Ranking Fifth Harmony Members As Vocalists | Who's The Best?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,1 тис.

  • @Tarikkb
    @Tarikkb 3 роки тому +1519

    Dinah is so underrated as a vocalist , her current songs doesn’t help the situation either they don’t highlight and show off her vocals

    • @clemermoacir
      @clemermoacir 3 роки тому +53

      This. I was really excited to hear her solo music. But it... Was not great.

    • @Tarikkb
      @Tarikkb 3 роки тому +22

      @@clemermoacir ikr , she is not doing justice to her talent

    • @ganasde65
      @ganasde65 3 роки тому +48

      True. I don't understand why she edits her voice so much. She would stand out if she actually let her voice be heard in its glory

    • @Tarikkb
      @Tarikkb 3 роки тому +38

      @@ganasde65 we really need a good ballad from her maybe working with the same producers that worked with 5H or Calvin Harris

    • @yazidboufous6541
      @yazidboufous6541 3 роки тому +30

      @@clemermoacir not great to you ... I actually love the style she's going for , I think she has the best discography

  • @NkirukasWrld
    @NkirukasWrld 3 роки тому +880

    I wish Dinah released an album because she really has the whole package, she got the voice, dancing ability, the looks and the stage presence !

    • @jayd3455
      @jayd3455 3 роки тому +6

      Exactly!! 😌

    • @Tikip_
      @Tikip_ 3 роки тому +20

      Recently someone told her she sounds too soulful so I think she boutta stop making RNB music which I hope she doesn’t

    • @NkirukasWrld
      @NkirukasWrld 3 роки тому +20

      @@Tikip_ oh man I hope she doesn’t stop making RnB music! I think she could do pop and RnB

    • @kendrickwilliams707
      @kendrickwilliams707 3 роки тому +5

      Yeah but miss Jane be playing with our damn feelings

    • @nothingheard
      @nothingheard 3 роки тому +26

      @@Tikip_ It's not a recent thing. Unfortunately, she was told that when she was in fifth harmony.
      Although, I think Dinah's weakness is her lack of self-discipline, she needs to combine her talent with hard work ethic. I feel like she had avoided grown up responsibilities for so long and relies on people to tell her what to do... and with the wrong team, that's a recipe for disaster.

  • @bluemoon7785
    @bluemoon7785 3 роки тому +1168

    I feel like Dinah is the most underrated vocalist in 5H. She can go low, high, belt, do runs. She has some breathing problems, but still, the girl can do anything....

    • @RoyaltysTalent
      @RoyaltysTalent 3 роки тому +42

      Definitely!!! I feel like because when they started she was really breathy and had no breath control. But at the end of 5H she was crazy good.

    • @popmashups6568
      @popmashups6568 3 роки тому +8

      THE RANGE right?!

    • @user-ve4kt1op9t
      @user-ve4kt1op9t 3 роки тому +21

      normani was the underrated vocalist in the group. everyone who know 5h says that dinah and ally are the best vocalists. dinah low notes are terrible , but i agree with everything else.

    • @RoyaltysTalent
      @RoyaltysTalent 3 роки тому +12

      @@popmashups6568 I feel overall Dinah is the best. She’s the best performer too 🤗

    • @femme2442
      @femme2442 3 роки тому +10

      @@user-ve4kt1op9t the thing is most of the time fans and outsiders like to say ally was the best and often do not give dinah the credit she deserves just bc of the off year she had with her breath control. they still use that against her today when her technique is actually good now. that’s underrated imo. also this guy mentioned how there’s no huge technical difference in dinah’s low notes and normani’s and how dinah is actually improving in that area so idk how you think they’re terrible.

  • @marcosszimmermann
    @marcosszimmermann 3 роки тому +806

    Dinah's riffs and overall agility is insane. She has everything, tone, belts, style, a lot of RnB (the genre is doing great lately) and she is gorgeous.

  • @lissy2533
    @lissy2533 3 роки тому +477

    it hurts how underrated Dinah and Normani’s runs areeee
    ppl tended to overlook them in favour of Camilla bc she was basically the runner of the group and I never really saw anyone give the Dinah and Normani the appreciation for their agility

    • @PS-Tekken
      @PS-Tekken 3 роки тому +18

      That’s because Camilla was the desired break out star so while other girls may be better vocalist they were always going to push Camilla to do the flashiest stuff to garnish the most attention

    • @karl2624
      @karl2624 2 роки тому +25

      Tbh I think Camilla tends to overdo the fuck out of her runs. She sounds horrid at times lmao

    • @takemyhand1988
      @takemyhand1988 2 роки тому +3

      Camila is just the jaw runner, not a real runner

    • @sass_king5576
      @sass_king5576 2 роки тому +5

      @@takemyhand1988 not true, her agility is strong

    • @mimia.4810
      @mimia.4810 2 роки тому +5

      @@karl2624 She use to do that as a teenager in 5h, her solo performances are better. I think she improved vocally and even despite her being annoying at times, she still wasn't the worse.

  • @samgotong8467
    @samgotong8467 3 роки тому +778

    Here: Let's talk about Lauren. Let's appreciate her

    • @saptaparnisaharoy3118
      @saptaparnisaharoy3118 3 роки тому +22

      Yeah please! Let's talk about her

    • @naeemaless774
      @naeemaless774 3 роки тому +21

      Lento tho 🔥

    • @samgotong8467
      @samgotong8467 3 роки тому +20

      @@naeemaless774 she's trending now omg

    • @samgotong8467
      @samgotong8467 3 роки тому +4

      @@saptaparnisaharoy3118 lessgoooo99

    • @naeemaless774
      @naeemaless774 3 роки тому +15

      @@samgotong8467 I'm happy for her she's really amazing I can play her singles on repeat from Expections and Lento to More Than That and 50ft her music and her voice it's so we'll put together and she deserves so much more recognition for it

  • @marrallo
    @marrallo 3 роки тому +940

    NORMANI HAS SO MUCH POTENTIAL😩😩😩😩😩😩 if she was trained vocally...

    • @rayr6823
      @rayr6823 3 роки тому +58

      yea, i think it was only ally who was vocally trained when she was young

    • @iosashes2087
      @iosashes2087 3 роки тому +88

      @@rayr6823 Ally and Normani both grew up taking professional vocal lessons. Dinah was taught by her mother, so Camila and Lauren are the ones without much real training.

