Is New Zealand's DNA in crisis and can it spark Bledisloe Cup triumph? | The Breakdown

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 вер 2024
  • The Breakdown discusses the All Blacks' recent struggles and losses, questioning whether New Zealand is still the envy of the rugby world, while also considering the upcoming Bledisloe Cup against Australia. #breakdown
    ---
    Watch Live Rugby for free - RugbyPass.TV
    Binge episodes of The Season Brisbane Boys College - • 'The Season' 8 - Austr...
    SUBSCRIBE to Rugby Pass for daily rugby videos, exclusive interviews, press conferences, highlights, original documentaries, weekly chat shows and much more: / @rugbypass
    ---
    RECOMMENDED PLAYLISTS:
    GUINNESS SIX NATIONS 2022
    • Guinness Six Nations News
    British & Irish Lions Tour 2021
    • British & Irish Lions
    RUGBYPASS FAN ZONE
    • RugbyPass Fan Zone
    RUGBY NEWS, PRESS CONFERENCES, INTERVIEWS & REACTION:
    • Rugby News
    CLASSIC FULL MATCHES & HIGHLIGHTS:
    • Classic Matches & High...
    THE ACADEMY S1, LEICESTER TIGERS - PLAYLIST:
    • Leicester Tigers - The...
    RUGBYPASS ORIGINALS - PLAYLIST:
    • Documentaries - RugbyP...
    HOLD BACK THE RIVER - PLAYLIST: • Hold Back The River - ...
    THE SEASON S1, ST JOSEPH'S NUDGEE COLLEGE - PLAYLIST:
    • 'The Season' 1 - Austr...
    THE SEASON S3, ST PATS SILVERSTREAM - PLAYLIST:
    • 'The Season' 3 - New Z...
    THE SEASON S5, HAMILTON BOYS HIGH SCHOOL - PLAYLIST:
    • 'The Season' 5 - New Z...
    THE SEASON S6, BRISBANE BOYS COLLEGE - PLAYLIST:
    • 'The Season' 6 - Austr...
    ---
    RugbyPass is the premier destination for rugby fans across the globe, with the best news, analysis, shows, highlights, podcasts, documentaries, live match & player stats, live blog feeds, and in some territories live streaming of the world's greatest rugby tournaments all in HD.
    In 2017 and 2018, RugbyPass acquired several popular rugby properties including Rugby Dump, Rugby Onslaught, Rugby365 and Fantasy Rugger, becoming the largest independent English-language rugby audience network in the world. The RugbyPass Network reaches tens of millions of rugby fans across its social media channels and millions of users across its websites.
    WATCH: weekly episodes of The Breakdown (NZ), The Aussie Rugby Show (AU), The Rugby Pod (UK), The Aotearoa Rugby Pod (NZ), The Breakdown & Offload. VISIT www.RugbyPass.com for the best international and local rugby news, views and entertainment.
    ---
    #Rugby #RugbyPass
    ---
  • Спорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 105

  • @EdLo3
    @EdLo3 2 дні тому +16

    Razor is finding his feet, give the guy time. He is getting to know his players. Who can he trust etc. It all takes time. Rassie knows his whole squad inside and out through two world cups. The ABs are going through a transition period which takes more time than the NZ media has the patience for.

    • @Goggawie
      @Goggawie 5 годин тому +1

      @@EdLo3 agree. Give a fair chance to all. I looove Springboks. RESPECT AB

  • @paulvanjaarsveld5965
    @paulvanjaarsveld5965 2 дні тому +10

    Love JM commentating, balanced, fair, educated………

  • @nsd_respect
    @nsd_respect 2 дні тому +15

    Justin van der Maarshy.

