'I'dentity - A documentary on Gender Identity Disorder | LGBTQ | Gazal Dhaliwal

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 вер 2024
  • I'dentity - A documentary on Gender Identity Disorder (GID): Gazal Dhaliwal and Nadia Uvkuturi share their stories on their journey of changing the identities they were born with.
    Director: Sharon Flynn
    Assistant Directors: Karishma Iyer, Riti Bahel
    Research: Meera Ravikumar, Lianne John, Siddhi Patel
    Script: Karishma Iyer, Riti Bahel, Sharon Flynn
    Camera: Siddhi Patel, Tanya Rai, Mousufa Mukadam
    Sound: Riri Bahel, Pooja Rizani
    Production: Mousufa Mukadam, Meera Ravikumar, Lianne John
    Editing: Tanya Rai, Meera Ravikumar, Pooja Rizani
    Fund Raising: Lianne John, Riti Bahel, Mousufa Mukadam, Tanya Rai
    Still Photography: Lianne John, Siddhi Patel, Tanya Rai, Pooja Rizani
    Editor: Navnita Sen
    Technical Support: Nielsh Correia, Sanjay Ingle
    Special Inputs: Ajay Norohna, Anita Parihar, Sweta Chavhan, Dhara Kanani
    A SCMSophia Production

КОМЕНТАРІ • 145

  • @spartacus9960
    @spartacus9960 10 років тому +42

    I swear i will never make fun of any trans, gay or homosexual people :(.. It made me cry,,,

    • @mizzcomptonggg9160
      @mizzcomptonggg9160 10 років тому +13

      There's no reason at all for anyone to ever make fun of, judge, or say rude things about anyone's life choices. Some people are born in the wrong body. Making fun of them is like making fun of women who were born with brown hair but color/dye their hair blonde, or anyone who wears colored contacts...it's the same thing, really; they both are modifying their appearance, they make the change to feel more confident, and they aren't bothering or hurting anyone by doing so!

    • @spartacus9960
      @spartacus9960 10 років тому +2

      I said am SORRY!

    • @changethegame911
      @changethegame911 7 років тому

      spartacus9960 gd

  • @ellieecharte7526
    @ellieecharte7526 10 років тому +49

    this touches me in so many ways. I hope people who are unfamiliar with transgender folk to watch this and see that it is a very hard thing to deal with. We don't choose to be this way, we simply are born this way just like someone with blue eyes is….so people please be sensitive to us, life is already hard but even harder for the transgender.

    • @marinjeanprovost9583
      @marinjeanprovost9583 10 років тому +8

      It is very hard. But I feel that I was dealt a bad hand but I won't give up. Even though often times I want to. But I know someday I will be a female.

    • @psychic_beth
      @psychic_beth 8 років тому +3

      God gave us trans folk unique challenges, it is our duty to show that we can overcome these challenges

    • @randycox3232
      @randycox3232 7 років тому +1

      Marin jean Provost ..... believe... you're already there! Be!!!!!!🌹

    • @randycox3232
      @randycox3232 7 років тому +2

      She is so pretty!!!!!

    • @kitswithkaren5003
      @kitswithkaren5003 2 роки тому

      Gender identity problems are a world wide problem.Even in the smallest countries there are people with gender identity problems.A very unique set of challenges for an individual to overcome.A difficult road to travel which is strewn with potholes.Hopefully i am near the end of the road with my journey.Love light peace and blessings to all transgender people.💐🐻🤗

  • @deepahomereview76
    @deepahomereview76 7 років тому +16

    You are such lucky having good parents in your life :)

  • @cathy2anderson
    @cathy2anderson 10 років тому +7

    What an excellent documentary! It is technically of very high quality, and also has a strong 'human interest.' You and your associates should be very proud of your achievement.

  • @maheshiyer3430
    @maheshiyer3430 5 років тому +11

    Discovering this film a lot late but it touched me in ways unimaginable. Great work to all involved in the making of this film!

    • @derekdolcy5839
      @derekdolcy5839 9 місяців тому +1

      😊😊😅❤❤❤❤❤😊👋💚🧡🧡🧡⭐hi

  • @abbieangel2129
    @abbieangel2129 9 років тому +41

    I did the same thing I always pray every night to. Turn into girl. But I am so afraid to tell my parents

  • @mauriciolinares7107
    @mauriciolinares7107 10 років тому +6

    Let people be the way they want to because they are not doing harm to no one.

