There's no way you can write from Iran because the regime there is spying on everyone. It is not a democratic country. I would be interested to hear from Yuval Noah Harari about what is happening there, such as the cranes in the streets and the citizens who suddenly disappear, as well as what happens to those who do not wear the hijab!
Are you going to fall for this little man? Who says that he's going to transcend everything God made because God only made organic compounds when we know that the periodic table has compounds and inorganic compounds. Is he the false prophet follow Jesus Christ before it's too late.
@@seanomaille8157 for sure we both hopes for safe and free life, Justice, Peace and Equality from the river to the sea. Specifically I'm skeptical about One Nation solution (Assuming that's what you meant by "one SHARED land"). It's kind of "let's reunite Yugoslavia / Pakistan and India". Sometimes borders are really good at ending civil wars. I think that the key point for bringing everything that you and I wish for between the river and the sea, is a mutual recognition of the right of all presents to live here. If that happens, who knows, it might even be possible to live together in the same nation.
Dear Professor Harari, As a Muslim, I deeply appreciate your profound and balanced perspective on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Your ability to see and acknowledge the pain on both sides, while advocating for peace as the only viable solution, resonates strongly with me. Your wisdom and fairness are a beacon of hope in these challenging times. We need more voices like yours, from both sides, to guide us towards a future where understanding and peace prevail. Thank you for your courageous and compassionate insights. We need more Yuval's from both sides. With deep respect and gratitude.
My respect for him increased tenfold! In an era where celebrities try to appease their authorities for personal and professional gains...he stood for peace and humanity...well done sir!❤❤
As Youval mentioned, reality is not so simple. When Hamas soldiers decided (choice) to broke the fences, thousands of gazans gave up to their instincts (human nature) and went on a killing spree.
@@JosPoortvliet1/3 of the West Bank is HOME to Israelis. It is part of Israel. It is the Palestinians who are “refugees” and need to find another home, just like every person who’s ever been a refugee. It’s all a sham concocted by Haj Al Amine Husseini. Lots of things they don’t tel you about reality.
From an Iranian-Canadian: In a world overshadowed by the likes of Netanyahu, Putin, and Khamenei, the luminous voices of our era's greatest minds, like Yuval Noah Harari, remain unheard. We are graced to live in the time of Yuval, a beacon of wisdom amidst the darkness.
@Georgio476 I'm from Israel. I looked for some sanity during these crazy days, and this is why I came here to listen to the wise words of Yuval Noah Harari. I really can't understand the 'pagers attack' that Israel carried out in Lebanon during the last few days. Instead of deescalation and diplomacy - some leaders look for escalation and war. it is madness! it will bring more death, more destruction, and at the end we will find ourselves in the exact same point ... Man, I wish peace for your country and for mine, even though it seems far far away.
This is how I understand our history of humanity, with humility and acceptance. As a contemporary man, I appreciate your words of peace. It is my wish that both peoples embrace each other as brothers, since at the end of the day that is what we all are, and sometimes we forget it. Shalom.
I pray that your speech resonates in the minds of all those struggling in fear. I pray that the seed of anger, resentment and intolerance is overcome. Thank you Yuval for your heartfelt and wise speech. 🙏🕊️❤
I doubt Palestinians would hate Israel if there was no aparthide and injustice. But I thank you. I hope you continue to bridge the gap towards a real solution for all humans in Palestine or Israel
What you say is demonstrably true. Palestinians living inside Israel (not the occupied territories and not the divided Jerusalem) who are given the most rights and freedoms do not hate Israel. Hamas would weaken and eventually be destroyed by Palestinians and Israelis together if Palestinians simply had the rights and freedoms they deserve. To do this as peacefully as possible would require collaboration with neutral third parties. To embrace peace, Israelis must be willing to give Palestinians rights and must be willing to acknowledge that working with Palestinians to establish trust will take many years, and Palestinians must learn to accept Israel's existence in spite of the horror Israel has inflicted upon them. Israel must acknowledge that Palestinians are mostly not Hamas, and that their violence against Palestinians broadly is not just, and is far too extreme and abhorrent, and it must not continue or be repeated. Obviously there have been poor relations throughout history, but that does not have to be the future. As Yuval has said, Germans are now at peace with Israelis and Jewish people, after slaughtering 6 million Jewish people. The past does not dictate the future.
As a Muslim, I find Professor Yuval Noah Harari truly impressive! Your ability to explain complex topics such as history, philosophy, and current conflicts in an understandable and balanced way makes you an inspiring voice in our time. Your views provoke thought and help to better understand different perspectives. You are a great human being.
As a Brazilian, Arabic immigrant family, I witnessed how our Jewish community was always helpful and kind with my family. I grew up admiring, being a friend and having usual contacts with Jewish people in Brazil and abroad, feeling their spirit, kindness, honesty and intelligence. These words, almost forgotten by the threats we live Today, present the only way to avoid useless violence. Peace!
From the profound, sincere and purest core of my heart I thank you for your love and respect for every living being, aswell as the words of peace you speak on behalf of humanity 🕊🙏❤
I have been waiting to hear Yuval's take on what's going on and I am very impressed by his wisdom. I really can relate to what a small mind does, not wishing to contain certain facts, it then disposes of them. This is what I experience all around me. Thank you Yuval, you have made things clearer to me.
From Canada: prayers that people on both sides of the conflict can find their way to trust, forgiveness and peace. Thank you Yuval for your inspirational words.
When there will also be a Palestinian intellectual, giving similar speech in Arabic, inside Palestinian territory, and will survive as a free person, there will be peace.
