Carl's a sell out. You can like someone without them being any good. He knows that. He just sell you all what you want to hear. Grow up and think for yourselves.
I absolutely love Carl and the old school player mentality. Today's players are giving so much praise (and money) for not accomplishing a thing! Players need to listen to the older guys like Banks. Thank you Carl for being the player you were. I'd certainly sign up for a Giants roster full of players like yourself. You represent what the Giants and football in general should be!
Carl you are so right! Analytics should be combined with the human aspect of the players. The movie Moneyball shows that clearly. Totally agree with you. This is why you and Papa have the best Giants show/pod on UA-cam/PodcastWorld
I always appreciate the measured approach to pulling up the hood on the narratives to search for evidence that proves or disproves it. No hot takes, just logic. Great work as always. Happy Thanksgiving.
Carl needs access to the meetings. Allow a NY Giant Legend to see what the hell is going on. The Giants won't do it because Carl will call people out and if it happens to really be the coaches, the coaches are the ones that are soft and make players soft. The DC is very soft and should never have been hired. The reason TN had a better defense was due to Vrabel not Bowen.
Thank you Carl. I've said I don't care who you don't like but play the darn game you're getting paid. People saying the defense isn't doing their job because they're tired. Defense took the field after a week off how tired could they be on that 1st drive
Joe Shoen needs to take accountability. Instead of keeping Xavier McKinney, Julian Love, Leonard Williams we decide to replace them after paying Daniel and tagging Saquon. We are replacing good players instead of building a roster. We do not have enough talent to compete with average and bad teams. Daniel Jones wasn't the problem? Yes he was and it was because the organization failed him and themselves. The dude never got a fair shot to compete because he was running for his life for 6 years and broke his neck and tore his ACL, he's not the same player he used to be. Evan Neal and Thibs with 2 top 10 picks, those should be contributing players right now, Instead Thibs gets hurt every year and Neal has gotten worse every year. Darren Waller? Paying Burns 150mil? Cutting your best QB in the middle of the season? What are we doing...?
Jones had plenty of chances, he has stunk for years but you couldn't be more correct about "Joe Shoen needs to take accountability." The lack of talent; this disaster, is almost entirely Joe's fault. This is his roster and he is a horrible GM. Complete lack of a backup plan at the QB position this year. Doesn't even have a capable #2, passed up Wilson and other veteran options at QB. Did not adequately address the outside CB position. Did not address the defensive tackle position. Had absolutely horrible picks in 2022 and 2023 draft classes. JMS, an avg center, our best pick in 2023? Trading up for Hyatt, lol. Banks can't make a play on the ball to save his life. Gray a 3rd stringer, rest of them no role or off the team. He sounded completely clueless on hard knocks. Give me a break.
They throw 5 passes in the first half. Two of which were incomplete. They handcuffed Tommy and ran it like they still had Saquon. That's more coaching than anything else.
few weeks away from the joyous holiday season and all the sports talk is about who and when could somebody be fired or on.the hot seat. it's a wonderful time of the year .
Listen to Carl Banks NY Giants. He played under the greatest defensive coach of all time who always found a way to get the best out of his players. Some of these coaches in the NFL are smart but they are unable to adjust if they don't have the perfect players for their scheme - and there are always injuries or something.
Running the Wildcat... Fact is that THE PLAY was unfamiliar to Tracy in that context. It would be different if he had several Wildcat plays under his belt. Yes, he remains fully responsible for the fumble. He's gotta work on that. However, Daboll has a history of calling funky plays close to the end zone. The Lesson - When dealing with a young roster, Simplicity is best.
the press interviewed casey stengal after a loss...the first question asked was "what do you think of your teams execution today.......Casey answered........"I'm all for it"
First to be clear about the Daniel Jones point Carl is making I have never said and he's not talking about me I know I'm just making a point about this discussion a bit first he's not a bad player nor does he not deserve to be on a team I don't think he does no doubt but based on the money he was paid and the Eli Manning comparisons you expected more than he produced regardless of the circumstances
Love the podcast, and agree with almost everything said, but I have to disagree with Bob Papa on his comments how the wildcat play with Tracy was the same as if he'd been handed the ball. The point (and the reason the wildcat wasn't a great idea) is that when Tracy lined up to take the snap, it was obvious what was going to happen--a Tracy run somewhere. If they'd run a normal play, then there would've been much less certainty on the Tampa Bay defense as to where the play was going to go. That's what made it a bad play call.