    • @iosashes2087
      @iosashes2087 3 роки тому +19

      She actually is trained...

    • @iosashes2087
      @iosashes2087 3 роки тому +19

      @@forroses.2445 Almost every signed music artist has a vocal coach. I'm talking about pre-X Factor.

    • @kordeination6385
      @kordeination6385 3 роки тому +16

      She's been taken vocal lessons, she said it in one of her previous interviews and also a while back as well.

  • @laura1less
    @laura1less 3 роки тому +283

    Dinah showed off all of her vocal agility in their last show. She was a beast.

  • @samairataylor7445
    @samairataylor7445 3 роки тому +173

    I’m literally in love with Lauren she’s so unappreciated I hate it

  • @EliSutarday
    @EliSutarday 3 роки тому +539

    all i really want to see is Normani take time to build her voice because out of everyone in the group..she has THE MOST potential

    • @KYRofficial_123
      @KYRofficial_123 3 роки тому +36

      She’s been talking time cuz last time Normani dropped something was 1 year ago

    • @Tikip_
      @Tikip_ 3 роки тому +45

      Normani has been building her voice. Her covers are amazing and even when she was on the sweetener tour her vocals and technique were great.

    • @dafihale7139
      @dafihale7139 3 роки тому +10

      @@KYRofficial_123 i read someone wrote that the girls still have 2 albums to do as a group to their company thats why they cant drop solo ep or album. Idk whether thats true or nah

    • @CurteousGemini
      @CurteousGemini 3 роки тому +11

      @@dafihale7139 I heard that too, and I’m starting to wonder if it’s true, because none of them have released a full project after nearly 4 years. 😕

    • @heopatra
      @heopatra 3 роки тому +17

      she said that she's been taking vocal lessons i think three times a week in one of her recent interviews lol

  • @jeremylin5372
    @jeremylin5372 3 роки тому +64

    Dinah Jane needs a Management / Label who can showcase her full potential. The most underrated member indeed..!

  • @Tikip_
    @Tikip_ 3 роки тому +493

    The only thing I disagreed with in this video is camila singing better in a lower register than Normani cause they used to have Normani do all the low notes and hers sound more natural

    • @tspopstar512
      @tspopstar512 3 роки тому +116

      Yeah I agree Camila lower register sounds forced and normani sounds soothing and natural

    • @giuliogallo4923
      @giuliogallo4923 3 роки тому +44

      @@tspopstar512 yeah lol Normani in lower register is a lullaby

    • @kordeination6385
      @kordeination6385 3 роки тому +51

      Exactly, when normani wasn't doing the lower register the song kind of sounded bland in my opinion. And that's exactly why we never knew Normani could do high notes because they always had her singing in a lower range.

    • @Tikip_
      @Tikip_ 3 роки тому +15

      @@kordeination6385 Exactlyyy, imagine “no way” without her background vocals and low notes

    • @jungkooksupremacy7675
      @jungkooksupremacy7675 3 роки тому +4

      @@tspopstar512 you didn't have to put down camila just to praise xenophobic normani 😐

  • @popmashups6568
    @popmashups6568 3 роки тому +183

    I personally think Dinah and Ally's voice ended up determinating 5H's final sound (previously led by Camila). I don't think Normani and Lauren ever had a real chance to fully showcase their vocal abilities since it was never "their sound". Dinah managed to complement her vocals with the groups sound better I guess

  • @Sejuani89
    @Sejuani89 3 роки тому +207

    Tone: Lauren (Im in love with her raspy smoky tone!)
    Belts: Ally (no competition)
    Agility: Dinah (though Camila got the inventive and unique runs but she lacks accuracy that Dinah possess)
    Musicality: Camila (she knows how to twist songs and make it sound different and make it her own but in a good way)
    Higher scale: Normani (though she lacks in belting, she makes it up with her clean whistle)

  • @irwinbradley9014
    @irwinbradley9014 3 роки тому +295

    Tone is subjective but Lauren all keys has the best tone

    • @dreeceowens3372
      @dreeceowens3372 3 роки тому +42

      Yeah i really like Laurens tone i like the little bit of rasp she has in her voice i hope its not relating to vocal damage

    • @allanmhanson
      @allanmhanson 3 роки тому +22

      Is the Beginnig she had such a rich voice. But you can’t deny she lost her deep and clean sound and became more flat and raspy in the prices.
      I believe it was because of smoking, it has to be that, or maybe bad technique. But she lost the power beltings she had in the beginning.
      Do you remember that “One step closer” HUGE note she did on the X Factor? In the las 5H tour she struggled to scream flat high notes ☹️

    • @blackjack2ne143
      @blackjack2ne143 3 роки тому +7

      @@allanmhanson Yess!!. Hope she take care of her beautiful voice and get a better vocal coach

    • @alexhales8569
      @alexhales8569 3 роки тому +7

      Allan M. Hanson she’s getting better though!! Check out Nada and her new high note in Lento. And she hits a high F (a note she’s never done before) in Invisible Chains!

    • @el.c.8858
      @el.c.8858 3 роки тому +3

      @@allanmhanson yeah her voice regressed but she’s trying to improve again kudos to her

  • @WonderKingE
    @WonderKingE 3 роки тому +42

    5H was one of the most vocally underrated groups ever. I mean some of their songs don't fully show their range and ability as a group that's for sure, and we definitely got a showcase of Camila's voice more than anything, but their vocals were always something to behold. Like come on. Each of them could outsing soooo many mainstream artists these days.

  • @jerryjerry1102
    @jerryjerry1102 3 роки тому +121

    I think Lauren and Normani are amazing. Lauren was very Underappreciated but yet still has one of the best voices

  • @EliSutarday
    @EliSutarday 3 роки тому +238

    literally a perfect explanation..i love Normani, Ally, Lauren, and Dinah..nothing but success

    • @Miraclemac
      @Miraclemac 3 роки тому +5

      The way youre so fast 😂

    • @EliSutarday
      @EliSutarday 3 роки тому +3

      @@Miraclemac my post notifications always on!

