I think a better analogy would be a shallow pond with a mix of water and sand. The water waves stop at some point but the sand will be grouped and spaced differently depending on the waves that happened.
@@noelstarchildit doesn't need to be torn. The waves cause matter to be distributed in certain ways. This then affects the future waves. See how that works for both examples?
I love your channel, you explain things clearly & simply with no over editing & avoid excessive clickbaiting and exagerating discoveries & on top of that your voice is very relaxing - thankyou for making these!
I have to agree 90% of your viewers want science, I understand you want to grow, but we have been getting close to real science people skipping some of your titles not your info once in video is fine.
This, in addition to the information presented in your recent video discussing time dilation, likely completely explains the Hubble tension. No wonder there would be different rates of expansion if gravitational wave memories oppose expansion by contracting spacetime in different amounts depending on the relative "gravitational turbulence" in different regions.
Thanks For explaining how Astrology works, and how the planets interact with each other to affect us here on earth while being millions of miles apart!!
I've seen a few of your vids but now, I've officially subbed to your channel. I respect the way you present your videos and the topics they cover, the information provided is accurate, informative and I love your work mate!! 👍
I often feel like that about his videos! At first I think, "what the heck is that," but I watch it anyway because it's Anton. Then by the end I'm going, "oh wow, that was amazing, I have to watch that one again!"
Ive been watching him for like 8 years. What you said is why I still watch every upload, even if I dont get to it immediately. This guy is a truly wonderful perosn.
Pardon my intrusion Anton, I just wanted to mention that the first second of this video deserves to be made into my favorite desktop wallpaper. The reasons are crystal clear to any of 70s and 80s pop artistic taste or vivid art in general.
7:42 so measuring them is similar to measuring magnetic lines in volcanic rock. The memory is stored and relative to the age of magnetic differences like solar flares and such. Doing it on planets with low magnetic fields can see large amounts of data because the interference from outside the planet like solar winds. Scanning will be a cool tool. Seeing a relative memory tied to as well.
In terms of analogies to compare to gravitational wave memory and how unlike water ripples, some effects are permanent...earthquakes. The waves produced by earthquakes can be similar in shape to waves in fluid, but since it's passing through solid rock, the landscape is forever changed by it.
An analogy: if you vibrate a thin metallic plate that is held fixed at the edges, it will get stretched. The plate used to be flat but now it is curved. The topography of the surface has changed. Maybe "dark matter" is dents in spacetime???
Gravitational waves also affect spacetime's 4th dimension: time. They affect the rate at which time passes. Essentially time slows down (time dilation) then speeds up then slows down then speeds up then etc. General relativity explains this effect in detail.
Essentially its Relative time, For observer A at that point, time & distance do not measurably change, partly because observer A's ruler & clock would also be changed as time, gravity & distance are linked in ratio such that the speed of light is constant for any observer. i.e. if time speeds up, distance will also increase such that C is constant for all observers. Observer A would not see "Essentially time slows down" Time only speeds up or slows down relative to an external point or observer, i.e. relativity.
The implications of gravity, time & distance being in ratio such that C is constant for all observers has been missed, spacetime is compressed by mass not just curved as Einstein's theories postulate. Gravity a proxy for the density or pressure of spacetime, density in this case would be like atmospheric pressure or water pressure at depth in oceans etc. Expanding space is merely space uncompressing in the absence of mass, the dark energy they thought required, is a measure or proxy for the elasticity of spacetime.
This is false. Gravitational waves have only two polarization components, both are space-like and perpendicular to the direction the wave is traveling. There is no longitudinal component, and there is no time-like component.
@@denysvlasenko1865 Well then, they are not gravitational waves. Which is what many suspect anyway. Spacetime includes time, its in the name. Time and space dilation go together. If the wave can warp space then it must by definition warp time. Otherwise C cannot be constant for all observers. You don't get it. Read up on Einstein's thought experiments and what the observers at each location would experience and why. What's the medium the gravitational wave is propagating in? There is no perpetration in a gravitational field as per quantum physics as there is no field & no graviton.
The "obstacle illusion affect of time" refers to the psychological phenomenon where the perception of time seems to slow down or stretch out when encountering an obstacle or challenge, making it feel like the moment is taking longer than usual, even if the actual time elapsed is the same; essentially, your brain is processing information at a faster rate due to heightened focus and attention in a demanding situation.
Been a fan for about over 5 years now. You are among the best of the best good sir. This was a phenomenal episode. I wonder if this is the path towards a more complete picture of panpsychism? Anywho, keep up the good work and keep on fighting the good fight. Cheers!
One day I believe research will prove that magnetism is faster than light. We just simply don't understand it nor have any methods to actually measure how fast it is moving.
@@blinded6502 Magnetism is not simply the Doppler effect of an electric field, but the two phenomena are related in the context of electromagnetic theory.
If the Universe had no memory of what went before, would it exist? Sorting facts from the memory of an aging and possibly senile Universe is a fun passtime.
The US navy has known this for over a decade though. They have patents for gravimetrics hardware and gravity wave detectors have probably been used in submarines for decades also.
In the pond analogy, one LARGE stone would have the desired effect - ripples that eventually dissipate plus altered depth. Another way I visualized this would be sound waves in a solid. At high enough intensity, the structure of the solid (say a crystal) can be permanently distorted, affecting all future wave propagation, albeit slightly.
Anton-- sometime could you talk exactly how spacetime "waves"? Does it compress and expand, like a sound wave? If so, how is compressed spacetime different than regular spacetime? Does time change, space change, or both? Somebody must know about this, otherwise they could never have built LIGO.
