You know how it goes, after doubting for a while you decide to go with the Manix or PM2 and one month later you also purchase the other one. And then the Manix LW and a PM2 sprint run etc. I’m so lucky my wife understands ;-)
Just got my first Manix 2 in the mail a few hours ago-Love it so far. I debated for along time over the Manix vs Paramilitary. I love both designs, but I love the leaf blade shape a little bit more. Also I love the larger finger guard on the Manix. It makes me feel less likely to slip forward.
My favorite feature of my Manix 2 is that the back of the knife handle close to the blade hasn't got the gap between the scales. For repetitive or hard cutting tasks the handle is MUCH more comfortable to push on. This has much to do with the ball bearing lock, as the thing filling the gap is actually the bearing block/guide. For me that makes the Manix 2 a pleasure to use and for me outweighs concerns about the knives weight and folded size.
Love that blacked out manix. Great comparison between the two. I'm with you, it's too hard to choose. For me it would depend on the day and the cycle of the moon.
***** ***** I'm not really a tactical knife guy, but I know lots of folks who are happy with the PM2 as an emergency tactical knife. It really isn't huge. I find the size to be just about perfect for most applications.
My good friend Casey bought me the cruwear gray version of the manix and there is some great milling in the liners for weight relief if anyone was wondering. That one just kicks up the manix likeabilty a notch. Love it. Favorite knife ever.
Great review the Manix 2 has the best ergos of any knife I've ever owned or even held the Para 2 feels better in pocket because its more narrow and lighter if I could only buy one I go with the Para just for comfort of carry and light weight because if something isn't comfortable you will leave it at home
I have the para 2 and love how slim/sleek the blade is and the compression lock is very handy compared to the liner locks on my other spydies. Also, you have to love the camo/ black blade, it looks SWEET!!
I was lucky enough to check both out in hand at the store before buying. The Manix was more comfortable for me and remains my favorite and most carried knife.
I ended up owning the Manix 2 first because visually it was more appealing to me between the two. Recently I acquired a Paramilitary 2 and will say that after getting used to the lock and the looks it has really grown on me. Doing the Spydie flick makes it really quick to deploy and it locks up great. The choil makes it good for fine knife work and it is comfortable to use. I like the Manix 2 as well but it does take up a lot of pocket real estate.
I just got both of these knives in the last two weeks....and I cant decide which one I like better. The Manix kind of feels better in my hand, and due to it's weight, it makes me think it's the stronger of the two knives, (Although I know that's not the case). It amazes me how light the PM is, and can be as strong as it is. Both are amazing knives!
I purchased an S30V G10 Manix 2 last February just after getting out of the hospital. What I noticed is that it seems to be a totally different knife from the Manix 2 LW. I love my Manix 2 G10. I seem to prefer it to any of my PM2s.
I have both the knives and I prefer the manix (I have the lightweight) it's just gripper it's lighter easier to sharpen and its very corrosion resistant the pocket clip is godly and doesn't look like hey! He has a knife in his pocket, I love the paramilitary and I love s30v but in my mind the manix is better especially the lock, the compression lock pinches me sometimes and the ball bearing is very strong
Been watching your chan for a long time now & it was your "Hard Use" video on the PM2 that helped me make the decision to buy it! It's my left pocket EDC and one of my favorite blades. Gonna subscribe now and want to thank you for what you do.
Manix 2 better value. PM2 sells for about $ 30-40 more. Manix 2 seems like a more durable design with full liners. I think the bearing lock is more secure than the liner lock. Love the Manix2 handle design. The Manix2 and my 940 are my 2 knives that have the most pocket time.
I believe I read from Spyderco tests the PM2 compression lock (not a liner lock) is strong than the Manix 2 cbbl. I think full liners only really help if you're doing a lot of twisting and prying. I've had two versions of the Manix 2 and sold both. I didn't like the "hump" in the spine. Made the blade too wide in pocket. The PM2 suits me better. I always wanted a 940. I got a 710 and love it.
+scullkrusher Wrong. The ball bearing lock on the Manix is a more heavy duty and secure lock compared to the compression lock. Search for the video Hold Out vs. Paramilitary 2. The same tests were done in a separate video using the Manix 2 and it performed better than the PM2
This for this series of videos about the Manix 2's. Decided to pull the trigger and bought a Manix 2. We'll see how it compares against my Delicas and my Endura...sorta wish this had the Emerson wave feature but I'm looking forward to trying that ball bearing lock.
Great video work, very informative! Thank you for helping me make up my mind on which one to buy. The Paramilitary 2 it is. PS Paramilitary 2 is 3.9 oz - while the Manix 2 is heavier at 5.0 oz.
Great video! I've been on the fence about these for a bit now, and this helped me decide. Just placed my order, and will have my new, black Manix 2 in two days. Stoked!!! Cheers from the Pacific NW!
