MeloWave Shadow GMRS Antenna vs Midland Ghost GMRS Antenna - Is The Melowave A Copy Of The Ghost?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 271

  • @Aegisltd
    @Aegisltd Рік тому +108

    It’s such a rare thing to find someone close to my age with a severely sarcastic sense of humor (which I enjoy immensely) that offers incredibly helpful advice. I’m very grateful I found your channel ! 👍

  • @shauno2006
    @shauno2006 Рік тому +28

    Fun fact, the Midland Ghost and 6Db whip actually work okay on 70cm and 2m. About 1.7 SWR. I was very impressed.

    • @grigorirasputin5020
      @grigorirasputin5020 Рік тому +2

      That is certainly helpful to know! Thanks!

    • @ChrisZwolinski
      @ChrisZwolinski Рік тому +6

      Another in the very informative “How SWR works “ series. Funny, I’ve know what SWR was since I was a CB kid in the 70s with NO sadHam license.
      I would have liked to have seen the readings from Chris’s perspective as well to see how well these little stubbies transmit. However my wife came in during your test, and I’m not allowed to watch UA-cam anymore. 😮😢

    • @sellickusa
      @sellickusa Рік тому

      I found the Midland 6db antenna to be best for my operational environment

    • @IanGarris
      @IanGarris Місяць тому

      Just sold me an antenna or five!

  • @wjf213
    @wjf213 Рік тому +20

    Definition of "GIRTH"....The ability to blow out the side of a tuna can without ever hitting bottom.
    Could you do a video on directional antennas like the Yagi? I'd love to see how well they perform against a standard antenna and if they can really extend the range of a radio any real amount. Thanks and keep up the great work.

    • @DePalma.
      @DePalma. Рік тому +1

      I’d like to see that too, maybe some good ones for Gmrs or a tutorial on how to make one…but above all please keep the awesome videos coming! 😎

    • @tadcobert1307
      @tadcobert1307 11 місяців тому

      Oh yes please!

    • @rockspydre
      @rockspydre 11 місяців тому

      I read this comment, and could barely breathe for the next 5 minutes. 🤣

  • @StephenFinkNRP
    @StephenFinkNRP Рік тому +5

    I looked away for a moment and when I looked back I thought I was watching the wrong video. 😘🤪😝 It's going to be a long long weekend. 🤗

  • @JohnSmith-gm4fj
    @JohnSmith-gm4fj Рік тому +7

    having worked in the antenna\combiner\multicoupler industry and having slept through countless seminars I can honestly say that YOU have found a way to keep my attention. Like a Bogner Penetrator antenna your signal has come across with crystal clarity, thank you!

  • @jaidoherty7638
    @jaidoherty7638 Рік тому +2

    I had to rewind this video many times because I kept having trouble hearing what you were saying towards the end. Thanks Randy, love your videos.

  • @BrianJalet
    @BrianJalet Рік тому +2

    I have to say, I learn so much from your series, but I also get a great deal of enjoyment out of your snarky/punchy approach. Thanks for that!

  • @HamRadioCrashCourse
    @HamRadioCrashCourse Рік тому +6

    Glad I could help!

  • @FLHamExtra
    @FLHamExtra Рік тому +3

    I like your videos. I’m learning about GMRS which is interesting. I’m taking my tech test for my ham license Saturday and I’m also going to get a gmrs license, thanks to you.

  • @andybonneau9209
    @andybonneau9209 Рік тому +10

    Thanks for the babe shots. This makes GMRS far more interesting.

  • @williamgonzales1980
    @williamgonzales1980 2 місяці тому

    Best in depth antenna analysis ever in the history of UA-cam. It really help my attention and made at least two large well rounded points...

  • @garretlewis4103
    @garretlewis4103 21 день тому

    I did the “from the yard test” on this Midland ghost antenna and the Browning ghost antenna. Using a hand held and the mobile radio in my truck, those two antennas performed the same to me on my “from the yard test”. Just a FYI in case anyone was curious.

  • @e.c.8668
    @e.c.8668 Рік тому +5

    I was good until he mentioned the pixies leaving the radio. I assume there is a conversion factor between the ham radio pixies and the GMRS electricities.

    • @TheNotaRubicon
      @TheNotaRubicon  Рік тому +8

      @HamRadioCrashCourse is not qualified to speak of GMRS "electricities" .. He's smart enough to stay in his own lane.

