I honestly like both of them. They're both great for what they are. I really wish Random Encounters didn't feel so discouraged after the amount flack they got. Still, I give them a lot of credit and I honestly think theirs has a good amount of charm.
Comparing them both shot-by-shot is a real treat! ^^ We definitely did our best on the original, but it's super special still to see each and every animator's style and personality injected into their scenes in the REanimated edition. Again, an incredible effort by an enormous, amazingly talented group... well done and thank you for setting this in motion, Pasty!
@@zackattack3867 I 100% agree with Shane. Onyx was pretty good, considering it's claymation, and had the lips move for the lyrics. Beewd wasn't animated but I found it more entertaining than the original. Playsty's was gross but was better animated.
@@haydomo1069 what are you talking about? I thought it was hilarious! And for the record as an animation and and artist myself stuff like that is hard to draw And animate! And this comment makes it even better! *lol* thanos chin 😂
To be fair the first one was animated by only one person while the other had dozens Meaning that you can't be to harsh! There both great and I feel bad for the animator for all the discourage they got Artist take time an effort into art and it's hard when you put your heat and soul into something and someone hates it... *still there both great so can no one argue with me right now* *I'm not in the mood to have an internet battle*
I know it's hard to animate and everything and this was their first try at it but some simple things like redrawing somethings and making the outlines thicker could have made this look much better
(Before I say anything, I just want to say I love the MAP animation! I think it had lots of talented animators that were passionate about project. I’m just gonna talk about the old one) I think Random Encounters got lots of undeserved hate from the first animation. They focus primarily on music, and any animation they typically do is stop motion animation with figurines and clay. They aren’t used to 2D animation and put lots of effort into it like they do for every song and video. And honestly, for not being familiar with 2D animation, they did a fantastic job! People also think that puppet animation is “cheating.” That is so not the case. Lots of shows use puppet animation because it allows them to make more content more quickly, and it can give as nicely of a result as hand drawn frame by frame animation. I like the old animation because I could tell that they were putting in the effort that they normally have (which is a crap ton might I add)! And besides, animation is hard, and they had to draw all of the characters from Cuphead as well as drawing multiple backgrounds. Lots of characters were also drawn in multiple ways to show different angles, which that is dedication right there I like both of the animations, but I hope that RE knows that there was nothing “wrong” with the first one
Paradox Free i mean a lot of people contributed to this animation they didnt made it it was people who had a clip and boom it was put together by those people
His voice is Andrew Stein, he makes music here on youtube. His Channel name is Mandopony, but he also made songs with Natewantstobattle together. I recommend that you check both of them out, they're really good!
Random encounters did the original, however, they are actually a music channel and this was their first go at 2D animation. Some years later they started a reanimating project with a lot of artists maintaining the original song.
Why am I just noticing this? “ONE shift of the stars and the tide is sure to turn!” “TOO bad Cuphead’s about to lose big!” “THREE heads will hunt him ‘till Cuphead feels the burn!” “FOR the rest of his headlining gig!”
I love how the every boss looks different including how the back ground and I love when when cuphead and the devil look like the spongebob show and I like when king dice talks as playdoh
Totally off topic to the video but can I just say how much I love Gwen (the voice of rumor honeybottoms’) voice something about it is so menacing yet so calming at the same time
For some reason some of the animations give me "Cartoon nostalgia" oh how i missed those days where you never knew what the reality felt like the animators who gave me that feeling earns my respect
Some people have to realize that random encounters specializes in MUSIC not animation. It doesn’t matter if it’s bad or not, that was probably one of the first time they used animation in one of their videos. They tried their best and that’s all that matters
Heres the problem, being an animator i can spot two problems. Frame rate. As many have said the frame rate does not fit for the animation. Its still good. But not fantastic. How big the teeth are and how the jaw was made in the clay mation process. The other one was pretty good too. It had some minor problems though.
Great thing about these reanimated projects is that because every scene is done by a different person, they can put all of their efforts into making that few seconds great
Each person has a unique style to their animations so random encounters kinda ya know made their own style I didn’t like it at first but it grew on me and now I love it
Yo, this is epic and awesome! XD *WELL DONE!* Now, why not take a little quick break, and come back for more? Then come back for more! Please come back for more! ; )
Ok, there is the original that has better voice actors than animators, and the reanimated that has the original song but better animation than the original. Good job!
I think I like the Original a little more because the reanimated one keeps switching from Cartoony, Realistic, etc while the original is one topic. The reanimated has better animation tho
I don’t really like how in the reanimated version they just went outside with a camera and added the original musical faces to a real life carrot onion and potato, just felt lazy to me
I honestly like both of them. They're both great for what they are. I really wish Random Encounters didn't feel so discouraged after the amount flack they got. Still, I give them a lot of credit and I honestly think theirs has a good amount of charm.
