SARDAR UDHAM | Movie Reaction 3 & Review! | Vicky Kaushal | Shoojit Sircar
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 жов 2021
- Reaction Gear: amzn.to/2QgTwk2 (affiliate link)
____________________
Intro music by DAVIS
UA-cam - bit.ly/30OK7RR
Spotify - spoti.fi/2I3vRvE
iTunes: apple.co/2KnvgYN
SoundCloud: / unofficialdavis
Facebook: / unofficialdavis
Twitter: / unofficialdavis
Instagram: / unofficialdavis
___
Jamazing Patrons of October: Krishna Venkataraman, Avijit Singh, Madhan, Bhavya Singh, Sameer, Akash Dhanasekar, Riju Mahna and Shean Roldhan!
Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
/ jabykoay
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~ACHARA KIRK~
Twitter & Instagram: @AcharaKirk
/ achara
~JABY KOAY~
UA-cam, Twitter, Instagram: @jabykoay
~VEERENDRA CHOWDARY~
Veerendra Chowdary created the opening animation.
Twitter: @NameisVeeru
~MOOSA RAZA~
Moosa Raza created additional background animation.
Instagram: @syedraza7
Twitter: @MoosaRaza27
___________________________________________________
Jaby WEST:
/ getjaby
Jaby ASIA:
/ jabytv
JABY KOAY'S SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
ua-cam.com/users/subscription_c...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Intro song: Hudson Stanton (looks more like Nick Jonas than me)
UA-cam: / hudson12311
Insta: / hudsonstantonmusicsardar UDHAM | Vicky Kaushal | Shoojit Sircar | Movie Reaction (Part 2)! - Комедії
This movie got rejected for Oscars, BECAUSE it projects hatred towards Britishers.🙂
Don't wanna sound rude but maybe another film that got selected might be better than this right? It's a competition and we don't know... Maybe... 'Maybe'
One more worst decision by Jury
They're just jealous or maybe not strong enough to accept what they did with us.
And no one is raising voice against it
@@user-hw8zg8zo1v Problem is not that it is rejected, problem is that the movie is rejected on the basis of this lame reason.
The most appreciable fact about the movie is that the feeling of patriotism was not forced upon the audience, which is the case with most movies in bollywood. There were no over-the-top dialogues and no patriotic song. The emotion coveyed was very pure and raw and the credit for the same goes to the strong cinematography of the film. Definitely a masterpiece!!!
Definitely the best aspect of this movie.
I agree. And I only kept thinking one thing the entire movie, that how the hell did Udham Singh have so much patience and determination. He lived through Jallianwala Bagh and he was so determined to complete his mission, even when he knew that the Britishers will hide every fact about him and his sacrifice. Facing the man responsible for the death of his brothers and having the patience to work in his house, having a normal conversation everyday, pretending that everything is fine. How did he get that much patience, I'll never know. Salute to all the freedom fighters of our country! This movie truly makes you feel the sacrifice and struggle for our independence.
U r so right, forced nationalism is just fascism
Jaise ki abhi satyamev jayate 2 aari hai mtlb kuch bhi banaya hai
And the protagonist not randomly singing a patriotic song is what made me love it even more
Trust me that “KOI ZINDA HAI ?”!!!! Hits very powerfully … and in the end Bhagat Singh pic in his hand sent chills through my spine and cried more and more 😭😭😭
The massacre was done on the day of Baisakhi - an important Sikh festival. It is the solar new year and also a spring harvest festival of Punjab. Additionally, Baisakhi is also the day the tenth Guru of Sikhs - Guru Gobind Singh Ji - created the new Khalsa order of Sikhs which was a casteless fraternity.
It's kinda like a massacre on Christmas eve.
I've heard that Gandhiji still said that people didn't co-operate with the Britishers the way it should have been! Is it true?
@@beingaPrince yeah he did
@@beingaPrince Well I am not here to defend Gandhi. But educated Indians of Punjab probably know, shoot at sight orders were there at that time in Punjab. So....
Not gonna lie I am not a fan of Gandhi that much.
Mr Gandhi has not done anything for us
@@KumarAyushman2006 No, they tried to co-operate and take permission but British won't listen
This movie doesn't need an Oscar to be appreciated, will be always a masterpiece for us 😭😭😞😞
IMDB rating of 9.2. Who cares about the stupid Oscar's anymore.
So truly said!! A masterpiece is always a masterpiece, whether you want to accept it or not!! 💐💐☮️☮️
Oscars has no value now.... It's stupid. Nobody cares. This year Oscar viewers fell by 50% or so
Yes ❤️
Who said that bollywood don't make good movies?
Actually, Irrfan Khan was supposed to play the lead role. Vicky said, "Replacing Irrfan Khan for Sardar Udham is my tribute to Irrfan, an actor whom I love and admire"
Great info...didn't knew it thanks bro
Yeah Vicky himself told about this in the Kapil Sharma show
This fact broke my heart even more.....
And how good of a job he's done. No disrespect to the great irrfan but its hard to imagine him in place of vicky as sardar udham singh
It's in the Amazon video trivia section.. It was supposed to be Irfan but he declined due to his deteriorating health.....
People who say "Bollywood doesn't make good movies" should definitely watch this ...
