What is a Mennonite? How are they different from the Amish? How Did I Become One and Why? | My Story

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @pdan62
    @pdan62 Місяць тому +5

    Served alongside Mennonites and ate with them, during hurricane disaster recovery, they were I fine witness of the love of God, sang at every meal better than I hear from most "English" churches.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +1

      That's a wonderful memory you must have to look back on. Thank you so much for sharing.

  • @laurabehan7867
    @laurabehan7867 2 місяці тому +6

    Thank you for sharing your journey! Very encouraging! In this heated political climate we need to all remember God is in control and he will take care of us! Our energy is best spent in the Word and helping others..

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  2 місяці тому +1

      This is such a kind and lovely message. I agree! I am glad you found encouragement in that portion of my video.

  • @jeremyj612
    @jeremyj612 Місяць тому +3

    Outstanding video and conversation! Glad to have stumbled on you, and I'll be following along. Thank you!

  • @janeashby7119
    @janeashby7119 21 день тому +1

    This was such a wholesome video. I particularly loved your description of your church at the end. Sounds like a church about an hour away from where I live.
    Definitely going to look into Mennonite beliefs because of this.
    In recent years my beliefs have been in line with Messianic Judaism, although I’m not a Jew myself.
    I just want to be way more Biblical and get rid of the world really. I find it so tough though because everyone around me, even at my church it would seem, is just so entrenched in the world!

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  21 день тому +1

      Thank you so much for the kind comment and for watching my video.
      I understand how hard it can be to be an individual and viewed differently by your peers who want to embrace the world, but God will be able to use you to inspire them and hopefully they are changing and learning in their own daily lives that you don't see outwardly reflected from their inward growth. Keep focusing on how God is helping you mature towards a deeper relationship and understanding of Him. Keep showing grace to those around you and pray for them and yourself to want to be set apart more to glorify God and live a more righteous lifestyle daily. I prayed for you as I read your comment. Seems like you are doing a great job! God bless you!

    • @janeashby7119
      @janeashby7119 21 день тому

      @@TheMennomilist Thank you SO much for praying for me! I really appreciate it. God bless you so much! I can really see God’s Spirit shining out of you and it’s beautiful!

  • @denisadellinger
    @denisadellinger Місяць тому +3

    Thanks for sharing. I wanted to know the differences between these groups, I was a teachar in a mennonite school. I loved it. So much parent support. I am a southern baptist, I also am political. I think we as christians need to take a stand for what kind of country we want to live in. Those founders, many christians, died for their stand. I'm glad you have found a place where you can serve and find fellowship, All of us need to take seriously what we do to serve our fellow humans. And honey. church splits affect a church in many ways. How can a body of people who are broken, start all these mission projects when many of the members have left? YOu are in survival mode just trying to lock the door to keep others from leaving. I've experienced that, Luckily, my church is on the growing stage now and we have new leadership. But it took a long time.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      Thanks for giving your insight. The church split wasn't really a typical split. I am just keeping peace by keeping that portion private. It was two years through its healing when I stated my longing for doing outreach. I understand what you stated though. Thanks again and have a wonderful weekend!

  • @lorineilson7529
    @lorineilson7529 Місяць тому +3

    Thank you for sharing.

  • @valeriemacrae8441
    @valeriemacrae8441 Місяць тому +1

    Love this video. Thank you for taking the time to share with us.

  • @TheChan7
    @TheChan7 Місяць тому

    What a great video! Thanks for expounding on what Mennonites believe. I think it’s wonderful. We are made in His image and are created to be emotional beings like Him but fear doesn’t come from Him.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +1

      Aw, thanks for watching, Euree! Good to have you here too.

  • @joandevries1892
    @joandevries1892 Місяць тому +4

    The all-time, best-selling book has been read by too few. When a religion fails to mention the importance of Israel, they have left the path of truth.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +2

      It has always been really weird to me when people are Christians but don't seem to know what is in the Bible and don't read it at all.

  • @DavidVictoriaReyes-xd9fj
    @DavidVictoriaReyes-xd9fj 2 місяці тому +4

    I’m an AG pastor. So sorry that you had a bad experience in that AG church but I’m happy you found a home in the Mennonite church.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  2 місяці тому +3

      Welcome! We had several bad experiences, but I don't blame the AG church for it (I even attended a homeschool group there for a few years), just the certain individuals that did what they did. I am happy about it too!