Glad I found this comparison. I've been debating on which one I'd get for my next EDC, but wanted to know about the locking systems. The PM2 compression lock seems like a more reliable system from what I can tell, but the filler on the Manix 2 is pretty beefy. And because the blade isn't resting on the ball bearing, I'd think it's just as strong. I'm leaning towards the Manix 2, and I'll probably get that one first, but I really want both... Soon enough, I suppose. Either way, thanks for the great review.
For all round cutting the P2 satin finish feels much more adept to approaching a cut and piercing say like a blister pack. I've only had one for a month but it's been a joy to carry and use. The Manix 2 with the DLC coating and chrome printing is a real trophy of a knife. I carry it occasionally but mainly because it makes me feel good. It's heavy and tough but the finish would be a shame to compromise by serious hard use. The DLC seems to absorb grease and or oil and this can show, I may need to give it a scrubbing with bleach or alcohol to return uniformity to the black finish although I don't see this as a serious problem. For EDC and frequent use the P2 with satin finish gets my vote. For my ego, sense of prestige, and knowledge that I'm carrying a seriously tough and capable 3" folder this all black Manix 2 is a beauty. The Manix 2 lightweight with BD1 steel is more of an even match with the PM2 all round I think, the lightweight being better for price and ease of sharpening and the PM2 in S30V being better for blade toughness, edge retention and general cutting tasks. In this case I would prefer the translucent blue lightweight, for its overall simplification of construction and materials. I bought one for my son and it seems much more practical than the all black S30V version of the Manix 2. The translucent blue of the lightweight scales offset some the intimidation factor that may present anyone around that may have an aversion to sharp pointy objects. Heaven forbid that we make anyone feel uncomfortable as we use our tools.
I edc my pm2 and it performs year in year out from cutting tape and cardboard to stripping sheathing off of large wire. Also occasionally cutting a full pound hamburger in half. I carry front right hand pocket...tip up with my wallet and the thinner profile doesn't interfere. The lock has never failed and the steel is amazing at holding an edge. If I ever need to defend myself with it I would feel confident I could.
Great review and comparison Scout. I have an identical Manix 2 on the way to me currently and will likely pick up a Para 2 at some point this year. Two great workhorse knives!
oooh my… JUST as i am watching your video i recieve a package. and inside is my very first paramilitary 2 :D call it perfect timing i'm already so in love with it!
I only have the PM2 and i love it. Though i might get the Manix 2 also. But i love the tip on the PM2, great piercing point. The only 2 things about the Manix that i think might not be as good would be the weight and the ball bearing lock. I've heard good things, but there is that little spring in there that over time might break? Really nothing to go wrong with the compression lock. But i think i might have to add the Manix. I just have to judge for myself. ;)
I've been trying to decide between these 2 beauties for the past couple of days, this video did not help at all lol Thank you for the info tho, great vid.
Sal Glesser's signature is on the PM2 as well fam. The man made the company yet you ignore him by saying the PM2 is Eric's brainchild. He did improve doe. With a lot. I love my Manix 2, Eric is great at designing knives.
Thats why I got em both I carry the lightweight manix 2 in my left pocket and the para 2 in my right pocket. I'm really favor the manix because its a really cool blue colour but the para 2 is a really great knife too.
I finally have both. The Para 2 is the better knife and still probably the best folding knife of all time. The Manix 2 does outperform the Para 2 as a heavy duty knife, but the Para 2 is much more versatile. The Para 2 is a nice heritage as a collaboration with Eric and his father, but the Manix 2 has similar significant heritage as being Eric's project. I do have the S110V Manix 2 G10 and the liners are very heavily skeletonized (unlike the normal Manix 2).
Great review. I've been thinking about buying a manix 2, but I wanted to see some features of it first but since covid all stores are closed an I cannot go and check them out. In this video I got all the details I wanted to know, and I've been watching many videos in which they don't give the details I wanted. Thanks!
I have that blacked out manix and it is an amazing knife. Recently I've been thinking of picking up a para 2 because the manix is kind of a beast, weighs a ton and the backstrap jimping is starting to annoy me a bit. It's more of a bomb-proof hard use knife and less of an actual EDC to me.
Me being the rare tip down guy I went for the para and love it. Want a Manix in the collection one day and would have one already if it was quad carry but avoid tip up only knives where possible as not to confuse my carry style. I have only purchased one tip up only knife that I just couldn't say no to and I feel like with the lanyard on my tip up, which is something I don't do, I can differentiate the carry style as I pull the knife out of my pocket. If that seems the case with more in pocket every day use testing then the Manix 2 is next on my list.
Most folks on the Spyderco boards seem to prefer the Paramilitary 2 - but the Manix 2 is also very popular. The Manix 2 XL is a bigger Manix that does have skeletonized liners and is worth a look. There are Sprint run versions of the Manix 2 that have skeletonized liners. These are about an ounce lighter and worth it if you can find one. I have a Sprint run Manix 2 with Cruwear steel. Very happy with it.