Preciate the pod, and respect to both you gentlemen. I still believe Daboll has to go, and Schoen needs to be the one to fire him. He is not the coach for this team.
I like this cursing Banks.. lol... for real though... as a fan and someone who loved playing football. Show some anger, fire, and edge out there... Play angry out there, this team looking like it's ok to get embarrassed. Even if we lose the game, get in there and fight! Its a relief to listen to Banks and get perspective, knowledge mixed with raw emotion like today. By the way, I dont listen to those guys who disrespected Banks till this day.
DJ was never the problem. DJ was a very good QB on an awful team. I'm done with all these stupid giants podcast. The team sucks, the coach sucks. Can't wait for dj to come back on a decent team and destroy us. This coming from a fan who's missed 2 games, when I was in the service, in 63 yrs. A lifelong giants fan. One parting comment, Carl Banks should be in the Hof
Can we just blow it all up and hire Carl as the new head coach? We need to bring back some of the old school mentality and leadership, and who better to do that than Carl?
When the Giants GM & HC forced out Wink and let Barkley walk, they lost the heart and soul of this team. They tossed the OL coach out and had to overpay Kafka to stay, avoiding the optics of a full blown staff mutiny. In business, that's a leadership issue, so FIRE the GM & HC. Love listening to Bob & Carl and still have a #58 and #56 jerseys!!
Guys, you brought up a lot of great points, but you missed the mark on Devito getting the start over Lock. Exactly when did Devito beat Lock out, as Carl said? Devito wasn’t impressive in the preseason. If he beat him out in practice, why was Lock listed as the #2 all year? Cause Devito will put more butts in the seats? That’s a terrible reason, if that is in fact the reason. About the only worse reason I can think of is so that Lock doesn’t reach the incentives in his contract. Either way, not a good look for the Giants organization. Players notice these things. Free agents notice these things.
Question for Carl: is it possible Daboll played DeVito over Lock to see if he could be their QB2 for 2025? This way, they won't have to bring back Lock (or sign somebody else) to be their QB2 for next season and such a decision could possibly free up more dollars to sign some free-agents at other positions of need. Just a thought and I'm wondering if it's plausible. Thanks.
Tackles are missed all the time. Where's the support? If the 1st guy doesn't get him down, he's at least disrupted the play. Where's the swarm? I think players are dogging it, and then they see a guy break loose, and then they decide to run after him. You finish tackles as a team. Yeah, sometimes one player makes a great play, and Carl was one of the best individual tacklers ever, but it's a team game. 3 guys were blocking Dex, were were the 3 or 4 unblocked players (QB and ball carrier aren't blocking).
GIVE KAFKA THE PLAY CALLING, AND DABOLL JUST BE A COACH! AND THE DEFENSIVE COORDINATOR. STINKS! IM TIRED OF THE REVOLVING DOOR. OF. COACHES!! AND PLAYERS! We win when the team stays together for a few years , coaches and players need to stay together!! Stop changing! I MISS THE. FASSEL AND COUGHLIN DAYS!
The horses have largely left the barn. The “leaders ” are pretty much gone. Everyone remaining has been short term and have known only failure as a Giant. Dexter may be all that remains. Unless you want to include the 3 year veteran Evan Neal as a leader.
Why not get veterans like Tiki who had fumble problems early on take Tyrone under his wing. Defensive guys like Carl and LT could do the same with the younger defensive guys. Amani with the receivers. Etcetera.
Our bad tackling always reflects “ tackling high.” And at the NFL level that won’t ever work. So there is a cowardice going on. People are afraid to tackle low because it hurts. But it is the only way. That is the “ softness” the Giants are describing .
Did the Giants Win Games with DJ ? Nope , And just like that the players Love Daniel , blame coaches , did the coaches throw a bad pass ? Did the coaches drop a pass ? Miss a Block ? Miss a Tackle ? Miss an assignment ?
To the devito out played lock point around the 45:00 mark. When dj got benched in the Carolina game, Drew lock played. If devito out played him why wasn’t he elevated to QB2? Come on guys.