    • @christopheraguilar911
      @christopheraguilar911 3 роки тому +9

      What bout camila

    • @taeslilclown9801
      @taeslilclown9801 3 роки тому +22

      @@christopheraguilar911 this is a video about fifth harmony 🤣 don’t insert her anywhere she’s no longer a part of

    • @thetydeeshow
      @thetydeeshow 3 роки тому +6

      @@taeslilclown9801 they asked because this video talked about all members & the normani, Dinah, Lauren & ally are kinda not in the group no more 😂😂✌🏽

  • @gabrielgalker6665
    @gabrielgalker6665 3 роки тому +171

    They should’ve been a vocal group, they had so much potential with their voices and it notices when they covered songs with more vocal power. Anyway I love those girls

    • @gracebellemaake
      @gracebellemaake 3 роки тому +45

      they were a vocal group but it's how they were managed that rlly messed them up.

    • @gabrielgalker6665
      @gabrielgalker6665 3 роки тому +5

      @@gracebellemaake you’re right

    • @user-qe2zh9ks1h
      @user-qe2zh9ks1h 3 роки тому +2

      Wait, they weren't a vocal group? What were they then?

    • @gabrielgalker6665
      @gabrielgalker6665 3 роки тому +15

      @@user-qe2zh9ks1h hahahaha I mean I wish that they could focus more in the vocals and harmonies, that’s what I think

    • @user-qe2zh9ks1h
      @user-qe2zh9ks1h 3 роки тому +1

      @@gabrielgalker6665 Ohhh I get it now, thanks!

  • @ej44026
    @ej44026 3 роки тому +40

    Lauren’s belts have improved soooo much in these past few years!! Especially hearing her sing “Expectations”

  • @leyselva
    @leyselva 3 роки тому +51

    Ally is so freaking amazing. They never took advantage of her versatility and powerful vocals in fifth harmony.

  • @udebrl
    @udebrl 3 роки тому +132

    Fifth Harmony gained so much hate and are quite underrated as vocalists, maybe not the best with harmonies, but all of them can sing pretty well.

    • @liz2668
      @liz2668 3 роки тому +16

      ik, i kinda miss them despite not really being a fan when they were a group. They all had this unique sound and don't sound alike

    • @taeslilclown9801
      @taeslilclown9801 3 роки тому +21

      @Michelle Appiah the only reason they kept getting dragged vocally was because their competition’s little mix 😭 let’s be honest, as a group LM is vocally better by miles, but individually, only Perrie and Jade have the skills to compete with 5H, who are stronger vocalists as individuals

    • @taeslilclown9801
      @taeslilclown9801 3 роки тому +12

      @Michelle Appiah even Lauren despite being the weakest will put up a fight. Yes, Lauren, Camila and Normani are inconsistent but all 3 have the skills and stamina to vocally hold their own. Leigh Anne, Jesy and even Jade (sometimes, despite being the best technical vocalist) while in the group tend to dodge some of their parts, while we’ve already seen countless of times that the 5h girls can finish entire songs or even a whole set on their own. They weren’t the best put-together group, but individually they’re all monsters in their own rights

    • @user-ly4dv2fw7j
      @user-ly4dv2fw7j 3 роки тому +1

      @@taeslilclown9801 I disagree. In terms of technique they aren’t seeing little mix. I might of agreed somewhat years ago but The little mix today are vocally at their peak right now. They all have their strengths and weaknesses but little Mix is more consistent across the board. Ally is a very nice belter with a good upper register but has a weak lower register and isn’t agile. Normani is agile with a good lower register but she’s a weak belter. Jesy although she doesn’t belt much, is a good belter with a decent lower register, she’s agile and has good upper register. Leigh Anne has a weak lower register but she is also very agile with a decent upper register and is a very great belter, although her belts lack intensity. In terms of jade she very consistent across the board tbh. Dinah could take Leigh and jesy but That’s it tbh. You should check out some of their new stuff like their falling cover and secret love song live at the search. They don’t dodge if anything they add more than what’s in the studio versions.

    • @keepme5888
      @keepme5888 3 роки тому +3

      because most of the people only know fifth harmony from worth it and work from home thats why people thought they are not a good singer and they can harmonize tho their label is just sucks

  • @paru2520
    @paru2520 3 роки тому +47

    dinah and ally were so underrated in the group, which is very sad cause they have amazing and powerful vocals., especially dinah!

    • @annawilson1479
      @annawilson1479 3 роки тому +4

      i agree! It makes me very sad as well. They deserve more love.

  • @patricemarie8394
    @patricemarie8394 3 роки тому +46

    I think if Dinah did R&b she would dominate, it’s sad that her label is kind of kickin her to the side ALSO that clip of Lauren singing at 6:35 jeez I didn’t know she had so much power

  • @queenjassjass988
    @queenjassjass988 3 роки тому +19

    Despite all the drama, Fifth harmony really was an amazing ass girl group vocal-wise. All 5 of them brought something different and unique to the group and ppl loved to shit on them and constantly compare them to other groups.

  • @RIHFLIX
    @RIHFLIX 3 роки тому +112

    Yall need to admit dinahs tone is THEE best. Dassit

  • @thatkpopfan4010
    @thatkpopfan4010 3 роки тому +84

    Wow. I really thought Ally would win. But I’m glad. I didn’t realise Dinah was THAT GOOD! Respect!

  • @cristi4n.anderson
    @cristi4n.anderson 3 роки тому +83

    Lauren has good support in her belts and lows, i don't mind her head voice, but it's floppy

    • @cristi4n.anderson
      @cristi4n.anderson 3 роки тому +2

      Dinah's belts are close to Beyoncé's, but as you said, she pushes, if she had some of the clarity that ally has!!!!!

    • @cristi4n.anderson
      @cristi4n.anderson 3 роки тому

      12:23 that much clearness in a breathy tone tho

    • @lydob2471
      @lydob2471 3 роки тому +14

      @@cristi4n.anderson huh, dinah has good belts for sure but in no way close to beyonce

    • @samgotong8467
      @samgotong8467 3 роки тому

      Whut

  • @twentysvn
    @twentysvn 3 роки тому +26

    Dinah and Lauren have the best vocal skills. Normani has the best tone, her voice sounds like butter.