The "lightning bolt" you are referring to is Sal Glessers'(the owner of Spyderco) makers mark ,the original designer of the Paramilitary. His son Eric helped improve the design for the second iteration. I don't think he's the nut job in this equation.
thinking of drilling out some holes in the liners on my manix 2. only downside to the manix 2 is that i wish they always had skeletonized liners from the get go. I think some of the newer models do, at least i think so. great knife especially after your finger tips callus up a little due to pulling down on the ball bearing lock. Anyone else find that your fingertips hurt after flipping the hell out of the knife at first?
I have both, manix 2 feels a little more sturdy in hand, pm2 is a little lighter and a liittle better balanced. Either way you go is a win for sure. My preference definitely goes to the pm2.
I got the Manix 2 after I realized how small the lil Native was in my hand. The Manix is pretty big and has some weight to it. I'm not a fan of how wide it is closed. You for sure notice it in your pocket. The lock is pretty stiff too. It does feel nice in my hand though.
Open the blade and open the switch, stick a small torx bit in the hole keeping it forced open overnight while not using it over a week or two. Helped mine break in a bit.
one other thing should have mentioned with the MANIX 2 Is the heel of the knife is slick and the handel will slip if you dont grab the clip with your fingers i have added a little scateboard tape ot the heel ot give it grip in my plam but dont understand why Spyderco didnt put jimping on the heel as they did on the bottom of the knife
Prefer blade shape and ergos on manix, prefer compression lock on paramilitary. So ended up getting the newer para 3 LW as my light EDC and my Manix 2 G10 is my heavy duty EDC.
Haven't actually seen the paramilitary in any stores near me, so I would need to order it online, but the store I go to had the Manix 2, so bought it. Great knife. Love it
Have both...like Manix better. More style, fits better in hand for me. More jimping. Para 2 is nice, but IMO it was overhyped and the price is more than it's worth.
I have both and they get pretty equal edc time. The pm2 is more fun to fidget with to me, but both knives are great all-rounders. Both mine are in s30v because I don’t think the upgraded steels are worth what they ask. S30v is plenty good enough for user knives imo.
Very useful comparison video. Thank you. This Manix2 looks somewhat better to me, even though I am aware that Paramilitary2 is WAY more popular. I wish Manix2 was as "narrow" in its depth and as light as Paramilitary2 though. I don't think that solid liners add very much in toughness, but drilled ones would add to a lightness of a knife for sure. Heck: all my watches are housed in titanium, so... Also: there is a greater chance for the coil spring to rust in a lock of the Manix. Rather than when a lock is made out of robust stainless steel, IMO. Still: I kind of like esthetics of Manix2 better.
Both excellent knives. I like how the PM2 rides in the pocket a little bit slimmer overall but I like how the Manix fills out my hand more. Just depends on what I feel like carrying. These are the 2 best Spyderco knife options out there right now IMO for a serious user.
I expected to be able to disengage the Manix lock with just the thumb like an Axis lock but you have to pull on both sides. For the weight, I prefer the Gayle Bradley 2, more blade, better materials, slimmer in pocket at about the same price.
Hey sorry, do you have the exact name of that Manix 2? Everwhere I look the only Manix 2 with the black full flat grind is the Manix 2 XL. I want that version! Haha. Great vid, thx.
I had a Manix2 but...it just didn't float my boat like the PM2. So I sold it and got myself a Manix2 LW. IMO a better knife - that weight is incredible.
I think it is safe to say that the PM2 is the superior knife overall. The compression lock, the lighter weight, while still being just as sturdy and "tough." I am a fan of both, but I think it's clear as day as to which one is "better" overall. Now, may not necessarily be better than any specific person. Some people prefer heavier knives. But, for EDC, lighter is (in general) better. I wouldn't fault someone for saying they prefer the Manix....but to say the Manix is superior for EDC - it's not, at least from a very broad and general perspective of knife users.
I have a lightweight manix 2 with s110v steel and an all black pm2 with s30v steel. It's tough to decide which is my favorite. They both have the features that I like. Hmmm maybe I'll just carry both lol! nice video!
pete sims sorry for the late reply. I've gravitated towards the PM2 more than the manix s110v. The S110v is definitely better at edge retention, I haven't sharpen it yet. On the other hand the PM2 is more practical for me. For use and carry. I'm not that good at sharpening but I can put a shaving edge on the PM2. But it takes me awhile. I'm afraid to sharpen the manix lol. And for carry, it is easier to carry the PM2 mainly because of what type of pants I wear. I wear slim type pants(levi's 511) and the manix is just too wide in the pocket for me.
Awesome I was hoping for this comparison. Any chance you could look at the Manix 2 vs Mini-grip? I know they aren't the same size but the lock style is similar and spyderco doesn't have a smaller ball bearing lock knife yet (with the updated design).
I recently got a Kershaw Blur for an EDC but for light camping use I started looking at the paramilitary 2. Would you recommend the Manix 2 just as much?
Great vid! I got my beloved Spyderco Sage 1 and looking at your vid, is it just me or does the Manix 2 slightly resembles the shape of the Sage 1? Looking at the geometry of the blade, the handle, the finger choils...look quite similar.