  • @thearmedoregoniancitizensj7911
    @thearmedoregoniancitizensj7911 Місяць тому +1

    Hello my name is Israel I'm from the Oregon coast. Mix indigenous, Russian hinz57.
    I grew up baptist and seventh day adventist. My wifey grew up with a grandparents that were Mormon. My journey that I have been on has led me here. I want to hear more
    I love true history not the ELITES

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +1

      Hi Israel. Nice to meet you. Thanks for being here!

  • @gladyw1011
    @gladyw1011 15 днів тому +1

    Hii Victoria... I'm really glad to know that such people who stand for God still exists in the Western countries. Today I was really frustrated about the church that I am attending and I felt so lost and the feeling of being rejected (kind of) because of my financial status is really heart breaking for me. I actually live in India and I was really happy to hear about your thirst for winning soul here in India. Here, to my knowledge, there aren't any Mennonite church in India. So how can I connect with you people? I am really longing for such a congregation that loves and cares for everyone. Please do reply if you can help me to connect or find such a wonderful congregation like yours. Thanks for sharing these precious things through your channel. It's a wonder how I came across your video today. God bless...

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  15 днів тому +1

      Hi! Thanks so much for watching and leaving a comment!
      There are Mennonite churches in India, though it is a tough country to establish churches. There is a Mennonite Brethren headquarters in Jadcherla, Telangana. There are a few in Janjgir-Champa. Most of the churches are in Andhra Pradesh and Chhattisgarh. I am not sure if these are states you are near or live in though. I wish you peace and people to be placed into your life that you will freely be able to fellowship with.

    • @gladyw1011
      @gladyw1011 15 днів тому

      @@TheMennomilist Thank you again for the reply. As I am from the southern most part of India (Tamilnadu), I won't be able to go there to the places you've mentioned but I am glad that there are Mennonite churches in parts of India too. Hope God will show me a way soon.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  15 днів тому +1

      @@gladyw1011 Tamilnadu is probably the most churched state in India too, so hopefully you can connect with other believers of Christ that won't make you feel lost or rejected but included and loved.

    • @gladyw1011
      @gladyw1011 15 днів тому +1

      @@TheMennomilist Yeah... I'm hoping to meet such people one day. Thank you for your kind words😇. God bless...

  • @Sandra-hk8ks
    @Sandra-hk8ks Місяць тому +3

    I've always wanted to live like that. Well I do really but I have no one in the world but Jesus my handicapped daughter. I'm 75 and worry if I were to die, my daughter would die a slow hard death. She can't talk or walk . She can't feed herself. It would be horrible. I just pray Jesus keeps me until He returns. Sooner than later I pray😅😅😅😊 .

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      I just prayed for you and your daughter. May God give you peace, a healthy long life, and give good care for your daughter when your time comes.

  • @tristarobichaud9142
    @tristarobichaud9142 Місяць тому +1

    I knew a woman who was raised in a Hutterite community when I was younger, and she definitely kept the simplicity and generosity - she was always trying to give people things. She was just so sweet, and even though she lived in mainstream society and attended an evangelical church, she still dressed like she had before and always wore a headscarf. Her children were a few years older than me, and are also so kind and generous and lovely.
    I know you're Mennonite and that's the focus of the video, but Hutterites come up so seldomly that I just had to share 😅

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +1

      This was such a delightful story to read. I loved it. Thanks for telling me about the Hutterite woman you knew.

  • @steventroyer1463
    @steventroyer1463 Місяць тому +2

    So appreciate your thought on caring about all governments

  • @boxlove7283
    @boxlove7283 Місяць тому +5

    Please do more Mennonite videos!!

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +1

      I shall try to! Anything in particular you would like to know about in regards to Mennonites?

  • @wottawally3715
    @wottawally3715 2 місяці тому +4

    I don’t even know where to begin with my comments because your story is so beautiful and powerful. I felt every single one of your emotions, was booing and cheering at each point. I’m feeling quite emotional myself as to your journey. I am so glad you have found your home. My love to you in the abiding and loving Lord xx❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  2 місяці тому +1

      You are very sweet. Thank you so much. I am glad too!

  • @holidayhunter1
    @holidayhunter1 2 місяці тому +3

    So, what do Mennonites believe about Jesus? Son of God? Saviour? Redeemer? Only way?

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  2 місяці тому +9

      In the video I stated how Mennonites are a Christian denomination - so Jesus is the son of God who died for our sins and is the only way to heaven, yes.

    • @holidayhunter1
      @holidayhunter1 2 місяці тому +2

      @@TheMennomilist Thank you. Btw, that is not always obvious for every denomination that calls themselves christian. So thank you for making that clear.