Nah theirs is just garbage honestly
Kura Mations yeah I just liked the animation as much as the music I mean it’s one of their few animated videos and it’s not bad
PowerOfTheC i kinda agree, the song was good but the animation tho
Five nights at Justinlikestobecool3 this was their first animation.
Silverfire 12 who asked you
Comparing them both shot-by-shot is a real treat! ^^ We definitely did our best on the original, but it's super special still to see each and every animator's style and personality injected into their scenes in the REanimated edition. Again, an incredible effort by an enormous, amazingly talented group... well done and thank you for setting this in motion, Pasty!
ey
"REanimated" HAHA FUNNY I GET IT
You guys should hire Lana Golin to animate the non live action musicals (Pac-Man,Bendy,etc)
Yes :)
666? )=(-D
I think the reanimated one is better. However, the original had some scenes that were better
zackattack3867 like what scene?
@@chocolatarein8940 Shane morris, Onyx Mendoza, Beewd, Playsty . But of course this is my personal opinion
@@zackattack3867 I 100% agree with Shane. Onyx was pretty good, considering it's claymation, and had the lips move for the lyrics. Beewd wasn't animated but I found it more entertaining than the original. Playsty's was gross but was better animated.
The original was more consistent but it was butt ugly and bad
Arlockus the new one is supposed to be different style put into one video so its obvious less consistent
2:21 tho that Grim Matchstick animation is so fluid
Well Oof I know right? Not many people talk about that scene
Ikr I love that part 😝
well oof yeah i love it
My fav part
Don't forget 3:18 I don't know her name
So glad this Collab is Finally out. Had so much fun working on this.
Which part were you at
Five nights at Justinlikestobecool3 this was my scene ua-cam.com/video/m_8ea3otyVM/v-deo.html
3:35 sally got more wrinkles than thanos's chin
jasper quarts yep. Def
jasper quarts it sucks that the person had to try and ruin the collab by making them look ugly and barely putting any effort into animating
@@haydomo1069 ruined it? They made it even better by putting comedy in it!
That reminds me of Sr Pelo art style XD
@@haydomo1069 what are you talking about? I thought it was hilarious!
And for the record as an animation and and artist myself stuff like that is hard to draw
And animate!
And this comment makes it even better!
*lol* thanos chin 😂
So The Devil's actually is Papyrus
2:43 Reanimated
OH MY GOSH-
*WHEEZE*
*OH SHIT*
Lol *WHEEZ*
*PLOT TWIST*
This is a Theory A game Theory
“Let’s use science” is the best part because it sounds like something the game theory would say.
And Matpat voiced that character
*about that-*
Yes I know that
No I like "while I come call the cops to bee support
Or "they call me king dice cuz that's who I am
I've always wanted to see the difference side by side! Thanks Pasty :)
No prob, dude!! I wanted to also! ^^ That and I figured since SOMEONE was eventually gonna make one of these comparison vids, might as well be me. :)
It was interesting, but this makes me cringe for some reason. Sorry.
YES RYLAN
hi
To be fair the first one was animated by only one person while the other had dozens
Meaning that you can't be to harsh!
There both great and I feel bad for the animator for all the discourage they got
Artist take time an effort into art and it's hard when you put your heat and soul into something and someone hates it...
*still there both great so can no one argue with me right now*
*I'm not in the mood to have an internet battle*
The guys that made the orignal did pretty well considering they had no prior experience with animation
Nugcon No prior experience?! That’s cool. But yeah, the original got a lot of hate from people that don’t even know how to animate
I know it's hard to animate and everything and this was their first try at it but some simple things like redrawing somethings and making the outlines thicker could have made this look much better
I mean they are a music channel so animation is not something they do but still was good for the first try.
2:46 I love how the devil is tapping his foot XD
hel ye
For some reason it looked like Tom
I think AJ did very good for his first time animating. His thing is music.
1:22 my animated)😍😍❤️❤️❤️
Cool and funny
@@Bee2. agreed
Looks great! :D
Awesome!
Cool i wanna see your vid
2:38 reanimated side is my favorite
Yeah like I love both of them but the reanimated just has so much emotion
3:28 I swear I've seen that animation art style before on the reanimated side....like it was peach vs Bowser or something like that
Thats rylan legos animation
rylanlego made that one, he make's those mario scenarios videos.