Palistinians intelctual wrote books about peace possibilities 😂😂😂😂 Yuval is such a liar in the begining of the war he suugests to use neuclear weapon and he denies all the palestinian suffering
Over 10 years ago, I took your history course (The Brief History of Humankind) on-line (I was one of the first student group there, because I remember so eagerly waiting for the arrival of the English version of the Sapiens book) and ever since my husband and I have been a big fan and have read all your books to date. I am really so thrilled to see you giving this great speech with such delicate care and consideration to the Israeli general public. I sincerely hope they get it. Our very best wishes to you sir, Prof. Harari, and peace for all of us in this world. All of us share the same origin on this earth, as you taught us. Many many, many many thanks!!!!!!!!
War is always a choice & you can always choose differently! War is always a response to despair. May peace & hope come finally to the Middle East. Yuval Noah Harari, you are an amazing human being. I‘m deeply in love with you. Much love from Kurdistan❤
I listen to several intellectuals but Yuval Noah Harari is my favorite. His knowledge, intelligence, eloquence, compassion and desire to make the world a better place is incredible, and inspires me to be a better person. Thank you!
May ALL beings everywhere be happy and free from suffering and may my thoughts, words and actions contribute in some way to that happiness and freedom for ALL. ☮️🕉️
Each and every word should be written in golden words and should be taught in every educational and learning institutions in the whole world. FROM your teachings Sir ,I HOPE that One Day will be free from all wars, all hatreds and just prevail peace and love. Keep EDUCATING THE WHOLE WORLD SIR 🙏 LOVE FROM PAKISTAN FOR YUVAL NOAH HARARI 🙏❤🙏
Dear Yuval Noah Harari, Today you spoke in the name of humanity and world peace, in the name of everyone and not of any nation, religion or ideology. You spoke in the name of love, of serenity to all human beings. Thank you for being a human
Thank you, Yuval, for speaking of peace and reminding us of our human potential! In its infinite wisdom, the Universe, from time to time, sends us Jesus, Buddha, Gandhi, Mandela, and Yuval...
At this time of massacre it’s very difficult to hear Israel’s name without feeling angry. I lived stateless and our family home was taken from us, I’ve never seen Palestine and foreigners to the land have lived there with ease.. i know the solution is not war.. there needs to be rational voices within Israeli communities that call for peace. Peace where justice is served for the criminals and where eveyone has equal rights. With the current indoctrination I see by Israeli educational system, I feel new generations will not think about peace..although any rational person can know it’s the only way out
As a Lebanese, we've grown accustomed to living with many different groups that once wanted to do harm to each other, I see no difference with the Palestinian and Jewish people. I have nothing but love for Jewish or any other people, but I do wish Israelis push for an permanent end to the war, as what is currently happening is unbearable. I know it's easier said then done, most Arabs don't even have the luxury of choosing our leaders. Also, I never read any of his books, which one do you suggest I start with?
I suggest that Yuval be invited ASAP to give this speech again in English, and broadcast this speech far and wide in both languages. More people worldwide need to hear it.
I'm gonna read these subtitles cause that's how much I love Yuval Noah Harari. He's been doing the right thing for a long time. He took a lot of criticism for not being loud enough for one cause or another, but he was always clear that he supported the rights of Palestinians and Israelis. This guy is so level-headed and brilliant, and I wish he could get the full support of the Israeli people (and Americans) to follow his lead. I just learned about Yuval over a year ago and became an ardent admirer. With love from the U.S.A. I'm not Jewish, I'm not Muslim, I'm born into a Christian family, but I don't follow any religious dogmas. Yuval uplifts and enlightens all people with dignity and courage, and for that I love him. ❤❤❤
@@centaur7607 thank you so far yes. We need someone to put an end to this. The global consciousness is suffering now and my only condolence is that the children will become the sacrifice that would bring a global change towards peace and equality.
Yuval! Thank you!! You are so brave. It's so sad that one must be brave to speak what is nothing more than reality. There is nothing to interpret in reality. May I be as brave as you. You are a role model.
Sir! Every time, I say (write) "Free Palestine 🇵🇸 from the River to the Sea". But, now here, I can't say due to my respect for you. Love you from Pakistan 🇵🇰 ♥
יש חשיבות גדולה לשאלה מי התחיל, יש חשיבות גדולה לשאלה מי ממשיך , יש חשיבות גדולה לשאלה מי מעוניין בתהליך שלום אין כאן שניים שווים אין שיווין. בשביל שלום צריך שניים בשביל מלחמה צריך רק צד אחד שרוצה בכך . שיווין הוא אשליה בסוגיה הישראלית פלסטינית.
יובל אני אוהב אותך, קשה לי להעביר עליך את הביקורת הזו. הלב שלך במקום הנכון אבל השכל שלך אינו תואם את המציאות. אפילו לאחר שנים של מדיטציה אתה חיי בעולם מדומיין שעושה השלכה על אחרים, במקום לגלות ולהבין איך האחר שונה ממך. איפה הקולות המקבילים אצל האחר? אתה לא עושה שלום עם Biff Tannen באמצעות חיבוק ושיחה, השלום (הזמני) מגיע לאחר שהוא מובס עפ הסטנדרטים שלו, לא שלך. זו דרכו של הטבע.
If there were more like Yuval in the world, there were no wars. This is the spirituality we all should strive to. The question is only how to transform it into action? And we cannot do it unilaterally! (We already tried couple of times and know how it ends …). I hope one day there will be enough people on the other side, who will think this way. Only then real peace could come.