  • @shrivastavash1788
    @shrivastavash1788 7 років тому +5

    i would like to say that many transsexuals live on that HOPE of becoming the real person with which their soul identifies. This HOPE gives them strength....THE STRENGTH which helps them to overlook all the pain that people have given to them, whether its emotional pain or physical pain.
    We live in a so called MODERN WORLD. The world which is INSENSITIVE, SCARED, and IGNORANT..... Yet i would like to say that there are many people who really are good and that is why we can still look forward for a change that will make everyone HAPPY.....GoD BLESS

  • @k3evso
    @k3evso 10 років тому +11

    Gazal looks like a girl and even as a child. It is fascinating to me.

  • @TheMacaddict09
    @TheMacaddict09 10 років тому +6

    This documentary is Lovely!!! I love the fact that this is a positive trans-narrative :) they are well spoken and articulate

  • @Karishma-K
    @Karishma-K 10 років тому +9

    An amazing and a super classy film it is. You did make me cry .. happily cry ^_^
    Good luck to the whole team and to all the humans. (Y)

  • @anandtiwari628
    @anandtiwari628 5 років тому +2

    Miss ghazal ,,u deserve the writer's post,,such a deep depiction in ur thoughts,,# respect

  • @SARANGGOSAVI
    @SARANGGOSAVI 9 років тому +2

    Amazingly good. This film has changed something in me buD. May be the attitude, concept. I can't put it in words. If I can do anything to spread happiness and bring a smile of such faces, let me know.
    Both characters have had so much strength.
    Hats off to you for such educational film, and big Applause and a Salute to both characters.
    Very good work Karishma

  • @mohitvashistha4920
    @mohitvashistha4920 8 років тому +8

    Gazal di sings so beautifully ! :)

  • @TheMacaddict09
    @TheMacaddict09 10 років тому +11

    By the way Gazal is STUNNING

  • @alicechoochin7375
    @alicechoochin7375 10 років тому +5

    Beautiful. You are an inspiration, and what a wonderful family. x x x

  • @dreamzamazon4761
    @dreamzamazon4761 6 років тому +2

    Gazal is so beautiful & blessed with wonderful parents

  • @Bill93848
    @Bill93848 8 років тому +7

    The gender identity itself is NOT a disorder and that is why the term "gender identity disorder" is no longer used. "Gender dysphoria" is much better but far too negative. I LOVE BEING TRANSGENDER. I LOVE BEING A WOMAN TRAPPED IN A MALE BODY. I AM ALMOST EMBARRASSED TO BE THIS FORTUNATE. Of course being transgender is a blessing. The reason ought to be obvious to everyone, even cisgender people. If you're trans, then you have the opportunity to transform yourself into the happy and functional human being you were destined to become. By the way, since I am a woman, I have a female sexual orientation. I am gay. I am happy and proud femme lesbian. No, I don't exactly look like Ellen Page but I am still a femme lesbian. My name is Jennifer. I am a nice forty-five year old woman who hasn't improved her own body yet. I have not yet transitioned and still look like a straight man. I am not in any particular rush. I am very happy living in the incorrect body and will be MUCH happier having the correct happy. Like any transgender person, my goal is to become cisgender. Also, I do belive very strongly in the binary understanding of gender. I once had a non-binary gender identity myself. I thought of myself incorrectly as a bigender person who inexplicably qualified as both a man and a woman. My bigenderism was just understandable gender confusion. You cannot live for forty-four years indentifying as a man and then suddenly stop, even after realizing that you were born as a girl and am now a woman. I had to go through a ten month psychological adjustment that was not the easiest experience in the world but I resolved it successfully. I am going to come out of the closet while I still look like a man and ask people to address me as "Jennifer" just to provide myself as a definition of the very simple and pleasant concept of transgenderism. I'm a nice girl. You'll like Jennifer because I already like all of you! Be happy.

  • @kimchiP0P
    @kimchiP0P 11 років тому +2

    its heart breaking to see the fortunate and the less fortunate sides of transexual women

  • @TLH11_23
    @TLH11_23 7 років тому +8

    I saw Ghazal in Satyamev jayate for the first time. I am truly inspired by you Ma'm.
    I also have attraction to men.
    but need counseliing whether i should go for sex change or not coz I am not sure about that...

    • @nivedita5488
      @nivedita5488 5 років тому

      Sunny Manghani
      Are u a regular follower of bks... actually gazal has mentioned the name in her documentary

  • @OffendingTheOffendable
    @OffendingTheOffendable 7 років тому +3

    its not a disorder its just who you are

  • @heirasojki2143
    @heirasojki2143 9 років тому +3

    You inspires me always Ghazal Didi

  • @The_Gallowglass
    @The_Gallowglass 9 років тому +2

    She sings very sweetly.

