It's amazing how they can put 4 generations of amazing Korean female vocalists in one song Hyein: 15 years old IU: 30 years old Joe Won-sun: 51 years old Patti Kim (Narrator): 85 years old
In an interview IU said the song is about special women in our lives. IU sing about her mother, Hyein is about her first friend and Wonsun Joe about her role model
@@Itzme_shravyablackpink's typa girl has a line "im not like the other girls at all" about other bp songs, i don't know. and got's step back has "step back step back silly girls" but that song also has a "girls bring it on" so it's kinda confusing
I'm happy that Hyein said she wants to follow the steps of IU to be someone who can put her thoughts into words. She is right, IU has the most genius lyrics in the Korean industry. JYP said that he met only 2 artists who could understand the composer's idea and what he wanted one of them was IU.
In Tang Wei's letter to IU, it was said that through the making of this music video and the line from the song, she wondered if her eyes were really like her mother's and she really wanted to check it out. She also said that she thought about how she imagined her mom in her younger years. And she realized that this image is not clear, because she was not part of her life then and she only knows it from her father's words and photos. On the set she imagined that she met her in her younger years and suddenly realized that her mother was just like her - young, beautiful and shining on stage. I think both the song and the video express that the relationship between mom and daughter is a special bond. Something beyond friendship and beyond love. Something special. One thing continues the other. When you're a kid you're sometimes unable to understand why mom acts a certain way. You know and see mom from one side. But when you grow up, you understand her better. Because you start to see the world from her perspective. And this story repeats itself again only with another child and another mom. A amazing song and music film on the theme of the connection of women in the family and their sometimes difficult relationships on the way to understanding each other.
Big shoutout to Hyein. She's just debuting, but she gonna have a wonderful career. I cannot forgot IU's expression while Hyein was singing at IU palette. That was the exact moment
In the MV credit they even mentioned Hyein’s vocal director. I guess she still needs a lot of guidance while working with other veteran singers in this song but still well done to her! Love every part of this song and the music video🥹
How can wverything be perfect about This Album? The Vocals, The Collaborations, The MVs and The Lyrics. IU really is legendary and My Genius Maknae Hyein slayed so much. Her Vocals are really special♡
사실 탕웨이님의 편지를 보기 전까지는 이 뮤비와 노래가 담은 메세지를 잘 파악하지 못하고 있었는데요, 편지를 통해 shh..가 엄마와 딸의 이야기임을 알게 된 순간 저는 정말 오열을 했습니다. 내가 우리 부모님께서 내게 쏟은 사랑을 온전히 이해하고 진심으로 감사해하고 있었는지, 나는 우리 부모님에게 그의 반이라도 되는 사랑을 베풀고 있는지. 나에게 엄마는 어떤 존재인지, 그리고 엄마에게 나는 어떤 존재일지. 뮤비처럼 내가 익숙치 않은, 젊은 모습의 엄마와 만나게 된다면 나는 과연 엄마를 알아볼까? 나는 엄마와 친해지고 사랑을 줄 수 있을까? 이런 생각들이 머릿속에서 꼬리를 물며 흘러가는데 그냥 눈물이 자동으로 나오고 있더라고요. 저는 이 곡이 '이 세상 모든 참된 엄마의 승리' 라는 메세지를 담았다고 느꼈어요. 가사에서 '그 이름은 mom'이 아니라 'Shh..'라고 부여한 이유도 엄마를 '엄마' 라는 단어 안에 가두지 않고, 엄마의 모습을 내가 현재 보고 있는 세월의 흔적이 잔뜩 묻은 엄마에 가두지 않고, 엄마에게 자기자신으로서의 '이름을 붙일 자유'를 선사해주고 싶음이 아닐까, 그래서 이름을 소개하는 자리를 침묵으로, 열린 이름으로 비워둔 것이 아닌가 싶었습니다. 늘 "너는 '딸' 이라는 단어 안에 갇혀 있으면 안 돼, 너의 이름으로 너의 삶을 살아" 라고 이야기하는 엄마에게, "너는 '엄마' 라는 단어에 갇혀있으면 안 돼, 너의 이름으로 너의 삶을 살아." 라며 딸이 이야기해주는 것만 같았어요. 그리고 저도 진심으로 우리 엄마가 그렇게 살아갔으면 좋겠어요. 늘 내가 우선이고 나에게 언제나 조건없는 사랑을 주는 우리 엄마에게, 본인은 늘 당연하게 주고 살아서 자신이 선사한 그 거대한 사랑의 크기를 짐작조차하지 못하고 있을 우리 엄마에게 똑같은 크기의 사랑을 쏟고 싶어요. 이제 나는 성인이 되었으니 엄마의 우선은 엄마로 두어도 괜찮다고 말해주고 싶어요. 그리고 자기자신으로서 맞이하는 엄마의 승리를 조건없이 믿어주고 응원해주고 싶어요. 제가 아직 이 곡과 이 뮤비가 담은 깊은 속사정을 온전히 이해하지는 못했겠지만, shh..를 통해 얻은 '엄마의 삶과 엄마의 사랑' 에 대한 저의 새로운 시선을 기록해봅니다. 이 곡 발매해주셔서, 탕웨이님 편지 공유해주셔서 감사합니다. 그리고 아름답고도 울림있는 편지를 작성해주신 탕웨이님께도 감사합니다.
처음 듣고 울뻔했네요. 초반부 가사를 보니 엄마와 딸의 이야기같았는데 중간부가면서 아닌가 싶다가 마지막 패티김님이 쉬,,, 하는걸 들으며 엄마가 애기들 달랠 때 업어가며 그런 소리 내잖아요. 괜찮아 울지마 쉬,,, 하고. 엄마 생각이 나더라구요. 아이유님, 앞으로도 오래 음악해주세요.
I'm actually a sucker for a time slip drama, the one that about a child who went to the past and meet the younger version of their parents, and finally understand their parents better, like twinkling watermelon & my perfect stranger are among my top dramas. And to know that iu also did that kinda story in a song and mv is wild for me. She literally executes everything in a freaking song, and the mv really complete the song, makes me understand the song better. At first listen, I already like the song even without understanding the back story yet, but after the disclosure of the mv, i like it much more. IU, you are such an amazing storyteller.
This MV is about a complicated yet fulfilling story between a mother & daughter. IU is the mother here. When it's HYEIN's lines, that is the POV of a daughter & same as Joe Won Sun in the perspective of a mother. In the last few seconds of the MV, which shows different generations of Korean women, and for this part, the Narration by Patti Kim (SK Legend artist who alrdy retired in her '80s) comes in.
@@jords533 The description is lyrics in the song + the description of the genre, this person is right, its not only a complex story between mother and daughter relationships, it is also about complex female relationship, how we are the product of all the women before us, its a love letter to all women, of all generations
This! From the lyrics and the MV, I can totally see the generational division IU portrayed. I love how the lyrics during Hyein is in a younger female POV, more innocent and not knowing the feelings they have. Then in Joe Won Sun's lyrics, she's definitely more matured and embraced her feelings, whatever it is. And i love olithecat's description, "its a love letter to all women, of all generations"
Usually it's IU's vocals that elicit so many emotions and goosebumps out of me. But when she adds the visuals and emotional stories through the types of thought-provoking music videos as she has in the four mv's related to "The Winning," the combinations are extremely powerful. This one pretty much had me on sensory overload, again. Shoutout to Hyein for her wonderful voice and performance as well. More evidence to me that IU is one of the best all-around singers, songwriters, actresses, producers, and creative minds in my lifetime. I'm 68.
열등감을 자극하면서도 동경하게 되는, 옭아매다가도 놓아주고 싶게 되는, 친구이다가도 적이 되는, 멀리 떨어뜨리고 싶지만 곧 다시 보고싶어지는... 이런 복잡한 관계를 엄마와 딸의 관계로 빗대어 표현한게 아닐까 싶기도 하고. 정말 미묘하고 깊은 관계성에 대해 너무 감각적이고 운치있게 표현했어요
이건 정말 영감을 주는 작품이네요.. 마냥 아릅답지만도, 마냥 예쁘고 곱지만은 않으면서도 그렇기에 서글프고 애잔함이 깃들어있는 복잡하고 깊은 엄마와 딸의 관계성이 입체적이면서도 감각적으로 표현되어있어 놀랐어요. 너무 세련된 느낌으로, 너무나 깊은 감성과 절제된 느낌으로. 4분여동안 저를 강하게 울리고 가네요. 두분의 눈빛연기가 정말 아름다워요. 가사도 정말 밀도높은 감동입니다. 아이유라는 가수가 다시보여요
the description of this mv says: 'It's not just a friendship story. It's not just a love story. There was something more complicated between her and me.' beautiful❤
@@yvesxiao9138I tried translating the following part of the description and it goes something like this 'Names that win me everytime. Names that don't leave my mind. who led me to who I am now. The names that make me up somewhere inside of me. To them who will be special and complex for a long time.' I think it can be interpreted in different ways but it might also be about the people she has lost
아이유 음악에 매번 느껴지는 건 전체적인 바탕이 서늘하고 쓸쓸한 느낌인데, 사랑이 빼꼼하고 고개들고 있는 그런 걸 매번 느낀다. 음악이 그런 것인지 아이유 음색 때문인지 아이유라는 사람때문인지 모르겠지만 아마 다 섞여 있겠지.서늘한 마음에도 사랑이 느껴져서 외로움이 따뜻하게 느껴지는 그런.. 잘 다독여주는 거 같다.
