Israel’s Descent Into Madness & the Holocaust Comparison, w/ Tarik Cyril Amar
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
- Watch the full interview on Patreon: / full-video-into-100173160
Rania Khalek was joined by Tarik Cyril Amar, a historian from Germany and associate professor at Koc University in Istanbul, to discuss Israel’s descent into genocidal fascism. Prof. Amar addresses whether it’s useful to make Holocaust and Nazi comparisons and the real reason behind the West’s unshakeable loyalty attitude when it comes to Israel’s barbarism.
This is just part of this episode. The full interview is available for Breakthrough News Members only. Become a member at / breakthroughnews to access the full episode and other exclusive content.
#BreakThroughNews
Our western leaders have shown us how evil they really are , I'm 72 years old, never did I imagine I would see this atrocity in my lifetime.
I’m in my sixties and neither did I.
@@laurieromano4311
i'm 76 and i'm not surprised by how evil our leaders are and always have been . number 1 : there not leaders there freaks . they " lead countries into wars they instigated. Why ?
to remain in office unchallenged , feed the economy ( military industrial complex ) example ... Biden's calling congress to approve billions & billions in weaponry for wars . in the USA that enriches the armaments industries and allow USA to bully and vanquish any nations that don't approve of our " values " Trump would do the same things Biden is doing if he is re-elected because there is no space between the two freaks. no voting for the lesser of two evils in the upcoming presidential elections in 2024. many people are not even going to bother to vote because who's there to vote for thats not a bloody freak 🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♀️ .
in America ( USA ) there is a saying often used and repeated consistently ... War is good for the Economy " sick statement but truthful . 😮😱.
wars i'm aware of since i was old enough to realize killed people and were sanctioned by this Nation :
Cold War , Korean War, Vietnam , Iraq , Syria , Lebanon, Afghanistan , Palestinian Israeli conflict, Ukraine and most likely Taiwan soon ... have i missed some ? no doubt many we are not aware of because we're not suppose. too.. classified top secret stuff 😮
My same words in another blog.......and from my observation of end times...this is just the beginning....
It gets worse and worse and people are still asleep.
The October 7th massacre was really bad , no doubt about it .
I protested outside the Australian prime minister’s office yesterday. A pro Israeli guy comes along and straight away some spooks standing from a distance filming in case one of the protesters gets violent towards him. I started filming the spook and they left. They were obviously trying to create a response so they could plaster it all over the news.
If anyone wants to come down to alboes headquarters in marrickville there are 24/7 protesters outside. You can sign up to do shifts or just come and go as you please.
An Australian company that makes parts for the f-35 planes was temporarily shut down by protesters a couple of days ago. I don’t know if it’s back open or not.
Solidarity with Palestine.
Right, engineering "anti-semitism".
Thanks for your support
Or…you might be a little paranoid or possibly just plain ole narcissistic.
Whatever you do don’t leave the house with out your tinfoil hat on.
Never forget October 7, a date that will live in infamy.
Solidarity with the real victims.
@@michelegosse7116 been doing it for decades '' ADL extortion racket et al
Thank you!! This is important information.
“The people of South Africa will never forget the support of the state of Israel to the apartheid regime.” ~ Nelson Mandela on being released in 1990
In 1977, the United Nations passed a mandatory arms embargo against South Africa. Israel has repeatedly violated this mandate, equipping the white minority government with a number of weapons, including missiles, several kinds of aircraft, long-range missile boats and other lethal equipment. Israelis have also trained South African troops and provided advisers to the apartheid state in its military attacks against Angola.
The sovereignty of Middle East and African countries is nonexistent as long as this apartheid state is exist . They are a threat to Global security and peace
Glad Others Know these Facts Lets Ensure Many More Know
Mandela did not persecute any Jews when he was freed. He appointed many to the highest levels of government especially the judiciary. He did not regard them as enemies.
He distinguished them from the Israeli government.
Of course he would call for a cease fire in Gaza now, but knowing what happened in the Hamas attacks which started the current nightmarish conflagration he would not have thought it a moral way to wage war.
yes indeed and now the Israeli flag appears with Nazi groups in the UK
Joe Slovo For One Interestingly I`m Told that as the Housing Minister preference was given to You know hews? synagogue of satan gives an interesting epilogue.@@nicholassmith3719
Over 7,000 Children have been subjected to emergency amputations without medical aid or relief. Children having limbs removed with no pain relief. Many of these children have become orphaned and have no family members to give them any after care. These children with missing limbs are existing in a continuous war zone. These orphaned, disfigured, disabled, amputee children are then systematically starved of food water and basic humanitarian aid. This is not the horror story of one child. This is the reality of thousands of young people, children, infants and children. A young child whom has had both of his hands amputated asked his father "Will my hands grow back when I grow up ?" This is HELL on Earth. Tomorrow will be even worse. 😢💛💜💛
Tell Qatar government and Indonesia
Even Mengele had more compassion
@@hermeneasah7240 shame on you. Deflecting from blaming the actual perpetrators. Your compassion has been neutralised.
I couldn’t watch some of the children being amputated without anesthesia. While Biden lick his ice cream say we will get ceasefire done by this weekend which still hasn’t happened.