It's important to understand that spacetime isn't a real thing that can be compressed. Gravity waves aren't propagating in a medium, because there is no medium. There is no "regular" spacetime either. It's just that rapid oscillations of very massive objects cause the effects of gravity to oscillate also, and those oscillations in the strength propagate at the speed of light as a wave. Our detectors are set up extremely precisely to be able to detect these microscopic changes. Here's another way of thinking about the situation. Instead of gravity bending spacetime, you could hypothesize some mystical substance that makes it harder to move away from a mass, like wading through a viscous fluid. It takes more energy for the same motion when there's a lot of that goop around. The "cost" of moving in some direction is encoded by a mathematical gadget called a metric, and it's this math that actually comprises the theory. The story you tell surrounding what the math "means" is up to you. It's just that physics educators really like this analogy because it's easy to demonstrate and give the public a sense of what the math is saying, but that doesn't mean that the analogy is "true." There is no material of "spacetime" which is being distorted, and it cannot be meaningfully stretched or shrunk. There is a similar issue with people asking "what does space expand into." Nothing. Space is not expanding. That's ridiculous. What's happening is, everything is getting further apart from everything else, on cosmic scales. There's no material.
@donniedeville5102 it is ridiculous because it relies on a nonsense premise. The question is completely reasonable given the non stop stream of lies that are given to the physics adjacent public. It's not their fault, they are mislead by poor analogies and a general failure to teach math in schools.
@@mathematicsreadinggroup7288 Einstein disagrees with you. "According to the general theory of relativity space is endowed with physical qualities; in this sense, therefore, there exists an ether. According to the general theory of relativity space without ether is unthinkable" --Ether and the Theory of Relativity, 1922. He explains in this talk why the ether of general relativity is different than the Lorentzian ether (he says it is a "relativization" of the Lorentzian ether), but he also explains why the theory of general relativity cannot work without spacetime being made of something.
@erinm9445 this is a profound misunderstanding. Einstein held the view that space was purely relational, following Leibniz. He's merely saying that the metric varies place to place, so "space has properties." To conclude that space is a physically real thing is to completely miss the point of the rest of his writings. This is discussed at modest length on SEP, if you want a discussion that avoids tremendous math.
Like tinfoil, you crinkle and crunch it, and then uncrunch it, but it is never as smooth. Maybe the wrinkles and the entropy that results from them is what makes the arrow of time?
Heheh, the pond remembers the stones that were thrown into it. Moval of objects, at least causes local changes. And via saddle points, such changes can have wide effects.
Gravitational wave science is rapidly evolving and presents exciting opportunities for discovering unknown phenomena in the universe. Recent confirmations indicate that the entire universe might be vibrating due to unknown sources.
Did it stop though? Could this be the true nature of the "quantum foam"? Brownian motion is just gravitational ripples? Weird particles popping in and out of existence, is just the fabric of the universe experience gravitational wave interference, going to an "excited" state.
mass can be measured in radians in a rotating universe, with a net time of 0. G(c^2/r). this means the four fundamental forces are a product of the inverse relationship between time and rotation, to conserve momentum. This gives rise to a observable universe of one radian. This equations is from my unifying theory.
Interesting makes me think that you could detect more waves if you knew how to control for the gravitational change to masses there must be an energy difference that's detectable
A fair amount of micro-waves from the effects of large sources, such as neutron stars and singularity interactions and formations could just end up being ringing of the gravitationally bound molecules with the much larger energy levels of the incoming gravitational waves. Additionally, one could potentially see what's initially thought to be these memories, of which I'm extremely dubious of for conservation of energy and entropy reasons, which instead would be merely precession and similar effects of neutron stars "lumpy" regions, which slowly will "settle" over time via neutron starquakes. Otherwise, that energy would accumulate and well, the universe would end up with all matter glowing from accumulated "memory" gravitational energy that magically doesn't seek a lower energy level.
When humans are long gone, I wonder what memory imprint we will leave on the universe with all our A.I. creations that will outlive us. Probably a scar so deep the universe will wilt.
Electric magnetic vibrations have sounds,if you have large enough magnets and spin them around each other,there’s actually a buzzing sound emitting from them,everything is energy,frequency and vibration.
Correct! 🙂 Everything is--in simplistic essence--a wave of some type. Light, Sound, Gravity, "Brain" (or mind--whatever)... just to name four of many. *Reflection is key.* 🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨ "Before I start, I must see my end. Destination known, my mind's journey now begins. Upon my chariot, heart and soul's fate revealed. In time, all points converge; hope's strength resteeled. But to earn final peace at the universe's endless refrain, we must see all in nothingness... before we start again." 🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨ --Diamond Dragons (series)
@@MsCrazylegs80 More so than that alone, at a molecular level, particles would "arrange themselves". 💪😎✌️ This, btw, is NOT some random, unsubstantiated theory; it's precisely what happens upon that atomic plane. It's also akin to how--for example--particles of salt set upon a speaker drum vibrating at 432Hz (or "X" or "Y" Hz) will organize into semi-geometric latticework. No, it's not IDENTICAL, but that's the super short, truncated explanation. Certain frequencies produce "nothing much", while others are... attuned! Attuned upon celestial frequencies. No joke. *Reflection is key.* 🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨ "Before I start, I must see my end. Destination known, my mind's journey now begins. Upon my chariot, heart and soul's fate revealed. In time, all points converge; hope's strength resteeled. But to earn final peace at the universe's endless refrain, we must see all in nothingness... before we start again." 🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨ --Diamond Dragons (series)
I don't understand the notion of permanent changes to space time if other intersecting gravitational waves alter the changes to space time created by earlier waves. Or do changes to space time never intersect/overlap?
The question is: What is change, if it exists "sub species aeternitas"? It is a confusing idea that being and eternity imply permanence, whereas the present and existence imply impermanence.
