Rose is a more 3-dimensional companion than Amy, River, and Clara combined. He hates that we still ship Rose with his version on the Doctor. So he tries to make us forget her, and when he can't, he belittles or minimizes her impact on the Doctor. I mean instead of using the Time Vortex from the Bad Wolf plot to allow Rose to project herself into the War to comfort and help the Doctor... he contrives a way for her to be OOC and not even interact with Tennant. Maybe because he didn't think there was room for Clara AND Rose to be in the same room with the Doctor. Maybe because he didn't want Rose to overshine Clara so he had to strip her of her Rose-ness. I would have infinitely preferred if Clara hadn't been able to change the Doctor's mind and so "The Moment" shows herself, and truly channels Rose to talk to Ten. It was kinda disrespectful to bait fans with a Billie/David reunion like that.
Well, while I really love Rose the companions are rarely mentioned again, and especially not after the doctor regenerates. Take Martha, sure she appeared in season 4 as well because she could as she just left without dying/not remembering, but she has never been mentioned after that. Donna hasn't been mentioned since her season either, but probably would have if the doctor hadn't regenerated. Amy appeared to say goodbye to the 11th doctor when he was about to regenerate, otherwise she was never mentioned again (except in the snowmen which was the episode after they died). Clara is the companion with the most episodes in the modern show and like amy she wasn't mentioned after she disappeared except right before the doctors regeneration (to be fair, as the doctor didn't remember her before that she couldn't really appear in season 10). Bill only got to be a companion for one season and hasn't been mentioned again. River is a bit special as she never were a companion really, and met several versions of the doctor. Even so, she was hardly mentioned at all after amy and rory except in two episodes. But Rose IS special. It was clear that the Doctor still missed her especially in season 3 with Martha but also in season 4. The 11th doctor missed Amy in one episode (though it seemed like he has missed her for quite a while then, the show just skipped it), so being mentioned occasionally for two whole seasons after leaving is special. Plus, Rose(ish) is the only companion that got to appear on the 50th anniversary episode (except Clara but she was only there as the current companion). And it's even stated the moment took the shape of Rose (or the bad wolf) as she would be so important to the doctor, it could have chosen any companion but it chose her.
This will be my favorite ship forever.... this was my first ship ever and...to just end it like that made my cry like a baby😭😭😭I will forever ship you guys...
This is why he punched through a wall of diamond for 4 and a half billion years to save Clara and then shot a man - he didn't want to go through something like this again. Rose broke his hearts and he wasn't going to give up without a fight the second time around. It's just a pity Clara didn't love him back the way Rose did. Poor Doctor. That's the curse of the time lords.
Yes he didn't want go thru that again but I believe he loved clara like best friend he didn't wanna live without his friend and didn't want go thru that pain he went thru with rose.
agreed the only other person I think that he saw in a romantic way aside from rose was river and she sadly died the doctor isn't the type to fall in love easily
I think David Tenant came to the realization that you not only have to be a great actor (which he certainly is) but you have to have someone great preforming with you (which Billie Piper certainly is). The right time and all the prerequisites have to be in place. Everything came together in s02e13 "the story of how I died" Certainly one of the most emotionally satisfying scenes in cinematic history. Certainly the number one in the SciFi category.
You taught me the courage of stars Before you left. How light carries on endlessly Even after death. With shortness of breath You explained the infinite. How rare and beautiful it is To even exist. I couldn’t help but ask For you to say it all again. I tried to write it down But I could never find a pen. I’d give anything to hear You say it one more time, That the universe was made Just to be seen by my eyes. I couldn’t help but ask For you to say it all again. I tried to write it down But I could never find a pen. I’d give anything to hear You say it one more time, That the universe was made Just to be seen by my eyes. With shortness of breath I’ll explain the infinite- How rare and beautiful It truly is that we exist.
Im crying 1-this song I LOVE THIS SONG THIS BAND HAS SUCH GOOD MUSIC 2-ten and rose omg im killing myself by rewatching this 3-they took the most bloody beautiful peices and the most bloody painful scenes why!!! 🇬🇧😭
Literally this year I started shipping these two. Ik I’m really late but I didn’t like the idea of the Doctor being in love. I find it so tragic now and I really wish the two got a happy ending.
oh my goodness this is so beautiful and heartbreaking and I'm so glad I wasn't the only one who immediately thought of the Doctor and Rose when I listened to this song
I am quite new to the Doctor Who fandom, but what I do already know is that THIS is the video I was hoping to find. It made me cry- especially the part where you put Ten's happiness, his joy to the lyrics "how rare and beautiful it is to even exist"- these precious moments when the pain gives way to the light... I hope you read this because I needed to thank you for making the video I longed for. There is a depth in it, so much mingled feelings, and the song is indeed perfect for this. So- thank you so much. ❤️
The best part about this is that they can make a spinoff series at any time, since both Rose and TenToo would age (along with the actors). Go ahead, BBC, i'll wait.