@@BrRizzy1 ignorance is a crime,you don't know where you come from neither where you are going, the one who spoke in the 621 century BC and 7 century BC of what is happening today in Gaza strip is not a man, open His word ---the Holy Bible read Zachariah chapter 9:1--8, Zachariah chapter 2 from verse one to end, your shame on me gives me courage, because, my Father God says,they will shame you,spit on you for the sake of my Word,I pray that you see light not darkness, PM Benjamin is a blessing to Israel liberation of ancestors promised land occupied by palistinian, where are the Canaanites the Hittites the Amorites the Hivites and the Jebusites,who is UN US ICJ to fight God perfect will for His chosen people Isreal Amen.let my God help you from darkness into Light in the Mighty name of Jesus Christ Amen, blessings Amen
“The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve.” ― Noam Chomsky.
I explained the roots of this paradox and showed a good Alternative for it , please go read it well !
I would argue both nazism, zionism and crony capitalism is nothing but good old colonialism, or what we in a society would say is theft and murder. The lies they tell (I am superior, you have less value then a bug) needs to be exposed. We must call them out for what they are : LIERS, THIEFS and MURDERER. Mike Pompeo : We lie, cheat and steal...He is one of them.
❤😢
@a❤🎉brambadal8997
“Do you have any words of wisdom that come from your own head? Or is plagiarism your one trick?”
Me, myself and the all seeing I
The most unforgivable thing about this, is that we are watching this in real time through the internet, and there are still people who support it.
It’s unimaginable and puts to rest the idea that many people sat back while the holocaust was happening because they just didn’t know what was going on… they did and they do. And they sit back anyway.
@@KG9551 Yes, and the claim that they didn't know is even more inexcusable today, with the internet.
Christian zion-ist
bluww flube supports it. you can say what you like for the genocide but not the other way. they will send you a warning. no fwirsh ahmennimen
Absolutely!💯 that’s the horror of it and you can’t unsee it !
No "victim" exercises total control of their "attackers" movement, food and resources for 75 years. This was a prison break.
Gaza isn't a prison. Prisons have convicted criminals and don't have children.
Concisely put, appreciate you!
I REMEMBER THE SPRINGBOKS TOUR OF AUSTRALIA IN THE MID SEVENTIES. THERE WERE DEMONSTRATIONS AGAINST THE SOUTH AFRICA RUGBY TEAM. WE WERE AGAINST APARTHEID . NOW AUSTRALIA SUPPORTS A COLONIAL APARTHEID OCCUPIER ZIONISTS REGIME THAT CLAIMS (UNSUPPORTED) THAT ANWRA ASSISTED IN OCTOBER 7TH
But an occupying force does.
If this was prison break, they would be all gone from Gaza by now. No prisoner breaks out of prison only to return or stay in it. If Gaza is prison and they want to break out, they clearly dont want to leave the prison.
Thank you for having this guest on. We in the comments are being silenced, because what your guest says is absolutely correct. The world is not blind. We see all the signs are there. Despite the censorship, gaslighting, misrepresentation of historical facts and attempts to redefine words, reality cannot be denied. No spokesman can change my morality. I don't have to be Arab, just a decent human being to empathize and speak out, and we do and will continue to.
Evil cannot hide its true identity forever. Israel has shown its true colors.
Now we see the true colours of radical Islam...
@@demian2658 Well-said!
Gazans were Cheering Hamas. Now they are Crying Victims. That's THEIR True colour.
@@demian2658as said above the whole world is watching the radical State of Israel!
So when the Palestinians chant “From the river to the sea, etc. etc.”
They’re not evil in your eyes when they’re basically calling to eliminate Israel and it’s people?
Of all the brilliant thinkers and speakers who I've listened to over the last few months, Tarik is the most formidable and enlightening. An absolutely brilliant guest who has gotten to the root of this genocidal mania that has taken hold of Israel. Thank you.
You two have brought us an incredible gift, a reminder that we are humans, with responsibililties. We must learn not to tolerate or accept this inhumanity. Thanks to both of you for your work.
Thanks indeed. The situation is a catastrophe and no one can look away as it is live streamed daily. The sorrow of it all. The pretense that this is not happening and all Biden needed to do was pick up the phone and tell the maniac Netanyahu to stop and thousands of lives and innocent children would have been saved. Instead he the dementia ridden president sent more weapons an hundreds if not billions to participate and support this appalling genocide.
Biden is complicit.
They are losing control of the narrative, we must keep on for our brothers and sisters in PaIestine
By blaming the REAL culprit: HAMAS.
@@georgerose1315you fool, blaming Hamas IS the narrative.
@@georgerose1315 Hamas isn't the one killing tens of thousands of civilians
@@georgerose1315 bot
@@georgerose1315stop drinking the hasbara koolaid. 75+ years of occupation is the root cause. Hamas is the symptom. Now go see your doctor. If you lack compassion for Palestinian children- you are a psychopath. You need professional help.
Thank you Rania for your guest and his sensibilities.
I have been saying and continue to say: WE ARE THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE
no, you are not.
Who? The jews?
Yes, we all Palestinians facing fascist
Speak 🦜 for yourself!
You know what happens when the world sees the Genocide & does nothing, the same evil regime will treat everyone as Palestinian people. Contempt for the world the Israeli apartheid regime has. Saten comes in many forms. Don't be surprised when he comes for the rest of the middle east.
This EVIL is coming to the rest of us!!!
