What Can We Learn From Ramakrishna's God Experience Using Islam & Christianity?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 37

  • @Mehervichitra
    @Mehervichitra 6 місяців тому

    Beautifully presented

  • @summerrainzz
    @summerrainzz 3 роки тому +14

    RamaKrishna was a unique spiritual being. He already had a certain god realization, that is why he found god in all religions. God-realization is the goal, so if he was already a god realized man, then he will naturally find god everywhere. If a non realized person tried to follow those different religions will they have the same experience as Ramakrishna? I don't think so.

    • @Jay-tu9vf
      @Jay-tu9vf 3 роки тому +2

      Yes of course you can, that's the whole point of Sri Ramkrishnas teachings.
      He achieved Godrealization in the abrahamic religions faster because he was already enlightened, that is to say he already knew god. The abrahamic traditions are just different paths to the same destination, the same God he already reached, which is why he was able to achieve Godrealization through them effortlessly.
      That was the reason why he tried other religions, he wanted to "taste" God in all flavours. He wantes to experience God in all ways to experience him/her.
      And when he would practise other religions he would forget hinduism completly, removing all images and not even entering a temple.
      He would practise only what is prescribed by the religion and his teacher and through these practises, he achieved enlightenment and got the highest spiritual experiences of that religion, like getting a vision of Christ for example.
      It is a different path, which will give you a different experience of god, nevertheless the destination is the same. After persuing all of them, sri ramakrishna declared all of them true.

    • @matthewkopp2391
      @matthewkopp2391 Рік тому

      In Christianity God-Man realizations are monopolized by Christ as you can see with many comments.
      But that does not mean some Christians don’t realize the same truth. There is a long list of Christians that have. In every era.
      Carl Jung’s father was a pastor. But Jung saw god in human beings. Paul Tillich was a Christian pastor and he saw God of Ground of all Being.
      And in Gospel of John Jesus is called „the Logos“ in Greek Logos is the divine order of the universe (Heraclitus) so Jesus is everywhere and Jesus is God.
      Spinoza was Jewish, he saw God everywhere. Meister Eckardt was a Monk he saw god everywhere. Etc.
      How can Christianity move out of this monopoly is hard, but not impossible.
      Part of the good thing is that it has created a taboo on false prophets and megalomaniacs who claim they are God at least to some degree.
      But it also made a taboo on real spiritual teachers that should be heard.

  • @kookiesadu4110
    @kookiesadu4110 Рік тому

    I read this on my textbook from that i Only believe in this line

  • @chiranjitdasgupta9608
    @chiranjitdasgupta9608 3 роки тому +4

    🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️🧡😊

  • @Alvishau111
    @Alvishau111 Рік тому +1

    The greatest teacher is Christ. He died so that we would have life
    2 Corinthians 5:14-15
    For the love of Christ compels us, because we judge thus: that if One died for all, then all died; and He died for all, that those who live should live no longer for themselves, but for Him who died for them and rose again.
    John 15:13
    Greater love has no one than this, than to lay down one’s life for his friends.

    • @pressy3182
      @pressy3182 Рік тому +1

      Christians shouldn't get deceived by these kind of teachings. Just follow christ. I am the way truth and life. No one can come to the father except through me. That's why Lord Jesus said many are chosen few will get into the kingdom of God. Jesus never preached religion. He preached the kingdom of God. Don't get deceived b

  • @ravindhranj6335
    @ravindhranj6335 3 роки тому +4

    Thank you sir for the analysis & the story of Ramakrishna.
    Only Jesus can give the eternal life.
    He is the way the truth & life & no one can come to the father except through him.

    • @HinduAcademy
      @HinduAcademy  3 роки тому +14

      Ravindhran, in your comment you said only Jesus can give the eternal life, such exclusive claims are the root for friction in the name of religion. Question is, if the pure in spirit is following a Hindu tradition (or any other religious tradition), would they see God? We say yes, Think about it. How can a loving father God send Billions of People to Hell? just because they have not heard about Jesus Christ? When thinking logically many Christian church claims do not stack up to scrutiny. See what pope says : ua-cam.com/video/PVEPEZiapW4/v-deo.html
      Please see this video on "Do all religion lead to the same God- ua-cam.com/video/kQVcAyt5V2k/v-deo.html