1:39 hyein's voice is soooo soothing to hear 😭 even tho she's only 15 yr old but she manage to have vocals like that really suprised me! 😭😭 ANJIR 271 LIKE
gimana ya jelasinnya, kontrol suaranya itu loh enak di kuping. ada penyanyi yg punya suara bagus tapi belum tentu bagus di kontrol suara, tapi hyein ini bisa dua duanya, keren emang.
IU is such a rare artist. Every MV song she puts out invokes specific feelings. I didn't expect to like "Shh..." to be so atmospheric and ambient, breathing a sense of sophistication - so ripen with restrained emotions. Perhaps it's my preference for R&B sound. As I admire those tracks in this album, dare I say this is my favorite song from her in this comeback. Seriously, this song is meant for adults.
이 곡은 이지은이 살면서 영향을 받은 여자들의 이야기이다 아이유의 엄마, 아이유의 첫 친구이자 경쟁자, 아이유의 롤 모델 이 모든 복합적인 감정을 표현한 shh 마지막 에필로그에 나오는 젊은 여자 둘은 친구 사이가 아닐까 싶다 좋아하지만 경쟁하고 미워도 하는.. 와씨.. 아이유랑 어머니 인터뷰 영상 보고 오니까 이 노래 개미쳤네.. 내 가난한 상상력으로는 떠올릴 수 없는 진짜 멋지고 대단한 곡이였어
When she became a mother, she realized why her mother had locked her up, and they reconcile. As they grow older, they become friends. Eventually, the relationship will continue in their next lives.
YES! I would LOVE to see them do a movie together. Add Zhang Ziyi & Michelle Yeoh as part of the cast & it would be a dream come true. The best Asian actresses in a movie together.
Speechless. Amazing! Is the “song” saying there is a story? Is it because we as daughters never get to call our mums by name, she has named her as shh? That’s so poignant and bittersweet. It could be about empowerment.. and I think knowing IU, I’d like to see its also a tribute and public show of admiration for all mums and grandmums- including hers :’) This is called The Winning album for a reason! IU has been the reason for me to dive into kpop. Since then I have come to appreciate more of other kpop artistes and groups in their hard work and music too. But IU is really on the another level of music creation. No wonder many kpop hoobaes look to her as their role model. And reading Tang Wei’s letter to IU again solidifies my thought that she is not only highly respected as an artiste but also as another fellow human living in this time. IU has long time established she writes songs not only to make it trendy or simply make a statement… I think anyone can make a statement today - like all of us here. but you can see and hear that she wants to tell a narrative, an idea, a perspective that are also good, beautiful, empowering, full of light and love. Thank you IU, what a refreshing album that marks the start of your 30s. :) Now I just hope I’ll get to see you live this year!!!
after ruminating on the lyrics.... wow I love it even more. The complicated levels of emotions and sentiments toward the mum and daughter relationship is very real and raw. Ah... what an art. IU's music is one that you could just take time to digest further and appreciate, and interact with your own life. :)
인생은 영화라는 게 존재만으로도 표출이 되는 아이유, 탕웨이, 이혜인, 조원선, 패티김님. 그녀들의 교집합을 찾아 예술로 표현해 내는 아이유님의 능력에 감타과 찬사를 보냅니다. 저는 처음 Shh.. 뮤비를 보고 유전이 가장 먼저 떠올랐어요. 부모에서 자식으로 대물림 되는 유전자를 말하고 싶은데.. 익숙함에 무심히 지나치는 같은 핏줄의 관계성에 대해 잠시 멈춰 생각해 볼 수 있는 시간을 만들어 주는 음악이 아닌가 싶습니다. 아이유님은 이 세상에 중요하지 않은 것들이 없다는 것을 잘 찾아내고 잘 알고 계신 사람 같습니다. 알면 알수록 멋있는 여자 아이유.. 최고..
어릴때는 엄마를 너무 밉고, 제일 싫어했던 건 바로 엄마를 닮게 생기는거였어요. 역시 엄마가 나를 사랑하지 않고, 그리고 그녀의 행동 하나하나가 항상 나는 엄마에게 그저 부담이거다, 이렇게 느꼈던 거든요. ”날 싫어 해요?저도 엄마가 싫어해요”. 이런 시절 있죠. 이제 나이 좀 먹다보니 느꼈던게, 사실은 엄마도 엄마가 처음이어가지고, 누구도 쉽지 않을거다. 점점 이해가되고, 사실 엄마가 나를 사랑한거고, 저도 엄마가 사랑한것 같은데, 이 관계가 참 묘해요.. it’s not about friend, not about love. 근데 이 뮤비같은 꿈 한번 꿀 수 있으면 좋겠어요,, 저도 궁금해요 우리 엄마가 뭘 숨겨는지. 쑥스러워서 직접 말 못하는데,, 여기서 할계요 엄마!!!! 사랑해요🌚
I had the same experience. As I get older and have become a mother, my perspective has changed a lot. I try to focus on her positive traits and appreciate her as a person.
뮤비는 어머니와 딸의 관계에서 느껴지는 감정을 다루고 있고 그만의 분위기가 느껴져서 잘 감상했어요. 탕웨이님과 아이유님의 흔들리던 눈동자가 너무 좋았어요. 가사도 언급하고 싶어요. 좀 더 넓은 여자 간의 관계에 대해 다루고 있는 것 같은데, 인상적이고 좋았습니다. 여자가 같은 여자에게서 느끼는 동경, 질투, 미움, 그리움, 소유욕 등등 여자이기 전에 본연 사람이라서 느끼는 그런 유대에서 오는 감정들을 사랑과 우정이라 뭉그트려버리지 않고 'we got something else' 라고 제대로 짚어준 가사가 작사가의 섬세함이 돋보여서 마음에 들었습니다. 그런 동경과 질투, 미움, 그리움, 소유욕 등 그 여자들의 조각을 받아 이루어진 한 여자의 세계는 어쩌면 한 사람의 인생에서 그 사람을 구성하는 영원한 유대의 세계관이네요. 여러 생각이 들게하는 가사입니다.