  • @victordastile5204
    @victordastile5204 2 дні тому +7

    Great to see Marshy there👊

  • @warfit4793
    @warfit4793 2 дні тому +8

    MARSHY !!! 🇿🇦

  • @chasey2327
    @chasey2327 День тому +3

    Other rugby nations have squeezed off Darth Vader's helmet - can he put it back on? Given that ABs were miles ahead in skills, conditioning and training for so long and kiwi coaches have worked overseas there are no secrets left and its inevitable that others would catch up. Rest of the world has a slight chance now but at the same time it's a shame. Still awesome to watch, every rugby fans fave team if they're being honest.

  • @Goggawie
    @Goggawie День тому +2

    Im SA. Eversince I can remember, ALL Blacks were the feared team to play. We hate and love them. Springboks playing AB always delivers exciting entertainment. Respect

  • @samgreer8274
    @samgreer8274 2 дні тому +4

    We need Cam Roigard

  • @davidlittle7418
    @davidlittle7418 2 дні тому +1

    Gotta love Marshy as a commentator, he simply is the best to listen to.

  • @internetcentrist
    @internetcentrist 2 дні тому +5

    I don't know why anyone is thinking the Bledisloe fixtures are going to be a challenge

    • @Nat-oj2uc
      @Nat-oj2uc 2 дні тому

      I don't know why you think it's not

    • @Mo-yd8xc
      @Mo-yd8xc 2 дні тому +1

      ​@@Nat-oj2ucbecause the wobblies are horrible. To have a 20-3 lead and wing up losing by 60+ to 27. They're a joke. The only reason they've won a match is because Argentina gift wrapped it.

    • @Balance-v8x
      @Balance-v8x 2 дні тому

      Yip, the ABs will win this one and think everything is OK again. Lack of vision.....

    • @jeffreychongsathien
      @jeffreychongsathien 2 дні тому

      They have to keep up the pretense to avoid dead air.

    • @Nat-oj2uc
      @Nat-oj2uc День тому

      @@Mo-yd8xc sure the only reason you won is because the ref gifted you a try

  • @RobClifton-vi4ef
    @RobClifton-vi4ef 2 дні тому +4

    Kids are brought up soft now in smaller families ,bigger families rough an tumbled back in the day .
    More kids play other sports now.

  • @Brent4120
    @Brent4120 День тому +1

    Interesting to see how much 'time' Razor gets, when the previous guy, who actually performed and got the ABs to the World Cup final was not respected.

  • @user-qp4oq8yj7z
    @user-qp4oq8yj7z День тому

    South Africa is not afraid to throw in a fresh face everyear. An under 20 front rower, backrower or backline. Their domestic competition must be loaded with young talent amongst the most experienced ones.They will never be short of first class players.

  • @speeddemon9555
    @speeddemon9555 День тому +4

    problem ? N.Z. rugby is not the no 1 sport in N.Z. now, there are more soccer players than rugby players, there is the hard core rugby fans, but, the rules of rugby have been changed so much, it has turned hoards of ex fans off the game, i have lost interest in rugby, the yellow and red cards and pedantic rules have ruined the game for both spectators and players alike, also with the way they have changed the game, we now have a crappy game of rugby league with lineouts.

    • @AbenerSomseb-if5cb
      @AbenerSomseb-if5cb 12 годин тому

      What do you mean rugby is a no 1 sport in new zealand

    • @speeddemon9555
      @speeddemon9555 5 годин тому +1

      @@AbenerSomseb-if5cb rugby is NOT the no 1 sport in N.Z.

    • @AbenerSomseb-if5cb
      @AbenerSomseb-if5cb 5 годин тому

      @@speeddemon9555 what happens what is no one sport in new zealand i know its not football

  • @aboubakarcornelius7296
    @aboubakarcornelius7296 6 годин тому

    I quote Marshall "We can bully the Australians, but we cannot bully the Sssh". Marshall couldn't say South Africa. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @HainiS-g8i
    @HainiS-g8i 2 дні тому +1

    Congratulations. To. You guys. I. Had. Feeling. To. Offer. The. Auckland. Goal. Kicker. That. Person. Was. Playing. The. Games. And. A uckland. Won the. Supper rugby this. Year. I. WNt. Him. His. Very. Good. To be. In. the. All blacks.