2018, and I'm still pining for these two (and still watching this video everytime I use youtube)... I even developed a white wall phobia, because of them lol but I can't help it... T.T
I have a theory, now that we know that gallifrey was never destroyed and the time lords are still alive then the doctor can visit rose in the parallel universe right? because in one episode of the second season the tenth doctor said that when the time lords were alive travelling through parallel universes was easy but then they died, so if they're still alive cause the doctor saved them that means that travelling between parallel universes is easy right?? (sorry for my bad english lol )
@@Gyspymoon7 Boo to Tentoo. I don't go for clones. Anyways, this theory is frickin brilliant! But if only Moffat and Chibnail hadn't ruined the damn series >:c *Heads to fanfiction*
The problem is that traveling to parallel dimensions, while theoretically possibly in the doctor Who lore is that besides it being practically impossible it wouldn’t be her
You can tell really how hurt Rose and him are. And you can really tell how much they loved eachother. You can see it in eachother’s eyes when they look at eachother. And the doctor could’ve been the coldest at that time but Rose brought happiness to him. Which made him happy, Even her. But to see them two get separated is heart breaking.
Compilations always make me think of the 12th Doctor's quote, "Nothing's sad til it's over. Then everything is." I'm glad YT sent me here to your channel. Gonna see what else you've got, now. I am adding this to my list of things to watch when my own pain gets to be too much, when I need something to cry over that I can convince myself isn't mostly because of my own loss. ❤️💔❤️💔 Oh, and here's a like and comment, for the 'Almighty Algorithm.' ❤️ ❤️
I’m so glad she got to spend the rest of her life with of human doctor but, the real doctor was still hurting out there but now knowing that there’s a person out there living the life he’s always desired and can’t have
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
You can tell how much the Doctor loved her. The Doctor x Rose ship will always be my strongest ship within the show. I miss her so much.
You could always tell in everything the doctor did. He never hid it, it was always so obvious.
It’s not a ship if it’s literally true, David tennant said it himself that rose and the doctor were a thing :)
I love the Doctor and Rose as a couple so much too. I also love the Doctor with Clara.
@@urlittlewindmill Ikkkkk. The Doctor loves/loved Rose it is canon. It irritates me so much when I read comments on how "Rose was so idiotic to believe the Doctor was in love with her"
Kyoru Honda FOR REAL
there was this innocence about them... like two kids running around. it just made the show so magic
that's what I love and miss about them the most. they just ran across the universe laughing and having fun together 😭
@@jjhatch5697 Like two childhood best friends slowly realising that they're in love. So pure
For her it was experiencing the magic of the whole universe for the first time. For him it was the magic of her. ❤️
For her it was experiencing the magic of the whole universe for the first time. For him it was the magic of her. ❤️
For her it was experiencing the magic of the whole universe for the first time. For him it was the magic of her. ❤️
It's 2020 and I'm still not over rose and the doctor. Rose and the doctor had this connection that no other companion has had with the doctor. They loved each other so much, yet they never said it. It breaks my heart to see her never mentioned anymore. It's like she has disappeared from the doctor who universe. I think she deserves more mentions, maybe even another appearance!
YES.
I don't really agree with you. I mean, the doctor and Rose realy had chemistry but saying that he never had the same thing with no other companions is denying completely Sarah Jane's existence. They had almost the exact same kind of relation with the doctor, which is actually shown in "the school reunion" episode, the thing is that Rose loved the doctor back a thing Sarah didn't realy did, she loved him, but in a diferente way. Well both stories make me really sad btw
No matter how many years past, I will never ever get over these two. They will always manage to break my heart, every single time.