I think the mobius strip isn't a symbol for infinity, it's a symbol for two sides that are really one. That ambiguity of where something ends and another thing starts,,,where one person ends and another side of their personality begins. In the narration lyrics we have the translation "known by everyone and no one at the same time." A mobius strip has the contradiction that there's actually only one side, but it presents as two, there's an illusion or "mask" hiding something deeper, and these lyrics point out a similar contradiction between the known and unknown sides of this person. What's the unknown side? The imagery in the MV and more importantly the acting and way the two characters (IU and Tang Wei) interact with each other is through eye contact, a whisper, and a revelation. It's this dance of "do you see me? do you see beneath my mask, my layers?" and once you feel like they do, you start to wonder if you can unveil whatever secret you have to them. Something you've hidden so securely and locked away so completely that you fear anyone finding it out. But there's some similarity there, "my eyes are just like hers" and you're drawn to them, to this idea that someone could see you and you can share your dark secret, "a happy nightmare." This dance almost feels to me like a spider weaving a web,,, not to catch it's prey necessarily but to be in control of the web, to have bases covered and traps laid to keep you out of trouble. We see IU crawling. The lyrics describe being lured by "Long footseps." We see Tang Wei "jump" close to IU and stare at her with an unnerving smile. "Haha, nowhere to run, I see you." It's this "overarching presence" that's "forever a step ahead" that sees you despite you trying to hide ("I stay silent") Take a look again at the way the characters interact BEFORE sharing their secrets. There's knowing smiles, hesitating eye contact, and holding back tears. It seems like they feel caught, or found out, that maybe this fear of being discovered is finally coming to pass. At first there's a reluctance to admit it -- see how slowly Tang Wei first meets IU's intense gaze. Then a resignation. Have you ever held a deep secret? Something you fear being judged for if found out? I'm not talking about anything illegal but maybe something psychological, something related to your identity. And maybe that eats at you. You've imagined it time and time again what you would do if someone found out. But what if someone saw behind your mask without you saying anything? Maybe that person really sees you. Maybe you can reveal this secret which has eaten at you and be free from all those pent up fears. And that's what we see: revealing a daughter that's no longer there, revealing a twin that's dead (? or kidnapped in the boot of the car). My interpretation of the twin is that it's repressing part of their personality. Again, the way these are revealed hint that they're deep secrets. IU isn't even looking into the trunk when Tang Wei's opening it, she's looking at Tang Wei. Tang Wei isn't looking into the cellar door when IU opens it, she's looking at IU with a smile and tears in her eyes. And that smile has changed from the unnerving "ha ha I see what you're hiding" to "oh silly, you're still human." It's a beautiful portrayal of seeing the person behind the trauma. IU's character only has photos of this person as a kid. We can only presume she's passed or no longer in her life. And holding that in and presenting a brave face to the world can tear apart a person. Finally sharing that side of the mobius strip, tearing away that illusion of two sides leaves you feeling so vulnerable. And we have Tang Wei accepting and smiling at IU's character. "Oh silly, that's what you've been hiding?" What we get at the end scene between them comes off as redemption. Someone on their knees reaching out, then being lifted up and hugged signifies redemption arc. Remember they just revealed their secret to each other, and now it's IU's turn to accept Tang Wei. To hug and accept that they are still human. That despite this contradiction in their head that they're misunderstood, that they're hiding half of themselves, IU's hug is her saying "you're still human, you're still complete." When someone sees you as you, when they can take in the whole picture, there's no more mask. There's no two sides. And like the mobius strip you realize that you are you completely, one and whole. That's such a liberating experience, I think that's why we get the narration at the end. To encourage sharing these stories, these characters who live a life feeling misunderstood, trapped, and like they're not fully themselves, but after sharing their secrets with a trusted one, they're liberated.
You've just gutted me in the best possible way. Both IU and you perfectly illustrated my own relationship with my mother. Hopefully it's still unfinished.
This is a very beutiful and deep interpretation! I would also like to share mine a little bit, a little different perspective on the twin part. For me IU's and Tang Wei's characters portray mother and daughter respectivelly. At the start of the MV you can see and old picture of IU with her daughter and the apartment itself is quite old (old fashioned) as well, but when we see the street on the outside where IU is walking near shopwindow, we can understand that this is around our time. Tang Wei's style says the same thing to me since it's different from photos and IU's flashback. "Some long time ago, She hid her mother away" For me Tang Wei is a daughter who came back to her mothers apartment, maybe for the first time in years. And IU's character in the same apartment is like the memories that are tied to it, warm memories you can't escape or run away from (in this case memories associated with mother). "She hid her mother away" in my opinion might refer to child's anger for mother, not understanding and not wanting to understand her point of view. To me it also could mean that after growing up and losing her mom (here i'm judjing from actresses' ages and IU's quite young looks), daughter may have hid all the memories deep within herself. So seeing her mother again, coming back to her mother's apartment once again and even talking to her (whispering), this time not as a child to mother, but as a woman to a woman, helped Tang Wei to finally understand and/or fully accept her mother (and all the memories) afer all these years. And opening to these memories and feelings made her more complete person, since after this we might see her smile a bit, in contradiction to the start of the MV. So I think that the light under this kind of wooden hatch was all those forgotten, all those hidden deep inside memories and all the tied to this place memories associated with mother. "She was my friend long ago. I hid her away, too." Now we see Tang Wei looking at IU (in the car), I see it as she now understands her mother better, as if she became alive once again, young and beautiful as her daughter is now, as if they could talk to no end just like old friends. But if daughter opened to her, now it's IU's turn to unveil her secrets. And so, for me the twin symbolizes all the love, care and desire to protect her child, such strong that she (IU) eventually tries to hide her daughter from all the bad things in the world (which migh've led to misunderstandings and anger). This opening also might symbolize all the impurities and imperfections of mother she's finally willing to share with her daughter. Taking each other's hand, looking in each other's eyes and hugging each other to me stands for finally forgiving and accepting each other with all the imperfections and impurites, becoming complete with themselves and with the other side. They saw each others naked truth and once again became a family. In this case I think narration might refer to widespread of this kind of relationship/problem ("old tale"), where a lot of people might find themselves in a similar situation ("Known by everyone"), "And no one at the same time" because not many are ready to open up and go through expirience characters in MV went throug. And the scene we see during the credits supports that point for me. I liked very much your thoughts on secrets and liberation, I strongly support them. Your interpretation is truly beautiful and in my opinion deserves more recognition in this comment section and even beyond when it comes to "Shh..".
약간 곡이 '그 사람' 느낌도 나고 '빈 컵' 느낌도 나는데 또 그 특유의 나른함도 있어서 새로워요! 진짜 아이유 언니 목소리랑 찰떡 ... 다른 가수분들 목소리도 너무 좋고 같이 뮤비 찍어주신 탕웨이님 연기도 미쳤고 여러모로 영화 보는 기분 들었어요 이번 앨범 타이틀부터 수록곡까지 다 너무 좋네요 뮤비 너무 감명 깊게 보고 가요♡♡
I love how it was IU & Hyein in a song together. Hyein has made it this far to collab with one of the biggest K-pop soloists & I’m so proud of her. This mv is honestly so beautiful & the song has such a deep meaning.
Such a beautiful song with different generations of women featured. IU is a genius lyricist!! The way she described the mother and daughter relationship is so clever and relatable.
i really truly admire IU and her embodiment of womanhood. Although most women would use their sexiness & beauty to feel empowered, IU would flaunt her brain, artistry, musicality and talent. Her music, art and even choices in films/movies doesn't add to the objectification of women. Even in this song, it was focused on the qualities of womanhood in different generations with different roles that makes them unique, special and connected. I am always in awe with her lyricism. My favorite lyrics of her in this song 2:50 Like an old soliloquy that has never stopped, here’s to those women who remain an enigma forever etched somewhere in my time
you should watch IU interview with her mom now, those lyric is to described her mom. it was great interview though, i began to admire not just IU, but her mom also now XD
IU does "add to the objectification of women." She 1) uses her "beauty" and "cuteness" to appeal to men, and 2) depicts women as objects of male desire and validation. This is evident in her MVs and songs, which frequently feature her singing to or about men
Why do we compare all the women who are killing it? Comparison broods insecurity. Putting IU in a high pedestal while degrading others is the point of the song as IU has been compared to those before her. And those women have to somehow “kill and burry” a part of their inner self just to “appeal” better. Women are all an enigma whatever HER name is. Ji-Eun’s brave for putting out this feminist song.
I just found out about Jo Woo Sun, a unique singer with a stunning voice. finally found out about JWS. She's really interesting. So far I've only watched IU and nothing else. IU, u r the godmother of kpop.
It really amaze me how you come up with SHH. The F and L. If you type F in a keyboard you'll get (ㄹ) and if L you'll get (l) and if you put them together you'll get(리) Lee💜. The one who entered concert halls with flutterd clothes and flashing lights, exits by only wearing comfortable clothes and just being true to herself. Known by everyone and no one at the same time. Her name is Shh(이지은)
It expressed the heartbreaking illegitimate child, the empty sorrow, the female psychology of strange affinity, and the unique characteristics of women who embrace and protect past pain.
This song and mv are among the reasons why IU’s music, just like her bff Taehyung’s, for me go beyond k-pop. They both create pure art full of symbolism and meaning and their music and vision is unique.
I want to know my mom as just her, without the title of daughter,wife or a mother to define her. However, infront of me she has only ever shown her role as a mother. I think it is because 'mom' has become a part of her soul that she cannot do without Infront of her daughter. When I think of home I think of mom. She is a little silly and definitely a flawed human being but the warmth she brings is something nobody else will ever be able to give me in life. She is my best friend, mom, companion and the one person I am sure I could always count on. I love you mom, always. Sorry, just ignore me. I was just venting.
This reminds me of the quote “As a woman I have so much empathy for my mother, but as a daughter, I have so much anger. “
Wow I've never heard that outside my own head before. Funny how we always think we're the only ones. Who said it?
@@CleoHarperReturns It’s from a poetry book called ‘My father’s eye, my mother’s rage’ by Rose Brink.
@@Sleepy-bg8seThank you! I'm going to look it up right now
this teared me up....