Without a doubt. In every country today, the ordinary msn in the street is expendable. Only the rich count.
@brianelliott472 Be honest. How much do you know of it, if anything, at all? How much of your fear is rooted in ignorance? In hearsay and propaganda?
Then Quickly vacate Gaza. Don't squat there.
To normalise this form of barbarism creates a threat for the world at large!
"After 30 years as a USA politician I learned to never believe Israeli figures" - Colonel Larry Wilkerson
''You have to go back to the time of Genghis Khan to get to the kinds of dimensions of killing that's happening in Gaza right now.'' Colonel Lawrence Wilkerson, U.S. Army (retired)
What we are seeing in Gaza is disgraceful at every level, but the abhorrent reaction by the "Collective West" is unforgivable. The Global Majority will never forget this perfideous behaviour.
Those of us in the West will never forget, either.
I just hope we can manage to do something about it.
Agree
Disgraceful is a tame word in this case. It’s hard to find words to describe it. It’s worse than satanic evil. u.s. politicians have blood in their hands, besides the wicked Z.
Quite right its really disgusting and inhumane. Our politicians are just not listening.
Thank you to all who have responded or supported my comment. We are as one against the horrors we are witnessing. The interview gives us some understanding as to how this mass Israeli societal insanity has developed. At core, the Palestinians have, since the founding of Israel, always been viewed as vermin and, much like the aborigines of Australia, they have been hunted down and exterminated by the settler colonialists. The Western enablers of this genocide are not only destroying their own credibility in the eyes of the Global Majority, they are revolting millions in the collective West, and they are quite possibly, aiding in the destruction of the whole Israeli Zionist project. The ramifications of this disaster will echo for centuries.
“The biggest insult to the memory of the Holocaust is not denying it, but using it to commit genocide against the Palestinian people.” - Norman Finkelstein
He makes himself famous among Jew-haters by vilifying Jews!
🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽
Why isn’t Egypt being condemned worldwide for refusing to open the border at Rafah into Egypt?
Millions of Ukrainians fled to Poland. Stop persecuting Israel, they never started this war on the 7th October and the have the right to finish it.
@@Petal4822 or perhaps Israel can get their thieving a$$e$ out of Palestine in the first place. Stop trying to excuse the next Holocaust. Which this time is Israel committing the atrocities.
@@Petal4822 The Israeli-Palestinian conflict did not begin on October 7. Read about the Nakba (1948).
Sayanim are in key positions in the USA, France, Germany, etc. In the USA, politicians will not risk opposing otherwise their careers will be ruined. It is Israel who decides; It took 50 years to prepare all this.
exactly, most governments are ZOG.
actually Zionists were making their play long before. At the same time as the Balfour declaration a prominent zionist called Chaim Weizmann sailed to America and curried the favor of the President at that time Woodrow Wilson, for his help in gaining Palestine as a homeland for the Jews .
There were many well organized and well funded Zionist groups inside America at that time. They were instrumental in helping Weismann get America into the war against Germany. Most of them had control of newspapers in and around New York and Washington and it was through using that power and influence that anti German lies were printed in these news papers. Like the whopper that German soldiers tossed living babies in to ovens with pitchfork's.
Remember ! the use of babies to make the perpetrators look inhumane.
Sound familiar !
Actually it's worse than that. The theft of Palestine was being planned way back in the 19C.
We must not be silent while witnessing injustice. The civilian casualty ratio in Gaza is higher than WW2. More journalists have died in Gaza than in any other conflict.
U$ pwers that be most responsable for this catastrophe. Our leader could have stopped this carnage from day one but refuses too. Follow the money.
The Zionist lobbyists have bought the US Congress.
That's the USA's way to deal with wars around the world (apart during the second world war) massacring innocent people...
Yes.
Brilliant guest! Thank you.
75 year long apartheid, 16 year long blockade of Gaza and now committing genocide. Pure evil
Gaza was under Egyptian rule from 1949 to 1967 and the west bank was under Jordanian rule during the same time period. Israel didn't exist as a proper country in 1931 so I have no idea where you get 75 years from.
@@facehugger3 Perhaps you are refusing to admit that apartheid Israel began its violent oppression of the Palestinian people with the Nakba in 1948. A typical action in that catastrophe: "On April 9, 1948, just weeks before the creation of the State of Israel, members of the Irgun and Stern Gang Zionist militias attacked the village of Deir Yassin, killing at least 107 Palestinians. According to testimonies from the perpetrators and surviving victims, many of the people slaughtered - from those who were tied to trees and burned to death to those lined up against a wall and shot by submachine guns - were women, children and the elderly. As news of the atrocities spread, thousands fled their villages in fear. Eventually, some 700,000 Palestinians would flee or be forcibly displaced at the outset of Israel’s creation, making the massacre a decisive moment in Palestinian history."
www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/4/9/the-deir-yassin-massacre-why-it-still-matters-75-years-later
@facehugger3 The year of the first Nakba was 1948, when 750,000 Palestinians were forced out of their homes, having to leave the country. Around 10,000 more were simply killed (it could be more). Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP) assembled a detailed history, along with pictures, of the Nakba in 1948. Regarding Gaza, the Six-Day War ended in 1967, and that's when Palestinians were pushed further into the West Bank and Jordan also lost and forfeited the land. Egypt lost the war in 1967 and forfeited Gaza. This is historical fact. I'm not Jewish and am giving you this information from memory.
www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/JVP-Nakba-Fact-Sheet.pdf
Here's a link to a very informative, two-part, brief documentary on the Balfour Declaration, which most Israelis know little about. It details how Israel became a state and the countries and people involved. www.aljazeera.com/program/featured-documentaries/2023/10/16/the-letter-that-led-to-the-founding-of-israel-balfour-seeds-of-discord
Well if that’s pure evil, how would you describe the events of October 7, the original genocide that set all of this “genocide” in motion?