  • @JWLearning
    @JWLearning 2 дні тому +1

    There's a myriad of reasons why the AB's are in a rough patch but from what I see there are two major issues that is also effecting Australia. First is the amount of quality players isn't as strong as previous generations, and the second is there's greater professionalism around the world now. Between 1995 to around 2015 Super Rugby was king, it was without doubt the best domestic rugby competition in the world. Now, not only have the European leagues surpassed it, there's more professionalism coming out of Japan, and even the recently established pro-leagues North American and South America. The world not only caught up, in some places it's surpassed Super Rugby and will only get stronger. The question now is what can NZ and AUS do about this? The most obvious short term fix is to let overseas players play for the national team, but that doesn't solve the long term problems.

    • @NathanAAASmith
      @NathanAAASmith День тому

      More sense made here than on the panel.
      Everyone else has caught up because they all have access to the same information now, thanks largely to the internet and coaches/players moving around more.
      There also use to be a better pathway to the top. You left High School, played colts Rugby for a couple of years and then made your way up to 1st grade of that club if you were good enough.
      If you stood out, normally after 2 or 3 seasons, sometimes longer, you, “might” make a provincial side.
      Back then, they also had North v South and Possible v Probables games for the best performing provincial players before they named the All Black side.
      In other words, you were well and truly tested before you reached the top.
      Now, if you show some talent, you get earmarked from a much younger age and quickly get drafted into a Super Rugby franchise.

    • @chasey2327
      @chasey2327 8 годин тому

      yep. And 'softer' laws and more ref intervention has reduced the grub plays

  • @Badlighter
    @Badlighter 2 дні тому +2

    Please can you have Murray mexted on as a regular guest

  • @howzit5406
    @howzit5406 День тому +1

    Not sure how a camparison to the Blackferns is relevant, nobody even knows who they are .

    • @MeanAzz_13
      @MeanAzz_13 День тому

      Yet they packed out Eden Park for the W.C FINAL. imagine if people knew who they were? 😂😂

  • @victorswart7411
    @victorswart7411 День тому

    Beating Aussies not a problem for ABs, so dont stress its 2 games in the bag. Dont know if it wil give you answers you looking for. We SAFFAS STILL RESPECT YOU GUYS.

  • @johngraham5948
    @johngraham5948 День тому +1

    The ABs have lost more than ground we've lost our fear factor there's only one player in this current team who was part of the "fear factor" era from 2011 upto now and that's Beauden Barrett this 2024 team is a young team who are trying to find their feet we don't have player's who put fear into the opposition and we may never have that anymore the challenge for Razor his coaching staff and the players is to find that 2nd half performance to close out those games close games and be the best team on that day

  • @dineshdavid405
    @dineshdavid405 День тому

    All Blacks - RIP

  • @1227kdogg
    @1227kdogg День тому

    Changes needed at 9 and 10 that's all. Roigard's return from injury will be good. Maybe look at bringing Mo'unga back. DMac is best coming on off the bench when the game is looser. The rest will just take some time as the new coaching philosophy takes up.

  • @Tiberius-
    @Tiberius- 2 дні тому +1

    Jordie and reikos experiment should come to a end! Fullback and winger struggling to break through line! Good players but lacking that x factor combination like Nonu and Conrad.
    Last Coaching Game plan didn't work last game with south Africa. Hoping Tj and Barret would add abit of speed in late 2nd half, the boys were already zapped.
    To many wingers and fullbacks in the current team. If they don't use the other players like proctor now. Then when the play the hard teams like south Africa, they gona get the same results. No x factor

  • @rugbywhisperer-coachkane3038
    @rugbywhisperer-coachkane3038 День тому

    The best All Black sides dominated upfront , pick n goes, breakdown counter rucks... the backs would then profit. Other sides are hurting the ABs at set piece and using rush defense to stifle the NZ X Factor out wide

