What is the BEST EXPEDITION COMPASS in the World?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @alexblue6991
    @alexblue6991 Рік тому +2

    The same thing happened to my wife and I a few years back we went our usual weekend hike we been going for years we were so confident we knew the way we left our mobile phone in the car that day we had a snow storm the trails were all covered and everything looked so different it took us a few hours to find our way back to the car Alec from Scotland

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  Рік тому +2

      I'm hoping to visit Scotland for a backpack trip soon. Be safe out there!

  • @dudepetri
    @dudepetri 3 роки тому +2

    I grew up and live in the Sierra Mountains. A compass is essential. I like the M-3G. I usually take a military compass with me. I think that every compass I have can be set for declination. At altitude of 6 to 8k ft, I have not had any trouble with bubbles forming.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому +1

      Which military compass do you bring?

  • @rachavya
    @rachavya 5 років тому +10

    Suunto does make mirrored compasses with the two very important features you cited: (1) global needle and (2) declination adjustment via tiny screw. So now do you agree that adding a mirror vastly improves the accuracy when shooting an azimuth.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  5 років тому +4

      The mirror is handy but slower for me.

    • @andrewulrich6612
      @andrewulrich6612 5 років тому +1

      Silva makes a global, declination adjustable and inclinometer too.

    • @mendozaconsultation
      @mendozaconsultation 4 роки тому

      Is it tru that declination changes 1 degree yearly ?

    • @mchenri9683
      @mchenri9683 4 роки тому +1

      @@mendozaconsultation That is dependent on where you are

    • @summittaedae2323
      @summittaedae2323 3 роки тому +1

      @@mendozaconsultation there’s some good UA-cam videos that’ll explain the isogonic lines, agonic chart. I’m still learning so offer no advice just a point in that direction for education. In Scotland our declination is so little it’s not worth worrying about atm it’s 1.6 degrees westerly declination. I’d only be 2m off my bearing every 1km and even usin the suunto mc2g your not gonna walk 1k without taking a new bearing. I’ve just bought the compass in the video here for navigating in woodlands where the mc2g is better suited to long distance sighting. Reason for two compasses is I always carry two maps and two compasses for safety in the highlands. Happy hiking 🥾

  • @Sarrienne
    @Sarrienne 4 роки тому +5

    Best compass is the Francis Baker M88... or their M73, if you like them heavy. Your map should specify the mag/true declination it's based on. Pair with a R.A. protractor (in mils or degrees, according to yor compass) and just remember - Grid to Mag, add. Mag to Grid, get rid.
    However... I still habitually favour the old Silva Type 4/54 baseplate with built-in romers, or a Suunto MB6 for general use... and a Casio Rangeman, just because it's cool!!

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому

      Good to note.

    • @ronvonbargen8411
      @ronvonbargen8411 3 роки тому

      I Think you have it backwards. Grid to Mag (map to land) you subtract for instance let's say you have a map Reading of 100° and the declination is east 10° so 100-10=90 or if it's a west declination it would be 100-(-10)=110°

    • @Sarrienne
      @Sarrienne 3 роки тому +1

      @@ronvonbargen8411 Well, it seems to work for every soldier in the British Army, myself included, and we generally hit what we're aiming at so we must be doing something right... It might work differently for those West of Plymouth, but that's just down to checking the declination on your map, which anyone with a compass should know to do. Everywhere else of interest is East, at which point it works just fine!

    • @ronvonbargen8411
      @ronvonbargen8411 3 роки тому +1

      @@Sarrienne I am in an area that has no declination, Minnesota usa along the Mississippi River. (well its actually 0.24° this year) so I don't really have to adjust for declination. I was basing my comment on my understanding without any real experience with declination. Maybe I'm wrong.

    • @robch4414
      @robch4414 2 роки тому +3

      That Grid to Mag mnemonic works when declination is West. If it's East, then the opposite applies.

  • @jamesreese1999
    @jamesreese1999 Рік тому +2

    Great video. I have the Suunto M3-G and the Cammenga lensatic (both tritium and phosphorescent versions). I use the Suunto for working with maps, but the Cammenga is unbeatable for walking as you follow a bearing. Also have the Suunto M2-G on order. Always take a backup compass with you in the woods---and have a USGS or equivalent map and know how to use it!

  • @mhavissl3141
    @mhavissl3141 2 місяці тому

    very informative video. thank you. After 5 years, do you still recommend this compass? or is there a newer/better version?

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  2 місяці тому

      The new version is very sticky - made my Greenland expedition rather challenging:
      Two Friends and a Polar Bear (Greenland): amzn.to/3Y4YWj5

  • @OutdoorPrep
    @OutdoorPrep 7 місяців тому +1

    I'm starting a trip in a week and just noticed that my Suunto has stopped working properly after just a few years. The liquid just evaporated or something... Piece of crap and no support / warranty. .

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  6 місяців тому

      Mine has developed a permanent bubble - the new version without the proper gimbal, just a glass cup resting on a needle, was a disaster in Greenland.