I’ll get you started, barbaric, unprovoked, ambush, pre-planned, intricate, and apparently foolish if they expected no retaliation.
@@facehugger3you do know Israel itself is an apartheid state. Not just in Gaza and West Bank.
“Israel is a settler colonial project that is nearing its end, as colonial projects reach their final phase become more brutal and ruthless.” ~ Ilan Pappe
🤡
“Most Zionists do not believe that God exists but they believe that he promised them Palestine” ~ Ilan Pappe
“God is not a real estate agency and never promised land for Nazis who have cowardly killed thousands of Palestinian children and women for over 75 years of occupation” ~ A wise man
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
PaLIEstine was made up you 🤡
In U$ many mega churches support @!p@c and z!0N$+. Justice for Gaza.
PROFOUND And True Recently a synagogue of satan in Toronto staged an event of selling West Bank land to Neo ashkeNazi speculators
🤣😅😆😂 - - brevity tis the soul of wit!
the world are with you Rania in all you are doing to inform the world and I am very thankfull also to Tarik Amar
may God bless you all..
@brianelliott472 ????? Not what?
@@orooropaa1846 Probly just a troll bot doing his thing, or another evil maniacal inhumane creep who'll descent into depths of hell that awaits them. Mark my words there are retribution for evilness. Karma is a bitch and she also never forgets when she comes for you it's 10 fold.
Someone I know (an ex friend) Waa incensed at me for comparison this, which is a genocide, to other genocides, including the Holocaust, which my grandparents survived (he had no relation but kept self righteously saying how insensitive it was for me to do so).
Gaza was a concentration camp. It's been a death camp for weeks, thank you for saying it
THANK YOU so much for this, Rania! I started making this comparison at least a month ago, unapologetically. It is all too apt. One of the experiences seared into my memory was going through the Holocaust Museum in DC about 20 years ago. In particular, some of the clips from the films of the women they did experiments on shook me and chilled me to the bone. I never ever would have predicted that I would see in real time something that reaches and then surpasses that level of vicious and horrific evil being carried out in front of my own eyes, and by the very people for whose memory the Holocaust Museum was designed.
In the words of Aaron Bushnell, “FREE PALESTINE !! FREE PALESTINE !! FREE PALESTINE !!!” 🇵🇸🗝️♥️
As Germany did for the holocaust survivors, Israel should pay compensation to Gaza genocide survivors. Their alliance who send their troops to help, should participate in this war reparation. Before any compensation, the land should be given back to their owner.
Israel's argument of course will be that Germany lost the war but Israel didn't
Yes!👍💯........In the perfect world.🤔
Rasuwl........✊........😎
Looking at the evil perpetrated by these evil people, there becomes a question over historical records. Have they been tampered and doctored. What was the real reasons for Hitler's extermination programs?....
If Israel is eventually found guilty of genocide, would that trigger compulsory reparations to Gazans (& West Bank victim's families)?
Germany did not steal any land to holocaust survivors, they is why Germany paid only compensation to survivors. But, for Gaza, the survivors should have compensation and the land , homes, farms, livestock, back to their owners.
What , for 75 years of immeasurable suffering?
No compensation can redeem them
You think the zionists (whose real god is the buck), will pay one dime of compensation ever to anyone? After this is all over, the gentiles will pay through the nose for the next 100 years for all the zionist excesses. Beleive me. Thats how crooked this world is, and how gullible the gentiles are, in dealing with the zionists.
@@mikeauld4444 Which one, 1948?
@@mikeauld4444 Hamas did not start any war. The war was started by the Zionist in 1948 and they have tortured and starved and dehumanized Palestinians ever since zionists set foot in Palestine. When there is retribution for the evil, Israel has done sadly it falls on innocent people as well. It is the job of people who have humanity to call into this evil evil government that they seem to have elected.
Are you on drug?
Stop the genocide!
It’s not a genocide 🤡
❤
Stop chatting 💩
@@andrewwalker7214 Stop shatting
Incredibly insightful conversation, well needed. Thank you
My God just astounding to see this celebration outside of this genocide. Are they truly just misinformed and not wanting to know the truth or are they truly this horrific and awful of nearly an entire society?? I just cannot wrap my mind around this 😢
It is the continued raising of the specter and horror of the holocaust in each succeeding generation. They experience the trauma of the original event as if it were today and develop the accompanying responses.
Victimization, lack of safety, the necessities of banding together for survival against an enemy, imagined or not,!subverts empathy and does not allow compassion and rationality. A ‘kill first’ mentality. All in the name of safety.
I have seen video of Israelis teaching their children songs in which they sing of the future, murder and genocide of Palestinians. They literally teach their children that one day they will kill them all.
Yes, they are truly that horrific.