Could you please, bring this historic video in English? Try to read but its to fast to flow. I hope one day you be the leader of the humanity and bring peace and harmony to the world 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
This gives me hope for humanity! "War is the attempt by small minds to eradicate the complexity of reality" = brilliant observation. It is because of our upbringing, education, emotions, feelings, values, beliefs that we humans are not capable of observing the whole. This limits human prosperity by limiting our scientific endeavours and limiting peace. Human thinking is the root of our problems.
The problem is, that Israel is rich and powerful. Palestine is poor and isn't supported by others, and by being kept poor, dependent and poorly fed and educated, the playing field is not level. In the face of all this, they are resilient and refuse to go away.
Anything you can dream of you can create if you want it badly enough and are willing to work for it. Before humans went to the moon or invented the internet small minds would have said “it is just a dream”. To create peace, humans need to work on expanding their small minds!❤
מטרה הנאום השראה. אני מניח ששנינו נסכים שאי אפשר לעשות הסכם שלום שיש לו איזושהי משמעות מול חמאס של שנת 2023. זה עדיין מעורר אצלי מחשבות. אני תוהה אם תגובת העולם הייתה שונה והתמיכה בישראל רחבה יותר אם המסרים שהממשלה הייתה משמיעה היו כאלו שמכירים ברצון לחיים משותפים בעתיד בטוח יותר לצד הפלסטינים, ולא עוד ועוד אמירות שמומחים מגדירים כ"פיגוע תדמיתי" על "וואי וואי איך צריך להיכנס בהם" - הרבה פעמים אמירות שגם הן תאורטיות בלבד והרבה מהן אי אפשר ליישם באופן בו הן נאמרות.
May peace be upon Israeli n Palestinian. You guys must learn from Indonesia. We have 17.000.000 islands, more than 700 ethnic, speaking more than 700 lunggages, practice more than 6 religions but we are united in our difference. Once we were broke out by the Dutch, English n Portuguese but we are reunited against the colonialist and stay as The Republic of Indonesia....come to Bali and see all this harmony and stop war in Gaza to kill each others
Well Sir, you have spoken up bravely and politely. Your words have the wisdom of a famous german poet named Lessing. All the best to you and your family!
Incredible clarity and incredibly moving speech and message from Yuval Noah Harari. Thank you for this, Yuval. The region, and the world, need this so much. - Benjamin
@@IrfanShaikh-y3s This is false. Look at post WW2 Japan. There was no retribution, no justice, but there was rebuilding. It's the same with almost every war.
Harari’s reduction of history to simple narratives downplays concrete facts and legitimizes fact-free discussions on social media. This promotes Western relativism, which is not shared by most of the non-Western world.
1 thessalonians 4: 16-18 For the Lord himself will come down from heaven, with a loud command, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet call of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. After that, we who are still alive and are left will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air. And so we will be with the Lord forever. Therefore encourage one another with these words. 2 Thessalonians 2: 11,12 For this reason God sends them a powerful delusion so that they will believe the lie and so that all will be condemned who have not believed the truth but have delighted in wickedness 1 corinthians 15: 1-5 the gospel,that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures.
Dear Yuval and team, thank you so much for this wonderful speech. I would like to write French subtitles for it, would you allow me to add them on your channel? Thank you again so much 🙏🏼 With gratitude, Brice
Gratitude! for those who stayed behind and need help. Peace to those who departed. Gratitude for so many of us, all over the world, who inevitably also suffer helplessly in the face of such uncontrolled fury. May Peace, Joy and Bread come. Thank you very much Yuval.
מילים יפות, אך לצערי הרב ללא כיסוי של ממש. לעשות שוב את מה שכבר ניסינו? הרי זו טיפשות. אי אפשר לעשות 2 ניסוים ולקבל תוצאה שונה. עד שמישהו יגיע עם נוסחה שונה מ-2 מדינות, לא יהיה שום שלום.
Yuval says (rhetorically) "Is there anyone in this Land [...] who doesn't want to love and be loved?" The audience member shouts out "the family of Netanyahu!" Yuval says "Even them too."
John 14:6 Jesus said to him, "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me. 1 Corinthians 15:3 that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He rose again the third day according to the Scriptures. Romans 10:9 that if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.
הבעיה היא שיובל שקוע בתוך תיאוריות של "האיזון הקדוש" (או שאולי הוא פשוט רוצה שיקנו את הספרים שלו 😊) ולא מבין (או לא רוצה להבין) מה שכל חמום מוח בלה פמיליה הבין מזמן.
Thank you. After so much anger and frustration for my sense of ineptitude and impotence in seeing so much grief, a grif that can travel thousands of kilometers away and hit the soul of even those who have only seen or known about it, I was finally able to let the tears flow, in the comfort of at least a hope. The hope in Humanity that God created with Love and that I know still exists and that takes concrete form in the invitations to PEACE... because Peace is Reality... while war is madness, it is paranoia, it is the renunciation of bearing fruit during our brief and precious opportunity of passage. And I will imprint that packed, applauding audience that listened to you in my memory for the moments of doubt🌈
Yuval, can I share an amazing story with you? One day I was driving home, when all of a sudden the Lord came to me in spirit. I felt very close to Him. I knew if I asked him to play any song on the radio he would, I guess to bless my faith. So I said "ok, Lord play "Come as you are by Nirvana". I turned on the radio and the song started playing right there on the spot, perfectly… I started getting flooded with chills like a waterfall, crying, and trembling. He stayed with me for 10 minutes in my driveway. until I got outta the car. A couple months after that I started getting amazing prayers answered way more often, because it helped me quit doubting when I pray and I was lined up with biblical instructions. It's 6 years later and I still get answered prayers in Jesus name.