    • @bigp3006
      @bigp3006 Місяць тому +5

      I agree its not always obvious. Im a former atheist who became a mennoite in 2010. I joined the jail ministry and did bible studies there. I had a prisoner who was very standoffish when I came and wanted me to read Acts; 8, 37. Once he heard the Ethiopian eunuch declare Jesus as the son of God, he relaxed. Earlier that day another ministry was there reading that and it was omitted, possible they were Jehovah witness but not sure. Some don't give credit to Christ, who said none come unto the Father but by me.

  • @MrRagingrapid
    @MrRagingrapid Місяць тому +6

    As a Conservative Amish Mennonite I’m glad you’ve made the start of your journey. Perhaps you could look at our Biblical Mennonite Alliance and see if that fits into your life a bit more?

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +4

      Wonderful! Not sure how much of my video you watched, but I state that I have been a Mennonite now for almost 11 years (come December), so not really the "start" of my journey any longer! I will look into Biblical Mennonite Alliance though, definitely.

  • @kleineroteHex
    @kleineroteHex Місяць тому +3

    Legalism is so sad, time and again, no matter what group.
    Excellent thoughts! Though the mennonite church i attended had quite a few rich people who no doubt donated to different causes but still were into creating more for themselves.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +2

      I am sorry to hear about that being something you witnessed.
      I agree that legalism in any area is not fun to witness.

    • @kleineroteHex
      @kleineroteHex Місяць тому +1

      @TheMennomilist we grow , hopefully, through those experiences. Hopefully closer to God.

  • @Sandra-hk8ks
    @Sandra-hk8ks Місяць тому

    I'm pentecostal but it's between God and I. Now I only talk to God all day and don't read much anymore because of the mandella effect its changed what the Bible says, besides I'm almost blind so it's very hard to read anymore. I would have been great with horses ive had them most of my life. Used to show horses and worked at the polo field for 10 years. I still raise chickens and guinny hens. I had pigs and goats for years but I got to old. I can cook and can everything, make noodles, cheese, butter, sour cream, sausage ,ect. Sounds like God's calling you out. He called me out but ......im still waiting. The samething happened to me in church. Jesus loves you so much. Never forget that.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      Aw animals and horses are so special. My first job was working with horses. Thanks for sharing a bit of your life in the comments with me.

  • @joegarry8983
    @joegarry8983 Місяць тому

    Can anyone tell me exactly where in scripture Jesus makes the claim, coming from his own lips, that he is God incarnate, or was that claim made for him by someone else, a third party, for example, the council of Nicea, John or Paul. You have a wonderful God given talent for explaining complex issues, thank you and God bless you for the giving of your time to share your thoughts with us.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  28 днів тому

      Thanks for the kind comment. Everywhere I look, Jesus says he is the "son of God" and that he does what the "father" asks of him. He does say in John 10:30 that he and the "father are one" but that word in Greek shows they work together united as a team. Answering this question would take a lot of time. The council of Nicaea did come up with the terms of the trinity, I believe, as a way to be able to win people over from Greek and Roman beliefs where they had three head gods working together as a way to make them understand it, but it wasn't ever preached until then, honestly. There is the verse in John 10:33 where people are about to stone Jesus for putting himself as being God. John 8:58 is where he says before Abraham "I Am" which I don't recall if he is using the form Yahweh or not for that. It has been a while since studying it. John 20:28 is where Thomas calls Jesus his lord and God and he was not corrected. Also in Matthew 28:9, the disciples worshipped him, which would mean Jesus is either an idol or God.
      I hope this helped clear anything up.

    • @joegarry8983
      @joegarry8983 28 днів тому

      @@TheMennomilist Yes its complicated and for someone like myself that is inclined to think and dig way too much into the nitty gritty of the whys and wherefores of almost every thing these questions can pose huge problems. Anyways I appreciate your kindness in giving of your time to reply and on this one, as they say in my neck o the woods, sometimes its better to let sleeping doggies sleep, Very best wishes and God bless from Ireland.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  27 днів тому

      @@joegarry8983 I understand. Believe me. Everyone quotes John 3:16 which says that whoever believes in the son will have everlasting life, which you are taking literally. :)

  • @tarheelk1969
    @tarheelk1969 Місяць тому +3

    I didn't think Amish or Mennonite could have tattoos.?

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +2

      Amish people definitely are not allowed to have tattoos. Many Mennonites have tattoos. I'll have to do a post about it. Again, I was not born into a Mennonite family either. My Mennonite pastor also has tattoos.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому +2

      P.S. Old Order Mennonites don't get tattoos either.

    • @AnneQ-bk6wi
      @AnneQ-bk6wi Місяць тому

      There are many Mennonite churches that are completely assimilated into modern societies and you would never know their personal belief system.