  • @wheel1775
    @wheel1775 Рік тому +6

    I have the Melowave and it knocks out my XM radio whenever I transmit. My cheaper Midland didn’t do it. I hope it doesn’t give me cancer. 😢

  • @Kennybunn0112
    @Kennybunn0112 Рік тому +3

    This is the best You Tube Channel out there.

  • @StevenRAssmann-tb7ty
    @StevenRAssmann-tb7ty 5 місяців тому +1

    Sad hams are crazy, I love your sarcasm and appreciate your videos

  • @alrubio4401
    @alrubio4401 Рік тому +5

    I was ready to give this video Several Extra Thumbs up for the scenes provided (to Prevent Antenna Boardeum) job well done..

  • @Dan-wt7jx
    @Dan-wt7jx Рік тому +6

    Definitely looking at one of these for the truck, but it would make my cb antenna look silly, so I need midland to make a chicken band ghost antenna to go with this for my gmrs.

  • @John-lz3hf
    @John-lz3hf Рік тому +3

    Thanks for keeping the boring charts interesting with all the random videos. Hilarious and Genius.

  • @dennishrusecky7549
    @dennishrusecky7549 Рік тому +3

    Excellent presentation as always, you are still the man. Your video entered into a place where no man has gone before. Great job

  • @Jeepjones85
    @Jeepjones85 Рік тому +5

    I wonder what is inside them, I run the midland antenna and it works great 👍

  • @sijonda
    @sijonda Рік тому

    I wasn't paying attention to my screen and was doing something else near the end of the video then glanced over when I noticed something didn't look right..... That made my day. Absolutely hilarious.

  • @acidreign8551
    @acidreign8551 Рік тому +4

    I am sure glad you had Chris explain some things to us since he is a licensed ham and is "qualified" to do so. But since you not a licensed ham operator, i hope the "experts" don't bust you using the rig expert device, pretty sure you need a ham license to own and operate one of those too. They will probably want to do something drastic like take away your belly button, and trust me, going through the rest of your life without your mama plug is going to be hell ! 😀

  • @madddawg1369
    @madddawg1369 Рік тому +2

    The online oxperts are going to say the difference is because you had the Midland on the left of screen.

  • @MattSadis
    @MattSadis Рік тому +3

    cool badge crew checking in. appreciate all these very informative reviews on stuffs. keep it up sir!

  • @NightHiker72
    @NightHiker72 Рік тому +3

    You Are The Frankie MacDonald Of The Radio World!! Rock On Man!!

  • @Stan_Rich
    @Stan_Rich Рік тому +1

    Thanks Randy, for your, once again, great antenna review. Both appear to be effective, almost equally. Many thanks to Josh as well, for his expert SWR explanation. With my Mobile in my Silverado, I run the “Midland - MXTA26 MicroMobile 6DB Gain Whip Antenna - Quadruple Signal Output - 32” “ on a “Midland - MicroMobile MXTA12 Antenna Mag Mount with NMO Connector” The Antennas you reviewed have the same “NMO Connector” so I may pick up one to have when I want a shorter ground to top of truck height measurement. Also, the “GMRS Radio Experts” on the Beach were also quite helpful in this vid. Lol! Recommend using them in your future vids.

  • @alzwicky156
    @alzwicky156 Рік тому +2

    Great comparison video and having josh explain swr was an added benefit to your favorite subscribers . Thanks for that bonus

  • @london19657
    @london19657 Рік тому +7

    I'm so happy that you are still alive(?) and making such informative videos. I only say that because most of your vids are a year old.
    Your fans have missed you. Including me, your favourite fan. I knew nothing about this hobby but you"re such a positive person, I had to buy the Boofwang.
    I will never go off-roading but I really enjoy your vids. I'm old and boring but living vicariously through you. Radio is a magical medium.
    You should have been a DJ, my friend.

    • @davidrush8283
      @davidrush8283 Рік тому

      www.youtube.com/@TheNotaRubicon/videos

    • @davidrush8283
      @davidrush8283 Рік тому

      You are welcome

    • @mmcnew1
      @mmcnew1 Рік тому +2

      You should be able find plenty of entertaining and informative videos posted by Randy this last year. His NotaRubicon Productions channel shows no fewer than 79 videos that have been posted between 3/22 and 2/23. Thats more than one video per week in this last year alone.

  • @jimkunkle2669
    @jimkunkle2669 Рік тому +2

    Josh for the win!!!