  • @srinidhisrinivas98
    @srinidhisrinivas98 9 років тому +1

    Gazal di after listening your voice i became a big fan of you and you sing very very very a long very good !

  • @a24Nu
    @a24Nu 11 років тому +1

    tynk u for make this available for us!!

  • @shekhshaharyar2144
    @shekhshaharyar2144 6 років тому +1

    Very touching.....

  • @jessicaread4880
    @jessicaread4880 9 років тому +1

    thank you for sharing. Very interesting and watchable. XJes

  • @riathakur6895
    @riathakur6895 5 років тому

    Great parents you are lucky Gazal
    Proud of you another girl as well

  • @2000Betelgeuse
    @2000Betelgeuse 10 років тому +5

    What most surprised (perhaps because of ignorance) is that the girl being documented here seems to be from a middle to upper class family, that probably made it easier, since a working class family is perhaps more prone to kick her out of the house...just an opinion

    • @rexxbailey2764
      @rexxbailey2764 9 років тому +3

      2000Betelgeuse LOLS WELL NOT A WRONG ONE... SHE WAS LUCKY CAUSE HER PARENTS HAD THE MENTAL CAPCITY TO THINK LIKE HUMANS ... WELL THEY WERE THE RARE ONES EVEN ONE THE UPPER CLASSES BY THE WAY IF U WERE TO NOTICE THE ADVICE THE ONES STAYING OPPOSITE THEIR HOUSE HAD GIVEN THEIR PARENTS WHEN THEY APPROCHED THEM WITH THE TOPIC.. THEY SUGGESTED THRASHING HER TILL SHE CAME TO HER SENSES .. SO SHE WAS PRETTY FORTUNATE IN MORE THEN ONE IN HER REGARDS ACTUALLY... NOT EVERYONE IS.

  • @rajatghosh5008
    @rajatghosh5008 10 років тому +1

    sweet, lovely to see u doing so well. cheers
    Rajat

  • @ganeshsubramanian7652
    @ganeshsubramanian7652 11 років тому

    Its really wonderful , Hat's off to your work Siddhi.. Compliments to the whole group from my side.

  • @gayindiaconfessions2108
    @gayindiaconfessions2108 10 років тому

    hey people really nice documentry movie. got a lot of knowledge from the experiences of gazal and ravi's life . definitely going to share this story on my page .
    gazal really awesome you are and salutes to your parents . they are very supportive and have changed my views on our punjabi parents . :) .

  • @anukritibahuguna9960
    @anukritibahuguna9960 10 років тому +2

    Great work guys!

    • @karishmaiyer8
      @karishmaiyer8  10 років тому +1

      Thank you, Anukriti. I didn't get a chance to chat up with you yesterday. Would you have a link to your film? I heard some great things about it, but couldn't make it for the screening.

  • @lizardgizzard108
    @lizardgizzard108 11 років тому +1

    Really inspiring!

  • @sukhjinderdhaliwal5199
    @sukhjinderdhaliwal5199 8 років тому +1

    truly inspiring !!!

  • @navjotjoyti8484
    @navjotjoyti8484 5 років тому

    Salute to your parents Gazal Mam

  • @sameerasamarasinghe1061
    @sameerasamarasinghe1061 8 років тому +2

    people should not be treated by looking at their physical characteristics.
    May be they have born with disorders.that's not their or their parent's fault.
    So I request you all guys who would read this, please never insult anybody for their appearance for their characteristics with them they are born to this world.
    those are a helpless minority.
    if you insult them sometimes they will be in hell over their
    lifetime.
    they are helpless.
    please I request you all ...

  • @apurboroychoudhary2528
    @apurboroychoudhary2528 3 роки тому

    Very inspiring content of vedio

  • @nn8322
    @nn8322 7 років тому

    amazing! so much respect for you!

  • @anishadeshmukh3596
    @anishadeshmukh3596 3 роки тому

    She so beautiful , Gazal di.

  • @balajiwaghmare9833
    @balajiwaghmare9833 5 років тому

    very best

  • @priyasunil8816
    @priyasunil8816 5 років тому +1

    Wow she is so beautiful

  • @tambourinegal69
    @tambourinegal69 11 років тому

    Thank you so much!! :)

  • @ssnader
    @ssnader 11 років тому

    Cool. the first sikh i ever heard of who is transgendered. Proves absolutely anybody anywhere from any background can turn out to be a transgender.