Passed on both got the yojimbo 2 in s30v then was offered a deal on the same in s90v and boy what a treat these are. But since then I've picked up the manix 2 in s110v and am having a hard time adjusting to the lock system. It's not even close to the ease of use coming from the axis lock (BM) and then going the compression lock with my YJ2. I'm so torn on trying the Pm2 as it is a touch longer from the specs I've seen. Thoughts?
nice video, i had to make the choice between them and for me other than i like the look of the manix 2 better i really made my choice as a lefty the para seems more of a right handed lock release
i'm holding the same manix 2 with DLC and S30V steel,i like this knife so much i own two of them,the other is with the gray coating and is a vary hard finish that should last a life time,i also think its one of spyderco's best knifes along with there para 2,vary nive video,lots of thanks.
Thank you for not being another rambling, slow speaking knife reviewer. I'm going with the manix I think, I'm used to the axis lock so it should feel right at home.
I've never had the privilege of holding any of the PM series but I did buy a sprint run manix 2 in 2012 with cts-bd30p which is carpenters version of s30v. It also came with skeletonized liners bringing the weight down to a very acceptable 4.2 Oz. It's also 1 of the most comfortable knives I've ever held regarding the ergonomics. I do also carry a 615 mini rukus at 5.9 Oz so I'm not overly scared of the extra weight when the knife just melts into my hand as my manix 2 and mini rukus are a toss up for my most comfortable knife. I wear a large glove if this helps. Also I've been able to fondle the new Shaman and it would easily kick my manix out of my pocket in ergos if I could talk the wife into letting me buy 1.
I got the blurple manix2 with s110v steel. Id have to drag the edge across concrete 50 times before it starts to dull. But as it is similar lock release with my old benchmade I'm partial to the ball bearing lock. Strength of a lock has never come close to being an issue. If it were I'd still be carrying a back lock. But neh
people about to fight in here lol ;) Personally......FOR ME, I prefer the Manix2. I have both, and I've got both a standard and lightweight Manix2. The reason why I prefer the Manix is how it feels in hand. I can't bash either over performance because both ROCK. But as you said, it's a good thing we dont need to chose between the 2, but some people have to and all I can say to them is try to get the in hand and then you'll know. Great point for decision Scout and keep it up :d
had a PM2, broke the tip off of it, took 5 weeks to get it back from spyderco, sold it. had a manix 2 xl, sold it, cause its HUGE! finally found a FFG manix 2, and awaiting on it on friday. I personally dont like the PM2 due to the blade to handle ratio. the Manix has MUCH better ergos than the PM2.
Oh man, the Manix 2 is so sexy but the PM2 is just an icon. I guess the question really is not which one to get, but which one to get FIRST.
earthenvessels sexy, its a inanimate object.
Indeed
earthenvessels Manix 2XL😀
I got the Manix 2 Lightweight CPM S110V. It's simply awesome.
Buuut i still really want a PM2.
@@714milky lol. Me to. I bought a manix 2 but dying to get a pm2. Love the manix though
You know how it goes, after doubting for a while you decide to go with the Manix or PM2 and one month later you also purchase the other one. And then the Manix LW and a PM2 sprint run etc. I’m so lucky my wife understands ;-)
knife addict!
I could have wrote that and it still be true, haha. 👍
I felt this in my soul lmao. Started with the paramilitary but it was so close o just ordered the manix too 😅
I like the design of manix 2 much more.
Yeah the huge handle on the Paramilitary bugs me
Just got my first Manix 2 in the mail a few hours ago-Love it so far. I debated for along time over the Manix vs Paramilitary. I love both designs, but I love the leaf blade shape a little bit more. Also I love the larger finger guard on the Manix. It makes me feel less likely to slip forward.
My favorite feature of my Manix 2 is that the back of the knife handle close to the blade hasn't got the gap between the scales.
For repetitive or hard cutting tasks the handle is MUCH more comfortable to push on. This has much to do with the ball bearing lock, as the thing filling the gap is actually the bearing block/guide.
For me that makes the Manix 2 a pleasure to use and for me outweighs concerns about the knives weight and folded size.
Just got my blacked out LW Manix 2. Unbelievably happy with it! Best feeling knife I’ve ever held in my hand.
Love that blacked out manix. Great comparison between the two. I'm with you, it's too hard to choose. For me it would depend on the day and the cycle of the moon.
Or maybe the flip of a coin? ;)
***** ***** I'm not really a tactical knife guy, but I know lots of folks who are happy with the PM2 as an emergency tactical knife. It really isn't huge. I find the size to be just about perfect for most applications.
+The Late Boy Scout
Heads i win Tails you lose ;)
Wonderful vid.. Love 'em both tho! nuff said.
3 of each in different steels does it for me.
My good friend Casey bought me the cruwear gray version of the manix and there is some great milling in the liners for weight relief if anyone was wondering. That one just kicks up the manix likeabilty a notch. Love it. Favorite knife ever.
Great review the Manix 2 has the best ergos of any knife I've ever owned or even held the Para 2 feels better in pocket because its more narrow and lighter if I could only buy one I go with the Para just for comfort of carry and light weight because if something isn't comfortable you will leave it at home
I actually like the Manix 2 better. My decisions been made, thanks Scout.