I can assume that this memory is from lost energy, like if mass of two black hole system is M, mass after collision of is M-dm (dm=energy lost in collision due to g. waves ~ few solar masses), than we should have less gravity from merged black hole (da = -G dm/R^2). Pretty hard to measure disappearing of few solar masses from another galaxy
This is what I've suspected for some time. Take a look at the bullet cluster. If you have two massive objects suddenly merge, they decelerate but what happens to the surrounding spacetime? It decelerates too but to a lesser degree due to the fluid-like nature of space.
He made an analogy of gravitational waves, to waves in a pond and how they were similar! Waves on water or in a pond, when colliding with other waves from different directions have a tendency of canceling each other out! Do gravitational waves do the same thing? If you have gravitational waves colliding from different directions, do they have a canceling affect on each other? If so, would this have an effect on how we perceive the wave?
As time passes, more mass/gravity waves are coming to our observable universe. At the same time, the universe is expanding with the increase of dark energy. I really think their is a connection between the 2.
Thanks for the video! I’m not sure I understand how the memory could be consistent to the original formation of the wave when the universe is constantly expanding, the wave is constantly moving through matter and they’re wave spreads as it travels much like the ripples in the pond. Those things might only change the wave slightly but if it changes at all it’s not a fact.
Might it be that gravitational wave memory could explain the rotation curves of galaxies (what most astro-physicists explain with dark matter)? Where gravity is really small (for example the outer regions of galaxies) even slight curvature of the spacetime would change what gravity every mass "sees". And if gravitational wave memory is like a frozen wave on a pond we would have a certain spacetime curvature because of this effect (or did I understand gravitational wave memory completely wrong?). If this is correct, gravitational wave memory might even explain gravitational lensing (for example as seen in the bullet cluster). What do you think?
In a certain sense, the universe is already known to have memory. The universe has us. We have memory. So the universe has memory. More interestingly, since we know we have memory, and we can create memory on physical media, it is obvious that the universe has the capability for memory. Then, since it contains forms with memory, forms that are far less complex than itself; it stands to reason that the universe at least could have memory. I would be surprised if it did not.
A wave can only travel at the speed of light, thus, the shape of the event producing it is still there, but diluted/diminishing. It could be hypothetically possible to measure several far places in the universe for all possible patterns from all possible sources, and back-engineer where they came from, and what caused it.
Speed of light has yet to be confirmed outside of an earth based experiment using an artificial start and finish as a measurement must start at its beginning in space time and end at its termination of its space time.
Perhaps, gravity waves passing over plates, could cause virtual pairs to not be reabsorbed into space, thus transferring some gravity wave energy into making virtual particals into real particals. Thus, matter inside planets, between layers of crystals metal etc, could cause matter creation within planets. Thus black holes can transfer their masses into planets throughout the universe, thus EXPANDING PLANETS. Thus an EXPANDING EARTH is possible.
Super interesting video. Exciting times for physics. I note that gravitons weren't mentioned once. Do you think the discovery of gravitational wave memory would be proof against the existence of gravitons?
Anton Petrov likens the effect of gravitational waves on the "fabric" of space-time to a change in the mass of a pond resulting from dropping stone pebbles into the pond. He is describing the "configuration of space-time fabric" (or features in space and time) being affected by waves of energy passing through time and space, because mass is a property of energy. He then equates space-time (itself) with the waves passing through it in order to express the idea that the configuration (or fabric) of space and time can change or remember. However, I disagree with labeling these changes or memories "non-linear" because that only implies a denial, which is not positive knowledge of changes in the features in space and time by gravitational waves in being, as opposed to gravitational waves in the present, or in other words gravitational waves in existence (using the traditional distinction between being and existence in philosophy).
Two questions: 1) I heard, if one does a double slit experiment shooting one particle at a time with a noticeable time interval before the next particle, the particles seem to know the path of the previous particles and scatter as the double slit experiment expects. Could the space through which a particle move remember the path of the particle so the next particle knows the path of the previous particle because of some gravitational affect? 2) I heard, the quantum foam is highly energetic. Could this energetic nature be the result of gravitational wave interference patterns at the quantum level?
5:04 so the collapse is like inward and relative towards each other and the connection can increase difference and cause different explosions of reality because it’s relative. Weird way to say it
So spacetime can permanently deform (theoretically)? Is that basically what you’re saying? If so I wonder if it depends on the amplitude of the wave. Thinking like the deformation curve of certain metals, it’s linear in a certain region and will snap back, but after a certain amount of deformation it enters a nonlinear region and can “get stuck” in a deformed state.
Leaves me wondering if the accumulation of gravitational waves, over the length of time of the universe's existence, and the resulting reshaping of the fabric of the universe, could result in the filaments, nodes and voids in the cosmic web.
I'm listed as an author by Caltech on the LIGO project. I did the design for LIGO's pick-off telescope, seven of the end mass telescopes (used as beam expanders and not as conventional telescopes), the surface calibration device for the return mirrors and others. Having thought a lot about LOGO and physics in general, namely the double slit expriments that I believe were solved in my book, "Infinity, Time, Death and Thought", I disagree with the illustrations of gravitational waves propagating outward from neutron stars or black holes revolving around each other. How can gravitational waves be shown moving outward when gravity is an attractive force that's pulling matter inward? It seems to me that matter would be pulled inward rather than exerting an outward wave. How can these waves be shown like waves radiating outward in all the illustrations I've seen? This makes no sense. Also, gravitational waves are not gravity waves and gravitons are nonsense. Gravitational waves would require a carrier such as the waves we see in water or waves carried through air for us to hear. There is no carrier in which "waves" can be propagated in the vacuum of space, other than speculation that the ether has made a comeback in some scientific circles.