Frrr
I never expected IU and Hyein to be in a song together 🥹
True
Real💕
I knew the moment she gasped on IU’s Palette
It's amazing how they can put 4 generations of amazing Korean female vocalists in one song
Hyein: 15 years old
IU: 30 years old
Joe Won-sun: 51 years old
Patti Kim (Narrator): 85 years old
that's the power of IU!!! i even never portray tangwei in IU's mv at all~
i felt like ui was going to eventually collab with hyein from the minute iu heard her sing on her show 🫶🏼
One question, is the one called Hyein the one from NewJeans?
@@natalitellomozombite8686Yes!
Daughters, mom, grandma. Generational collaboration 🤣 Patti Kim is Korea's legendary female singer. IU's casting ability is crazy 💜
In an interview IU said the song is about special women in our lives. IU sing about her mother, Hyein is about her first friend and Wonsun Joe about her role model
Yet somehow it all adds up to each other so well. Their parts are so complementing
in kpop where most songs about women talks about them being better than other girls. hearing this song is really a breath of fresh air.
this song sounds sooooo deep..
stares at got the beats step back lyric video
Lmfao I’m still angry about that song @@worldwidefunnyguy
Uh since when do most songs have women talking about them being better then other girls?? 💀 never heard of any.
@@Itzme_shravyablackpink's typa girl has a line "im not like the other girls at all" about other bp songs, i don't know. and got's step back has "step back step back silly girls" but that song also has a "girls bring it on" so it's kinda confusing
Hyein's voice sounds so good in this song. Not too high, not too low, really sublime.
I'm happy that Hyein said she wants to follow the steps of IU to be someone who can put her thoughts into words. She is right, IU has the most genius lyrics in the Korean industry. JYP said that he met only 2 artists who could understand the composer's idea and what he wanted one of them was IU.
Who was the other?
The other?
@@lXlLADYLiCiOUS thas Tang Wei famous chinese actress
@@kunalparmar873 ooh.. the fact that both hey and IU are in this together 😮
@@gabrielabowsun4764Kim Bum Soo
In Tang Wei's letter to IU, it was said that through the making of this music video and the line from the song, she wondered if her eyes were really like her mother's and she really wanted to check it out. She also said that she thought about how she imagined her mom in her younger years. And she realized that this image is not clear, because she was not part of her life then and she only knows it from her father's words and photos. On the set she imagined that she met her in her younger years and suddenly realized that her mother was just like her - young, beautiful and shining on stage. I think both the song and the video express that the relationship between mom and daughter is a special bond. Something beyond friendship and beyond love. Something special. One thing continues the other. When you're a kid you're sometimes unable to understand why mom acts a certain way. You know and see mom from one side. But when you grow up, you understand her better. Because you start to see the world from her perspective. And this story repeats itself again only with another child and another mom. A amazing song and music film on the theme of the connection of women in the family and their sometimes difficult relationships on the way to understanding each other.
The best explanation 😢
thanks for that ❤
So beautifully said! Thank you.
This comment is so helping me.
I get it. So beautiful song and video 😊
Thank you for your explanation 🎉🎉❤
Big shoutout to Hyein. She's just debuting, but she gonna have a wonderful career. I cannot forgot IU's expression while Hyein was singing at IU palette. That was the exact moment
girl she debuted two years ago that’s not just debuting
32 minutes in from that episode, yeah?
@tesiii I think they meant her debuting as a solo artist. This is her first song collaborating without the other members. So, it kinda counts as one.
In the MV credit they even mentioned Hyein’s vocal director. I guess she still needs a lot of guidance while working with other veteran singers in this song but still well done to her! Love every part of this song and the music video🥹
Wait but I don't see hyein can you tell me where she is? (Not hating I can't find hyein that's it)
Hyein’s verse was so beautiful
And chorus!
IU & Hyein's voice chemistry is already heavenly but adding the varsetile actress Tang wei as the female lead in the MV is just fireeeee 🔥
This is why IU is the best solo artist in k pop industry
Right her voice is so enchanting I also see hyein in her
FACT.
Absolutely
REAL
True
How can wverything be perfect about This Album? The Vocals, The Collaborations, The MVs and The Lyrics. IU really is legendary and My Genius Maknae Hyein slayed so much. Her Vocals are really special♡
Finally, a kpop fan that doesn't just say "omg the ~visuals~"
I really hope Hyein gets more popular
Her visual is crazy & her voice is genuinely lovely
It's not just a simple MV, it's like a movie trailer.
We need IUTV for the filming of all MVs in this album 🥰🤭
각각의 나이대의 여자들의 모여서 만들어진 하나의 작품.. 각자의 음색이 돋보여서 더 매력적인 음악이였는데 뮤비에서는 탕웨이님과 아이유님의 연기가 더 해져서 더 갓벽해졌다..
Omg Tang Wei acted so good in this MV. Her storytelling eyes are filled with emotions and stories...
젊은 시절 기억속의 사진속의 엄마와 똑같은 모습의 낯선여자 그리고 딸이 나이가 들었어도 한눈에 먼저 알아본 엄마.. 울컥하네요
그런거예요? 나는 옛날 연인이 환생해서 서롤 알아본건 줄
탕웨이편지 너무 멋있었음
True
사랑해요 아이유
F(friendship)에 대한 것이 아니다 L(love)도 아니다. 자신의 내면아이와 자아에 대한 내용이에요
사실 탕웨이님의 편지를 보기 전까지는 이 뮤비와 노래가 담은 메세지를 잘 파악하지 못하고 있었는데요,
편지를 통해 shh..가 엄마와 딸의 이야기임을 알게 된 순간 저는 정말 오열을 했습니다.
내가 우리 부모님께서 내게 쏟은 사랑을 온전히 이해하고 진심으로 감사해하고 있었는지,
나는 우리 부모님에게 그의 반이라도 되는 사랑을 베풀고 있는지.
나에게 엄마는 어떤 존재인지, 그리고 엄마에게 나는 어떤 존재일지.
뮤비처럼 내가 익숙치 않은, 젊은 모습의 엄마와 만나게 된다면 나는 과연 엄마를 알아볼까?
나는 엄마와 친해지고 사랑을 줄 수 있을까?
이런 생각들이 머릿속에서 꼬리를 물며 흘러가는데 그냥 눈물이 자동으로 나오고 있더라고요.
저는 이 곡이 '이 세상 모든 참된 엄마의 승리' 라는 메세지를 담았다고 느꼈어요.
가사에서 '그 이름은 mom'이 아니라 'Shh..'라고 부여한 이유도
엄마를 '엄마' 라는 단어 안에 가두지 않고,
엄마의 모습을 내가 현재 보고 있는 세월의 흔적이 잔뜩 묻은 엄마에 가두지 않고,
엄마에게 자기자신으로서의 '이름을 붙일 자유'를 선사해주고 싶음이 아닐까,
그래서 이름을 소개하는 자리를 침묵으로, 열린 이름으로 비워둔 것이 아닌가 싶었습니다.
늘 "너는 '딸' 이라는 단어 안에 갇혀 있으면 안 돼, 너의 이름으로 너의 삶을 살아" 라고 이야기하는 엄마에게, "너는 '엄마' 라는 단어에 갇혀있으면 안 돼, 너의 이름으로 너의 삶을 살아." 라며 딸이 이야기해주는 것만 같았어요. 그리고 저도 진심으로 우리 엄마가 그렇게 살아갔으면 좋겠어요.
늘 내가 우선이고 나에게 언제나 조건없는 사랑을 주는 우리 엄마에게, 본인은 늘 당연하게 주고 살아서 자신이 선사한 그 거대한 사랑의 크기를 짐작조차하지 못하고 있을 우리 엄마에게 똑같은 크기의 사랑을 쏟고 싶어요. 이제 나는 성인이 되었으니 엄마의 우선은 엄마로 두어도 괜찮다고 말해주고 싶어요. 그리고 자기자신으로서 맞이하는 엄마의 승리를 조건없이 믿어주고 응원해주고 싶어요.
제가 아직 이 곡과 이 뮤비가 담은 깊은 속사정을 온전히 이해하지는 못했겠지만, shh..를 통해 얻은 '엄마의 삶과 엄마의 사랑' 에 대한 저의 새로운 시선을 기록해봅니다. 이 곡 발매해주셔서, 탕웨이님 편지 공유해주셔서 감사합니다. 그리고 아름답고도 울림있는 편지를 작성해주신 탕웨이님께도 감사합니다.
솔직히 그 편지 아니면 뮤비내용 이해하기 어려울것같은건 사실이네요ㅜ덕분에 이해 잘 되었습니다. 감사합니다.