Bob the issue is that DJ should not be benched for worst qb's with 7 games left. If you do it with 2 games or a game left that is different but 7 games? Nah that is the team giving up so the players saw the message. The Broncos did it with 2 games left owing way more
Just like EVERY SINGLE other week…the game was never competitive. That falls DIRECTLY on the coaching staff. What does it say when the coaches bench and then release your best chance to win at quarterback? There is half a season left!!!! Going to be UGLY for the next 6 weeks…
Sounds like we talking about a bunch kids . Who rather be friends then to win games. Miss handled or not. Daniel has been badd period, I see two or three touchdowns left on the field every week.
The Entire Organization does not have One thing they do right, Since the CB58 days, The offensive line in the 80s we knew their Names Oates, Benson etc.Defensive we knew everyone name because they were Great at holding the line of scrimmage. They need a sense unity of pride to hold the line of scrimmage in Both side of the ball! The Organization need build a team that could recognize talent and draft talent, When Eli was getting up in years they never address get his Backup. They going to draft a 1st round QB and cannot block for run or pass! The Offense Scheme Stale and predictive because they cannot protect the QB then you become routine. Eli use to get kill. They always looking on Defense instead of Read and reacting! Special team tackling! Coffin corner. No turnovers Really. I'm not sure this is a team 1st mindset. Giants lets Go!
I think the reason people are clamoring to the idea of running the wild cat in that situation it’s because we don’t have the luxury to get cute we’re not a successful enough offense good enough to get cute to try stuff that is even more risky being that we’re not running that play often. What can go wrong for the Giants will go wrong for us and we have not been in rhythm long enough to take high risk chances. Yes he could’ve fumbled in a regular run play sure the wildcat came at an inopportune time is what us fans are critical of.
It’s the coach and play calling then we have a Gm that let one of the best RB go in the game for all of this really this was the plan and how long yall think the defense gone show while the offense sits idle truly embarrassed at this point and I’m a die hard representative of the giants .. I could keep digging but I won’t
Joe S failed miserably at his assessment. Some things are beyond money. I would also add that all the top players he didn't pay are performing on their new teams. Fail...absolute fail. Sorry Gettleman gets beat up for picking a running back and Jones...but he picked better quality. Jones got f'd in the head here with too many bosses trying to tweak him. His biggest issue was fumbles his rookie year. He had no problem throwing TDs or down field until people tried to fix him and his injuries happened.
Maybe Daboll is to blame for a lot but I don't care... no-one should point fingers at specific teammates and especially the coach..If Mara gets a new coach for Nabers and we start this again he's gonna do the same shit when things go wrong. He plays with the body language of a quitter and he has a good number of drops.... I think he has great talent but he needs to say " We suck and we have to get better" Say it and mean it. New York media will swallow you whole that's why Mara is so intent on have Manning and Jones as the QBS... FYI We do suck and we have to get better.
Malik nabers criticized the head coach the things he complained about had nothing to do with the front office remember DJ was benched thats a coaching decision nabers is criticizing daboll coaching decisions not joe schoen rember the gm doesn't make coaching decisions the head coach makes coaching decisions.and remember DJ asked the front office to release him malik nabers has no problem with the front office the front office /joe schoen is the one who drafted him not daboll remember joe schoen drafted the wide receiver personnel for the offensive coordinator mike kafka, daboll is there to coach not to be offensive coordinator thats kafka job.but the thing is brian daboll was stupid enough to take play calling from mike kafka when mike kafka play calling got the giants in the playoffs and helped daboll win the coach of the year award in 2022.daboll needs to leave joe schoen and kafka needs to stay period 💯
Giants are a joke. DJ will find success with a new team. Players calling out " softness" would never happen under Parcels or Coughlin. Or Belechick or Reid or any of the great Coaches.
This is the pod every Giants fan, player & coach needs to listen to! Carl was a f’ing BEAST! My man keeps it 100!!!!!
100
Thank you! Spread the word.
Always a great pod. A must listen to…thank you, Carl and Bob.
I wish Carl can talk to the defensive players. Any chance he wants to coach??!?!
Carl's a sell out. You can like someone without them being any good. He knows that. He just sell you all what you want to hear. Grow up and think for yourselves.
