The old man seems like the nicest person. Suing someone for your lack of responsibility is foolish. However, he admits to being a bad owner, atleast that's something.
He sued because he was not given the chance to find his dog. Well, he was definitely spared from the the horrible experience of finding his dog dead of dehydration in the park.
That's true. Though I'd feel the same as them. They did a nice thing taking her to the vet but, didn't give anyone the opportunity to find her and make the decision to save her life instead of just killing her and then claiming they found her laying on the road and thrown out of a vehicle.
Plaintiff did not take the dog to the vet often. So, the rescue vet checked the dog, and something was seriously wrong with it to put it down. They do not put down healthy dogs.
Owners expected the vet, who is working at rescue (probably with little funds), to invest thousands or tens of thousands of dollars in life-saving care, to save a dog that had no known owner and may never retrieve the dog. And even if they saved the dog and owner found them, would likely refuse to compensate the rescue for the care provided. Utter morons.
So disgusting. He killed his own dog and he doesn't even care, he laughs about it. And she had recently had puppies, so they are backyard breeders. Despicable people. Horrible
From what was described in the vets report, it unfortunately was that close to death and it had no chop or tags so the owner was not traceable - its his own fault his dog had to be put down 😪
if the owner HADN'T left the back open, the English bulldog would have had heatstroke in the truck. A LOT of English bulldogs have breathing problems and can't deal with heat.
One of my husbands daughters came home and said I'm getting a pug. He said no your not. He explained to her with her schedule between working,school and sports (golf and softball) she would not have the time to take care of the dog and he would not do it. She didn't get the dog.
There’s a reason the dog ran away and a reason the Vet put her down. 35 pounds looks to be 5 pounds underweight for that breed according to the internet- she could’ve been sick or injured beyond repair.
I live in a desert type area and a frenchie in the city got out of his yard - he passed from heat exhaustion very quickly. Brachycephalic dogs can go downhill fast in heat, poor kid 😔🖤
They were stupid enough to think she could be away from them for a few hours, when really they need to stay home for quite some time not just to look after the pups but to recover themselves! Hopefully they don't own more dogs after this disaster
“Didn’t give me time to find my dog” sir i’m not sure u really tried🤷🏽♀️he said they got to the park at 8:30 am….he took the ONE dog that was still in the truck home at 10:30 am…then came back to the park and partied for 6 more hours….ummm that means u spent less than 2 hrs “looking” and then went on about ur day so why are we here?
If the poor dog was too ill from temperature and was suffuring and problably would die anyway why wait longer? So the poor animal could suffer more until those idiots come find her? They mad not about the dog but about the facebook post that made them look as bad as they were.
Owner never take accountability this would t have happened if they were paying attention if it was a child missing they be in jail or maybe they would blame someone else than themselves
Very reasonable people here than on Facebook. They showed a clip of this case and people were saying Judge Judy got it wrong as well as being a bully against the plaintiff. Did we just watch the same case? Some lady defending him asking if no one had ever made a mistake. I can’t with people.
JJ has zero patience with this plaintiff because she has a soft spot for dogs. This couple left English Bulldogs in a hot vehicle in 90 degree heat for hours.....and that breed overheats faster than other breeds because they can't pant properly to cool themselves off, because their airway is squashed for appearance. That alone makes them awful owners. Then one dog goes missing so the husband (supposedly) looks for a while, then goes back to partying? For hours? That poor little pup.
So what, were they intending to keep the dogs with them outside in 90° heat all day?? Why even bring them? Why even have an outdoor event that lasts from 10am to 4pm in that kind of heat anyway?? I don't feel bad for them in the slightest.
Too bad she can't tell animal breeders to get a job a real job...he made 5k for 2 puppies and poor momma dog just not fair how animals are forced to breed for money. Glad momma was put down she is better off .....how horrible she would of had a horrible death if not rescued.
I wish Judge Judy would explain the law better because she obviously chose a bias before this case started and it seems irrelevant without case law behind it. It seems like the old man is at fault and purposefully took the dog without looking for the owner. Law in our state requires you look for the owner in a case like this.
But if what old man says is true, he didn't take the dog, he found the dog lying by the highway. He took the dog to a vet which was the responsible thing to do. I am assuming dog had no chip hence they could not contact the owner.
Pneumonia is NOT heat stroke. So the dog was already in signficant distress without the introduction of the 90+F temperatures according to that. And old man's wife doesn't have a clue. YOU DON'T HAVE SURGERY FOR PNEUMONIA.
