The Downside of “Profit First” for Small Business

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 56

  • @TaraWagner
    @TaraWagner  3 роки тому +5

    What do you think of the Profit First method? Do you utilize it in your biz? P.S. Be sure to jump on my free training, “How to Use a Holistic Approach to Create a Profitable Business Without Burning Yourself Out”. Learn more and reserve a seat here: xotara.us/training

    • @TheElizabethAlarcon
      @TheElizabethAlarcon 3 роки тому

      ✨ No lies detected! ✨ I think you hit the nail right on the head. You do have to find the right balance that works for you and your business. I kept adjusting and I think I’m in a good place for now. Definitely not a one and done or one size fits all system.

  • @TimGoree
    @TimGoree 11 місяців тому +7

    To me, the solution you're talking about is a simple tweak in the percentages of the system. Still use the same system, but instead of taking 50% of the total hanging out in your Profit Hold Savings Account every quarter, take less, or none at all. That Profit Hold account is meant as a quarterly profit distribution for the owners (like a dividend) AND disaster recovery AND a future growth fund for your business. So if you want to build up a big future growth fund to invest back in your business, pump up your total Profit percentage, and ratchet down your percentage of profit take quarterly for the owners. Done deal. Same system, just a change in percentages based on your desire as the owner.

  • @clairebeane3455
    @clairebeane3455 Місяць тому

    Thank you for this. Subscribed over this video. As I was reading through PF these were the issues I thought I might run into down the road. I want it to work “for” me “where I am” and down the road for “where I want to be with my business”.

  • @akeemhimself
    @akeemhimself 2 роки тому +16

    But half of the problems you talked about are against what he said... he said to start with 1% and move up to whatever is comfortable and sustainable. The 50% of profits at the end of each quarter, (not from every single sale) comes from the smaller percentage you take from each time you get revenue. He said to always have cash reserves in case of rainy days.

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  2 роки тому +3

      Yes, true. And the problems I'm talking about are what I see happening over time working with his method. To follow it 100% is often complex so other habits tend to take over. But as I mentioned, I still agree with most of his method, just think it needs to be managed thoughtfully. Would you agree?

  • @tomaskey6844
    @tomaskey6844 9 місяців тому

    I just started the audiobook and decided to get a shorter video to help me see it visually. I liked seeing your view right from the beginning so I have that in mind from the start. I have my first YNAB coaching session and will see how she responds to profit first. I’m exploring business banks and came to this through researching Relay. Very interesting

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  9 місяців тому +1

      Glad it was helpful! Hope the session goes well

  • @geoffl
    @geoffl 27 днів тому

    first real benefit I've heard: reducing destructive "it's a writeoff" behavior. It's fine to pay taxes if it means your business is actually producing money for you.

  • @SmallSpoonBrigade
    @SmallSpoonBrigade 2 місяці тому

    I've just started reading the book, so I might not understand. But, the discussions I've seen indicate that there's profit and then there's the owner pay and they're not the same. The profits just get set aside, they may be used to grow the business, or they may eventually be taken as actual owner income depending upon what is going on. They may even be invested for another source of income.

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  2 місяці тому

      It's been a bit since I've read it, so the book or this vid is not fresh in my mind but those two words (profit and owner draw) are often used interchangeably, especially for tiny businesses and solopreneurs, so it's important to look at all sides and options to make the right moves for you.

  • @Shrimpyyyyyyyy
    @Shrimpyyyyyyyy 2 роки тому +2

    I’m listening to the book right now and he says to accumulated 3 months worth of expenses in the profit account and then anything over that should be used to reinvest back into the business so maybe I’m listening to an update version of the book?

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  2 роки тому

      That is a great way to do it as well. Remember to evaluate your business needs first and discover what method of organization around your biz profits will work best. There are a plethora of ways to manage it successfully. What do you believe will work best for your biz right now? I'd love to hear it.

    • @jazzmoon77
      @jazzmoon77 8 місяців тому

      Agreed. The “problem” isn’t a problem - it’s not following the guidance in the book which is to differentiate between putting too much into regular opex vs making profits that can be reinvested into growing the business, not just drawing down all profit as owners pay.

  • @furmanfurman
    @furmanfurman Рік тому

    @TaraWagner Good points! I'm new to Profit First and trying to implement asap. Q. Do you have an account for Profit and an account for Owner's Draw...aka your paycheck?.

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  Рік тому +1

      I don't do all the accounts he recs. I have an Income and Expense account, a tax and payroll account, and I transfer my owner draw monthly from the first into my personal checking, and my wages from the 1st into the second. Find what works for you!

  • @jojose417
    @jojose417 6 місяців тому

    I love this!! Getting the book I’m just starting out selling on the side

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  6 місяців тому +1

      So glad you're starting early with it! I hope this video helps your process with it!

    • @jojose417
      @jojose417 6 місяців тому

      Definitely helpful thank you so much!!

  • @michaelsohocki1573
    @michaelsohocki1573 Рік тому

    Thank you for the video, my company evolution is similar to yours, I've been open for fourteen years now, considering profit first seriously.