@@CynthiaGeorgette Thanks for listening !
Love you guys, Carl you keep me a sane giants fan in times like these 😂
Thank you Carl and Bob for filtering out all the noise and telling it like it is. Go Giants!
I absolutely love Carl and the old school player mentality. Today's players are giving so much praise (and money) for not accomplishing a thing! Players need to listen to the older guys like Banks. Thank you Carl for being the player you were. I'd certainly sign up for a Giants roster full of players like yourself. You represent what the Giants and football in general should be!
Thank you Bob and Carl. You always tell it straight. No bullshit.
Carl you are so right! Analytics should be combined with the human aspect of the players. The movie Moneyball shows that clearly. Totally agree with you. This is why you and Papa have the best Giants show/pod on UA-cam/PodcastWorld
They base everything on analytics but the same data that works for a company like apple may not work for a toshiba.
This is great, Carl and Bob are making it make sense , thanks
Thank u Bob n Carl for the facts you two are the only giants voice of reasoning
Once again, Bob and Carl nalied it. You gotta B-leav!!! Let's go Giants!!! ✌🏻
This gotta be a new record for F bombs by Carl 😂😂😂
I don't blame him.
For me, I DON’T “BLEAV” in Dabol ! You are what your record says you are ! It says FAILURE!
You guys always make sense you are the best
I always appreciate the measured approach to pulling up the hood on the narratives to search for evidence that proves or disproves it. No hot takes, just logic. Great work as always. Happy Thanksgiving.
Amen Carl, way to call it out!
Happy Holidays 🎅
Carl needs access to the meetings. Allow a NY Giant Legend to see what the hell is going on. The Giants won't do it because Carl will call people out and if it happens to really be the coaches, the coaches are the ones that are soft and make players soft. The DC is very soft and should never have been hired. The reason TN had a better defense was due to Vrabel not Bowen.
Yes, CB! 58 speaks the truth! G-Men fan since 1979!
It is coaching Carl. Naber ain't wrong
Thank you Carl. I've said I don't care who you don't like but play the darn game you're getting paid. People saying the defense isn't doing their job because they're tired. Defense took the field after a week off how tired could they be on that 1st drive
I give you two guys tons of credit for having the stomach to witness this train wreck on a weekly basis.
The Giants still need to fix their protection problems. It's been over 10 years already.
Love you guys. This was my one game a year that I went to.
Joe Shoen needs to take accountability. Instead of keeping Xavier McKinney, Julian Love, Leonard Williams we decide to replace them after paying Daniel and tagging Saquon. We are replacing good players instead of building a roster. We do not have enough talent to compete with average and bad teams. Daniel Jones wasn't the problem? Yes he was and it was because the organization failed him and themselves. The dude never got a fair shot to compete because he was running for his life for 6 years and broke his neck and tore his ACL, he's not the same player he used to be. Evan Neal and Thibs with 2 top 10 picks, those should be contributing players right now, Instead Thibs gets hurt every year and Neal has gotten worse every year. Darren Waller? Paying Burns 150mil? Cutting your best QB in the middle of the season? What are we doing...?
Jones had plenty of chances, he has stunk for years but you couldn't be more correct about "Joe Shoen needs to take accountability." The lack of talent; this disaster, is almost entirely Joe's fault. This is his roster and he is a horrible GM. Complete lack of a backup plan at the QB position this year. Doesn't even have a capable #2, passed up Wilson and other veteran options at QB. Did not adequately address the outside CB position. Did not address the defensive tackle position. Had absolutely horrible picks in 2022 and 2023 draft classes. JMS, an avg center, our best pick in 2023? Trading up for Hyatt, lol. Banks can't make a play on the ball to save his life. Gray a 3rd stringer, rest of them no role or off the team. He sounded completely clueless on hard knocks. Give me a break.
They throw 5 passes in the first half. Two of which were incomplete. They handcuffed Tommy and ran it like they still had Saquon. That's more coaching than anything else.
17:09 nothing but love for Banks
I wish Banks was on this coaching staff. Daboll should be playing this on a fucking loop
Love this slow keep it up brothers. Miz.