No over the top action, dialogues,
It was pure Goosebumps
We not all are good one
Especially....films like of Salman Khan make ...is just....you know
True people hating bollywood is just another trend
@@garimasuhani7227 haven't you seen Bajrangi Bhaijaan, Veer, Dabang, his tens of old movies. Don't oppose him based on few bad movies
This film doesn't classify as a Bollywood movie as it was not cringe. This is an international movie intend for eveyone to see not only indians
An important fact to mention. They only stopped firing because they ran out of bullets.
For us indians, Britishers are no different from Nazis and imperial Japanese. German and Japanese feels guilty and asked for forgiveness, but so called great Britain and its citizens are shamelessly proud of their cruelty on us.
Also most of them don't know about the deeds of their previous generations😔
@@atuldalai9271 thats the real problem. They dont even call it invasion but call it civilising.
@Akhand Bharat Even if we agree with their side of the facts, what about the cruelties; what kind of mindset do they have?
Imperial japan was pretty cool, only non white superpower.
@@allarjun956 like they did in continents of americas and liberated themselves from their people in England 🤣🤣🤣
"The Sun never set on British Empire because in Dark Even the God didn't Trust them" The dialogue always hits hard!
Shashi Tharoor!!!!
@@Lyallpuriya Nalanda and Taxilla were some of the biggest universities and hotspots for education at about 5th century BC in present day Bihar. Irrigation system?? Lol Ever heard of the Indus valley civilization, its said to have better irrigation system than nowadays, and Freedom?? Freedom to do what?? Looks like someone never read history, actually its not ur fault when u r not taught this entire piece of dark history as it would belittle ur country. And yeahh railways is the only valid point u made even though they made it for their own benefits
@@toomanythoughts2 he won’t answer you.
@@Lyallpuriya reply back man…
@@krislv9219 leave it! He knows he was bullshiting
As a matter of fact the British Government awarded O. Dyer 26000 rupees for his act of valor at the Jalianwala bagh. The amount after inflation adjustment stands to Rs.140 million rupees in 2021
Wow. That really paints the picture of the British Snobbish Evil.
Crore mein likh na
Oh damn.....no limits to their inhumanity
They awarded 26000 pounds (not rupees) from a fund collected in England to Reginald Dyer (the officer who gave the orders to fire), not O' Dwyer who was assassinated by Udham Singh.
It is so fullfilling to see this movie evoke such emotion in people who are not from India let alone not from Punjab. This one is truly a masterpeice
It's a crime against humanity....i cried n cried.....
The director Shoojit Sircar is from Bengal
Yet he presented Punjab in such an authentic way, especially Jallianwala bagh scene. The sets, costumes, language, people, so authentic
Being a Punjabi, I totally felt connected to it. Hats off!
Shoojit Sircar are one of the few director from Bengal who didn't include politics in there film otherwise every film from Bengali director is full of politics
@@modithewokebutcher.9855 not all.
Gulati ji a 3rd gen bengali takes care of jalianwala bag for decades .
@@saibalbh31 but most regional film maker are and offcourse bollywood commercial producer
@@modithewokebutcher.9855 it's not relevant to mention a complete movie industry as "logicless" btw every movie industry has its own set of masterpiece movies and own set of crap movies also. You people just see some movies and judge whole industry as logicless. Not right . Period!!
This is the first time that Jallianwala bagh massacre is shown with such clarity.
No filmmaker ever had vision to make this.
By watching these scenes, we can feel the pain but what in real people had to go through was the real pain
It's extremely accurate. Similar to the massacre scenes in Ben Kingsley's "Gandhi" film.
The Legend of Bhagat Singh also shows it well, so much so that when rang de basanti was being made the director asked Raj Kumar Santoshi if he can use the Jallianwalla Bagh scene from the legend as he did not think he could do better and it made into the Rang de basanti film.
I cannot even imagine the mental agony they gone through!!
this one is the most graphical representation of the massacre. didnt let me sleep for a whole week
@itrader aur kese lega comments section mai Gyan chod ke
The scene with the water is a purification. Holy water purifies you.. it’s like a rebirth. He did in fact completely change as a person. His innocence was lost that night and he lived from that moment onwards for revenge and to drive freedom forward.
Being a Sikh and an Indian....We should never forget our history of what we have been through. And always move for the best possible future with wellness of the human kind not any specific sect or region....and fight for whatever happens wrong. God bless all the lives lost in Jaliya wala bagh. Waheguru❤️
I personally think that whatever is happening with Punjab and the youth of Punjab whatever is happening right now they think they are doing something what Bhagat Singh did what chandrasekhar aazad did what sukhdev did what Subhash Chandra Bose did they think they are opposing brutality of government but they are in totally different situation and intentions are totally different i respect every Sikh person i am proud that I was born on gurupurab but the youth is getting brainwash in current sinario people need to see the reality and reality needed to prove itself always
@@jaysharma815yes as a punjab resident i can say this is 💯% true they try to like act like them they follow some random peoples who misguide them with inappropriate speeches about government and try to act like they are following the path of Bhagat singh yet i can confidently say that they dont even know birth date of Bhagat or even who Sardar udham singh was
THE SAD NEWS IS, they just rejected this movie for Oscar entry, they claim that it's creating hatred against British. But surprisingly the movie of Winston Churchill wins the best actor award. Idk how much hipocracy people are craving for, that's ridiculous. And it's painful coz this story was meant to reach a lot of people and is till date the best bollywood has delivered.