Photonic wave memory, magnetic wave memory, they all work. problem is measurement. If we use photons as data, then we can use electromagnetic interactions with photons as memory and be able to measure it. Gravitational waves will make more sense when science accepts plasma and electromagnetic properties of the universe as affecting "gravity waves".
If we can read these could we possibly produce a picture of the past which could essentially be a form of time travel or having an exact record of our past?
Spacetime is a medium for matter, just as water is a medium for fish. It propagates waves, and can stretch and contract. Its just not as easy to manipulate.
As a poster has suggested, the vibrations may be from magnetism or light. I feel the construction techniques evident in Ireland's towers with openings above head level must be connected to an Earth resonance but, did this resonance originate at the surface and migrate UP? Or is it being adjusted DOWN?
Or gravity is the effect of the ether (or could be named sub-quantic matter because this matter is different as it is infinitely fractal) flowing and then "pushing" everything concentrically into astral bodies (invalidating Michelson-Morley experiments because they inferred that the ether was static while it is not). Given that this model of the Universe is validated in the future, I might want to precise that I understood this in 1979; I wrote a text about it on a physic student publication when I was a student back then and then I went to play on other interesting things like for example inventing a new correlation coefficient still around the same time when I was a student - published only on UA-cam much later as a trace of this invention in case it can be useful in some fields of research ;) - and kept my main priorities in life (now retired). So, there is no void, and everything is in touch with everything. The SQM vibrates like anything else in the Universe and the SQM wide range of waves frequencies are part of the electromagnetic waves that we observe. BTW, in that model, dilation of time is a misinterpretation of facts; it is an illusion as the SQM variations in its flow toward a planet or star, as it gets closer to them, affect the rate of the frequencies of any atom surrounding the planet or stars. And frequencies of some atoms are at the source and reference of the atomic clocks so called measure of time...
The nucleus of the galaxy is a tumbling blackhole radiating mass out from its poles. The energy and gases condense to form galactic arms, a continuous production.
You have micro gravity, like two atoms. Why don't they always have to mash? So there might be lumpyness. This let's information sit at waypoints in the lumpiness. So its like a computer, a > b ? Move a, c. However, the information is so ultra fine and dense, unless you channel higher dimensions, you'd suppose it was a 10^5,000 meter cubed. But you simply close a steal door to a server farm and check all the temperatures, then open the steal door, and look at your watch, it accelerates at the second^4, just like light and electricity, the lumpiness knows the servers changed the room relative to the outer environment at some dielectric rate of change. Certainly the earth and planets 1/64,000 don't account for the crystal invariance.
So… Einstein suggested gravitational waves were possible but didn’t think they could be detected. He also suggested that stimulated emission of radiation was possible… So, lasers, which he predicted, were used to detect gravitational waves which he also predicted.
I think a better analogy would be a shallow pond with a mix of water and sand.
The water waves stop at some point but the sand will be grouped and spaced differently depending on the waves that happened.
oh yea that's great
I get it and it is better, though I doubt its' integrity. How does spacetime remember it has been stretched and shrunken, it's not as if it was torn?
@@noelstarchildSpacetime being able to be torn is still a state. I want to understand how and where the state resides.
@@noelstarchildit doesn't need to be torn. The waves cause matter to be distributed in certain ways. This then affects the future waves.
See how that works for both examples?
NO it is corrupted folds all matter is just corrupted folds.
I love your channel, you explain things clearly & simply with no over editing & avoid excessive clickbaiting and exagerating discoveries & on top of that your voice is very relaxing - thankyou for making these!
I have to agree 90% of your viewers want science, I understand you want to grow, but we have been getting close to real science people skipping some of your titles not your info once in video is fine.
Possibly the best out there in my opinion
wonderful Anton
This, in addition to the information presented in your recent video discussing time dilation, likely completely explains the Hubble tension.
No wonder there would be different rates of expansion if gravitational wave memories oppose expansion by contracting spacetime in different amounts depending on the relative "gravitational turbulence" in different regions.
The universe remembering that awkward interaction I had with my crush back in middle school
Don't forget all those 'times' in your shower!
Those moments are imprinted forever, it will never forget...
Oh NNNOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😮
When the gravity of the situation hit your soul hard enough, it probably did create a gravitational wave 🤔
And your dreams..
We remember, and we're part of the universe.
Thanks For explaining how Astrology works, and how the planets interact with each other to affect us here on earth while being millions of miles apart!!
You are tearing me apart, LISA!
Oh, hi Mark.
So Star Trek was right when their sensors could scan for a risidual warp signature of another ship long after it had left the area.
FSD wake scanner is available for purchase
o7 CMDR @@AgentLeon
@@AgentLeon o7 :)
@@AgentLeon….from Temu!
@@theeniwetoksymphonyorchest7580 with supercruise overcharge!
I've seen a few of your vids but now, I've officially subbed to your channel. I respect the way you present your videos and the topics they cover, the information provided is accurate, informative and I love your work mate!! 👍
Turned out to be more interesting than I thought. Good job, Anton.
I often feel like that about his videos! At first I think, "what the heck is that," but I watch it anyway because it's Anton. Then by the end I'm going, "oh wow, that was amazing, I have to watch that one again!"
Anton... you are the man. Plain and simple. Thank you once again for your beautiful content
Ive been watching him for like 8 years. What you said is why I still watch every upload, even if I dont get to it immediately. This guy is a truly wonderful perosn.
Wonderful as always Anton. Thank you. 🤘
Pardon my intrusion Anton, I just wanted to mention
that the first second of this video deserves to be
made into my favorite desktop wallpaper.