  • @Krispin291
    @Krispin291 2 місяці тому

    I beg for forgiveness since I had to pause the video for a very short period of time! I thought I knew them but nope. Keep on!

  • @HardcoreFourSix
    @HardcoreFourSix Рік тому +2

    Next level "stealth" antenna....Larsen Mirage NMO 450-470...the hockey puck antenna

  • @DePalma.
    @DePalma. Рік тому +1

    The girls rubbing sun tan lotion on each other was so natural for my brain that I didn’t even notice I wasn’t looking at an swr meter for 5-10 seconds😂

  • @mgoben6499
    @mgoben6499 Рік тому +1

    Yeah whatever Chris lol! +1 for the R33 Skyline drift clip. And the redheads.

  • @fredm8788
    @fredm8788 Рік тому +4

    I'm going to need the Barometric Pressure at the time of the testing, please 🥺

  • @brianbuchanan2414
    @brianbuchanan2414 Рік тому +1

    Really enjoy your videos, your humor is not lost

  • @overwatchdesigns8969
    @overwatchdesigns8969 Рік тому

    “I never knew I needed this channel so much. Why did it take me so long to find you?” -Not a so called “Expert”

  • @tinybadastronaut
    @tinybadastronaut 3 місяці тому

    I know this is an old video, but my god, I cracked up at Josh's entrance 😂

  • @Chadh9322
    @Chadh9322 Рік тому +1

    i like your "for the boys" clips

  • @RandellReeder
    @RandellReeder Рік тому +4

    My wife happened to be looking at the computer scream from across the room and proceeded to scream at me during the antenna test session.... Thanks for getting me in the doghouse. I'm banned from your channel for 30-days.

  • @torresmaria842
    @torresmaria842 Рік тому +3

    You always put a smile in my face. Macho 👨 man...

  • @cevgunnerF
    @cevgunnerF Рік тому +1

    Just a bit off-topic, thanks for your GMRS license step by step guide! Googled fcc gmrs license, it was in the top 2 answers! I was signed up and paid up within an hour! I enjoy your humor, and presentation - Keep up the great work 👍

  • @MrMlemon
    @MrMlemon Рік тому +2

    you should mount one on your UV-5R... That would be hilaerial.

  • @jamisoncook1948
    @jamisoncook1948 Рік тому

    Thank you for the comparison. Regardless of what the "experts" say your testing was spot on. It shows real world testing and your humor is enjoyable!! Keep up the good work!!!

  • @chrisking9000
    @chrisking9000 Рік тому +2

    You are too funny. I love the clips of the bikini babes and the car crashes. You have done something truly new.

  • @NathanKnetzer
    @NathanKnetzer Рік тому +1

    I had to start the video over at around the 12:45 mark... I lost track of what you were talking about

  • @oldmanhare
    @oldmanhare 9 місяців тому

    Excellent use of stock footage. Definitely help emphasize the points made here.

  • @jessikainla
    @jessikainla Рік тому +2

    Comedy and mayhem with a side of GMRS antenna info - love it

    • @markdoyle8713
      @markdoyle8713 Рік тому

      As the not a rubicon’s favorite subscriber ; a licensed gmrs and ham operator . I have done exhausting research and found that the only credentials required to purchase and possess a rig expert device is a healthy bank account …… they are not cheap.

  • @denniscrowley8517
    @denniscrowley8517 9 місяців тому

    Man, you got some real intelligent friends. And humble as a peacock(peecock)
    Thank you for your content.

  • @johnclark2149
    @johnclark2149 Рік тому +1

    God forbid that you might show a SmithChart! Those “sad hams” would loose their minds!! 😂

  • @Bob-lt5hf
    @Bob-lt5hf Рік тому +3

    Did you notice that the Melowave is labeled in MelowYellow???

  • @alessandroconcas
    @alessandroconcas Рік тому

    I think the things going interesting when Chris transmit near the ocean, they looks similar but don't have the same "prestacions"...😎

  • @robbennett
    @robbennett Рік тому +4

    Does Josh have a valid gmrs license? Is he qualified to talk about swr theory on gmrs frequencies?! I have questions.

  • @magnitudematrix2653
    @magnitudematrix2653 Рік тому +2

    I really like to see companies compete.

  • @carrow2250
    @carrow2250 5 місяців тому

    Thick, short, and black - just how I love my…antennas

  • @12HedmanLane
    @12HedmanLane Рік тому +1

    Let's get down to brass tacks. How many rounds do they hold?