I just can't get over the current lack of Rose in DW. I know she's off the show and all, but why is she never, ever mentioned anymore? She's a fairly recent character, and as this video and many other show, she had a huge impact on the Doctor and they were obviously in love. Clara is still mentioned. Even River. Doesn't Rose deserve to be remembered too? I just don't think they're accurately portraying how utterly important Rose and her story were to the Doctor.
moffat ruined it
Sandra Perales Yes and the only other time she came back was the the fourth serues and the 50th anniv episode and she was the moment there not really rose tyler but somehow a part of her
Completely agree, I found a small place in my heart for any and even for Clara but I could never with River. If the doctor was going to get married to anyone, it should have been rose
Moffat hates that Rose is a more 3-dimensional companion than Amy, River, and Clara combined. He hates that we still ship Rose with his version on the Doctor. So he tries to make us forget her, and when he can't, he belittles or minimizes her impact on the Doctor. I mean instead of using the Time Vortex from the Bad Wolf plot to allow Rose to project herself into the War to comfort and help the Doctor... he contrives a way for her to be OOC and not even interact with Tennant. Maybe because he didn't think there was room for Clara AND Rose to be in the same room with the Doctor. Maybe because he didn't want Rose to overshine Clara so he had to strip her of her Rose-ness. I would have infinitely preferred if Clara hadn't been able to change the Doctor's mind and so "The Moment" shows herself, and truly channels Rose to talk to Ten. It was kinda disrespectful to bait fans with a Billie/David reunion like that.
Well, while I really love Rose the companions are rarely mentioned again, and especially not after the doctor regenerates. Take Martha, sure she appeared in season 4 as well because she could as she just left without dying/not remembering, but she has never been mentioned after that. Donna hasn't been mentioned since her season either, but probably would have if the doctor hadn't regenerated. Amy appeared to say goodbye to the 11th doctor when he was about to regenerate, otherwise she was never mentioned again (except in the snowmen which was the episode after they died). Clara is the companion with the most episodes in the modern show and like amy she wasn't mentioned after she disappeared except right before the doctors regeneration (to be fair, as the doctor didn't remember her before that she couldn't really appear in season 10). Bill only got to be a companion for one season and hasn't been mentioned again. River is a bit special as she never were a companion really, and met several versions of the doctor. Even so, she was hardly mentioned at all after amy and rory except in two episodes.
But Rose IS special. It was clear that the Doctor still missed her especially in season 3 with Martha but also in season 4. The 11th doctor missed Amy in one episode (though it seemed like he has missed her for quite a while then, the show just skipped it), so being mentioned occasionally for two whole seasons after leaving is special. Plus, Rose(ish) is the only companion that got to appear on the 50th anniversary episode (except Clara but she was only there as the current companion). And it's even stated the moment took the shape of Rose (or the bad wolf) as she would be so important to the doctor, it could have chosen any companion but it chose her.
It's 2023 still love rose/ david dr.who everytime i see this makes me cry miss them both their pair deserve part 2 of the series
No idea why I keep torturing myself with these two T.T
Supreme Overlorde THANK GOODNESS I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE
Still dont know, still keep watching them.
SAME!!!
I know. After all these years, too. 😍😍😍😪😪😪
DJas118 still doing it now
Before I clicked on this I took a second and was like: Am I really doing this to myself?
Apparently I am. Gosh, I’m crying so hard.
2017: not over it
Never!
Lynn Wastoid 2018 not over it either
Lucy Ely same
Same!
2018: Still not over it lol.
This will be my favorite ship forever....
this was my first ship ever and...to just end it like that made my cry like a baby😭😭😭I will forever ship you guys...
Best ship yeah
This is still my favorite ship and always will be. It was my first ship too.
I don't wanna go
I wanna this relationship back
they showed me what love should be like
This is why he punched through a wall of diamond for 4 and a half billion years to save Clara and then shot a man - he didn't want to go through something like this again. Rose broke his hearts and he wasn't going to give up without a fight the second time around. It's just a pity Clara didn't love him back the way Rose did. Poor Doctor. That's the curse of the time lords.
Poor Doctor!!!:(
ElevenMisrule Well I don't think clara and the doctor were in love they were just best friends.
Yes he didn't want go thru that again but I believe he loved clara like best friend he didn't wanna live without his friend and didn't want go thru that pain he went thru with rose.
yeah, same with those comments above me, the doctor didn't seem to love Clara romantically like he did with Rose. More of a best friendship.
agreed the only other person I think that he saw in a romantic way aside from rose was river and she sadly died the doctor isn't the type to fall in love easily
2024. Still not over it.
- After all this time?
- Always.
I think David Tenant came to the realization that you not only have to be a great actor (which he certainly is) but you have to have someone great preforming with you (which Billie Piper certainly is). The right time and all the prerequisites have to be in place. Everything came together in s02e13 "the story of how I died" Certainly one of the most emotionally satisfying scenes in cinematic history. Certainly the number one in the SciFi category.
2018 and still never going to get over this. I’m still crying.