Tks so much, you helped me to understand the story as well as meaning in this MV ❤
이 댓글 진짜 레전드
Sounds like you need to write Mom a letter.
와 미쳤다....
처음 듣고 울뻔했네요. 초반부 가사를 보니 엄마와 딸의 이야기같았는데 중간부가면서 아닌가 싶다가 마지막 패티김님이 쉬,,, 하는걸 들으며 엄마가 애기들 달랠 때 업어가며 그런 소리 내잖아요. 괜찮아 울지마 쉬,,, 하고. 엄마 생각이 나더라구요. 아이유님, 앞으로도 오래 음악해주세요.
진짜 울뻔했어요...?
저도 진짜 눈물그렁. 우리딸과 나의 관계가 미래에 이런 느낌일까싶기도 하고ㅎ
이런 상상력 부럽다
@@Certified_Appraiser노잼...
IU and Tangwei chemistry’s top teir🫣
딸이 딸이 아닌 한 여성으로, 엄마가 엄마가 아닌 한 여성으로… 서로 사랑했기에 서로를 가뒀지만 그 길을 벗어나 행복하길 바라는 마음을 느껴요..
근친아닌가요 여성으로왜사랑이나가냐고요 에휴 이번부른곡좀아니잖아요 여성이면어머니한테성이가나요?첫사랑이성적으로? 오디푸스?악몽? 아니그곳성욕??????느끼냐구요 더 궁금하게만드는 요상한고구린. 쉬? 어디벗어나서 사랑을 느껴요 그길을벗어나면 모텔가서 성욕해소가나요?아휴 뮤비도 무슨 빨간빛의모텔같은데서 칙어 ..저기 미아리아니죠?뭐하냐고요 짜증😢😢😢😢😢😢🎉🎉🎉🎉6
@@ct-fu1ei 님은 어떻게사시는지.. 님은 어머니나딸에게 저런고백받아봐요.. 으 왜 구리겡생각이나게 저런연기가있는지.. 난안괜찮은데 괜찮으면다가져요욕심 쇼퍼
@@만혈당뭐냐 이 댓글은 두서도 없고.. 해석이야 자유지만 왜이렇게 꼬였는지.. 뭐 1차원에 살기라도 함..?
뭔개소리냐 이제
@@만혈당일본인인가요? 한국 사람이 부모에게 사랑한다 하면 에로틱 밖에 생각 못하고 질색 한다든데
님 생각이 많이 징그럽네요
I'm actually a sucker for a time slip drama, the one that about a child who went to the past and meet the younger version of their parents, and finally understand their parents better, like twinkling watermelon & my perfect stranger are among my top dramas. And to know that iu also did that kinda story in a song and mv is wild for me. She literally executes everything in a freaking song, and the mv really complete the song, makes me understand the song better. At first listen, I already like the song even without understanding the back story yet, but after the disclosure of the mv, i like it much more. IU, you are such an amazing storyteller.
Hyein's vocals on this song show how talented she really is and everyone stanning NewJeans is sleeping on her so hard 😭
no fr they need to push her so much more
I love that IU was so smitten by her voice when NJ attended IU's show that she had to get Hyein's vocals in one of her songs!
which part is Hyein?
@@loveatris 1:33 from this it’s hyein
Her part is adding so much emotion to this song
hyein's voice is so unique. it touches my heart fr😭
what time
1:33
@@ujangrid
@@myura87241:30 to 2:22
❤
fr
1:30 HYEIN 🐣🐣 Bunnies is so proud of you 💕💕
Yeay, baby Hyein 💜
This MV is about a complicated yet fulfilling story between a mother & daughter. IU is the mother here. When it's HYEIN's lines, that is the POV of a daughter & same as Joe Won Sun in the perspective of a mother. In the last few seconds of the MV, which shows different generations of Korean women, and for this part, the Narration by Patti Kim (SK Legend artist who alrdy retired in her '80s) comes in.
read the description
@@jords533 The description is lyrics in the song + the description of the genre, this person is right, its not only a complex story between mother and daughter relationships, it is also about complex female relationship, how we are the product of all the women before us, its a love letter to all women, of all generations
@@olithecat_yz6311 exactly
This! From the lyrics and the MV, I can totally see the generational division IU portrayed. I love how the lyrics during Hyein is in a younger female POV, more innocent and not knowing the feelings they have. Then in Joe Won Sun's lyrics, she's definitely more matured and embraced her feelings, whatever it is.
And i love olithecat's description, "its a love letter to all women, of all generations"
then what's F and L meaning??
Usually it's IU's vocals that elicit so many emotions and goosebumps out of me. But when she adds the visuals and emotional stories through the types of thought-provoking music videos as she has in the four mv's related to "The Winning," the combinations are extremely powerful. This one pretty much had me on sensory overload, again. Shoutout to Hyein for her wonderful voice and performance as well. More evidence to me that IU is one of the best all-around singers, songwriters, actresses, producers, and creative minds in my lifetime. I'm 68.
❤❤❤
For real and that gentle looks 😃😃😍😍
I'm 59..😂
She's the best❤
I'm almost 64 years old too! IU is an all-rounder and a special woman.😊
열등감을 자극하면서도 동경하게 되는, 옭아매다가도 놓아주고 싶게 되는,
친구이다가도 적이 되는,
멀리 떨어뜨리고 싶지만 곧 다시 보고싶어지는...
이런 복잡한 관계를 엄마와 딸의 관계로 빗대어 표현한게 아닐까 싶기도 하고. 정말 미묘하고 깊은 관계성에 대해 너무 감각적이고 운치있게 표현했어요
혹시 관계자가 아닌가 싶을정도로 상당히 구체적인 해석을 잘하셨네요^^
젊은시절의 엄마를 만난다면
사랑했다고 꼭 안아주고싶어요.
뉴진스 혜인 목소리랑 아이유 목소리랑 너무 잘어울리고 뮤비도 한편의 영화같다 연기도 너무 잘하심
이건 정말 영감을 주는 작품이네요.. 마냥 아릅답지만도, 마냥 예쁘고 곱지만은 않으면서도 그렇기에 서글프고 애잔함이 깃들어있는 복잡하고 깊은 엄마와 딸의 관계성이 입체적이면서도 감각적으로 표현되어있어 놀랐어요. 너무 세련된 느낌으로, 너무나 깊은 감성과 절제된 느낌으로. 4분여동안 저를 강하게 울리고 가네요. 두분의 눈빛연기가 정말 아름다워요. 가사도 정말 밀도높은 감동입니다. 아이유라는 가수가 다시보여요
it's not about f, it's not about l 이라는 가사가 이것은 우정(friendship의 F)에 대한 이야기도, 사랑(love의 L)대한 이야기도 아니라는 것이구나
와..저눈 당연히 F는 female이고 L은 lady인 줄 알았어요😮 다른 해석이 가능했군요?!
@@민단단노래 설명에 쓰여 있어요!
'이것은 단순 우정 얘기가 아니다.
단순 사랑 이야기도 아니다.
그녀와 나 사이엔 좀 더 복잡한 게 있었다.'
thanks for this, I was wondering
"Shh.." is Gorgeous
"Love wins all" is Beautiful
"I stan U" is Stunning
"Holssi" is Freedom
"Shopper" is Adventure
💗💛
And Bam Yanggang is beating all of them
@@clawcross ok
❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️
@@clawcrossor Bam Yang Geng Blocked by them? 😂
맞아 나는 엄마라는 이유로 그녀를 가뒀어. 나의 첫사랑. 나를 구속시키는 그녀.
아이유-탕웨이 두 분의 눈빛연기도 완벽했지만, 인스타그램에 올려주신 서로 주고 받은 손편지글을 읽어 보니 이 뮤비의 의도나 공감대를 뚜렷하게 보여주신것 같아 더욱 좋네요. 좋은 작품을 선보여주셔서 리스너로써 감사드려요
저도 탕웨이배우님이 쓰신 편지 보고 뮤비를 다시 보니까 저도 모르게 울컥했네요..ㅜㅜ😢 두 배우님들 눈빛만으로도 감정을 표현하시다니 대단합니다..
편지를 보고 오니까 진짜 이 곡을 한층 더 풍부하게 음미할수 있게 된 느낌.. 아이유의 곡은 항상 새롭고 신선해서 좋네요
Shh 뮤비 노래를 들을수록 너무너무 좋네요💜🎵🎬🎊👍
C’est
젊은 시절의 엄마와 성인이 된 딸... 정말 의미가 깊고 아름답네요ㅜㅜ❤
OMG.. 1:32 I almost didn't recognize HYEIN's voice😭 oh my gosh I was so shocked, it's so beautiful🫧
IU, HYEIN & WONSUN JOE. You guys! MASTERPIECE❤✨
1:30_2:22 better
보면볼수록 뮤비속 주인공인 엄마와 딸의 관계만을 그린게 아닐지도 모른다는 생각도 들어요. 아이유 속에 숨쉬고 있는 여러 shh의 존재들. 그녀를 구성하는 암호같은 shh들.