  • @deongeldenhuys3076
    @deongeldenhuys3076 День тому

    Say it out loud, Razor is not the coach for test rugby , his combination choices and the fact that he has the opertunity to select a All Black 15 that can beat any team in the world...why did Bauden not play 10 and Procter 12 in Capetown with Satiti on 8...both the starting 12 and 13 are not firing since when does a all black coach condone that. Leave the political approach and call a spade a spade

  • @brettfleiner4906
    @brettfleiner4906 2 дні тому

    NZ will comfortably beat Aus, no doubt in my mind, both the coaching team and the players will want to make a statement and Aus should not have the steel to stop NZ. If NZ lose even one game against Aus, there should be some cause for panic, despite them being in a rebuilding phase.

  • @mjribes
    @mjribes 2 дні тому +2

    1) Who gives a monkey's about the Black Ferns, honestly? I'd trade the Black Ferns never winning a match again for the All Blacks getting back on top.
    2) Since when do we talk about "rugby DNA"? That's a Saffer term. And us using that ahows how deeply they've bored into our psyche.
    3) Let players who are playing abroad play for the All Blacks! We're shooting ourselves in the foot and going into battle with one hand tied behind our backs.

  • @pheasantplucker6117
    @pheasantplucker6117 День тому

    Yes

  • @minkedutoit1596
    @minkedutoit1596 День тому

    Rugby will always be Springboks and All Blacks....in all of rugby history these two teams complete each other. Rugby will not be rugby if you don't have the AB and Springboks. By the 1st world war NZ and SA had established themselves as rugby's 2 greatest powers. A NZ army match tour of SA in 1919 paved the way for a Springbok tour to NZ and Australia in 1921. And my belief is that they are still to this day the 2 greatest rugby power houses....

  • @matty_mccarthy
    @matty_mccarthy 2 дні тому

    Need to be better in the air & kickoffs aren’t calculated, 2 things we did dominated previously

  • @octodadmtbmartyrichards2862
    @octodadmtbmartyrichards2862 2 дні тому

    I was surprised 😮 that we didn’t lose by more in sa
    Not much to play for young up and coming players, compared to 10 years ago Eg no gwin shield, no rep rugby until u16, no Npc development teams, clubs are struggling

  • @JohnOC86
    @JohnOC86 День тому +1

    Jesus lads relax NZ will be back im Irish and iv seen this before you kinda when through this when Australia was ruling the rugby world. You just go through it .SA went through it. But you defo have talent maybe it’s clubs. your tradition will always be the All Blacks. Oh Ireland can beat SA so they know how to lose

  • @DirkJacobsz
    @DirkJacobsz 2 дні тому

    Geez you guys make me cry - try being a Wallabies fan - we are lucky if we get a win once every 4 years..

    • @davidlittle7418
      @davidlittle7418 2 дні тому

      Yeah it's a bit like we are peasants covered in cow shit watching royalty cry about a spot on their silk robes. The princesses will cheer themselves up by giving us a hiding, won't change the fact they are not the best anymore lol.

  • @michaelmoynihan9591
    @michaelmoynihan9591 2 дні тому

    Kiwis nighttime activity's does not help them either. The choking on wool the following mornings does not help their footie.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @RobClifton-vi4ef
    @RobClifton-vi4ef 2 дні тому

    DNA pool from Africa an Eastern Europe ,bring more immigrants from those countries to help NZ gene pool .

  • @pheasantplucker6117
    @pheasantplucker6117 День тому

    Get D-Mak to run straight not sideways. Easy.

  • @peterhughes8699
    @peterhughes8699 2 дні тому

    Short answers are ... NO and NO..... DNA crisis not required

  • @warrenbooysen
    @warrenbooysen День тому

    Relax everyone … NZ are two to three forwards with grunt away from being back on top. And SA are two to three retirements away from getting back to reality. PSDT, Eben, Kolisi for instance.