    • @Twin_Dragon_Fists
      @Twin_Dragon_Fists 2 роки тому

      Yeah her tone is so silky

    • @liamdonegan404
      @liamdonegan404 2 роки тому

      I like Lauren’s tone the most. It’s part of why she’s my fav. It’s edgy and allows her to sing songs like expectations with so much power bcuz she’s able to give the more soulful content

  • @azurendsc
    @azurendsc 3 роки тому +9

    Ally's belt in their radio presentation of -I'm in love with a monster- is *chef kiss*

  • @abdullazizkram5940
    @abdullazizkram5940 3 роки тому +19

    Dinah is a whole package star, i wish all the best for all of themthey deserve the worrrlllllddddddddd each of them has a big talent that could surprise the worrrlllddd

  • @eleeveeayees3425
    @eleeveeayees3425 2 роки тому +10

    Dinah has that potential to be a great performer, she can dance and if she trains more in dancing and keep having vocal coach and good team, she's gonna make it.

  • @neftalijusinogalarza3235
    @neftalijusinogalarza3235 3 роки тому +39

    Lauren’s tone is gorgeous!

  • @Tarikkb
    @Tarikkb 3 роки тому +68

    I feel like Camila’s tone helps her a lot she always sounds consistent and confident in her runs and upper register and she really stays there when she experiments with her voice in live performances it’s always the runs and agility cuz she’s comfortable there , she never experiments with new stuff until she’s really comfortable ( like belting), I like that about her she knows her strengths and limits , that’s why she always puts on a consistent shows vocally , she’s also surprisingly versatile in terms of styles she can sing

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth 3 роки тому +8

      She’s the least versatile voice in pop lol. She only has one style of singing and her shrill tone doesn’t allow her to work well in other genres outside of pop. The most versatile voices of the group are Dinah and Lauren

    • @rayr6823
      @rayr6823 3 роки тому +2

      @@carpediemearth and ally bcs damn girl can sing so many genres

    • @Tarikkb
      @Tarikkb 3 роки тому +5

      @@carpediemearth by versatile I mean yea she sings similarly but it fits to a lot of genres personally I listened to a lot of Camila’s leaked unreleased songs and she really tried a lot of genres and they all were good in my opinion, it looks like she has done , retro pop, latin, melodic ballad, regular pop, hip hop , slow soulful, and they all sounded solid

    • @Tarikkb
      @Tarikkb 3 роки тому +3

      @@carpediemearth I can’t wait to hear Lauren’s solo work it feels like she’s waiting for her time cuz their 5H contracts are still effective, and I think it’ll be off early this year , and Dinah is so talented I hope she makes songs that showcase her vocals and range

    • @Tarikkb
      @Tarikkb 3 роки тому +2

      @@rayr6823 ally’s vocals are SO amazing she’s incredible but I really want to see some different stuff from her , her songs still don’t sound like “ally “ to me , u know what I mean?

  • @zaybrandon5522
    @zaybrandon5522 3 роки тому +27

    This video was very fair and really points out how all the girls have strengths and weaknesses but all talented and deserve respect vocally and i agree

  • @jeremiasb_vv
    @jeremiasb_vv 3 роки тому +27

    Dinah's voice is one of the best voices I've ever heard in my life, it's surreal, perfect

  • @petlanticlee3610
    @petlanticlee3610 3 роки тому +34

    Lauren is my fav. But I have to admit that I enjoy camilla's voice as well. Their tone and voice are so distinctive that you can immediately recognize them in the harmony

  • @GarageStudio7
    @GarageStudio7 3 роки тому +89

    Before watching, I'm guessing *Dinah or Ally* 👑
    I know preference of tone is subjective but gOsH, Lauren has such a beautiful natural sound 😍
    *Fifth Harmony* really had the potential to be a major force to be reckoned with in the music industry (even now).
    Already love this video and I haven't even watched it yet! I'm so happy that you took on this topic in this manner ⭐

  • @RACHEL_CHARMSS
    @RACHEL_CHARMSS 3 роки тому +74

    Normani is a singer and a dancer and she is amazing

    • @kordeination6385
      @kordeination6385 3 роки тому +7

      Exactly can't wait for her to drop the album to prove the people that said she couldn't sing wrong.

  • @princessejulie6107
    @princessejulie6107 3 роки тому +16

    My favorites are Dinah and Camilla. I love Camilla's voice better in her solo stuff than in Fifth Harmony's songs. I love her upper range so much i songs such as "Living Proof" and "Bad Kind of Butterflies", it's gorgeous!

  • @ayeshas5823
    @ayeshas5823 3 роки тому +29

    For me; Normani is the BEST!!!! I LOVE her 😍 voice-vocals, belted notes, riffs/runs and: hv/falsetto/whistle.....She's my FAVOURITE member of FH!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️l LOVE ❤️ her soft voice....it's so beautiful, soothing, relaxing and #HEAVENLY...to hear...ILYSM NORMANI!!!❤️❤️❤️
    I loved the way you explained every single thing in this video....it made it a lot easier for me to understand....so thank you.❤️

  • @kpoprubix9812
    @kpoprubix9812 3 роки тому +12

    Lonely night is Dinah's song. She shines the most in that song. It's one of my favorite

  • @zarulorca1240
    @zarulorca1240 3 роки тому +12

    This is the only girl group with the most distinct voices on each members..

    • @cxh9219
      @cxh9219 3 роки тому +9

      I find it very interesting that girls are so different from each other. voice, a little of the ancestry of each one (one tongan, the other cuban, mexican, african and so on), personality, etc.
      I don't know if I wrote it completely right. translator sucks

    • @vocalising4218
      @vocalising4218 11 місяців тому

      ​@@cxh9219you have written this perfectly. Its interesting that you mentioned ancestry as that definitely influences a voice.