Great show, inside the GIants on what is going on and how to right the ship. Happy Turkey Day to you Both and Lets GO GIANTS !!!
few weeks away from the joyous holiday season and all the sports talk is about who and when could somebody be fired or on.the hot seat.
it's a wonderful time of the year .
Listen to Carl Banks NY Giants. He played under the greatest defensive coach of all time who always found a way to get the best out of his players.
Some of these coaches in the NFL are smart but they are unable to adjust if they don't have the perfect players for their scheme - and there are always injuries or something.
I love Carl Banks. Great player and person.
Excellent content you both are the best!! Thank you for being real & true!!😊😊
NEED YOU ON THAT STAFF CARL!!
TY enough of the casual bombastic noise and more of this
The disrespect to DJ started in hard knocks and never stopped……..nobody deserves that type of hate….. wonder who the fans going after next……
I wish Carl Banks was on our coaching staff.
Running the Wildcat... Fact is that THE PLAY was unfamiliar to Tracy in that context. It would be different if he had several Wildcat plays under his belt. Yes, he remains fully responsible for the fumble. He's gotta work on that. However, Daboll has a history of calling funky plays close to the end zone. The Lesson - When dealing with a young roster, Simplicity is best.
Player paychecks are TODAY! Congrats Boys 🎉 Fans are 💯 % in support 😂
Thank the football gods for these guys.
New defensive coach ... Carl Banks !!!
Spot it, say it. They give up on these coaches
Proven HC would never let this shit fly. We need one and a QB then there might be light at the end of tunnel
Carl Banks should be hired as a coach for the Giants
Why in the hell did they draft him?!?!?! My brain is f&$!ing melting.
the press interviewed casey stengal after a loss...the first question asked was "what do you think of your teams execution today.......Casey answered........"I'm all for it"
Great analyst. Carl tells it like it is w/o BS! Carl for HeadCoach or GM
First to be clear about the Daniel Jones point Carl is making I have never said and he's not talking about me I know I'm just making a point about this discussion a bit first he's not a bad player nor does he not deserve to be on a team I don't think he does no doubt but based on the money he was paid and the Eli Manning comparisons you expected more than he produced regardless of the circumstances
Well said Carl....... ❤ # 58
Love the podcast, and agree with almost everything said, but I have to disagree with Bob Papa on his comments how the wildcat play with Tracy was the same as if he'd been handed the ball. The point (and the reason the wildcat wasn't a great idea) is that when Tracy lined up to take the snap, it was obvious what was going to happen--a Tracy run somewhere. If they'd run a normal play, then there would've been much less certainty on the Tampa Bay defense as to where the play was going to go. That's what made it a bad play call.
Preciate the pod, and respect to both you gentlemen. I still believe Daboll has to go, and Schoen needs to be the one to fire him. He is not the coach for this team.
John Mara knew this about Barkley that's why he wanted to keep him. He let his GM make the decision though fans say he meddles.
I like this cursing Banks.. lol... for real though... as a fan and someone who loved playing football. Show some anger, fire, and edge out there... Play angry out there, this team looking like it's ok to get embarrassed. Even if we lose the game, get in there and fight! Its a relief to listen to Banks and get perspective, knowledge mixed with raw emotion like today. By the way, I dont listen to those guys who disrespected Banks till this day.
The best
DJ was never the problem. DJ was a very good QB on an awful team. I'm done with all these stupid giants podcast. The team sucks, the coach sucks. Can't wait for dj to come back on a decent team and destroy us. This coming from a fan who's missed 2 games, when I was in the service, in 63 yrs. A lifelong giants fan. One parting comment, Carl Banks should be in the Hof
You hit the nail on the head Carl. Schoen doesn't give a damn about culture, only the dollars and cents of the business.
Can we just blow it all up and hire Carl as the new head coach? We need to bring back some of the old school mentality and leadership, and who better to do that than Carl?
When the Giants GM & HC forced out Wink and let Barkley walk, they lost the heart and soul of this team. They tossed the OL coach out and had to overpay Kafka to stay, avoiding the optics of a full blown staff mutiny. In business, that's a leadership issue, so FIRE the GM & HC. Love listening to Bob & Carl and still have a #58 and #56 jerseys!!