  • @juankamilokarvajaljaramill7424
    @juankamilokarvajaljaramill7424 3 роки тому

    Genial .. encontré mi brújula Suunto... la voy a aprovechar

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  2 роки тому

      Thanks for watching.

  • @brianfoxy1
    @brianfoxy1 3 роки тому +1

    Hi I loved you in Everybody loves Raymond keep going

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  2 роки тому

      Thanks for watching & subscribing!

  • @chrisgill2048
    @chrisgill2048 3 роки тому +2

    What is it like for night navigation? How clear is it and how long does it stay clearly visible at night?

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому +2

      The rotating bezel stays lit for quite a while. It's "okay" for night nav but a quick headlamp glance definitely helps.

    • @ronvonbargen8411
      @ronvonbargen8411 3 роки тому +2

      It's easy to keep red in the shed but good luck trying to read a bearing at night with out a light. the best compass that I have used for night navigation is the cammenga with tritium

  • @ronsutton2053
    @ronsutton2053 3 роки тому

    You convinced me! Have just ordered one for use here in the UK

  • @1polonium210
    @1polonium210 3 роки тому

    Nice video! I learned how to use a compass during my undergraduate course in field methods in geology many years ago. We used the standard Brunton used by geologists, and I used that compass through my MS and PhD programs. After 40 years, it works as well today as it did when I bought it. The Brunton is a great compass, but it is a bit cumbersome for trekking and orienteering. There are other Bunton models that are better suited for hiking, etc., but I am very much a fan of Suunto compasses. All are very light-weight, easy to use, and durable. Based on your recommendation, I have purchased a Suunto M3G. I have also ordered a Suunto thumb compass for orienteering exercises.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому

      I hope it works out.

  • @1stFlyingeagle
    @1stFlyingeagle 3 роки тому +1

    sorry to inform you. Suunto MC2 Navigator Mirror Sighting Compass with Built-in Clinometer, Quadrant Yes this has the mirror and angle gauge.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому +1

      That version is nice, too.

  • @paplu2009
    @paplu2009 3 роки тому

    Thank you very much

  • @mickd6942
    @mickd6942 10 місяців тому

    I tend not to take advice from someone who thinks they can sight through the magnifying lens on a baseplate compass but do get back to me when you know what your doing , lastly under no circumstances navigate unless you have a competent person to do it for you .

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  10 місяців тому +1

      Thanks for watching!
      Crossing Greenland with this compass: www.sastrugipress.com/books/two-friends-and-a-polar-bear/
      Skiing to the South Pole with this compass: www.sastrugipress.com/books/antarctic-tears/
      Stay safe out there!

  • @jamesgaul3544
    @jamesgaul3544 2 роки тому +2

    "The ONLY compass I know that has a way to set declination"... Really!!! lol

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  2 роки тому +1

      Things have changed since then thank goodness.

  • @peterweikel7123
    @peterweikel7123 2 роки тому

    Ok, I am no world traveler. I hunt, I spend many days in the back country. I use a Cammenga military compass and just ordered one of these for a backup. If it works as you claim it may become my primary. Thanks for the info and the video

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  Рік тому

      Good luck and be safe out there.

  • @dcentral
    @dcentral 4 роки тому +2

    I’m reading so many mixed reviews about quality of Suunto and Sylva compasses because of bubble formations. Is it really a rocket science to create an easy to use compass that doesn’t form bubble at altitude?

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  4 роки тому +2

      It's actually a challenge - a reduction in pressure causes bubbles in anything. You can boil water (create bubbles) in a syringe. It's an annoying fact of physics.

    • @ingowalkerling5141
      @ingowalkerling5141 Рік тому

      Back in the 1930ies Wilhelm Kienzler ("WilKie") sold the WilKie "Meridian" compass. This type was the first in the world with a thermo-elastic capsule to prevent bubbles. Now a similiar type is sold under several chinese no-name brands, but without the original fluid/capsule. The fluid formula is still a secret.

  • @TELong1603
    @TELong1603 5 років тому +3

    What is the difference between the Suunto M2G and the M3G?

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому

      Here's a link to help:
      www.suunto.com/en-us/Compare-Products/?products=13595%3B6435

    • @idahomountainelk
      @idahomountainelk 3 роки тому

      M2 is a mirror baseplate compass. M3 is a regular baseplate compass.

  • @cadd9511
    @cadd9511 2 роки тому

    Is it only me or did anyone else get a Raymond vibe (Everyone loves Raymond)?
    Anyways, this video is 2 years old (2019), yet Raymond doesn't know Suunto makes the MC2G (since 2016)? It has identical features as his beloved MC3G. However the MC2G has a mirror.
    Yes it may be a few mm thicker. But I think the pros outweigh the cons. Not only do you get a longer base once unfolded (for mapping), you also have a more compact item hanging on your neck when the mirror is folded.
    I will take the MC2G over the MC3G anyday. The mirror setup will provide much more accuracy when shooting a bearing.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  2 роки тому

      Thanks for watching!

  • @alexandercarder2281
    @alexandercarder2281 3 роки тому

    I’ve got the suunto a10 😊

  • @James_Bowie
    @James_Bowie 4 роки тому +1

    At 5:24 -- absolute north? What's that? Never heard of 'absolute' north. Declination adjustment allows the compass to point to grid north -- the north that is used by map makers.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  4 роки тому

      Should've said True North.