혹시 관계자가 아닌가 싶을정도로 상당히 구체적인 해석을 잘하셨네요^^
Now that iutv is out it turns out you were right!
the description of this mv says:
'It's not just a friendship story. It's not just a love story. There was something more complicated between her and me.'
beautiful❤
mother (IU) n daughter (TW)
I thought of her friendship with Sulli too.
@@yvesxiao9138who is Sulli?
@@winterb4371 herfriend who died. Was a member of F(x).
@@yvesxiao9138I tried translating the following part of the description and it goes something like this
'Names that win me everytime.
Names that don't leave my mind.
who led me to who I am now.
The names that make me up somewhere inside of me.
To them who will be special and complex for a long time.'
I think it can be interpreted in different ways but it might also be about the people she has lost
아이유 진짜 천재다..... 어떻게 이런 다양한 장르와 다양한 이야기로 노래를 만들고 그에 어울리는 스토리텔링으로 뮤비까지..
0:39 IU
1:30 HYEIN
2:22 조원선
3:34 패티김
딸 둘, 엄마, 할머니가 함께 노래를 만든 것 같네요 ㅎㅎ 아이유 섭외 능력 미쳤다 🤣탕웨이는 이모? 작은엄마? ㅋㅋ
2:50 IU
I like this part
Love IU~!
아이유의 이번 앨범이 명작인 이유가 하나 더 생겼다..
아이유 음악에 매번 느껴지는 건 전체적인 바탕이 서늘하고 쓸쓸한 느낌인데, 사랑이 빼꼼하고 고개들고 있는 그런 걸 매번 느낀다. 음악이 그런 것인지 아이유 음색 때문인지 아이유라는 사람때문인지 모르겠지만 아마 다 섞여 있겠지.서늘한 마음에도 사랑이 느껴져서 외로움이 따뜻하게 느껴지는 그런.. 잘 다독여주는 거 같다.
와 이 댓글 진짜 공감..표현 너무 잘하시네요
The song talks about mothers, right?
@@-kottoko. yep, it's about tangwei met her mother when she was young(iu) and she realise that her mom is a little girl like her too
여자에서 엄마로 누군가의 가족으로서 헌신하는 shh 모두 존경합니다
인터뷰 보고 다시 들으니까 또 느낌이 다른…진짜 명곡
1:39 hyein's voice is soooo soothing to hear 😭 even tho she's only 15 yr old but she manage to have vocals like that really suprised me! 😭😭
ANJIR 271 LIKE
She's 15?!
@@Aris-or5vy indeed!!
di newjeans suaranya hyein paling ngena di w 🥲, kaya di intro ditto, di lagu ini, di get up, beuhhh ❤
gimana ya jelasinnya, kontrol suaranya itu loh enak di kuping. ada penyanyi yg punya suara bagus tapi belum tentu bagus di kontrol suara, tapi hyein ini bisa dua duanya, keren emang.
IU is such a rare artist. Every MV song she puts out invokes specific feelings. I didn't expect to like "Shh..." to be so atmospheric and ambient, breathing a sense of sophistication - so ripen with restrained emotions. Perhaps it's my preference for R&B sound. As I admire those tracks in this album, dare I say this is my favorite song from her in this comeback.
Seriously, this song is meant for adults.
Agreed 😌
The slower cadence works better for story-telling. It's perfect. :)
FR
이 곡은 이지은이 살면서 영향을 받은 여자들의 이야기이다
아이유의 엄마, 아이유의 첫 친구이자 경쟁자, 아이유의 롤 모델 이 모든 복합적인 감정을 표현한 shh
마지막 에필로그에 나오는 젊은 여자 둘은 친구 사이가 아닐까 싶다 좋아하지만 경쟁하고 미워도 하는..
와씨.. 아이유랑 어머니 인터뷰 영상 보고 오니까 이 노래 개미쳤네.. 내 가난한 상상력으로는 떠올릴 수 없는 진짜 멋지고 대단한 곡이였어
친구이자 경쟁자이자 미워도하는 수지?
@@soso-ii5ns 첫친구 얘기하는데 뜬금없는 분이네ㅋㅋ
@@soso-ii5ns 첫친구면 어릴때잖아 ..머리뭐야
엥 이거 장면에 애하고애엄마하고 안고 빨간조명안에서 이야기하는장면 안봤냐
hyein sounds like an angel
She is an angel
❤
Shh는 들을수록 세련됐고 좋고 여운이 남음
I didnt notice the switch from IU's to Hyein's vocals because of how silky their vocals are and also bc i was so invested in the MV
When she became a mother, she realized why her mother had locked her up, and they reconcile. As they grow older, they become friends. Eventually, the relationship will continue in their next lives.
But why they locked each other up? Out of dear love? What does that mean?
@@zxcvbnm14373that's what I'm trying to figure out 😅
Hyein's voice so soothing. so is IU's.
Petition for a director to cast IU and Tang Wei for a film 🎥 that takes them both to Cannes again 🙏💗
YES! I would LOVE to see them do a movie together. Add Zhang Ziyi & Michelle Yeoh as part of the cast & it would be a dream come true. The best Asian actresses in a movie together.
I didn't expect it. I love both of them.🥳
汤唯🥰
Speechless. Amazing!
Is the “song” saying there is a story?
Is it because we as daughters never get to call our mums by name, she has named her as shh? That’s so poignant and bittersweet. It could be about empowerment.. and I think knowing IU, I’d like to see its also a tribute and public show of admiration for all mums and grandmums- including hers :’)
This is called The Winning album for a reason! IU has been the reason for me to dive into kpop. Since then I have come to appreciate more of other kpop artistes and groups in their hard work and music too. But IU is really on the another level of music creation. No wonder many kpop hoobaes look to her as their role model.
And reading Tang Wei’s letter to IU again solidifies my thought that she is not only highly respected as an artiste but also as another fellow human living in this time.
IU has long time established she writes songs not only to make it trendy or simply make a statement… I think anyone can make a statement today - like all of us here. but you can see and hear that she wants to tell a narrative, an idea, a perspective that are also good, beautiful, empowering, full of light and love. Thank you IU, what a refreshing album that marks the start of your 30s. :)
Now I just hope I’ll get to see you live this year!!!
after ruminating on the lyrics.... wow I love it even more. The complicated levels of emotions and sentiments toward the mum and daughter relationship is very real and raw. Ah... what an art. IU's music is one that you could just take time to digest further and appreciate, and interact with your own life. :)
Frr
,The song talks about mothers, right?
I love 'Shh..' concert live vocal.Its energetic and heroic vibe.
4분 48초 중 아이유랑 탕웨이가 서로 바라보고 있는 컷만 약 2분 30초인데 그 표정 연기로 뭘 말하고 싶은지 다 표현하는 둘의 캐미가 미친 듯
인생은 영화라는 게 존재만으로도 표출이 되는 아이유, 탕웨이, 이혜인, 조원선, 패티김님. 그녀들의 교집합을 찾아 예술로 표현해 내는 아이유님의 능력에 감타과 찬사를 보냅니다. 저는 처음 Shh.. 뮤비를 보고 유전이 가장 먼저 떠올랐어요. 부모에서 자식으로 대물림 되는 유전자를 말하고 싶은데.. 익숙함에 무심히 지나치는 같은 핏줄의 관계성에 대해 잠시 멈춰 생각해 볼 수 있는 시간을 만들어 주는 음악이 아닌가 싶습니다. 아이유님은 이 세상에 중요하지 않은 것들이 없다는 것을 잘 찾아내고 잘 알고 계신 사람 같습니다. 알면 알수록 멋있는 여자 아이유.. 최고..
잘 찾아내고 잘 알고있다는 말이.. 너무 와닿네요. 저도 그래서 늘 아이유님의 음악이 궁금하고 유달리 애틋한 것 같아요.
탕웨이가 왜 탕웨이인지 알게 해준 뮤비.....그리고 아이유님 이런곡 만들어줘서 사랑합니다
혜인아진짜 넌 레전드다 진짜 너 파트만 몇번을 듣고 있는건지 혜인아 진짜 사랑해 음색 최고다 진짜 내 귀가 녹아내렸어
콘서트 다녀오니까 자꾸 생각남.. 라이브에 더 좋은 곡인것 같기도..