You are ignoring all the times you can't get the radio to play Nirvana, or whatever you want, and focusing on the very few times when you can. It's called motivated reasoning and confirmation bias. You're ignoring all the evidence that doesn't support your hypothesis/belief, and only focusing on that which does. You are believing only because you want to, because it makes you happy. However, many of us are happy without your beliefs.
Umm al-Rashrash is a Palestinian land that was under Jordanian administration. Before the Jordanian administration, it was under Ottoman sovereignty and joined the southern Levant. Then Israel took it from Jordan in the 1948 war, after which Jordan abandoned the administration of Umm al-Rashrash and the West Bank in the Wadi Araba Agreement of 1994.
Thank you, thank you mister Yuval Harari!...the world needs you and others like you.. For the sake of humanity, for the sake of our aching planet hearth..... Keep on spreading the message of peace, based on history and explaing all the narratives ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
From iran I wish peace and dignity for everyone.
Thank you for your impressive speech.
There's no way you can write from Iran because the regime there is spying on everyone. It is not a democratic country. I would be interested to hear from Yuval Noah Harari about what is happening there, such as the cranes in the streets and the citizens who suddenly disappear, as well as what happens to those who do not wear the hijab!
From the river to the sea, one SHARED land safe and free. Justice . Peace. Equality. Shalom. Salaam. Síocháin.
@@seanomaille8157 Israel forever.
❤❤❤
Are you going to fall for this little man? Who says that he's going to transcend everything God made because God only made organic compounds when we know that the periodic table has compounds and inorganic compounds. Is he the false prophet follow Jesus Christ before it's too late.
From Egypt 🇪🇬
Thanks Yuval for this powerful speech 🕊
Thanks to all the heroes of Peace out there 🕊☮
Salam xx
Kudos to the brave voices from Egypt, Israel and the whole world, who call for more peace and not more hatred. Sending you much love from Israel.
From the river to the sea, one SHARED land safe and free. Justice . Peace. Equality. Shalom. Salaam. Síocháin.
From Mexico, Yuval, thanks for giving us wide hope within this narrow minded humanity
@@seanomaille8157 for sure we both hopes for safe and free life, Justice, Peace and Equality from the river to the sea. Specifically I'm skeptical about One Nation solution (Assuming that's what you meant by "one SHARED land"). It's kind of "let's reunite Yugoslavia / Pakistan and India". Sometimes borders are really good at ending civil wars. I think that the key point for bringing everything that you and I wish for between the river and the sea, is a mutual recognition of the right of all presents to live here. If that happens, who knows, it might even be possible to live together in the same nation.
Dear Professor Harari,
As a Muslim, I deeply appreciate your profound and balanced perspective on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Your ability to see and acknowledge the pain on both sides, while advocating for peace as the only viable solution, resonates strongly with me. Your wisdom and fairness are a beacon of hope in these challenging times. We need more voices like yours, from both sides, to guide us towards a future where understanding and peace prevail. Thank you for your courageous and compassionate insights.
We need more Yuval's from both sides.
With deep respect and gratitude.
❤
My respect for him increased tenfold! In an era where celebrities try to appease their authorities for personal and professional gains...he stood for peace and humanity...well done sir!❤❤
“War is not a law of nature it is a human choice” excellent
As Youval mentioned, reality is not so simple. When Hamas soldiers decided (choice) to broke the fences, thousands of gazans gave up to their instincts (human nature) and went on a killing spree.
@@georgepetrica567 You-just-don't- get -it, do-you.......get off the hamster wheel, rodent.
@@georgepetrica567yes, as he points out - many small minds. Just what fuels all the settlers violence in the West Bank.
Let no one DECEIVE you
@@JosPoortvliet1/3 of the West Bank is HOME to Israelis. It is part of Israel. It is the Palestinians who are “refugees” and need to find another home, just like every person who’s ever been a refugee.
It’s all a sham concocted by Haj Al Amine Husseini. Lots of things they don’t tel you about reality.
From Canada: Words of wisdom from one of your most brilliant sons. Listen to him, follow his words and make PEACE for ALL.
From an Iranian-Canadian:
In a world overshadowed by the likes of Netanyahu, Putin, and Khamenei, the luminous voices of our era's greatest minds, like Yuval Noah Harari, remain unheard. We are graced to live in the time of Yuval, a beacon of wisdom amidst the darkness.
I’m Egyptian American, I would vote for Uval to be the president of the US and the whole Middle East.
You are an Iranian bot.
me too. kudos to the brave voices who call for more peace and not more hatred.
Iranian Canadian here;
I would vote for him to be the world's president.
@@yousef2508 I agree with you - I would vote for him.But he's to smart to wish to become a politician....
Even though he's gay?
As a Lebanese, I agree heart and soul with every single word said.
@Georgio476 I'm from Israel. I looked for some sanity during these crazy days, and this is why I came here to listen to the wise words of Yuval Noah Harari.
I really can't understand the 'pagers attack' that Israel carried out in Lebanon during the last few days. Instead of deescalation and diplomacy - some leaders look for escalation and war. it is madness! it will bring more death, more destruction, and at the end we will find ourselves in the exact same point ... Man, I wish peace for your country and for mine, even though it seems far far away.
This is how I understand our history of humanity, with humility and acceptance. As a contemporary man, I appreciate your words of peace. It is my wish that both peoples embrace each other as brothers, since at the end of the day that is what we all are, and sometimes we forget it. Shalom.
Mad respect for this man who speaks truth and is awakened!
God bless you
This man wants your brain controlled by the global "elites." He is a snake, and nothing more.
It all started because of god. Leave the god away from this.