It is the very same psychology as in Germany 1930ies/40ies. First they look away, when they can't any more, they tell them self 'it's by law', then 'I can't change it', then 'it is happening thus must be right', then they participate from fear, then to talk away their fear, they participate with passion.
85% approval rating and some of the respondents in the polls said Israel was not being vicious enough. They are a sick nation who have never been forced to face consequences for their contravention of International law and all their war crimes through the last 76 years.
Brilliant guest, with a lot of insight. It's hard to stop crying.
Isn't it!? The helplessness of us all wants me to scream and keep screaming.
Do we beg russia to save us from the genocidal maniacs in DC? Or do something ourselves?
The bouncy castles...jesus Christ...the whole nation seems to be insane
Its no different from Jim Crow States in the US. They literally had a family wank over dead black folks. Would make sense in some fukkked up way if it was retribution for bad behavior (so some form of twisted reciprocation) but this was clearly not the case because African Americans just came out of slavery were still fighting with their lives for their freedom. I've reflected on this phenomenon for a fair few years. It is a novel historical behavior even though humans have been killing eachother for 1000s of years. I really think its a kind of collective psychological sickness. They are in simply speaking terms - very sick people. BUt thie revelation would feed the depravity further.
I detest what Israel is doing and how much support the population gives to the IDF. However I must admit that these bouncy castle protesters are not huge in number.
Dont mention Jesus in Israel, please. They go even more insane.
Not seems IS!!
Israel society is pretty sick!
The action of Aaron Bushnell lets you imagine what the feeling of the people sharing the same concern than him.
"The victim must be perceived as friendless, & therefore there's something wrong with THEM"
Ah, yes: witness the trolls - somewhere in this very comment section! saying the Arab nations should take the Palestinians in, & that they're not is proof of how terrible the 🇵🇸's are.
That kind of mocking sadism often comes from a psychotic self-image as underdog. Being trained as wholly seperate, unique and afflicted dehumanises everyone else because it nullifies normal human contracts. Narcissism also renders baseline 'contracts' a kind of theatre.
💯 Insecure, unloved and rejected by the rest of the world, they have justification for everything.
The whole thing is beyond a nightmare.
Evil to the greatest degree.
Great discussion. So many things I had not thought about! Thank you both.
Today is Palestinian people tomorrow is going to be the world population😭😭😭
That's the point.
Exactly As I Have Been Saying
I too think that is the MESSAGE to the population who are not rulers if we do not comply !!! The rulers will do this to any of us who do not comply. I think it is coming to all of us!!!
The way of Palestin is the way of the world.
Remember covid? It already started
This is excellent content. It's superb actually.
Thank you Rana, thank you Tarik.
I will be thinking about all this for days and sharing it for days like mad. Its so so insightful and important.
Thank you 🙏🏽 from Brazil
Hitler's Willing Executioners is the title of the book Dr. Amar mentioned. I have a copy
And the other book he mentions is Christopher R. Browning's 'Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland'. In one of the later editions he also, if I recall correctly, engages with the argument of 'Hitler's Willing Executioners'.
Blurb from Browning's book: Christopher R. Browning’s shocking account of how a unit of average middle-aged Germans became the cold-blooded murderers of tens of thousands of Jews-now with a new afterword and additional photographs.
Ordinary Men is the true story of Reserve Police Battalion 101 of the German Order Police, which was responsible for mass shootings as well as round-ups of Jewish people for deportation to Nazi death camps in Poland in 1942. Browning argues that most of the men of RPB 101 were not fanatical Nazis but, rather, ordinary middle-aged, working-class men who committed these atrocities out of a mixture of motives, including the group dynamics of conformity, deference to authority, role adaptation, and the altering of moral norms to justify their actions. Very quickly three groups emerged within the battalion: a core of eager killers, a plurality who carried out their duties reliably but without initiative, and a small minority who evaded participation in the acts of killing without diminishing the murderous efficiency of the battalion whatsoever.
While this book discusses a specific Reserve Unit during WWII, the general argument Browning makes is that most people succumb to the pressures of a group setting and commit actions they would never do of their own volition.
Ordinary Men is a powerful, chilling, and important work with themes and arguments that continue to resonate today.
Please read "Tell the Truth and Shame the Devil" by Gerard Menuhin
This interview is mind blowing, it opens up completely for those who say "how can the Isaraheelis get away with this genocide". This interview sets the scene for now and the future.
This was a terrific interview. I'd like to see much more of Amar.
Please, please, please....put this in the public domain for everyone to see. I live in Germany and noone talks, speaks up etc. I am feeling VERY desperate because noone seems to be even interested in trying to understand what is really happening. I think Tarik Cyril Amar has done a wonderful thing in explaining the situation and how it is evolving. I have understood this from the beginning, I was so shocked at first that I only spoke to my direct family, who were themselves unsure. I have activated myself now and am trying to inform people carefully and respectfully about what is really happening, the processes, the behaviours, the manipulation, the propaganda etc. I have a direct plea to Mr Amar to come to Germany and help explain this to normal German people. I know many lovely Germans who are just not able to grasp what is happening and have not searched for the truth. Many are afraid and many are running for cover as we saw in the Berlinale Film Awards with the clapping incident and the well kown politician said she was only clapping the Israeli award winner not the Palestinian!!! This is crazy, dangerous cowardice and I am still hoping that she will stand up and acknowledge her ridiculous and pathetic behaviour!! Yes, I may be waiting a long time!!