Carl on the Analytics & Human Elements was pure gold🥇Experience over everything! I Bleav In Giants!💯🫡
Guys, you brought up a lot of great points, but you missed the mark on Devito getting the start over Lock. Exactly when did Devito beat Lock out, as Carl said? Devito wasn’t impressive in the preseason. If he beat him out in practice, why was Lock listed as the #2 all year? Cause Devito will put more butts in the seats? That’s a terrible reason, if that is in fact the reason. About the only worse reason I can think of is so that Lock doesn’t reach the incentives in his contract. Either way, not a good look for the Giants organization. Players notice these things. Free agents notice these things.
Just say the truth first of all Thank-you Nabers for saying the truth The issue is Schoen And dabbell need to go.
😢🔥 🔥 JOE AND BRIAN 🔥🔥😢
Carl for HC 🎉
Question for Carl: is it possible Daboll played DeVito over Lock to see if he could be their QB2 for 2025? This way, they won't have to bring back Lock (or sign somebody else) to be their QB2 for next season and such a decision could possibly free up more dollars to sign some free-agents at other positions of need. Just a thought and I'm wondering if it's plausible. Thanks.
Tackles are missed all the time. Where's the support? If the 1st guy doesn't get him down, he's at least disrupted the play. Where's the swarm?
I think players are dogging it, and then they see a guy break loose, and then they decide to run after him. You finish tackles as a team. Yeah, sometimes one player makes a great play, and Carl was one of the best individual tacklers ever, but it's a team game. 3 guys were blocking Dex, were were the 3 or 4 unblocked players (QB and ball carrier aren't blocking).
So our defense sucks, I think Wink was telling us where our problem is ? 😔
GIVE KAFKA THE PLAY CALLING, AND DABOLL JUST BE A COACH! AND THE DEFENSIVE COORDINATOR. STINKS! IM TIRED OF THE REVOLVING DOOR. OF. COACHES!! AND PLAYERS! We win when the team stays together for a few years , coaches and players need to stay together!! Stop changing! I MISS THE. FASSEL AND COUGHLIN DAYS!
The horses have largely left the barn. The “leaders ” are pretty much gone. Everyone remaining has been short term and have known only failure as a Giant. Dexter may be all that remains. Unless you want to include the 3 year veteran Evan Neal as a leader.
Why not get veterans like Tiki who had fumble problems early on take
Tyrone under his wing. Defensive guys like Carl and LT could do the same with the younger defensive guys. Amani with the receivers. Etcetera.
Our bad tackling always reflects “ tackling high.” And at the NFL level that won’t ever work. So there is a cowardice going on. People are afraid to tackle low because it hurts. But it is the only way. That is the “ softness” the Giants are describing .
Did the Giants Win Games with DJ ? Nope , And just like that the players Love Daniel , blame coaches , did the coaches throw a bad pass ? Did the coaches drop a pass ? Miss a Block ? Miss a Tackle ? Miss an assignment ?
To the devito out played lock point around the 45:00 mark. When dj got benched in the Carolina game, Drew lock played. If devito out played him why wasn’t he elevated to QB2? Come on guys.
I’ve been saying it all year we need IDL depth BADLY. Dexter can’t be in every play
Players only wasting their own money by letting lack of effort get on tape.
Banks should be our coach
Bob the issue is that DJ should not be benched for worst qb's with 7 games left. If you do it with 2 games or a game left that is different but 7 games? Nah that is the team giving up so the players saw the message. The Broncos did it with 2 games left owing way more
I miss george young.
You need to scheme with the players you have not the players you wish you had.
Can you bet on your breakfast order? How can we live without gambling? You guys are great. Thanks. I’m wagering 85% of my salary now
Don't care anything to hear anything about Snakequon Barkely
Just like EVERY SINGLE other week…the game was never competitive. That falls DIRECTLY on the coaching staff. What does it say when the coaches bench and then release your best chance to win at quarterback? There is half a season left!!!! Going to be UGLY for the next 6 weeks…
Coaches Coach , players play , Stop the crying , Go Out and DO YOUR JOB , if that is to much to ask go flip burgers , the FANS are Sick of the BS
Can the giants just hire him as DC next year
Can’t tackle? Or won’t tackle? The word soft is very appropriate. And if I were Bowen, I’d be embarrassed to show my face.
