This is really cool and peaceful Barakallahu feek, brother! Hidaya is still my favourite and now, I love it more! May Allah grant you his Guidance (Hidaya)
Alhamdulilah as long as they’re from vocals only they’re halal. Some people just prefer their nasheeds not having beats. Both halal, just personal preference! 😃
@@Deen_Over_Dunya_Love yes JazakAllah khair. The only “proper” ulema who prohibit it that I’ve come across are from islamqa. Majority of scholars seem to be fine with it including mufti menk. People like zakir naik and asim Al Hakeem who talk against beatboxing are not mufti’s nor do they specialise in Fiqh. Amazing daees but I take what they say in fiqh matters with a pinch of salt! Alhamdulilah both versions provided for people’s preference 😀
@ Jazakallah khair for actually responding. Yes, there is ikhtilaaf in this matter. I have the same view of Assim al Hakeem and the like. The mufti of my masjid doesn't allow it, and that's the opinion I follow. But if you look at it critically, doesn't what islamicqa said make sense? Khair, Allah knows best.
@@Deen_Over_Dunya_Love BarakAllah feek. If I’m honest, the more critically I analyse it the less the prohibition makes any sense at all! Halal chicken and haram chicken taste exactly the same. The permissibility has nothing to do with the taste but everything to do with the source. As long as the source of the sound is from the human voice, regardless of how much it resembles a beat, it’s vocals and therefore halal. People who try to argue that the ‘illah or reason for prohibition of music is the effect it has and then try to make qiyas with beatboxing have to provide evidence from the Quran or Sunnah for this reason. For example, Allah tells us the reason for prohibition of alcohol is the harm and the intoxication. From this we can make qiyas that any intoxicants such as cocaine etc are also haram despite not being directly mentioned in the Quran. There is absolutely no evidence for the reason for prohibition. Looking at it critically, I think even the evidence for the prohibition of music itself is quite shaky. I believe musical instruments are haram because that was the position of all of the madhahib and the majority of the scholars accepted the disputed Hadith in bukhari regarding musical instruments not being allowed. What frustrates me is that often certain Nasheed artists don’t use beatboxing yet use other sound effects making noises that no human being could make, but because they don’t have beatboxing they somehow come across as “more pure”. It’s very dishonest, and Qadr Allah the ummah seems to go along with it! Sorry for the long message! May Allah bless you!
![Sultan - Hidaya [Official Video] VOCALS ONLY](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SqjRVGFHjWY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Sultan - Hidaya [Official Video] VOCALS ONLY](/img/tr.png)
Please always try to upload no beats version 💥💕
SubhanAllah that was such a beautiful Nasheed, really motivates me to do good
Me too
This is so so lit 🔥 🙌 🥰❤🤩
BHAI WHAT CAN I SAY U YOUR VOICE IS SOMETHING MASHA ALLAH YOUR VOICE GIVE US VIBE WHICH WE NEED
This is really cool and peaceful
Barakallahu feek, brother!
Hidaya is still my favourite and now, I love it more!
May Allah grant you his Guidance (Hidaya)
Loved this version more 💞 so peaceful
Mashallah, Extraordinary
Mashaaalah...You are truly great...Thank God i have met another star to be listening to
Really loving all of your Nasheeds❣️...keep the good qork up
Anything by Nasheed Sultan touches straight your heart ❤️
Mashallah
May all bless u my brother 💙💙and grant us jannah
Ma Sha Allah brother 💙
This version hits different ❤️🔥
maschaAllah this nasheed is soooo beautyfull Allahummabarik, the lyrics speaking from my heart!!!
Love you brother❤️🇧🇩
❤ohh Ma shallah
This version is 100 time better 👏👏👏😊
Alhamdulillah !! This is a very underrated song brother. I love it.
This is so nice, no beats.
Without beats is better ❤
Niceeee peace
Alhamdulilllah
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I love you for Allah brother❤️
Assalamualaikum By the way can we give this song a translation subtitle? Especially Indonesian subtitle and arabic subtitle?
Brother are you Bangladeshi?
I’m from the UK, parents from Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@SultanNasheeds your face seems Bangladeshi.🧐
@@Tanim.H2O thanks for your feedback 😂
Most important thing is being Muslim 👍
@@SultanNasheeds yes yes obviously ✌️
Aren’t beats halal?
Alhamdulilah as long as they’re from vocals only they’re halal. Some people just prefer their nasheeds not having beats. Both halal, just personal preference! 😃
@@SultanNasheeds No, some ulima consider it impermissible as it resembles music.
@@Deen_Over_Dunya_Love yes JazakAllah khair. The only “proper” ulema who prohibit it that I’ve come across are from islamqa. Majority of scholars seem to be fine with it including mufti menk. People like zakir naik and asim Al Hakeem who talk against beatboxing are not mufti’s nor do they specialise in Fiqh. Amazing daees but I take what they say in fiqh matters with a pinch of salt!
Alhamdulilah both versions provided for people’s preference 😀
@ Jazakallah khair for actually responding. Yes, there is ikhtilaaf in this matter. I have the same view of Assim al Hakeem and the like. The mufti of my masjid doesn't allow it, and that's the opinion I follow. But if you look at it critically, doesn't what islamicqa said make sense? Khair, Allah knows best.
@@Deen_Over_Dunya_Love BarakAllah feek. If I’m honest, the more critically I analyse it the less the prohibition makes any sense at all! Halal chicken and haram chicken taste exactly the same. The permissibility has nothing to do with the taste but everything to do with the source. As long as the source of the sound is from the human voice, regardless of how much it resembles a beat, it’s vocals and therefore halal. People who try to argue that the ‘illah or reason for prohibition of music is the effect it has and then try to make qiyas with beatboxing have to provide evidence from the Quran or Sunnah for this reason. For example, Allah tells us the reason for prohibition of alcohol is the harm and the intoxication. From this we can make qiyas that any intoxicants such as cocaine etc are also haram despite not being directly mentioned in the Quran. There is absolutely no evidence for the reason for prohibition.
Looking at it critically, I think even the evidence for the prohibition of music itself is quite shaky. I believe musical instruments are haram because that was the position of all of the madhahib and the majority of the scholars accepted the disputed Hadith in bukhari regarding musical instruments not being allowed.
What frustrates me is that often certain Nasheed artists don’t use beatboxing yet use other sound effects making noises that no human being could make, but because they don’t have beatboxing they somehow come across as “more pure”. It’s very dishonest, and Qadr Allah the ummah seems to go along with it!
Sorry for the long message! May Allah bless you!