2020 😭
@@billiejoness Yup we still crying
2022 😩
@@nicoleburns6388 still crying 💀
This is my all-time favorite Ten x Rose fanvid. It's heartbreaking and beautiful at the same time.
The best ship in the DW universe by far... I’m literally crying I miss seeing Rose and Ten so much.
It made me cry when rose left because she was so good
I miss Ten and Rose so much. Still. Even after all this time.
You taught me the courage of stars
Before you left.
How light carries on endlessly
Even after death.
With shortness of breath
You explained the infinite.
How rare and beautiful it is
To even exist.
I couldn’t help but ask
For you to say it all again.
I tried to write it down
But I could never find a pen.
I’d give anything to hear
You say it one more time,
That the universe was made
Just to be seen by my eyes.
I couldn’t help but ask
For you to say it all again.
I tried to write it down
But I could never find a pen.
I’d give anything to hear
You say it one more time,
That the universe was made
Just to be seen by my eyes.
With shortness of breath
I’ll explain the infinite-
How rare and beautiful
It truly is that we exist.
2020 not over it... I really miss them! Rose belongs to Doctor!
Im crying
1-this song I LOVE THIS SONG THIS BAND HAS SUCH GOOD MUSIC
2-ten and rose omg im killing myself by rewatching this
3-they took the most bloody beautiful peices and the most bloody painful scenes why!!!
🇬🇧😭
Roses are red
The Tardis is blue
The Doctor once said
Rose Tyler...
Thank you for shattering my heart
Such a little movie! This song is one of the best songs ever, and it's perfect to Doctor/Rose :)
I agree this song is AMAZING! Thank you!
Oh my god I'm seriously tearing up, I loved these two I can't believe they got separated :((
*When I stood on this beach*
*on the worst day of my life..*
*What was the last thing you said to me?*
"Does it need saying?" YES IT DOES.
Literally this year I started shipping these two. Ik I’m really late but I didn’t like the idea of the Doctor being in love. I find it so tragic now and I really wish the two got a happy ending.
you got some tears out of me. The scene in the beginning of the video where he smashes on the TARDIS our of frustration.
I wish Rose could come back (somehow) to the 13th Doctor. Everything is possible I suppose
Bel Aozu same I miss her sm
Bel Aozu same! I miss her so much.
Crazy Whovian •o• I second that. The best love her character forever...
The 13th doctor would be Rose!! Just kidding lol but yeah I wish she could come back too.
KurtpokeMarch6 Well the New Doctor looks like a tributs to Rose... blonde hair 😎
forever my otp ❤️ no other pairing from a tv show has left an impact on me on the same level these two did. missing david and billie on the show still
2019
Still not over this couple👫💜
2020 and still not over this....
oh my goodness this is so beautiful and heartbreaking and I'm so glad I wasn't the only one who immediately thought of the Doctor and Rose when I listened to this song
me too
This song was made for Doctor Who
I am quite new to the Doctor Who fandom, but what I do already know is that THIS is the video I was hoping to find. It made me cry- especially the part where you put Ten's happiness, his joy to the lyrics "how rare and beautiful it is to even exist"- these precious moments when the pain gives way to the light... I hope you read this because I needed to thank you for making the video I longed for. There is a depth in it, so much mingled feelings, and the song is indeed perfect for this. So- thank you so much. ❤️
Awwww Thank you ❤️❤️❤️
It's 2017 and I'm still not over those two together 😭😭💖
Abbie Heath 2018 and I'm still crying over these two :'(
2020 and I'm not over this xD
what about 2024???????
I actually heard this song first before watching this video, and I thought that it was a perfect song for the doctor and rose!
The best part about this is that they can make a spinoff series at any time, since both Rose and TenToo would age (along with the actors). Go ahead, BBC, i'll wait.
No..No, I'm not crying...i'm not...FUCK, I'M CRYING! This is delightfully video!
LOL Thank you! :)
Steve moffat the writer confirm that the doctor still in love rose after all this time it doesn't change just because he coming a woman
2020 and still here. I’ve been stuck with this pair since 2005
This is so sad and cute at the same time I can't tell you how much I want to cry..
This video is incredible. Your timing and colouring is fantastic. A very moving piece of art.
*stop making me cry*
8:30 in the morning and I'm in tears. Ta
2018, and I'm still pining for these two (and still watching this video everytime I use youtube)... I even developed a white wall phobia, because of them lol but I can't help it... T.T
I have a theory, now that we know that gallifrey was never destroyed and the time lords are still alive then the doctor can visit rose in the parallel universe right? because in one episode of the second season the tenth doctor said that when the time lords were alive travelling through parallel universes was easy but then they died, so if they're still alive cause the doctor saved them that means that travelling between parallel universes is easy right?? (sorry for my bad english lol )
But he won't, because she has the human Doctor. He won't do that to her.