Excellent, excellent analysis by this guy despite him saying he has nothing to add.
Thanks Rania for your brilliant advocacy on this issue
As a citizen of the global south, I think you should unlearn your privilege. They're setting a precedent as your guest said to do this to any poor or designated disempowered group anywhere in the world. You aren't safe just because you live in the global north.
The global north is sliding into poverty
We are seeing it already. The beginning of the fall of democracy.
Utterly chilling. The west has gone mad with power.
The US has never seen a war crime it didn't like.
Mad because of a total, total absence of moral and ethical clarity.
Sadly its not just west. All powers sooner or latter turn to evils like that. No matter which empire or culture you study, you find some bloody event comparable to some kind of genocide. Arab slave trade is one example, Genghis Khan is another. Its almost like entire human race is inherently evil?
they put Julian in a dungeon for exposing war crimes, now they just stream them 247
@jackklugman107 Frightening! As someone aptly remarked, " The brazen indifference to public opinion demonstrated by 'power' is a harbinger of our collective future." We left it our leaders for too long. We've been irrevocably marginalized.
Great show. Thank you ✌️❤️
We often ask how could the German people have sat back and allowed the holocaust to happen. Well now we know. RIP Aaron Bushnell ❤🩹
I also remember as a youngster while watching T. V.; I as a Black Youth being brainwashed even about my own condition in this society, faced a dual dynamic of rooting and cheering for the U. S. Cavalry coming to the rescue of the White Settlers traveling through the land of savage Indians. And as each Indian was shot off his horse, I would cheer. Yes stereotyping/dehumanizing is real not just theoretical but something that I as an oppressed person was a victim(of). The almost impossible task of struggling to make mankind realize that there is one race...
The Human Race, I am afraid will be a goal/concept never to be reached.🤔.
Rasuwl........✊........😎
You articulated the goal -
One race - the human race .
I agree I do not see how we get there quickly .
My only thought is the view from space of the earth … we live on a miraculous blue ball in a lot of quiet darkness .
Everything that is alive is a miracle .
If we were ever attacked by or met alien beings we might realize the differences among us are arbitrary and minuscule relative to the possibilities of the universe .
I really don't want to live in a world with wars How Barbaric in Modern world 😢 And Definitely worse seeing babies bodie parts toddlers legs blown off Mass graves, it's like we have Woken up to A Nightmare of the history of suffering and you think they are going to get helped and Israel Overthrown, but no it's Silence Very Sad For Humanity 😢
Might be the most chilling interview seen yet - that's saying something 😬 we're watching all these experts discuss this stuff day after day 👀 this one is super terrifying #CeasefireNow!!!
28:29 Instead, those countries are bombing Yemen, the only country trying to stop the genocide. It’s not normal. It turns my stomach every single day. We’re all traumatized by witnessing this and feeling helpless to do anything but yell on social media, and marching. None of which will bring any of the dead back! 😢💔
Thank you for portraying this plainly and clearly.
Israelis who are actually revealing in this is actual the WORST.
HOW COULD THEY???
Beyond disturbing snd sadistic.
As much as the conversation here is fairly accurate, I will tell you the number one similarity between Gaza today and the Holocaust is that you have a group of people who believe themselves to be supreme beings and chosen by God so by default can do no wrong. This will answer all of the questions you are asking as to how Israelis are complicit during this massacre. The astonishing part is the Jews would become the same thing that nearly destroyed them during World War 2. It’s as if theirs a cultural vengeance built up over the years that allows them to not see the parallels and uplifts their egos as a sense of revenge and also a deluded reformation that they are no longer the “vermin” but someone else is. There’s a deep physiological aspect to this where a traumatized race can be lead to these extremes down the road. I wonder how and if this will be the case for the Palestinians. The cycle and continuous war needs to end.
Darkness exposed. It’s cannot be hidden any longer.
I find Tarik one of the most interesting scholars I've ever heard speak about this matter. He is one of the most articulate people I've heard speak on the subject, he's very well thought out, and he brings dimensions to this conflict I hadn't even thought of looking at. Very interesting interview. Very thoughtful, very insightful. Scary, but necessary. Thank you for all your work, and for informing us, of what is yet to come. I wish with every fibre of my being that the twisted road our world is being plunged into starts straightening out at some point. But seeing how, NOT ONLY, are our world leaders not stopping these monstrosities, but they are STILL - DIRECTLY - encouraging the destruction and the mutilation of a people... simply because they were born in the wrong spot on the globe... even if we DON'T get vaulted into WWIII, I am still very afraid of what our liberties and our lives might become in the not too distant future.
Yes.
Spot on, great commentary 🙏
holocaust 1 ended 1945 holocaust 2 started 1947.
❤
You forgot all kinds of other events like Rwandan genocide and Khmer Rogue.
Holocaust in Palestine started in 1920 and did not stop till this minute
That was in the West, but in the beautiful holy land started at the same time and didn't stop
Well the Arabs have been trying to massacre all the Jews in Israel but fortunately they haven’t succeeded
Much respect to Prof Amar. I read your oped on TR news as regards to NATO and its involvement in the Russia/Ukraine war. Would recommend everyone to read it in order to understand where that war is going and it's forthcoming culmination. Quite a horrible omen but based on facts. My question to you is this..why are most of the middle eastern nations so benign in helping the Palestinians? Why are they so spineless? It's just mind boggling to me. Can you give it some context? Thanks
They've Overpowered them and many have sold their souls for silence and peace of getting destroyed, but I think majority of the world are in shock and didn't think Anything like this I mean live streaming Genocide 🤯💔😫
I think you’ll find some answers to your questions in “Gaza in Crisis” by Noam Chomsky and Ilan Pappe, some of the Arab nations have oil exports to the USA that could stop if they dare do anything against Israel. Also a range of historical reasons.