He doesn't believe in God and often speaks against it. He also has the opinion that people who believe in God are stupid.
@@Migenatube this man views people as hackable machines.
@@mikususins1767I think that’s probably not exactly what he believes. Considering most of the people he is appealing to, believe in God.
From the river to the sea, one SHARED land safe and free. Justice . Peace. Equality. Shalom. Salaam. Síocháin.
❤
This is the best speech I’ve heard on the issue- thank you for using your position to stand up for humanity, Yuval! A rare gem in these times
I wish with all my heart that people would listen to this man!
❤ me too
I pray that your speech resonates in the minds of all those struggling in fear. I pray that the seed of anger, resentment and intolerance is overcome. Thank you Yuval for your heartfelt and wise speech. 🙏🕊️❤
Love from Pakistan sir.
You're making the real efforts towards peace, awareness and history.
Respect❤
I doubt Palestinians would hate Israel if there was no aparthide and injustice.
But I thank you. I hope you continue to bridge the gap towards a real solution for all humans in Palestine or Israel
That's because you have no clue and are ignorant of history, get your news from Al Jazeera and never spoken to a Palestinian in your life.
Palestinians have hated jews before there was even a state of israel, let alone apartheid.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amin_al-Husseini
@@elimelechschreiber6937
The opposite. I think jews in Arab countries had the least amount of discrimination before Israel.
@@elimelechschreiber6937 And yet they co-existed in Palestine, unlike now. Wouldn't an alien watching from a far, make the exact opposite conclusion?
What you say is demonstrably true. Palestinians living inside Israel (not the occupied territories and not the divided Jerusalem) who are given the most rights and freedoms do not hate Israel. Hamas would weaken and eventually be destroyed by Palestinians and Israelis together if Palestinians simply had the rights and freedoms they deserve. To do this as peacefully as possible would require collaboration with neutral third parties. To embrace peace, Israelis must be willing to give Palestinians rights and must be willing to acknowledge that working with Palestinians to establish trust will take many years, and Palestinians must learn to accept Israel's existence in spite of the horror Israel has inflicted upon them. Israel must acknowledge that Palestinians are mostly not Hamas, and that their violence against Palestinians broadly is not just, and is far too extreme and abhorrent, and it must not continue or be repeated. Obviously there have been poor relations throughout history, but that does not have to be the future. As Yuval has said, Germans are now at peace with Israelis and Jewish people, after slaughtering 6 million Jewish people. The past does not dictate the future.
I adore you, who ever have healthy mind &spirit , will listen and respect your opinion.from Canada.
May peace be always with you Yuval Harari!
Yep ! SHALOM !
As a Muslim, I find Professor Yuval Noah Harari truly impressive! Your ability to explain complex topics such as history, philosophy, and current conflicts in an understandable and balanced way makes you an inspiring voice in our time. Your views provoke thought and help to better understand different perspectives. You are a great human being.
❤ truth
As a Brazilian, Arabic immigrant family, I witnessed how our Jewish community was always helpful and kind with my family. I grew up admiring, being a friend and having usual contacts with Jewish people in Brazil and abroad, feeling their spirit, kindness, honesty and intelligence. These words, almost forgotten by the threats we live Today, present the only way to avoid useless violence. Peace!
Thank you for sharing your perspective ❤
You are a great person Yuval,keep fighting for peace.Greetings from Cuba.
From the profound, sincere and purest core of my heart I thank you for your love and respect for every living being, aswell as the words of peace you speak on behalf of humanity 🕊🙏❤
כל הכבוד יובל אם יש יותר אנשים כמוך העולם הכל היו חיים בשלום
In which language?
I've never seen it before.
@@seiji9710Hebrew
@@jechidanl Thank you.
From Portugal and the world thank you for your amazing speech. Please let this inspire a people
Thank you Yuval you're the light of humanity. Thanking for being so brave to take a political stance for peace, humanity, dignity and love.
I have been waiting to hear Yuval's take on what's going on and I am very impressed by his wisdom. I really can relate to what a small mind does, not wishing to contain certain facts, it then disposes of them. This is what I experience all around me. Thank you Yuval, you have made things clearer to me.
Thank you Yuval for the great speech that enlightens my small mind... I am trying to make it bigger
This video deserves a million views
Thank you Yuval Harari! The truth has been spoken. May there be PEACE always! Love & Peace!❤☮
May all children be allowed life, liberty, and prosperity
@@ChrisGuerra31 You better have NO offspring in these Armageddon end time . . .
From Canada: prayers that people on both sides of the conflict can find their way to trust, forgiveness and peace. Thank you Yuval for your inspirational words.
May we see Peace in our bloody region
An Atheist wisdom for such religious wars. Peace for all.
Atheists are the least biased among all.
Yuval is gift for the world. ❤
Theodore Herzl founder of Zionism who created all this mess was an atheist.
I only understood one word without the subtitles, "Shalom."
We all want Shalom Salam Peace. 🕊
Toda
I wish that was true.
Try again - now there are subtitles in Arabic and English 😊
The translation is not exact on some cases. No big issues but it sometimes simplifies the message
When there will also be a Palestinian intellectual, giving similar speech in Arabic, inside Palestinian territory, and will survive as a free person, there will be peace.
Palistinians intelctual wrote books about peace possibilities 😂😂😂😂
Yuval is such a liar in the begining of the war he suugests to use neuclear weapon and he denies all the palestinian suffering
@@abdalluhhasanat1185lol. Why do people who are so ignorant exist?
😊@@abdalluhhasanat1185
Don't hold your breath.