  • @ThatsTravelUSA
    @ThatsTravelUSA 2 місяці тому +1

    Very interesting

  • @LunaciaBooks
    @LunaciaBooks 2 місяці тому

    This is a great and informative video! Also, I can hear the hurt in your voice when you talk about how you were treated. 💜
    Also, a lot of what you and your church do, is what to me is socialism, and humanity. Personally, I don't need a god for that, but the most important thing is to treat people with respect. We all live on the same planet. We should treat with eachother with resepct.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks so much.
      I think I can understand why it sounds like socialism, but in government, it just fails and can't work, while in smaller communities it can work and has. They base it off of "The Acts Church" which is in Acts in the New Testament in the Bible.

    • @anyabar4618
      @anyabar4618 2 місяці тому +2

      The difference between new testament values that ask sharing and equality and socialism. Socialism you don't have a choice and you never have enough. Christian sharing you do have a choice as well as because the sharing is mutual you always have enough. Now the enough may not look like what the world says is enough but it is. (I'm not a Mennonite but a non-denominational Christian and while my church doesn't advocate for intentional sharing I believe that the true believers and members do exemplify some of these traits.)

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  2 місяці тому +2

      @@anyabar4618 Very true! Yes. Also, socialism didn't even exist yet when Jesus walked the earth or even when the Mennonites began.

    • @LunaciaBooks
      @LunaciaBooks 2 місяці тому +1

      @@TheMennomilist My point was that it doesn't really matter WHAT you call it. It's what you do that matters, regardless of religion or lack of thereof.

    • @LunaciaBooks
      @LunaciaBooks 2 місяці тому +1

      @@TheMennomilist Also, our government is closer to socialism than the US government, and works better. ;-) (And socialism shouldn't be confused with communism, two very different things).

  • @jamesnewport1227
    @jamesnewport1227 20 днів тому

    Showing pictures instead of keeping one up the whole vid would of been nice.

  • @rhondahart2416
    @rhondahart2416 Місяць тому +1

    You sound like a wonderful Christ follower. During covid we were in an AG church, wow they were teaching some wild stuff but I cried when we left because they were wonderful, friendly people.
    Do you just focus on the Gospels only or do you read the letters also?

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      Yeah, it is always difficult to leave places with people who you care about. Do you keep in touch with some of those people?
      Oh yes, we read the whole Bible! OT and NT!

    • @rhondahart2416
      @rhondahart2416 Місяць тому +1

      @@TheMennomilist Yes I do see some of the people from time to time in our small town that we live near. Some times I'm tempted to go on Sunday and worship with them, they had such an amazing worship service but sadly they have some heretical teachings so it's not wise to do so.
      I'm glad you read the whole bible. I became a Christ follower five years ago at an old age and the Lord has led me to study hard and to reach out to high control groups , mainly the Jehovah Witnesses which are in our area and online.
      My husband and I came from northern Indiana so we are familiar with the Amish and the Mennonite. I did not know that there was a sect like yours that did not dress with the standard garb that you normally see. This is quite interesting.
      Have you ever heard of the German Baptist sometimes called Old Orders or Dunkerds? My Mom's side of the family came from that line , my Grandmother was one her whole life. They look very similar to standard Mennonite with print dresses but have the cape and bonnet like the Amish. They have very simple homes and drive only blue or black cars.
      I hope you keep posting, it was very interesting.
      Here are some things that I'm curious about : Do the Pastors get training in the ancient languages of the bible? Where would they go for that?
      Since my experience in a church that taught heretical stuff I'm always so cautious about churches .
      Also do you witness to people to bring them into the kingdom? I got the idea that your church does do that.
      I loved the outreach to the community that you spoke about so many churches today are so inclusive.
      Have a blessed day!

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      @@rhondahart2416 Thanks so much for sharing this story with me!! There are hundreds of Mennonite churches that don't dress as people typically envision the Mennonites to dress, not just the group of Mennonite that I am with (Mosaic Conference). I think the reason for this is that we also go around the world as missionaries and connect with people. We don't expect them to suddenly dress in an old German or Dutch Mennonite standard from the 1600s-1800s look when their cultures are so much different. I will definitely do more Mennonite videos soon and will try my best to answer your questions better in those. I have been planning a few. I think, ultimately, legalism can kill a church quickly and turn people away from the simplicity of the gospel.
      I am aware of the German Baptists and Dunkerds.
      The old German language I brought up, is what the Amish do in their messages, not the Mennonite. We preach in English and other languages from other countries in whatever they can understand. My church is bilingual and does all the services in English and Spanish (which I don't know much Spanish at all, but I am one of the only white people who attends my church. . most are from Latin-based countries, the Caribbean, or are African American).
      Are you without a church currently? Are you in fellowship with other believers regularly (which is also church)? I can understand being timid about joining one if you experienced something not so good in the church you had left. I hope you find a place where you can worship with other believers and be a part of a community of people with.
      Ah, yeah, we have a church of Jehovah's Witnesses near here and many have tried to give me materials and stop by my house and I am nice to them and have had conversations. I know someone who came out of that church and they were brainwashed and had to go through this really weird training that made them go through such crazy abuses. It is pretty bad. Glad you minister to those who are in that.
      Thanks for commenting!