  • @multipletanksyndrome
    @multipletanksyndrome 2 дні тому

    When did the ABs settle for 3s, not 7s? Used to be you needed to score tries to beat the All Blacks. Now, you can just put kick them. How many times did they kick for the corner? What does that say about their confidence in their line out and maul? Which positions need better talent?

  • @ExcitingBob
    @ExcitingBob 20 годин тому

    lol Marshall is a few drinks down

  • @andrewharris1837
    @andrewharris1837 2 дні тому

    AB's havevloss their shine bcoz not possible to replace Retallic,Mounga,Smith overnite.Will take time but Razor will do it😊

  • @ianjames3162
    @ianjames3162 2 дні тому

    Jeff Wilson keeps asking the right Player Development questions, but no-one answers him. It's easy to say "we must get our Mojo back" (whatever that means). It's "how"? It's also easy to say: "South Africa don't know how to lose". That's just NOT true. A much more accurate assessment of the two Springbok performances is that they (the Springboks) were inaccurate, messy at line-out time, not especially dominant at scrum time, and their rush defense was often exposed. In fact, the All Blacks don't know how to win. Hence Jeff asking Player Development questions. The Boks have got "insurance" vs Argentina in Argentina because they've split their squad. They'll have a "reason", but on their performances the Argentinians playing with the skills they can, might expose a reality. And if that reality is exposed, it will be very revealing about the All Blacks.

  • @pdublt3d
    @pdublt3d 2 дні тому

    We still have the talent, it's just being bought out from under us for more money.

  • @honahwikeepa2115
    @honahwikeepa2115 День тому

    Not tough enough in the contact area. You get dominated.

  • @paulvanjaarsveld5965
    @paulvanjaarsveld5965 2 дні тому

    The AB”s did not replace their world class locks that retired…that is the problem…

    • @user-eo7gl4yq2u
      @user-eo7gl4yq2u 2 дні тому

      To be fair, they lack depth at lock. Tupou has been on song for the AB's this year so far

    • @JonathanNichollsjono
      @JonathanNichollsjono 2 дні тому

      ​@@user-eo7gl4yq2uHow great would your new locks have been if they could have played at least two years alongside those before the greats retired? There's no succession plan.

    • @user-eo7gl4yq2u
      @user-eo7gl4yq2u День тому

      @JonathanNichollsjono Tupou has been outstanding and he's lifting his game. I agree, there was no succession plan because the ABs and NZR are so hung up on special project players. They tried to develop Lord into a world class lock but hasn't come right. They're in a good position with Sam Darry. The NPC had shown some promising stars in the lock dept. The ABs need to start taking calculated risks by developing their stocks before the lucrative overseas clubs snaps them up.

  • @JohnOC86
    @JohnOC86 День тому

    The fear is gone as Irish the fear is just gone. I look at your team it’s poor

  • @JohnDoe-iq9bz
    @JohnDoe-iq9bz 2 дні тому

    The Wallabies exist for 1 reason. To make the all blacks look good😂😂😂

  • @nickrad6966
    @nickrad6966 2 дні тому +1

    Everyone has gotten better and your rugby has stagnated. Get over yourselves.

  • @jameswyatt4443
    @jameswyatt4443 День тому

    The real crisis is your own arrogance and inability to understand rugby. The greatest All Blacks team ever was 2015, in the World Cup final you kicked 39 times against the Wallabies, in the semi you kicked 47 times against the Boks, and in the quarter against France 39 times. You also dominated the scrums, and lost just 1 lineout in those 3 games against France. Check yourselves, your identity is kicking a lot to control territory and dominating set piece, the only difference between then and now is you were scoring lots of tries, which you can’t do now, due to the better defences of today, specifically the Boks. I hope all of you South African rugby haters who criticise a kicking and set piece game learn your lesson..

  • @dannyarcher6370
    @dannyarcher6370 2 дні тому

    To all the hysterical liberals in the comments, they clearly mean DNA in the figurative cultural sense; as in cricket is part of India's DNA.