@@abdalluhhasanat1185i think you mixed him with someone else
Over 10 years ago, I took your history course (The Brief History of Humankind) on-line (I was one of the first student group there, because I remember so eagerly waiting for the arrival of the English version of the Sapiens book) and ever since my husband and I have been a big fan and have read all your books to date. I am really so thrilled to see you giving this great speech with such delicate care and consideration to the Israeli general public. I sincerely hope they get it.
Our very best wishes to you sir, Prof. Harari, and peace for all of us in this world. All of us share the same origin on this earth, as you taught us.
Many many, many many thanks!!!!!!!!
War is always a choice & you can always choose differently! War is always a response to despair. May peace & hope come finally to the Middle East.
Yuval Noah Harari, you are an amazing human being. I‘m deeply in love with you. Much love from Kurdistan❤
Thank you
From Jordan
Harari is one of the few sane voices in this insane world.
😂😂😂
Oh you poor little lamb! If you only knew about his evil agenda against humanity 😬
What agenda?
@@Marianne52413
I listen to several intellectuals but Yuval Noah Harari is my favorite. His knowledge, intelligence, eloquence, compassion and desire to make the world a better place is incredible, and inspires me to be a better person. Thank you!
Great ! Since most of folks think he is "evil" . . . (may be a big projection !)
May ALL beings everywhere be happy and free from suffering and may my thoughts, words and actions contribute in some way to that happiness and freedom for ALL. ☮️🕉️
Are you vegan? You wrote ALL beings, so I assume you are.
Each and every word should be written in golden words and should be taught in every educational and learning institutions in the whole world. FROM your teachings Sir ,I HOPE that One Day will be free from all wars, all hatreds and just prevail peace and love. Keep EDUCATING THE WHOLE WORLD SIR 🙏
LOVE FROM PAKISTAN FOR YUVAL NOAH HARARI
🙏❤🙏
Should we also teach his vegan values?
@@vivianchinelli8797 Are u trying to start a war? lol
Dear Yuval Noah Harari,
Today you spoke in the name of humanity and world peace, in the name of everyone and not of any nation, religion or ideology. You spoke in the name of love, of serenity to all human beings.
Thank you for being a human
Thank you, Yuval, for speaking of peace and reminding us of our human potential! In its infinite wisdom, the Universe, from time to time, sends us Jesus, Buddha, Gandhi, Mandela, and Yuval...
I support every step for peace from Syria 🇸🇾
I love Yuval, and this speech. Is there anyone from the other side of the conflict extending good will to Israel and Jewish people?
Words of wisdom I once heard: Don't 'hope' that your spouse treats you well, inspire them to.
Yes you are very right. But you didn't answer the question....
At this time of massacre it’s very difficult to hear Israel’s name without feeling angry. I lived stateless and our family home was taken from us, I’ve never seen Palestine and foreigners to the land have lived there with ease.. i know the solution is not war.. there needs to be rational voices within Israeli communities that call for peace. Peace where justice is served for the criminals and where eveyone has equal rights. With the current indoctrination I see by Israeli educational system, I feel new generations will not think about peace..although any rational person can know it’s the only way out
Having that said I have 0 hate towards Jewish ppl and don’t care what someone’s religion is
As a Lebanese, we've grown accustomed to living with many different groups that once wanted to do harm to each other, I see no difference with the Palestinian and Jewish people. I have nothing but love for Jewish or any other people, but I do wish Israelis push for an permanent end to the war, as what is currently happening is unbearable. I know it's easier said then done, most Arabs don't even have the luxury of choosing our leaders. Also, I never read any of his books, which one do you suggest I start with?
Important speech! Kudos to @yuvalnoahharari and to the organizers. Please continue your peace efforts in these dire times.
From India/Qatar
Want peace among the human beings around the world.
I suggest that Yuval be invited ASAP to give this speech again in English, and broadcast this speech far and wide in both languages. More people worldwide need to hear it.
Word on *this*❣️
You are a great thinker and fair minded person as humanely possible, I appreciate living at the same era with human being like you.
One of the best speeches I have ever heard!
Word on *this*❣️
I'm gonna read these subtitles cause that's how much I love Yuval Noah Harari. He's been doing the right thing for a long time. He took a lot of criticism for not being loud enough for one cause or another, but he was always clear that he supported the rights of Palestinians and Israelis. This guy is so level-headed and brilliant, and I wish he could get the full support of the Israeli people (and Americans) to follow his lead. I just learned about Yuval over a year ago and became an ardent admirer. With love from the U.S.A. I'm not Jewish, I'm not Muslim, I'm born into a Christian family, but I don't follow any religious dogmas. Yuval uplifts and enlightens all people with dignity and courage, and for that I love him. ❤❤❤
Thank you from Palestine. Yes Yes and yes
I hope you are safe ❤❤❤
@@centaur7607 thank you so far yes. We need someone to put an end to this. The global consciousness is suffering now and my only condolence is that the children will become the sacrifice that would bring a global change towards peace and equality.
@@trisaritups3509 I hope there will be a permanent ceasefire soon, and the violence and suffering will end. Stay safe! ❤️
@@centaur7607 ❤️🙏
His mission in life is to show humanity the real reason why we as humans are in this planet.
Thank you, Yuval.
Thanks Sir! It's the finest appeal for peace. Hope both sides will understand & accept reality.❤
Peace peace &Peace 🙏 from Belgium 🇧🇪
I have so much respect for the wisdom and guidance of Prof Harrari.
Yuval! Thank you!! You are so brave. It's so sad that one must be brave to speak what is nothing more than reality. There is nothing to interpret in reality. May I be as brave as you. You are a role model.