    • @rhondahart2416
      @rhondahart2416 Місяць тому +1

      @@TheMennomilist I had forgotten that Mennonites go around the world on missions. I have a recipe book somewhere stashed that has recipes from Mennonite women around the world. Interesting ingredients sometimes but really very basic everyday things getting by on minimal ingredients with maximum impact for health.
      We have attended a Baptist based church in our area for a year but currently are worshipping online because my husbands health has not been good in the last few weeks. He is now getting stabilized so we can attend again soon.
      I tend to lean towards Calvary Chapel teachings but that church is too far for us.
      I also like community churches . We have to be careful where we live because churches do not announce their affiliation on their signs or web sites then you go and find out there's some strange stuff going on. That is how we got into the AG church. I love fellowship with other believers and right now most of it is online but I have some core friends in person too.
      Looking forward to more of your stuff! Blessings!

  • @Dustinicus.
    @Dustinicus. 2 місяці тому +2

    amish people with cell phones and cars

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  2 місяці тому +1

      If you see Amish with these things they are either kids in their Rumspringa or they are Mennonite that you are mistaking as Amish. :)

    • @Dustinicus.
      @Dustinicus. Місяць тому +2

      @TheMennomilist that's what I meant. Mennonite are Amish with cell phones and cars. I understand there is more too it than that. I was tr6ing to be cheeky

    • @miriamhershberger5343
      @miriamhershberger5343 Місяць тому

      I don't understand a nose ring or tattoos on anybody. Please explain what the motive is behind it.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      @@miriamhershberger5343 I will address this in a future video.

    • @tammyblack2747
      @tammyblack2747 Місяць тому

      @@miriamhershberger5343she was not raised as a Mennonite.

  • @lindseykathryn5746
    @lindseykathryn5746 Місяць тому +1

    You left out Apostolics.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      I didn't really go into the early 1900s denominations since I was focusing on the ones from the Reformation time and the history of the Mennonites. :)

    • @lindseykathryn5746
      @lindseykathryn5746 Місяць тому +1

      @TheMennomilist They were founded in the 1800s and also in the same regions as Amish and Mennonites. Also, when you were talking about the clothing differences between Amish and Mennonite, they could also be Apostolic, which is easier to confuse since their dress and manners association with modern technology is closer to Mennonites than Amish are.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      @@lindseykathryn5746 Ah, I see. The Mennonites were established in the 1600s during the Reformation so that's why I wouldn't have covered that, and the question asked wanted to know the difference between Mennonite and Amish. Thanks for letting me know a little more about the Apostolics. I was always told they started in about 1903 or so. I would have to research them further. Were they part of the Brethren Quakers maybe or even separate from them?

    • @lindseykathryn5746
      @lindseykathryn5746 Місяць тому

      @TheMennomilist No, they were founded in 1832 in Switzerland by Samuel Froehlich. From there, a member of the Amish Mennonite church in Ohio Joseph Virkler requested Froehlich to send a brother to visit and teach, so Benedict Weyeneth was sent and the first Apostolic church was founded in Sardis Ohio. I'm not very familiar with how it spread from there, I am not Apostolic myself, but I lived with them for several years as well as Mennonites and Amish. I love your story and enjoy learning how God leads His children on their journey in this world. God bless you, and may His grace and face shine upon you.

    • @TheMennomilist
      @TheMennomilist  Місяць тому

      @@lindseykathryn5746 Ah, well if the Apostolic church stemmed from the Anabaptists originally, this is the first I heard of it! Thanks. That's really cool.
      I appreciate your comments and thank you for watching/listening! May God be with you daily!

  • @Larry-fj1eo
    @Larry-fj1eo Місяць тому

    CAN'T TOLERATE THE INK!

    • @Sandra-hk8ks
      @Sandra-hk8ks Місяць тому

      Thank goodness they can be removed now