  • @ANameInHeavenMin
    @ANameInHeavenMin 10 років тому +1

    Good News For The Lgbt Community With Rickie Bartlett

  • @joypaul85
    @joypaul85 10 років тому +9

    now i can show this to my parents before my sex change surgery.

  • @Sheela1000
    @Sheela1000 10 років тому

    beautiful Post

  • @thelinksschoolswat6286
    @thelinksschoolswat6286 5 років тому

    Gazal I want to show that documentary to my family also

  • @kathymcbride2425
    @kathymcbride2425 Рік тому

    love from uk

  • @RajeshKumar-kh5hf
    @RajeshKumar-kh5hf 4 роки тому

    So cute gazal all the best

  • @RamanathGanpati
    @RamanathGanpati 11 років тому

    Hi Karishma,
    Good job!

  • @Riteshkumar-of2yk
    @Riteshkumar-of2yk 7 років тому

    Gazal just u r my hero

  • @vipul_kr._garg
    @vipul_kr._garg 2 роки тому

    Can we have the link or the name of gazal's documentary that she made?

  • @jagankumar9292
    @jagankumar9292 3 роки тому

    Gjb

  • @prashantmore1492
    @prashantmore1492 5 років тому

    Nice singing mam

  • @sonalichand7244
    @sonalichand7244 8 років тому

    God bless you dear😘😘

  • @sanjoghamal5401
    @sanjoghamal5401 8 років тому +1

    Gazal I love u

  • @drishtirastogi8535
    @drishtirastogi8535 5 років тому +1

    That guy at 9:32 - 9:34 must be reproaching himself now with deep regret!😂

    • @yogeshhm7165
      @yogeshhm7165 4 роки тому

      I'd regret too if I was him 😂 Gazal is stunning both inside out! 😍😍😍

    • @nehusingh826
      @nehusingh826 6 місяців тому

      ​@@yogeshhm7165😳😳😳

  • @taniya7677
    @taniya7677 5 років тому

    U guz r fighters....

  • @jagdevsinghmaan7257
    @jagdevsinghmaan7257 5 років тому

    Gazal Dhaliwal I like to you & love 💖 you 🤗🙏🏼

  • @sowmya14
    @sowmya14 11 років тому

    Amazing shit!!

  • @kathymcbride2425
    @kathymcbride2425 Рік тому

    always love india love cricket love transgender too xx

  • @khushmuskaan7531
    @khushmuskaan7531 9 років тому

    I must say you have amazing voice. gazal god bless u.

  • @ritiknegi7295
    @ritiknegi7295 Рік тому

    Main bhi is dard main hu😟 kya aap bta sakte ho apne kese gender change kiya khan kese?

  • @deemanrush25
    @deemanrush25 10 років тому +1

    Always treat people how you want be treated and do not Jude them by the look respect them the will respect you back I believe you will be happier I am a hairdresser I do not look what my client is I look the person who they well dine for all of them and director to

  • @SURENDERGURJAR-do8oe
    @SURENDERGURJAR-do8oe 7 років тому

    app wa kee hi
    kuch alag jindgi ho goods life my best friends app sab

  • @jamessenik8440
    @jamessenik8440 8 років тому

    Coolvideo

  • @ShazyJeo
    @ShazyJeo 10 років тому

    Nice topic headline - Visit Shazy Jeo for hybrids lifestyles for GIDs

  • @singhrana4039
    @singhrana4039 7 років тому

    gazal u r buetifull

  • @yashobantasahoo1727
    @yashobantasahoo1727 3 роки тому

    I also want to change myself as a girl...l also get a wrong body....plz help me gazal

  • @gursewaksingh3180
    @gursewaksingh3180 4 роки тому

    I live also patiala

  • @garryghoman758
    @garryghoman758 5 років тому

    Hlo so cute gazal ji😍😍

  • @MsSmith-cf6sh
    @MsSmith-cf6sh 9 років тому +3

    It's so sad that TG people have to live like this and be classified as have a mental disorder ,but its true because it means something is not right their trapped in the wrong body and it causes distress to them.

    • @psychic_beth
      @psychic_beth 8 років тому

      the only reason it's classed as a disorder is so insurance companies will cover trans healthcare

    • @MsSmith-cf6sh
      @MsSmith-cf6sh 8 років тому

      Bethany Bloomfield No it's because it's deviated from the norm.