  • @nonombre6099
    @nonombre6099 3 роки тому +11

    Lauren's tone is so perfect, she just lacks consistency in preparing her voice although she has recently improved her skills I feel like she can give more vocals in birds of prey and acoustic sessions are so good. I'm proud

  • @funsmartcontent4928
    @funsmartcontent4928 2 роки тому +5

    Giving Fifth Harmony Member Positions:
    Ally: Main Vocalist, Leader
    Lauren: Lead Vocalist, Center
    Normani: Main Dancer, Vocalist
    Camila: Face of the Group, Lead Vocalist
    Dinah: Main Vocalist, Lead Dancer
    All: Visual

    • @myjapsy2826
      @myjapsy2826 Рік тому

      Ally: Main Vocalist, Leader, Rapper
      Lauren: Vocalist, Visual, Lead Dancer
      Normani: Main Dancer, Vocalist, Main Rapper, Center
      Camila: Lead Vocalist, Face of The Group, Rapper
      Dinah Jane: Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Youngest (Maknae)

  • @5hlmupdaptes947
    @5hlmupdaptes947 3 роки тому +22

    I NEVER noticed Ally is not used to do runs/riffs omg

    • @rayr6823
      @rayr6823 3 роки тому +7

      she always did it but she kept it simple

    • @deepanshu1841
      @deepanshu1841 3 роки тому +1

      same omg

  • @liz2668
    @liz2668 3 роки тому +35

    This is based on my preference and not on technique:
    Lows: Lauren
    Belts: Ally
    Runs & Agility: Camila
    Tone: Lauren
    My favourite: Lauren

    • @o.7079
      @o.7079 3 роки тому

      highs?

    • @krszns
      @krszns 3 роки тому +2

      Runs: ally

    • @badbada3003
      @badbada3003 3 роки тому +1

      Runs and agility is dinah lol

    • @nonombre6099
      @nonombre6099 3 роки тому +1

      same but highs is for Ally

  • @joshua2764
    @joshua2764 3 роки тому +23

    Imo only:
    Belting: Ally
    Falsetto: Camilla
    Whistling/running/riffing:Normani
    Lows: Def Lauren
    HV/Agility/tone: Dinah

    • @badbada3003
      @badbada3003 3 роки тому

      Agility Dinah lol

    • @badbada3003
      @badbada3003 3 роки тому

      @@joshua2764 opinion Huh? Lol

    • @badbada3003
      @badbada3003 3 роки тому

      @@joshua2764 iS that you'r preferences or basing on vocal technique?

    • @joshua2764
      @joshua2764 3 роки тому

      @@badbada3003 hold up now that I think about it...
      Re read my comment again

    • @badbada3003
      @badbada3003 3 роки тому

      @@joshua2764 lol your opinion is basing on vocal technique or what

  • @drlle_3349
    @drlle_3349 3 роки тому +16

    Lauren’s tone

  • @wiamzebian7906
    @wiamzebian7906 3 роки тому +38

    It felt like camila had the good and proportional amount of everything

    • @aintnootherfan
      @aintnootherfan  3 роки тому +17

      I agree actually

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth 3 роки тому +5

      Camila only has technical abiliy for runs. She doesn’t have a good tone, or range, or soul

    • @francoboo3857
      @francoboo3857 3 роки тому +12

      @@carpediemearth her tone is great and her range as well. she‘s incredible

    • @baby2911985
      @baby2911985 3 роки тому +12

      @@carpediemearth Camila without soul? Are you kidding, a lot of people love her live performance because she lives and conect with every song, even when it doesnt her own song.

  • @japs1812
    @japs1812 3 роки тому +24

    Dinah has the best vocals!!! She is a vocal beast.
    Lauren is my girl, love her music.

  • @nonombre6099
    @nonombre6099 3 роки тому +8

    lauren will always be my favorite in 5H and solo but dinah always has me here for her.

  • @natalyalindo982
    @natalyalindo982 3 роки тому +8

    Laurens lower register is so good, it was like natural for her I can’t tell if she’s a mezzo soprano or a contralto but either way she kills it

  • @johnfundal6603
    @johnfundal6603 3 роки тому +76

    Do you guys notice how Camila is capable of doing her runs in different registers such as her lows, mid belts, and falsetto? Where as Dinah mostly does her runs in falsetto because she is most comfortable in falsetto.

    • @michaelmorris8302
      @michaelmorris8302 3 роки тому +7

      She would be impressive if she was 13 not as a grown woman

    • @amanda-almeida
      @amanda-almeida 3 роки тому

      @@michaelmorris8302 chill out

    • @michaelmorris8302
      @michaelmorris8302 3 роки тому

      @@amanda-almeida k

    • @thebinlgbtisbabadook7832
      @thebinlgbtisbabadook7832 3 роки тому +19

      In a post-5H interview, Dinah actually revealed that whenever she gives her best during studio recordings and rehearsals, the producers told her to "stop being too soulful", basically, they were telling her to hold back. The producers didn't want her to shine. Also, in their unreleased song Goodbye, Dinah shine like the frickin sun 😂 but the track ended up on the cutting floor because she outshone Camzi in that song. It wasn't Camzi's fault, it was the management. Camzi is just a victim just as the 4 girls. Damn. I hate music entertainment politics.

    • @badbada3003
      @badbada3003 3 роки тому +7

      Well dinah has done very complex runs in her mix, lows, and upper register. Dinah is more controlled, precise

  • @Ariii78
    @Ariii78 3 роки тому +27

    Dinah and Normani Was underrated vocally

  • @Twin_Dragon_Fists
    @Twin_Dragon_Fists 2 роки тому +19

    Normani has the prettiest voice of the group in terms of tone. Her voice is so silky and smooth and that's crazy to me...love her

  • @ExoticlyFoxy
    @ExoticlyFoxy 3 роки тому +36

    Imo if I could have any of these girls voices, I'd choose Dinah or Ally for sure. In all honesty all the girls can sing. I miss 5H sooo much 😕

  • @nothingheard
    @nothingheard 3 роки тому +244

    Ally has so much versatility too. She is the best rapper and belter of the group and her studio runs stand out a lot.
    Ask yourself why she always had a solo in their songs even though she wasn't the label's favorite.
    My overall favorite is Lauren.

    • @rhodesgrec1648
      @rhodesgrec1648 3 роки тому +9

      Lauren is my favorite too

    • @vocalising4218
      @vocalising4218 3 роки тому +34

      That's true, but in an interview Ally said she had to fight to get solos. I don't think the producers would have done her justice if she hadn't.

    • @terrispencer4913
      @terrispencer4913 3 роки тому +9

      @@jamieslauren literally in terms of rap, it goes Normani, Ally, Dinah Lauren, Camz. The last three are subjective

    • @maybe4003
      @maybe4003 3 роки тому +6

      Camila hated on Ally

    • @tjsquibbofficial
      @tjsquibbofficial 2 роки тому +10

      @@terrispencer4913 Eh, no. It would go in terms of rap to me:
      1. Normani
      2. Ally
      3. Camila
      4. Dinah
      5. Lauren
      We've only heard the top 3 rap (Normani in BOSS and Top Down, Ally in Angel and Camila in Top Down along with a freestyle).