I think he will be more reticent to talk about the phony Islamists in Erdoğan's entourage such as the owners of the company İÇTAŞ, which has lately been exporting large amounts of steel to Israel. It is not only the West that is complicit in this genocide.
About time wake up world leaders
Wake up indeed. The UN and the ICJ are pointless.
How does an oppressed people become as bad or worse than their former oppressors? give them POWER.
Ich bin Deutsche, Jahrgang 1939 und diese Frage stelle ich mir schon seit Jahrzehnten und das jetzt tagtäglich erleben zu müssen ,belastet mich sehr. Für mich erinnert das, was in Palästina abläuft , schon längst - jetzt harmlos ausgedrückt - an ein gewolltes entsorgen der Einheimischen. Für mich ist da kein unterschied zu HITLER
The psycopathic liars are still the same. Do you understand? That you have been decieved
Thank you so much for this video. It was very beneficial. Keep up the Great Work! Much appreciated!
How sick is the US government. Bragging about sending in aid, building a peir to bring in aid. But at the same time giving the perpetrators aid in weapons and money.
YES, the student has indeed surpassed his master and become a NAZIONIST
Previously, « Aryan Race / chosen race »,.. « God's Chosen People », Just After, Names and times differ, goals and actions emanate from one source.
The torch was passed in the 1940s with a radical amendment which consisted of claiming victim status at the time of the commission of massacres against Palestinian women and children and claiming to be the most moral army in the world.
YES, the student has surpassed his master, Evil, Evil, Evil...
Aaron Bushnell said to humanity this crucial message " Our ruling class have decided that will be normal ". Class and 15 minute cities/guettos. Netanyahu is training AI though the actions upon Palestinians, to be sold on as military equipment.
yup they would be happy to put all of us in a Belmarsh or Gaza
Great conversation! Especially like the bit about the 'toolbox', and legitimizing genocide as 'war', as precedent, and 'just wait til it's used against you'.
Chilling.
thank you T. C. Amar. For your work and sanity.
Brilliant guest, thx Rania!
The general ethnic cleansing of Palestine is perfectly comparable to the Holocaust as a whole. The specific situation in Gaza is comparable to the Warsaw ghetto.
It’s worse. The first slaughter victims perished with their bodies intact. Now, the bodies are mutilated and scattered into pieces. Horrid evil many times over this time.
It’s worse. The first slaughter victims perished with their bodies intact. Now, the bodies are mutilated and scattered into pieces. Horrid evil many times over this time.
It’s worse. The first slaughter victims perished with their bodies intact. Now, the bodies are mutilated and scattered into pieces. Horrid evil many times over this time.
It’s worse. The first slaughter victims perished with their bodies intact. Now, the bodies are mutilated and scattered into pieces. Horrid evil many times over this time.
Except that Jews in Warsaw did not rape murder and kidnap German civilians
It's horrifying to think that these sadistic psychopaths are given guns and missiles
You mean Hamas?
@@MakeItInterestingNowno, isnotreal ..the imaginary state
Long before what's happening in Gaza, I said many Zionists objected to what happened in Holocaust largely because it was them, but when it's happening to Gaza, it's because they feel they are gaining some advantage for their equivalent of a Zionist Reich if you will. It's not really different. The Germans also wanted to clear Slavic lands in many areas to build German settlements, to have a German garden of Eden.
Who started this and who still has hostages. Most people commenting seem to be mutants.
@@MakeItInterestingNow Who started this? Zionists, originally way back in the late 19th century, ramping up in the 1920s and really getting it on from the late 1940s. THAT'S who started this.
@@MakeItInterestingNowIsrael was created though violence, has perpetuated violence against the Palestinians since 1948, has stolen more land in the West Bank since 1967.
@@MakeItInterestingNow Israel is holding thousands of hostages in prisons, without trial or often even charges.
@@AbuHashemPSC you mean the Arab terrorists and murderers that Israel jailed after trial? Hardly the same thing as kidnapping a child wouldn’t you say?
The situation in Gaza Ghetto can best be compared to the Warsaw Ghetto during World War II. in both cases, rounded-up residents (Jews then)were held captive under inhumane conditions, with the difference that the Warsaw Ghetto lasted only a few years while these inhumane conditions in the Gaza Ghetto have lasted for three generations (75 years)
Danke Dr. Tarik Cyril Amar. Das war sehr impressiv. Sie sollten ganz viel in deutschen, österreichischen, und Schweizer Mainstream Zeitungen publizieren.
Thank you Rania Khalek - great interview!
I think the professor was referring to a book by Daniel Goldhagen titled "Hitler's willing executioners "..very interesting reading and quite an astute comparison of what is happening to the Palestinians as we speak.
Those who are still supporting Israel's actions have lost their soul...