  • @aarti8688
    @aarti8688 4 роки тому

    i wish ek bar gazal di se milneka moka mile

  • @HollyDollyTakahani
    @HollyDollyTakahani 10 років тому +1

    Bwautiful

  • @ginahales-owen2687
    @ginahales-owen2687 9 років тому +1

    end an argument inside the build is like 2 data sets and the machine. use a data set 5678 . now nake 2 machines of differing ratios 1 3 5 7 , 2 4 6 8 . one a boy one a girl.
    add them up 5678 5678
    1357 2468
    that's 6 9 12 15 then 7 10 13 16 one a boy one a girl. the personal data is interleaved with the machine so you may be like youre sister the personal data may be the same but youre a different person with an embedded boy or girl. put the combination on the field strength it grows in on the puter models it just appears.
    with 2 different people one a boy one a girl. so once it builds one youre that person as a boy or girl so it can be mixed on the interleave. so you are what you say you are like others. its all easy ! it cant be helped but remember that is you not what anyone thinks he can make you or condition you to be. so reassignment is normal at times ok ? x

  • @RakeshSharma-nh9kd
    @RakeshSharma-nh9kd 6 років тому

    Gazal u r so beautiful

  • @anaayaanjani327
    @anaayaanjani327 4 роки тому

    Gazal is vest

  • @kat21sd
    @kat21sd 10 років тому +4

    who's is that man to say who & who isn't a Transsexual ,there are pre op & post op transsexuals also Trans women should be identify them selves none else, I dont care what degree they may have being Transsexual or transgender is an experience of a Human is existence in my opinion

    • @tinalyons8656
      @tinalyons8656 7 років тому

      i couldn't agree more with you Kat. But saying that others in life have their opinions even if I disagree

  • @balramsah577
    @balramsah577 6 років тому +2

    Please respect transgenders.

  • @sshowgirl933
    @sshowgirl933 5 років тому

    hi i am new here be happy

  • @jagankumar9292
    @jagankumar9292 3 роки тому

    Hlo

  • @जयनेपाल-ख8ब
    @जयनेपाल-ख8ब 5 років тому

    शादी करने की गे टप जरूरत है,

  • @vampirehunt63
    @vampirehunt63 7 років тому

    Gazal if u get time please marry me please,hahaha..i m serious

  • @angelmanu1129
    @angelmanu1129 6 років тому

    patiala balo hamin bhe mil lo m also transman kya hm shadi kr skte hai

  • @2sonsofjacob819
    @2sonsofjacob819 10 років тому +1

    "Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Be not deceived: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, *nor effeminate, nor abusers of themselves with mankind*" 1 Corinthians 6:9 (KJV)
    "For this cause God gave them up unto *vile affections*: for even their women did *change the natural use* into that which is *against nature*: And likewise also *the men, leaving the natural use of the woman, burned in their lust one toward another*; men with men working that which is unseemly, and receiving in themselves that recompence of their *error* which was meet." Romans 1:26-27
    "And turning the cities of *Sodom* and Gomorrha into ashes condemned them with an overthrow, making them an ensample unto those that after should *live ungodly*." 2 Peter 2:6
    Sodomite = homosexual

    • @chrisbarabas4979
      @chrisbarabas4979 10 років тому +7

      What's your point? And also I hate to tell you this, but the bible is not perfect it was written by man, and those men put their own oppinons into their works. God did not come down and posses them and write the the thing him or her self. Also if I'm not mistaken the written accounts of all these things came 40 to a 100 years later after the fact. I do believe the bible is a great work, and it absoultely has a lot of great instruction on how to live your life, but it is not perfect nor infallable. Also Jesus said love, forgive, and accept those who are different from you and those that are your enemy. I believe in Jesus and I sure didn't see him hating on anyone. Shame on you using to the bible is such a way using it to inspire hate and discrimination. I think you missed the point or the rest of bible too specially like the all the parts of the New Testament that deal with Jesus. Find me a passage where Jesus says its ok to hate on a group of peolple for being different.

    • @2sonsofjacob819
      @2sonsofjacob819 10 років тому

      ***** Just because the Bible doesn't condone the homosexual lifestyle doesn't mean that it incites hate and discrimination. Rather, it is a loving warning to the LGBTQ community, that they may repent before Jesus comes back.

  • @johnkhan3865
    @johnkhan3865 5 років тому

    Hallo gasal ,I want to asking you are still single, I like you das way?