  • @sophyaalamudun301
    @sophyaalamudun301 3 роки тому +7

    This is a really well put together video!! And I agree with you, Dinah is my favorite too :)

  • @varunravi27
    @varunravi27 2 роки тому +8

    These are my thoughts:
    Lower register: Lauren > Normani = Camila > Dinah > Ally (Ally's lows are very, very weak compared to the rest of 5H... she literally dodges G#3s, a note which no one would dodge)
    Belts: Ally > Dinah > Lauren = Camila (both are consistent up to A4/Bb4... and here I was, thinking that Camila consistently supports C5s) > Normani (her upper belts are actually pretty good but her mid-belts... not so much)
    Vocal agilty: Dinah > Normani > Camila (she has the same problem as Demi Lovato... both move their jaws excessively when doing complex riffs) = Lauren > Ally
    Upper register: Dinah > Camila (her falsetto is arguably her best register, but that's just my opinion because technicality isn't involved when it comes to falsetto) = Ally (her head voice is technically one of the best in the industry right now, along with Perrie Edwards, Dove Cameron, Mariah Carey, Patti LaBelle and SoHyang) > Normani (her falsetto isn't great but her amazing whistles compensate for it) > Lauren (Lauren's head voice is beautiful but she could develop that register a bit more)
    My favourite member's Lauren but Dinah's AMAZING and SO UNDERRATED 💙
    But for different aspects, I have different favourites:
    Vocally: Dinah
    Tone: Lauren
    Emotion: Lauren
    Personality: Camila
    Ranking them as vocalists (overall), it would definitely go like this:
    1. Ally
    2. Dinah
    3. Lauren
    4. Camila
    5. Normani

  • @jpam14988
    @jpam14988 3 роки тому +5

    Lower register
    5- Ally
    4- Dinah
    3- Camilla
    2- Normani
    1- Lauren
    Belting
    5- Normani
    4- Lauren (younger Lauren would be number)
    3- Camilla
    2- Dinah
    1- Ally
    Riffs and runs
    5- Ally
    4- Lauren
    3- Normani
    2- Camilla
    1- Dinah by faaaaaar
    Upper range/falsetto/head voice
    5- Lauren
    4- Camila
    3- Ally
    2- Normani
    1- Dinah
    Overall (my opinion)
    5- Lauren
    4- Camila
    3- Normani
    2- Ally
    1- Dinah
    But Normani is still my fav, followed by Dinah.

  • @damsapollo
    @damsapollo 3 роки тому +40

    Dinah's tone is like Beyoncé's (not everytime tho). And wow I'm so surprised with her agility and it's even more beautiful because she has great musicality (agility+musicality should always coincide, IMO).

  • @popvocalstv
    @popvocalstv 3 роки тому +34

    Just a little bit of what I think about the video (great job btw)
    I agree with you on the low notes, I think If we were going to count only the 5h times, Dinah would probably be at last, since she had some problems with A3 (lol), but she improved so much, now she can hit audibles F#3's consistently (which is decent for a soprano)
    Belting: yeah for sure Normani is the last, I think that if she hadn’t had so many problems with confidence she would have been much better at it, THANK YOU for saying Lauren improved on her belts after 5h, I always say that and people don't believe me, I mean we just have to look at the fact that she does E5's consistently now, when some years ago she was having problems with some C#5's
    Agility: Well the fact that on the PSA Tour Ally dodged runs (that weren't that difficult) says a lot about her ability on that area
    My favorite is Lauren!

    • @GarageStudio7
      @GarageStudio7 3 роки тому +5

      You added great points 😍
      You've really been giving some great videos on your channel (admirable vids about the pop girlies & lads)!

    • @popvocalstv
      @popvocalstv 3 роки тому

      @@GarageStudio7 thank you!!!

    • @GarageStudio7
      @GarageStudio7 3 роки тому

      @@popvocalstv Truly my pleasure 😊

    • @iosashes2087
      @iosashes2087 3 роки тому

      Dinah's not last on low notes. Her low note is a D3 in Make You Mad and she's never really struggled with that. She hits a C#3 in her Officially Missing You cover without much issue as well.

    • @popvocalstv
      @popvocalstv 3 роки тому +1

      I don't think you read my comment, I said that at the 5h time, Dinah would be the last, also most of her D3's on Make You Mad are inaudible

  • @annoyedjay
    @annoyedjay 3 роки тому +24

    I’m late to the party but Normani is soooooooo underrated as a vocalist 😭 she may not be a powerhouse singer but she definitely has more strengths than most people think! Imma need y’all to appreciate her for more than her dance abilities and whistle notes 🙄

  • @dont6771
    @dont6771 2 роки тому +5

    Idk who is the best but I really like Lauren's voice the most. Everytime I hear it, I just feel chills.

  • @krszns
    @krszns 3 роки тому +15

    It’s definitely dinally powerhouse with the best vocals

  • @wthjavi
    @wthjavi 3 роки тому +31

    cmon dinah and ally practically INVENTED belting .

    • @choloyolo8522
      @choloyolo8522 3 роки тому +1

      *X Factor Lauren has left the chat*

    • @wthjavi
      @wthjavi 3 роки тому +3

      @@choloyolo8522 *miss lauren never been in the chat to begin with*

  • @vocalsbycyrus
    @vocalsbycyrus 3 роки тому +39

    Lows: Lauren
    Belts: Dinah (technically it’s Ally but I prefer Dinah’s voice in the belts)
    Runs: Normani
    Tone: Lauren
    Stage Presence: Normani

    • @xylypotatohead3947
      @xylypotatohead3947 3 роки тому

      Why was Camilla pushed so much then lol?

    • @user-ve4kt1op9t
      @user-ve4kt1op9t 3 роки тому +2

      @@xylypotatohead3947 her personality and voice is marketable.

    • @xylypotatohead3947
      @xylypotatohead3947 3 роки тому +6

      @@user-ve4kt1op9t ok that makes sense.
      Tbh I never understood the appeal of her voice but that's because I prefer less nasal and deeper voices.