Wow, this guest had the balls to openly propose that in a "normal" world and/or circumstances, many in the world would directly provide support to the Palestinian resistance including Hamas. As taboo as this may sound to some, he literally described the elephant in the room. Excellent podcast.
Thank you
BreakThrough News
What are they doing!! doing the same thing that was done to them! It is inconceivable that a group of people that was literally almost ethnically cleansed is doing the exact same thing to another ethnic group 85 years later.. I can't wrap my mind around that
They never got out of the stone age. Read Deutoronomy sometime, along with the Talmud. When Netanyahu called them amalek, that means utter anhilation justified by thier Old Testament god.
No, they’re fighting back against a religion that would have then eradicated if they had the means. If Muslims had the resources Israel did they would’ve done the same thing along time ago.
How can you fault a group for going past an eye for an eye knowing that their enemies would eliminate them from existence if that had the means to?
When the Palestinians, or any Muslims, yell ahah ackbar at the killing of non Muslims (as they did on Oct 7), it’s not a cry for mercy it’s a celebration of the death of a non Muslim. It means my god is better than your god as evidenced by the killing of one of yours.
The comparison is 💯 perfect valid.
The differences, the Jews in the concentration camps, weren’t continuing to la bombs towards the Germans
Facts!! Those who deny what is happening are complicit in the genocide. Theare no exuse and no justification of killing innocent people.
This is pure insanity, how low the occupiers have sunk, in celebration of the suffering of the people of Gaza!! I'm physically sick!!
How did you feel on October 7?
100% correct. The mechanism is identical.
All points this man makes are valid.
so true
Stop Netanyahu now, Israel.
The bouncy house as a part of blocking aid, is truly revolting. Thank you both for discussing this horrifying and revolting g3nocide. It is unbelievable that this is happening, again. The Holocaust against the Jews in WWII is not the same incident as G@za, but there is a very similar situation with similar characteristics, happening in G@za.
Thank you also for pointing out that *bystanders have agency*, they aren’t just passive observers.
I noticed the disturbing characteristics Iz was displaying early on in the present siege-and their tendency to think they’re perpetually victims while denying their behavior towards the P@lestinians.
German citizens didn't set up jumping castles outside concentration camps. This is a new level
Un camp de la mort avec un port flambant neuf.
Et pas de port pour soixante jours!
As a german its wierd that i have never heard about Tarek. We are censored here when it comes to israel. Unbelivable
This speaker is as AMAZING as the host!
FYI, investigators found that many of Anne Frank journals entries were written by a relative many years later.
Rania, what are some of the social accounts you follow that are broadcasting this shit? Keep up the great work.
Thank you Rania, Tarik and Break Through, yet another outstanding and important interview.
The demonisation that Professor Amar speaks of Palestinians has a long history, and importantly a colour coding that designates a certain phenotype, that has been for a long time been disseminated throughout visual media in the west. It is the visual equivalent of the ideological antisemitism, with added element of visual, physical signifiers: brown/olive skin, brown eyes. This can very easily be seen in the visual cultural out of Europe and the United States over the past half century. It used to be subtle, but has become almost overt over the last 20 years or so. It is almost scientifically applied, and once one latches onto this highly devious mechanism and its constituents, it will open an entire realm of understanding how white supremacist, racists use culture as a weapon, a eugenic of writing an entire segment of humanity out of the gene pool, in this case it is that, through phenotype designation, the Arab/Middle Eastern person; in the same way that white racists did this to Black peoples from the 16th century onwards.
For us who have lived in Western Europe, we have seen this mechanism put into place and normalised iteratively, where an entire generation has been visually programmed to hate on sight, literally reacting to stock images neurologically programmed into their minds by repeated exposure to negative, highly and carefully constructed negative stereotypes.
What’s happening in Gaza is not haphazard, or merely just reactive, but actually is a showing of deep understanding of Israelis of their white racist progenitors, and sponsors in Europe and the United States. In short, they understand their audience, racist psychopaths, better than most humanity imagines. R
How did the Palestinians coexist with Israelites that lived together in Palestine prior to 1917?
They coexisted fine because they were in the Ottoman Empire .
Look up videos of Jerusalem 1890’s.
Three religions lived in peace .
Look up Bagdad at the same time … 30% Jewish .
Zionism has been an irritant in the region since it arrived in the
1920’s and 30’s .
The idea of one group being superior and displacing the existing residents by force is a flawed foundation for a peaceful nation state
@@GardenerGeorge I agree but also I want to point out that also during the ottoman period in the region surrounding Jerusalem there were also other religious minorities. We tend to look at the Abrahamic religion as 3 faiths, while that's true for the main branches of the Abrahamic faiths there are other smaller groups. Groups such as the Samaritans, Druze, and Baha'is also existed in Palestine Pre-1917. The ottomans in a way kept some balance between these groups and allowed for free movement across the empire (up until Arab Revolt/WWI).
At that time, there was no Israel and fasionizm, only Jews.
There is a problem with not empathizing with "vermin", because it aims to make some living being "the other". Real compassion is the ability to relate to something outside of one's own self-centeredness, automatically.
The Fight Against Lebensraum Depravity Continues 👏✅
OMG!! Brilliant analysis. Israel cannot and must not get away with this. We're all in danger by this precedent.
Empire is the only lens to see this and our future. November 2024, Bastille Day American style. ❎ , not so much. 😢
What a flake you are!