Yeah, I'm not with the majority of you and there are a lot of unknown things.. such as the age of the pups, where exactly was she truly found, vet report from the day in question, ect. I don't agree for a moment that the people should have been able to say "yep, put the dog down it ain't ours 🤷" when the owners didn't even get a chance to have a say... Then to post on Facebook saying the dog had pneumonia and would need surgery for that, the stupidity. And saying the dog was thrown out of a vehicle and laying on the side of the road. She posted all that for attention for her "good deed". It was wonderful of them to take her anywhere but, to have her put down is outrageous. I've had an english bulldog through my teen years into adulthood and my dad was negligent and tied her out on the porch with water BUT apparently left her too long because he said she got tangled at the bottom and stuck in the sun and died of heat stroke. It's extremely common for dogs like that to have respiratory distress, unfortunately. They need ajr conditioning or constant water supply in heat. It seems as if they took them out with them for a ride and such then intended to drop them off back at home, which is more than dog most owners do.
It’s actually ridiculous that this person who found the dog and the vet decided to put it down. Yes, the dog went missing and it was his fault for taking the dogs to the park to begin with. That doesn’t make it okay to kill the dog. The vet and the “rescuer” unilaterally decided to KILL an animal. It was not the right thing to do, to euthanize a dog because it’s dehydrated.
Had the dog have puppies RECENTLY!!! *hits the desk* bang bang*. LOL. Judge Judy cracks me up.
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂 I swear I replayed that part SEVERAL times!!!! Lmao! She cracks me up, too!
Uhhhh yes yes yes yes yes, she had puppies recently
😂😂😂 that poor desk
😅Not giving him chance to lie! 👩🏻⚖️
That stare in the beginning when Judge Judy had her head lowered as plaintiff gave story 😂 boy if looks could kill
The old man seems like the nicest person. Suing someone for your lack of responsibility is foolish. However, he admits to being a bad owner, atleast that's something.
65 is an ‘old’ man?.? 😂😂😂😂
@@randywolfinger1496well he's not a young man
"The old man" 😅😅😅 he may be 65 at most. We'll see how good you look when you hit your 60's or maybe even as young as your 50's. HA!
@@RemyJustice97How about the Defendant or the other man, old man good Lord!
@@RemyJustice97Nor are you intelligent
He sued because he was not given the chance to find his dog. Well, he was definitely spared from the the horrible experience of finding his dog dead of dehydration in the park.
That's true. Though I'd feel the same as them. They did a nice thing taking her to the vet but, didn't give anyone the opportunity to find her and make the decision to save her life instead of just killing her and then claiming they found her laying on the road and thrown out of a vehicle.
@@Frosty0762 you know what they say: “no good deed goes unpunished”. Sad but true!
“Well, yeah, I am a bad owner” 😂
😂😂
Here comes the doctrine of clean hands lecture!
They claimed I'm a bad owner.....you are a bad owner!!! Give it to him Judy❤
"Has the dog had puppies RECENTLY!!!??" I HOLLERED! Hahaha!!
Judge Judy is all fired up today!
She always is when it comes to cases having to do with dogs.
@@DannyHidalgoyup. I love that she refers to treating them/watching them as if they are toddlers.
She must be hungry
She loves dogs 🐶
You have to be a real P O S person to sue the person that was actually helping your dog and giving it assistance. The absolute nerve!
Plaintiff did not take the dog to the vet often. So, the rescue vet checked the dog, and something was seriously wrong with it to put it down. They do not put down healthy dogs.
Owners expected the vet, who is working at rescue (probably with little funds), to invest thousands or tens of thousands of dollars in life-saving care, to save a dog that had no known owner and may never retrieve the dog. And even if they saved the dog and owner found them, would likely refuse to compensate the rescue for the care provided. Utter morons.
clearly the dog was so inbred that she had severe health problems
Lmao! I had to play back that part where JJ is knocking on the desk! She is not having no rubbish today 🤣🤣🤣
That poor dog. It didn't deserve to suffer like that 😢
So disgusting. He killed his own dog and he doesn't even care, he laughs about it. And she had recently had puppies, so they are backyard breeders. Despicable people. Horrible
Hear hear.
Having puppies probably with pneumonia! Poor dog!
Plaintiff has a lot of nerve to sue the defendant and the vet hospital for his own negligence
"They claimed I'm a bad owner"
"You are a bad owner!"
"Well yeah, I am"
It must be close to her lunch time 😂 she's not having it today
Sushi
The plaintiff needs to learn the law of holes 🕳 when you're in one..... Stop digging 😮😢😅😂
GREAT POINT,...STOP DIGGING...
Judge Judy is clearly an expert on English bulldogs 💕
4:38 JJ wasn’t having it with this dude 💀
That path was so funny lmao!
Poor dog! 😢
It’s 95 degrees!
The dog is in the truck!
Someone tried to rescue!
But he was out of luck!!
- in my Glorilla voice 😅
😂😂😂😂😂
Please 😂😂😂😂😂
This guy really thought it was a good idea to come on the show to let everyone know that he was a bad dog owner.
Putting a dog down so quickly doesn’t make sense unless the dog was near death when found.