  • @idahomountainelk
    @idahomountainelk 3 роки тому

    My brand new M3 G needle sticks bad. Going to send it back to Suunto when the USPS calms down in January.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому

      Hope it works out.

    • @idahomountainelk
      @idahomountainelk 3 роки тому

      @@ALinsdau Suunto, through forestry suppliers, replaced my M3G compass. The new one works perfectly!

  • @ervano798
    @ervano798 Місяць тому

    The Suunto M3-G is certainly a very good compass, but the best Expedition compass? In my opinion certainly not. I am not an expeditioner but have experience with compasses.
    I suspect that real expeditioners sometimes will have the need to take a bearing and so accurate as possible. And yes, with the Suunto M3-G you can take a bearing, but accurate? No, impossible. I don’t have that experience with a M3-G (or similar). Under the conditions of real expeditions i think expeditioners will prefer and have the need for an accurate bearing which isn’t possible with the M3-G. Therefore, you need a mirror- or similar sighting compass. For real expeditions I would say a Suunto M3-G compass is only good for eventually back-up if there is nothing else to use.
    I own a M3-G similar compass, a Recta DT40. This is not a Global compass but I don’t need that because I never travel so far South to have the need for a Global compass. This compass is the one I use for working on the map. To take bearings in the field or positioning which I like to be as accurate as possible I use a mirror sighting compass Suunto MC-2. That gives me the most accurate measuring.

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  Місяць тому

      For long distance polar navigation, the mirror/wire compasses aren't efficient to use. A chest mount is the currently accepted "fasted" way to continuously navigate, especially in a white out. You can only look at the compass on the chest mount, adjust your heading to align the needle into your bearing, and keep going. There's nothing to sight on in a total/partial whiteout.
      Sadly Suunto changed the design so it's not a true gimbal any more, just a needle in glass (plastic). We had a terrible time with them in Greenland:
      Two Friends and a Polar Bear (Greenland): amzn.to/45GKzlS

  • @robertocatrone715
    @robertocatrone715 3 роки тому

    well done sir.

  • @Obsidian369
    @Obsidian369 3 роки тому +1

    Dude why is it best, show features, stop talking so much my god

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому

      Thanks for the comments.

  • @whitemexican3923
    @whitemexican3923 2 роки тому

    For simple hiking in lower 48 would Cammenga Lensatic be ok?

  • @The_Original_Nitro_Rat
    @The_Original_Nitro_Rat 5 років тому +2

    I run the Silva ranger #515 with all... the adjustments. Sighting mirror, declination adjustments, marked out clear base plate..its the cats meow.. the only but not really a problem for a woodsman like me is.. it's not global, has to be kept level to read.. other then that its perfect. But..😏..I am seeking the global model. Lil easier with shaky hands and bad eyes👍🏽

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  5 років тому +2

      There is a mirror version of this compass from Suunto if you prefer that style.

    • @EspenFrafalne
      @EspenFrafalne 3 роки тому +1

      The Silva "Expedition S" compass also have adjustment for declination, and a mirror.

  • @anomalousanonymous1
    @anomalousanonymous1 5 років тому +1

    The SUUNTO MC-2 is a mirror compass that has adjustable declination and an inclinometer. This model has a global needle, and Suunto also makes this available with an NH needle at a cheaper price.
    www.suunto.com/en-gb/Products/Compasses/Suunto-MC-2-Global1/Suunto-MC-2-G-Mirror-Compass

  • @us24575
    @us24575 3 роки тому

    What countries and expeditions have you actively used it in?

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому +1

      Antarctica, Denali, Russia, Patagonia...

    • @us24575
      @us24575 3 роки тому

      @@ALinsdau Must be quite an adventure ot visit those remote locations. Have you ever tried it in deep jungle environments for both North and South Hemispheres? Costa Rica, Amazon, etc.

  • @johnspencer3994
    @johnspencer3994 3 роки тому +3

    One would think a professional speaker would know how to get to the *bleepin* point

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  3 роки тому +1

      Thank for the comments.

  • @SteveSwannJr
    @SteveSwannJr 5 років тому +1

    What about your dad's video?

  • @ibragim_on
    @ibragim_on Рік тому +1

    Suunto doesn’t make a good compass any more😢

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  2 місяці тому

      Their new global design saved $$$ for them but produced a weaker product.

  • @justelvin
    @justelvin 4 роки тому

    You've "yet to find a compass with" adjustable declination besides this Suunto???

    • @ALinsdau
      @ALinsdau  4 роки тому

      In local stores, yes.

    • @James_Bowie
      @James_Bowie 4 роки тому +1

      @@ALinsdau try Brunton truarc.

    • @Sarrienne
      @Sarrienne 3 роки тому +1

      @@ALinsdau Really? We had that on compasses back in the 1990s... !

  • @nodescriptionavailable3842
    @nodescriptionavailable3842 3 роки тому

    Does this compass account for flat earth?