Sir! Every time, I say (write) "Free Palestine 🇵🇸 from the River to the Sea". But, now here, I can't say due to my respect for you.
Love you from Pakistan 🇵🇰 ♥
❤🇮🇳
His new Book is coming.
יש חשיבות גדולה לשאלה מי התחיל, יש חשיבות גדולה לשאלה מי ממשיך ,
יש חשיבות גדולה לשאלה מי מעוניין בתהליך שלום
אין כאן שניים שווים
אין שיווין.
בשביל שלום צריך שניים בשביל מלחמה צריך רק צד אחד שרוצה בכך .
שיווין הוא אשליה בסוגיה הישראלית פלסטינית.
Once you change enough minds, and everyone stops saying "it can't change, both sides will never want peace" then you'll have peace.
Peace to all on earth! Excellent message by Yuval!
Thank you Yuval for being human and a critical thinker whose long can contain peace for nothing sides.
Excellent! Thank you, Mr. Harari, for your wise and realistic words. #givepeaceachance ❤
Human created religions. Religions doesn’t created humans. Peace & love everybody likes, but when he is in groups he gets blind.
יובל אני אוהב אותך, קשה לי להעביר עליך את הביקורת הזו. הלב שלך במקום הנכון אבל השכל שלך אינו תואם את המציאות. אפילו לאחר שנים של מדיטציה אתה חיי בעולם מדומיין שעושה השלכה על אחרים, במקום לגלות ולהבין איך האחר שונה ממך. איפה הקולות המקבילים אצל האחר? אתה לא עושה שלום עם Biff Tannen באמצעות חיבוק ושיחה, השלום (הזמני) מגיע לאחר שהוא מובס עפ הסטנדרטים שלו, לא שלך. זו דרכו של הטבע.
Thank you from Prague!!
If there were more like Yuval in the world, there were no wars. This is the spirituality we all should strive to. The question is only how to transform it into action? And we cannot do it unilaterally! (We already tried couple of times and know how it ends …). I hope one day there will be enough people on the other side, who will think this way. Only then real peace could come.
Words of wisdom I once heard: Don't 'hope' that your spouse treats you well, inspire them to.
❤❤❤
Could you please, bring this historic video in English?
Try to read but its to fast to flow.
I hope one day you be the leader of the humanity and bring peace and harmony to the world 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
I would love an English transcript for this piece of wisdom, thank you Yuval
This gives me hope for humanity! "War is the attempt by small minds to eradicate the complexity of reality" = brilliant observation. It is because of our upbringing, education, emotions, feelings, values, beliefs that we humans are not capable of observing the whole. This limits human prosperity by limiting our scientific endeavours and limiting peace. Human thinking is the root of our problems.
Well put
The problem is, that Israel is rich and powerful. Palestine is poor and isn't supported by others, and by being kept poor, dependent and poorly fed and educated, the playing field is not level.
In the face of all this, they are resilient and refuse to go away.
נאום תאורטי ... זה מה שאפשר לחלום, המציאות היא שונה
Anything you can dream of you can create if you want it badly enough and are willing to work for it. Before humans went to the moon or invented the internet small minds would have said “it is just a dream”. To create peace, humans need to work on expanding their small minds!❤
"You only s p e a k about LOVE if you have lost it . . . and about peace too !" (unknown guy)
מטרה הנאום השראה. אני מניח ששנינו נסכים שאי אפשר לעשות הסכם שלום שיש לו איזושהי משמעות מול חמאס של שנת 2023. זה עדיין מעורר אצלי מחשבות. אני תוהה אם תגובת העולם הייתה שונה והתמיכה בישראל רחבה יותר אם המסרים שהממשלה הייתה משמיעה היו כאלו שמכירים ברצון לחיים משותפים בעתיד בטוח יותר לצד הפלסטינים, ולא עוד ועוד אמירות שמומחים מגדירים כ"פיגוע תדמיתי" על "וואי וואי איך צריך להיכנס בהם" - הרבה פעמים אמירות שגם הן תאורטיות בלבד והרבה מהן אי אפשר ליישם באופן בו הן נאמרות.
May peace be upon Israeli n Palestinian. You guys must learn from Indonesia. We have 17.000.000 islands, more than 700 ethnic, speaking more than 700 lunggages, practice more than 6 religions but we are united in our difference. Once we were broke out by the Dutch, English n Portuguese but we are reunited against the colonialist and stay as The Republic of Indonesia....come to Bali and see all this harmony and stop war in Gaza to kill each others
Maybe it' s easier to have many ethnic or religious groups than just two.
@@mgpmul there actually is more than 2 in Palestine... everyone keeps forgetting the christians in the region XD
Hmm, not so fast. Indonesia invaded Malukku, Timor, Guinea, etc.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_Indonesia
Well Sir, you have spoken up bravely and politely. Your words have the wisdom of a famous german poet named Lessing. All the best to you and your family!
I pray form this very, very influential man, to keep changing his mind towards the right direction.
Incredible clarity and incredibly moving speech and message from Yuval Noah Harari. Thank you for this, Yuval. The region, and the world, need this so much. - Benjamin
Justice is tye Prerequisite for peace. There will be no peace until justice is served.
No, that's utterly false. There is almost never justice before peace, throughout history. Justice is the enemy of peace.
@user-wd2mt6ok2i. ... and how will this justice look like? what do you think should happen?
@@IrfanShaikh-y3s This is false. Look at post WW2 Japan. There was no retribution, no justice, but there was rebuilding. It's the same with almost every war.
Totally agreed. The problem is when this unifying discourse is only this widespread among one side of the involved parts.