From what was described in the vets report, it unfortunately was that close to death and it had no chop or tags so the owner was not traceable - its his own fault his dog had to be put down 😪
“They didn’t give me a chance to look for my dog” how is one supposed to know how long it’s been since the dog was separated from its owner??
Good morning from Australia 🇦🇺
@TheFlickkim, have a g'day! Hiya from London on a Tuesday evening
Good morning from rainy Melbourne 🤣
Hello from the state of Indiana. 🎉
Good night from Croatia ❤️
He won without saying more than name and age.
Theyre mad and looking for someone to blame because they cant make money off of the dog anymore
Why tf would they kill an English bulldog?
4:38 Whoa whoa JJ control your temper 😳😱 😡👩⚖️. Lol lmao XD #hahahaha 😭😂💀
I laughed so hard at how she said have your dogs had puppies recently!! 🤣🤣
😂
Now why they sue this man 🤦🏻♀️ we call that ah pappy show 😂😂😂😂
if the owner HADN'T left the back open, the English bulldog would have had heatstroke in the truck. A LOT of English bulldogs have breathing problems and can't deal with heat.
BOTH OF the dogs would have been dead in less than 15 mins if they'd been shut in the truck
One of my husbands daughters came home and said I'm getting a pug. He said no your not. He explained to her with her schedule between working,school and sports (golf and softball) she would not have the time to take care of the dog and he would not do it. She didn't get the dog.
No vet would ever euthanize a healthy dog that has as recently gone astray.
There’s a reason the dog ran away and a reason the Vet put her down. 35 pounds looks to be 5 pounds underweight for that breed according to the internet- she could’ve been sick or injured beyond repair.
I live in a desert type area and a frenchie in the city got out of his yard - he passed from heat exhaustion very quickly. Brachycephalic dogs can go downhill fast in heat, poor kid 😔🖤
"Had the dog had puppies RECENTLY⁉️🗣️🗣️🗣️"
😅
Was not a joke.
Lunch crew we here!
Why would you take Mom out for a truck ride when she just had puppies... awaiting pt 3 for answers!
They were stupid enough to think she could be away from them for a few hours, when really they need to stay home for quite some time not just to look after the pups but to recover themselves! Hopefully they don't own more dogs after this disaster
How can this go for 4 parts?!😮 unless there is some suprize twist Smoking Gun coming up?!😂
YOU ARE A BAD OWNER🗣️🗣️🗣️
The owners are ignorant and neglectful.
“Didn’t give me time to find my dog” sir i’m not sure u really tried🤷🏽♀️he said they got to the park at 8:30 am….he took the ONE dog that was still in the truck home at 10:30 am…then came back to the park and partied for 6 more hours….ummm that means u spent less than 2 hrs “looking” and then went on about ur day so why are we here?
Mr Vue sounds remedial
Naw, the vet & rescuer didn’t even give the owner 24 hours to claim him…they jumped the gun and made assumptions…
I agree! No one seems to be acknowledging that
If the poor dog was too ill from temperature and was suffuring and problably would die anyway why wait longer? So the poor animal could suffer more until those idiots come find her? They mad not about the dog but about the facebook post that made them look as bad as they were.
Did the dog have puppies recently ?? i liked the tone
"He took her to the vet and had her put down." Plaintiff is making the defendant sound like a dog assassin.
Owner never take accountability this would t have happened if they were paying attention if it was a child missing they be in jail or maybe they would blame someone else than themselves
these two irresponsible fools were breeding the dog???!!!!
Very reasonable people here than on Facebook. They showed a clip of this case and people were saying Judge Judy got it wrong as well as being a bully against the plaintiff. Did we just watch the same case? Some lady defending him asking if no one had ever made a mistake. I can’t with people.
Part 3???
If the uploads are good, they go up every half an hour. 😊
@@TheFlickkim thanks! 😊
JJ has zero patience with this plaintiff because she has a soft spot for dogs.
This couple left English Bulldogs in a hot vehicle in 90 degree heat for hours.....and that breed overheats faster than other breeds because they can't pant properly to cool themselves off, because their airway is squashed for appearance. That alone makes them awful owners.
Then one dog goes missing so the husband (supposedly) looks for a while, then goes back to partying? For hours? That poor little pup.
*Dear whomever is reading this May Almighty GOD soft your heart and bring a day filled with peace and joy!!!*
God bless you 🙏🏻
fanatic
Which god is this you refer to Sir?
Amen 🙌
Amen, you too. 💖
Judge Judy is assuming that the back was left down and she's making that assumption as factual
It’s so sad the dog put down though ):
Always someone else's fault. Never take responsibity for their bad choices. Reminds me some people.