    • @user-ve4kt1op9t
      @user-ve4kt1op9t 3 роки тому +6

      @@xylypotatohead3947 her tone, runs & nasally sound makes me cringe. but her voice was the most unique i’m not gonna lie.

    • @redeemedstone
      @redeemedstone 2 роки тому

      @@xylypotatohead3947 probably longevity in the industry she was the babyface of 5H. I'm still gutted for the way they treared the other girls just as they were taking off. But proud of how each girl is in her own lane, at her own pace learning to stand on her own. They have all released great music, not many girl groups can say that after splitting up.

  • @shan08swabs31
    @shan08swabs31 3 роки тому +5

    I wish normani would have the confidence like Camila. They are all very talented but the others never got a chance to shine because Camila was put in the forefront.

  • @iosashes2087
    @iosashes2087 3 роки тому +43

    I agree with this. Dinah without a doubt is the best/most well rounded vocalist and member overall (since she's No.1 at singing and No.2 at dancing and stage presence). She's one of the most amazing singers of this new crop of young artists. It's really unfortunate she ended up with a label and team that won't do her talent justice. And if that's not bad enough she's somehow the punching bag of the 5H fandom.
    I gotta admit that putting Normani above Camila at rifts and runs surprised me but when you explained it, it made complete sense. I think the only thing I'd argue is that Normani is better at low notes than Camila. I'd recommend listening to Normani singing Happy Birthday (solo), her Drake cover, and Can You See at the Apollo theater. For everyone who says she can't support much, from what I've heard, it seems she supports down to an F3 which is the lowest in the group.
    Also Dinah is MUCH better at low notes than she was in the group (listen to her Officially Missing You cover) and I appreciate how you showed Lauren's improvement in her voice since the group broke up. Thanks for this!

  • @anelfernandez406
    @anelfernandez406 3 роки тому +7

    Dinah is my favorite, because of her agility and powerful and creative vocals!🙏❤🔥

  • @Icandoit36058
    @Icandoit36058 2 роки тому +3

    I think they all have fascinating voices that’s what makes the group so special. They also started out very young and they’ll grow and get better in their singing career.. I wish them success on their solo journeys.

  • @DDQ96
    @DDQ96 3 роки тому +48

    Dinah has always been the Best vocalist . Still is..

  • @deyvidluiz3048
    @deyvidluiz3048 3 роки тому +4

    Your run at the end, I'm in love

  • @ellaronci2703
    @ellaronci2703 3 роки тому +5

    these girls are all so talented

  • @notyourdaddy2148
    @notyourdaddy2148 3 роки тому +7

    my favourite was always lauren cause of her tone, but i also loved dinah’s tone and overall voice. tbh i only liked 5h cause of them lol really wish you would have done a thorough analysis of all of their upper registers, that’s kinda the part i was really looking forward to 😭😭 i really wanted you to go over notmani and ally’s easy in their hv, falsetto, and whistle, as well as lauren’s loss of her falsetto, dinah’s agility in hers, and camila’s recent use of her hv. nevertheless, a fantastic video like always quing! keep up the good content :)

  • @davianstewart2539
    @davianstewart2539 3 роки тому +31

    Sorry but normani lower register is better than camila let’s be honest

    • @taeslilclown9801
      @taeslilclown9801 3 роки тому +6

      This! like Lauren and Normani literally carried all the harmonies with their lower registers and are by far the strongest and most comfortable in their lower ranges

    • @benjaminsotocornejo3653
      @benjaminsotocornejo3653 3 роки тому

      Not when she doesn’t support the low notes showcase here

    • @taeslilclown9801
      @taeslilclown9801 3 роки тому +5

      @@benjaminsotocornejo3653 Normani’s actually more consistent with her lower register than Camila and supports down to g3. the only problem is she lacks resonance

    • @jessicacurbeam2990
      @jessicacurbeam2990 3 роки тому +1

      Camilla can’t sing tbh she’s very pitchy and squeaky I can’t listen to her back to back

    • @lydob2471
      @lydob2471 3 роки тому

      @@jessicacurbeam2990 I'm going to start off by saying that I'm not a camilla fan and I dont really like her voice but saying she cant sing is just wrong.

  • @Tikip_
    @Tikip_ 3 роки тому +49

    Dinah was definitely the best singer in the group but Normani’s voice/sound is my fav

  • @aanandi726
    @aanandi726 3 роки тому +5

    Lauren has amazing voice.......her low notes and when she sings with her head voice ...... In 5h she wasn't given the chance to sing high notes well except for 1st album. Now she's practising and is really great. I'm proud

  • @janstormborn9699
    @janstormborn9699 3 роки тому +9

    Dinah jane hansen will forever be the queen.

  • @younessbensaid6541
    @younessbensaid6541 3 роки тому +15

    The best tone for me is Normani's one ! Its so soothing Camila > Ally > Normani > Lauren
    Great vid anyway ! They're all good vocalists, NO ONE'S BAD OR MEDIOCRE

    • @badbada3003
      @badbada3003 3 роки тому +3

      Camila is better than ally???? Howw

    • @nonombre6099
      @nonombre6099 3 роки тому +2

      camila best than Ally? lauren last? . u r a joke

  • @jayd3455
    @jayd3455 3 роки тому +21

    Dinah’s agility/runs rlly are in a league of their own! I can definitely understand why people would have preference for the other girl’s voices but I just think Dinah is a crazy vocalist fr

  • @henryha2285
    @henryha2285 3 роки тому +24

    Camila = most unique tone
    Lauren = lovely smokiness to her voice
    Dinah = best head voice
    Ally = best at high notes
    Normani = best dancer

    • @grappling-wd7ic
      @grappling-wd7ic 3 роки тому +18

      Normani isn't just a dancer...

    • @cynthiawilliams3692
      @cynthiawilliams3692 3 роки тому +4

      The shadee towards normani 😲☠ all are talented and can sing. No need to do that

  • @sahm6192
    @sahm6192 3 роки тому +6

    I always felt it was.
    Dinah
    Ally
    Camila and Normani
    Lauren.
    In that order. I based it off what they can do as in low, high, mids, belts, falsettos, whistle. Then who sounded better in which area and proficiency. But Normani is my favorite.