Harari’s reduction of history to simple narratives downplays concrete facts and legitimizes fact-free discussions on social media. This promotes Western relativism, which is not shared by most of the non-Western world.
1 thessalonians 4: 16-18
For the Lord himself will come down from heaven, with a loud command, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet call of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. After that, we who are still alive and are left will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air. And so we will be with the Lord forever. Therefore encourage one another with these words.
2 Thessalonians 2: 11,12
For this reason God sends them a powerful delusion so that they will believe the lie and so that all will be condemned who have not believed the truth but have delighted in wickedness
1 corinthians 15: 1-5
the gospel,that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures.
God won't fix this nightmare because he doesn't exist. Why don't you start caring about people's lives who live somewhere other than where you live?
Dear Yuval and team, thank you so much for this wonderful speech. I would like to write French subtitles for it, would you allow me to add them on your channel?
Thank you again so much 🙏🏼
With gratitude,
Brice
יובל אתה מדהים, בין היחידים שעוד משמרים אצלי תקווה בלב ❤
🇵🇸❤🇮🇱
I wish the leaders of the wars and their supporters had 10% of your wisdom.
Good heart and great mind!
Gratitude! for those who stayed behind and need help. Peace to those who departed. Gratitude for so many of us, all over the world, who inevitably also suffer helplessly in the face of such uncontrolled fury. May Peace, Joy and Bread come.
Thank you very much Yuval.
מילים יפות, אך לצערי הרב ללא כיסוי של ממש. לעשות שוב את מה שכבר ניסינו? הרי זו טיפשות. אי אפשר לעשות 2 ניסוים ולקבל תוצאה שונה. עד שמישהו יגיע עם נוסחה שונה מ-2 מדינות, לא יהיה שום שלום.
Can anyone translate what's going on at 6:55? Wonderful speech by the way.
Yuval says (rhetorically) "Is there anyone in this Land [...] who doesn't want to love and be loved?" The audience member shouts out "the family of Netanyahu!" Yuval says "Even them too."
Thank so much for clarifying this.
"it is hard to squeeze a lot of reality into a little mind" Hear, hear!
כולי תקווה שנזכה ליום הזה של שלום ואחדות בין העמים
It is what a real thinker says👏👏
Can you imagine the Palestinians having such a speech???? And that's the problem.
John 14:6 Jesus said to him, "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.
1 Corinthians 15:3 that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He rose again the third day according to the Scriptures.
Romans 10:9 that if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.
"War isn't a law of nature. It is a human choice."
יש בעיה, לא כולם רוצים שלום. יש לא מעט אנשי מלחמה, הם לא יכולים בלי מלחמה... יש אנשים דתיים, והם מצדיקים מלחמה...
This is ignored by Yuval. I’m ashamed ever to have bought his books. Jews are often the worst antisemites! 😖
הבעיה היא שיובל שקוע בתוך תיאוריות של "האיזון הקדוש" (או שאולי הוא פשוט רוצה שיקנו את הספרים שלו 😊) ולא מבין (או לא רוצה להבין) מה שכל חמום מוח בלה פמיליה הבין מזמן.
Thank you. After so much anger and frustration for my sense of ineptitude and impotence in seeing so much grief, a grif that can travel thousands of kilometers away and hit the soul of even those who have only seen or known about it, I was finally able to let the tears flow, in the comfort of at least a hope. The hope in Humanity that God created with Love and that I know still exists and that takes concrete form in the invitations to PEACE... because Peace is Reality... while war is madness, it is paranoia, it is the renunciation of bearing fruit during our brief and precious opportunity of passage. And I will imprint that packed, applauding audience that listened to you in my memory for the moments of doubt🌈
Yuval, can I share an amazing story with you? One day I was driving home, when all of a sudden the Lord came to me in spirit. I felt very close to Him. I knew if I asked him to play any song on the radio he would, I guess to bless my faith.
So I said "ok, Lord play "Come as you are by Nirvana".
I turned on the radio and the song started playing right there on the spot, perfectly…
I started getting flooded with chills like a waterfall, crying, and trembling.
He stayed with me for 10 minutes in my driveway. until I got outta the car.
A couple months after that I started getting amazing prayers answered way more often, because it helped me quit doubting when I pray and I was lined up with biblical instructions. It's 6 years later and I still get answered prayers in Jesus name.
You are ignoring all the times you can't get the radio to play Nirvana, or whatever you want, and focusing on the very few times when you can. It's called motivated reasoning and confirmation bias. You're ignoring all the evidence that doesn't support your hypothesis/belief, and only focusing on that which does. You are believing only because you want to, because it makes you happy. However, many of us are happy without your beliefs.
Umm al-Rashrash is a Palestinian land that was under Jordanian administration. Before the Jordanian administration, it was under Ottoman sovereignty and joined the southern Levant. Then Israel took it from Jordan in the 1948 war, after which Jordan abandoned the administration of Umm al-Rashrash and the West Bank in the Wadi Araba Agreement of 1994.
All good people want peace to prevail. The song ONE DAY captures this yearning. ONE DAY it is.
Beautifully spoken, I just wish the English translation better captured you profound and poetic Hebrew
Was it poetic in Hebrew? I wish I could somehow see some of that, too -- but that, along with humour, is really the hardest part of translation.
I don't speak Hebrew, but by the reaction of the audience I can tell I was missing something. Translation is not an exact science. What a shame.
Beautiful speech. Beautiful insight.
Thank you, thank you mister Yuval Harari!...the world needs you and others like you..
For the sake of humanity, for the sake of our aching planet hearth.....
Keep on spreading the message of peace, based on history and explaing all the narratives
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
🇮🇳 🇮🇱 true friend