Poor dog🥺🥺🥺🥺
So what, were they intending to keep the dogs with them outside in 90° heat all day?? Why even bring them? Why even have an outdoor event that lasts from 10am to 4pm in that kind of heat anyway?? I don't feel bad for them in the slightest.
Raven symone’s dad is in the audience
I wish someone would ask what was the purpose of bringing the dogs to the party in the first place?
Why didn't the finder ask around locally to those who were there first ?
So if she already had pneumonia, he should've taken her to the vet, not the party.
When JJ doesn't like you, there is nothing you can say that she can't twist against you. Best to just shut up.
Rescues effing around again assuming evil intent where there was none.
Jj gets too intense when it comes to animals sometimes
She’s passionate about animals.
Was the dog not wearing a collar?? Also, did they just...go on and have the party while the dog was missing?? All day?
Will there be an upload of part 3. It’s a guessing game at this point.
This show proves how stoopid ppl can be
Putting a dog down you just found is crazy
The defendant was not the rescue and also not the dog's owner. Next not paying attention to the case.
NEXT
@@trekgirl65 Says you. The brain dead.
Too bad she can't tell animal breeders to get a job a real job...he made 5k for 2 puppies and poor momma dog just not fair how animals are forced to breed for money. Glad momma was put down she is better off .....how horrible she would of had a horrible death if not rescued.
"There was a lot of activity at the park, so I think maybe one of them let my dog out of the truck." The nerve of this guy! 🤦🏻♀️
Is Judge Judgy saying small dogs can't breed? Around 1:35. Obviously the toy dogs category exists.
did I miss something on this case?
apparently
That was a nasty facebook post though
I wish Judge Judy would explain the law better because she obviously chose a bias before this case started and it seems irrelevant without case law behind it. It seems like the old man is at fault and purposefully took the dog without looking for the owner. Law in our state requires you look for the owner in a case like this.
But if what old man says is true, he didn't take the dog, he found the dog lying by the highway. He took the dog to a vet which was the responsible thing to do.
I am assuming dog had no chip hence they could not contact the owner.
Do they actually put down animals that are chipped?
Mr Vu!!! LISTEN UP, why don't you get involved with dog rescue and not dog breeding (forced sex slavery).
Plz judge Judy dont eat up last part
He's definitely a bad dog owner. He shouldn't have any dogs.
Those dogs never should have been out in the heat for all those hours.
Plaintiffs are responsible for the dog's death. Enough already.
Whats wrong with judge Judy
Who doesn’t see a dog coming out a car.
Pneumonia is NOT heat stroke. So the dog was already in signficant distress without the introduction of the 90+F temperatures according to that. And old man's wife doesn't have a clue. YOU DON'T HAVE SURGERY FOR PNEUMONIA.
Well, at least plaintiff's wife is gorgeous😬
Owner negligence = ok to kill other peoples' dogs? What?
The wife pretty. She looks like Ray J’s wife Princess
Plaintiffs should be banned from owning animals.
wife is cute af
Yeah, I'm not with the majority of you and there are a lot of unknown things.. such as the age of the pups, where exactly was she truly found, vet report from the day in question, ect.
I don't agree for a moment that the people should have been able to say "yep, put the dog down it ain't ours 🤷" when the owners didn't even get a chance to have a say... Then to post on Facebook saying the dog had pneumonia and would need surgery for that, the stupidity. And saying the dog was thrown out of a vehicle and laying on the side of the road. She posted all that for attention for her "good deed". It was wonderful of them to take her anywhere but, to have her put down is outrageous.
I've had an english bulldog through my teen years into adulthood and my dad was negligent and tied her out on the porch with water BUT apparently left her too long because he said she got tangled at the bottom and stuck in the sun and died of heat stroke. It's extremely common for dogs like that to have respiratory distress, unfortunately. They need ajr conditioning or constant water supply in heat. It seems as if they took them out with them for a ride and such then intended to drop them off back at home, which is more than dog most owners do.
His wife cud be anna sawai sister i swear
WTH is wrong with JJ today? Seems like she’s very bias.
The guy basically is responsible for killing his own dog, suing some old innocent man, and doesn’t even seem to care.
Because the man had the audacity to sue a man who rescued her dog. The dog was innocent and died because of its owner’s negligence.
It’s actually ridiculous that this person who found the dog and the vet decided to put it down. Yes, the dog went missing and it was his fault for taking the dogs to the park to begin with. That doesn’t make it okay to kill the dog. The vet and the “rescuer” unilaterally decided to KILL an animal. It was not the right thing to do, to euthanize a dog because it’s dehydrated.
Horrible defendant I can’t believe he killed an animal
Terrible pet owners.
Terrible people 💔💔💔
Second
This is all mess. They killed the dog. They made him look bad.. they could of hold the dog til he find it and pay his part. This is just 1 sided
very obnoxious judge.. i just hope she is no longer working there as judge... she is totally a garbage