I have the para 2 and love how slim/sleek the blade is and the compression lock is very handy compared to the liner locks on my other spydies. Also, you have to love the camo/ black blade, it looks SWEET!!
I was lucky enough to check both out in hand at the store before buying. The Manix was more comfortable for me and remains my favorite and most carried knife.
I've had my manix 2 for 4 years or so.. the grip/ergo is perfect any way u hold it. SOLID AF
I had mine for 8 years now. Just picked up a PM2 in digicamo with an S45VN Dlc blade. Both are awesome, and super cutting tools.
Your review was quite helpful. Thanks for taking the time to do what you do. Man you burned up the shoe leather at shot show! I was impressed. : )
Thanks!
I ended up owning the Manix 2 first because visually it was more appealing to me between the two. Recently I acquired a Paramilitary 2 and will say that after getting used to the lock and the looks it has really grown on me. Doing the Spydie flick makes it really quick to deploy and it locks up great. The choil makes it good for fine knife work and it is comfortable to use. I like the Manix 2 as well but it does take up a lot of pocket real estate.
I just got both of these knives in the last two weeks....and I cant decide which one I like better. The Manix kind of feels better in my hand, and due to it's weight, it makes me think it's the stronger of the two knives, (Although I know that's not the case). It amazes me how light the PM is, and can be as strong as it is. Both are amazing knives!
I have the spyderco manix 2 xl and I love it. I always have it in my pocket. I would love to try the Para military 2.
I purchased an S30V G10 Manix 2 last February just after getting out of the hospital. What I noticed is that it seems to be a totally different knife from the Manix 2 LW. I love my Manix 2 G10. I seem to prefer it to any of my PM2s.
While I do love my Manix 2 lightweight in CPM SPY27, I still prefer the Paramilitary 2. I've got 2 of them.
No way could decide between the 2!! I got both!!
Love both too!!
I have both the knives and I prefer the manix (I have the lightweight) it's just gripper it's lighter easier to sharpen and its very corrosion resistant the pocket clip is godly and doesn't look like hey! He has a knife in his pocket, I love the paramilitary and I love s30v but in my mind the manix is better especially the lock, the compression lock pinches me sometimes and the ball bearing is very strong
The PM2 is a Sal Glesser design. The Manix 2 is an Eric Glesser design. You can clearly see the signatures are different!
Been watching your chan for a long time now & it was your "Hard Use" video on the PM2 that helped me make the decision to buy it! It's my left pocket EDC and one of my favorite blades. Gonna subscribe now and want to thank you for what you do.
Manix 2 better value. PM2 sells for about $ 30-40 more. Manix 2 seems like a more durable design with full liners. I think the bearing lock is more secure than the liner lock. Love the Manix2 handle design. The Manix2 and my 940 are my 2 knives that have the most pocket time.
I believe I read from Spyderco tests the PM2 compression lock (not a liner lock) is strong than the Manix 2 cbbl. I think full liners only really help if you're doing a lot of twisting and prying. I've had two versions of the Manix 2 and sold both. I didn't like the "hump" in the spine. Made the blade too wide in pocket. The PM2 suits me better. I always wanted a 940. I got a 710 and love it.
Watch the video that scout did with blade HQ the compression lock is insanely strong
+scullkrusher Wrong. The ball bearing lock on the Manix is a more heavy duty and secure lock compared to the compression lock. Search for the video Hold Out vs. Paramilitary 2. The same tests were done in a separate video using the Manix 2 and it performed better than the PM2
do you find the manix 2 a bit heavy in the pocket at 5 onces?
This for this series of videos about the Manix 2's.
Decided to pull the trigger and bought a Manix 2. We'll see how it compares against my Delicas and my Endura...sorta wish this had the Emerson wave feature but I'm looking forward to trying that ball bearing lock.
I like both but prefer my Blurple PM2 w/s110v for heavy use.
Great video work, very informative! Thank you for helping me make up my mind on which one to buy. The Paramilitary 2 it is. PS Paramilitary 2 is 3.9 oz - while the Manix 2 is heavier at 5.0 oz.
Great video! I've been on the fence about these for a bit now, and this helped me decide. Just placed my order, and will have my new, black Manix 2 in two days. Stoked!!! Cheers from the Pacific NW!
Glad I found this comparison. I've been debating on which one I'd get for my next EDC, but wanted to know about the locking systems. The PM2 compression lock seems like a more reliable system from what I can tell, but the filler on the Manix 2 is pretty beefy. And because the blade isn't resting on the ball bearing, I'd think it's just as strong. I'm leaning towards the Manix 2, and I'll probably get that one first, but I really want both... Soon enough, I suppose. Either way, thanks for the great review.
Great review!! I have both of them on the way because I could not decide over one or the other. So.......I bought both!! 😉
For all round cutting the P2 satin finish feels much more adept to approaching a cut and piercing say like a blister pack. I've only had one for a month but it's been a joy to carry and use.