어릴때는 엄마를 너무 밉고, 제일 싫어했던 건 바로 엄마를 닮게 생기는거였어요. 역시 엄마가 나를 사랑하지 않고, 그리고 그녀의 행동 하나하나가 항상 나는 엄마에게 그저 부담이거다, 이렇게 느꼈던 거든요. ”날 싫어 해요?저도 엄마가 싫어해요”. 이런 시절 있죠.
이제 나이 좀 먹다보니 느꼈던게, 사실은 엄마도 엄마가 처음이어가지고, 누구도 쉽지 않을거다. 점점 이해가되고, 사실 엄마가 나를 사랑한거고, 저도 엄마가 사랑한것 같은데, 이 관계가 참 묘해요.. it’s not about friend, not about love.
근데 이 뮤비같은 꿈 한번 꿀 수 있으면 좋겠어요,, 저도 궁금해요 우리 엄마가 뭘 숨겨는지.
쑥스러워서 직접 말 못하는데,, 여기서 할계요
엄마!!!! 사랑해요🌚
I had the same experience. As I get older and have become a mother, my perspective has changed a lot. I try to focus on her positive traits and appreciate her as a person.
가서도 직접 해보세요
탕웨이님의 애드립이였다는 마지막 안는씬은 이 뮤비의 모든 내용을 함축하고 있는듯 합니다.. 이 뮤비에서의 최고의 장면이고 뮤비 자체라고 생각해요 지은양도 탕웨이님이 안을당시에 눈물이 핑돌았다고 하던데 보는 저도 눈물이 핑 돕니다
뮤비는 어머니와 딸의 관계에서 느껴지는 감정을 다루고 있고 그만의 분위기가 느껴져서 잘 감상했어요. 탕웨이님과 아이유님의 흔들리던 눈동자가 너무 좋았어요. 가사도 언급하고 싶어요. 좀 더 넓은 여자 간의 관계에 대해 다루고 있는 것 같은데, 인상적이고 좋았습니다. 여자가 같은 여자에게서 느끼는 동경, 질투, 미움, 그리움, 소유욕 등등 여자이기 전에 본연 사람이라서 느끼는 그런 유대에서 오는 감정들을 사랑과 우정이라 뭉그트려버리지 않고 'we got something else' 라고 제대로 짚어준 가사가 작사가의 섬세함이 돋보여서 마음에 들었습니다. 그런 동경과 질투, 미움, 그리움, 소유욕 등 그 여자들의 조각을 받아 이루어진 한 여자의 세계는 어쩌면 한 사람의 인생에서 그 사람을 구성하는 영원한 유대의 세계관이네요. 여러 생각이 들게하는 가사입니다.
진짜 명필 이시네요 평론가
아이유와 탕웨이의 미친 연기..
정신나갈거같아~
은근 슬적 아이유 올려치고 있네 ㅋㅋㅋ
탕웨이랑 비교할 급이냐?
대체 어디가 올려치기…? 너가?
@@pelso4377꺼져 그럼
@@pelso4377탕웨이가 누군데 그래서 ㅋㅋ 아이유랑 쨉이되나?
I think the mobius strip isn't a symbol for infinity, it's a symbol for two sides that are really one. That ambiguity of where something ends and another thing starts,,,where one person ends and another side of their personality begins.
In the narration lyrics we have the translation "known by everyone and no one at the same time." A mobius strip has the contradiction that there's actually only one side, but it presents as two, there's an illusion or "mask" hiding something deeper, and these lyrics point out a similar contradiction between the known and unknown sides of this person.
What's the unknown side? The imagery in the MV and more importantly the acting and way the two characters (IU and Tang Wei) interact with each other is through eye contact, a whisper, and a revelation. It's this dance of "do you see me? do you see beneath my mask, my layers?" and once you feel like they do, you start to wonder if you can unveil whatever secret you have to them. Something you've hidden so securely and locked away so completely that you fear anyone finding it out. But there's some similarity there, "my eyes are just like hers" and you're drawn to them, to this idea that someone could see you and you can share your dark secret, "a happy nightmare."
This dance almost feels to me like a spider weaving a web,,, not to catch it's prey necessarily but to be in control of the web, to have bases covered and traps laid to keep you out of trouble. We see IU crawling. The lyrics describe being lured by "Long footseps." We see Tang Wei "jump" close to IU and stare at her with an unnerving smile. "Haha, nowhere to run, I see you." It's this "overarching presence" that's "forever a step ahead" that sees you despite you trying to hide ("I stay silent")
Take a look again at the way the characters interact BEFORE sharing their secrets. There's knowing smiles, hesitating eye contact, and holding back tears. It seems like they feel caught, or found out, that maybe this fear of being discovered is finally coming to pass. At first there's a reluctance to admit it -- see how slowly Tang Wei first meets IU's intense gaze. Then a resignation.
Have you ever held a deep secret? Something you fear being judged for if found out? I'm not talking about anything illegal but maybe something psychological, something related to your identity. And maybe that eats at you. You've imagined it time and time again what you would do if someone found out.
But what if someone saw behind your mask without you saying anything? Maybe that person really sees you. Maybe you can reveal this secret which has eaten at you and be free from all those pent up fears. And that's what we see: revealing a daughter that's no longer there, revealing a twin that's dead (? or kidnapped in the boot of the car). My interpretation of the twin is that it's repressing part of their personality.
Again, the way these are revealed hint that they're deep secrets. IU isn't even looking into the trunk when Tang Wei's opening it, she's looking at Tang Wei. Tang Wei isn't looking into the cellar door when IU opens it, she's looking at IU with a smile and tears in her eyes. And that smile has changed from the unnerving "ha ha I see what you're hiding" to "oh silly, you're still human." It's a beautiful portrayal of seeing the person behind the trauma. IU's character only has photos of this person as a kid. We can only presume she's passed or no longer in her life. And holding that in and presenting a brave face to the world can tear apart a person. Finally sharing that side of the mobius strip, tearing away that illusion of two sides leaves you feeling so vulnerable. And we have Tang Wei accepting and smiling at IU's character. "Oh silly, that's what you've been hiding?"
What we get at the end scene between them comes off as redemption. Someone on their knees reaching out, then being lifted up and hugged signifies redemption arc. Remember they just revealed their secret to each other, and now it's IU's turn to accept Tang Wei. To hug and accept that they are still human. That despite this contradiction in their head that they're misunderstood, that they're hiding half of themselves, IU's hug is her saying "you're still human, you're still complete." When someone sees you as you, when they can take in the whole picture, there's no more mask. There's no two sides. And like the mobius strip you realize that you are you completely, one and whole.
That's such a liberating experience, I think that's why we get the narration at the end. To encourage sharing these stories, these characters who live a life feeling misunderstood, trapped, and like they're not fully themselves, but after sharing their secrets with a trusted one, they're liberated.
I feel like i'm just watching a movie when i reading this, damn, such a beautifull explanation
You've just gutted me in the best possible way. Both IU and you perfectly illustrated my own relationship with my mother. Hopefully it's still unfinished.
This is a very beutiful and deep interpretation! I would also like to share mine a little bit, a little different perspective on the twin part.
For me IU's and Tang Wei's characters portray mother and daughter respectivelly. At the start of the MV you can see and old picture of IU with her daughter and the apartment itself is quite old (old fashioned) as well, but when we see the street on the outside where IU is walking near shopwindow, we can understand that this is around our time. Tang Wei's style says the same thing to me since it's different from photos and IU's flashback.
"Some long time ago,
She hid her mother away"
For me Tang Wei is a daughter who came back to her mothers apartment, maybe for the first time in years. And IU's character in the same apartment is like the memories that are tied to it, warm memories you can't escape or run away from (in this case memories associated with mother). "She hid her mother away" in my opinion might refer to child's anger for mother, not understanding and not wanting to understand her point of view. To me it also could mean that after growing up and losing her mom (here i'm judjing from actresses' ages and IU's quite young looks), daughter may have hid all the memories deep within herself. So seeing her mother again, coming back to her mother's apartment once again and even talking to her (whispering), this time not as a child to mother, but as a woman to a woman, helped Tang Wei to finally understand and/or fully accept her mother (and all the memories) afer all these years. And opening to these memories and feelings made her more complete person, since after this we might see her smile a bit, in contradiction to the start of the MV. So I think that the light under this kind of wooden hatch was all those forgotten, all those hidden deep inside memories and all the tied to this place memories associated with mother.
"She was my friend long ago.
I hid her away, too."