“They” is the jury of film federation of India. Indian committee rejected it and decided not to send it for oscars.
The juries for the Oscars are mostly European Britishers they will deny this movie out of there bias
@@Embracing_Impermanance that's why marlon Brando rejected oscar
Thats whychinese and russians have disregard for the west.
@@Embracing_Impermanance INDIAN jury didn't send it to Oscars not the English Jury. and Indian Jury is filled with bootlickers of current govt and they didn't want this movie to gain International audience because the messages and themes are still relevant today in India
Sad to know this movie is rejected from the list of India's official entry in Oscars.
Whattt??? Why??? What’s the criteria for entering the Oscars? This was a great movie!!
@@Achara Because it shows British in bad light😑
Obviously they're gonna give the stupid nepotism films for Oscars
@@dhruvilist for real?? That’s stupid. Schindler’s list showed the Germans in a bad light and it won an Oscar 😤
@@Achara The movie Showed Britishers in a Bad light, this judgement was made by an Indian !! That's the most shoking Fact !!
I'll just put this out simply : The Jallianwalla Bagh Massacre shown in the Sardar Udham film, is by far the best and most intense depictions to have ever seen the day of light.
I had previously brokedown watching the same event depicted in Anushka Sharma's Phillauri. But compared to this, that was nothing. I cried for an whole hour after watching this ending, and felt immense pain in my heart and soul for all the people who lost their lives under the British Raj. My heart goes out to anybody who lived through this trauma. God bless all the revolutionaries who gave their lives for the freedom of this nation and its people.
One of the major things with the movie was the lack of uniform source material. Essentially, built from bits and pieces of records - They had this idea more than 20 years ago and since then have steadily been researching and piecing together pieces of Sardar Udham's life.
The non-linear storytelling actually alludes to this so you are experiencing the movie in the way the filmmakers slowly unraveled his life. I'll forever compliment Shoojit Sircar's genius for taking this "disadvantage" and turning it into a story-telling device.
It is why the emotional core - and primary motivation - for Sardar Udham's later actions and dedication is kept at the end.
The line about the official apology. Is the deepest.
Exactly..like how could they not give us an apology yet
I literally sobbed at that part
Udham singh was serving water during jallianwala bagh massacre but movie didnt show tht but why?
@@nischesharma the movie did show it
@@ucd389 no they didnt hwle was sleeping in movie but he qas serving water at bagh
FYI, This movie isn't allowed to be inducted as a nominee for an Oscar because it shows Britishers in bad light. It shows hatred towards them.
Also, the role of Sardar Udham Singh was first to be enacted by Late Irrfan Khan.. but due to his unfortunate demise.. Vicky was chosen and he is too damn good.
do you know the people who shot were soldiers from Gorkha regiment. once again, it is a Bengali who rejected this movie for the Oscars. thats indian history in a nut shell. our own people are biggest traitors.
The film markers and Amazon can still submit the movie to the oscars for categories like best actor, best director, best cinematography etc . I believe this film will win one or two categories at the oscars
@@leomorgan2783 let's see.. as of the film federation of India has sent another movie for the nomination
@@SINGH3KING yes but the film markers and Amazon can still submit the movie independently. Suriya sir did the same for soorai potru . We need to appeal to shoojit sir to submit it directly to the oscars
@@sagarkothari5218 Yes the movie was not sent to Oscars for whatever reasons they thought were fit, but you don't need to point out what culture the person of the film federation belonged to. And even if you still want to point that out, please realise, the director of this movie is also a Bengali.
Also, the Gorkha Regiment consisted of soldiers from the ethnic community Gurkha of Nepal. So again, not exactly Indians :) That was why Dyer used the Gorkhas instead of the Indian soldiers.
You raised a very interesting point.. in my entire schooling the sheer brutality of British raj was missing.. it's only Gandhi and congress throughout . We did not get our freedom without blood lost.. the British wiped atleast 6 million indians.. and they remain unapologetic for their actions ...
every tear in your eyes shows how much u love and respect humanity and have pain for injustice done by some psychic people across the world from time to time. I am from Punjab and I am proud to be SIKH. Holds great respect for my people who have attained martyrdom from time to time. Sikh history is full of such incidents, its just coming up now. You must read the Sikh History right from the masters time. Love for you guys.
THE FACT THAT THERE IS NO OFFICIAL APOLOGY TILL NOW IS JUST MIND-BLOWING
Mind-blowing??? Isn't it rather appalling? 😤
Main bittu
@@nikhilpolekar8325 they mean mind blowing in a negative way.
They can take their apology up their ass.
Is an apology too much for them, I mean ya after killing thousands of people mercilessly they can't even owe us an apology for anything.. btw there was no apology for the bhopal gas tragedy too
Nothing happened after his death, every one was buzzy with their battle for freedom! There are several forgotton heroes in the freedom struggle of India
Udham singh jiserve kar rahe tha paani jallianwala main lekin kyun ni batya
He was not forgotten, there is a district In Uttarakhand named after him.. that is one of the places I knew him from, before the movie came out.. the last part of movie was just heart wrenching...
Dont you know that in 80s after a very long time British India returned that martyr's cremated body and whole India was praising and not a single needle point was vacant on roads on his cremation in India.