The Manix 2 with the DLC coating and chrome printing is a real trophy of a knife. I carry it occasionally but mainly because it makes me feel good. It's heavy and tough but the finish would be a shame to compromise by serious hard use. The DLC seems to absorb grease and or oil and this can show, I may need to give it a scrubbing with bleach or alcohol to return uniformity to the black finish although I don't see this as a serious problem.
For EDC and frequent use the P2 with satin finish gets my vote.
For my ego, sense of prestige, and knowledge that I'm carrying a seriously tough and capable 3" folder this all black Manix 2 is a beauty.
The Manix 2 lightweight with BD1 steel is more of an even match with the PM2 all round I think, the lightweight being better for price and ease of sharpening and the PM2 in S30V being better for blade toughness, edge retention and general cutting tasks. In this case I would prefer the translucent blue lightweight, for its overall simplification of construction and materials. I bought one for my son and it seems much more practical than the all black S30V version of the Manix 2.
The translucent blue of the lightweight scales offset some the intimidation factor that may present anyone around that may have an aversion to sharp pointy objects. Heaven forbid that we make anyone feel uncomfortable as we use our tools.
One is built like a fullback, the other like a tight end.
Leon Tan lol Manix 2 fullback and para 2 tight end? Agreed
I edc my pm2 and it performs year in year out from cutting tape and cardboard to stripping sheathing off of large wire. Also occasionally cutting a full pound hamburger in half. I carry front right hand pocket...tip up with my wallet and the thinner profile doesn't interfere. The lock has never failed and the steel is amazing at holding an edge. If I ever need to defend myself with it I would feel confident I could.
I want both! 😤
Great review and comparison Scout. I have an identical Manix 2 on the way to me currently and will likely pick up a Para 2 at some point this year. Two great workhorse knives!
Both are excellent knives - I think it really comes down to personal preference, and your intended POU.
oooh my… JUST as i am watching your video i recieve a package. and inside is my very first paramilitary 2 :D call it perfect timing
i'm already so in love with it!
I only have the PM2 and i love it. Though i might get the Manix 2 also. But i love the tip on the PM2, great piercing point. The only 2 things about the Manix that i think might not be as good would be the weight and the ball bearing lock. I've heard good things, but there is that little spring in there that over time might break? Really nothing to go wrong with the compression lock. But i think i might have to add the Manix. I just have to judge for myself. ;)
Love the blade shape on that manix
I've been trying to decide between these 2 beauties for the past couple of days, this video did not help at all lol Thank you for the info tho, great vid.
both are amazing knives. I favor the m2 a bit more though.
Sal Glesser's signature is on the PM2 as well fam. The man made the company yet you ignore him by saying the PM2 is Eric's brainchild. He did improve doe. With a lot. I love my Manix 2, Eric is great at designing knives.
Thats why I got em both I carry the lightweight manix 2 in my left pocket and the para 2 in my right pocket. I'm really favor the manix because its a really cool blue colour but the para 2 is a really great knife too.
I finally have both. The Para 2 is the better knife and still probably the best folding knife of all time. The Manix 2 does outperform the Para 2 as a heavy duty knife, but the Para 2 is much more versatile. The Para 2 is a nice heritage as a collaboration with Eric and his father, but the Manix 2 has similar significant heritage as being Eric's project. I do have the S110V Manix 2 G10 and the liners are very heavily skeletonized (unlike the normal Manix 2).
Great review. I've been thinking about buying a manix 2, but I wanted to see some features of it first but since covid all stores are closed an I cannot go and check them out. In this video I got all the details I wanted to know, and I've been watching many videos in which they don't give the details I wanted.
Thanks!
I have that blacked out manix and it is an amazing knife. Recently I've been thinking of picking up a para 2 because the manix is kind of a beast, weighs a ton and the backstrap jimping is starting to annoy me a bit. It's more of a bomb-proof hard use knife and less of an actual EDC to me.
Me being the rare tip down guy I went for the para and love it. Want a Manix in the collection one day and would have one already if it was quad carry but avoid tip up only knives where possible as not to confuse my carry style. I have only purchased one tip up only knife that I just couldn't say no to and I feel like with the lanyard on my tip up, which is something I don't do, I can differentiate the carry style as I pull the knife out of my pocket. If that seems the case with more in pocket every day use testing then the Manix 2 is next on my list.
do another field test as you did with blade HQ for the para2 only take both and do the same tests with both. loved that field test
manix 2 wins for me, but I love my pm2 as well
Most folks on the Spyderco boards seem to prefer the Paramilitary 2 - but the Manix 2 is also very popular. The Manix 2 XL is a bigger Manix that does have skeletonized liners and is worth a look. There are Sprint run versions of the Manix 2 that have skeletonized liners. These are about an ounce lighter and worth it if you can find one. I have a Sprint run Manix 2 with Cruwear steel. Very happy with it.
The "lightning bolt" you are referring to is Sal Glessers'(the owner of Spyderco) makers mark ,the original designer of the Paramilitary. His son Eric helped improve the design for the second iteration. I don't think he's the nut job in this equation.
just found out about your youtube channel.. you have an amazing selection.. i have officially spent.. two weekends.. watching your videos..