  • @dave7315
    @dave7315 2 роки тому +4

    Normani and Ally’s Whistle Notes are sick..

  • @chikoritaleaf
    @chikoritaleaf 3 роки тому +30

    i feel like whatever they went thru in 5h completely ruined dinah’s confidence in singing. i watched her on the terrell show and she literally looked like she was scared to sing even tho that was the whole purpose of being on the show... hope she regains it back bc she’s actually a good singer

    • @aintnootherfan
      @aintnootherfan  3 роки тому +11

      Yeah, she seemed so insecure and uncertain there!

    • @jesusgarcia5197
      @jesusgarcia5197 3 роки тому +4

      Their label and management is forever trash for doing what they did to the girls.

    • @idgafboutuu5882
      @idgafboutuu5882 3 роки тому +4

      @Michelle Appiah I saw that. Its such a shame that they wasted her talent and made her feel less about herself. Like gurlie did not sing on 2 singles and barely sang on tracks

    • @chikoritaleaf
      @chikoritaleaf 3 роки тому +4

      @@idgafboutuu5882 such a waste honestly. out of all the girls, i personally feel like she had the most potential to mature into an amazing vocalist but now it seems like she’s been weighed down by everything

  • @pierremarquez6369
    @pierremarquez6369 3 роки тому +14

    Technically Dinah is the best singer in the group in terms of range.

  • @imuzz
    @imuzz 3 роки тому +4

    Someone show this to dinah

  • @queenjassjass988
    @queenjassjass988 3 роки тому +4

    And it upsets me how underrated Dinah is when she literally is the total package. She has an amazing voice, great stage presence, and is such a sweet person. I hate how so many stans constantly pick on her and tear her down on twitter for literally anything she does/says. She wasn’t the most mature person in the past and she still has some maturing to do, but my gosh let the girl breathe for once 🤦🏾‍♀️

  • @grandeflamesbutera3949
    @grandeflamesbutera3949 3 роки тому +4

    I don’t really know this group so well to make a comment on their voices but this was an amazing video!!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @addisonjohansson3428
    @addisonjohansson3428 3 роки тому +3

    Besides the point of the vocal parts, just having Lauren’s green eyes stare at me when he talks gives me chills. Especially that specific picture that was chosen. 😅

  • @thatkpopfan4010
    @thatkpopfan4010 3 роки тому +100

    If Ally Brooke isn't #1 I swear I'm gonna...

    • @GarageStudio7
      @GarageStudio7 3 роки тому +19

      🤭

    • @leyselva
      @leyselva 3 роки тому +6

      She deserves to be number 1. She is too perfect.

    • @choloyolo8522
      @choloyolo8522 3 роки тому +2

      Dinah is better overall in my opinion...

  • @annawilson1479
    @annawilson1479 3 роки тому +2

    YESSSS DINAHHHH!!!!!! Shes my fave !! But everyone in fifth harmony is amazing!

  • @sass_king5576
    @sass_king5576 3 роки тому +37

    I’d say camila is a better at runs and agility overall than Normani but thats my opinion, other than that great video !!

    • @liz2668
      @liz2668 3 роки тому +5

      Yeah, I like her runs better too.

    • @izonexbae
      @izonexbae 3 роки тому +12

      I think Camila has some better moments but her jaw tension can become overbearing with her lows and she at times get very sloppy whereas Normani doesn’t attempt them too much but when she does they are a nice attempt in her belts

    • @Yasimsings6071
      @Yasimsings6071 3 роки тому +1

      I agree 100%.

  • @idkhbu1845
    @idkhbu1845 3 роки тому +2

    I love this video!! u can tell that he is a fan by the random clips that he presented. It's safe to say that overall 5H has great singers. My girls killed it as a group and still killing it as solo artists 😌💖

  • @gracebellemaake
    @gracebellemaake 3 роки тому +37

    it's such a disaster how mismanaged the group was. the talented vocals in this group were devastatingly put to waste. i'll always be a harmonizer tho

    • @reissy09
      @reissy09 3 роки тому

      I agree but they also didn’t get on at all lol it’s always gonna be a lottery with manufactured groups. You can get lucky with little mix where he’s easy to manages coz they all click and get on ... or like fifth harmony where they just don’t like each other. Such a shame when their vocals are just incredible. I remember seeing them live thought and it was so evident they were there to just do a job

    • @idgafboutuu5882
      @idgafboutuu5882 3 роки тому +7

      @@reissy09 umm as a harmonizer that is not true. They were friends all 5 of them up until C left but with friendship ot4 was superior. Up to this day they still are friends especially Dinah and Lauren. They went to bali and often hangs out before rona

    • @reissy09
      @reissy09 3 роки тому

      @Michelle Appiah I don't think you've seen any interviews recently where they literally say they haven't spoken to each other but wish each other well....thats not friendship....also a harmoniser. love group. but delusion if you think they all besties.

    • @summernight2752
      @summernight2752 3 роки тому +1

      @@reissy09 I agreed that there are possibility of them aren't besties off-cam, they're just meant to be co-workers afterall, but let me say just because they're not really close friend doesn't mean they dislike each other. I could see there is possibility they still dislike Camila or just choose to silent but Ot4 evidently still supporting each other

    • @girlboss3426
      @girlboss3426 3 роки тому +1

      @@reissy09 the ot4 are friends, Lauren and ally talking with Normani and stuff,but dont expect them to be friends with Camila

  • @samonelly4813
    @samonelly4813 3 роки тому +3

    “Being a pop star is more than just singing” so true

  • @dulceclarisse9656
    @dulceclarisse9656 3 роки тому +6

    Even my favorite is Lauren, I always said that Dinah is amazing and also is the best of 5H, she's such a crazy vocalist

  • @itzkamron
    @itzkamron 3 роки тому +6

    Im a ot5 stan but somethin about when lauren pops up in the music videos makes me scream

  • @josuealopez3167
    @josuealopez3167 3 роки тому +7

    Camila deserves the spotlight and Normani she deserves the spotlight too the fame but ppl be sleeping on her like c'mon

    • @krszns
      @krszns 3 роки тому

      Naw normani is not slept on she just still owes the label an album from fifth harmony that’s why she’s not dropping music.

    • @josuealopez3167
      @josuealopez3167 3 роки тому

      @@krszns oh well can't wait when she drop music