3:33 the right one made me laugh way too hard xD
(Before I say anything, I just want to say I love the MAP animation! I think it had lots of talented animators that were passionate about project. I’m just gonna talk about the old one)
I think Random Encounters got lots of undeserved hate from the first animation. They focus primarily on music, and any animation they typically do is stop motion animation with figurines and clay. They aren’t used to 2D animation and put lots of effort into it like they do for every song and video. And honestly, for not being familiar with 2D animation, they did a fantastic job!
People also think that puppet animation is “cheating.” That is so not the case. Lots of shows use puppet animation because it allows them to make more content more quickly, and it can give as nicely of a result as hand drawn frame by frame animation. I like the old animation because I could tell that they were putting in the effort that they normally have (which is a crap ton might I add)! And besides, animation is hard, and they had to draw all of the characters from Cuphead as well as drawing multiple backgrounds. Lots of characters were also drawn in multiple ways to show different angles, which that is dedication right there
I like both of the animations, but I hope that RE knows that there was nothing “wrong” with the first one
0:07 on reanimated looks official
All the characters are so much more expressive, and all the different styles didn't clash like I thought they would.
Paradox Free i mean a lot of people contributed to this animation they didnt made it it was people who had a clip and boom it was put together by those people
@@MemE-sb4pm Well, yeah
3:32 favorite scene of the Reanimated collab
Am i The Only One Who Loves Grim Matchstick's Voice
His voice is Andrew Stein, he makes music here on youtube. His Channel name is Mandopony, but he also made songs with Natewantstobattle together. I recommend that you check both of them out, they're really good!
Chaz Thank you
Hes so good
@@milancholisch oh I thought he was voiced by Natewantstobattle! Learn something new
@@sylveoncovers4603 Nate voices King Dice ^^
3:32 is the best one for REanimated
I like them both. I like the original a little more, just because it is the original and it is consistent with the same animation.
3:29 Ryan's one
I knew I knew that Art from somewhere, I just couldn't put my finger on it
I know the art from somewhere... But I can't say that name fits it weirdly. It might just be my head though.
Loud house?
FNAF PRODUCTIONS what?
Amazing job everyone! And thank you so much for setting this up Pasty!!! This was such a fun project to work on!
Truly had alot of fun and fjsut came to drop by to thank you and everyone else! ^^
2:00 to 2:05 is so good I love how in the remastered they have the other phases singing in the background and I love how it looks.Nice work
I’m sorry if this is offensive to the person who made the original but the reanimated one is much much better
Random Encounters uploaded both, but people actually made theirs in the animated
Random encounters did the original, however, they are actually a music channel and this was their first go at 2D animation.
Some years later they started a reanimating project with a lot of artists maintaining the original song.
@@ariaa.9428 yeah ik
“a royal pain who’s diabolical plan”
me: A H H H H H H H
For me that animation fucked up the scene.
I'm glad I wasn't the only one freaked out
3:58 i REALLY CRIYNG OF LAUGH!!!!
PIG SALUTE *UUUUUUUUUOH*
i don't know why, but my favorite part is the "let's use science" part... it just looks so cool
Maybe the amount of metal they had to manipulate
1:20 is my fav
It's extremely fluid
2:11 is my favorite reanimated one
Why am I just noticing this?
“ONE shift of the stars and the tide is sure to turn!”
“TOO bad Cuphead’s about to lose big!”
“THREE heads will hunt him ‘till Cuphead feels the burn!”
“FOR the rest of his headlining gig!”
I actually like both of them a lot! I can’t get over the spinning Beppi tho, it’s so cute-
Dude so cute
can I just say how perfect the reanimated version was at 3:33
2:21
Elena did a fantastic job, I think more people should appreciate this
2:11 I personally found the animation style for Hilda Berg on the right to be more engaging.
3:24 Reanimated Peppi So COOTE
DUDE TGATS THE CLEANEST ANIMATION EVER
The first animator (Arti) had a name that started with A.
The last animator (Zach Dewb) had a name that started with Z.
1:22 favorite scene of the Original animation
I like the reanimated better just because some characters look kinda oofed in the original
Hey you said oof omg trespasser that is a lanky box fan ooh
I love how the every boss looks different including how the back ground and I love when when cuphead and the devil look like the spongebob show and I like when king dice talks as playdoh
Totally off topic to the video but can I just say how much I love Gwen (the voice of rumor honeybottoms’) voice something about it is so menacing yet so calming at the same time
I wonder what a fully stop motion version of this would look like, like the bendy animation!