Now we see Tang Wei looking at IU (in the car), I see it as she now understands her mother better, as if she became alive once again, young and beautiful as her daughter is now, as if they could talk to no end just like old friends. But if daughter opened to her, now it's IU's turn to unveil her secrets. And so, for me the twin symbolizes all the love, care and desire to protect her child, such strong that she (IU) eventually tries to hide her daughter from all the bad things in the world (which migh've led to misunderstandings and anger). This opening also might symbolize all the impurities and imperfections of mother she's finally willing to share with her daughter.
Taking each other's hand, looking in each other's eyes and hugging each other to me stands for finally forgiving and accepting each other with all the imperfections and impurites, becoming complete with themselves and with the other side. They saw each others naked truth and once again became a family.
In this case I think narration might refer to widespread of this kind of relationship/problem ("old tale"), where a lot of people might find themselves in a similar situation ("Known by everyone"), "And no one at the same time" because not many are ready to open up and go through expirience characters in MV went throug. And the scene we see during the credits supports that point for me.
I liked very much your thoughts on secrets and liberation, I strongly support them. Your interpretation is truly beautiful and in my opinion deserves more recognition in this comment section and even beyond when it comes to "Shh..".
뉴진스의 정체성이라 생각하는 혜인이 보컬도 좋지만 조원선은 진짜 압도적인 포스다,, 목소리 등장만으로 압권하고 집중되는게 넘 멋있다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
이건 참....매스터피스라는 말은 안 할 수가 없네..지은아 정말 잘했다!
전혀 그런 내용인줄 몰랐어.. 뜻을 알고 뮤비 끝까지 보는데 눈물이...아이유 앨범 하나가 진짜 여러 감정의 눈물을 흘리게 하네
IU doesn't look like she's in her 30s at all. She is so beautiful and very cute
I wish Hyein was part of this mv❤
보는 내내 탕웨이의 눈빛에 신비로움, 그리움, 슬픔, 진지함 같은게 담겨져 있어서 눈을 떼지 못하고 나도 모르게 눈물이 나는...
Hear me out, IU’s voice gives 🍓 vibes (sweet and timeless)
Hyein’s voice gives 🍒 vibes (tart and rich)
And Won-sun’s voice gives 🍊vibes (mellow yet powerful)
Guys i guess, they are talking about ‘friends’ when they say (F) and ‘lovers’ when they say (L). In the song, mother-daughter relationship in the MV
logical
wait, this is re-uploaded mv??
@@haechanchannie2356 yes, they re-uploaded the MV because they spelled HYEIN's english name wrong
what a significant words
@@eliz3bethwhat Hyeins English name? Grace?
Hyein is so emotional. . she will be the greatest soloist can't wait ❤
IU and Tang Wei must be in drama together.
IU x Hyein x JoeWosun x Patti Kim 4 voices that makes these song incredible and amazing..
약간 곡이 '그 사람' 느낌도 나고 '빈 컵' 느낌도 나는데 또 그 특유의 나른함도 있어서 새로워요! 진짜 아이유 언니 목소리랑 찰떡 ... 다른 가수분들 목소리도 너무 좋고 같이 뮤비 찍어주신 탕웨이님 연기도 미쳤고 여러모로 영화 보는 기분 들었어요 이번 앨범 타이틀부터 수록곡까지 다 너무 좋네요 뮤비 너무 감명 깊게 보고 가요♡♡
IUの歌詞のshhの意味が分かった瞬間、ストーリーが頭の中ど駆け巡り、私ならどうしたのだろう?
貴方なら？いやきっと正しいと言う終着点は無いけど、彼女(IU)の歌声には終着点があるのかも知れないと少し幻想的でもあり、不思議な気持ちになりました。
良い歌を提供してくて、ありがとう。本当に素晴らしいミュージシャンです。
I love how it was IU & Hyein in a song together. Hyein has made it this far to collab with one of the biggest K-pop soloists & I’m so proud of her. This mv is honestly so beautiful & the song has such a deep meaning.
They both have the same zodiac signs too, what a coincidence.
Tang Wei is so beautiful & IU is a good singer
Such a beautiful song with different generations of women featured. IU is a genius lyricist!! The way she described the mother and daughter relationship is so clever and relatable.
Hyein has an angelic voice and crazy stage presence. She born to be that girl ❤
i really truly admire IU and her embodiment of womanhood. Although most women would use their sexiness & beauty to feel empowered, IU would flaunt her brain, artistry, musicality and talent. Her music, art and even choices in films/movies doesn't add to the objectification of women. Even in this song, it was focused on the qualities of womanhood in different generations with different roles that makes them unique, special and connected. I am always in awe with her lyricism.
My favorite lyrics of her in this song 2:50
Like an old soliloquy
that has never stopped,
here’s to those women who remain an enigma
forever etched somewhere in my time
That's why love her 🥰
+ she's like the most beautiful woman 👑
you should watch IU interview with her mom now, those lyric is to described her mom. it was great interview though, i began to admire not just IU, but her mom also now XD
IU does "add to the objectification of women." She 1) uses her "beauty" and "cuteness" to appeal to men, and 2) depicts women as objects of male desire and validation. This is evident in her MVs and songs, which frequently feature her singing to or about men
Why do we compare all the women who are killing it? Comparison broods insecurity. Putting IU in a high pedestal while degrading others is the point of the song as IU has been compared to those before her. And those women have to somehow “kill and burry” a part of their inner self just to “appeal” better. Women are all an enigma whatever HER name is. Ji-Eun’s brave for putting out this feminist song.
1:05 탕웨이씨가 아이유에게 쓴 편지를 읽고 뮤비를 보니 이 씬이 더 뭉클하게 다가오네요..
와 영화 같아
아이유 혜인 조원선 패티김 탕웨이 조합 너무 좋아요ㅠㅠ
Hyein’s voice 🥹🫶🏻
IU and Tang Wei look so amazing, they should cast in drama together
I just found out about Jo Woo Sun, a unique singer with a stunning voice. finally found out about JWS. She's really interesting. So far I've only watched IU and nothing else. IU, u r the godmother of kpop.
It really amaze me how you come up with SHH. The F and L. If you type F in a keyboard you'll get (ㄹ) and if L you'll get (l) and if you put them together you'll get(리) Lee💜. The one who entered concert halls with flutterd clothes and flashing lights, exits by only wearing comfortable clothes and just being true to herself. Known by everyone and no one at the same time. Her name is Shh(이지은)
Super!!!
@@romuteambroza8236 ☺️
In korean, Lee is supposed to be 이 not 리.
@@dienz I am not trying to argue but thats just what I get when I tried to search it in google. And I know how it spelled also 🙂💜
조원선씨..❤목소리 그대로시네요
롤러코스터 노래 들으면 추억은 방울방울일만큼 시간이 흘렀네요
❤ 반가워요
뮤비 진짜 소름돋게 너무 좋네.. 탕웨이님이 왜 그런 편지를 써줬는지 조금이나마 이해할 수 있었음
It expressed the heartbreaking illegitimate child, the empty sorrow, the female psychology of strange affinity, and the unique characteristics of women who embrace and protect past pain.
here again after i watched iutv
Jieun being interviewed by her mom i finally understand and appreciate the song more💕🔥🥰🥹
IU and Hyein vocals are no joke! They sounded so heavenly and so beautifully! I love u girls so much!😊💜
This song and mv are among the reasons why IU’s music, just like her bff Taehyung’s, for me go beyond k-pop. They both create pure art full of symbolism and meaning and their music and vision is unique.
세상 무서운 엄마같기도 하고 쿨한 엄마 같기도 하고.. 딸을 무척 사랑하는듯..하고...딸은 반항하는 듯 하지만 엄마를 늘 원하지...
I want to know my mom as just her, without the title of daughter,wife or a mother to define her. However, infront of me she has only ever shown her role as a mother. I think it is because 'mom' has become a part of her soul that she cannot do without Infront of her daughter. When I think of home I think of mom. She is a little silly and definitely a flawed human being but the warmth she brings is something nobody else will ever be able to give me in life. She is my best friend, mom, companion and the one person I am sure I could always count on. I love you mom, always.
Sorry, just ignore me. I was just venting.
This song is a genius … so thought provoking as well on how we treated our mothers
노래도 노래지만 탕웨이의 편지가 진짜 감동적.
이 노래는 그 편지의 배경음악.
탕웨이 ... 미친 감수성... 그 자체 .
탕웨이 편지가 완성한 노래
압도적인 탕웨이의 존재감..
누구의 엄마 , 누구의 아내가 아닌 그녀의 이름으로 불러지길 바라는 마음같아요