Thanks again my friend. That I REALLY love this knife!
Was going to buy a manix 2 until I found out about the pm2 LH, had to buy a production knife made for Lefty's.
thinking of drilling out some holes in the liners on my manix 2. only downside to the manix 2 is that i wish they always had skeletonized liners from the get go. I think some of the newer models do, at least i think so. great knife especially after your finger tips callus up a little due to pulling down on the ball bearing lock. Anyone else find that your fingertips hurt after flipping the hell out of the knife at first?
+Dominik S
newer manix has skeletonized liners bring the weight down to 4.2 ounces (vs 4.9 on older models).
My 2 favorite spydercos.... HOW TO CHOOSE
I have both, manix 2 feels a little more sturdy in hand, pm2 is a little lighter and a liittle better balanced. Either way you go is a win for sure. My preference definitely goes to the pm2.
I got the Manix 2 after I realized how small the lil Native was in my hand. The Manix is pretty big and has some weight to it. I'm not a fan of how wide it is closed. You for sure notice it in your pocket. The lock is pretty stiff too. It does feel nice in my hand though.
Open the blade and open the switch, stick a small torx bit in the hole keeping it forced open overnight while not using it over a week or two. Helped mine break in a bit.
The dark blue lightweight has S110V! Steel and it is AWESOME.
one other thing should have mentioned with the MANIX 2 Is the heel of the knife is slick and the handel will slip if you dont grab the clip with your fingers i have added a little scateboard tape ot the heel ot give it grip in my plam but dont understand why Spyderco didnt put jimping on the heel as they did on the bottom of the knife
Prefer blade shape and ergos on manix, prefer compression lock on paramilitary. So ended up getting the newer para 3 LW as my light EDC and my Manix 2 G10 is my heavy duty EDC.
Great vid. Thanks for the clear and didactic explanation.
It's a tie!! Everyone's a winner!!
A very useful and interesting video. Thank you.
Dude, thank you!!! Solid, comprehensive review. You just made my decision much easier.
Haven't actually seen the paramilitary in any stores near me, so I would need to order it online, but the store I go to had the Manix 2, so bought it. Great knife. Love it
Have both...like Manix better. More style, fits better in hand for me. More jimping. Para 2 is nice, but IMO it was overhyped and the price is more than it's worth.
Couldn’t decide to purchase just ended up buying both of them
Carry one in your left pocket, and the other in your right!
DrinkSumJuiice That is exactly what I do everyday
I have both and they get pretty equal edc time. The pm2 is more fun to fidget with to me, but both knives are great all-rounders. Both mine are in s30v because I don’t think the upgraded steels are worth what they ask. S30v is plenty good enough for user knives imo.
i have just ordered the all black one looking forward to getting it 😀
+Travis Sollars He wasn't talking about a knife.
LOL
It's a brilliant knife 😀
Very useful comparison video. Thank you.
This Manix2 looks somewhat better to me, even though I am aware that Paramilitary2 is WAY more popular. I wish Manix2 was as "narrow" in its depth and as light as Paramilitary2 though. I don't think that solid liners add very much in toughness, but drilled ones would add to a lightness of a knife for sure. Heck: all my watches are housed in titanium, so... Also: there is a greater chance for the coil spring to rust in a lock of the Manix. Rather than when a lock is made out of robust stainless steel, IMO. Still: I kind of like esthetics of Manix2 better.
Both excellent knives. I like how the PM2 rides in the pocket a little bit slimmer overall but I like how the Manix fills out my hand more. Just depends on what I feel like carrying. These are the 2 best Spyderco knife options out there right now IMO for a serious user.
***** ohhh a metal gear fan!!! excited for the phantom pain??? ::D
feketetv Quite excited, although also quite disappointed in recent Konami/Kojima affairs. :/
hmmm. yeah :( at least he can finish the game.
I expected to be able to disengage the Manix lock with just the thumb like an Axis lock but you have to pull on both sides. For the weight, I prefer the Gayle Bradley 2, more blade, better materials, slimmer in pocket at about the same price.
Hey sorry, do you have the exact name of that Manix 2? Everwhere I look the only Manix 2 with the black full flat grind is the Manix 2 XL. I want that version! Haha. Great vid, thx.
I had a Manix2 but...it just didn't float my boat like the PM2. So I sold it and got myself a Manix2 LW. IMO a better knife - that weight is incredible.
I just got the dark bue light wight S110V very nice love the steel much better then my BD1
I think it is safe to say that the PM2 is the superior knife overall. The compression lock, the lighter weight, while still being just as sturdy and "tough." I am a fan of both, but I think it's clear as day as to which one is "better" overall. Now, may not necessarily be better than any specific person. Some people prefer heavier knives. But, for EDC, lighter is (in general) better. I wouldn't fault someone for saying they prefer the Manix....but to say the Manix is superior for EDC - it's not, at least from a very broad and general perspective of knife users.