Numi, Elena, Sony, and Tempest were the true MVPS for me lol
For some reason some of the animations give me "Cartoon nostalgia" oh how i missed those days where you never knew what the reality felt like the animators who gave me that feeling earns my respect
Cup head died a lot but mug man stepped in and they beat the devil qwq
I thought you were talking about Cupheads FAME died and I was about to smack you-
._.
The sony-shock scene looks so smooth and beatiful
Ikr!
Aw, thank you!
YYYEEEESSS absolutely worth the wait.
Some people have to realize that random encounters specializes in MUSIC not animation. It doesn’t matter if it’s bad or not, that was probably one of the first time they used animation in one of their videos. They tried their best and that’s all that matters
Dude, you did an amazing job with the video. It looks really good! Keep up your amazing work.
I liked the first video so much and when the reanimated came out I got super exited
The reanimated looks neat for how long it took ngl
I really like the reanimated cause it changes the mode like this video everyone right now!❤😊
When you look at the original one you think it's not that bad
*But when you compare it to the reanimated one...*
*Skkkk...*
2:33 - 2:38
Sry but i legit had to cover my eyes
Yeah.. I gotta agree. The rest was totally awsome, but that animation style really didn't work very well in the song...
Both in that scene sucked
Ya they just didn't feel right with all of the other animations
Yes It didn’t quite fit in, but hey. It probably took a while, and I can’t be talking since I couldn’t make anything close to that.
Heres the problem, being an animator i can spot two problems. Frame rate. As many have said the frame rate does not fit for the animation. Its still good. But not fantastic. How big the teeth are and how the jaw was made in the clay mation process. The other one was pretty good too. It had some minor problems though.
Love this!!! Very glad to have been a part of this project
Great thing about these reanimated projects is that because every scene is done by a different person, they can put all of their efforts into making that few seconds great
My favorite part is the one, two, three, four countdown with the different characters. So great to listen to and to look at!
Each person has a unique style to their animations so random encounters kinda ya know made their own style I didn’t like it at first but it grew on me and now I love it
Yo, this is epic and awesome! XD
*WELL DONE!*
Now, why not take a little quick break, and come back for more?
Then come back for more!
Please come back for more! ; )
Let’s all agree that none of these bosses are hard and the hardest one is...
The tutorial level
I say reanimated only looks better because everything is more lively and moving more
This comparison video totally made me appreciate both of the original videos more! 😁👍
Random Encounters did a wonderful job, I wish they didn’t get so much hate. They didn’t deserve it. They deserved praise for their hard work.
I really wish I could have helped with this. This is still all to amazing thoooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ok, there is the original that has better voice actors than animators, and the reanimated that has the original song but better animation than the original. Good job!
What i like most about the new version is that it changes from style from styles, its just neat
I like how there are impressive animations. I wanna see the animations that fit really well with cuphead in their own thing!
Can I just say how much I love RylanLego’s part?
I love the 3d animation bits
That’s a big improvement
Guys just look how good you have gotten!
This was nice :D
Sony-shock did an amazing job
I like them both but few problems with reanimated
#1:The CGI parts...just why
#2:The Clay Part Of King Dice
Cala-Maria’s “Wooah!” After she dropped the fish was adorable.
Edit: also, “They call me King Dice, ‘cause that’s who I am” was hilarious.
Devil : (says literally anything)
Me : DARKIPLIER
2:30 MY AMAZING BOYFRIEND INSTANT-CLASSIC!!! ♥️♥️♥️✨✨✨
0:16 I Saw goofy
Goofy's cameos
Wait what
Oh my god, this really needed one
Some of the parts of the reanimated ones are mm.. questionable
“No I’m pretty sure they killed him” this makes me laugh more than I should
It’s funny how in reality it took you in the game 3 hours when to you it took over 78 hours
3:17 BEST PART
You mean 3:18?
@@sawytheboi6332 oh yes
The reanimated version is how this thing shouldve gone, but it's nice to have both
1:11 the phantom train art so good!
I like the reanimated version more
It’s so good
I like very animated better because the first version is very very creepy and the reanimated just looks better
I knew dat is REANIMATED !!!
1:41 *howdy! Im flowey! Flowey the flower!
Great video!
reanimated is so good
It's sad because some people hate on it and call it garbage without no constructive criticism.. Like cmon!
_"They call ne King Dice, cause that's who I am"_
GENIUS
I think I like the Original a little more because the reanimated one keeps switching from Cartoony, Realistic, etc while the original is one topic. The reanimated has better animation tho
OMG! Niceee
I don’t really like how in the reanimated version they just went outside with a camera and added the original musical faces to a real life carrot onion and potato, just felt lazy to me
1:13 this a really cool shot of the phantom express in the reanimated