@@divyanshujoshi yes I live here. Its Udham Singh Nagar
All they remember is gandhi and stupid nehru
Udham Singh, Bhagat Singh, Chandrashekhar Azad all members of the HSRA were dedicated communists, this is something that Indian cinema seems to skip because of the Red Scare and stuff but this movie did an amazing job at not hiding the true legacy of the Indian anti-colonial struggle (which was largely left wing)
They weren't communists.
Do you read history from WhatsApp?
@@bhavikbhatt8346 just say you have never read any of Bhagat Singh’s works or anything about the HSRA’s ideology (scientific socialism/Marxism) they were extremely dedicated communists. On Lenin’s death anniversary in 1930, Bhagat Singh said: “ON LENIN DAY WE SEND HEARTY GREETINGS TO ALL who are doing something for carrying forward the ideas of the great Lenin. We wish success to the great experiment Russia is carrying out. We join our voice to that of the international working class movement. The proletariat will win. Capitalism will be defeated. Death to Imperialism.” It doesn’t get much more communist than this.
@@bhavikbhatt8346 and the last book Bhagat Singh read before he was martyred was a biography of Lenin. Read his works, you will understand whether these people were communists or not.
@@bhavikbhatt8346 idiot, every one of the big revolutionary name you know, was a dedicated communist.
A dedicated anti imperialist.
A dedicated Marxist.
You can cry and tear out your hair, but facts will remain facts.
Only an ideology like communism can initiative rebellion and revolution against imperialist.
That small passage shown in the movie is the only way to exit and it was blocked by them so there’s no way for the people to get out.
There was a well in the ground People jumped in that to save their life but that eventually killed them because it was filled to top with bodies. Can you even imagine??
You can still see the bullet holes in the houses if you can visit the place.
The only difference between brits and Hitler...Brits won the war and wrote their history. I never see any difference between the two of that era
You are disturbingly right!
Difference between Germany and England, Germans accepted their atrocity, but England made themselves heroes.
@@arjungautam478 Yes.
@@arjungautam478 yes
@@arjungautam478 karma will hit back harder just wait and watch.
This is the first time I am seeing Jaby this emotional .
I think he was emotional when he seen that stand-up by sundeep sharma about his dad.
in 27:49 yup you are right also there is another reference wanted to tell you that when he was Hanged in London Prison his Body dies out but when he was taking a Dip in water near Golden Temple after Traumatic Events his Soul Dies...... thats the Beauti of the story...
indian can feel the pain of there blood.
Only intelligent people explore other cultures like this. Even though it may be difficult to watch at times, you two now have the knowledge of what happened, and you will pass that down to your children. THIS is the most important thing. Just think how hard this was to watch, and then try to imagine how the victims felt.... This is why it's great to learn about these things, so that you pass the best traits to your kids. You both are good people, and THANK YOU!
The Nobel laureate Rabindranath Tagore also returned his “nighthood” title after this incident.
Jallianwala Massacre - Every Indian has read about it, heard about it or has seen it in many movies before. But what this movie does brilliantly is, show it like no one has ever shown it before.
True. This movie, along with showing the massacre, also shows the aftermath and shows the trauma udham faced.
U didn't get it. Loss is loss but what year ???? Plz can say
This is the most important lesson that they don’t tell you about freedom. We take freedom for granted today. Freedom isn’t a right, it’s a privilege, for which many have laid down their lives. The massacre scene left most of us soulless. We have studied about it in school, and seen in movies, but it’s always put up in a simple way that the English came fired and killed so many. I think this is the first time someone has tried to show us what happened post the firing.
I love and completely agree with that line "Freedom isn't a right, it's a privilege". It's a thing that was given to us by the sacrifice of our freedom fighters.
But Rights and Humanity is Most Important things in Life
Ikr the rescue mission at night was more heart wrenching than the massacre itself 😭
So scary
You are absolutely right. This is why my blood boils whenever I see the widespread dishonesty amongst us Indians and the bribery system that exists in our country. Sometimes I feel we do not deserve the freedom given to us by our great predecessors.
"Revolutionary are not terrorist"😭😭
They all were saying this that time but no one listened them and killed them
The toddler looking for his "Bebe" (mother) broke me completely ! I watched the movie this evening, and I have a toddler that age ! I have been crying since evening, with absolutely disgusting and unwarranted thoughts entering my head every 10 mins ! About that toddler in Jallianwala Bagh ! About my own son !
Even most of the indian didn't know who *Udham Singh* is. This movie needed to be made! Thanks to Soojit Sircar! ❤️
U r soooooooooooooooooooo wrong. Majority Indians know about udham singh. Its not everyday and Indian killing British in Britain.
@@aanchalfinwoman I don't agree. Most the people are aware about Bhagat Singh, People are being taught about him in History classes, but not that much of importance is given on Udham Singh, so it is obvious for most of the people not to be aware of him that much. Not saying everyone, but there are a lot.
@@mdnajam7 Yeah never heard about him in school though
@@user-hf2qh5ck7j Yes, even me too.
I’ve known him for 20 years now
Yes Achara, apparently everyone who gathered was killed. And they didn't stop until there ammunition was exhausted. They were carrying thousands of rounds.
That’s horrific! It’s just so hard to get my mind around that people did that to people who were not being violent in any way.
It was baisakhi (festival) when this massacre happened. The crowd had baisakhi pilgrims along with protesters.