The reasons are crystal clear to any of 70s and 80s pop artistic taste or vivid art in general.
7:42 so measuring them is similar to measuring magnetic lines in volcanic rock. The memory is stored and relative to the age of magnetic differences like solar flares and such. Doing it on planets with low magnetic fields can see large amounts of data because the interference from outside the planet like solar winds. Scanning will be a cool tool. Seeing a relative memory tied to as well.
In terms of analogies to compare to gravitational wave memory and how unlike water ripples, some effects are permanent...earthquakes. The waves produced by earthquakes can be similar in shape to waves in fluid, but since it's passing through solid rock, the landscape is forever changed by it.
An analogy: if you vibrate a thin metallic plate that is held fixed at the edges, it will get stretched. The plate used to be flat but now it is curved. The topography of the surface has changed. Maybe "dark matter" is dents in spacetime???
Gravitational waves also affect spacetime's 4th dimension: time. They affect the rate at which time passes. Essentially time slows down (time dilation) then speeds up then slows down then speeds up then etc. General relativity explains this effect in detail.
Essentially its Relative time, For observer A at that point, time & distance do not measurably change, partly because observer A's ruler & clock would also be changed as time, gravity & distance are linked in ratio such that the speed of light is constant for any observer. i.e. if time speeds up, distance will also increase such that C is constant for all observers.
Observer A would not see "Essentially time slows down" Time only speeds up or slows down relative to an external point or observer, i.e. relativity.
The implications of gravity, time & distance being in ratio such that C is constant for all observers has been missed, spacetime is compressed by mass not just curved as Einstein's theories postulate. Gravity a proxy for the density or pressure of spacetime, density in this case would be like atmospheric pressure or water pressure at depth in oceans etc. Expanding space is merely space uncompressing in the absence of mass, the dark energy they thought required, is a measure or proxy for the elasticity of spacetime.
This is false. Gravitational waves have only two polarization components, both are space-like and perpendicular to the direction the wave is traveling. There is no longitudinal component, and there is no time-like component.
@@denysvlasenko1865 Well then, they are not gravitational waves. Which is what many suspect anyway.
Spacetime includes time, its in the name. Time and space dilation go together. If the wave can warp space then it must by definition warp time. Otherwise C cannot be constant for all observers. You don't get it. Read up on Einstein's thought experiments and what the observers at each location would experience and why.
What's the medium the gravitational wave is propagating in? There is no perpetration in a gravitational field as per quantum physics as there is no field & no graviton.
@@denysvlasenko1865 Without time the geometry of the universe would be a single point or singularity.
The "obstacle illusion affect of time" refers to the psychological phenomenon where the perception of time seems to slow down or stretch out when encountering an obstacle or challenge, making it feel like the moment is taking longer than usual, even if the actual time elapsed is the same; essentially, your brain is processing information at a faster rate due to heightened focus and attention in a demanding situation.
no, it's gravitational wave memory from colliding black holes
@GerhardTreibheitHe's referring to a psychological effect.
Been a fan for about over 5 years now. You are among the best of the best good sir. This was a phenomenal episode. I wonder if this is the path towards a more complete picture of panpsychism? Anywho, keep up the good work and keep on fighting the good fight. Cheers!
Thanks!
Interesting indeed, thanks Anton👍❤
Everything is still vibrating since coming into existence.
Somebody decent and adorable, please go hug Anton!
He looks so sad.
I love this channel. So incredibly interesting. You have some pretty funny comedians in your comments as well which is an added bonus 😊
One day I believe research will prove that magnetism is faster than light. We just simply don't understand it nor have any methods to actually measure how fast it is moving.
Magnetism is doppler effect of electric field. It cannot travel faster than electric field can by definition
@@blinded6502 Magnetism is not simply the Doppler effect of an electric field, but the two phenomena are related in the context of electromagnetic theory.
If we remember, the universe can remember. We are made of star dust after all 😊
Alzheimer disagrees.
Information is forever, inscribed in the fabric of space time.
@@knarFkcalB Well, it's a fabric but where's the ink?
“We are Staaaar children, coming out of nowhere into nowhere in turn.”, :Bruce Dickenson
@@JZsBFF Energy is the ink.
If the Universe had no memory of what went before, would it exist? Sorting facts from the memory of an aging and possibly senile Universe is a fun passtime.
The US navy has known this for over a decade though. They have patents for gravimetrics hardware and gravity wave detectors have probably been used in submarines for decades also.
Try the blanket analogy but the blanket has a wave induced in it violently and everything on it get shoved in one direction forever.
Wow!!❤❤❤ wonderful simulations! Superb subject! Thank you Anton!
In the pond analogy, one LARGE stone would have the desired effect - ripples that eventually dissipate plus altered depth.
Another way I visualized this would be sound waves in a solid. At high enough intensity, the structure of the solid (say a crystal) can be permanently distorted, affecting all future wave propagation, albeit slightly.
My intuition - Gravitational waves`s memory save all information about lost paths in wave function collapse.
Anton-- sometime could you talk exactly how spacetime "waves"? Does it compress and expand, like a sound wave? If so, how is compressed spacetime different than regular spacetime? Does time change, space change, or both? Somebody must know about this, otherwise they could never have built LIGO.
It's important to understand that spacetime isn't a real thing that can be compressed. Gravity waves aren't propagating in a medium, because there is no medium. There is no "regular" spacetime either. It's just that rapid oscillations of very massive objects cause the effects of gravity to oscillate also, and those oscillations in the strength propagate at the speed of light as a wave. Our detectors are set up extremely precisely to be able to detect these microscopic changes.