@@Gyspymoon7 but she will always want the real doctor more..
@@Gyspymoon7 Boo to Tentoo. I don't go for clones. Anyways, this theory is frickin brilliant! But if only Moffat and Chibnail hadn't ruined the damn series >:c *Heads to fanfiction*
The problem is that traveling to parallel dimensions, while theoretically possibly in the doctor Who lore is that besides it being practically impossible it wouldn’t be her
@@tonystewart123 except that the way it ended was that Rose got stuck in a parallel dimension, so it would be her if he went to the right dimension.
I will go down with this ship
This is just stunning and i'm crying.. but of course I am because it's Saturn and Doctor/Rose... like my heart
2019: still not over it
This is so beautiful! I'm so emotional! Well done!! :)
Thank you! I've been meaning to make this video for so long now! I'm glad you liked it!
You can tell really how hurt Rose and him are. And you can really tell how much they loved eachother. You can see it in eachother’s eyes when they look at eachother. And the doctor could’ve been the coldest at that time but Rose brought happiness to him. Which made him happy, Even her. But to see them two get separated is heart breaking.
This fully made me cry in the middle of the library. I love it so much. Thank you.
Probably the same reason I do, its a beautiful song and a rare expression of love that seldomley exist nowadays.
This is such a lovely video. And I'm weeping because of all the feels. Thanks for sharing! xx
*cries in gallyfreyan*
this is so damn beautiful.. love them both so much!! 😘
Oh man i'm crying so hard rn
Do you ever love something so much you want to throw something at a wall?
They were soulmates; anything you say cannot deny the fact that they were 😭❤️😍
OMG That was amazing I cried 2 times
Awww thanks :)
So beautiful ..... miss both :( .....
This is my favorite video on the internet I love is so much, I cry every time ❤️
this is really emotional I'm glad there's no dislikes
Thank you!!!
There are two dislikes, but that's because they're on the behalf of the daleks and cybermen
Lovely
Amazing. I'm crying 😭 😭 😭
I’m not crying, just sweating through my eyes.
2020, still not over it
OMG! That…..was…..BEAUTIFUL! Thank you from a Droser!
2022 and still missing them
This is so beautiful and it moved me to tears!!
2021 e eu ainda não superei esses dois 😭🤧
Beautiful, I loved it! And I'm not gonna cry, honest...
I can't stop watching this...
This is perfect!!! The feels!
Thank you!!!
The Doctor and Rose I repeat THE DOCTOR AND ROSE😖😖❤️❤️
This was just so wonderfully done~!!!
Thank you!!!
I love it so much! Thank you for this amazing vid, you did such a great job❤️
Compilations always make me think of the 12th Doctor's quote, "Nothing's sad til it's over. Then everything is."
I'm glad YT sent me here to your channel. Gonna see what else you've got, now. I am adding this to my list of things to watch when my own pain gets to be too much, when I need something to cry over that I can convince myself isn't mostly because of my own loss.
❤️💔❤️💔
Oh, and here's a like and comment, for the 'Almighty Algorithm.' ❤️ ❤️
Great work on that music video! It evoked the emotions!
so beautiful
Ohhh Gooosh! Gorgeous! It makes me cry again and again! Best work I've ever seen!
That got me!!!!!!! I’m lying here in bed crying because of this!!! Why do I torture myself????
Just kill me now please. Beautifully done btw. thank you!
I’m so glad she got to spend the rest of her life with of human doctor but, the real doctor was still hurting out there but now knowing that there’s a person out there living the life he’s always desired and can’t have
amazing video love it.
November 2018 and I'm still dying inside
That was so well put together. So beautiful and so passionate. ❤️❄️❤️❄️❤️
2019 not over #tenrose 😭
#EveryDoctorAndRose
2020... still not over it
My heart. Oh wait I don’t have one anymore after this
That was bloody beautiful, and now I’m sobbing. 😭💙💙
YOU HAD TO CHOOSE THIS SONG OF ALL THE SONGS. FUCK. CRYING IN THE CLUB TONIGHT. JUST GOT INTO THE DAMN SHOW TOO
Beautiful tribute to these two 😭😍👍
I hate seeing the doctors face when he sees rose and duplicate doctor kiss, he just looks so… unhappy
They do make a great couples I'd love to see their children and grandchildren later on future tv series?
Very beautiful
Thank you!!!! :)
Brb crying