@@Achara don't you dare call them people. I love you achara and forgive my words but DON'T DARE CALL OR THINK OF THEM AS HUMANS. Brits still has those colonial mindset even today. They deny and justify all of thier crimes to this day
@@rhythmkhandelwal2940 theresa may apologised for that massacre in april 2019 in their parliament
@@jog.antani didn't looked like an apology by her attitude it was more like a forced apology not from heart
one of best reactions of film! the film was just heavy on emotions it just brought out the tears 😔😔 just beautiful and you having loved it makes directors efforts more worth it!
Some flim doesn't need Oscar...that flims can't be judged by awards sardar udham singh is one of them
The most heartbreaking scene in movie history. End of the conversation.
watch schindlers list, the pianist
@@20tejas so it wasn't emotional for you?
@@kaze.14 it was 'Jallianwala bagh incident' ....it's more than just an emotional movie scene.
@@prateekgrewal4717 it was heartbreaking not emotional understanding the context of the comment.
@@prateekgrewal4717 Being emotional and boldly claiming "The most heartbreaking scene in movie history. End of the conversation" are totally different things. This scene is heart breaking, very very sad, horrifying scene for sure but dont say it is the most heartbreaking scene in movie history.
Not being able to find her body makes it even more authentic and real, as there were millions of people to find from
And his words that he went to find his own and later realised that everyone was his own
Haa bhaii 🥺
Omg....goosebumps💔💔💔
Thousands not millions
Around 400 something was the actual count. Not millions.
@@NC-hu3ti British wrote it themselves they wanted to keep numbers as small as possible
Hamarai yaha jalsai mai 400 loog nhi aatai
Sadly my grandfather‘s father was also the person who died in Jallianwala Bagh Hi actually climbed in the wheels as they see in the clip and he was about 50 to 60 years
Finally Bollywood crossed the Hollywood by this masterpiece...
The soilders who shot the civilians were from gorkha regiment that got recruited from nepal in that period and small section of soilders were from baloch regiment mordern day Baluchistan... So they were not directly associated with india during that time.. They were more of british servants and indian feelings hardly mattered to them. General Dyer knew if he appointed indian soilders to do this task. They might not do it.
If i was in that place be it people from any country i wouldnt do it i mean there are little kids. I would aim my gun at the general and kill him first,later i will be okay wih the punishment i get. This is how i feel everytime i watch this scene.
@@yashvi2048
But there are people like them .
Forget that.. people kill n rape brutally in riots that occur almost once in 2-3 years.
Absolutely right 👍
they were non punjabi british indian soldiers acting against punjabis.. majority were gorkhas
@@Riversfrndshipforum Seems like you didn't read my comment .
The last photo in his hand ,is of real legend Bhagat singh when he was in jail....🙏They use the real picture of Shaheed Bhagat singh ji in the movie...
Yes , that is the actual last pic of Bhagat Singh..
The best line is this was a small footnote in some book
Really puts history in perspective
So much of history is viewed from single point of view
"Funeral is for the one who is surviving not for the one who died". 👏👏👏 Loved it
Yasssss...absolutely true. Great one by jaby.
Actually no it's not. It's for helpful for the living to break away the connection - true but it's utmost important for the atmaan which is why our days and customs go on for so long. At least in Indian tradition, if you are going through processions you should know why we do this because if you don't then you'll end up making up stupid reasons and philosophies behind it which doesn't even suit our worldview just like you are doing now. That means after a while people will start giving advice about changing them based on false assumptions and false equivalences based on imported philosophies that are fundamentally opposed to our worldview. A recent example: People giving unsolicited advice about kanya-daan when they don't even know what it is and think it means giving away a daughter which is actually stupid. Better leave your traditions if you don't know or understand your customs but at least don't spread misunderstanding and corrupt it.
Even I know not to give a sermon about Japanese or Korean tradition without knowing their underlying worldview and reasonings but people in India have lost their capacity for wisdom and independent thinking and are hell-bent on corrupting and cleansing what remaining knowledge is still intact. This country is already facing intellectual bankruptcy, we don't need to create more opportunities. The British have anyways won in what they came to do since I do hear Indian people speaking the same language that the colonizers did and I am not talking about English here.
@@Priya-cm3tr I would say funeral is equally important for for both dead person and the surviving loved ones
That quote is so old. It’s not originally Jaby’s
Well actually I wanted to stay away from the debate...but in Hindu tradition...we burn our dead because we believe in Atman..and the logic behind it is meant for the dead...obviously Jaby is right in his own way. But I agree with Priya here.
Such a shame that two foreigners are shell shocked about the hard hitting fact of the movie but our own jury doesn't think it is good enough for oscars.
Stop glorifying Oscars, nobody cares about them.
@@jujulila2211 true dat
@@jujulila2211 yeah! I owe Oscars for introducing me to a great list of movies. But that thread ended there.
Indian Jury is filled with bootlickers of current govt and they didn't want this movie to gain International audience because the messages and themes are still relevant today in India
@@ArthurKnight1899 Messages amd themes are still relevant in today's India? How come? Can you explain
Thanks for understanding ... understanding it so well. You guys absolutely got the movie and the purpose behind it. I Wish Vicky and Shoojit Sir be able to watch this some day. Love you guys ❤️
Thank you Achara and Jaby for this video. The after reaction talks is the main thing you both do. Keep up with the good work. Very good.