  • @nypigskin
    @nypigskin Рік тому

    I didn’t hear a thing you said after 12:47. Now I have my-jiggle-hurtz.

  • @58Alpha
    @58Alpha Рік тому +1

    So, can we take apart each antenna for further comparison if they're the same? The results were quite similar, maybe no two Midlands would be equal I'm values due to manufacture tolerances and differences. So another way to verify is looking at the innards.

  • @DDGVET4
    @DDGVET4 17 днів тому

    I am ignorant and uninformed. However, I am NOT an expert. I watch this channel to become witty, entertaining and erudite.

  • @agrahazl
    @agrahazl Рік тому +1

    Did you actually capture the barometric pressure at both locations? As everyone knows air density can impact electron wave propagation. given the difference in elevations, is there anyway to account for gravitational lensing given the distance involved? Signals go faster downhill. Sad Ham irony aside, another great video and solid information!

  • @tommyleddy8728
    @tommyleddy8728 Рік тому

    I’m going to have to watch this one again. Things went blank ate the end.😅

  • @ericsvalland4417
    @ericsvalland4417 Рік тому

    Sorry man, but I lost what you were saying after the 12:45 mark! 🤣🤣

  • @JohnAdams-or9xw
    @JohnAdams-or9xw Рік тому

    Another great video Randy thanks for all the great videos you have made on this subject of gmrs. I have learned so much from watching them thank you my friend .

  • @CusterSurvivors
    @CusterSurvivors 5 місяців тому

    Bravo. Delivery impeccable. Everything you do has no peccs. I am happy. And I learn stuff from you.

  • @immabouttobebannedagain1320
    @immabouttobebannedagain1320 Рік тому +1

    Some people will find the perfect place to mount this little butt plug ghost antenna where none of the spurious emissions will find their way to atmosphere or reach farrrrrs enough to be heard by experts.
    Without specific mounting instructions, some of those people may become angry and disagree vehemently with your findings of performance.
    Perhaps some should subscribe and watch other videos to educate themselves before accusing and deny the acquired information you have so graciously imparted to the Favorite Viewer.
    Thank you for making the rest of us aware that some questions from those that refuse to accept help are just for the sake of argument and should be ignored for sanity sake.
    Thanks for the review.

  • @schnitznschnatzn
    @schnitznschnatzn 5 місяців тому

    Battle of the dummy loads! Woohoo! Which one can absorb more energy without exploding?

  • @Dj_Latinman
    @Dj_Latinman Рік тому +1

    i love those antennas but i have the browning ghost antenna

  • @silverismoney
    @silverismoney Рік тому

    Sad hams are indeed sad hams. Nothing like being an elite and excluding people. No wonder the number of HAMs is dropping continually. I don't care if you have a loicense or not, you keep doing your thing man. I value your channel.

  • @rockspydre
    @rockspydre 11 місяців тому

    Oh my god! The red head!
    Wait… what channel is this?

  • @BuckeyeHitters
    @BuckeyeHitters 7 місяців тому

    Not a member but may I politely ask, can you please review a Baofeng with a discone antenna. My thoughts were, a discone antenna may let others receive better reception and have more "FARS."

  • @DesertVan
    @DesertVan Рік тому +1

    Will this work on a balloon at 40,000 feet that goes off route by force majeure? Asking for a friend😊🇨🇳!

  • @greentoast9125
    @greentoast9125 Рік тому +1

    What about the phase of the moon? Deodorant or antiperspirant? Boxers or briefs?

  • @lamerdan
    @lamerdan Рік тому

    Great vid. Glad to see you are finally unleashing your Randyness.

  • @alanbloodworth2653
    @alanbloodworth2653 Рік тому

    Keep the antenna comparisons coming. Great content. Thank you.

  • @727cpt
    @727cpt Рік тому +1

    Midland 5/8 wave and Melowave is 1/4 wave. This didn’t make any difference in the test results. Anyone with a brief explanation?

  • @butopiatoo
    @butopiatoo Рік тому

    Now I'm confused. What was the brand of suntan oil that was being used? I mean that was a George Hamilton quality tan.

  • @n00615h
    @n00615h Рік тому

    I'm more interested in your radio antenna cleaning mat.

  • @Bluemsw1057
    @Bluemsw1057 5 місяців тому

    Did the links for your shirts break? I have tired multiple video links and can't get any of them to work. Love your channel.