Sounds like we talking about a bunch kids . Who rather be friends then to win games. Miss handled or not. Daniel has been badd period, I see two or three touchdowns left on the field every week.
Banks - re: Barkley & analytics - don't you think they were concerned about him staying healthy?
This offense is from 1943. That's most of the problem. But Malik needs to sit down and shut up. He's played 9 games
The Entire Organization does not have One thing they do right, Since the CB58 days, The offensive line in the 80s we knew their Names Oates, Benson etc.Defensive we knew everyone name because they were Great at holding the line of scrimmage. They need a sense unity of pride to hold the line of scrimmage in Both side of the ball! The Organization need build a team that could recognize talent and draft talent, When Eli was getting up in years they never address get his Backup. They going to draft a 1st round QB and cannot block for run or pass! The Offense Scheme Stale and predictive because they cannot protect the QB then you become routine. Eli use to get kill.
They always looking on Defense instead of Read and reacting! Special team tackling! Coffin corner. No turnovers Really. I'm not sure this is a team 1st mindset. Giants lets Go!
I'm tired of watching the Giants lose.
Maybe bench him at halftimes and put lock in more.. not demote him all the way. Then if lock sucks devito. Shoukd have had dj on a short leash this yr
I think the reason people are clamoring to the idea of running the wild cat in that situation it’s because we don’t have the luxury to get cute we’re not a successful enough offense good enough to get cute to try stuff that is even more risky being that we’re not running that play often. What can go wrong for the Giants will go wrong for us and we have not been in rhythm long enough to take high risk chances. Yes he could’ve fumbled in a regular run play sure the wildcat came at an inopportune time is what us fans are critical of.
It’s the coach and play calling then we have a Gm that let one of the best RB go in the game for all of this really this was the plan and how long yall think the defense gone show while the offense sits idle truly embarrassed at this point and I’m a die hard representative of the giants .. I could keep digging but I won’t
Joe S failed miserably at his assessment. Some things are beyond money. I would also add that all the top players he didn't pay are performing on their new teams. Fail...absolute fail. Sorry Gettleman gets beat up for picking a running back and Jones...but he picked better quality. Jones got f'd in the head here with too many bosses trying to tweak him. His biggest issue was fumbles his rookie year. He had no problem throwing TDs or down field until people tried to fix him and his injuries happened.
Carl “MoFo” Banks #58
How can you say he won the job, but he isn't the #2 guy all year long. That doesn't make sense Carl. Your contradicting yourself.
Maybe Daboll is to blame for a lot but I don't care... no-one should point fingers at specific teammates and especially the coach..If Mara gets a new coach for Nabers and we start this again he's gonna do the same shit when things go wrong. He plays with the body language of a quitter and he has a good number of drops.... I think he has great talent but he needs to say " We suck and we have to get better" Say it and mean it. New York media will swallow you whole that's why Mara is so intent on have Manning and Jones as the QBS... FYI We do suck and we have to get better.
If he can't figure this out by now,he is horrible
FIRE THE GM....HES HORRIFIC
Yall should put yourselfs in the thumb nail cause i only click cause its yall talking
Malik nabers criticized the head coach the things he complained about had nothing to do with the front office remember DJ was benched thats a coaching decision nabers is criticizing daboll coaching decisions not joe schoen rember the gm doesn't make coaching decisions the head coach makes coaching decisions.and remember DJ asked the front office to release him malik nabers has no problem with the front office the front office /joe schoen is the one who drafted him not daboll remember joe schoen drafted the wide receiver personnel for the offensive coordinator mike kafka, daboll is there to coach not to be offensive coordinator thats kafka job.but the thing is brian daboll was stupid enough to take play calling from mike kafka when mike kafka play calling got the giants in the playoffs and helped daboll win the coach of the year award in 2022.daboll needs to leave joe schoen and kafka needs to stay period 💯
Giants are a joke. DJ will find success with a new team. Players calling out " softness" would never happen under Parcels or Coughlin. Or Belechick or Reid or any of the great Coaches.
Damn Carl you don't wanna coach? I think you'd make a great coach personally...
They could have signed Russell Wilson or Joe Flacco, etc
They chose to stick with Cutlets
That’s your QB1 now. Run with Tommy and his clown agent