I have been wrestling with picking one or the other...but the carry options, and the blade lock has me leaning to the PM 2..
I have a lightweight manix 2 with s110v steel and an all black pm2 with s30v steel. It's tough to decide which is my favorite. They both have the features that I like. Hmmm maybe I'll just carry both lol! nice video!
I'm toying with the idea of the Manix 110V. I have a Pm2 already. is there much difference between blade retention?
pete sims sorry for the late reply. I've gravitated towards the PM2 more than the manix s110v. The S110v is definitely better at edge retention, I haven't sharpen it yet. On the other hand the PM2 is more practical for me. For use and carry.
I'm not that good at sharpening but I can put a shaving edge on the PM2. But it takes me awhile. I'm afraid to sharpen the manix lol. And for carry, it is easier to carry the PM2 mainly because of what type of pants I wear. I wear slim type pants(levi's 511) and the manix is just too wide in the pocket for me.
Henry Navalta hey really appreciate the reply, I've also stayed with the pm 2, maybe one day I'll invest but not just yet. thanks for your help!
Awesome I was hoping for this comparison. Any chance you could look at the Manix 2 vs Mini-grip? I know they aren't the same size but the lock style is similar and spyderco doesn't have a smaller ball bearing lock knife yet (with the updated design).
manix vs large grip would make more sence
Grip IMO
I recently got a Kershaw Blur for an EDC but for light camping use I started looking at the paramilitary 2. Would you recommend the Manix 2 just as much?
Yes I would get the g10 manix 2 with s30v sir.
Kenneth Jarrell To late :P. Recently purchased the PM2 and im in love with it. Thanks for ur input though.
Anytime Mr.Dub hope you enjoy the pm2
Which knife has a fatter tip?
I like the blade belly on the manix better. Wish they made a manix 3 with the compression lock.
Great vid! I got my beloved Spyderco Sage 1 and looking at your vid, is it just me or does the Manix 2 slightly resembles the shape of the Sage 1? Looking at the geometry of the blade, the handle, the finger choils...look quite similar.
I love my PM2. black Blade (Diamond light coating) with digi camo handle.
Passed on both got the yojimbo 2 in s30v then was offered a deal on the same in s90v and boy what a treat these are. But since then I've picked up the manix 2 in s110v and am having a hard time adjusting to the lock system. It's not even close to the ease of use coming from the axis lock (BM) and then going the compression lock with my YJ2. I'm so torn on trying the Pm2 as it is a touch longer from the specs I've seen. Thoughts?
nice video, i had to make the choice between them and for me other than i like the look of the manix 2 better i really made my choice as a lefty the para seems more of a right handed lock release
i'm holding the same manix 2 with DLC and S30V steel,i like this knife so much i own two of them,the other is with the gray coating and is a vary hard finish that should last a life time,i also think its one of spyderco's best knifes along with there para 2,vary nive video,lots of thanks.
Thank you for not being another rambling, slow speaking knife reviewer. I'm going with the manix I think, I'm used to the axis lock so it should feel right at home.
I've never had the privilege of holding any of the PM series but I did buy a sprint run manix 2 in 2012 with cts-bd30p which is carpenters version of s30v. It also came with skeletonized liners bringing the weight down to a very acceptable 4.2 Oz. It's also 1 of the most comfortable knives I've ever held regarding the ergonomics. I do also carry a 615 mini rukus at 5.9 Oz so I'm not overly scared of the extra weight when the knife just melts into my hand as my manix 2 and mini rukus are a toss up for my most comfortable knife. I wear a large glove if this helps. Also I've been able to fondle the new Shaman and it would easily kick my manix out of my pocket in ergos if I could talk the wife into letting me buy 1.
Manix 2 translucent blue of course!
I have both knives. Guess which one's tip broke.
PM 2 tip broke
I love my para 2, wish I could get a black on black one but like my camo on black.
You seemed to favor the manix
I got the blurple manix2 with s110v steel. Id have to drag the edge across concrete 50 times before it starts to dull. But as it is similar lock release with my old benchmade I'm partial to the ball bearing lock. Strength of a lock has never come close to being an issue. If it were I'd still be carrying a back lock. But neh
people about to fight in here lol ;) Personally......FOR ME, I prefer the Manix2. I have both, and I've got both a standard and lightweight Manix2. The reason why I prefer the Manix is how it feels in hand. I can't bash either over performance because both ROCK. But as you said, it's a good thing we dont need to chose between the 2, but some people have to and all I can say to them is try to get the in hand and then you'll know. Great point for decision Scout and keep it up :d
since you like thin knives, i think you should checkout the sog slimjim. it has an extreme thin profile.
had a PM2, broke the tip off of it, took 5 weeks to get it back from spyderco, sold it. had a manix 2 xl, sold it, cause its HUGE! finally found a FFG manix 2, and awaiting on it on friday. I personally dont like the PM2 due to the blade to handle ratio. the Manix has MUCH better ergos than the PM2.
Both are tempting; BOTH are on my Wish list. To paraphrase Wayne Campbell:
"They will be mine. OH YES -- they WILL be mine."