    • @camaradael2424
      @camaradael2424 3 роки тому +2

      @@HinduAcademy with due respect, it is not the Christians who say that Jesus is the only way to God and salvation. It is Jesus himself who said that. The god of israel also said that according to the christian canonical scriptures.
      If you ask a jew, a jew will say that god of israel said in their scriptires that their abrahamic god is the only true god, all else are false gods. Same with muslims, it is not them who says that allah is the only true god, muhammad said it and their qur'an. Now if you say that all religions speak of the same god, you are invalidating the sayings of each of these gods in their own scriptures.
      The reason why there has been wars between these 3 major religions is not due to their followers' understanding of their own scriptures. It is because their own god clashes against each other according to what is written in their own scriptures which their own god claims as the voice of their own god. Remember, when Yahweh, Jesus, and Allah proclaimed exclusivity, it is them who said it, not their followers. Their followers only follow what they (Yahweh, Jesus, Allah) said as written in the scriptures.
      Unless you say these scriptures were written by men, that's the only time you can say that all religions lead to the same god.

    • @ramabapat
      @ramabapat 3 роки тому +4

      @@camaradael2424 Their exclusivity, superiority and expansionism are all written in their books. What I can say in favor of Jesus is that he meant it for the people around him at that point in time. It’s like me saying ‘I have the best parents’. And then a ton of things got added on to what Jesus actually said and long after he died and then the New Testament vetted by the clergy. The whole god-damn ‘written word’ is a joke and good luck to those that anchor their lives to books.
      BTW, no Christian has had any divine experience worth sharing in all these 2000 years. All they have is ‘Sainthood Certificates’ . It’s best we stop talking about Abrahamic dogmatic one-book ideologies as some kind of actual ‘spiritual’ paths.

    • @carlzdbz5633
      @carlzdbz5633 2 роки тому

      When a not a god realize person speaks....

    • @xyx6775
      @xyx6775 Рік тому

      It was written for Jewish ppl

  • @atomatman3104
    @atomatman3104 Рік тому

    IM NO LONGER BIASED BUT LIBERATED WITHIN NOTHINGNESSSSSSSSSS,,,,,,,DARKNESS IS FASTER THAN THE LIGHTS I AM NEOMAYAI RAM

  • @अर्जुन-य8झ
    @अर्जुन-य8झ 3 роки тому +1

    धन्यवाद् जे लखानी 🙏

  • @mukhouk
    @mukhouk 2 роки тому +1

    Can a realized person go back to be UNREALIZED/ ordinary man???!!!
    Can an active swimmer/biker unlearn swimming/biking in no time???!!!
    Ramakrishna or any other fully realized Saint can seat on toilet and concentrate His mind on something/anything He'll easily be able to reconnect and see the vision he wishes to.
    Based on that can it be a valid recommendation for ordinary seeker to seat on a toilet to meditate for self-realization???!!!
    If one wants to kill someone through poisoning you don't offer a labelled bottle of poison to that person instead you offer a glass of milk with few drops of poison in it!!!
    Similarly, if asura's (satan/devil) sole purpose is to take souls away from God it will concoct a religion much like poisoned milk. Only a spiritual giant like Ramakrishna, a swan, can extract only the good part from the glass of poisoned-milk!!!
    Dharma is one like pure glass of milk one may drink cold or hot, spiced with cocca or cinnamon (Vaishnav, Shaiva, Shakta, Boudha, Jain, Shikh and followers of all the great Guru paramparas including true followers of Christ) would offer more or less same benefits.

  • @murtazakhan9578
    @murtazakhan9578 7 днів тому

    Translate in urdu

  • @hinduekta812
    @hinduekta812 Рік тому

    Brother you have to learn first

  • @marisolvelez9076
    @marisolvelez9076 3 роки тому +2

    How do we know if he didnt have mental issues

    • @rocky821
      @rocky821 3 роки тому +4

      by reading gospels of ramakrishna and studying vivekananda. If someone asks me whether jesus had mental issues i would tell them to read bible and clarify yourself.

    • @ramabapat
      @ramabapat 3 роки тому +4

      If you saw his entire life, esp. in person, you wouldn’t say that. Calling everything a ‘mental condition’ is simplistic at best and malicious agenda at worst. First of all, you need to know there’s something deeper than body and mind that makes life life.

    • @kathapriya
      @kathapriya Рік тому +1

      When people think limited without having proper knowledge of the thing, they say things like mental disease and framed Concepts. You need to know first about Shri Ramakrishna first.

  • @ancientsecrets4569
    @ancientsecrets4569 3 роки тому +3

    Dr Lakhiani pls stop ur nonsense