Jaby and Achara - there was a specific reason why Dyer chose those soldiers.. They were the Gurkhas and they necessarily dint have a soft corner. That's the main reason he chose the Gurkha regiment to open fire.
Yup
Yes the Bastard Dyer arrived with two armoured vehicles, 25 Gurkhas of 1/9 Gurkha Rifles (1st battalion, 9th Gurkha Rifles), 25 Pathans and Baluch and 59th Sindh Rifles so they wont have the sense of self belonging with the peoples. Even the God can’t forgive the British then and now.
there were others too
I wish i was one of that regiment too with a machine gun in hand, my gun would have just pointed in the opposite direction
A factual correction:- there was sikh regiment too with gorkha regiment...but director showed only gorkha..
THE BEST SHOT, BUT THE DARKEST PART OF THE MOVIE...THE JALLIANWALA BAGH
As it must
Agree 😭
I have read about the incident multiple times but this scene helped me live it. I hate the British even more now.
@@asmityadav4216 don't Say like that .it's not the total fault of britten. That police General and some people did this .
@@amalrajpc2876 I don't hate the general people , what I meant was ,that I hate the British empire even more now. I don't hate the current generation.
Even the strongest person on earth can't help but would cry at this particular segment... Long live Udham ❤
That Was Really Happen In My Motherland N That's What This Is 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🏻 LONG LIVE INDIAN REVOLUTION SOCIALIST SALUTE
RED BLOODY SALUTE TO COMRADE UDHAM SINGH INDIAN REVOLUTIONARY
India is the world's most invaded country
almost 200 Times.
I Know that India have Many Problems Now.
But I sometimes feel Proud that
India Still is exist as a Independent Country and it's Developing Gradually 🙏🇮🇳❤.
Indians kabhi hope nehi chorta.
I m a cricket fan, and if opponent needs 20 from 100 balls with 8 wickets in hand and i still think india will win.
The hope never dies in the heart of indians.
India is yet to be independent in true sense, we are still being ruled by extremist. I don't have anything against Hindus and Muslim or whatever religion it may be, but people should mind their own business. Still people are being killed/mob lynched in the name of religion. Hindu gaurakshaks, muslim extremist, who spread hatred.
Note: I am not a Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Jewish, Sikh, Jain or a Buddhist. I belong to one of the most minor community in India from northeast.
@@keen2024 What is your Religion,if you are minor in ne.
@@keen2024 ok
@@keen2024 Small brother of Hinduism.
There is a saying in our area jaby - " WE DON'T WIPE OUR TEARS AND MOVE ON , WE DRINK THEM " they remain in our soul and mind forever 🇮🇳
Bhai dotectpr udham ji ko kyun ji dikha saka serve karte hue unko sote kyun dokhaya
In simple words :- " Forgive but not forget "
Thank you for reviewing it and re-living what we Indians do every time we are told about that day. It's merely the tip of what all happened but finally, the world is getting to know everything they weren't told by the British about the British raj in India.
This incident strengthened his mental resolve even more. Which is shown when he kept walking down the snowy region alone after he split paths with other people.
To address Achara (27:58), Jallianwalla Bagh is about 5 minutes (by walk) away from the Golden temple. And yes that scene (Vicky taking bath in golden temple) has a deep symbolic meaning.
Bathing in holy waters is supposed to give peace which he couldn't find...
20 years into making, Shoojit Sircar has been researching the character for a very long time. Irrfan Khan was initially signed up for playing the role - a very good choice, obviously. Vicky Kaushal did well, sort of paying a tribute to Irrfan.
Vicky did a phenomenal job....However, if the late master Irrfan had done this, I dont know....it would have been something !
@@arvindramanathan6278 irrfan sir son was going to play the young udham. He would have ruined it . He won’t have the acting capability to convey his emotions like Vicky did in that massacre scene
@@leomorgan2783 Don't speak what you don't know. Vicky is a child to Irfan in acting skills. What Irfan could have done from his eyes alone in such a deep movie no one can imagine.
@@yinyang.333 I’m talking about the part where Vicky played 20 yr old udham in the film . Irrfan sir son babliw was suppose to play that part , he would have ruined it never compared Vicky to irrfan sir
thank you for reacting ...Last part of movie it was just visual it conveyed what it needed too..the director made me feel what had happened..I cried my heart just imagining how tragic.... that many lives women men children and how cruel it was by British government..was towards Indians..I feel sad to the core...at last m feeling thank ful for people who fought for our freedom and sacrificed their Life for the future generation..movie was heart touching😢
Shaheed Udham Singh Ji Gem Of Our Country...My Eyes Is Full Of with Tears... Jai Hind 🇮🇳 🇮🇳🇮🇳
This movie taught us the price of our Freedom struggle. .. Salute to all who fought for our nation 🙏🙏
Now it’s in the hands of monkeys (sanghis)
Now its in the hand of right one
True😭
Respect them
This is the history we take for granted.. even in India.. we don't respect what we got from this after decades of fighting - Independence.
We still fight over religion, caste, creed, money, power, etc. We need to get over it and appreciate what we have.
We're not entitled for an apology if we are the way we are right now. People need to change, not only the government.
Unfortunately bigotry and hate is very tough to shed my friend, even in these times.
@@aradhyamishra5590 yes.. it's not easy..
But I think simple things like following traffic rules and keeping the roads clean will come a long way..
The world needs patience..
I wish you tell this to whichever party you vote for first.