Here's another way of thinking about the situation. Instead of gravity bending spacetime, you could hypothesize some mystical substance that makes it harder to move away from a mass, like wading through a viscous fluid. It takes more energy for the same motion when there's a lot of that goop around. The "cost" of moving in some direction is encoded by a mathematical gadget called a metric, and it's this math that actually comprises the theory. The story you tell surrounding what the math "means" is up to you. It's just that physics educators really like this analogy because it's easy to demonstrate and give the public a sense of what the math is saying, but that doesn't mean that the analogy is "true." There is no material of "spacetime" which is being distorted, and it cannot be meaningfully stretched or shrunk.
There is a similar issue with people asking "what does space expand into." Nothing. Space is not expanding. That's ridiculous. What's happening is, everything is getting further apart from everything else, on cosmic scales. There's no material.
I Love how you label a fair question as ridiculous. You are everything that is wrong with science today.
@donniedeville5102 it is ridiculous because it relies on a nonsense premise. The question is completely reasonable given the non stop stream of lies that are given to the physics adjacent public. It's not their fault, they are mislead by poor analogies and a general failure to teach math in schools.
@@mathematicsreadinggroup7288 Einstein disagrees with you. "According to the general theory of relativity space is endowed with physical qualities; in this sense, therefore, there exists an ether. According to the general theory of relativity space without ether is unthinkable" --Ether and the Theory of Relativity, 1922. He explains in this talk why the ether of general relativity is different than the Lorentzian ether (he says it is a "relativization" of the Lorentzian ether), but he also explains why the theory of general relativity cannot work without spacetime being made of something.
@erinm9445 this is a profound misunderstanding. Einstein held the view that space was purely relational, following Leibniz. He's merely saying that the metric varies place to place, so "space has properties." To conclude that space is a physically real thing is to completely miss the point of the rest of his writings. This is discussed at modest length on SEP, if you want a discussion that avoids tremendous math.
Like tinfoil, you crinkle and crunch it, and then uncrunch it, but it is never as smooth. Maybe the wrinkles and the entropy that results from them is what makes the arrow of time?
Happy New Year Anton the Atom 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Anton the Photon!!
Anton the quark, I win.
The memory Anton describes is encoding, without recall. Though we might be able to recover something from the encoding.
Heheh, the pond remembers the stones that were thrown into it. Moval of objects, at least causes local changes. And via saddle points, such changes can have wide effects.
Gravitational wave science is rapidly evolving and presents exciting opportunities for discovering unknown phenomena in the universe. Recent confirmations indicate that the entire universe might be vibrating due to unknown sources.
Did it stop though? Could this be the true nature of the "quantum foam"? Brownian motion is just gravitational ripples? Weird particles popping in and out of existence, is just the fabric of the universe experience gravitational wave interference, going to an "excited" state.
Without some kind of universal memory, cycle of creation and destruction wouldn't be so perfect.
mass can be measured in radians in a rotating universe, with a net time of 0. G(c^2/r). this means the four fundamental forces are a product of the inverse relationship between time and rotation, to conserve momentum. This gives rise to a observable universe of one radian. This equations is from my unifying theory.
Fascinating!
so many physics breakthrough incoming....🔥
The Universe Thinks Therefore It Is
It thinks through us. we are the tools that make it conscious of itself
@@robertunderwood1011yes but we are more than us
The universe thinks therefore we are
Cheers, Anton 🙏 🫡🖖
Interesting makes me think that you could detect more waves if you knew how to control for the gravitational change to masses there must be an energy difference that's detectable
You make each one better then the last
A fair amount of micro-waves from the effects of large sources, such as neutron stars and singularity interactions and formations could just end up being ringing of the gravitationally bound molecules with the much larger energy levels of the incoming gravitational waves.
Additionally, one could potentially see what's initially thought to be these memories, of which I'm extremely dubious of for conservation of energy and entropy reasons, which instead would be merely precession and similar effects of neutron stars "lumpy" regions, which slowly will "settle" over time via neutron starquakes. Otherwise, that energy would accumulate and well, the universe would end up with all matter glowing from accumulated "memory" gravitational energy that magically doesn't seek a lower energy level.
When humans are long gone, I wonder what memory imprint we will leave on the universe with all our A.I. creations that will outlive us.
Probably a scar so deep the universe will wilt.
This is pretty darn cool
Electric magnetic vibrations have sounds,if you have large enough magnets and spin them around each other,there’s actually a buzzing sound emitting from them,everything is energy,frequency and vibration.
Correct! 🙂 Everything is--in simplistic essence--a wave of some type. Light, Sound, Gravity, "Brain" (or mind--whatever)... just to name four of many.
*Reflection is key.*
🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨
"Before I start, I must see my end. Destination known, my mind's journey now begins. Upon my chariot, heart and soul's fate revealed. In time, all points converge; hope's strength resteeled. But to earn final peace at the universe's endless refrain, we must see all in nothingness... before we start again."
🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨
--Diamond Dragons (series)
@ if we could listen to every sound the universe creates and do a soundtrack it would be hypnotic and amazing!.
@@MsCrazylegs80 More so than that alone, at a molecular level, particles would "arrange themselves". 💪😎✌️ This, btw, is NOT some random, unsubstantiated theory; it's precisely what happens upon that atomic plane. It's also akin to how--for example--particles of salt set upon a speaker drum vibrating at 432Hz (or "X" or "Y" Hz) will organize into semi-geometric latticework. No, it's not IDENTICAL, but that's the super short, truncated explanation. Certain frequencies produce "nothing much", while others are... attuned! Attuned upon celestial frequencies. No joke.
*Reflection is key.*
🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨
"Before I start, I must see my end. Destination known, my mind's journey now begins. Upon my chariot, heart and soul's fate revealed. In time, all points converge; hope's strength resteeled. But to earn final peace at the universe's endless refrain, we must see all in nothingness... before we start again."