  • @user-fw3le4xf3j
    @user-fw3le4xf3j 17 годин тому

    funny some people keep saying this is the worse All Blacks team ever, but i’ll give them credit for beating the so called best Irish rugby team ever in the World Cup last year 😂

    • @chasey2327
      @chasey2327 8 годин тому

      by a nose hair photo finish lad

  • @mikeevans9062
    @mikeevans9062 2 дні тому

    No comment about the Black Ferns match, what’s up guys I guess you didn’t even watch it

  • @Nat-oj2uc
    @Nat-oj2uc 2 дні тому

    Sititi is 8 right but who would've played 6 Marshall?

  • @davidlittle7418
    @davidlittle7418 2 дні тому

    lol I think the kiwis need a hug, oh dear they've lost a few games, spark a Bledisloe cup triumph lol when was the last time they lost the Bledisloe. Sounds like trying to put icing on a turd & calling it cake ha ha.

  • @josephjamesrollo9826
    @josephjamesrollo9826 2 дні тому

    Aussie is not competitive. They are on a losing streak. Good training run for allblacks

  • @Mo-yd8xc
    @Mo-yd8xc 2 дні тому

    Who envied NZ?😂

  • @philipgolding3672
    @philipgolding3672 День тому

    Jeffie... We are not talking about rugby in Botswana are we????.....

  • @sakabula2357
    @sakabula2357 2 дні тому

    You guys can come back next week and call me names etc if I'm wrong but I honestly can't see any way the Wallabies can upset the ABs this coming weekend...I've heard people say the Aussies are angry because of that last test in Argentina...what about the ABs??They just lost two in a row here in the republic...I'm just glad they are gone so my stress levels can get back to normal.Nah...ABs going to give them a hiding...Joe is a good coach...all respect..but I just don't think he has the right caliber of players available.

  • @robertobetta9602
    @robertobetta9602 День тому

    What’s in crisis is the referees and their decision making. Sour grapes, no.

  • @ciaranbrk
    @ciaranbrk 2 дні тому

    The do know how to lose they lost at home already. They are a fantastic side though this boks team are a great side.

  • @HainiS-g8i
    @HainiS-g8i 2 дні тому

    Coal. Kicked. I. Means

  • @stephendaisley8645
    @stephendaisley8645 2 дні тому

    Stop mentioning DNA as a biological pre- determinant....You are brilliant rugby players not biologists!!

    • @michaelmoynihan9591
      @michaelmoynihan9591 2 дні тому

      Kiwi dna is 75% European. Paddies English Welsh and jocks..they travelled in ships.watched porn had a great time with kiwi girls.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @michaelmoynihan9591
      @michaelmoynihan9591 2 дні тому

      The kiwis traced their dna.they are 75% jocks paddies welsh and poms.fact.they travelled in ships.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @HainiS-g8i
    @HainiS-g8i 2 дні тому

    I. Think is bettet Buck. Shelford to. Train. The. All. Blacks. Scrum

  • @EarlFrans
    @EarlFrans 2 дні тому

    New Zeeland will soon look similar to Australia on the rugbyfields of the world. Clinging for to long to the same group of players and not building depth. By the time you realize this and introducing new blood you`ll continue to loose 4 another 4 years before the team find each other and start to play as a unit. Your team is good, but just tooooo OLD

    • @Nat-oj2uc
      @Nat-oj2uc 2 дні тому

      What are you smoking Australia constantly changing the players.

    • @EarlFrans
      @EarlFrans 2 дні тому

      At least they do, NZ don`t. They`re building capacity, NZ stagnating no wonder everybody is starting to win AB`s

  • @njakes3001
    @njakes3001 2 дні тому

    Howzit boet 😂

  • @readesiun988
    @readesiun988 2 дні тому

    South Africa don't know how to lose, except they do, Ihey lost in July

  • @igsaan8573
    @igsaan8573 День тому

    JM is the GOAT