@@allarjun956 so which party you think is with a clear conscience? If is there any do let us know, because as far as I know there isn’t any. In that sense should we stop caring about changing for better and being concerned for our nation, or stop voting altogether as every party is crooked? Grow up, change comes from within and if even if it doesn’t, we can live knowing we have done our part and made our forefathers proud who died for our freedom.
@@allarjun956 if I really wished, I'd have my own group of extraordinary beings rather than any current people!
This movie is not just a movie this is a god gift to us ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I'm literally cry after watching the movie. Jaby you have good soul.
The soldiers who fired were Baloch(Now in Pakistan) and Gurkhas( mostly Nepalese nationals). British took them because they didn't have any connection with Punjab so giving orders to fire was easy for Brits and no soldier would have questioned.....
Any British soldier would do what they did. They were trained to do that. The national consciousness didn't exist mostly.
Did you guys know that originally it was Irrfan Khan who was cast as Udham ?? But due to his health situation it had to be handed over to Vicky. Imagine Irrfan in this role. Phew!!!!😇😇.
RIP legend.
But I think, Irfan sir won't be disappointed by the way Vicky Kaushal has portrayed the role. He would be proud.😊
@@yashovardhan849 Absolutely 💯💯💯he is such a brilliant actor❤️
Vicky Kaushal is easily one of the best actors out there too. In every role he takes the person vicky is not present, he is a completely different character till deep under the skin. Unlike many others who though act well are recognisable as what their actual personality is. That's why Vicky Kaushal is way up there in my list of best actors. Infact I believe Vicky and Nawaz are the best actors of Bollywood right now followed by Ranbir followed by Irrfan Manoj Pankaj followed by Ranveer Rajkumar Hritk(guzarish) followed by Shahid(Haider) and Amir. Irrfan sir will be proud. 💙
Irrfan is , was and always will be LOVE❤️
I watched the movie and I cried 😢 lots of time, and I know that when I will the movie again and that Jalianwala bagh sense I will cry because tears coming automatically and I can't control it. Freedom fighter Sardar Udham Sigh ji amrar rahe🙏🇮🇳❤
I have seen many reaction videos of yours, but subscribed after watching this one. Details well discussed.
I wish Jaby you'll come to Amritsar and see the GOLDEN TEMPLE and Jallianwala Bagh by yourself. Amritsar is Chaotic yet a peaceful and welcoming place, great people, holy site for everyone.
Can’t agree more.
That well gives you goosebumps and you are angry at the same time
I wish
I visited Amritsar once and was struck by the beauty of Shri Harmandir Saheb (Golden Temple), couldn't take my eyes of it and felt like staying there forever. Also enjoyed the food and hospitality of langar at the temple. I want to visit the golden temple again.
The British had a policy to use the army of different parts in different states so there is no feeling of belonging.. so the soldiers who are from other states were stationed in Punjab at that time
They really messed us in every way they can.
Thats a very clever strategy !
Yup that was the gorkhaa regiment.
Yup, gurkha, rajput and pashto specifically for this massacre
@@puneetkaur7245 no rajput regiment. Atleast read before spreading misinformation.
This is in public forum, you can even read on Wikipedia.
Really guys u r the really excellent movie reviewer in the world I m from india and i m glad to say that i belong to country that had really very great
Personalities i m watching ur videos for last 10 days and beliew me i have watched ur almost all reviws i really like u guys tq for ur great words for this country
It is so cruel an experience, heart wrenching a lesson for today's corrupt politicians, an eye opener ....
In this movie an underrated aspect is how much respect was given to regional language, Vicky Kaushal spoke authentic Punjabi. Not just a bollywood actor attempt like so many other movies. The movie spoke the correct language in almost every scenario. Hindi with HRSA members, Punjabi in Amritsar and English in England. Such a small aspect but so important for continuity
Isn't Vicky Punjabi himself?
@@noyonika2245 he pretty much is, his parents are from Hoshiarpur, Punjab but he and his brother were born in Bombay. I do believe in an interview he said he speaks punjabi at home and predominantly listens to punjabi music
@@gavghag6109 he speaks perfect punjabi...watch his interview in Punjabi for this movie
Jaby is feeling exactly what all of us felt watching the end scene.
@@The1977guddu That smile of hers was sarcastic, not a genuine smile. She did feel what we felt but not to the extent of what Jabby felt as we could see it on his face. She did say that she had to switch off her mind from feeling because it was too much for her. This scene is so strong and powerful that literally words won’t be ever enough to explain how one feels.
These make me cry to think about...that ..in jaliyan wala baag in Punjab where all this happened in past ...
Even though our Sardar bhai are still servings and do Langers in Amritsar...Golden temple....
This shows that evils can be Big...but it feels soo small in front of goodness...
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏
Thanks for reviewing this movie.. and it truly shows the pain , sardar udham singh carries for so many years in his heart , mostly every one cries after seeing the last part of the movie which, and sardar udham singh was there in real moment... Everyone is understanding the pain that's the award for the movie much more than man made awards like oscar and others..
The Brits used soldiers from different parts of entire Indian sub continent. The soldiers used here didn't had any attachments with the place, they probably didn't even spoke the same language.
The Brits were cunning, very cunning, they were very good at what they did.