    • @TheNotaRubicon
      @TheNotaRubicon  5 місяців тому

      Fixed! if you see any other broken links on videos just leave a comment..
      This is the updated link: amzn.to/3wQBSZN

  • @yucafries7681
    @yucafries7681 11 місяців тому +1

    Pull that damn film off the Rig Expert pls!!!

  • @kcstafford2784
    @kcstafford2784 10 місяців тому

    i been a fan of Josh for years now ...can i run an old school 6ft whip GMRS i have one on my old pickup 4CB and would love to have 2 fully funtional....Good work Randy thanks

  • @Kennybunn0112
    @Kennybunn0112 Рік тому

    WRWD728 here. Thanks for your videos.

  • @morthomer5804
    @morthomer5804 Рік тому +1

    Ham operators never worried about antenna girth

  • @ffmedic3349
    @ffmedic3349 8 місяців тому

    Dude that humor kills me ❤❤❤ 😂😂😂😂

  • @mitchmac3383
    @mitchmac3383 Рік тому

    🤣🤣 the chewed up pencil as a pointer. I hate you so much that I love you.

  • @W2IRT
    @W2IRT Рік тому

    Was that Tiffany the Ming Mole from the John Cadogan's favourite Island? And Josh is an AvE fan too! Starting to see a confluence of the best vloggers in the world.

  • @applesbighatranch6906
    @applesbighatranch6906 Рік тому

    "specifivicities" - I thought so, too. You nailed it the first time. A word so difficult to pronounce, the speaker is only capable of uttering the word correctly just once.

    • @applesbighatranch6906
      @applesbighatranch6906 Рік тому

      And I reply to my very own comment to merely add (and so as not to clutter up the First Column Comments) that I am a proud! ownzer of the Midland variant of the stubby, black RF Electricities Emitting Device. Oh! and I have also pur-chay-seed the Midland! MXTA26, because, truth be told, I wish to emulate to a greater degree my fine mentor, Lord Randolph of N.A.R.

  • @FinallyMe78
    @FinallyMe78 Рік тому +1

    That pencil pointer is way too clean. Do you even use it? ;)

  • @jamesmichaelwoods2930
    @jamesmichaelwoods2930 Рік тому

    Good to hear you Chris.

  • @WildcardRC
    @WildcardRC 8 місяців тому

    We need more info on that read head... Asking for a friend.

  • @tnewdad
    @tnewdad 6 місяців тому

    Love your “B roll”!

  • @artkillsevil
    @artkillsevil Рік тому +1

    Bro great channel can you make a shirt that says I'm not a ham operator but I play one in mine craft

  • @dustytrailscactusron
    @dustytrailscactusron Рік тому +1

    Excellent comparison, thank you.

  • @landontakeamericaback2106
    @landontakeamericaback2106 Рік тому +1

    😂🤣😂🤣2seconds in lmao god bless Calypso banana puffy sleeves. Be careful with that big black thing😂🤣😂

  • @brianw4brian
    @brianw4brian Рік тому

    So anything someone writes you do not like you censor them? Did I get that right you were conveying.

    • @TheNotaRubicon
      @TheNotaRubicon  Рік тому +1

      Yes, you got that right. If you dont like it, you are free to go away.

  • @bobvc6687
    @bobvc6687 10 місяців тому

    Oh my. If I'm deleted I will not be. Consider mi Q first. Considering no metal roof on Jeep, ground plane , and solutions given...... Could the spare cable be coiled and stored below the antenna, and above the speaker roll bar? Will that make the ground plane effectively providing a solution to Jeeps with no metal roofs?

  • @marioprzepiora
    @marioprzepiora Рік тому +1

    You forgot to add the following: barometric pressure, phase of the moon, time of day, and the sun's solar radiation at that particular moment.
    A local magnetic field strength might also be relevant for all the sad HAMs to verify and undoubtedly dispute your results.

  • @eolson1964
    @eolson1964 23 дні тому

    I have to ask, have you got the same results using different radios.with those same antennas? Very curious to know

  • @landontakeamericaback2106
    @landontakeamericaback2106 Рік тому +1

    Was the red head the Baofeng voice👯‍♀️

  • @1AXMRDR
    @1AXMRDR Рік тому +1

    Cleavage and antenna science in the same video? I love it.

  • @rossbar70
    @rossbar70 Рік тому +2

    I'm only here for the affiliate link theatrics