🐲✨🐲✨🐲✨
--Diamond Dragons (series)
5:25 an inventor listens and finds a memory that hasn’t been had before. We listen and expand the relative naturally. Similar to nature and stuff.
I don't understand the notion of permanent changes to space time if other intersecting gravitational waves alter the changes to space time created by earlier waves. Or do changes to space time never intersect/overlap?
The question is: What is change, if it exists "sub species aeternitas"? It is a confusing idea that being and eternity imply permanence, whereas the present and existence imply impermanence.
@RamondeMey What does whatever you mean have to do with gravitational waves?
I can assume that this memory is from lost energy, like if mass of two black hole system is M, mass after collision of is M-dm (dm=energy lost in collision due to g. waves ~ few solar masses), than we should have less gravity from merged black hole (da = -G dm/R^2).
Pretty hard to measure disappearing of few solar masses from another galaxy
Could Dark Matter just be permanent space-time fabric distortions, accumulated over a very very long time?
This is what I've suspected for some time. Take a look at the bullet cluster. If you have two massive objects suddenly merge, they decelerate but what happens to the surrounding spacetime? It decelerates too but to a lesser degree due to the fluid-like nature of space.
Form implies memory and the first atoms that were created incorporated EM with spin giving rise to form/memory, mass, time and consciousness.
He made an analogy of gravitational waves, to waves in a pond and how they were similar! Waves on water or in a pond, when colliding with other waves from different directions have a tendency of canceling each other out! Do gravitational waves do the same thing? If you have gravitational waves colliding from different directions, do they have a canceling affect on each other? If so, would this have an effect on how we perceive the wave?
As time passes, more mass/gravity waves are coming to our observable universe.
At the same time, the universe is expanding with the increase of dark energy.
I really think their is a connection between the 2.
Thanks for the video! I’m not sure I understand how the memory could be consistent to the original formation of the wave when the universe is constantly expanding, the wave is constantly moving through matter and they’re wave spreads as it travels much like the ripples in the pond. Those things might only change the wave slightly but if it changes at all it’s not a fact.
Might it be that gravitational wave memory could explain the rotation curves of galaxies (what most astro-physicists explain with dark matter)? Where gravity is really small (for example the outer regions of galaxies) even slight curvature of the spacetime would change what gravity every mass "sees". And if gravitational wave memory is like a frozen wave on a pond we would have a certain spacetime curvature because of this effect (or did I understand gravitational wave memory completely wrong?). If this is correct, gravitational wave memory might even explain gravitational lensing (for example as seen in the bullet cluster). What do you think?
Well gravitational memory on top of one huge one, the big bang!
In a certain sense, the universe is already known to have memory. The universe has us. We have memory. So the universe has memory. More interestingly, since we know we have memory, and we can create memory on physical media, it is obvious that the universe has the capability for memory. Then, since it contains forms with memory, forms that are far less complex than itself; it stands to reason that the universe at least could have memory. I would be surprised if it did not.
So it's sort of like a vinyl record, so we need a very, very small space record needle to read all the dips and rises.
❤✌️
literal universal consciousness and memory~!
A wave can only travel at the speed of light, thus, the shape of the event producing it is still there, but diluted/diminishing. It could be hypothetically possible to measure several far places in the universe for all possible patterns from all possible sources, and back-engineer where they came from, and what caused it.
Like a record player reading the grooves of gravitational waves?
Speed of light has yet to be confirmed outside of an earth based experiment using an artificial start and finish as a measurement must start at its beginning in space time and end at its termination of its space time.
@@richardotier6820Why is it called an oven when you of in the cold food of out hot eat the food?
Perhaps, gravity waves passing over plates, could cause virtual pairs to not be reabsorbed into space, thus transferring some gravity wave energy into making virtual particals into real particals.
Thus, matter inside planets, between layers of crystals metal etc, could cause matter creation within planets.
Thus black holes can transfer their masses into planets throughout the universe, thus EXPANDING PLANETS.
Thus an EXPANDING EARTH is possible.
Super interesting video. Exciting times for physics. I note that gravitons weren't mentioned once. Do you think the discovery of gravitational wave memory would be proof against the existence of gravitons?
Anton Petrov likens the effect of gravitational waves on the "fabric" of space-time to a change in the mass of a pond resulting from dropping stone pebbles into the pond. He is describing the "configuration of space-time fabric" (or features in space and time) being affected by waves of energy passing through time and space, because mass is a property of energy. He then equates space-time (itself) with the waves passing through it in order to express the idea that the configuration (or fabric) of space and time can change or remember. However, I disagree with labeling these changes or memories "non-linear" because that only implies a denial, which is not positive knowledge of changes in the features in space and time by gravitational waves in being, as opposed to gravitational waves in the present, or in other words gravitational waves in existence (using the traditional distinction between being and existence in philosophy).
Can't wait til gravitational topography becomes a thing that physicists acknowledge
Remember might be a big word. Matter might tell spacetime how to curve... but how does it uncurve?
Two questions:
1) I heard, if one does a double slit experiment shooting one particle at a time with a noticeable time interval before the next particle, the particles seem to know the path of the previous particles and scatter as the double slit experiment expects. Could the space through which a particle move remember the path of the particle so the next particle knows the path of the previous particle because of some gravitational affect?
2) I heard, the quantum foam is highly energetic. Could this energetic nature be the result of gravitational wave interference patterns at the quantum level?