@Som Aditya Indians had no Nation or Civilizational identity at tht time. They were all educated by British syllabus. So thts how powerful Social engineering is
The best scene for me is when British general gives order and walk behind the indian soldiers...that was the best visual, best acting best part of the movie was....and British actor totally deserve the applause for the acting...it gave me chills...👍
The DARK HISTORY of BRITISH RULE and INDIA'S STRUGGLE TO GET FREEDOM will never be forgotten by the Indians. BHARAT MAATA KI JAY🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
That was 200% accurate for sure, dear .......!!!!
Guys, see if you can interview Vicky again, more focused on this movie. It will be really great !
Yes!!! I would love to watch that ❤️
Agreed
Yes completely agree. Vicky is amazing in interviews. Would love to hear you both interview him again. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
The distress Jaby felt is so real. I've felt the same way, even when this incident was shown in many cheesy, patriotic movies. When we read in our social studies textbooks, about the mothers jumping into a well carrying their children, to escape the shooting, we still feel our stomach turning.
This movie though... it just made sure that viewers cannot walk away marking the incident as a footnote in history. I hope this gets enough non-Indian viewers. As Udham Singh said - no, we don't hate British. But, that doesn't mean that British get to walk away not acknowledging it.
The hate and animosity towards the Brits will be carried on for generations to come, we can never forgive them.
Vicky kaushal acting in this movie deserve so much appreciation ⭐
It is good to know that at least some people are working in the industry to give the idea of how was independence achieved... 💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐 Great job !every cast of the movie has done a commendable job.... Awesome.
The only significant inaccuracy in the movie is that Udham Singh was present at the massacre site with his friends from the orphanage. He was one of the few survivors who were able to escape.
We don't know that for a technically and it's assumed that he was there during the massacre.
This scene was so difficult to watch, even as I type this, my hands are shaking. All the books and articles, they just show us the tip of the iceberg, the reality was too heartbreaking and brutal even to imagine. The British will never be forgiven for their deeds
Forgive but never forget .
Its their ancestors who did it . You cant blame the current generation for these horrifying acts.
@@architsharan6259 Yes I agree , but the Government has not even apologized for what they did.
absolutely no blame or hatred towards the British people, but the British Government
Yes I agree but what about the Indian Soldiers who fired the bullets... They could have easily killed motherfucker Dyer there and protested... I think they are equally responsible for the incident.
@@rajeev8008 those indian soldiers who open fired and the British are equally responsible
@@architsharan6259 somethings aren't worthy of forgiveness, especially when they don't even have any remorse.
😭😭🥹 This type of Incident hurts me as an young Indian, I am a teenager and I cried and phrase the patriotism of my freedom fighters.
Types of movies I love to watch and also love your reaction how you feel pains of Indians 🙂
Watching tears in your eyes made me cry...your reaction is genuine and powerful. Love you two.
You will cry only when those britishers will cry....... 🙂👍
@@aloksingh-yp3gc irony
Jaby felt the pain could see those tears rolling out his eyes😭
Those are some unfogetable days of Indian history🥺
The significance of the final bath scene is that, usually, people bathe in these holy waters to "Wash their sins off", symbolic for rebirth, which, in this case was Udham's Rebirth as a freedom fighter and him getting new purpose to dedicate his life to.
This movie shook me...
I'm deeply troubled!!!
As a Indian i would appreciate if the western people's watch this movie we don't want Oscar we just want recognition. I damage that Britishers has done to us is so immense that we are still facing its consequences. As one your viewer i would really appreciate if you atleast tell your friends and colleagues about this film and show them the really face of their ancestors and what they did to us and to others 🙏
Stop begging and disgracing. If they want to, they will. We don't need their pity. And stop folding hands. Have some esteem
We dont want their recognition... We know wat britishers did... Their crowd dont even know wat brits did to the world coz they dont teach that in their curriculum... They were taught brits act were a step towards civilization... It boils my blood... So we dont need anything from anyone...
If they want to know they will know... They will be curious to find out about the truth.. thats it..
Let me clear a thing, which you guys were confused with...
The men who were shooting , were not indian...they were from afghanistan and gorkha(nepali)..who didn't have any sympathy towards the condition of india...
Gurkhas in Punjab, Sikhs in Afghanistan. Brits were smart. But still no Indian soldiers resisted.
Yup
Last hour of this movie!!🖤😖....I couldn't control my tears!!...
You have to remember, whatever they show in the movie about that scene, the reality was 100 times more horrific
you see even now when people in England are asked about their British empire, what they say is that brits gave us railways, law system and all while they never mention the cost we paid as if it was impossible without them.
They need to see Shashi Tharoor speech
Also look up, '1957 high schoolers debate' , with the thumbnail 'why do you think colonialism is so bad'
The brit is so ignorant about British brutality in its colonies, and argues the same things you said.
That’s because that’s all we learn. And in many ways not even that.
Being in school in the UK. I didn’t do that much in the British Raj or the empire really. We learnt about what the Commonwealth and Empire was but not what they did. In school I learnt about Gandhi however more so many his non violence stance he was linked to other non violence movements around the world such as Martin Luther King Jr and Mandela. When India got independence and how Pakistan and Bangladesh were formed but not the struggle to get there. Plus I learnt about the Mughals. That was it. We learnt about both world wars but nothing about the soldiers from India and the other Empire counties who fought alongside them. I only knew about the Gurkhas as they fought for their rights for pension and settling in the UK.