  • @pandorasunboxing
    @pandorasunboxing 2 роки тому

    Awesome video!!! Thank you for this great video🙏

  • @westandbyher
    @westandbyher 3 роки тому +2

    I do profit from the profit. I put 25 percent from my profit into crypto(here you need first to analyze the market and to invest in the right time) and then I have more profit, then I take back 25% and reinvest it back into my business and the best part is that those "old 25%" they keeping to grow.

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  2 роки тому

      Nice! I love that you have a pretty solid strategy in place for your biz.

  • @carrieschultz7165
    @carrieschultz7165 10 місяців тому

    I don't really understand the difference between profit and owner's pay. Is profit something we put away for a rainy day and Owner's pay simply our paycheque? Might be a silly question but these are two separate categories in the Profit First book.

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  9 місяців тому +1

      not silly at all! And there might be a variety of answers based on POV/opinion or who wants to know (the IRS will be more exact than you might need to be for example). But I view them on a very practical level, as essentially the same thing. It's money you take out of the business for yourself to do what you want. (Although if you're saving for a business rainy day, talk to your accountant about whether that's profit or not. Def not owner pay.) It IS different than if you pay yourself a salary under an S-corp but if you're not an s- or c-corp, then owner's draw and salary and profit will feel like interchangeable words.

    • @carrieschultz7165
      @carrieschultz7165 9 місяців тому

      Thank you!! That makes sense. I appreciate you taking the time!

    • @JacobBall75
      @JacobBall75 9 місяців тому +1

      I would look at it differently. The Owners Draw or salary are interchangeable, but PROFIT should be viewed as a separate entity. It’s a bonus, not part of your owners draw or salary. Your owners draw / salary is your regular pay that hopefully covers your own personal lifestyle expenses. That owners draw / salary is a regular business expense, and should be treated as such.
      The whole premise behind Profit First is that it’s a separate line item to be extracted FIRST, not to be confused with owner draw or salary or an expense. It’s on TOP of your salary, and it’s only distributed to the owner/s of the business quarterly AND you (as a guide) only distribute 50% of whatever is in the profit account with the balance being left for a rainy day or business growth 😊

    • @Lauren-i8i
      @Lauren-i8i 3 місяці тому

      @@JacobBall75👏👏👏

  • @UrbanCajunGirl
    @UrbanCajunGirl 2 роки тому

    #2 is spot on!

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  2 роки тому

      Nice! Glad you enjoyed the vid. Have you read the book yet?

  • @TeaPourSixFour
    @TeaPourSixFour 2 роки тому

    I Subscribed to your channel. Thank you 🙏🏾 Ms. Ayden in Nevada

  • @sidi.soueina
    @sidi.soueina 2 роки тому

    thanks!

  • @G.Family.
    @G.Family. 9 місяців тому

    Profit First Changed my Life ❤
    I need to be more disciplined though because I definitely used the tax money for a trip to Barbados 😂 😂😂

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  9 місяців тому +1

      Love that! You've got this! What is the first step you're going to take?

    • @G.Family.
      @G.Family. 9 місяців тому +1

      @@TaraWagner step 1 pay my tax on 31st Jan (uk deadline)
      Step 2 pay off the bank overdraft ☠️

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  9 місяців тому +1

      You got this!

    • @G.Family.
      @G.Family. 9 місяців тому +1

      @@TaraWagner 🙌

  • @KingAndrew5000
    @KingAndrew5000 10 місяців тому

    this book is Business 101. Honestly, if you're not capable of keeping track of your money, you shouldn't be in business in the first place.

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  10 місяців тому +3

      Unfortunately this kind of mindset only hurts small business owners who are good at what they do as a business, but are still learning how to "do business". We all start somewhere! Do you remember the mistakes you made in the beginning that seem simple now? I sure do!

    • @Lauren-i8i
      @Lauren-i8i 3 місяці тому

      We all have a learning curve to some degree and that’s OK.
      Profit First is NOT Business 101 as it has been conducted for the last 300 years.
      Instead of the traditional:
      Income - Expenses = Profit
      The equation is:
      Income - Profit = Expenses.
      This turns the old model on its head.
      If we don’t preserve profit first we will likely spend available funds out of habit.
      We must learn to run our business on a tighter budget instead of spending every dime we have in order to protect profits or we won’t have anything left at the end of the quarter.

  • @DunBossNyakundi
    @DunBossNyakundi Рік тому

    Hey I thought the author already talks about starting a small %....... isn't your so called "solution covered..... or its me

  • @OtakuBoxes
    @OtakuBoxes 8 місяців тому

    Show me the money 🎉.

  • @jaysvapesandpipes
    @jaysvapesandpipes 2 роки тому

    Show me the money

  • @TeaPourSixFour
    @TeaPourSixFour 2 роки тому

    🫶🏻 yes, helpful & humane review. I am a fan of all money mindset books and programs but especially Toyin Crandell 💓 where I am learning about & implementing Profit First. I’m happy to hear about your business thoughts and journey Tara ! Keep at it lady.

    • @TaraWagner
      @TaraWagner  2 роки тому

      I 100% agree! What is your biggest takeaway from the Toyin Crandell?