5:04 so the collapse is like inward and relative towards each other and the connection can increase difference and cause different explosions of reality because it’s relative. Weird way to say it
So spacetime can permanently deform (theoretically)? Is that basically what you’re saying? If so I wonder if it depends on the amplitude of the wave. Thinking like the deformation curve of certain metals, it’s linear in a certain region and will snap back, but after a certain amount of deformation it enters a nonlinear region and can “get stuck” in a deformed state.
Leaves me wondering if the accumulation of gravitational waves, over the length of time of the universe's existence, and the resulting reshaping of the fabric of the universe, could result in the filaments, nodes and voids in the cosmic web.
I'm listed as an author by Caltech on the LIGO project. I did the design for LIGO's pick-off telescope, seven of the end mass telescopes (used as beam expanders and not as conventional telescopes), the surface calibration device for the return mirrors and others.
Having thought a lot about LOGO and physics in general, namely the double slit expriments that I believe were solved in my book, "Infinity, Time, Death and Thought", I disagree with the illustrations of gravitational waves propagating outward from neutron stars or black holes revolving around each other.
How can gravitational waves be shown moving outward when gravity is an attractive force that's pulling matter inward? It seems to me that matter would be pulled inward rather than exerting an outward wave. How can these waves be shown like waves radiating outward in all the illustrations I've seen? This makes no sense.
Also, gravitational waves are not gravity waves and gravitons are nonsense. Gravitational waves would require a carrier such as the waves we see in water or waves carried through air for us to hear. There is no carrier in which "waves" can be propagated in the vacuum of space, other than speculation that the ether has made a comeback in some scientific circles.
Photonic wave memory, magnetic wave memory, they all work. problem is measurement. If we use photons as data, then we can use electromagnetic interactions with photons as memory and be able to measure it. Gravitational waves will make more sense when science accepts plasma and electromagnetic properties of the universe as affecting "gravity waves".
If we can read these could we possibly produce a picture of the past which could essentially be a form of time travel or having an exact record of our past?
Spacetime is a medium for matter, just as water is a medium for fish. It propagates waves, and can stretch and contract. Its just not as easy to manipulate.
Dark matter is correlation to spacetime being a medium, we dont need darkmatter, its spacetime itself moving being dragged by the matter of a galaxy.
Where else would the information sucked into black holes go. It must be in the ejections and gravitational waves created by the black hole.
A wave will take a path that minimizing energy and travel time so I’m sure it’s creates a memory or path of least resistance
As a poster has suggested, the vibrations may be from magnetism or light. I feel the construction techniques evident in Ireland's towers with openings above head level must be connected to an Earth resonance but, did this resonance originate at the surface and migrate UP? Or is it being adjusted DOWN?
Or gravity is the effect of the ether (or could be named sub-quantic matter because this matter is different as it is infinitely fractal) flowing and then "pushing" everything concentrically into astral bodies (invalidating Michelson-Morley experiments because they inferred that the ether was static while it is not). Given that this model of the Universe is validated in the future, I might want to precise that I understood this in 1979; I wrote a text about it on a physic student publication when I was a student back then and then I went to play on other interesting things like for example inventing a new correlation coefficient still around the same time when I was a student - published only on UA-cam much later as a trace of this invention in case it can be useful in some fields of research ;) - and kept my main priorities in life (now retired).
So, there is no void, and everything is in touch with everything. The SQM vibrates like anything else in the Universe and the SQM wide range of waves frequencies are part of the electromagnetic waves that we observe. BTW, in that model, dilation of time is a misinterpretation of facts; it is an illusion as the SQM variations in its flow toward a planet or star, as it gets closer to them, affect the rate of the frequencies of any atom surrounding the planet or stars. And frequencies of some atoms are at the source and reference of the atomic clocks so called measure of time...
We can remember, therefore the universe can.
Exactly.
That misses the point perfectly
Can a rock remember? Dirt??? A seashell? It’s a pretty saying, superficially…..
@@ikarienator by no means does it miss the point lol
@ I can’t remember 😂
Does it remember it's beginning? Does it remember if it had siblings? Does it remember bumping into other universes?
Imagine the BBs gravity wave , it probably contributed to the expansion.
If every change in gravitation is printed in the universe, the could we work backwards to see in the past based on waves only?
Can the discovery of the graviton be far off? Exciting times!
One more doctoral subject: gravitational archéology !!!! Where do I sign ???
The nucleus of the galaxy is a tumbling blackhole radiating mass out from its poles. The energy and gases condense to form galactic arms, a continuous production.
You have micro gravity, like two atoms. Why don't they always have to mash? So there might be lumpyness. This let's information sit at waypoints in the lumpiness. So its like a computer, a > b ? Move a, c. However, the information is so ultra fine and dense, unless you channel higher dimensions, you'd suppose it was a 10^5,000 meter cubed. But you simply close a steal door to a server farm and check all the temperatures, then open the steal door, and look at your watch, it accelerates at the second^4, just like light and electricity, the lumpiness knows the servers changed the room relative to the outer environment at some dielectric rate of change. Certainly the earth and planets 1/64,000 don't account for the crystal invariance.
Anton, would this mean that the universal constants will change just a bit in a just a bit of time?
🙋🏽♀️anton everyday
Gravitational waves mean a gravitational field. How large are these waves? thanks
Yes it can. Next question.
if the universe is in a blackhole how come we can't see our blackhole??
never sort anton’s comment section by new bro
Although the mechanism is different, homeopatic memory (memory of a molecule previously present in water), is something similar.
Except is does not exist at all.
Could the vibration of the universe be from the original big bang?
What if matter creates and expels an existence state every time it changes and perceives the discarded existence as gravity.
So… Einstein suggested gravitational waves were possible but didn’t think they could be detected. He also suggested that stimulated emission of radiation was possible… So, lasers, which he predicted, were used to detect gravitational waves which he also predicted.